As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

July 1912

15 articles

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

A dispatch reports the death in Cedar Rapids of Joseph McScattoa, aged seventy, a veteran of many Indian wars who died from an old tomahawk wound. The report states he was present with Custer when the general was killed by Sitting Bull.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Iowa County Democrat · 4 July 1912 · page 4

Indian Warrior Dies

Cedar Rapids, la., July 3.—As a re sult of a tomahawk wound received thirty-five years ago Joseph McScat toa. hero of many Indian wars, la dead here, aged seventy. He was with Custer when the general was killed by Sitting Bull.

See the clipping

The Daily Sentinel · Grand Junction, Colo.

A speaker reminisces about visiting the Little Bighorn battlefield, describing it as the site where General Custer and the Seventh Cavalry died fighting the Sioux. He frames the soldiers as heroes whose sacrifice secured the frontier for later generations.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Daily Sentinel · 5 July 1912 · page 3

& ———————————————————————— vears. Years ago, when the settlers of you came on in advance of the wave of civilization. It is said that the early pioneers of the west all were brave and hardy people because the timid never started and the weak died on the way. PPioneers Were Heroes. I am not a pioneer, 1 can never hope to be numbered with those who laid the foundations, of this great state. The best I can aspire to is to be considered worthy to help carry on their work. I am not easily mov ed through my sympathies, but the thoughts that come to me as I con sider the life of the pioneer are strangely affecting.

See moreSee less

1 regard . the men and women who blazed the trail into this valley as heroes. 1 stood one day on the famous bat tlefield on the Little Big Horn in Wyoming where General Custer, bemmed in by the savage Sioux, went with the Seventh Cavalry to their death. As I gazed at the dis tant brown hills that circles the last resting place of that gallant band, and thought how ineffably sad was their tragic death in that lonely land, I felt proud to be a citizen of a country that had such soldiers as these to guard with their lives the outposts of its frontier. Their deaths were not in vain for their herole deeds have been told in song and story for the admiration of the world. Monuments may mark where they fell and today a grateful people dwell in peace and safety in the region preserved by their daunt less deeds. A year ago I was over in one of the beautiful mountain parks of this western slope, and I saw where an other hero had planted an outpost of civilization and blazed the trail for us to follow. %“n a little valley rich with waving grass a Colorado pion eer and his wife had spent the hest vears of their lives, In the early days of their struggle in this new country one of the horses died and this dauntless man had hitched a cow in its place. He grubbed ti.e tough sage brush; he stirred the stubborn soil with his plow:; he brought out his ditch over interminable miles of rocky hillslide. He worked and waited for 30 vears and finally sold out for what to him was a fortune. His wife, broken by her labors, sank under the burden and went to sleep, just as the enjoy ment of the reward of their toil was near. The man, unstrung from his privations in the long, long years, lost his mind. These two, in life and death, were heroic. No bugle summoned them to that grim conflict with nature. No monuments mark where their bones are laid. Yet they gave up their lives for their country as truly as soldiers who fall in battle. When next I stand in historic places where memorials of bronze and marble tell of a people’s reverence for those who died that we might have security and enjoyment in our day, I shall think of those two aged pioneers, sinking to sleep, leaving that valley beautified by their lives of toil for others to enjoy. The kind of heroism that makes the strongest appeal to me is the steadfast heorism of that lonely man and his strangely mismated team turning the first fur rows in the vast silences of the un peopled frontier. Colorado is Well Fed. A friend of mine told men when 1 was starting over here that this was a supremely great occasion on which to deliver a Fourth of July address. “Colorado is filled with a vague un rest,” said he, “The state is stirred to its very center with feelings never felt before.” Perhaps this is true, yet I see no reason why, on a beautiful day like this, I should spend my time and

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This article looks back from 1912 on Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn, the Nez Perce conflict, and the killing of Sitting Bull at Pine Ridge, framing them as the end of the Indian as warrior. It then shifts to nostalgic discussion of dime novels like Buffalo Bill stories that romanticized frontier outlaws and pony express days.

New-York Tribune · 7 July 1912 · page 28

dred and seventy-five of his troopers on the Little Big l|.,rn, in Montana, in 1^7?>; the revoll and ubjugation ,,! Chief [osoph and the Nea Perces in 1877; and the outbreakand subversion oi the Sioux near Pinc Ridge, South l).ik..t.i, in 1VH>, which had for one ol itsincidi nl i the killing of Sitting Bull, one of Custer' i layers ol the

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Dr. C. C. Dibert was critically injured during a sham battle reenactment of the Little Bighorn at a July 4th celebration in Bedford, PA. A gun wad lodged in his ear and powder burned his face, causing him to fall from his horse unconscious and bleeding.

Evening Star · 7 July 1912 · page 13

INJURIES MAY BE FATAL.

Red Men and Company L, 5th Regiment. Pennsylvania National Guard, save a r? production of the battle of the Little Big Horn, where Custer and his command were killed. Following the skirmish, some of the rou^h riders were running the gantlet. Indians being stationed along the race track. A wad from a gun lodged in Di Dibert's ear. powder badly burning hi> face, and he fell from his horse, blond streaming from h's ears and mouth. !!? was unconscious several hours. When tl accident occurred Dr. Dibert was ridit.% with Miss Margaret Stiver, an attractive little rough rider, who had led the parade in the morning.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A retrospective article discusses dime novels and frontier romance, referencing Custer's death at Little Big Horn in 1876 as historical background. It frames this alongside other Western events like the Nez Perce conflict and Sitting Bull's killing as part of a bygone era now being replaced by assimilation.

Evening Star · 7 July 1912 · page 28

dred and seventy-five of his troopers on the Little Big Horn, in Montana, in 1876; the revolt and subjugation of Chief Joseph and the Nez Perces in 1877; and the outbreak and subversion of the Sioux near Pine Ridge, South Dakota, in 1890, which had for one of its incidents the killing of Sitting Bull, one of Custer's slayers of the Little Big Horn,?the red man as a fighter stepped out.

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A veteran Indian fighter named Joseph McSeaton died in a Cedar Rapids hospital from an old tomahawk wound. The report states he had scouted under Custer when the general was killed by Sitting Bull, and later served under Sheridan.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Wrong

Evening Times-Republican · 8 July 1912 · page 5

Tingley, July 8.—A. R. Franklin, a prominent citizen of this place, died suddenly Saturday while at work in a grain field near town. He had been assisting Ike KIburz in the harvest field, and without warning toppled over upon a sheaf of grain, dying of heart failure before aid could be rendered. The deoeased was a member of the city council and of the school board. He is survived by his widow and a brother, Fred, who Is living in Des Moines. Mrs. Franklin was In Des Moines at the time of her husband's death.

See moreSee less

Muscatine. Celebrating the Fourth with a pistol containing genuine .leaden pellets caused Lyle McGuire to spend the night In the city jail and cogitate over the irony of "independence," which he was commemorating. Washington. At a meeting of the building com mitttee of the Methodist church, the contract for the new church was let to H. J. Bishop of Cedar Rapids for $57,093. The work of staking off the lot for the new building was com menced the following morning and work will be pushed as fast as pos sible on the new building. It is an ticipated that building operations will take about a year. Cedar Rapids. Joseph McSeaton, veteran war scout and Indian fighter, died in a local hos pital here, aged 70 years. Death was due to a tomahawk wound received in an Indian encounter twenty-five years ago. McSeaton was a scout under Custer at the time that the general was killed by Sitting Bull, and was also scout under Sheridan In Indian war fare. He had been wounded a number of times and carried several bullets In his body. What ChMr. Quite a number of enthusiastic peo ple of the town held a second meet ing at the city hall to finish the work of forming a permanent park organisa tion. It was decided to call the organ ization The What Cheer Park asso ciation, and to Incorporate for fifty years. The by-laws prepared by Messrs. Windett, Harbison and Snouf fer were adopted with slight changes and other matters of Interest were dis cussed. Davenport. What nearly proved a fatal accident fcllov/ed the throwing of a firecracker. The victim of the mishap was Albert Pent, a young man residing with his parents along the Green Tree road. Peat was In the rig when some one, unknown to the authorities, tossed a big firecracker Into the street. The thing exploded and the horses sprang forward with a bound. Peat, who was seated in the rear seat, fell out back ward and landed on his head. He was picked up unconscious. Prlneaton. A petition was received from the Princeton Cemetery Improvement As sociation at the last meetong of the town council asking that Oak Ridge cemetery be purchased from Dr. John Knox, to become the property of the town. Dr. Fulton and M. L. Hire were appointed a committee by Mayor Smith to investigate the matter. The town license of Fred Kruse, saloon keeper, whose permit was renewed for this year at a special meeting of the council, was raised from 24.60 a month to Museatina. Considerably to the gratification of the button factories of this city Is the fact that a targe amount ot shells Is being shipped here, both by water and by rail. Several cargoea of shells have recently been brought up the river In barges, the Columbia and the Mucket having brought 'many tons of shells to the city within the past few weeks. Many carloads of sheila are also being received by rail. For torn time past there has been a scarcity of shells for the smaller button fac tories, nad where it was impo^alble to obtain thein It was necessary for tM ffcetovjr to

See the clipping

The Greeley Tribune · Greeley, Colo.

An elderly man calling himself 'Buffalo Jack' McConnell visits Greeley, Colorado, claiming to have served with Captain McKenzie at the time of the Custer massacre and been honored by Generals Scott, Grant, and Meade. He also claims to have been captured by Sitting Bull, scarred by a thrown tomahawk, saved by the chief's daughter Silver Heels, and to have later eloped with and married her.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Greeley Tribune · 11 July 1912 · page 6

Indian War Fame is Visiting Here + "Buffalo Jack” McConnell is 4 ♦ In Greeley after an absence of + ♦ over a year. "Buffalo Jack” + ♦ has returned from the Mexican <• -4 border where he was petroling 4 + 150 miles of the frontier with <• •4 six others. Buffalo Jack Is + 4 80 years old but still has a * ♦ longing for the fighting life. ❖ ♦ He was with Captain Me- * 4* Kenzle at the time of the 4* 4* Custer massacre and has been 4- •4 honored for bravery by Gen- -4 4eral Scott, General Grant and -4 4General Meade.

See moreSee less

4> 4* Years ago while Lu Baker -4 4* was hunting buffalo on the 4> 4* banks of Lone Tree creek east 4* + of Greeley McConnell saved his 4 4* life from death by the Indians. -4 4 While Buffalo Jack was scout4* 4ing for the government he was 4- ♦ captured by Sitting Bull and 4* + still bears the mark of * + 4* tomahawk that the chief threw + 4* at him. It was the pleading of 44- Bllver Heels, the chief's daugh- + + ter. that saved Buffalo Jack 44- from death at the stake. Buf4- ♦ falo Jack ran away with Silver ♦ 4 Heels and married her. 4. ♦ Buffalo Jack McConnell ar- ♦ + rived in Greeley Wednesday ♦ 4and Is here to see about his ♦ 4> pension. 4 444444444444444 Evans Men Mix It Evans, July 9.—The case of Mike O'Grady, charged with the running of a disorderly bouse In Evans, will come up soon In Greeley. Mike O'Grady waa arrested last fall by Marshal Winchester. Friday Win chester and O’Grady met on the Stmt. » n d. PJ>. of she hard feelings between them mixed It Winchester was fined $5 and eosta la Jadge Tregonlng's court. Ha paid the fine.

See the clipping

Fergus County Democrat · Lewistown, Mont.

Emil Plum, a Lewistown resident who served with Major Reno's command and arrived at the Little Bighorn battlefield the day after the Custer massacre, has died after a long illness. The obituary recounts his long military career and later civilian life in Montana.

Fergus County Democrat · 16 July 1912 · page 1

DEATH OF EMIL PLUM, AN OLD TIME RESIDENT. FUNERAL HELD FROM CATHOLIC CHURCH—SAW MUCH SERVICE IN INDIAN CAMPAIGNS.

J. Abel, John Brooks, Mike Gurnett, Timothy Crowley aud Daniel Crowley. The decedent was born at Barman on-the-Rhiue, Germany, Sept. 29, 1846, and when eighteen years of age en tered the German army, serving in the war with Austria. Coming to this country in 1868, he at once enlisted in the cavalry branch of the army and served continuously for ten years. At the time of the Custer massacre, he was with Major Reno's command and

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A 1912 letter from a former railroader reminisces about accompanying Capt. Grant Marsh on the steamboat that carried wounded soldiers from the Little Bighorn battlefield in 1876. The writer questions details from memory after 36 years, including the pilot's name and a commemorative elk-horn shield mounted on the boat.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 16 July 1912 · page 4

(events, but well remember your ar its rival at Bismarck with the wounded from the Custer battlefield, and had rative. 1 recall vividly fitting up a

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A correspondent writes in 1912 recalling personal memories from the 1870s, including seeing Custer battlefield relics like travois and pemmican unloaded from the steamer Far West, and meeting Generals Sheridan, Terry, and Sherman. The writer expresses admiration for the recipient's role in those historic events and hopes to visit the region again.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 16 July 1912 · page 4

|Ved by tlon with the trip that is not quite shortly after the arrival of the "Far West" with a number of Interesting relics from the Custer battlefield, consisting of travolrs, tranos, lodge poles, etc., together with large quan­ tities of pemican in sacks that were corded up on the levee like ricks of cord wood. I am not sure, however, whether this was on the famous trip mentioned or on a subsequent one. It was also my pleasure to have personally, conducted the trip of Gen. Sheridan, Gen. Terry and Gen.

See moreSee less

For­ syth and others over the Northern Pacific railroad to Bismarck, at the time they went there to arrange foi the disarming of the Indians and take their ponies from them. I also had the pleasure of n^eeting Gen. Sherman and Gen. Terry on the occasion ot their visit to that section mentioned

See the clipping

Decorah Public Opinion · Decorah, Iowa

The report says Joseph McSeaton, a Civil War veteran and former scout for Custer and Sheridan, died in Cedar Rapids at age 70, with a post-mortem showing his death resulted from a tomahawk blow received 35 years earlier. It states he scouted for Custer at the time Custer was killed by Sitting Bull.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 16 days earlier.

Decorah Public Opinion · 24 July 1912 · page 3

WEST UNION BASE BALL. Game Friday with Waticama, and Others Wanted.—Newcomer Brothers the Battery. West Union now has a first class base ball team. The committee nam ed for taat purpose has raised a good guarantee fund and has hired the Newcomer brothers, the popular and effective players from U. I. U.’s al most invincible team, to officiate as a battery, while excellent local tal ent will fill the other places on the nine. Manager J. W. Dwyer desires the teams of all nearby towns to know that West Union now has a first class ball team, and that the team is open for games with any team that wishes to make a date, for any place at any time, except on Sunday.—West Un ion Argo.

See moreSee less

Guess Manager Shea’s braves will have to go down and give them a few rounds. Veteran Indian Fighter Passes. Joseph McSeaton, a veteran of the war of the south and an Indian fight er, after successfully evading the craftiness of the Redmen for many years, finally was conquered by the man on the white horse and passed away at Cedar Rapids last Monday, at the age of 70 years. A post mor tem examination of the brain showed that death resulted from a tomahawk blow received in an Indian engage ment thirty-five years ago. McSeat on was a scout for Custer at the time he was killed by Sitting Bull. He also scouted for Sheridan and was in several noted Indian wars. Beautiful Women. Nothing adds more to the beauty of women than luxuriant hair. The regular use of Meritol Hair Tonic will keep the hair healthy, promote its growth, keep it clean and bright, and gives it that wavy appearance so much admired. E. J. Barman, Druggist, Decorah, lowa, sole agent. George L. Higbie, Manton, Mich., used Foley Kidney Pills for kidney and bladder trouble. He says: “I find for my case no other medicine equals Foley Kidney Pills for bene ficial effect." They are a safe and reliable medicine for kidney trouble and rheumatism. Contain no harm ful drugs. Sold by Engbertson’s Pharmacy. July NEW CREAMERY AT FORT. Farmers Tributary to Fort Atkinson to Build a New < ’reamery. The promoters for the Burnap Building and Supply Co. of Toledo, Ohio, have given up the attempt to sell enough stock in the creamery, owing to the strong opposition to their plan. However, there has been a very strong sentiment worked up among the farmers tributary to Fort Atkinson to put up a creamery, to be owned and controlled entirely by the farmers, and the business men of Ft. Atkinson are helping the good thing along by offering to donate the sum of $390 or more to the farmers toward buying the necessary lots if they will put up and organize a far mers’ creamery on the co-operative plan. It is proposed to call a meeting in the near future and have the stat* dairy commissioner come and give a lecture and also give the farmers the benefit of his knowledge how best to organize,and operate it. Fort At kinson offers the best advantages for the successful operation of a first class creamery. Ice can be had right there at a trifling expense. Loading and unloading coal and produce will be only a fraction of what it costs others, and the shipping facilities are of the very best. It is up to the far mers to take an interest in the mat tried next Tuesday. ter and get together as soon as pos sible. —Ossnan Bee.

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

A 1912 letter from a former Northern Pacific railroad official to Captain Grant Marsh recalls the famous 1876 steamboat journey carrying wounded soldiers from the Little Bighorn battlefield. The writer reminisces about mounting elk horns on the boat's pilot house to commemorate the trip and questions whether Capt. Nick Benson served as pilot, asking Marsh to confirm or correct his memory.

The Washburn Leader · 26 July 1912 · page 1

*•'-•*:vvV^--•-- --.v.^. .: :. ti-----.--- '-v. •. •••'•. whom you probably remember, a copy of the "Conquest of the Missouri," and having been a resident of tuat section of the country during the stirring times immediately preceeding it and for some, time after Custer's massacre it being my pleasure to have had intimate ac quaintance with General Custer, and a great many of the officers who were killed with him, as well as other promi nent characters who were identified with the development of that country, having also Jjad the pleasure of meeting you, although possibly you may not re call it, I was extremely interested in reading this book, as it recalled many incidents with which I was personally familiar.

See moreSee less

In 1873 I was appointed General Master Mechanic of the Northern Pa cific railroad, in charge of their motive power and equipment, and was in that country until 1878. Of course after the elapse of 36 years, it is difficult to re call all of the detail or events, but I well remember your arrival at Bismarck with the wounded from the Custer

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

A correspondent writing in 1912 reminisces about meeting the recipient upon the Far West's arrival at Bismarck with wounded from the Custer battlefield, recalling details like a pilot named Capt. Nick Benson and relics unloaded at a warehouse. He admits uncertainty about several details and asks the recipient to correct him if his memory is faulty.

The Washburn Leader · 26 July 1912 · page 1

Custer battlefield, consisting of travoirs, tranos, lodge poles, etc., together with large quantities of pemican in sacks that were corded up on the levee like

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This retrospective piece recounts how, after the Little Bighorn massacre, Sioux warriors drifted back to their reservations carrying captured guns and horses. It describes General Terry's later roundup of weapons and ponies from the Standing Rock Agency, noting the poor quality of both.

Evening Star · 28 July 1912 · page 36

COMETIMES there is a comic side to ^ war's spoliations. After the massacre of General Custer and his command on the Little Big Horn in 1.S70, the War Depart ment was fully apprised of the fact, before suspected, that most of the hostiles returned to their reservations when they grew hungry or tired of the warpath, bringing with them the guns they had used to shoot down white soldiers or settlers, and riding the ponies that made them the most splendid light cav alry in the world. Later that year it was decided to disarm and dismount the Sioux living at Standing Roek Agency, and Gen eral Terry, with twelve hundred troops, sur rounded the camps anil demanded of the Indians their arms and horses.

See moreSee less

The result set the army laughing for a week. Before the requisition, every able bodied Sioux who had not at least one? often two?Winchester, Henry, or Sharp,

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A Topeka newspaper describes a band concert at Chesney Park featuring a dramatic musical piece called 'The Death of Custer,' depicting the Battle of Little Bighorn with staged effects including war dance, bugle calls, gunfire, and Custer's burial. The performance included theatrical elements like red light fuses for campfires and ended with 'Nearer My God to Thee.'

The Topeka State Journal · 30 July 1912 · page 5

(Advertisement.) joyed by Everyone. n-,v thousand people heard Mar shall's band play what was accepted as one of the most beautiful outdoor concerts ever heard in Topeka, at Ches ney park last night. Nine program se lections and two extras were given the crowd and at a late hour the park emptied slowly with a hope that the band would offer a few additional ex tras. Some of the most difficult music for band playing was rendered in faultless style. Classics were intermingled with light fanciful marches. The "star" performance of the even ing's concert was the descriptive "The Death of Custer" Battle of the Little Big Horn.

See moreSee less

It was an American and Indian fantasy and was literally staged by Marshall's band last evening. The Sioux Indian war dance was as realistic as Buffalo Bill ever attempted. The bugle calls in Custer's camp were given by three players of the band stationed in different parts of the park the band responding. Red light fuses depicted the camp fires throughout the park and among me cruwuav nroach of the cavalry playing national . , t a; with airs ana tne aiiui.iio icBivimu.s . their characteristic music carried the crowd off its. feet. The battle of "lit tle Big Horn" was given coior u, firing of guns in parts of the park. Then followed the music of the Indians rejoicing over their victory with voice accompaniment, the arrival of rein forcements and the burial of Custer. mv. Kurioi n9i eiven beautiful effect

See the clipping