As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

June 1899

17 articles

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D.

A newspaper exchange item reports that Sitting Bull's grave at the Fort Yates military cemetery is marked only by a broken, relic-hunted headboard reading 'No. 51. Sitting Bull, Indian.' It credits him as the mastermind who planned the 'deathtrap' at the Little Big Horn that destroyed Custer's command.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Black Hills Union · 2 June 1899 · page 8

is a purely philanthropic moVe on the part of Pierre, and', he intimated to the Mail that if Spearfish was real good and lent its assistance in getting the office away from Rapid and located at Whitewood, that at some time in the misty future he might be prevailed upon to jring the old thing over here. He didn't like it a bit because the editor of the Mail refused to sign the petition, and intimated that the editor didn't know a good thing when he saw H. LJierre says that only by his efforts that the office was not removed to Deadwood last fall.

See moreSee less

He speaks in glowing te-ms of Whitewood as the centre of gravity in the Black Hills, and says its has five trains a day to Deadwood. Pierr«i is all right in his way, and so is Whitewood, but is hardly likely that they will cut any more ice in removing the land office than Deadwood did a few months ago, notwithstanding the fact that Pierre says he has the unqualitied support and assistance of live congressmen in this move. Spearfish Mail. Rapid City has long been afflicted with the periodical visits of alleged "specialists" who would remain a few days in the city, exoeriment on a few suffering mortals, charge them a high price for their "ser vices" and pass on to greenei fields and pastures new. Another aggre gation of this character which will be here soon announces that it comes "prepared to treat club feet, hump back, cross-eves, and ingrowing toe nails." It is about time that the people of this community gave these fakirsthego by. Rapid City pos sess as good physicians and sur geons as can be found anywhere and the man or .vorcnn who will turn themselves over to a total stranger, with permission to dope the system and knife the body, deserves to be fleeced financially and every other way. Sands & Astleys circus and train ed animal show enterained a goodly throng of people in this city Wed nesday afternoou and evening. The trapeze work was good and the per forming horses and dogs formed a pleasing feature of the exhibition. The three-shell game was worked to some extent, but the suckers did not seem as thick as in fc rmer years, hence the harvest was limited. This show is a five-car aggregation, but up to the average of that size. An exchang remarks that a brok en wooden headboard and a neglect ed mound of earth in the Fort Yates military cemetery mark the resting place of Sitting Bull, the great Sioux medicine man whose witty brain planned the deathtrap of the Little Big Horn, into which Gen. Custer's command fell. On the broken headboard is written: "No. 51. Sitting Bull, Indian." Relic hunters have cut most of the head board away. John Chitty was a caller at THE UNION office last Monday. He left the Hills something over a year ago to iook for a better place and after and after having looked the ground over iu live different states he finally came back over land and like the country editor, he is "here to stay." He says he is glad to get back and he don't intend to squan der any more time looking for a better place to live. Mrs. J. D. Groff, daughter of Capt. C. V. Gardner, was a Sunday evening arrival from Piedmont and spent the early part of the week with Mrs. Art. W. Gird. She came down for the purpose of consulting Dr. Waldron regarding an abcess which had formed on the neck of her three months old child. The swellng was lanced Monday and the little one has since been doing finely. Mrs. Levi McGee and little daugh ter Gertrude were Sunday evening arrivals home, after having spent the week with Mrs. C. A. Weigand at Whitewood. The Judge had in tended to go up on the Sunday morn ing train and accompany them home, but when he got to a point within a couple of hundred yards of the depot the train pulled out and—well, the judge didn't Sunday at Whitewood. By invitation of Mr. and rs. J. C. Read their son, Burns, was surprised by a number his friends at his home Monday evening. Those going from tpwn were called for at six o'clock and went to the Read home via the hayrack raute. A merrier crowd would be hard to find and a more enjoyable time has not been had this And now its Harry Cromer. He was married at Chicago a few days ago to charming widow of the windy city. She has five children, two of them being twin daughters seventeen year of age. Harry was a calm and docile individual, but when he got ready for the matri monlal yoke it seems he went at it -enthuslaticaUy. Mrs. Mary Gorman, who resided on Elk Creek, died from the effects of a tumor Sunday last. She Game to the Hills in 1876 and was well known at CeatraL Gity and Hill

See the clipping

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D.

The report describes a broken wooden headboard and untended grave mound at Fort Yates military cemetery marking Sitting Bull's resting place, noting relic hunters had cut away most of the headboard. It credits Sitting Bull's "witty brain" with planning the "deathtrap" that destroyed Custer's command at the Little Bighorn.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Black Hills Union · 2 June 1899 · page 9

ft is a purely philanthropic moVe on the part of Pierre, and' he intimated to the Mail that if SpearBsh was real good and lent its assistance in getting the office away from Rapid and located at White wood, that at some time in the misty future he might be prevailed upon to iring the old thing over here. He didn't like it a bit because the editor of the Mail refused to sign the petition and intimated that the editor didn't know a good thing when he saw it.. LJierre says that only by his efforts that the office was not removed to Deadwood last fall.

See moreSee less

Fie speaks in glowing te-ms of White wood as the centre of gravity in the Black Hills, and says its has five trains a day to Deadwood. Pierr.j is all right in his way, and so is Whitewood, but iL is hardly likely that they will cut any more ice in removing the land :e than Deadwood did a few months ago, notwithstanding the that Pierre says he has the nq uul lied support and assistance of live congressmen in this move. Spearfish Mail. Rapid City has long been afflicted wit th the periodical visits of alleged specialists who would remain a fe days in the city, exDeriment on few suffering mortals, charge them a high price for their "ser vices" and pass on to greeuei fields and pastures new. Another aggre ation of this character which will prepared to treat club feet, hump iick, cross-eyes, and ingrowing toe nails." It is about time that the people of this community gave these fakirsthego by. Rapid City pos iss as good physicians and sur geons as can be found anywhere and the man or .vorann who will .n themselves over to a total tul stranger, with permission to dope the system and knife the body, deserves to be fleeced financially and every other way. Sands & Astleys circus and train ed animal show enterained a goodly throng of people in this city Wed nesday afternoon and evening. The trapeze work was good and the per forming horses and dogs formed a pleasing feature o( the exhibition. The three-shell game was worked to some extent, but the suckers did not seem as thick as in ft rmer years, hence the harvest was limited. This show is a five-car aggregation, but ii up to the average of that size. An exchang remarks that a brok en wooden headboard and a neglect ed mound of earth in the Fort Yates military cemetery mark the resting place of Sitting Bull, the great Sioux medicine man yhose witty brain planned the deathtrap of the Little Big Horn, into which Gen. Custer's command fell. On the broken headboard is written: "No. 51. Sitting Bull, Indian." Relic liunters have cut most of the head board away. John Chitty was a caller at THE UNION office last Monday. He left the Hills something over a year ago to look for a better place and after and after having looked the ground over iu live different states he finally came back over land and like the country editor, he is "here to stay." He says he is glad to get back and he don't intend to squan der any more time looking for a better place to live. Mrs. J. D. Groff, daughter of Capt. C. V. Garduer, was a Sunday evening arrival from Piedmont and spent the early part of the week with Mrs. Art. W. Gird. She came down for the purpose of consulting Dr. Waidron regarding an abcess which had formed on the neck of her three months old child. The since been doing finely. Mrs. Levi McGeeand little daugh ter Gertrude were Sunday evening arrivals home, after having spent the week with Mrs. C. A. Weigand at Whitewood. The Judge had intenaJZ eo un on th I theSu°day I*0™"

See the clipping

Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J.

Twenty-three years after the massacre, memorial services were held on the spot where Custer and his men died, attended by both white men and Indians, some of the latter descendants of those who fought in the battle. Participants decorated the graves of both the fallen Indian dead and the cavalry troopers.

Passaic City Record · 3 June 1899 · page 2

floral emblem by the soldiers of the North. The men of the Grand Armv of the Repub lic found and marked with the National colors the graves of other Southern sol diers in Mount Moriah Cemetery. Indiana at Custer’s Troopers’ Graves. Helena, Mont. (Speciul).—Memorial ser vices were held ou the identical spot where General Custer and the men of the Seventh Cavalry were massacred twenty-three years ago, and were largely attended by white men and Indians, many of the latter being descendants of the perpetrators of the butchery. The Indians took a great in terest in the proceedings, decorating the graves not only of their fallen dead, but of the troopers as well.

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

A report from Custer's Battlefield describes sparse Memorial Day flowers due to late-blooming season, and laments ongoing vandalism chipping away at headstones and wooden crosses marking where soldiers fell. The piece insists Custer's men fought heroically to the last in a desperate defense, not a massacre.

The Anaconda Standard · 4 June 1899 · page 2

IT WAS NOT A MASSACRE

Custer's Battlefield, May 31.-It is too bad that Memorial day is not set a month later in this part of the country. Apparently those who are responsible for the naming of May 30 as Memorial day had no thought that Montana and other states in the Northwest would desire to unite with the rest of the country in decorating the graves of the country's heroic dead. Yet while many hundreds of people visited these grounds for the exercises of Memorial day, yet there were scarcely any flow ers left here in honor of the dead.

See moreSee less

A small boy could carry under one arm all the flowers that were placed around the Custer monument. This is not ow ing to any neglect on the part of the people of this section, but merely ow ing to the fact that flowers here are not yet in bloom. Had the day been a month or six weeks later carloads of flowers might have been heaped on the graves of the Custer heroes, as are heaped each year on the graves of those

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

A 1899 Memorial Day report describes vandalism to headstones and crosses at the Custer battlefield, with relic-hunters chipping marble and whittling wooden markers. It notes the field remains largely unaltered since the battle, leaving much to imagination since no soldiers survived and Indian accounts of the fight are contradictory.

The Anaconda Standard · 4 June 1899 · page 2

There was never a battlefield where more is left to the imagination than is the case with the Custer battlefield. The authentic testimony regarding the fight is so slight that one can give free rein to the imagination and picture the fight to suit himself. There were no survivors among the defeated, and the reports of the victors are so contradic tory that little reliance can be placed on them. The white stones which mark where each soldier fell are practically the sole testimony as to the progress of the battle, and with these stones in view one can imagine the details of the battle as best suits himself.

See moreSee less

He is free to mark Custer's course from Reno's camp as he pleases; he can suit himself as to where Custer first saw the Sioux or the Indians first saw the whites; as to where the attack began, and what directions it took up to the tragic finale when Custer and his small band of followers were wiped out at the last stand. As a further aid to the imagination the field has been left as it was on the day of the great battle. There are no fences or stone walls. There is not a tree on the hills or in the hollows. The only additions to the scene are the monument, the marble stones and the house of the cemetery keeper. There are no gardens or flower plants or fountains or trees. Across the river west of the Custer battlefield is a little camp of Chey ennes. One of them, a half-breed, dressed in citizen's clothing, said that he visited the battlefield four days after the fight occurred. He expressed the view that the Indians attacked from the south instead of the west, that the soldiers gradually retreated until at the time of Custer's last stand they were completely surrounded. At the time of his original visit the dead sol diers were being buried. They were first buried just where they lay, but only a little dirt was thrown over the bodies, and soon the wolves and coyotes had unearthed the bodies and further mutilated them. Subseuently the bod les were dug up and all were buried together under the big monument, the white headstones being erected to mark where each soldier had fallen. The body of Custer is buried at West Point. It is more seldom now that one hears the Custer battlefield designated as the Custer massacre. Annihilation is not massacre. As well might one designate Dewey's annihilation of Cervera's fleet as a massacre as to. so style the ex termination of Custer's force by the Sioux. The soldiers were armed and trained for warfare, marching on the Sioux with the intention of defeating and chastising them. Had Custer ex terminated the band of Sioux on this

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A North Carolina man named Bobo, jailed in Puerto Rico for killing a native, has a father killed in the Custer massacre and a father-in-law, Kanipe, described as its sole survivor. This brief mention appears amid unrelated state and local news items.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 4 June 1899 · page 1

the latter. The State charters the Batigron) Tex tile Company, which will build and ope | rate cottonand woollen-miils at the town of Halifax. The capital is 3200,000, and the stockholders are Gustavus and Clarence Millhiser, of Richmond, and Samuel F. ' Patterson, of Baltimore. A North Carolinian named Bobo, from McDowell county, is in jail at San Juan, Porto Rico, charged with killing a native. He has been court-martialled, and E. J. Justice, member of the Legislature from McDowell, went there and defended him. Justice has returned, and says Bobo will be acquitted.

See moreSee less

Bobo's father was killed in the Custer massacre in 1876, and his tather-In-taw 1s the sole survivor of that massacre, His name is Kanipe, Odds are offered that George T. Win ston will be elected president of the Azricultural and Mechanical College here Monday. Director Charles E. Johnson tells mo that all the line of the RichmondRidge way railway in North Carolina 1s ready for the rails, | Ba _ou—

See the clipping

The Semi-Weekly Messenger · Wilmington, N.C.

A report notes that a North Carolinian named Bobo, jailed in Puerto Rico for killing a native, had a father killed at the Custer massacre in 1876, and that his father-in-law, Kanife, is described as the sole survivor of that battle. The item is incidental to a roundup of state news items.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Wrong

The Semi-Weekly Messenger · 6 June 1899 · page 1

Samuel F. Patterson, of Baltimore. A North Carolinian named Bobo, from McDowell county, is in jail at San Juan, Porto Rico, charged with killing a native. He has been court-martialed and E. JJustice, member of the legis lature for McDowell, went there and defended him. Justice has returned and says Bobo will be acquitted. Bobo's father was killed in the Custer mas sacre in 1876 and his father-in-law is the sole survivor of that massacre. His

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A soldier narrates a melodramatic frontier story involving a love triangle between two officers, Reddy Rodd and Meigs, over a woman named Lucy Kleinhart, set during army campaigns following the Custer massacre. The story shifts into a tense night scene where Meigs, on guard duty, investigates suspected whiskey drinking near camp despite the danger of nearby Indian scouts.

The Providence News · 6 June 1899 · page 7

till they was worried and sick, and wouldn't talk more than civil—-them as had been so thick, “Ye mind the year or two after the Custer massacre? Well, we was busy them days; '76 was busy times; but

See the clipping

The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont.

John C. Wagoner, who had carried a bullet in his head since the 1876 Custer massacre and served as chief of Custer's pack train at Little Big Horn, committed suicide in Stillwater, Minnesota. The item appears in a general news summary column decades after the original battle.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Philipsburg Mail · 9 June 1899 · page 2

John C. Wagoner, who has carried a bullet in his head since the Custer massacre in 1876, committed suicide at Stillwater, Minn., last week. lie was chief of General Custer's pack train and was at the massacre of the Little

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A delegation of Arapahoe and Shoshone Indians, including Chief Sharp Nose, met President McKinley to discuss leasing their Wyoming lands. The report notes Sharp Nose fought and was wounded at the Custer fight twenty-three years earlier.

Evening Star · 10 June 1899 · page 1

G. A. R. DELEGATION CALLS A delegation of Arapahoe and Shoshone Indians, who are in the city to arr:inge for leasing their lands it northern Wyoming, called on the President this morning. There are four Arapahoes, Chiefs Sharp Nose, Tallow and Plenty Bears, with Wiliean Shakespeare as interpreter. There are five Shoshones, Dick Washakie, Judge Bishop, Wahwanablddy, Moyavoo and Charles Myers, interpreter. Chief Sharp Nose is the great lighting chief of the Arapaho-s. He was in the Custer massacre. and is the hero of many enicounters with the pale face. He was woindd In the Custer fiyht and was cri:.kIled for life.

See moreSee less

These Indians live in the mountajia re gins of northern Wyomruing, whri they are n sight of perpettal snow on the mountain tolts. The hot weath'r h-re fims not agreed with them it all and they have all I ii ne: ih-y -uffercl. Wahwaint bitlv has c;m:Ilaiv I thte mt:s. Hi. a b.g fat rol rnrinm, w oe- ,h:,r I .-. ti i .it his hnotis yig hu-r i-iall tri-tn e e-jo. I-ie atp.rt-hen 1 -d warnua w. tat h: in the *--ast and I.rru;.t with :in it lug alji&ea -ai, wiel !- simerl tr-mn --m itine.in[1 [,I,,ill ry T oece t nesirly reaches th! g ou. i Even it:s ini g..r nt.-t an ben brde-n to 1 W.tn' biddy. N :i:v h!Ista ig the I, I te n,,her todnh ty , h lsilt :mnn lr. that perr, to tlay lingah:ird u ime wi it him

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

The piece praises Custer's character and recounts stories from Bismarck residents about his departure from Fort Lincoln and the grief that followed news of the battle. It frames the Little Bighorn fight as a noble, tragic last stand annihilated by Native American forces.

The Anaconda Standard · 11 June 1899 · page 3

It is pleasing to learn of the Memo rial day services on the Custer battle field. Montana has in the famou~s hill which is surmounted by the Custer monument a most appropriate spot for an observance of the day. No field has been the theater of a more desper ate fight-no ground was ever drenched with a nobler blood. Never was a gal lant band more completely annihilated -never did the heavens bend over a more awful scene than the6vwhih saw the hordes of redskins massacre and mutilate the flower of the United States army.

See moreSee less

Custer was the ideal soldier. Hle was dashing, brave. fearless, loyal, affee tionate and impulsive. To understand him it is necessary to converse with those who knew him well. Talk with the old-time citizens of Bismarek. N. D.-a town all of whose citizens once had the honor of being placed under arrest by the intrepid cavalry com mander-and you will learn that he was as gallant and amiable in peace as he was valorous and brilliant in war. Listen to stories which 'are told by the Dakotans who saw him start on his ill-fated journey, heard his last farewells, saw Mrs. Custer and the wives of the other officers bid them what proved to be the last farewell, the pride with which Custer gazed upon his noble troops, in whom he had

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

This retrospective piece corrects popular artistic depictions of Custer's Last Stand, arguing it was a direct uphill charge by Indians rather than a chaotic ambush, and that Custer had cut his famous long hair before the campaign. It frames Custer's fatal decision to attack early as driven by wounded pride after being slighted by Grant's administration, casting his death as tragic but fitting for his heroic character.

The Anaconda Standard · 11 June 1899 · page 3

ture. Custer's last charge gives to history a most remarkable evidence of the strength of character in ita rolld-slir ited man. Having been slighted at Washington be'tause of his s\idtencitill the Indian agency scandtls under (irnt's administration and semins other officers pla'ced ill roiintnd of the expedition, he \'went fl'orward to force the recognition to which he was entitled and to command respect front considered. The main point is the stand which Henderson takes on great ques tions, and on those questions, with the possible exception of the issue of ex pansion, he is stubbornly and blackly republican.

See moreSee less

Let us hope that the day will come when geographical arguments will have no weight in this country. We are one people, one nation, one republic. The seven millions of people in the state of New York are patriotically American and share with the 250,000 citizens of Montana that love of' liberty which makes the union great. The resident of Montana who does not respect the honest opinions of the resi dent of New York is not thoroughly Ameican. The resident of New York who sneers at the honest opinions of the Montanan is far from being worthy of a share in the blessings of freedom. So I say, let not the geographical ar gument alone convince the West that General Henderson's Iowa residence will make his election a victory for the West. Look to the issues--not to the man. Let us be Americans-not sec tionalists. There is much sincere regret In New York over the accident which befell Tod Sloane on Derby day in England.

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

Memorial services were held at the site of the Custer massacre twenty-three years after the event, attended by both white settlers and Indians, including descendants of those who fought there. Attendees decorated graves of both the fallen Indian warriors and the Seventh Cavalry troopers.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 14 June 1899 · page 2

Indian' at C?*ter'? Troopers' Grave*. Hele.sa, Mont. (Special).?Memorial services were held ou the identic il spot where General Custer and the men of the Seventh Cavalry were massacred twenty-three years j ago, aad were largely attended by white men aad Indians, many of the latter being descendants of the perpetrators of the

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

A club steward displays a pipe said to have been taken from Sitting Bull by Buffalo Bill after Custer's defeat, with hieroglyphics once translated by Cody. The piece also recounts an anecdote of Sitting Bull being astonished by a trick cigar fan and later hailing the steward as a 'Big God'.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

Weekly Union · 21 June 1899 · page 12

SITTING BULL’S SURPRISE. Thought George Connor Was a God When He Favored the Indian. A most interesting relic of the passing of the Red Men and the winning of the West by the Anglo Saxon race was shown a Union representative a few days ago, by George Connor, the popu lar steward of the Elks club, in this city. It consists of a pipe given Mr. Connor by his friend, Col. William F. Cody, bet ter known as ‘“‘Buffalo Bill,” who took it from the person of Sitting Bull, the notoriously ‘‘bad injun,” away bpack in 1878, after his capture by “Buffalo Bill,” for the ‘‘wiping out’” of General Custer and his men in the Little Big Horn bat tle July 3, 1876.

See moreSee less

The bowl and stem are all one piece of natural wood, both being covered with Indian signs and hieroglyphics in comprehensible to the average white man, but which were read to Mr. Con nor once by Colonel Cody. Soon after its acquisition by Colonel Cody it was exhibited in the windows of Tiffany in New York, attracting the attention of both press and public, both by reason of the skillful workmanship manifest and its historical value. An amusing incident occurred in 1880 when “‘Buffalo Bill’s’”” show was here. He and Sitting Bull visited Mr. Con nor’s place of business and called his attention to a trick fan which by pull ing out the handle once, nothing was shown, but on repeating, a cigar holder was shown containing three cigars. The amazement of the Indian chief was interesting. He tried to take it frdom Mr. Connor but was sternly re buked by “Buffalo Bill."”” Before they left the fan was given to the Indian and his pleasure was unbounded as he im mediately plucked from his hair an eagle’'s feather, giving it in return. Colonel Cody said afterwards that “Sit ting Bull” held a perfect levee among the other Indians in the troup and opened and closed that fan a hundred time or more a day. A few days after Mr. Connor was Cody's guest at L.owell, Mass. As soon as ‘““Bull” saw Connor he immediately ' began dancing, beating his breast vig orously and shouting “Big God!—Big God!” evidently thinking that Mr. Con nor made the fan. | RS R S eL B

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

This report describes the Hole-in-the-Wall outlaw stronghold in Wyoming, used by a notorious gang of train robbers in 1899. It notes in passing that the Sioux once used the same refuge after fleeing following the 'Custer massacre,' decades earlier.

The Anaconda Standard · 28 June 1899 · page 6

Iplace of refuge for two generations. It was here that a portion of the Sioux fled after the Custer massacre, and here bands of robbers from time to time have made their rendezvous, certain of escape from further pursut.

See the clipping

The Daily Chieftain · Vinita, Ind. Okla.

This 1899 article discusses General Nelson Miles' personal memoirs, in which he champions Custer's actions during the campaign against Sitting Bull. Miles argues that Custer's battle strategy was sound and that his defeat resulted from inadequate support rather than poor judgment.

The Daily Chieftain · 28 June 1899 · page 2

TELLS A GRAPHIC STORY. Cuter', Operations Against the Slonx ladoreed by Major General fttllea. In Major General Miles' personal recollections of army life a chapter is devoted to General Custer and the Sioux war, the massacre and the campaign that followed. The points of interest in this history of the last great campaign against the Indians are naturally the operations leading to the death of Custer and the oper ations in Arizona that led to the retiring of General Crook from active command and the transfer of General Miles to that district General Miles writes with great feeling and .

See moreSee less

unhesitatingly cham pions the cause ot General Custer in. the campaign against Sitting BulL He states clearly the conditions that prevailed when . General Custer moved with the Seventh cavalry into the Indian country, when Gen eral Terry, in command of the de-1 partment, General Sheridan in com mand Of the' military district and General Sherman in command of the army, knew not enough of the conditions and circumstances to give definite instructions. General Miles admits that at the time there was a feeling in military circles that Gen our Puritan ancestors fought their wars with the Indians. One of the notions which seems firmly estab lished is that the early settlers gen erally used the bell muzzle blunder buss. Almost every artist who draws a Thanksgiving or Christmas picture of a Puritan going to meet ing gives him a gun with a muzzle like the end of a trumpet. Now, the fact is that the bell mouth firearm was never a military arm among English speaking people at all, nor was such a weapon ever common either in this country or in England until about the middle of the last century, when it came into use for the defense of houses against bum, glare, for stagecoach guards and similar purposes. The blunderbusses which are common enough in the curiosity shops are almost without exception later than 1750, and many of them date only from the early part of this century. A large, bell mouthed gun was in use somewhat earlier on board of naval and other armed ships, but this was a heavy piece mounted on a swivel and used very much as the howitzer was later. Then as to the locks. Even some of our most distinguished writers seem to be completely at sea on this point. One New England writer, whom I will not name for fear of seeming disrespectful to a man de serving of honor, wrote some time ago in a magazine article that some soldier in King Philip's war might have invented the flintlock by find ing that an Indian flint arrowhead would make fire if inserted into the cock of his matchlock. Now, the soldier of 1675 was given a match lock, not because the military au thorities were ignorant of guns which could make their own fire (wheel locks and snaphaunces were in common use), but because the matchlock was considered better for ordinary use. More than this, if he had thought of it, he would have known that his matchlock would not make fire with a flint. The flint lock with which our war of inde pendence was fought requires a powerful blow to make the flint strike fire from the steeL This the matchlock did not have, nor did the pan cover open in such a way as to make this possible. At the time of King Philip's war and for a long time afterward the ordinary firearm for infantry was the matchlock musket. These are plenty in European collections, but very rare in America. I have never seen one m any collection in tnis country. At the same time the snap haunce, a primitive form of the flintlock, was quite extensively used by hunters, and probably by the In dians, who would naturally object N'o. 5, Flyer to the match, which if kept lighted would betray its presence, especial ly at night. Wheel locks were prob ably used to some extent by the earliest settlers, but it was always an exceptional arm and too costly to be generally used. By the time of King Philip s war it was rather old fashioned and not likely to have fig ured much. In Springfield is a fine bronze statue of one of the early

See the clipping

Kansas City Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

A Kansas newspaper's weekly historical retrospective lists events from years past, including noting that 23 years earlier Custer and the Seventh Cavalry were massacred by Sitting Bull in the same week Tilden was nominated for president. The item is one line among many unrelated historical anniversaries compiled for the column.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 9 days earlier.

Wrong

Kansas City Journal · 30 June 1899 · page 4

From the Washington FosU , Missouri has finally found a Jury with enough nerve to send a train robber to prison, but has Its governor enough nerve to keep him there? ago this week George S. Smith, the de faulting treasurer of Leavenworth, was convicted at Atchison. Twenty-four years ago this week McDanlels, the Muncie train robber, escaped from the Lawrence jail and was killed In resisting recapture. Twenty three years ago this week Custer and the Seventh cavalry were massacred by Sitting

See the clipping