The Indian Leader reports on a December 1917 ceremony at Bullhead, South Dakota, honoring seven young Sioux men volunteering for U.S. Army service in WWI. It notes the area's history tied to Custer's defeat and Sitting Bull's killing, and names descendants of participants in those earlier events now present at the ceremony.
The Indian Leader · 1 January 1918 · page 6
FULL-BLOOD INDIANS VOLUNTEER
By O. R. Kopplin, .Standing Rock Reservation, S. Dak. trouble, and Grover Eagleboy.— Editor.] ULLHEAD, S. Dak., tucked away in a pretty valley on the Grand River, 20 miles southeast of Mc Intosh, once the hotbed of hostile Indians, who under Sitting Bull slew Custer and his men, also located but a few miles from the tragic spot where Sitting Bull himself was slain by the United States Indian police, was the scene of a most re country. ed marshal of the day. reputation,
The passage recounts the Thomander family's 1879 journey by ox-team from Idaho to Montana's Bitter Root valley, noting that Custer's massacre was only three years past and the Battle of the Big Hole still recent enough that remains of victims were visible along their route. It details their hardships, resolve, and lack of firearms as they traveled through dangerous territory still marked by recent conflict.
The Daily Missoulian · 6 January 1918 · page 9
lot in this, the plcasuntest valley in Montana. Four hundred mile» of rough, mountain road lay between them and the present town of Hamilton. With today'« improved highways and our modern mean* of travel 400 mill« through the Rockies is not only an inconsiderable trip, but a real pleasure to a man ar, d his family. Hut such a journey 38 years ago with an ox-Uant was a very different undertaking, when it is remembered that hostile Indians infested t he woods and road agents haunted the routes of the overland stage.
See moreSee less
Custer's massacre was but three years i>ast. and the Battle of the Big llole, over which sacred field the route would lead them, was still so recent that remains of some of the victims of that bloody fight were still in evi dence.
A 1918 article reports on the retirement of veteran court stenographer Bartholomew Sloynahan after many years of service in New York courts. Among his notable career highlights, the piece mentions he reported the court-martial of Major Reno in Chicago, which arose from the Custer massacre.
The Sun · 6 January 1918 · page 6
dally work at the Criminal Court Buiio. lug yesterday said, "good-by" to i:Ar.' tholomew Sloynahan on hat voluntary retirement as official stenographer ef the Criminal Brunch of thn Some Court. He had been there tweniv find In that time hart reported the tri.i. ivuuiiiu ,ullIlf3ll, nr. Kenncrlv Nan Patterson and Ilnrry K, Thaw j, was said he ha been a sliortlnt -ul re porter forty-three years. He renori.,! the trial of Men. Babcock, secretary t Gen. (Ir.uit, lu St. l.otil. nnd the co,ir' martial In Chicago of Major lleno whlrh grew out of the Custer massacre
An obituary for Montana pioneer White Calfee recounts his adventurous life, including service with Kit Carson, the Confederate Army, and General Terry's relief column after the Little Bighorn battle. It states he personally counted 243 dead white men and 16 dead Indians on the Custer battlefield.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Harlem News · 11 January 1918 · page 9
WHO CAME TO MONTANA YEARS AGO, IS DEAD. Was Associated With Kit Carson, a Boy Fought Mexico; the Confederate Army; Mas * General Terry; Counted the e on the Custer Battle Field. White Calfee, who lived an adv turous life until his later yeais, had been a resident of Montana the past half century, died at n home in Bozeman a few days He was born in Kentucky in 1 > and much of his boyhood was spent in Texas during the guerilla wars Be tween Texas and Mexico. He is saia to have participated in many battles even before he had reached mans estate When the south seceeded Calfee enlisted in an Arkansas Confederate regiment.
See moreSee less
He was taken prisoner at the battle of Prairie Grove in 1862. After he had been confined in prison for a time he took the oath of allieg ance to the federal government and was released. Was With Kit Carson. In the spring of 1864, while at Fort Sumner he was arrested for treasonable utterances and spent two months in prison at Fort Union. Aft er his release from there he joined an expedition under Kit Carson to New Mexico. Crossing the plains in 1865, the party he accompanied had many encounters with the Indians. He arrived in Bozeman in July, and has made his home in or near the city the greater part of the time, be ing engaged in farming for several years. He also had a saw mill in this vicinity and another at Pony, selling both a number of years ago. On Custer Field. He has often told of his exper iences when a member of the Yellow stone expedition, as he was with Gen. Terry’s company that went to relieve Custer, but found on meeting the Indian scout Curley about the Custer massacre. He stated that when he reached the C ister battle field he counted 243 dead white men and 16 dead Indians. with all luxuries abandoned that can be dispensed with. There will also be fewer trains running in the near future, as any thing that has the appearance of duplication will be cut out. As a result the trains that do run will be usually pretty well filled up, as no more coaches will be used than the actual passenger traffic warrants. In the dining coars the fare will be simple, with luxuries in an edible way all eliminated. Substantial food will be served, but there will be no frills. As a matter of fact, most of the cutting down aong that line has already taken place.
This nostalgic article recalls Custer's lifelong habit of riding, noting he died in June 1876 in the Little Big Horn valley, and recounts anecdotes of his war horses during the Civil War. It also includes recollections of Generals Sherman and Hooker from the Atlanta campaign, mixed in with unrelated newspaper filler like an advertisement and a legal notice.
St. Helens Mist · 11 January 1918 · page 6
sergeant when tne regiment was m . friendi pre9ented to him. as I learn retreat, ordered the "About fare" and ; whcn U)e general was m comman l IS63. !!. tieorge A. Custer Follow your general. i ne regiq( U)e department of Kentucky, from ment obeyed, and Steedman spurred ; which ,)e was relieved by the war ofGen. Custer, mounted, was in In
A 1918 newspaper feature recalls various generals' horses, including several belonging to Custer—Don Juan, Frog Town, and Dandy. It describes Dandy as present at the Little Bighorn battle, wounded but surviving to return to Fort Lincoln and later sent to Custer's father.
St. Helens Mist · 11 January 1918 · page 6
In North Carolina by Custer's men. This Is the horse that Gen. Custer rode down Pennsylvania avenue, Washington, in the grand review of May, 18 65, the observed of all ob servers. Don Juan went wild that day, and ran away In the parade. The huzzas that were about to greet him at the reviewing stand fell to a silent hush, and a dozen mounted or derlies rushed In pursuit. The presi dent and cabinet started up in In voluntary fear, but Custer threw a rapid salute at the array of dizzy of ficials, and with a powerful effort stopped the flying war horse as If ?
See moreSee less
giant had chained a thunderbolt. Frog Town was another of Gen. Custer's war horses. He was the finest specimen of the thoroughbred 1 ever saw, standing 16 hands, well balanced and of excellent proportions, In motion he was superb, a perfect model for the sculptor's art. The favorite war horse of Gen. Custer on the plains was a brown horse called Dandy. He was 15 i hands, a com pact, muscular horse, fine head and neck. He marched In the ranks of Custer's little army of daring troop ers on June 25, 1876, against the confederated Sioux tribes, that ter rible day of the massacre of Custer and his men, in the valley of Little Big Horn, and was shot through the shoulder. He lived, however, to re turn to Fort Lincoln, whence, after a partial recovery, he was sent to
A newspaper miscellany piece first explains the classical 'Greek gift' phrase, then gives a brief historical summary of the Battle of Little Bighorn, describing Custer's five troops being wiped out while Reno's command suffered heavy losses nearby. It notes the expedition against Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse, and that the Indians withdrew upon hearing of Gibbon's approaching column.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 15 January 1918 · page 6
Information Bureau Inquiries regnrdlng (llinosl any toplr, eii'i'ptlnc un legal and medico I inb Jeeix, nre nnwvrered free. ,\p all ln? uulrle* are nnnvicreil dlrrctl) by per. tonnl letter n nelf-iidilrcjined, utamprfl envelope In rei|Ulri-d. \?JdreH? I'h* i I liui*-DI?pn(i It Informr t Ion Itureau, Itirliuiond, A a. Included I nder the Itule. ?c. It. I... 1;,i?.t:\ iUe.?This bureau does not utrlertckc to lurnish information ot the himl you request: our adver tising columns olt'er a good tuediuio fur business dual:-. liegiMranfn in Jnll. T A . Richmond.?-Yes. persons in j:nls and prisons on June were regis- !
See moreSee less
'ered under the draft law, and It i. to ro assumed that their registration ; card.- will he delivered to lliem upon' the expiration of tlisir :?entente::. fnmoti tlngi'. 1! M. II. Newport News. --Camou flage i.- Krenoh -.tudio : Jang tor what our painters ]I "faking" trt the art of painting. In Mich picture* the aim of tinartist is to introduce real ob ject.- in such a way that they ian lvirdly i,e distinguished from the t-b .Urts merely depicted. When art was employed in *? ;iv conceal :!i? nature ; of real objects, "camouflage" was very naturally borrowed to describe trick. ? ery of this kind. A battery is ramou I tla'ge.l if it in in full sight, but made invisible .is i-u-'li by art. Itrnft 4{uotna. I IS. M. ?;.. I'hnporia.? Under the new I ruies of clas: ideation for the draft all i registrants are subject to call by the I board of examiner*?. Credit for volun i leers previous to the close of the. tirst | draft was allowed to counties on their I quotas, and .ueh credit, it in excet's of i tli<! quota un'ler the. llrtit call, would he } carried forward to the next quota, is i tho general understanding. '? "(ireck lilft" mill tlie W'fK>ilen Ilorne. i Miss H. M.. IJichniond. ? Reference to | thi? "ilrecrt Kift ' will be found in Vir I gil's "Aeneid," as follows: "I fear th<~ j Greek?1, even when they bring gifts." The wooden horse, according to t-JrecK ! mythology, was a gigantic horse which j ligured in the siege of Troy and caused tlie fall and det ruction of the city. It whs devised by I iyssc and I 'ioinedes. was ltdi 11 of wood, and filled with 1 fired; soldi' rs. S.inon. a cunning tJreek. | Informed tli" Trojans that tlir wooden I iiorse had been constructed as an atone ment for the. palladium, which had been cari'ed off by th? ilrechs, ;<i;? I that if I ihey would drag it into their own. city, ; Asia would gain the s upremacy over j | Greece. The Trojans believed the story j and introduced the wooden horse wiiii ! in their wails, whereupon Sinon at j night released the soldiers, who Imme [ diutely opened the gates to the lireehs. The sc;itinel.s were .-lain and the city sacked and bin tied. Vur\it nr> of t)te ? 'rj?ilcr MjiMni'rr, A n. I*'.. l.\'nohbiirc ?????>neral t'Jeorge A. Custer, ttie famous Indian fighter of tlie Seventh United States Cavalry, and every officer and man under him in the tive troop1' to the number of 'MO. v.ere hilled on the battle held of Uittie Horn. The rest of the Seventh Cavalry, ja few niiiea away Iroin Custer, under Major Jleno. lost heavily in killed and wounded. The Seventh Cavalry, under <.ien era I ?'?.islcr, was only a part of a big expedition sent out against. Hie j Sioux Indians., led by Sitting Thill. Crazy j Horse, and other chiefs. Indian ?ign:> J having been reported, tho Seventh Cavalry, under General Custer, consist ing of twelve troops, was ordered de tached from the main body to take up tne trail and tind the Indians, with a | view to make it possible to surround them with the aid of the. main body. This plan failed, and what was left, of Major Reno's command was only saved when the Indians suddenly began to withdraw after hearing of the ap proach of the main column under GeuI eral Gibbon. Says Carlin Grants Woman Suffrage
A movie theater advertisement promotes the film 'Man Above the Law,' an Indian drama set in the Wild West era. The ad claims cast member Minnie Provost is an aged Indian squaw who was the last surviving witness of the Custer Massacre of 1876.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Laramie Republican · 21 January 1918 · page 6
TRINAGLE PRESENTS “MAN ABOVE THE LAW” A big Indian Drama of the by-gone days of the Wild and Wooly West. In the cast of this play will be MINNIE PROVOST, an aged Indian squaw, supposed to be • the last surviving witness of the Custer Massacre in 1876. The leaders in this big
An advertisement for the Empress Theater promotes the film 'Man Above the Law,' a Western drama featuring Minnie Provost, described as an aged Indian woman supposedly the last surviving witness of the Custer Massacre of 1876. The ad also lists other cast members and showtimes.
The Laramie Republican · 22 January 1918 · page 6
“MAN ABOVE THE LAW” A big Indian Drama of the by-gone days of the Wild and Wooly West. In the cast of this play will be MINNIE PROVOST, an aged Indian squaw, supposed to be the last surviving witness of the Custer Massacre in 1876. The leaders in this big play are JACK RICHARDSON, JOSIE SEDGWICK, CLAIRE McDOWELL MARY GERACIA And a full cast of Indians. With above will be a Keystone Comedy Six Reels, Shows 7:15 and 8:45 Admission 10 and 20 cents. ZEPPELIN’S LAST RAID WEDNESDAY
Outdoor Life editor Chauncey Thomas claims Gen. Custer and his officers were drunk during the Little Bighorn fight and that Custer disobeyed orders by engaging the Indians. The article suggests Custer would have faced court martial had he survived.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Courier-Index · 25 January 1918 · page 11
MAGAZINE WRITER SAYS GENERAL CUSTER WAS DRUNK WHEN HE FOUGHT INDIANS
1 I Cliauncey Thomas, contributing ed itor to Outdoor Life, a magazine pub lished in Denver, Col., for lovers of outdoor life and sports, has an article in the January number of the magazine in which new side lights are thrown on the famous fight in which Gen. Custer and his little band of soldiers were extermi uated by the Indians. According tc Thomas, Gen. Custer and his officers were drunk at the time of the fight. < uster disobeyed the orders of his commanding officer and took his detachment of men out to meet fhe Indians, and had Custer's life been spared the chances are he Would have faced a court martial.
See moreSee less
The article written by Mr. Thomas follows: I fn tlie October issue Lieut. Geo. N Quaekenhos, of the New York f'lty police department, and formerly an old timer on the pjains. lias an account of the Custer fight, and touches, with keen interest to all old time westerners, on many details of the early days beyond the Big Muddy. Therein he honors me with Pleasant words, and speaks especial of my father, W. ft. Thomas, the pioneer editor, who knew personally tuost. if indeed not all, of the men Pientioned by Lieut. Quackenbos. I war between the red and the white as the white invaded the red man's land, a victory for the white was a battle, and a victory for the red was a massacre. In fact, it is easy to tell which side won here or there by the use of these two words, "battle ' or "massacre" by the white recorder. No doubt the Indian his torian merely reversed the two words, and with the same lack of justification. A massacre is when one side is helpless, either unarmed non combatants, prisoners, or those who have surrendered, and the kill ing side is comparatively all-power ful. and slays without possible re sistance. In Indian-white man warfare there were many massacres, first on one side then on the other. The Indians killed unarmed men, women and children, then the whites killed un armed Indians—men, women and children. Of course it sounds a bit nicer to say ‘bucks, squaws and nits.” yet the fact remains that they were men, women and children. We whites did it down to the last new born babe at Sand Creek, and other places without number, and so did the Indians. I speak without personal prejudice for one of my ancestors, who came
A writer recounts frontier massacre lore including the legend of Thomas Quick, then claims a long-hushed truth about Custer's defeat: that Custer disobeyed Terry's orders out of personal jealousy, and that both Custer and Reno were drunk during the battle. Benteen, held back with the baggage train, was not drunk and saw little fighting.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Courier-Index · 25 January 1918 · page 11
WAS DRUNK WHEN HE FOUGHT INDIANS
side then on the other. The Indians killed unarmed men, women and children, then the whites killed un armed Indians—men, women and children. Of course it sounds a bit nicer to say ‘bucks, squaws and nits.” yet the fact remains that they were men, women and children. We whites did it down to the last new born babe at Sand Creek, and other places without number, and so did the Indians. I speak without personal prejudice for one of my ancestors, who came back to his cabin one day to find his wife dressed and hung up like a beef, and his children dead, scat tered about the door where one by one they had been whirled about an Indian’s feathered head and then hud their brains dashed out against the door step—this man went hunt ing for Indians.
See moreSee less
And in his life he killed 100 men, women and child ren. He died of smallpox, and the j Indians dug him up, held a great Custer as is well known, was more or less in disgrace in the army at that time, and General Terry had been put in command of the expo-; sition against the Indians. Custer, purely for personal reasons, disobey ed Terry's expressed orders, and at tacked the Indians without proper support. If Custer had lived he would undoubtedly have been court martialed. victory or no victory, for insubordination wherein he risked the lives of his command for per sonal gain and jealousy against his superior officers. All this, of course, is old history, published many times. But the mystery so far has been hushed up. yet it is the other of the two reasons that caused the de feat on the Little Bighorn, and that; is just plain whiskey. Ueno was drunk that dav. And so wras Custer and most of the officers under him. Benteen was not drunk, but he was left in the rear in command of the
A 1918 newspaper piece claims drunkenness among Custer and his officers, not just insubordination, caused the Little Bighorn disaster, citing a secondhand account of a man who left Custer's command fearing exactly such an outcome. It also describes Sitting Bull fleeing before battle with two squaws and portrays him as a cowardly medicine man rather than a war leader, while noting the Indians lacked unified command.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Courier-Index · 25 January 1918 · page 11
Command under Custer. Three men died at Antelope Springs before that and Custer was drunk Time heals many sores, and Time brings out the truth hidden at the time, but I the fact is that Custer was not liked by his men. Because of his dramatic death, we have tried to make a hero j of him as the leading figure among I the army officers of the plains; but ! the fact was, and is. that he was held in less trust and esteem at the time tfiau most of the other noted officers of the frontier, such ns I have been able to piece together, j and as I said 1 have been Interested in the ('uster matter all ray life, and have had a fair chance to get !
See moreSee less
the inside about it from uncolored sources. Disobedience of orders, personal jealousy and whiskey did it, and the most fortunate man on that battle field was ('uster himself, for he died there of his own recklessness, and did not live to face the disgrace that was inevitable • had he lived. Reno
This is a 1918 review of a book about Sioux history and assimilation into white culture, noting their transition to modern conveniences like automobiles and matches. It references the Battle of Little Bighorn as a moment of intense interest, mentioning Custer's command was annihilated by Sioux under Sitting Bull, and notes the author includes an Indian's account for balance.
The Bismarck Tribune · 28 January 1918 · page 6
^mance. The famous battle of the Lit tle Big Horn, in which Custer's com 'tnand was annihilated by the Sioux «nder Sitting Bull, is of intense inter est. The author endeavors to be fair, Admitting that this battle has always -$een described by white men, so he in
A newspaper review describes a book presenting the Sioux account of the Little Bighorn battle, noting that descendants of the warriors who defeated Custer object to the standard white version of events. The review praises the book's fairness and its inclusion of a chapter on Sioux religion and a closing portrait of the Sioux in contemporary times.
The Bismarck Tribune · 28 January 1918 · page 6
Brown. But this Indian does not dismas the cause of the and it is fiEht. cuss the cause of the fight, and it is just here where the modern civilized children of these red men who defeat ed Custer at the Little Big Horn ob ject to the white man's history of the battle. There is an interesting chap ter on the religion of the Sioux, and
The article recounts a sentimental story of Lincoln promoting a young guardsman, later Colonel Ilges, who fought through the Civil War and then against the Sioux. It credits Ilges with capturing Sitting Bull and Gall and hails him as the avenger of Custer, whose 'entire cavalry regiment' allegedly fell at Little Bighorn.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Luxemburger Gazette · 31 January 1918 · page 9
Lyon & Willging. befürchten lassen. gahlüngen murden während des Rechts - Anwälte. - Geschstsjähres von der Kanalbehörde im Betrage von F 98,100,610 b 5 gepilvlß B.& I. Bidg., Dubuque, lowa. mes zu brechen und die Fauptlinge Gaul und Sitting Bull gefängen i nehmen. Der ganze Nordwesten, besonders aber die Siedler in Minnesota, athme ten erleichtert auf und feierten den schneidigen deutsch - amerikanischen Offizier als Retter Bei den Soldaten galt er als der Rächer Custer's, der 1876 belanntlich nebst einem gangen Regiment Kaballerie unter den Strei chen der von Sitting Bull geführten Sioux gefallen war. 1886 schied Ilges aus dem Militärdienst aus und hat seitdem in Cincinnati gewohnt. Viele Jahre lang hatte er das Amt des srädtischen Wägemeisters belleidet.