As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

February 1919

4 articles

The Kadoka Press and Kadoka Reporter · Kadoka, S.D.

A Kansas farmer and Seventh Cavalry veteran compares German surrender tricks to Native Americans at Wounded Knee, describing Lakota under Big Foot as having hidden weapons and treacherously opening fire on disarming troops. He recounts the ensuing battle, including women and children fighting, ending only when 'there were no more Indians.'

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Kadoka Press and Kadoka Reporter · 7 February 1919 · page 9

ARE BROTHERS IN TREACHERY

The German is not the origlnntoi of the “Katnerad” ruse, according ti Ed Houston, u farmer living north ol Junction City, Run., who followed all accounts of butties in the big wai very closely. Mr. Houston says that the Indian was an adept at crying “Katnerad.” In bis own tongue, of course, long tie fore the German empire was formed, and cites an experience of his own to prove it. Mr. Houston was a member of Troop G, Seventh cavalry, tne regt inent commanded by the gallant Col George Custer, for eight years. Co

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

A 1919 veteran of the Seventh Cavalry, Ed Houston, claims Indians invented the fake-surrender 'Kamerad' trick before the Germans, recounting the 1890 Wounded Knee disarmament fight. He describes Chief Big Foot's band opening fire during disarmament, leading to a battle in which soldiers 'gave no quarter.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Beatrice Daily Express · 8 February 1919 · page 21

A nil L,n jlTlt.no tut iiniMontHT American Indian at Hla Worst, anil1 the Hun, Shown to Have Qual ities in Common, The German is not the originator of the “Kamerad” ruse, according ta ICd Houston, n farmer living north n( Junction City, Kan., who followed all accounts of battles In the big war very closely. Mr. Houston says that the Indian was nn adept1 at crying “Kamerad,’* in his own tongue, of course, long be fore the German empire was formed, ami cites an experience of his own to prove It.

See moreSee less

Mr. Houston W’as a member of Troop O, Seventh cavalry, the regi ment commanded h.V the gallant Col. George Custer, for eight years. Un der Captain Kdgerly he went to the scene of the Pine Itirige troubles. The , troops lined up to disarm a band of, Indians that hud given themselves up.1 They included the chief, Big Foot, nriil a large number of braves, as well as women and children. i The captives were herded together and soldiers formed a hollow square around them. Euch Indian wore his blanket draped over Ills shoulders, and, with arms folded aeross the chest In tiie customary Indian position, maintained a stoical silence. It was known that a number of the Indiana carried guns, but no treachery was suspected. I Suddenly, apparently without a given signal, one Indian opened (ire

See the clipping

Casper Daily Tribune · Casper, Wyo.

A Wyoming newspaper reports on an Indian conference in Casper where chiefs from several tribes will gather to install a new infant Sioux chief. The report notes that the infant's grandfather, said to be 112 years old, is one of the last survivors of the chiefs who fought in the 'famous Custer massacre.'

Casper Daily Tribune · 18 February 1919 · page 6

I grandfather of the infant Chief ’ I Longbear f rom the Sioux reservaj tion in Montana. The Montana chief is 112 years I of age and is one of the last sur vivors of the great chiefs who par ticipated in the famous Custer massacre which marked the turn ing point of the struggle between thf* white and red men for supreI macy of the plains. Other chiefs of all the tribes in the great Indian conference are ex pected to be on hand for the cere monies attendant upon the naming of the infant to succeed in turn his grandfather and father as Sioux Chief.

See the clipping

The Bennington Evening Banner · Bennington, Vt.

A 1919 article comparing German "Kamerad" surrender tactics to those of American Indians cites a Kansas farmer, Ed Houston, who served eight years in Custer's Seventh Cavalry (Troop G). Houston recounts how Indians used the same deceptive surrender cry long before Germans did, referencing his later service at Pine Ridge.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 11 days earlier.

The Bennington Evening Banner · 19 February 1919 · page 3

ARE BROTHERS IN TREACHERY

The Gemma Is not the originator j of the "Kamerad" ruse, aceor'dim? to j Kd Houston, n fanner living north of. .function City, Kan., who followed ail j accounts of battles In the bis war very closely. Mr. Houston says that the Indian j was an adept at crying "Kamernd," j in his own tongue, of course, long be fore the German empire was formed, I and cites an experience of his own to prove It. Mr. Houston was n member of Troop G, Seventh cavalry, the ret inoid commanded by the gallant Col.

See moreSee less

George Custer, for eight years;. Un der Captain L'dgerly he went to the scene of the Pine Ridge troubles. The (roups lined tip to disarm ft bond of Ir.ilhmu Hint luil i'lvin thenisplveq nn a large number of braves, as well as

See the clipping