As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

March 1903

16 articles

The Indian Advocate · Sacred Heart, Okla.

A retrospective history of 19th-century Indian conflicts describes Custer being left with only five companies against nearly 3,000 Sioux warriors and being wiped out entirely. It then moves on to summarize later Indian wars including the Modoc and Nez Perce conflicts and the 1877 relocation policy.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Indian Advocate · 1 March 1903 · page 8

72 THE INDIAN IN THE NINETEENTH CENTURY. they met in a long and desperate struggle were Crazy Horse and Spotted Tail, notable warriors both. At the battle of the Big Horn, by some misunderstanding or mismanagement, General Custer was left with only five companies to meet nearly three thousand savage Sioux. He fought desperately until the last, but he was killed and his command was so ut terly destroyed that not a single man was left alive. The at tempt to remove the Modocs from California to Oregon in 1872 was the signal for a new war; and a year or two after wards similar results followed when it was attempted to push the Nez Perces from the homes ihey sought in Oregon to a new reservation in Idaho.

See moreSee less

This tribe, under its famous leader, Chief Joseph, was hard to conquer. The military org anization, the civilized method of warfare, and the courage and skill of the tribe were publicly complimented by Gener als Sherman, 'Howard and Gibbons, who declared Chief Jo seph to be one of the greatest of modern warriors. In 1877, discouraged by the failure of our efforts to hold . the Indians in check, it was determined by Secretary Schurz, then in charge of the Department of the Interior, to remove, them all' to the western part of the Indian Territory, where the tribes in possession agreed to cede the necessary land. It was hoped to create there an Indian commonwealth, but trouble arose" from the attempt to carry out the well-meant ef fort. A single story, the story , of .the Northern Cheyennes, will illustrate the wrong the Indian suffered, as well as those he inflicted. The Chevennes, as has been seen, were a tribe of valiant warriors, some of them at home in the hills of the North, some residing in the hills of the South. The Cheyen nes, Arapatioes, Kiowas and Comanches were banded to gether in a close and common "bond, and, at first the friends of the government, had become frequently its enemies, by reason of broken 'faith, cruel treatment, injustice, and down right wrong. That chronicle of misery, "A Century of Dis honor," contains forty pages of facts taken from the govern ment records, which relate the inexcusable and indefensible

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Max Goetze, a Seventh Cavalry veteran who joined in 1871 and served with Custer in the Black Hills in 1874, has died of pneumonia in Sturgis, South Dakota. He later worked as an ambulance driver at Fort Meade and was buried there with military honors.

Omaha Daily Bee · 3 March 1903 · page 2

DEATH RECORD. Max Goetse. STURGIS, ' S. D., March 2. (Special.) Max Ooetxe, aged about 64 years, is dead of pneumonia. The deceased joined the Seventh cavalry at SU Loals in 1S71 and was in O troop. He wag with Custer, in the Black Hills in 1874. After his dls charge, in the '80s, be took up a ranch a few miles from this city and farmed con tlnuously until a few months ago, when he was given a Job as driver of the am bulance at Fort Meade. He held it faith fully and -well until a few days ago, when he caught a cold and pneumonia followed He was a good musician, having been In the Seventh .cavalry' band and also with local bands.

See moreSee less

Tho funeral was held today and his remains were Interred at Fort Meade with, military honors, he balng a member of the Regular Army and Navy union. Madrlo Rablllard

See the clipping

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont.

A roundup of Montana local news items includes a plan for a steamboat trip to the St. Louis exposition via the Missouri River. The captain proposing the trip is noted to have navigated the Yellowstone and Big Horn rivers shortly after the Custer massacre.

The River Press · 4 March 1903 · page 5

CITY AND STATE.

Big Horn shortly after the Custer massacre with a load of goods, and he believes he will be able to navigate the Missouri with a steamer in 1904.

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

Dr. W. R. Porter, a surgeon with Custer's Seventh Cavalry who was assigned to Reno's command and thus survived the Little Bighorn massacre, has died in India. He later practiced medicine in Bismarck and became a wealthy, respected figure before his unexpected death while traveling.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Minneapolis Journal · 5 March 1903 · page 11

DEATH A GREAT SURPRISE Dr. Porter, Who Died In India, Will Be Burled at Oberlln. BUTTE, MONT.Dr. W. R.. Porter, who died at Agra, India, yesterday, was well known in Montana and the Dakotaa. He was a pioneer of the northwest, hav ing been a surgeon in Custer's famous Seventh cavalry. He narrowly missed the fate of the rest of Custer's command by being assigned to Reno's command when the regiment was divided. He waa a surgeon on the steamer Far West when Reno's wounded soldlders were taken down the Tellowstone river.

See moreSee less

He accompanied them as far as Bismarck. A little later he resigned from the army and practiced his profession at Bis marck, where he was regarded as the most eminent physician in the Dakota.?. He had acquired a large fortune. For twenty years he had been asso ciated with H. F. Douglas and D. R. Mead in the Merchants bank of Glendive. He was fond of travel and died while making ~of lth World. His health, hjj[ second tour while not robust, had beHim-c*otnatireii "tuen* by his friends, and the news Of his death was a great surprise. The body will be embalmed and taken to OberUn, Ohio, to be-interred by the, side of his wife, whoi died, some years age . ."'. J*unwU Want Ada I Jarer..^nrea*t' ibfttw*en/iMmneaioplhv. St, r PautVan'^ 'Chip*,?-- 'C j ' - BUT'

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The article recounts the military career of Dr. Porter, an army surgeon who served with General Crook in the Apache campaigns before being assigned to Camp Hancock under Custer. It notes he was with Reno's command during the June 25, 1876 massacre at Little Big Horn and helped tend the wounded during their evacuation down the Yellowstone aboard the steamer Far West.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 5 March 1903 · page 3

H.tion. That with an opera house massacre of General Custer and his I equipped with modern conveniences. I our pwple would be enabled to secure Porter was as brave as he was a line of attractions that would render |.jn(]]V theater going popular and result tjro command. on an(j sympathetic in nature.

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This 1903 obituary for Dr. Porter recounts his bravery as a surgeon during the Little Bighorn massacre, praised by Colonel Benteen for his tireless care of the wounded. It also details his later life, marriage, business success, and offer to serve in the Spanish-American War.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 5 March 1903 · page 3

PERSONAL

on Marsh's steamer Far West. This ran tjro command. on an(j sympathetic in nature. On the field of battle, in the face of bullets and poisoned arrows that brought many of his comrades to the ground he never flinched, but as a kind samaritan hastily dressed the wounds of those whom he thought could survive and on more than one occasion narorwly escaped ambush and massacre by remaining on the battle ground with the wounded or in endeavors to assist the wounded to keep up with the command so that they might not become the victims of horrible mutilation.

See moreSee less

Colonel Benteen, known as the fighting general, said of him, after the massacre of the Little Big Horn: "I know of no doctor in the regular corps who would have per­ formed tbe work which Dr. Porter did BISMARCK DAILY TRIBUNE: THURSDAY, MARCH 6, 1903 I with his small forcc of assistants don't think there was or is one in the

See the clipping

Albuquerque Daily Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

Captain George Bartlett, a veteran scout, recounts the Wounded Knee massacre to an El Paso newspaper, claiming the Seventh Cavalry's men harbored revenge for Custer's death before opening fire on disarmed Sioux. He also describes personally rescuing a wounded Sioux chief's son from the snow-covered battlefield.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Albuquerque Daily Citizen · 5 March 1903 · page 5

Paso News. He tells an entirely new tale of the Wounded Knee massacre in the Bad Lands of Dakota. It was long after the sad fate of Gen. Custer and a part of

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

A cablegram from Agra, India reports the death of Dr. H. Porter of Bismarck, N.D., who died of heart failure while touring the world. The notice recalls he had been a surgeon with Custer and Reno's command at the Little Bighorn fight, caring for Reno's wounded and bringing them down the Missouri River aboard the steamer Far West.

The Washburn Leader · 7 March 1903 · page 1

Bismarck, N. D., March 5. A cablegram from Agra, India, an nounces the dea th of Dr. H. Porter of this city, who was mak ing a tour of the world. Death resulted from heart tailure. Dr. Porter was one of the best known men in this state. He was a sur geon with Custer and Reno it the Little Horn fight with the Sioux Indians where Custer was killed. He was in charge of the wounded of Reno's command, brought down the Missouri River on the stea

See the clipping

The Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

A 1903 newspaper feature describes the Hole-in-the-Wall hideout used by outlaws like the Belle Fourche bank robbers and 'Laughing Sam' Carey. It notes that Sioux fled there after the Custer massacre, with troops later failing to capture them.

The Courier-Journal · 12 March 1903 · page 3

Long before the Hole became a hid ing place for white desperadoes it was known and used by the Indians A remnant of the Sioux band fled there after the Custer massacre Later an at

See the clipping

Hot Springs Weekly Star · Hot Springs, S.D.

A man identified as having joined the Seventh Cavalry in 1871 and served with Custer in the Black Hills campaign of 1874 died of pneumonia in Sturgis. He later took up ranching after his discharge in the 1880s.

Hot Springs Weekly Star · 13 March 1903 · page 2

He Fought with Custer.

Arrested for Robbery. A Milbauk special says: The two men arrested at Marvin charged with stealing .S08 from the depot at Alke on Jan. 28 were brought: before Justice Pasco on Tuesday. They gave their names as Clias. Edward Long and Thos. Bey nolds. The evidence against them was strong enough to warrant their being bound bound over in $1,000 bonds to the spring term of the circuit court. He Fought v.-ith Custer. (bietzc, aged 54 years, died at a Sturgis Wednesday of pueumonia. De ceased joined the Seventh cavalry at St.

See moreSee less

Louis in 1871. and was in troop. Ho was with Custer in the BJnek Hills in 1874. After his discharge in the 80s iie look up a ranch a few miles front this I city and farmed continuous'.v until few I months ago.

See the clipping

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D.

A newspaper promotes an upcoming carnival spectacle featuring a staged wagon train attack, with nearly 100 Native Americans who reportedly fought at the Custer massacre invited to participate alongside veteran frontiersmen. The piece profiles some of the old plainsmen involved and recounts their personal frontier combat histories.

The Black Hills Union · 20 March 1903 · page 5

DARING ATTACK ON A WAGON TRAIN

has been handed a list of nearly UNION ]00 of these braves—all of whom took part in the Custer massacre. They will all bo here, among them being several noted chiefs. The list can be seen in this office. As to the old plainsmen engaged to ta.ke part in the hold-up of the over land train, will note a few THE UNION

See the clipping

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A bankruptcy hearing in Macon revealed pensioner Z.T. Stanley's claim to be one of only two survivors of the Custer massacre, drawing $72 monthly for wounds. He told an elaborate story of Buffalo Bill reading Indian smoke signals to warn Custer of the impending attack, which Custer allegedly dismissed before Sitting Bull's warriors struck.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Savannah Morning News · 22 March 1903 · page 18

WOULD KILL CREDITORS. Macon Telegraph: “But for going into bankruptcy, I would have had to kill some of my bothersome creditors,” was the remarkable admission Z. T. Stanley, a voluntary bankrupt from Baldwin county, made in Referee Proudfit’s court on the hearing of the proceedings to wind up the bankrupt's estate. Stanley receives $72 a month as a pension for wounds received in the Indian wars out West during Gen. Custer's career. Stanley claims that one time he saved the life of Gen. Cus ter and Capt. Wheaton, the latter now ■being a major general in the Philip pines.

See moreSee less

Stanley told Referee Proudfit an interesting story of how he came to get that $72 a month from the United States government. He claims that he and a man named Humphries were the only two survivors of the Custer mas sacre. He was sick and not with the men when the Indians surprised the American troops. They -were in a rav ine, hemmed in by solid rock sides 200 feet high. He says that Buffalo Bill came to Custer’s camp the day be fore the massacre and warned him of the attack, as he had "read the Indian smoke.” The Indians had a peculiar ■way. of making the smoke from their camp fire drift up Into the heavens in any way they desired. For it to go straight up meant one thing, to go zigzag another, diagonally crosswise another, and so on. In this way they could communicate with each other sixty miles away. Buffalo Bill had learned how to read the Indian smoke signs, and when (he saw the war dance signalled he went In haste to warn Custer. Custer, said Stanley, scouted the idea, and Buffalo Bill left, just posting himself out of harm’s way when Sftting Bull's braves swooped down on Custer's little band, the ter rible massacre following. For his In juries Stanley says the government first gave $8 a month as pension, then it was increased to $24, then to S4B, and now he gets $72. Stanley’s eyes were ablaze with anger when he thought of his importunate creditors.. They so worried and deviled him ‘with their importunities that he had about de cided to do some killing, when the bankrupt law was suggested to him.

See the clipping

The Washburn Times · Washburn, Wis.

An 1903 obituary reports the suicide of George Van Buren, a self-described scout and descendant of President Van Buren, in Montana. It claims he carried orders from General Miles to Custer, arrived the day after the battle, and was the first to send news of the Custer massacre east.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Wrong

The Washburn Times · 26 March 1903 · page 4

FILLS A SUICIDE'S GRAVE.

Butte, Mont., Jan. 22. —George Vac Buren, one of the most noted charac ters of the Northwest, committed sui cide in a cabin in Rattlesnake valley, about ten miles north of Missoula, on Monday, word of his tragic end having been brought to Missoula during the afternoon. Van Buren killed himself after a pro tracted spree, placing the barrel of his rifle against his heart and touching the trigger off with a stove poker. He got out of bed about midnight, and soofi afterward his wife heard a shot and found him lying on the kitchen floor.

See moreSee less

Van Buren was sixty years old and claimed to he a lineal descendant of President Van Buren. He acted as scout under General Howard during the Nez Perce trouble when the battle of Big Hole was fought. He was sent out by Miles with orders for General Custer, reaching the scene of the mas sacre the day following the annihila tion of the band of soldiers. He acted as a newspaper correspondent, and it was he who first sent out the reports of the Custer massacre to the Easteru a *7**r~S. “Strength and vigor come of good food, duly digested. ‘Force’, a ready to serve wheat and barley food, adds no burden, but sustains, nourishes, invigorates.” Remember, a set of the best cook utensils, made of copper, steel and enamel, worth $7.50, given away ab solutely free with every Majest c Range sold this week at B. Ungrodt/£ hardware store, Don’t get left. THE WASHBURN TIMES, THURSDAY, . MARCH 26. and Vandercook is growing so

See the clipping

The Athena Press · Athena, Or.

The article describes decorations featuring views of the Little Big Horn country where Mr. Reynolds served as a government courier with Gen. Terry (referenced as Keoo), alongside a British coronation flag from King Edward VII's ceremony. It notes his Winchester rifle, kept since his service among hostile tribes, is still in his possession.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Athena Press · 27 March 1903 · page 4

. i 1 it. ioua in the traeic Custer massacre Views in the Little Big Horn country where Mr. Reynolds was a government courier with Gen. Keoo, and a British flag used in the celebration of the coro nation of Kimr Edward VII. at which Mr. and Mrs. Reynolds were present, are amoni? interesting decorations. Tne British flag and the Stars and btnpes form a draoerv around the Indian faces in the center of which group is placed a portrait of Mr. Reynolds in all the trap. pings of the mounted courier of the plain.

See moreSee less

The 44-calibre Winchester which was his inseparable companion duriaz the perilous experience in the government service among 'the hostile redskins is still in the possession of Mr Reynolds Multa a lUdl.h. An exchanze zives the following as an evidence of the extreme richness of the soil iiy Oklahoma: in Rutlnr. Okla.. who has fol lowed the "biggest ear of corn" and "hitrcrAHt numkin" controversy in the OD .

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The Waterway Journal published an article on the death of Dr. H. R. Porter, prompted by his old friend Captain Grant Marsh. Marsh had captained the steamboat Far West, which made a famous rapid trip down the Yellowstone and Missouri to Bismarck carrying the wounded from Reno's command after the Custer massacre, with Dr. Porter serving as the government surgeon in charge.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 28 March 1903 · page 3

Yellowstone and Missouri to Bismarck with the wounded of Reno's command after the Custer massacre in 187*1— Or. Porter being the government sur­ geon in charge. Karl Germaine—The magician, at the Atheneum on next Monday after-1 noon and evening the seventh enter­ tainment of the lecture course. Chil­ dren's admission to thp matinee at 4 o'clock. 1(» cents, adults 25 cents, gen­ eral admission to the evening enter-, tainment 50 cents. No children's ad­ mission price for the evening perform­ ance. Course tickets presented at the matinee will be punched and will not he good for the evening performance.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A Loyal Legion banquet in 1903 honored retiring Generals Hughes and MacArthur with speeches praising their careers. One speaker claimed that had General Hughes' advice been heeded, the Custer massacre would never have happened.

The San Francisco Call · 31 March 1903 · page 5

HONORS HEROES

high tributes for valor and patriotism. The speaker also took occasion to dwell on the great soldiers and sailors whose names adorn the pages of the Loyal Le gion. In the course of his lengthy ad cress he stated that had General Hughej' advice been taken the Custer massacre would never have taken place and more Indians would have been killed than evtr before in the history of this country. He dwelt on the general's work in Manila before the uprising of the Insurgents. He said Hughes cleared the streets as ef ficiently as did Napoleon clear the streets of Patfs.

See the clipping