As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

July 1900

9 articles

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis.

A Carlisle Indian school student claims his father, a battle leader, said 5,000 warriors fought Custer, far more than the commonly cited 1,200. The piece also notes thousands of reservation Indians reportedly slipped away at night to join Sitting Bull before returning home.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

River Falls Journal · 5 July 1900 · page 2

Five Thousand Again*! < u*ter. There is a student at the Carlisle In dian school whose father was a leader in the battle of the Little Big Horn, where Gen. Custer and his entire com mand were killed. Some authorities tell us that 277 men fell in that awful massacre and none lived to tell the tale. The opposing Indian force is set down at about 1.200. This student says his father informed him that there were no less than 5.t>00 Indians in the battle. Nine thousand "tame" Indians were settled on surrounding reserva tions, and many of these slipped away in the nighttime to join Sitting Bull for a raid, returning under cover of darkness to their homes.

See moreSee less

Nearly 4.WX) were with him when Custer made his fatal error.- N. Y. Pre-s.

See the clipping

The Wisconsin Weekly Advocate · Milwaukee, Wis.

An ex-Confederate major recalls a night raid on Custer's camp during the Civil War, where he had the unarmed general in his gunsights but chose not to fire. The story is offered decades later as a human-interest aside tied to Custer's later fame and death at Little Bighorn.

The Wisconsin Weekly Advocate · 12 July 1900 · page 8

CUSTER'S CLOSE CALL.

Failed to Fire. Maj. Thomas Lawson, a prominent exConfederate of this city, tells an inter esting story of Gen. George Custer, the dashing Federal commander, who after ward fell in the massacre of the Little Big Horn. Maj. Lawson served with the Virginia troops. He was in Pickens’ i charge at Gettysburg, and although still [ hale and hearty, bears the marks of I three serious wounds. “During the Virginia campaigns,” said Maj. Lawson, “our forces made a night ! attack. Our regiment charged into Cus । ter’s camp and stampeded the Yankees.

See moreSee less

. Chance sent us in the direction of the ; general’s readquarters. In the midst of I the route I saw a handsome man rush ' from a tent a few feet from me. He was i only half dressed, and from his long hair I recognized him, even in the dim light, ।as Custer. He had no arms of any sort, I and the Confederates were in almost ; complete possession, but hastily pulled a bridle over his horse s head, and with out waiting to saddle, up he jumped on the animal and galloped off. without arms, to attempt to rally his routed men. He was within ten feet of me for more than a minute, and I drew my revolver to shoot him, but I could not kill so brave a man when he had no means of defense himself. It would have been too much like murder. “I have always been glad that I did not fire on the gallant Custer that night.” —Louisville Post.

See the clipping

The Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

A Labor Day celebration planned for September in Jeffersonville, sponsored by the Red Men's Boangetaha Club, will include an industrial parade with tribal float displays and a reenactment of the Custer-Sitting Bull fight. The event will also feature fireworks from barges on the river.

The Courier-Journal · 15 July 1900 · page 17

Chinas stinkpots to small cannon The Custer -Sitting Bull fight will be repro duced and there will be a display of fire work a from barges on ths river - —The Hon W H Elchorn of Bluffton who la a member of ths Board of Mana gers of ths Indiana Reformatory waa In the city yesterday Mr Elchorn stated that ths next masting of the board at the Reformatory August 1 would be attend ed by Gov Mount State Auditor Hart and State Treasurer Levy Their pres ence la desired that they may Inspect the Reformatory ' In general but more espe cially the cellhouse now In course of con struction which Is to -be finished by January 1 next It will accommodate 600 men be flve tier high and perfect In sanitation and security Ths cost will bo 8250000 and represents about one-half of tha appropriation for Improvements to be made at the Reformatory

See the clipping

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

An aging frontier scout called 'Perk the Wolfer' recounts his days guarding government wagon trains in the 1860s-70s. He recalls starting out with Custer's expedition in 1876 but turning back before the fateful battle at the Little Bighorn on June 25.

El Paso Daily Herald · 17 July 1900 · page 1

Custer's time, the time when he went under, I mean, and I wasn't there. But I wasn't far away from the Little Big Horn, down further to the south. I started in with Custer too but I went back. We didn't none of us bave no idea it was going to end like that. That is, I didn't. There was 6ome that predicted that the In dians was going to do just what they did do. That summer after tbe cav alry started out I was sort of restl es and kept out with a wagon train.

See moreSee less

On the 25th of June, the year that Col orado came in, I didn't get up into the Black Hills. That was an awful thing, that massacre, but the Indians paid for it. "Well, after that I was up on the Snaoky Platte. Me and one or two otherof the boys was taking a govern BEAM)

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

Captain Charles Varnum, who served as chief of scouts under Custer, disputes a published account by Frank Grouard claiming to have been Custer's scout. Varnum argues Grouard was actually with Crook's command, not Custer's, and confuses him with another scout named Frank Girard.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Laramie Republican · 21 July 1900 · page 2

SCOUT STORIES CAPT. VARNUM RIDDLES A YARN ABOUT GEN. CUSTER'S DEATH

Mr. Elwood Mead, who is in charge of the irrigation investigation now in progress, attaches great importance to the work that may be done by western colleges in imparting a knowledge of irrigation to students. In this he in cludes not merely engineering, but al so the social and industrial features of a complete irrigation system. When the investigation in which he is now engaged begun only two col leges in the United States taught irri gation or irrigation engineering in the class room, and these were in Colo-1 cr Dsuver.

See moreSee less

redo and Utah. Since then there has! been a great awakening and nearly all) i a reporter of the Denver Post, "but when one who happens to person ( ally know glances over the various . ’authentic’ accounts of battles and other bloody’ episodes of army life, he finds it imperative now and then to I stop and smile and wonder at the , credulity of the public in swallowing down whole statements containing so . many conflicting elements that they , fall apart of their own weight.” Captain Varnum had just been glanc ing over an elaborately “featured” and . plentifully’ illustrated page article which recently appeared in the San j Francisco Call. It was entitled: "The L Death of General Custer, Told by’ His j Scout, Frank Grouard.” “It is a pretty title," continued Cap tain Varnum, "and it is a pity to spoil 1 it, but ‘told by his scout’ will have to . be changed to ‘garbled by a scout,’ if the plain truth is wanted." , “So Grouard was not Custer’s scout, j eh?" 5 The captain smiled an old-fashioned . campaign smile —a smile merry in the . main, but with hard corners that crinkled his stiff, weather-beaten > cheeks with a succession of acute 1 angles. “Os course, he wasn’t. I don’t . really believe that be ever saw Custer . in his life, and I positively know that 5 he was never in Custer’s command, r either at the time of the massacre or before that —and do you know why I am so positive? I’ll tell you. I was chief of scouts and I came pretty near knowing every man who served under I me. “Now, there was a scout with us who is often confounded with Frank t Grouard, because his name sounds very _ like his. This was Frank Girard, who L was for years with Custer, and fought p with the command in many an ugly skirmish. I say ‘was’ in referring to t him, but I should say is, for he still j lives—runs a big blacksmith shop at Mandan, South Dakota. t "This man Grouard was with Crook. t If you will notice, he says so in this , article, and yet he talks about taking r news to Custer! That’s where the string of absurdities in this ‘authentic’ j account begins. Now, listen while I ? read what he has to say about the movements of the troops previous to the terrible massacre of June 22, 1876." , The captain read: ’ “Custer, Terry and Gibbon had just separated on the morning of the 22d of Jure, at which time Custer led the a Seventh cavalry up the Rosebud from the lately abandoned camp, while Terry and Gibbon followed up the Yellow? s . stone. "Now. that’s all straight enough, but look at this:

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

Captain Varnum ridicules a published account of Custer's last campaign, pointing out factual errors such as a nonexistent town of Sheridan, a fabricated council of war, a wagon train that wasn't there, and an impossible claim that scout Grouard joined Crook from Custer's command. He cites the Medal of Honor citation of Private James Bell as proof of who actually carried the first news of the massacre to Crook.

The Laramie Republican · 21 July 1900 · page 2

tains on’Little Goose creek.’ * “There wasn’t any town of Sheridan f at all at that time, you know, not the first sign of a town" —then he read on: “ ‘While still at a distance of several miles down the river from the encamp ment of the Indians, Custer cal'ed to gether his officers in a council of war.’ “There was no council of war, but let that pass. “ ‘The result of this council was the breaking up of the command into four sections under the leadership of Custerr Reno, Benteen, and McDougal.

See moreSee less

Custer headed five troops, Reno and Benteen each three troops, and McDougal with one guarded the wagon train.’ ‘There he goes again,” Captain Var num broke off. “Wagon train! We had nothing of the sort along. That was no time or place for a wagon train, “But here’s the most beautiful mir acle in the whole bunch,” the veteran proceeded. “This article states that Grouard, becoming dissatisfied with the plans of Custer, joined Crook near Sheridan, Wyo. I wish somebody would tell me how he could join Crook from Custer’s command. It was simp- ; ly an impossibility. He would have had to go to the Pacific coast and travel by water to San Francisco and then by rail to Cheyenne and up 300 miles 1 overland to the headwaters of Powder ' river, where Crook was encamped. No human being could have crossed tbs ' Big Hom mountains at that time. It

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

A Wisconsin travel party heading to Yellowstone includes Mr. Goldin, said to have served on Custer's staff and been sent back with orders to Reno just before the final fight. The item claims this circumstance made him the only white man to escape alive from the Custer massacre.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Iowa County Democrat · 26 July 1900 · page 3

WISCONSIN PEOPLE. Hilbert N, Haugen, a Connor Hock county man, has I'oon renominated for congress at Hampton, town, Mr. Hau ■ i’ii was elected to that position two years ago, ami was renominated by ao< olanvatiun. Ho was horn ami raised in tiio town of Plymouth ami his brother, K. N Haugen. still resides on the same sort ton of land. Allan H Konulson. formerly of Wau kesha, Is a missionary in i ulna, and his friends are greatly concerned as *o ills safety, Ho worked his way through Carroll college and graduated in 181 H.

See moreSee less

'l'lio next year he returned to (lie college and look a post graduate course After leaving Carroll ho spent a year al the stale university and then went (o Chicago, whore he studied medicine and graduated. I'll on he be came blent Hied with (lie China inland mission, an undenominational organi zation with headquarters at Toronto, and was subsequently sent to China as what is known as a medical mission ary. He is 29 years of age and his parents reside al Chicago. \ .1 anesvllle pari) composed of Mr. and Mrs I-'. \ Capetlo, Mr. and Mrs. I’. \V (loldln, Herbert tloldln. It M. Host wick, Misses Dunwlddle, Racine Host wlck and Mary Host wick will leave August 2d for a trip lo Yellowstone park. After viewing the boautlea of the park the party will on the return spend some days In (lie "bad lands," the scene of so main hard fought bat tles between tile United Stales troops and the Indians and also lie' scene of lint Custer massacre, Thin section of Ihcconnl ry whilcof Interest lo the aver age tourist will lie of special Interest to Mr (loldln on aeeonnl of (he associa tions conneeied with the different bat tlefields. At Hie lime of (lie Custer massacre (loldln was on Custer's staff and just, before going into the light that wiped out the Custer command tloldln was sent hack with orders to Reno lo come on with Ills troops. Hut Icethis elrcumMtaiiee Mr. (loldln would not now be making a visit to the econo of Cinder's last light as he was tho only white man that escaped alive,

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

Captain E.H. Allison, a former scout adopted into the Uncpahpah Sioux, announces plans to tour South Dakota reservations teaching Indians about voting and civic duties. The article notes his background, including his role after the Custer massacre in persuading Sitting Bull to return from Canada.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 27 July 1900 · page 4

TO TEACH INDIANS TO VOTE.

Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn; went to Canada to induce Sit ting Bull and his band, who had fled thither, to return to the United States, and be was in charge of the command which took Sitting Bull to Fort Ran dall. “Few of the Sioux Indians have ever participated in a presidential cam paign,” said Captain Allison the other day. “In fact, but few of them can be said to have a political opinion. It is my purpose to go out on all the reser vations west of the Missouri and hold meetings wherever a dozen or more In dians can be gathered .together.

See moreSee less

This work will take three or four months. I shall give them elementary lessons in civic duties and shall try to show them what it means for them to be cit izens of the United States. I shall ex plain why It is necessary to have elec tions, polling places and laws govern ing such things. I shall have blank ballots and conduct mock elections in order to give these new citizens of ours a concrete idea of election methods.”

See the clipping

The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · Edgerton, Wis.

A group from Racine plans to visit Yellowstone and then the Bad Lands of South Dakota, touring sites of the Custer massacre and other Indian wars. The piece notes that Col. Golden, a member of the party, had served on Custer's staff and was reportedly the only white man from Custer's command to escape alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 27 July 1900 · page 8

Makes the food more delicious and wholesome ROYAL BAKING POWDER CO., NEW YORK. Hanerville. THE Master Kenneth Leikness is suffering with a sore throat. The youngest child of Ed Moore is sick with the measles. FRIDAY, JULY 27, 1900. Mrs Pederson of Stoughton is visiting at the home of C. Olson. Mrs E T Watson returned Thursday from a visit with relatives at Milton. Earl Townsend of Stoughton is help Albion. ing C H Cannon break a western team. Among the number who went on the excursion to Clear Lake lowa were Mr.

See moreSee less

Hermanson, Procter Clough, Robert and James Livick, Mr and Mrs Keegan. Friday evening Arthur Hammond was surprised by about 40 of his friends gathering at his house to help celebrate his birthday. He was presented with a handsome gold watch. Milton. Milton C Whitford left Monday for the west in the interest of the Janesville Barb Wire Cos. Miss Lettie Reynolds and her mother who has been spending a year or more in Rhode Island returned to their home in this village Friday. Over a hundred persons went to Clear Lake, lowa on the excursion from this place and Milton Junction. An evi dence that low rates will catch the pub lic. On Monday evening July 23 Martin E Clarke and Josephine Coon were united in marriage at the residence of Mr and Mrs B H Wells. President W C Whit ford performed the ceremony and about twenty guests were present, only a few intimate friends aside from relatives be ing in attendance. Janesville. The funeral of the late J B Callahan was held from St Patrick’s church at 9:30 o’clock Saturday morning, Rev Dean McGinnity officiating. The services were largely attended and were very im pressive. A large number of railroad men were in attendance to pay their last Albion Prairie. respects to the deceased. The pall bear ers were conductors and members of the OR C of which thedeceased was a member. They were: F'runk Sughrua, John P Sughrua. N Dunwiddie, Fred Fraunfelder, P J Dulin, D S McDermott and C M Joss. The lloral offerings were many and beautiful, those of the organi zation of which he was a member being especially so. Work on the excavation for the foun dation of the new tobacco warehouse to be built by Sylvester A Son on the lot recently bought from Adam Holt, is well under way. The contractors have a number of men and teams at work and rapid progress is being made in getting the ground ready for the foundation, A large quantity of stone is already on the lot and the stone cutters are getting it in shape to commence on the foundation as soon as the hole for the cellar is com peted. F R Moulton, for the past eight years assistant superintendent of the Wiscon sin Division of the Chicago A North western railroad, has resigned. Over work and consequent poor health are the Fulton* chief reasons for this move. Nels Nelson of Milton Junction was brought before Judge Fifield of the mu nicipal court Monday morning and with drew his plea of not guilty and pleaded guilty to the charge of adultery. On the recommendation of the district at torney Judge Fifield sentenced Nelson to a term of one year in the state prison at Waupun. This is the same case that was tried last week in which the jury could not agree. They stood 10 for con viction and two for acquittal. A party consisting of Mr and Mrs F A Capple, Mr and Mrs T W Golden. Her bert Golden, R M Bostwick and the Misses Dunwiddie, Racine, Hattie and May Bostwick, will leave this city Au gust 2 for the Yellowstone National Park. From the park the party will visit the “Bad Lands,” in western South D. and view some of the battle grounds famous as the scences of the Custer massacre and other bloody con flicts between the Indians and the United States troops. At the time of the Custer massacre Col. Golden was on the staff of Gen. Custer and was sent back with orders to Reno and was the only white man of Custer’s command that escaped alive. * . Patents Granted. List of Patents granted to citizens of Wisconsin for the week ending July 17, 9 reported expressl}' for The Reporter Stoughton. through the patent and law office of O. E. Duffy, 707 G. St., N. W. Washington, D. C., from whom copies can be had for twenty-five cents each: Robert G. Lee, Augusts, combined bi cycle prop and rack: Hogo Loewenbach, Milwaukee, tablet and file holder: Chas. McDonner, Milwaukee, saw-set; Henry Swan, Oshkosh, fifth-wheel; Geo. M. Wright, Winneconne, thill coupling; Badger Canning Cos., Oshkosh, “Palette” (for canned tomatoes). One of the department heads at Wash ington recently wrote an article for The Ladies’ Home Journal which required the President’s approval for publication. The president asked that the article be given to him. At the end of a week the manuscript came back edited in a way which completely won editorial admira tion. The President was apparently thoroughly conversant with all the marks which editors use in making cor rections. Every erasure and interlinea tion had its proper sign and each was in the President's own handwriting. —Maple City Self-Washing Soap works perfectly in hard, water. It bleach es white clothes and sets fast colors. Use according to directions on the wrapper. For srle by all grocers.

See the clipping