As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

August 1903

26 articles

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

An 1903 article corrects an Atlanta editor's claim of a 'sole surviving' human from the Little Bighorn massacre, stating that the only survivor was the horse Comanche, belonging to Capt. Miles Keogh. It quotes a 1878 general order honoring Comanche's heroic survival and mandates his ceremonial treatment by the Seventh Cavalry.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 10 days earlier.

The Savannah Morning News · 2 August 1903 · page 8

Judge. other cities in the future not to be so lavish in expenditures. Now the Grand Army of the Republic meets in San Francisco this month, and here are only two items of expense: Fifteen thousand earthen bean pots have been ordered made for baked beans, and 820.000 are appropriated for the Electri cal Arch and Court of Honor on Mar ket street. This will give some idea of what a big sum of money is needed to carry through one of these reunions in a satisfactory manner. Committees spend at least eight months in the prep aration.

See moreSee less

and the cost of committee rooms, clerk hire, printing and post age is no small item of expense. Louis ville, Ky.. has royally entertained the G. A. R. and the U. C. V., and is now clamoring—yes, clamoring—for the U. C. V. to come there again next year. Mr. W. E. H. Searcy, postoffice box 223, Griffin, Ga., wants the names of the Georgia Cadets, who served in the Con federate Army. But the “headline man”—the awful blunderer—has it headed “Georgia Colonels.” I have a revised “Roster” of the "Georgia Ca dets" from the Georgia Military Insti tute, with a report of their services "from Atlanta to the sea,” in connection with the Confederate and state troops opposing Sherman's advance. This “Roster” and accompanying report came to me from the gallant Maj. Frank W. Capers, now deceased, who commanded these cadets. 1 would cheerfully loan this “Roster” to Mr. S., but I have been so badly treated in the past in such matters that I have been compelled to positively decline to loan any rare document or book. My valued friend, Hon. S. G. McLendon recently wanted to examine one of my ancient volumes of the "Lives of the Signers of the Declaration of Inde pendence,” but when I looked for it I found it and another volume gone. The same is true of some of my valuable documents. As soon as I am able to copy the "Roster” I will have It pub lished. Some newspapers refer to the eccen tric American artist just deceased in England as James McNeill Whistler, and others call him James A. McNiell Whistler, but he was recorded at West Point Military Academy simply as "James A. Whistler,” not James Abbott McNiell Whistler. The family is one of the oldest and most conspicious in our army history, more than a dozen having been officers of soldiery qauli ties. I think the original family name was Whestler, as John Whestler of Maryland was captain in 1797, and Wm. Whistler, of the same state was a lieutenant in 1801, dying in 1863 as col onel of the Fourth U. S. Infantry. He was the father of Artist Whistler. The only member of the family now in the army is Maj. Garland N. Whistler, of the artillery corps at Fort Wadsworth, N. Y. All the -Whistler’s made good soldier’s except Jacob, who was “drop ped” 1816 as a lieutenant of Infantry, later made a "military store keeper,” but “removed” in 1818. The most dis tinguished of the family was Joseph N. G. Whistler, who graduated at West Point in 1846 and was brevetted for gallantry in the Mexican War and Civil War from first lieutenant to brigadier general. Artist "Whistler went to West Point In 1851, but was "found” in chemistry and dismissed. The death of Rev. Dr. Robert C. Foute, of Grace Church, in San Fran cisco, is the occasion of a misleading press telegram from that city. It says: “When young he entered the Confederate army and served in it during the Civil War.” Now, the truth is that he was never in the army, but he did serve in the Confederate navy. I knew Rev Dr. Foute well some twenty years ago when he was rector of Saint Phillips Church in At lanta. He was a native of Tennessee, and a man of large, vigorous frame and with a very loud voice. “When young he entered,” not the army, but the Naval Academy at Annapolis as a midshipman, on Sept. 20. 1858. He re signed, however, and entered the C. S. navy as a Midshipman on June 17, 1861, and later became a master and a lieutenant. He was on the 111-fated Merriptac, or iorn clad Virginia, dur ing her battle with the famous Moni tor. Midshipman H. H. Marmaduke, and Lieut. J. Taylor Wood, whose names are familiar to Savannah vet erans, were with him then under Ad miral Buchanan. Rev. Dr. Foute, was another example that a military educa tion, and war experience do not unfit young men for the highest and holiest of all earthly occupations. The Confederate veterans were high ly honord at the New Orleans reunion by the presence of an unusual num ber of distinguished widows whose hus bands were illustrious soldiers. Mrs. T. J. (“Stonewall”) Jackson and her granddaughter, Mrs. Braxton Bragg, Mrs. Edmund Kirby Smith and daugh ter, Mrs. Ben Hardin Helm and daugh ters were of the number. The vener able Judge John H. Reagan, the sole survivor of the Confederate cabinet officers, was accompanied by his es timable wife. All these noble women, as well as many others equally as worthy, yet not so distinguished by marriage, were paid many honors by the veterans. Miss Lucy Lee Hill of Chicago, daughter of Lieut. Gen. A. P. Hill, was also a conspicuous visitor, being sponsor for a Virginia brigade. The appearance of the venerable widow of Gen. Bragg was quite a surprise to the veterans, as she has lived a very quiet, retired life since the death of her distinguished husband. He was a North Carolinian, but had resided in Mobile and New Orleans. An Atlanta editor is respectfully in formed that there was no “sole-living survivor of the Custer massacre,” al though he states that "the last one has just died.” The only "living" thing that came back to our army from the terrible Custer mhssacre at Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876, was “Old Comanche,” the war horse of Capt. Miles W. Keogh, of the Seventh Covalrv. a brevet lieutenant colonel for gallantry in battle. Bt. Maj. Gen. S. otuifeiS, LOionti of uie beveniu cav alry, in 1878, issued a general order for "Old Comanche's” future good treatment. "His kind treatment and comfort,” the order read, “should be a matter of pride and solicitude on the part of every member of the Seventh Cavalry, to the end that his life may be prolonged to the utmost limit. Wounded and scarred as he is, his very existence speaks in terms more eloquent than words of the desperate struggle against overwhelming num bers, of the hopeless conflict and of the heroic manner In which all went down on that fatal day. * * * He will not be ridden by any person under any circumstances. * * * Hereafter, upon all occasions of ceremonies (of mount ed regimental formations), Comanche, saddled, bridled, dr*aped in mourning, and led by a mounted trooper of Com pany I, will be paraded with the regi ment.” This order is signed by that gallant Georgian, then Adjt. Ernest. A. Garlington, now Col. Garlington, of the inspector general's department. No “sole surviving" human being from that masftacre could have been more highly honored than was this "old Co manche.” The presence In Savannah of Troop C of the famous Seventh Cavalry during the past two weeks will give added Interest to this item. There was another case of an animal pen sioned, but not of the heroic type to which "Old Comanche" belonged. Some years ago there was an aneint army mule at Mount Vernon Barracks, in Alabama, rfamed "Mexique." It was confidently supposed to have been left there by Gen. Andrew Jackson’s army in 1820. When it was condemned to be sold as useless property, Gen. Sher man and Gen. Hancock and other offi cer* protested, and advise that the government take care of it while it other cities in the future not to be so lavish in expenditures. Now the Grand Army of the Republic meets in San Francisco this month, and here are only two items of expense: Fifteen thousand earthen bean pots have been ordered made for baked beans, and 820.000 are appropriated for the Electri cal Arch and Court of Honor on Mar ket street. This will give some idea of what a big sum of money is needed to carry through one of these reunions in a satisfactory manner. Committees spend at least eight months in the prep aration. and the cost of committee rooms, clerk hire, printing and post age is no small item of expense. Louis ville, Ky.. has royally entertained the G. A. R. and the U. C. V., and is now clamoring—yes, clamoring—for the U. C. V. to come there again next year. Mr. W. E. H. Searcy, postoffice box 223, Griffin, Ga., wants the names of the Georgia Cadets, who served in the Con federate Army. But the “headline man”—the awful blunderer—has it headed “Georgia Colonels.” I have a revised “Roster” of the "Georgia Ca dets" from the Georgia Military Insti tute, with a report of their services "from Atlanta to the sea,” in connection with the Confederate and state troops opposing Sherman's advance. This “Roster” and accompanying report came to me from the gallant Maj. Frank W. Capers, now deceased, who commanded these cadets. 1 would cheerfully loan this “Roster” to Mr. S., but I have been so badly treated in the past in such matters that I have been compelled to positively decline to loan any rare document or book. My valued friend, Hon. S. G. McLendon recently wanted to examine one of my ancient volumes of the "Lives of the Signers of the Declaration of Inde pendence,” but when I looked for it I found it and another volume gone. The same is true of some of my valuable documents. As soon as I am able to copy the "Roster” I will have It pub lished. Some newspapers refer to the eccen tric American artist just deceased in England as James McNeill Whistler, and others call him James A. McNiell Whistler, but he was recorded at West Point Military Academy simply as "James A. Whistler,” not James Abbott McNiell Whistler. The family is one of the oldest and most conspicious in our army history, more than a dozen having been officers of soldiery qauli ties. I think the original family name was Whestler, as John Whestler of Maryland was captain in 1797, and Wm. Whistler, of the same state was a lieutenant in 1801, dying in 1863 as col onel of the Fourth U. S. Infantry. He was the father of Artist Whistler. The only member of the family now in the army is Maj. Garland N. Whistler, of the artillery corps at Fort Wadsworth, N. Y. All the -Whistler’s made good soldier’s except Jacob, who was “drop ped” 1816 as a lieutenant of Infantry, later made a "military store keeper,” but “removed” in 1818. The most dis tinguished of the family was Joseph N. G. Whistler, who graduated at West Point in 1846 and was brevetted for gallantry in the Mexican War and Civil War from first lieutenant to brigadier general. Artist "Whistler went to West Point In 1851, but was "found” in chemistry and dismissed. The death of Rev. Dr. Robert C. Foute, of Grace Church, in San Fran cisco, is the occasion of a misleading press telegram from that city. It says: “When young he entered the Confederate army and served in it during the Civil War.” Now, the truth is that he was never in the army, but he did serve in the Confederate navy. I knew Rev Dr. Foute well some twenty years ago when he was rector of Saint Phillips Church in At lanta. He was a native of Tennessee, and a man of large, vigorous frame and with a very loud voice. “When young he entered,” not the army, but the Naval Academy at Annapolis as a midshipman, on Sept. 20. 1858. He re signed, however, and entered the C. S. navy as a Midshipman on June 17, 1861, and later became a master and a lieutenant. He was on the 111-fated Merriptac, or iorn clad Virginia, dur ing her battle with the famous Moni tor. Midshipman H. H. Marmaduke, and Lieut. J. Taylor Wood, whose names are familiar to Savannah vet erans, were with him then under Ad miral Buchanan. Rev. Dr. Foute, was another example that a military educa tion, and war experience do not unfit young men for the highest and holiest of all earthly occupations. The Confederate veterans were high ly honord at the New Orleans reunion by the presence of an unusual num ber of distinguished widows whose hus bands were illustrious soldiers. Mrs. T. J. (“Stonewall”) Jackson and her granddaughter, Mrs. Braxton Bragg, Mrs. Edmund Kirby Smith and daugh ter, Mrs. Ben Hardin Helm and daugh ters were of the number. The vener able Judge John H. Reagan, the sole survivor of the Confederate cabinet officers, was accompanied by his es timable wife. All these noble women, as well as many others equally as worthy, yet not so distinguished by marriage, were paid many honors by the veterans. Miss Lucy Lee Hill of Chicago, daughter of Lieut. Gen. A. P. Hill, was also a conspicuous visitor, being sponsor for a Virginia brigade. The appearance of the venerable widow of Gen. Bragg was quite a surprise to the veterans, as she has lived a very quiet, retired life since the death of her distinguished husband. He was a North Carolinian, but had resided in Mobile and New Orleans. An Atlanta editor is respectfully in formed that there was no “sole-living survivor of the Custer massacre,” al though he states that "the last one has just died.” The only "living" thing that came back to our army from the terrible Custer mhssacre at Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876, was “Old Comanche,” the war horse of Capt. Miles W. Keogh, of the Seventh Covalrv. a brevet lieutenant colonel for gallantry in battle. Bt. Maj. Gen. S. otuifeiS, LOionti of uie beveniu cav alry, in 1878, issued a general order for "Old Comanche's” future good treatment. "His kind treatment and comfort,” the order read, “should be a matter of pride and solicitude on the part of every member of the Seventh Cavalry, to the end that his life may be prolonged to the utmost limit. Wounded and scarred as he is, his very existence speaks in terms more eloquent than words of the desperate struggle against overwhelming num bers, of the hopeless conflict and of the heroic manner In which all went down on that fatal day. * * * He will not be ridden by any person under any circumstances. * * * Hereafter, upon all occasions of ceremonies (of mount ed regimental formations), Comanche, saddled, bridled, dr*aped in mourning, and led by a mounted trooper of Com

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

This passage reports the funeral of Thomas Wood, Sr., a Civil War veteran who later served in the regular army under General Custer. It briefly notes that Custer was killed by Sitting Bull's band of Indians.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 12 days earlier.

Wrong

The Jersey City News · 7 August 1903 · page 1

SERVICES FOR MR. WARD The funeral, of Thomas Wood, Sr., who died at his home No. 66 Mercer street, on Wednesday last, took place this afternoon at two o’clock. He was bprn in Ireland 64 years ago, and was a resident of this city for 48 years. A son and daughter, Thomas N. Wood and Mrs. Louise H. Herke, survive him. Funeral services were held oyer his body last evening. They were (Conducted 1 by the Rev. William H. Ruth, of St. Pauls Methodist Church, and were large ly attended by members of Van Houten and Zabrikie Grand Army Posts.

See moreSee less

Mr. Woods was not only a veteran of the late Civil War, but, serving under General Piiil Sheridan, but also later in the reg ular army under the lamented General Custer, who was killed by Sitting Bull’s band of Indians. -♦

See the clipping

The Camden Chronicle · Camden, Tenn.

A newspaper opinion piece by Dr. Charles A. Eastman argues that Native American perspectives on frontier conflicts have never been fairly told, citing Wounded Knee and the Little Bighorn as examples of biased reporting. It reframes the 'Custer massacre' as actually a brilliant Indian victory against Custer, who had surprised their camp.

The Camden Chronicle · 7 August 1903 · page 2

The Red Man's Point of View, by Dr. Charles A. Eastman

Knee. A ling was formed about the Indian, and after d. a disadvantage la the midst of their women and children. This battle goe down In history us the "Custer massacre." j? j? j& UTa Joy oi Workkg.

See the clipping

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho

A 1903 newspaper recounts a decades-old tale of a ritualized duel to the death between two Sioux men, Crooked Neck and Shaken Head, at the Standing Rock agency, said to have occurred shortly after the Custer massacre. The piece describes tribal tensions during a beef distribution day that escalated into the planned fight witnessed by agency employees.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Weiser Signal · 8 August 1903 · page 2

One Had To Die - Duel to Death Between Two Indians at Standing Rock Agency - Crooked Neck and Shaken Head Ended a Feud - Rifle Against Shotgun

him fast by the horrible fascination of U. Such a duel took place between two Indians at the Standing Rock agency many years ago, and the man who witnessed It has not yet forgotten the smallest detail of that sanguinary fight. It was beef killing day at the agency In the year 1870, but a few weeks after the Custer massacre. Long point, on the eastern bank of the Missouri.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

This 1903 newspaper article recounts military history, briefly noting the Custer massacre of June 1876 on the Little Big Horn before detailing General Miles' subsequent campaign against Sitting Bull's forces in the Yellowstone country. It describes the construction of frontier posts, wagon train attacks by hostile warriors, and a defiant letter from Sitting Bull challenging U.S. troops' right to travel through the region.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 9 August 1903 · page 17

gaged in it." FIGHTING WITH SITTING BULL. The country was shocked by the Custer massacre in June, 1S76, on .Little Big Horn

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The report recounts Sitting Bull's attacks on Col. Otis's wagon train near Spring Creek and Clear Creek in October 1876, including his demand letter to turn back. It continues with Gen. Miles's pursuit and confrontation with Sitting Bull at Cedar Creek, ending in further fighting when no peace terms were accepted.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 9 August 1903 · page 17

Col. Otis sent out a scout named Jack son with a reply stating that he intended to take his train through to Gen. Miles, and that he would give Sitting Bull a fight any time he desired one. The In dians kept up fire at long range while the train proceeded, but after a mile or two Indians approached with a flag of truce. They said they were tired, hungry, tired of war and wanted peace. Sitting Bull wanted to meet Col. Otis outside of the lines of the escort, but Col.

See moreSee less

Otis would not go, and Sitting Bull sent three chiefs to represent him. Ve gave the Indians some bread and bacon. They followed along for a time after Ills wagon train and finally disappeared. Before he reached Tongue river Gen. Miles came up with his entire command. His scouts had brought in word of the atI tack by the Indians and he had come out to the rescue. When he found where Sit ting Bull had gone Gen. Miles started after him and overtook him at Cedar Creek, Mon. Miles had a personal con ference with Sitting Bull, who said he

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

The report notes that Mrs. Elizabeth Custer, widow of General Custer who died at Little Bighorn, is in Washington helping former regiment members secure pensions and government jobs. It remarks she still looks youthful despite being past 60.

The Minneapolis Journal · 11 August 1903 · page 5

Mrs. Elizabeth Custer, widow of the general who fell in the massacre at Little Big Horn, is in Washington trying to assist some mem bers of her husband's old regiment to ob tain -pensions and government employment. She is still young in appearance, altho she must have passed the 60th milestone in lifers journey. ,

See the clipping

The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt. · and 1 other paper

A brief society note lists notable women of the day, including Mrs. Elizabeth Custer, widow of the general who fell at Little Big Horn. It remarks she still looks young despite having passed sixty.

The Barre Daily Times · 13 August 1903 · page 4

DAMES AND DAUGHTERS. Mrs. Brady of Sitka, wife of the gov ernor, Is secretary of the Woman's club of Sitka. Dr. Mary Chandler of Lowell, Mass., is said to be the only woman in Amer ica who is entitled to practice both law and medicine. Mrs. Jeanette F. Goin is one of New lOi'KS richest women, but is never seen in society, for which she ex presses vast contempt. Mrs. Goin owns an immense deal of valuable real estate. Mrs. Elizabeth Custer, widow of the general who fell iu the massacre at Little Big Horn, is still young in ap

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Central Nevadan · Battle Mountain, Nev. · 22 October 1903

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass. · and 1 other paper

This passage reviews military campaigns against Plains Indians from 1874 through 1877, including Miles's expeditions and skirmishes in the Yellowstone country. It briefly references the Custer massacre of June 1876 as context within this broader historical narrative of the Indian Wars.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 14 August 1903 · page 9

men engaged in it.” The country was shocked by the Custer massacre, in June, 1876, on Little Big Horn river. Bands which had broken off from the main body of hostiles and young warriors from the agencies went about

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 9 August 1903

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Mrs. Diplock of Augusta received a letter from her brother George Butterfield Smith, long believed killed with Custer's command at Little Bighorn in 1876. Smith's letter reveals he enlisted in the 7th Cavalry but survived, having gone years without writing home.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 August 1903 · page 3

AS FROM THE DEAD, Wa» Letter Which Mn> peorge Dip lock of Augusta Redbived, ' r - k ■■P Take a letter from the grave was one which Mrs. George -Diplook of North street, this city, received a few days ago. dt was from a brother whom she, ttnd all her relatives, had mourned as dead for more than 30 years. It had been their (Inn conviction that he Weis one of the brave band which died fighting with the gallant < 'uster on the Little Hig Horne, that morning in 1876, when tlie painted red devils, under Sit ting Hull, closed in upon and wiped the entire command from off the earth.

See moreSee less

They knew that the brother was with Custer and from the time that he start ed West, until the other day, when the postman brought a letter no word had been received from him. It was 33 years ago that George But terfield Smith of lleadfield, came to Augusta and started for Boston, bent on enlisting in the regular army. Only once after that did any of his people ffver hear from him until the present summer. That once was •■when a friend told his brother that he had enlisted and gone West to join Custer in the Black Hills. Then came the news of

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A man named George Smith, long thought dead by his family in Maine, writes home after decades of silence, prompted by a postmaster's letter connecting him to relatives in Augusta. In his letter he recounts enlisting in the 7th Cavalry and serving in Montana during Custer's 1876 campaign, noting he was with Gibbon's column near the Little Bighorn at the time of the battle.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 August 1903 · page 3

AS FROM THE DEAD

U. S. Cavalry, under Custer. It was a wild country, you may be sure. Wi reached Fort Benton and from there made a long march to Camp Baker where we joined our company. "Was in the first campaign of '71 with Custer and Stanley, in the Yel lowstone. Again with Custer in '76 On the night of June 23, 1876. Custer

See the clipping

The Chicago Citizen · Chicago, Ill.

A newspaper editor recalls correspondent John Finerty's unusual combat involvement during the 1876 Sioux campaign, including charging with cavalry at the Battle of the Rosebud and surviving a three-day fight with the Sibley scout party. The account notes Finerty narrowly missed being present at Custer's massacre only because Sitting Bull attacked Custer before Crook's forces.

The Chicago Citizen · 15 August 1903 · page 1

.M ISSED CUSTER MASSACRE. “During this campaign he went with the famous Sibley scout party, which during Its absence from the main column encountered a strong party of Sioux under Chief White Antelope, "'•tli whom they had a three days’ tight, and from which he escaped by a most perilous nlght-and-day march. He missed being at the massacre of Custer’s troopers only for the reason that Sitting Bull chose to attack Custer

See the clipping

The Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

This retrospective article details General Nelson Miles's Civil War wounds and his later Indian Wars campaigns, including the pursuit of Sitting Bull after Custer's defeat. It describes a tense parley between Miles and Sitting Bull that ended in battle, with Miles's smaller force driving back the larger Sioux band.

The Morning Astorian · 16 August 1903 · page 4

- Rose From Obscurity Miles had been summoned to the Tel lowstone wrion, there to winter with his own regiment and six companies of the Twenty-second, so as to be ready for the next spring, but, with charac teristic energy, he prepared for Immed hits operations, and accordingly when Sitting Bull worried his supply trains he at once started after htm. Having come up with him, a parley was held between the lines. Therewere to be but six men on each side, but more In dians saunteded up, one by one, and oiw of his scouts afterwards told Miles that an Indian, during the Interview quietly slipped a carbine under Sitting Bull's buffalo rote.

See moreSee less

Miles Insisted that all but six should go back, and, remember ins Canby a fate, he had also taken pre caution to have the whole party under range of his troops on the ridge. He told Sitting Bull his terms, and when he showed how much he knew of the chiefs purposes the latter's eyes "glis tened with the fire of hatued." A sec ond Interview resulted in another re fusal of the chief to yield, and then Miles gave him 15 minutes to geto his lins Sitting Bull, who had perhaps imagined that his overwhelming defeat of Custer's command .and subsequent experience with the larger force con centrated against him, would give him a great prestiage with Miles, started up in fury, and -rave a call to his camp as he rode back. Quickly the grass was fired to impede the troops, but the latter, although numbering only 398 rifles, went forward at the command witto a rush and swept back the Sioux, who were" for more numerous, many miles to the Tellowetone. Six days la ter, about 2000 Indians surrendered, while Sitting Bull and others broke

See the clipping

The Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

The passage recounts Gen. Miles's later campaigns, including driving Sitting Bull across the Canadian border and his subsequent operations against Geronimo's Apache bands in Arizona. It frames these as sequels to the earlier Sioux conflict, crediting him with bringing peace to the Northwest.

The Morning Astorian · 16 August 1903 · page 4

Ellis, lie marched to Clark's Fork Pass, and, waiting till the band came up, at tacked and captured the whole of them, eleven being killed In the fight, while the principal' loss of the troops waa an excellent officer, Capt. Bennett. The next year Miles drove Sitting Bull across the border, and after that peace reigned In the Northwest, and safety was assured for the march of settle ment and civilization. Several years later came the memor able campaign of Gen. Miles against the Apaches for which he was expres sly transferred to the Department of Arizona, having in the meantime re ceived his well-won star of brigadier general.

See moreSee less

He organized with the great est care a system of scouting and of watch stations, drove the hostile Chir icuhua and Warm Spring bands of Geronimo and Natchez across the border Into Mexico, and there a force under the

See the clipping

The Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.

Reporting on a speech by Hamlin Garland, the article recounts his claim that white civilization unfairly judged Indian resistance, with 'outrages' often fabricated and 'massacres' really fair battles. It specifically argues the Custer fight should not be called a massacre since no breach of promise or treachery occurred.

The Daily Pioneer · 17 August 1903 · page 2

THE INDIAN QUESTION.

Custer "massacre" for example. A massacre is always a stain upon the nation by whom it is practiced, as it cannot be affected without a violent breach of confidence, and a direct act of treachery. How, then, an the Indians be said the have mas sacred Custer and his brave fol-

See the clipping

The Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.

The passage recounts Custer's intention to kill and capture his Native American opponents, describing how his plans failed and he and his men were massacred after being outnumbered many times over. It notes the soldiers had pursued the Indians for weeks before the final clash.

The Daily Pioneer · 17 August 1903 · page 2

sacred Custer and his brave follower s? Was there a brea ch of *t]}e promise or an act of treachery weeks they had been liounded by I campingground to anothe r. I Finally Custer caughtjip withJj made a rash bid for fameet audi bered many times over,, yhe' glory by charging down upon spring, 85c No. the horde, well knowing th at his chances for victory were slight. His one intent was to kill andcai).- ture. His plans miscarried: lie and Ins men were killed, massacred, 3944 87 hard A 2 41 34 SM 94 V2(a 1 S red 2 @5.20.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A letter arrives in Augusta, Maine, from George B. Smith, long believed killed with Custer at Little Bighorn 33 years earlier. Smith reveals he survived because his company was detached under General Gibbon and was too far away to join the fatal battle.

The San Francisco Call · 18 August 1903 · page 6

AUGUSTA, Me., Aug. 17.-LIke a voice from the crave came a' letter to day addressed to Mary Georgle Diplock of this city, from a brother whom she and all her relatives had mourned as killed in the' Custer massacre, of the Little Big Horn, 33 years ago. It had been their firm conviction that George B. Smith, Mrs. Dlplock's ' brother, was one of the. .brave little band that Sitting Bull annihilated on that morning. in 1S76They knew he was in the army with Custer and from the date of the massacre until to-day nothing was ever heard from him.

See moreSee less

The letter received to-day was post marked Oakland. Cal.. and showed that the writer. Smith, was the owner of a valuable stock farm fifteen miles out of Oakland. He says that it was by the merest chance that he was not in the Little Big Horn flght. His company had been detailed under Gibbons, who went up the Little Yellowstone, while Custer and his command started for the Rose bud. Gibbons' force was near Custer during the fight, but too far to be of any service. Smith is now 53 years old.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A Maine woman learns that her brother, George B. Smith, long believed killed in the 1876 Custer massacre, is alive and running a stock farm near Oakland, California. He survived because he had been detailed to Gibbon's command and marched up the Little (Yellowstone?) River instead of accompanying Custer to the Rosebud.

New-York Tribune · 18 August 1903 · page 5

LONG LOST BROTHER FOUND. For Years It Was Supposed He Was Killed in the Custer Massacre. [BY TELEGRAPH TO THE TRIBUNE.] Augusta, Me., Aug. 17.—After a lapse of thirty

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

A newspaper reports that an elderly Sioux man named George Brown, living in a small Indian encampment in St. Boniface, is actually Chief Spotted Bull, the last surviving brother of Sitting Bull. The article notes that Spotted Bull, along with his brother and Rain-in-the-Face, took part in the uprising in which General Custer was killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

The Minneapolis Journal · 21 August 1903 · page 2

Special to The Journal Winnipeg, Man , Aug 21 Yesterday was a civic holiday and also a red-letter day for the parks of Winnipeg in the matter of attendance The rain in the morning kept many from going out of the city, who in the afternoon went to the parks which never were fresher or more attractive About 6,000 crossed the pontoon bridge to Elm park A crowd of nearly 2 000 persons took in the Odd Fellows' excursion to Portage la Prai rie, BOO civic employes went out to Little Stony mountain to see the city stone quarry while a similar number went on the Canadian Pacific railway excursion to Winnipeg beach The -many sporting events helped to dram the city, which was practically deserted ex cept around the newspaper offices, where there were large crowds waiting for the bul letins on the cup race Extensive preparations are being made by the Labor Day celebration committee for a monster parade in the morning of Sept 7, and a grand picnic at the park in the afternoon The unions will be out In force with uniforms and floats In St Boniface there is a small Indian encampment upon the banks of the river A casual Inquirer would learn that one of these tents is occupied by George Brown and his family A careful inquiry into the matter would reveal the fact that this old Indian is a chief of the Sioux tribe among whom he is known as "Spotted Bull " He is the only brother now living of the famous Sitting Bull The brothers, together with Rain-in-the Face participated in the Indian uprising in which General Custer of the Seventh United States cavalry met his death

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

This 1903 report describes the closing of Fort Yates near Standing Rock, with troops marching to Fort Lincoln. It notes the fort's historical significance as the site where Sioux surrendered after the Custer campaign and where Sitting Bull was later killed.

The Minneapolis Journal · 22 August 1903 · page 14

Abandonment of Fort Yates. Preparations for the abandonment of Fort Yates near the Standing Rock In dian reservation are In progress, and on the first of September the troops now there will Btart on a practice march over land to Fort Lincoln, near Bismarck, where they will be stationed Auction sales of quartermaster s stores that are not needed at the new fort are being held and next month the fort will be a memory Fort Yates has been prominent among the frontier posts, from its proximity to Standing Rock where the Sioux were taken after their surrender following the Custer Campaign and from Its Intimate historical connection with the Indian up rising of the early nineties when Sitting Bull was killed Captain Rose of Yates will be the new commanding officer at Fort Lincoln, vice Major J S Parke, who has been pro moted New barracks hospital officers' quarters, administration and other build ings at Fort Lincoln will be completed in October

See the clipping

Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J.

Mrs. George Diplock of Augusta, Maine, learns after 33 years that her brother George B. Smith, long believed killed in the Custer massacre, is alive and running a stock farm near Oakland, California. He avoided the battle by being detailed to Gibbon's command instead of riding with Custer's column.

Passaic City Record · 22 August 1903 · page 7

LONG LOST BROTHER FOUND. For Years It Was Supposed He Was Killed in the Custer Massacre. Augusta, Me.—After a lapse of thir ty-three years Mrs. George Diplock. of this city! who has long believed that her brother, George B. Smith, was killed in the Custer massacre in 1S75, has received a letter from him dated

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

George B. Smith has been mourned for thirty years in Augusta, Maine, as a soldier who died with Custer at Little Bighorn. He has written to his sister revealing he is alive and running a stock farm in Oakland, California.

The Indianapolis Journal · 30 August 1903 · page 14

ABOUT PEOPLE AND THINGS.

George B. Smith has been mourned and eulogized on every Memorial day at Au gusta, Me., for about thirty years as one of the gallant soldiers who fell with Custer at Little Big Horn. Mr. Smith has been

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

George B. Smith of Augusta, Maine, had been mourned each Memorial Day for about thirty years as a soldier who died with Custer at Little Bighorn. He has now written to his sister revealing he is alive and running a stock farm in Oakland, California.

Omaha Daily Bee · 30 August 1903 · page 13

QUAINT FEATURES OF LIFE.

It, Is Indefinable. ai'AUT FEATIRKS OF LIFE. George B. Smith has mourned and eulo gised on every Memorial day at Augusta, Me., for about thirty years as one of the gallant soldiers wko fell with Custer st Little Big Horn. Mr. Smith has been alive all the time, however. He writes to l is sister, who is a resident of Augusta, that he Is very much alive and is making money running a stock farm at Oakland, Cal. . Another proof of the statement that one's friends vanish when wealth vanishes Is proved In the case of Francis Marion Wells of San Francisco, a well known sculptor, writer, clubman and social leader.

See moreSee less

Re cently he lost his money, was taken griev ously ill and sought admission to a char lty hospital. None of the people whom, he lavishly entertained In former days and who had then pretended to be friends has come to his assistance or Inquired for him. Dr. J. F. Iamlnj, an enthusiastic ama teur photographer of Cape May, N. J., had an unusual experience. In developing a

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Winnipeg report describes an old, decrepit Indian named Spotted Bull, said to be the brother of Sitting Bull, now camped near St. Boniface. He refuses to discuss the Custer massacre himself, though his wife admits he took part in the battle where Custer was killed.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 9 days earlier.

The Sun · 30 August 1903 · page 26

IAX J I AN elegantly elellnll furnished furih1 apartment to sublet subletIncluHnir sublettnriuItng 111 IncluHnir meals for two w JS 20 private hath telephone telephoneelevator telephoneelevator 1 1 mr elevator transients I rr VAN AN HENSSELAER dLlhit01 JIOTHL lliTtLI rpL 17 I Fast P llth nth at t 1 near 5th lh av avSPOTTED B BITTD asSIOTT1DhJfII SPOTTED SIOTT1DhJfII ITTD nril U FIR ORTH ORTHSltllne ORTIISltnp ORTISitting Sitting Sltnp Hulls nlls Hrother Irolhfr Sppnclo SIle Ills I Lean Leanflnd Ifan IfanRnd lcannail nail Slippered Slppertr Agr r1 In Manitoba tlanllohaWINNIPEG ManitobaVlsipro IanltohaWINNIPEG WINNIPEG Man Ian Aug Au 24Spotted 24SpottedBull 24Hpotld 24HpotldBII Bull BII brother hrothfr to the Ihl fnmotiff famo11 Sitting SIUnK Bull Bullis DII BullIs is now camped on the banks of the Red RedRiver Ree Redhticer River Iher In II St Bon Bonlflce Boniface if nee a suburb Rlburb of Winni WinnipcK WinnlPI Viinnipeg peg PI Ho H in I old and anr decrepit decrfpll and his gen general gln glnIral genoral ¬ oral Iral appearance npptlrnce is that of a cantoff caltot rather ratherthan ralherIhnn rallIerthan than an Indian warrior warriorHe warriorlie arriorI He I in proud of his hi identity Identy but stead oteadfnHtly RIEae steadfnstiy fnHtly refuses rlfuRes to rilscues rifcu A the massacre m acre of ofm ofOn ofen On < m Custer CUlllr In n reply to all al queries Culrlls he homnkefl hemlkeA hemrttkes mnkefl mlkeA the I ht Bame Mml answer nncwerMe nnwerII answerMe

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A correspondent describes passing by rail near Billings, Montana, through the site of Custer's last fight, noting the monument and white headstones marking fallen soldiers. The piece also describes the nearby Crow Indian reservation and Indians gathered at Billings after a circus visit.

New-York Tribune · 31 August 1903 · page 9

WHERE CUSTER DIED. Correspondence of The Manufacturing Jeweller. One historic spot is traversed by the Burlington road, a hundr miles or so thic side of Billings, Mont. It is the scene of Custer's last fight. Here on the crest of a gentle hill, rising above the valley of the Little Big Horn, is a monument to that allant Indian fighter. Near by the hill is thickly otted with the white headstones of those other gallant soldiers who shared with Custer the crown of martyrdom on that fearsome day, when the Sioux warriors reaped their terrible revenge.

See moreSee less

Near . this battlefield are now located the peaceful homes of the Crow Indians. We passed through the res ervation for forty miles, and bad a chance to see the semi-civiliz red man. All of them have comfortable dwellings, usually with a tepee attachment for the summer. Many of them have fine droves of horses and they raise hay for the feeding of these, but do not do much general agriculture. At Billings, on the day that

See the clipping

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

George B. Smith of Augusta, Maine had been mourned for about thirty years as a soldier killed with Custer at Little Bighorn. He has now written to his sister revealing he survived and is running a stock farm in Oakland, California.

The Savannah Morning News · 31 August 1903 · page 4

ternational peace manifestation of the West European Parliaments. —George B. Smith has been mourned and eulogized on every Memorial day at Augusta, Me., for about thirty years as one of the gallant soldiers who fell with Custer at Little Big Horn. Mr. Smith has been alive all the time'

See the clipping