As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

August 1909

18 articles

Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.

A Native American man called Sacred Trail, educated at a Minnesota Indian school, is encamped in Westerly with his wife and baby and plans to lecture under the Red Men lodge's auspices. He is noted as the first to tell the Indian side of the Custer massacre in the eastern U.S., arguing it would be cheaper and more humane to educate Indians than fight them.

Norwich Bulletin · 2 August 1909 · page 6

In Indian costume, Sacred Trail is attracting attention in Westerly. With his wife. Good Eyes, and his baby, Wastewin (Good Girl), he is encamned in his wigwam on the old Oak street baseball grounds. He is planning to give a course of lectures under the auspices of the local lodge of Red Men, and make an exhibit of Indian relics. Sacred Trail was educated in a state Indian school in Minnesota. He Is the first to tell the Indian story of the Custer massacre, in the east, and says that as it cost the government-, 1,000 for every Indian killed, it would be more economical as well as most hu mane to let the Indians live and edu cate them.

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A 1909 retrospective describes General Custer's 1874 expedition into the sacred Black Hills, noting that accompanying scientists officially reported no gold while Custer and prospectors found otherwise. The piece reflects on the treaty violations and sacred significance of the land to the Sioux before gold rush pressures led to U.S. incursion.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 4 August 1909 · page 3

General Custer, with an expedition of 1,200 men and a corps of scientists from Fort Lincoln in the^ summer of 1874, to ascertain I It is an extraordinary fact that the geobgists'and mineralogists wl*o a^ companled the expeditioI*r-iand, they were men of the highest professional standing, occupying chairs in the faculties of universities—made a fin al report to the Secretary of War that they were unable to find any traces of gold or any other valuable minerals in the Black Hills, and that the character of the formation for bade them to expect the presence of minerals.'

See moreSee less

This profound expert opinion may be found as an appen dix to the official report of General Custer to the Secretary of War, and was printed as a congressional doc ument by Secretary Belknap in his annual report for the fiscal year end ing June 30, 1875, where anyone who chooses can find the names of these eminent explorers. GeneralCuster, however, dissented from the judg ment, of Ws scientific corps, and nar rates the experience" of three practi cal miners and experienced prospect tors who accompanied the expedition

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A newspaper lists the program for a band concert, including a piece titled 'The Death of Custer'—a musical portrayal of the Battle of Little Big Horn with a synopsis describing the war dance, attack, battle, and aftermath. This is a commemorative musical composition performed decades after the actual battle, not a news report of the event itself.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 5 August 1909 · page 10

PART TWO. The Merry Selections fr: the operetta Lehar Widow.” (Idyl) fa)—"The Glow Worm.’ Lincke -Humoresque Symphunny No. 2, (b) Dal bey Waltz—“Italian Nights." Tobani "The Death of Custer"—A musical por trayal of the Battle of Little Big Horn. Johnson Synopsis: Indian war dance the night before the battle: bugle (alls in Cus ter’s camp; approach of the cavalry: the attack; the battle (Custer s forces represented by National Anthem, the Indians by native melodies); tho savages’ triumph: the death; arrival of re-inforcements too late; ceremo nies over Custer’s grave; "Nearer My God to Thee.” Finale—“America." Adelbert Wells Sprague. Conductor I

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

A La Crosse newspaper reports that two local men found a grave marker at the Little Bighorn battlefield identifying the burial place of Mark Kellogg, a La Crosse hotel owner turned New York Herald correspondent who died with Custer. The article frames this as finally solving a long-standing mystery about Kellogg's fate since 1876.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 5 August 1909 · page 7

MYSTERY OF 1876 IS SOLVED.

La Crosse, Wis., Aug. 6.—A plain white marker on» the famous battle field of the Little Bighorn, the scene of Custer's last stand, has solved a mystery which has remained unex plained since 1S76—the fate of Mark Kellogg, then one of the leading cltl sens of this section. L. Fred Raston, a Ia Crosse millionaire, and Norric c. Bachellor, formerly an alderman here and now an irrigation promoter in thai vicinity, found the grave. Kellogg, a hotel proprietor in the early days In La Crosse, was one of the western correspondents for the New York Herald and was assigned to go with Custer's expedition.

See moreSee less

Thai he died In the famous Custer battle of the Little Bighorn, Just out side of what Is now the village of Har lln, is proved by records found there by La Crosse men.

See the clipping

The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich.

Dr. Charles Eastman, a full-blooded Sioux physician, told Kalamazoo Normal students that General Custer and his men were not massacred at Little Bighorn but were wiped out in a fair, open battle with the Indians. The claim challenged the popular 'massacre' narrative decades after the event.

The Yale Expositor · 6 August 1909 · page 6

full-blooded Sioux Indian, declared Gen. Custer and his command were not massacred at the Little Big Horn but wired out in an open battle with the Indians.

See the clipping

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

W. M. Camp, an author from the east, is visiting the Crow reservation and Custer battlefield area to gather material for a book about General Custer. The planned work will include a detailed account of Custer's life and his last stand, and Camp plans to visit Billings before heading east.

The Billings Gazette · 6 August 1909 · page 8

Life of Army Man. W. M. Camp, a writer from the east, is spending some time on the Crow reservation and in the vicinity of the Custer battle field. Mr. Camp is gathering data concerning the last stand of Custer and his men which will be used in a book which he is soon to write and which will contain a very complete account of the life of the famous general and his exploits in the west. Mr. Camp has a number of friends in this city and will visit in Billings benfore leaving for the east. He is ac complnanied by a party of North Caro lina and Virginia people.

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A 1909 dispatch claimed a grave marker had solved the long-standing mystery of correspondent Mark Kellogg's fate at Little Bighorn. The Tribune counters that there was never any mystery, as Kellogg's body was found on the battlefield in 1876, unmutilated, and not lying across Custer's body as William Curtis had claimed.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 7 August 1909 · page 4

•3JN1QN! THE FATE OP MARK KELLOGG. The following news dispatch ap pears in the newspapers of the north west, under a LaCrosjse, Wis., date: A plain white marker on the fam ous battlefield of the Little Big Horn the scene of Custer's last stand, has solved a myfstery which has remain ed unexplained since 1876—the fate of Mark Kellogg, then one of the leading citizens of this section. L. Fred Easton, a LaCrosse millionaire, and Norris C. Bachellor, formerly an alderman here and now an irriga tion promoter in that vicinity, found the grave.

See moreSee less

Kellogg, a hotel propri etor In the early days in La Crosse, was one of the western correspon dents for the New York Herald and was assigned to go with Custer's expedition. That he died in the famous Custer battle of the Little Big Horn, just outside of what is now the village of Harlin, is proved by records found there by La Crosse men. The impression conveyed by this despatch is that there has been a mystery regarding the fate of Kel logg, which has just been cleared up. As far as the Tribune is ad vised, there has never been any mys tery with reference to Kellogg's fate. He accompanied the Cu/ster expedi tion to the Little Big Horn as a newspaper correspondent, represent ing the Bismarck Tribune and the Custer's detachment of the Seventh cavalry when it was attacked and wiped out by the Sioux and suffered the same fate as the officers and men of that command. His body was found on the field of battle, but the Indians evidently appreciated the fact that he was a non combatant, for his body was not mutilated. Nor was his body found laying across the body of Gen. Cluster as William E. Curtis says in his correspon dence. His notes were found with his body, which was given burial with the others who fell on that memorable day. The Herald pro vided a substantial sum for his fam ily, and the facts with reference to Kellogg have been frequently set forth in written accounts of the massacre. President Taft has signed the tar iff bill and the work of the extra session of congress has closed. The new bill will be known as the Payne law, just as the previous bill have .been known as the Dingley law and ihe McKinley law, from the name of the chairmen of the house committee where the bill originates. There is puch a multiplicity of schedules and such a number of articles of trade and commenrce to be covered by a tariff bill, that few persons even now have comprehensive Idea of the pro visions of the new bill. President Taft states the bill represents the downward revision idea, and it is a step in the direction desired by a great number of the people of the United States. It is not to be sup posed that a tariff bill of any sort would be satisfactory to all sections of the country. The more the tar iff is argued, the more it is appar ent that it is a local issue. One section of the country desires the re taining of high duties upon products that another section of the country desires low tariffs upon. To har iowaize all of these conflicting inter. este and to get enough votes to pass a tariff bill requires concessions pro •anfi tam, patience, diplomacy and skill. There are disagreements, die appointments and differences with •respect to this or any tariff bill that is passed. It to one thing to in sist that -all schedules be substanti ally ireduoed and all tariffs lowered, and another thing to find a major ity of the senators and representa tives w^ho will support such a bill. The best that can be obtained in any tariff straggle J* a compromise. So ,,- i—.'-•.'.?-. *. '-'y

See the clipping

The Newark Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.

This society column about Asbury Park summer resort life mentions a new baby parade carnival feature depicting Custer's last stand and the massacre of his troops inside the Stadium. The rest of the passage covers hotel guests, charity events, and social gatherings unrelated to Little Bighorn.

The Newark Star and Newark Advertiser · 7 August 1909 · page 13

A brand new feature of the baby pa rade carnival Is being arranged for the night of the masque fete. On this oc casion Custer’s last stand and the mas sacre of his troops will be depicted In side the Stadium. Registered at the Fenimore this week are: Mr. and Mrs. R. E. Storms, of Westwood; Roger Chew, of Bayonne; Mrs. Henry Gledhill and. son, of Nut ley; E. E. Snyder and A. C. Wadleigh, of Arlington; T. A. Creedon and Miss

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A 1909 resort society column describes plans for a masque fete at Asbury Park featuring a reenactment of Custer's last stand inside a large stadium, with National Guardsmen playing soldiers and local young men recruited to play Indians. The piece notes the militiamen must be scripted to lose the staged battle.

Evening Star · 8 August 1909 · page 16

CtlY. of Mr. William L. Gordon, one of the beach commissioners, will be Titanla. Miss Gordon Ik a beautiful young girl, still In her teens, but with a marked dig nity of manner which would stand her in good stead should the?selection have bean made as reported. She Is fair In com plexion. has chestnut hair and brown eyes, is of medium height, plump and pretty and is known as one of the most graceful young belles of the resort. A brand-new feature of the baby parade carnival is being arranged for the night of the masque fete. On this occasion Custer's last stand and the massacre of

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The report describes Chief Red Willow and Chief White Horse, two Sioux delegates from the Pine Ridge mission attending a Catholic Federation convention in Pittsburg. It notes Red Willow's image appears on silver certificates and that he fought in the 'Custer massacre' and other battles.

The San Francisco Call · 9 August 1909 · page 1

Chief Red -Willow* especially draws attention. He Is the, lndian whose pic ture, is engraved on : the- %s i i silver cer tificates now in circulation. He also has quite a record as a warrior, having taken part. in the Custer massacre and many previous fights. . .. White Slave Dealers Jailed VICTORIA, B. ; C., Aug. 8.-— According to advices brought by the ' steamer Monteagle, which arrived from the orient today, the: Yokohama harbor po . lice on the return of the steamer Kaga Maru from Seattle arrested two Japan ese men and two women.

See moreSee less

-The men are accused of being at .' the head of 'in organized bureau'engaged. in the trafflo in women for /immoral -purposes, v The women were .brought ' to Vancouver on the pretext that they, we're'* to be" mar ried to "resident Japanese and "after ward smu ggled ; in to the . Un I ted * States.'

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

At a Catholic Federation convention in Pittsburgh, delegates showed great interest in two Sioux chiefs, Red Willow and White Horse, from the Pine Ridge mission. Red Willow, whose image appears on $5 silver certificates, was noted as a warrior who had taken part in the Custer massacre.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 9 August 1909 · page 1

CATHOLIC FEDERATION INTERESTED IN INDIANS

and Chief Whits Horso, two full-blooded Sioux Indians from Dakota, delegates from tho Pino Rldgo mission of Jesuit mis sionaries. Chief Red Willow especially draws at tention. He Is the Indian whoso pic ture is engraved on the 55 silver certifi cates now In circulation. Ho also has quite a record as a warrior, having taken part In Iho Custer massacre and many previous lights. ,

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A 1909 newspaper report describes Chief Red Willow, a Sioux delegate from Pine Ridge attending a Catholic convention in Pittsburgh, noting he took part in the 'Custer massacre' and other fights. The piece mentions he is also the Indian depicted on five-dollar certificates then in circulation.

The Salt Lake Herald · 9 August 1909 · page 1

tention Hes the Indian whose picture Is engraved on the fivedollar certificates now in circulation lIe also has quite a record as a warrior having taken part in the Custer massacre and many pre vious fights

See the clipping

The Citizen · Honesdale, Pa.

A newspaper miscellany column mentions 'Chief Red Willow,' pictured on a U.S. $5 bill, who reportedly fought in battles following the Custer massacre and is now visiting Pittsburgh. The item is a brief, offhand aside amid unrelated gossip items of the day.

The Citizen · 13 August 1909 · page 4

Chief Red Willow whose picture appears on the face of a U. S. ?5 bill, is at present in Pittsburg, in attendance at tho American Federa tion of Catholic societies. This big chief who helped kill white soldiers in the fights following the Custer

See the clipping

The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho

An old Idaho settler, Tom Russell ("Tinker"), died in Pioche, Nevada, and his obituary recounts his army service with the 14th Infantry under General Crook, including participation in the aftermath of the Little Bighorn battle. It claims he helped bury Custer's men and later fought at Slim Buttes before settling in Idaho.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Caldwell Tribune · 14 August 1909 · page 1

THOMAS RUSSELL DIED IN NEVADA Thomas Russell, better known to the old settlers of this section by the nickname of "Tinker" died at the mining campe of Pioche, Nev., yes terday. His remains will be brought to this city for burial, but the time of its arrival cannot be given at this time, owing to poor railroad connec tions. News of the serious condition of Mr. Russell reached Emmett Satur day, and his son and namesake, Tom Russell, Jr., left at once for Pioche, and he reached his father's bedside before his fathr's death.

See moreSee less

Another son, John, was also there. The rest of his family except Frank, who is employed in a surveyor's camp in Utah, are in Emmett. The deceased was a native of Ire land and was 56 years of age. His parents immigrated to New Jersey when he was a small boy. In 1875 he went to New York and enlisted in Co. B., 14th Infantry of the reg ular army and was sent to Salt Lake the following year to take part in the Indian campaign. One of his comrades was Micky Morton. His regiment was under the command of General Crook and participated in the campaign in which General Cus ter and his command were massacred on the Little Big Horn. Both he and Micky Morton were among the squad that buried Custer and his company after the battle. He also participated in the battle of Slim Buttes, at which time his regiment lived on horseflesh for 40 days. After this war, he returned to Utah and at Beaver he and his pres ent widow were married. In 1880, the Russells and Mortons moved to Idaho, and July 24th of that year made camp in the Payette valley near Seven Mile Slough. They took up claims adjoining each other half a mile southwest of town, and in com pany with a number of other settlers built the Emmett ditch to water their lands. With the exception of the Wardell ditch which provided water for the sawmill, this was the first irrigation project completed in the valley. Mr. Russell was a tinner by trade and while improving his home stead, made tinware and stove pipe for the settlers. Later he opened a shop and up to a few years ago had worked at the business almost con tinuously since coming here. He was a prominent factor in the early his tory of the country, and a very pop ular man. He was big hearted and generous and a man of good impulses, and in spite of his faults of later years, the news of his death will bring sadness to many a heart. ®h* Cdtodl 3frHmtie y

See the clipping

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis. · and 2 other papers

Wisconsin men claim to have found the grave of Mark Kellogg, a La Crosse hotel proprietor turned New York Herald correspondent, on the Little Bighorn battlefield. Records found at the site are said to confirm Kellogg died there in Custer's 1876 last stand.

The Manitowoc Pilot · 19 August 1909 · page 2

HIS WAS CUSTER'S FATE

Bighorn Records. I.A CROSSE, Wis., Aug. 10. A plain white marker on the famous battlefield of the Little Bighorn, the scone of Cus ter's last stand, lias solved a mystery which has remained unexplained since IS7o—the fate of Mark Kellogg, then one of the lending citizens of this sec tion. L. Fred Easton, a La Crosse mil lionaire, and Norris C. Bachellor, former ly an alderman here and now an irriga tion promoter in that vicinity, found the grave. Kellogg, a hotel proprietor in the early days in La Crosse, was one of the west ern correspondents for the New Vork Herald and was assigned to go with Custer’s expedition.

See moreSee less

That he died in the famous Custer bat tle of the Little Bighorn, just outside of what is now the village of Hardin, is proved by records found there by La Crosse men.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis. · 20 August 1909
  • Watertown Leader · Watertown, Wis. · 20 August 1909

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The piece argues West Point's leniency toward undisciplined cadets, as seen in hazing scandals, echoes the case of George Custer, who was nearly expelled but was retained due to wartime officer shortages. It claims his later disobedience of orders directly caused the Little Bighorn massacre.

Arizona Republican · 20 August 1909 · page 2

George A. Custer was the most in tractable of West Point cadets. He had been punished by suspension, threatened with expulsion and would have been expelled but for the urgent need of officers in the Civil war. He served in the latter part of It with great gallantry, fcecame a popu lar idol and secured promotion in spite of his frequent infractions of discipline. But, however great his service, it would have been better for his coun try if he had been expelled from West Point, for there would not have oc curred that awful slaughter on the Little Big Horn, the direct result of Custer's disobedience of orders.

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The report describes Flatiron, a hereditary Sioux chief who fought against Custer, now traveling with a ranch show for his calming influence on other Indians rather than active performance. Three other Indian warriors who had prominent roles in the Custer massacre—Charlie-Owns-the-Dog, Standing Cloud, and Long Bull—are also named as members of the same traveling show.

Rock Island Argus · 21 August 1909 · page 6

I tA V. . linnnnmn1 t Via TnIIantt V.- fore they went into the Custer, fight, lie is still an orator arid every once in a while he holds a powwow. He is too old tf do active work with the show, but is taken along for his good influence among the Indians, seem ing to have the power to quiet them when they become restjess or dissat isfied. Flatlron is a member of the Osalala tribe of the Sioux nation, and is one of the hereditarv rhiefs of that tribe. Three other Indian war riors who had conspicuuous parts in the Custer massacre are members of the J 01 Ranch aggregation. They are charlie-owns-the-Dcg, Standing Cloud and Long Bull. The red men 'will make an encampment of tepees

See the clipping

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

A newspaper in 1909 reprints an old 1875 letter written by a naturalist describing grouse hunting near Camp Baker, Montana, with incidental mention of scout Charley Reynolds, who was later killed at the Little Bighorn alongside Custer's wiped-out command. The piece is framed as a nostalgic look back at old frontier life for Montana readers.

Edgefield Advertiser · 25 August 1909 · page 6

A GROUSE VICTORY.

.years v. r.; chief of scouts at Fort Lin coln, Neb., and who less than a year after the dace of this latter was' killed by Co SiOUZ: ?.ud Cheyennes on the banks of thc'Little Big Horn River when Custer's command was wiped

See the clipping