The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.
An 1903 article corrects an Atlanta editor's claim of a 'sole surviving' human from the Little Bighorn massacre, stating that the only survivor was the horse Comanche, belonging to Capt. Miles Keogh. It quotes a 1878 general order honoring Comanche's heroic survival and mandates his ceremonial treatment by the Seventh Cavalry.
CorrectionThis set right an article from 10 days earlier.
The Savannah Morning News · 2 August 1903 · page 8
Judge. other cities in the future not to be so lavish in expenditures. Now the Grand Army of the Republic meets in San Francisco this month, and here are only two items of expense: Fifteen thousand earthen bean pots have been ordered made for baked beans, and 820.000 are appropriated for the Electri cal Arch and Court of Honor on Mar ket street. This will give some idea of what a big sum of money is needed to carry through one of these reunions in a satisfactory manner. Committees spend at least eight months in the prep aration.
See moreSee less
and the cost of committee rooms, clerk hire, printing and post age is no small item of expense. Louis ville, Ky.. has royally entertained the G. A. R. and the U. C. V., and is now clamoring—yes, clamoring—for the U. C. V. to come there again next year. Mr. W. E. H. Searcy, postoffice box 223, Griffin, Ga., wants the names of the Georgia Cadets, who served in the Con federate Army. But the “headline man”—the awful blunderer—has it headed “Georgia Colonels.” I have a revised “Roster” of the "Georgia Ca dets" from the Georgia Military Insti tute, with a report of their services "from Atlanta to the sea,” in connection with the Confederate and state troops opposing Sherman's advance. This “Roster” and accompanying report came to me from the gallant Maj. Frank W. Capers, now deceased, who commanded these cadets. 1 would cheerfully loan this “Roster” to Mr. S., but I have been so badly treated in the past in such matters that I have been compelled to positively decline to loan any rare document or book. My valued friend, Hon. S. G. McLendon recently wanted to examine one of my ancient volumes of the "Lives of the Signers of the Declaration of Inde pendence,” but when I looked for it I found it and another volume gone. The same is true of some of my valuable documents. As soon as I am able to copy the "Roster” I will have It pub lished. Some newspapers refer to the eccen tric American artist just deceased in England as James McNeill Whistler, and others call him James A. McNiell Whistler, but he was recorded at West Point Military Academy simply as "James A. Whistler,” not James Abbott McNiell Whistler. The family is one of the oldest and most conspicious in our army history, more than a dozen having been officers of soldiery qauli ties. I think the original family name was Whestler, as John Whestler of Maryland was captain in 1797, and Wm. Whistler, of the same state was a lieutenant in 1801, dying in 1863 as col onel of the Fourth U. S. Infantry. He was the father of Artist Whistler. The only member of the family now in the army is Maj. Garland N. Whistler, of the artillery corps at Fort Wadsworth, N. Y. All the -Whistler’s made good soldier’s except Jacob, who was “drop ped” 1816 as a lieutenant of Infantry, later made a "military store keeper,” but “removed” in 1818. The most dis tinguished of the family was Joseph N. G. Whistler, who graduated at West Point in 1846 and was brevetted for gallantry in the Mexican War and Civil War from first lieutenant to brigadier general. Artist "Whistler went to West Point In 1851, but was "found” in chemistry and dismissed. The death of Rev. Dr. Robert C. Foute, of Grace Church, in San Fran cisco, is the occasion of a misleading press telegram from that city. It says: “When young he entered the Confederate army and served in it during the Civil War.” Now, the truth is that he was never in the army, but he did serve in the Confederate navy. I knew Rev Dr. Foute well some twenty years ago when he was rector of Saint Phillips Church in At lanta. He was a native of Tennessee, and a man of large, vigorous frame and with a very loud voice. “When young he entered,” not the army, but the Naval Academy at Annapolis as a midshipman, on Sept. 20. 1858. He re signed, however, and entered the C. S. navy as a Midshipman on June 17, 1861, and later became a master and a lieutenant. He was on the 111-fated Merriptac, or iorn clad Virginia, dur ing her battle with the famous Moni tor. Midshipman H. H. Marmaduke, and Lieut. J. Taylor Wood, whose names are familiar to Savannah vet erans, were with him then under Ad miral Buchanan. Rev. Dr. Foute, was another example that a military educa tion, and war experience do not unfit young men for the highest and holiest of all earthly occupations. The Confederate veterans were high ly honord at the New Orleans reunion by the presence of an unusual num ber of distinguished widows whose hus bands were illustrious soldiers. Mrs. T. J. (“Stonewall”) Jackson and her granddaughter, Mrs. Braxton Bragg, Mrs. Edmund Kirby Smith and daugh ter, Mrs. Ben Hardin Helm and daugh ters were of the number. The vener able Judge John H. Reagan, the sole survivor of the Confederate cabinet officers, was accompanied by his es timable wife. All these noble women, as well as many others equally as worthy, yet not so distinguished by marriage, were paid many honors by the veterans. Miss Lucy Lee Hill of Chicago, daughter of Lieut. Gen. A. P. Hill, was also a conspicuous visitor, being sponsor for a Virginia brigade. The appearance of the venerable widow of Gen. Bragg was quite a surprise to the veterans, as she has lived a very quiet, retired life since the death of her distinguished husband. He was a North Carolinian, but had resided in Mobile and New Orleans. An Atlanta editor is respectfully in formed that there was no “sole-living survivor of the Custer massacre,” al though he states that "the last one has just died.” The only "living" thing that came back to our army from the terrible Custer mhssacre at Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876, was “Old Comanche,” the war horse of Capt. Miles W. Keogh, of the Seventh Covalrv. a brevet lieutenant colonel for gallantry in battle. Bt. Maj. Gen. S. otuifeiS, LOionti of uie beveniu cav alry, in 1878, issued a general order for "Old Comanche's” future good treatment. "His kind treatment and comfort,” the order read, “should be a matter of pride and solicitude on the part of every member of the Seventh Cavalry, to the end that his life may be prolonged to the utmost limit. Wounded and scarred as he is, his very existence speaks in terms more eloquent than words of the desperate struggle against overwhelming num bers, of the hopeless conflict and of the heroic manner In which all went down on that fatal day. * * * He will not be ridden by any person under any circumstances. * * * Hereafter, upon all occasions of ceremonies (of mount ed regimental formations), Comanche, saddled, bridled, dr*aped in mourning, and led by a mounted trooper of Com pany I, will be paraded with the regi ment.” This order is signed by that gallant Georgian, then Adjt. Ernest. A. Garlington, now Col. Garlington, of the inspector general's department. No “sole surviving" human being from that masftacre could have been more highly honored than was this "old Co manche.” The presence In Savannah of Troop C of the famous Seventh Cavalry during the past two weeks will give added Interest to this item. There was another case of an animal pen sioned, but not of the heroic type to which "Old Comanche" belonged. Some years ago there was an aneint army mule at Mount Vernon Barracks, in Alabama, rfamed "Mexique." It was confidently supposed to have been left there by Gen. Andrew Jackson’s army in 1820. When it was condemned to be sold as useless property, Gen. Sher man and Gen. Hancock and other offi cer* protested, and advise that the government take care of it while it other cities in the future not to be so lavish in expenditures. Now the Grand Army of the Republic meets in San Francisco this month, and here are only two items of expense: Fifteen thousand earthen bean pots have been ordered made for baked beans, and 820.000 are appropriated for the Electri cal Arch and Court of Honor on Mar ket street. This will give some idea of what a big sum of money is needed to carry through one of these reunions in a satisfactory manner. Committees spend at least eight months in the prep aration. and the cost of committee rooms, clerk hire, printing and post age is no small item of expense. Louis ville, Ky.. has royally entertained the G. A. R. and the U. C. V., and is now clamoring—yes, clamoring—for the U. C. V. to come there again next year. Mr. W. E. H. Searcy, postoffice box 223, Griffin, Ga., wants the names of the Georgia Cadets, who served in the Con federate Army. But the “headline man”—the awful blunderer—has it headed “Georgia Colonels.” I have a revised “Roster” of the "Georgia Ca dets" from the Georgia Military Insti tute, with a report of their services "from Atlanta to the sea,” in connection with the Confederate and state troops opposing Sherman's advance. This “Roster” and accompanying report came to me from the gallant Maj. Frank W. Capers, now deceased, who commanded these cadets. 1 would cheerfully loan this “Roster” to Mr. S., but I have been so badly treated in the past in such matters that I have been compelled to positively decline to loan any rare document or book. My valued friend, Hon. S. G. McLendon recently wanted to examine one of my ancient volumes of the "Lives of the Signers of the Declaration of Inde pendence,” but when I looked for it I found it and another volume gone. The same is true of some of my valuable documents. As soon as I am able to copy the "Roster” I will have It pub lished. Some newspapers refer to the eccen tric American artist just deceased in England as James McNeill Whistler, and others call him James A. McNiell Whistler, but he was recorded at West Point Military Academy simply as "James A. Whistler,” not James Abbott McNiell Whistler. The family is one of the oldest and most conspicious in our army history, more than a dozen having been officers of soldiery qauli ties. I think the original family name was Whestler, as John Whestler of Maryland was captain in 1797, and Wm. Whistler, of the same state was a lieutenant in 1801, dying in 1863 as col onel of the Fourth U. S. Infantry. He was the father of Artist Whistler. The only member of the family now in the army is Maj. Garland N. Whistler, of the artillery corps at Fort Wadsworth, N. Y. All the -Whistler’s made good soldier’s except Jacob, who was “drop ped” 1816 as a lieutenant of Infantry, later made a "military store keeper,” but “removed” in 1818. The most dis tinguished of the family was Joseph N. G. Whistler, who graduated at West Point in 1846 and was brevetted for gallantry in the Mexican War and Civil War from first lieutenant to brigadier general. Artist "Whistler went to West Point In 1851, but was "found” in chemistry and dismissed. The death of Rev. Dr. Robert C. Foute, of Grace Church, in San Fran cisco, is the occasion of a misleading press telegram from that city. It says: “When young he entered the Confederate army and served in it during the Civil War.” Now, the truth is that he was never in the army, but he did serve in the Confederate navy. I knew Rev Dr. Foute well some twenty years ago when he was rector of Saint Phillips Church in At lanta. He was a native of Tennessee, and a man of large, vigorous frame and with a very loud voice. “When young he entered,” not the army, but the Naval Academy at Annapolis as a midshipman, on Sept. 20. 1858. He re signed, however, and entered the C. S. navy as a Midshipman on June 17, 1861, and later became a master and a lieutenant. He was on the 111-fated Merriptac, or iorn clad Virginia, dur ing her battle with the famous Moni tor. Midshipman H. H. Marmaduke, and Lieut. J. Taylor Wood, whose names are familiar to Savannah vet erans, were with him then under Ad miral Buchanan. Rev. Dr. Foute, was another example that a military educa tion, and war experience do not unfit young men for the highest and holiest of all earthly occupations. The Confederate veterans were high ly honord at the New Orleans reunion by the presence of an unusual num ber of distinguished widows whose hus bands were illustrious soldiers. Mrs. T. J. (“Stonewall”) Jackson and her granddaughter, Mrs. Braxton Bragg, Mrs. Edmund Kirby Smith and daugh ter, Mrs. Ben Hardin Helm and daugh ters were of the number. The vener able Judge John H. Reagan, the sole survivor of the Confederate cabinet officers, was accompanied by his es timable wife. All these noble women, as well as many others equally as worthy, yet not so distinguished by marriage, were paid many honors by the veterans. Miss Lucy Lee Hill of Chicago, daughter of Lieut. Gen. A. P. Hill, was also a conspicuous visitor, being sponsor for a Virginia brigade. The appearance of the venerable widow of Gen. Bragg was quite a surprise to the veterans, as she has lived a very quiet, retired life since the death of her distinguished husband. He was a North Carolinian, but had resided in Mobile and New Orleans. An Atlanta editor is respectfully in formed that there was no “sole-living survivor of the Custer massacre,” al though he states that "the last one has just died.” The only "living" thing that came back to our army from the terrible Custer mhssacre at Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876, was “Old Comanche,” the war horse of Capt. Miles W. Keogh, of the Seventh Covalrv. a brevet lieutenant colonel for gallantry in battle. Bt. Maj. Gen. S. otuifeiS, LOionti of uie beveniu cav alry, in 1878, issued a general order for "Old Comanche's” future good treatment. "His kind treatment and comfort,” the order read, “should be a matter of pride and solicitude on the part of every member of the Seventh Cavalry, to the end that his life may be prolonged to the utmost limit. Wounded and scarred as he is, his very existence speaks in terms more eloquent than words of the desperate struggle against overwhelming num bers, of the hopeless conflict and of the heroic manner In which all went down on that fatal day. * * * He will not be ridden by any person under any circumstances. * * * Hereafter, upon all occasions of ceremonies (of mount ed regimental formations), Comanche, saddled, bridled, dr*aped in mourning, and led by a mounted trooper of Com