As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

December 1918

19 articles

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A newspaper comic strip features two characters, Bill and Hank, discussing art and books, with Bill mentioning he owns a painting of 'Custer's Last Stand' alongside other patriotic artwork in his home. The conversation is unrelated to the actual historical event and uses the battle as a casual cultural reference point.

Omaha Daily Bee · 1 December 1918 · page 30

Bill Likes to Read. "Now, I'm anrtist. I get some enjoyment outa life. You go up tc my house and you'll see some fin samples of art on my walls Wash ington Crossing the Delaware, Custer's Last Stand, and all them great things. And in thy bookcase 1 got all the good books The Man Without a Land, The Last of the Mechanicians, Pilgrim's Paradise, and all them. "Now, just look at the difference. I went over to see a plumber'friend of mine. He's got a big mansion up i there by the iceman's house.

See moreSee less

He p showed me into his library and I , never seen such bookcases in my, life. All mahogany and inlaid with wonderful glass panels, an', everything. And I opened 'em up and" what do you think was in emr Hank gave it 4ip. Books? - he suggested. '

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A short personal-interest note identifies John Sivertsen, a 74-year-old veteran of the Seventh Cavalry, who is planning a Christmas visit to Wisconsin. It recalls that he served with Reno's detachment, which charged the Indians after Custer's battalion had been wiped out.

The Washington Herald · 3 December 1918 · page 7

PURELY PERSONAL

patriotfsm for thin city. John Slvertsen. a veteran trooper' of the Seventh United Stale* Cav alry. 74 yeara of age, I? arranging! to spend his Christmas holidays at hi* old home in Wisconsin. Slvert ?en wai a member of the "Fighting Seventh" when the greater part of, that noted regiment was wiped out j at the time of the Custer massacre. J He wan with the flanking detachI

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A 1918 letter disputes earlier 'last survivor' claims, asserting that Curley Head, an Arikara scout, escaped the battle and is the true survivor rather than the famous Crow scout Curley. It also claims an earlier newspaper account mistakenly identified him as a Crow scout.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Bismarck Tribune · 3 December 1918 · page 6

A REAL SURVIVOR OF CUSTER'S LAST FIGHT IS AT BERTHOLD

A REAL SURVIVOR OF CUSTER'S your isue of this morning, captioned ''Too Many Last. Survivors," which re­ fers to the so called "Last Survivors of the Custer Massacre," every now and then we read of the "youngest drummer boy." Mr. l.enson's re­ marks-' are apropos the occasion. Nevertheless there are aside from the cavalry horse Comanche, to which Mr. Benson refers, a "last survivor." This was Curley Head, an Areckaree Indian scout from the Fort Rerthold reservation, in what is now .North­ western North Dakota. The best In­ dian scouts in the employ of the United States army during the days of Indian warfare came froni the Areckaree, GroKventree and Mandan Indians of the Fort Herthold reserva­ tion.

See moreSee less

Custer's chief of scouts. Bloody Knife, was an Areckaree, 'He lost hif life in tlie 'battle of The Little Big Horn. Curley Head was nt this tim? (1S7C) ID years of age. Ho was in the battle, killed a Sioux warrior, took the Sioux blanket and in the ex­ citement escaped through the lines, made his way to the Missouri rive: and intercepted General Hanteen. who was on his way up the river on the steamboat flreatwest, with inl'orce ments. The first account, given of this bat­ tle was that wired a New York ptiper by Colonel Lonrisliop'y nliior and founder of tb HKn-an-k Tribune. Colonel Lounsb rry. usinllv correet narrator, c'toui ou.-ly reicrri-l In '.'nr ley Head as ss. Crow scout fruin the Crow reservation in Montana. This misstatement exemplilie. the practi­ cal emj'ossibilitv of catching up with an error of this kind, as practically all su' se.-iuent writers on the -battie I speak with some authority on this I States. instructions. 1

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A correspondent writing decades after the battle recounts his personal knowledge of Curley Head, a scout he says informed Custer of Sioux strength. He argues the Little Bighorn should not be called a massacre, crediting Gall and John Grass with outgeneraling Custer, whose vanity led him into a trap.

The Bismarck Tribune · 3 December 1918 · page 6

LAST FIGHT IS AT BERTHOLD for four years. I knew Curley/llead vtry well and as government agent I gave him land in severalty .and issued him a span of brood mares, four cowa and a limited supply of farm iinplevor," lor which he received $75 per month for fivo months, (,'urley Heat", died on his homestead In 1910. In this connection it is erroneous to refer to tho battle of The Little Big Horn as a massacre. The Indian neither asks nor gives Quarter in bat­ tle and takes no prisoners.

See moreSee less

In this battle Custer was simply outgeneral­ ed by Gall, John Grass and the other Sioux chiefs (Sitting Bull was not considered a lighting man by the In­ dians). Tho Indians set a trap for Custer, who walked into it and was slaughtered. It was Custer's love of personal glory, superinduced by van-] ity, that was responsible for I his so called massacre. Custer, who, accord­ ing to Curley Head, was fully in­ formed as to tho number and disposi­ tion of the Sioux by Bloody Knife, should have waited and made thej junction with Keno, which "were instructions. Speaking of the Fort Bert hold In-

See the clipping

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

The Sioux at Fort Yates celebrated the Armistice on November 30, performing their victory dance for the first time since the evening after the Custer massacre. The event also featured the first adoption of a Sioux flag and speeches urging mercy toward the defeated Germans.

Grand Forks Herald · 4 December 1918 · page 5

Fete in Which Victory Dance Fig ured for the First Time Since Eve ning After Custer Massacre. The story of the Sioux Indians' celebration of the coming of peace has just reached the city. The cele bration vfaa held at Fort Yates on November 30,. and on that occasion the Indians celebrated their famous Victory dance, the first time they have done so since the evening after the Custer massacre. Another interesting feature of tho celebration was the adoption of a Sioux flag, the first time the Indians have had one.

See moreSee less

There were Indian speakers, and those present, number ing several hundred garbed in the original Indian costumes, sang their native songs. One of the Indian speakers said: "Let them (the Germans) put away their barbarism and we will give them back their old place by the sacred camp fire of nations. For the sake of humanity, we will give them food to keep them from starving till they can provide food for themselves, ac cording to the old and sacred practice of our fathers, 'to be mericiful to a conquered enemy.'

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

At Fort Yates, N.D., western Sioux Indians celebrated the traditional Victory dance on Nov. 30, delayed from Nov. 11 due to influenza. The report notes this was the first such dance since the night after the Sitting Bull-Custer battle, and the Sioux also adopted their own flag to fly beneath the U.S. flag.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 4 December 1918 · page 1

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

Native Americans in North Dakota celebrated a victory dance for the first time since the Custer massacre, this time marking the Allied victory in World War I. Speakers praised the bravery of both white and Indian soldiers, raised over $300 for war work, and expressed no desire for revenge against the defeated enemy.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 4 December 1918 · page 1

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Sioux County Pioneer · Fort Yates, N.D.

A 1918 newspaper reports that Standing Rock Sioux held their first Victory Dance since the night after the Custer battle, now celebrating WWI's end. The ceremony included a ceremonial tree, Sioux and U.S. flags together, and speeches of reconciliation rather than revenge.

Sioux County Pioneer · 5 December 1918 · page 1

,• Saturday the Western Sioux In* tans celebrated the old time In* dian Victory-dance, postponed from Nov. 11 to Nov. 80 on, account of inflttensa. This is the flrist time the Indian Victory dance has been Celebrated since the evening after the Sitting Bull-Custer battle, ana

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

A notice announces Theo. W. Golden will speak at a YMCA men's and boys' meeting in El Paso, recounting his military experiences including having been part of the command annihilated by Sioux at Little Bighorn, from which he escaped due to detached duty. His talk will cover the battle and subsequent efforts to avenge the losses.

El Paso Herald · 5 December 1918 · page 12

SCOUT TO TALK

will be "borne soldiers x nave Known. Wnm An Indian Fishier. Mr. Golden is well known to most El Pasoans as he has made this city his home for many years, since com ing from Wisconsin and before enter ing the service of the army Y. M. C. A. In early life he was a soldier and was connected with the command which was all but annihilated by the Sioux Indians in the battle or massa cre of the Little Big Horn, when the gallant Custer and all those with him lost their lives.

See moreSee less

Golden escaped through having been sent upon detached duty the day of the massacre. In his address to the boys he will tell of this battle and subsequent efforts to avenge the losses Incurred. The boys meeting will be under di rection of "Wilson McVey, associate secretary of the boys division of the 1 Paso Y. M. G A. Music for both meetings to be held next Sunday aft ernoon will be furnished by Charles Jjounsoerry, a cornetist.

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

A North Dakota newspaper digest from December 1918 includes a brief note that Sioux Indians at the Fort Yates reservation held a victory dance for the first time since the 'Custer massacre.' The item appears amid unrelated wartime and local news items, showing how the 1876 battle still resonated in regional memory decades later.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 7 December 1918 · page 6

WEDNESDAY, DEC. 4. Sioux Indians on Fort Yates reser vation celebrated dance of victory for first time since Custer massacre. County, farm agents in North Da kota are conducting fight on blackleg. Annual conference of Fargo district of Methodist Episcopal church opened this evening. France went mad with joy when Germans signed armiBtlce terms. Miss Stella Buchanan, of Buchanan, N. D., who is in Hod Cross service, wroie to Fargo friends. Fargo office of United States em ployment service today canvass for jobs for returning soldiers. Fargo city commission indefinitely postpones action of proposal of Union Light, Heat & Power Co.

See moreSee less

to reduce gas rates if nermltted to Increase steam heat rates. Oeorge iiuiuo^k, prominent Fargo architect, in letter to The Forum, de clares against government control of railways and telegraph and telephone lines. John Charmley. veteran newspaper man of Mott, died. Pvt. John Bannister. Fargo, is the fourteenth C.o man tr die in France. He enlisted in June, 1917.

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

The obituary for printer Thomas Lyons notes his boyhood home was in Bismarck, where his father lived before Custer left Fort Lincoln in 1876 on the expedition to the Little Bighorn. It describes the outcome as the massacre of Custer's entire command by the Sioux.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 12 December 1918 · page 9

OLD BISMARCK PRINTER DIES

Mont,—Loarned Trad® With Jewell Butte, Mont, Dec. 12.—Thomas M. Lyons, 50, veteran printer or Bis marck, N. D., and many other places, died here and his body was taken ta the North Dakota capital for burial. His boyhood home was in Bis marck, where his father lived before General 'Custer left Fort Lincoln in 1876 on the famous expedition that resulted in the massacre of his whole command on the Little Big Horn by the Sioux. Thomas Lyons learned the printing trade in the Bismarck Trib une office under the guiding hana of Marshall H.

See moreSee less

Jewell, the paper's founder, and there acquired the cog nomen of "Tige" Lyons that follow ed him in printing offices all over the western country. At the time of his death he was proofreader on the Butte Miner. Two brothers and two sisters live in Bismafck. A few years' ago he was president of the local typographical union.

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

The Western Sioux at Standing Rock reservation performed the old-time Indian Victory dance for the first time since the evening after the Sitting Bull-Custer battle in 1876. The dance, delayed from Armistice Day due to influenza, may never be seen again unless the elders who know its ritual are still alive for a future war.

The Washburn Leader · 13 December 1918 · page 1

INDAINS REVIVE OLD TIME VICTORY DANCE. Fort Yates N. £f., Dec 12— Last week the Wstern Sioux celebrated the old time Indian Victory dance, postpone from November 11 to Novem ber 30 because of influenza. •This was the first time the Indian Victory dance has been celebrated on Standing Rrock reservation since the evening after the Sitting Bull-Custer battle in the summer of 1876, and 'the last time it will ever be seen unless the United States should have an other war while the old Indians' who know the ritual of this dance still live.

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The article profiles Dave Packineau, a Fort Berthold Gros Ventres rider who enlisted and fought in France, and recounts tribal history tying the Gros Ventres to Custer's scouts at Fort Lincoln. It notes that Curly Head, still living on the reservation, is regarded as possibly the only real survivor of the Custer massacre.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

The Bismarck Tribune · 14 December 1918 · page 3

Arickaras, Mandans and Hidatsas. have lived a peaceful, prosperous And contented life on Berthold reserva­ tion, which ^during the recent war es­ tablished a splendid record in patriotic work of all kinds. It was from these tribes that Custer derived all of his best scouts during the time he wa^ stationed at Fort Lincoln, and Curacy Head, wJio •still lives on the reserva­ tion is Regarded as possibly the only real survivor of the Custer massacre.

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

A newspaper obituary for Major Murphy recounts his last article about Curley Head, said to be the last survivor of the Little Bighorn battle, describing his escape and later life. The piece claims the original 1876 report by Col. Lounsberry wrongly identified Curley Head as a Crow scout, an error allegedly repeated by all later writers.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

Wrong

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 17 December 1918 · page 4

Death of Major Murphy Removes Prominent Pioneer Major John J. S. Murphy, the pioneer North Dakota resident who died several days ago at Minneapolis, had the distinction of being largely responsible for the elementary school system for Indians in the United States. He is survived by a widow and three sons, Paul B., now in training at Camp Zachary Taylor John S., Jr., a second lieutenant at Camp Grant, and Arthur, who is in the navy. Major Murphy was born at Wells ville, N. Y., on May 4, 1864, of Irish American parentage.

See moreSee less

He came to North Dakota in 1866, first settling in Ransom county. Three years later he was appointed Indian agent on the Fort Berthold reservation, which post he continued to hold until Presi dent Cleveland .named his successor in 1896. The deceased was first elected to the legislature in 1894 as a member from Ward county and he was several times fe-elected, be coming a leader in that body. He was father of North Dakota's wolf bounty act championed an ex tension of the time required for the residence of divorces, removing this st/ite from competition with Nevada for the favor of those suffering from ties which galled, and he was author of a constitutional .amendment re quiring a literary test for voters in North Dakota. The legislative session of 1896 un animously endorsed the major for United States Indian commissioner. Following his withdrawal from ac tive politics, Major Murphy became agricultural and industrial commis sioner for the Soo line at Minot, a post which he held until ill health compelled him to retire two years ago. Few men had a more exciting or1 picturesque career than Major Mur phy. Ho was a politician of the old school, and he has his bitted enemies as well as his warm friends. His close relationship with the tribes in" western North Dakota and eastern Montana, provided him with material which he used ih many articles concerning the Indians of the west. The last article written by htm was published less tjian a month ago, dealing with the history of Cur ley Head, the last survivor of the Custer massacre. In it Major Mur phy wrote: "Curley Head was at this time (1876) 19 years of age. He was in the battle of Little Big Horn, killed a Sioux warrior, took the Sioux blanket and in the excitement es caped through the lines, made his way to the Missouri river and in tercepted General Banteen, who was on his way up the river on the steamboat Greatwest with reinforce ments. Tho first account given of this battle was wired to a New York paper by Colonel Lounsberry, editor and founder of The Bismarck Tri bune. Col. Lounsberry, usually a correct narrator, erroneously re ferred to Curley Head as a Crow scout from the Crow eservation in Montana. This misstatement* ex emplifies the pactical impossibility of catching up with an error of this kind, as practically all subsequent writers on the battle of the Little Big Horn refer to Curley Head as a Crow Indian scout. "I speak with some authority on this subject regarding Curley Head as President Harrison appointed me United States agent for those Inn dians 29 years ago. I had charge of them f^r four years. I knew Curley

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

At a Standing Rock reservation school in December 1918, Hunkpapa Sioux held a Victory Dance to celebrate the Allied win over Germany, the first such dance since their 1876 victory over Custer. The report describes the ceremonial fire, kaiser effigy burning, and traditional tom-tom dance witnessed by a Red Cross representative.

The Bismarck Tribune · 18 December 1918 · page 4

United States Indian agent. The next day was a free-for-all in merry-making. The kaiser was hung in effigy, discovered toy scouts (dis. ability discharged recruits), duly shot and enthusiastically cremated. The thing of greatest, significance and im­ portance was the Victory dance. The last execution of it was in the far off days when these people celebrat­ ed the victory of Sitting Bull and Gall over Custer on that tragic field in

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This obituary for Rising Sun (John Grass) of the Turtle Mountain Chippewas recounts his long life, including his role in 1889 persuading armed mixed-blood Indians at Dunseith to disperse during a tax dispute, averting bloodshed. The piece explicitly compares the averted conflict to a repetition of the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn.

The Bismarck Tribune · 20 December 1918 · page 4

JOHN GRASS OF TURTLE MOUNTAIN CHIPPEWAS DEAD AFTER REMARKABLE LIFE

raflzed~' tion was Prevented Maaeacre. He was partly the means of pre­ venting a repetition of the Custer massacre in the Donseith hills when the county authorities had a bisun

See the clipping

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

A feature on a prosperous Gros Ventre leader, 'Old Dog,' describes the peaceful history of the Berthold reservation tribes who supplied Custer's best scouts at Fort Lincoln. It notes that Curley Head, still living on the reservation, is regarded as possibly the only real survivor of the Custer massacre.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Bismarck Tribune, 14 December 1918, The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican, 17 December 1918.

Grand Forks Herald · 23 December 1918 · page 3

"OLD DOG" IS BIG INDIAN. Bismarck, N. D., Old Dog, chief of the Gros Ventres, one of the four tribes which lives in peace and harmony on Berthold reservation, has brought Mrs. 6ld Dog to a local hos pital for treatment. Old Dog is a full blooded Gros Ventres. He stands nearly seven feet In his shoes has a magnificent breadth of shoulders and the majesty 11 of countenance and bearing are asso ciated with the Indian of fiction.i Old Dog is one of the wealthiest.! and most progressive Indians on the 1 reservation.

See moreSee less

He has thousands of acres of good land several thousand head of registered cattle and hun dreds of fine horses. Last summer he built a nine-room home in which he installed a modern heating and plumbing system. I When Bismarck was established, the Gros Ventres hunted as far south as the conjunction of the Heart with the Missouri river, jifst south of the present site of Mandan. Nedr here there was one of the Gros Ventre's fa vorite camping grounds. For' the past generation the Gros Ventres, with the Arickaras, Mandans and Hidatsans have lived a peaceful, prosperous and contented life on Berthold reservation, which during the recent war established a splendid record in patriotic work of all kinds. It was from these tribes that Cus ter derived all of his best siouts dur ing the time he was stationed at Fort Lincoln. Curley Head, who still lives on the reservation, is regarded as pos sibly the only real survivor of the Custer massacre.

See the clipping

The Devils Lake World and Inter-Ocean · Devils Lake, N.D.

An obituary for Rising Sun, a 100-year-old Chippewa elder, recounts how in 1889 he helped prevent a violent confrontation between armed Turtle Mountain Indians and county militia over a tax dispute, which was feared might become 'a repetition of the Custer massacre.' The account describes his role in persuading hundreds of armed tribesmen to disperse peacefully.

The Devils Lake World and Inter-Ocean · 25 December 1918 · page 3

RISING SUN, 100 YEARS OLD, DEAD AT HIS HOME

Prevailed Massacre. He was partly the means of pre venting a repetition of the Custer massacre in the Dunseith hills when the county authorities had a misun

See the clipping

The Ward County Independent · Minot, N.D.

This passage is part of an obituary or memorial tribute to a man called Rising Sun, recounting anecdotes of his piety, honesty, and devotion. It also credits him with averting a violent confrontation between mixed-blood Indians and county militia near Dunseith, North Dakota in January 1889 over a tax dispute.

The Ward County Independent · 26 December 1918 · page 5

He was partly the means of pre­ venting a repetition of the Custer massacre in the Dunseith hills when the County authorities had a misun­ derstanding with the mixed-blood In­

See the clipping