As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

February 1897

14 articles

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

This report recalls that General A. J. Smith once commanded the 7th Cavalry before Custer, prompted by news of Smith's stroke. It corrects the popular belief that Custer was a full colonel, clarifying he was actually lieutenant colonel, with Samuel Sturgis holding the colonelcy during the 1876 Little Bighorn massacre.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 2 February 1897 · page 4

Tho announcement from St. Louis that General A. J. Smith had been stricken with paralysis recalls the fact that in 1SC7-S lie was an important factor in the cruel In dian wars which ravaged Western Kansas during those years. At that time he was colonel ot the famous Seventh cavalry, which is known as "Custer's regiment," and was in command of Fort Darker and also for a short time of Fort Hays. It is the common belief that Custer was a full fledged colonel, but this is a mistake. At the time of the Big Horn massacre in 1S7G, when the Seventh regiment was well nlgli annihilated, ho was lieutenant colonel of

See the clipping

The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.

A correspondent, prompted by Custer's 'massacre' death, recalls a Civil War letter exchange about Gen. Kershaw's lost commission and spurs, then launches into a detailed personal account of the April 1865 retreat to Appomattox and the fighting at Sailor's Creek meant to illustrate Custer's character. The piece is framed as a tribute prompted by lingering grief over Custer's death at Little Bighorn.

The Anderson Intelligencer · 3 February 1897 · page 1

possiou of my family for ten years. C. A. W. 1 THE LATE MAJOR GEN CUSTER. Ever since the heartrending intclli1 genoe of thc massacre of the gallant 1 and chivalrous Custer and his brave 1

See the clipping

Audubon County Journal · Exira, Iowa

The article recalls an incident from the 1876 Sioux campaign in which scouts Frank Grouard and Captain Jack Crawford, serving with Reno's and Benteen's commands respectively, raced each other toward Deadwood to be first to telegraph news of Custer's defeat. It frames this as the origin of a journalistic scoop for the Omaha Bee, prompted by a recent meeting between General Miles and editor Edward Rosewater.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.

Wrong

Audubon County Journal · 4 February 1897 · page 2

General Custer commanding. Captain Crawford aoted at time also as a correspondent for 1 Bee, then a small daily, strugglL for existence. During Custer's lat stand Crawford was with Colone. Benteen, who commanded a part of Custer's command at Slim Buttes, and Grouard was with Colonel Re no, who commanded another detach ment of Custer's forces. After the Custer massacre Reno dispatched

See the clipping

Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory

The House committee on pensions voted to report a bill raising Mrs. Margaret Custer Calhoun's monthly pension from $17 to $30. She was the widow of Lieutenant James Calhoun and sister of General Custer, both killed at Little Bighorn, where her husband, three brothers, and a nephew also died.

Idaho County Free Press · 5 February 1897 · page 4

WILL INCREASE A WIDOW'S PENSION

Honse Believes Mrs. Margaret Caster Calhoun Is Entitled to More. Washington, Jan. 27.—The house com mittee on pensions today decided to report a bill Increasing from 317 to 330 a month the pension of Mrs. Margaret Custer Cal houn. the widow of Lieutenant James Calhoun of the Seventh calvary and n sister of General Custer, who was killed ln the Little Big Horn battle. Mrs. Cal houn's husband, three brothers and a nephew were also killed on that occasion.

See the clipping

The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho

A poem by Charles Woodbury, published in a Milwaukee paper on the occasion of Mrs. Custer's visit, romanticizes General Custer's death at Little Bighorn, citing an alleged quote from Sitting Bull that Custer laughed as he died. The verses cast Custer's final stand as a glorious, mythic battle akin to legendary heroic last stands.

The Kootenai Herald · 6 February 1897 · page 6

CUSTER LAUGHED AS HE DIED.

Clmrle* Woodbury's Verses on i he Hero of the I.lttle Mitt Horn. Apropos of the presence in Milwaukee of the willow of General Custer, the Wisconsin prints tlie following from a forthcoming volume en titled "Songs of the New Days." by Charles Woodbury of that city. The volume is to be brought out simultaneously in London and New York:

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

A review of General Nelson Miles' memoirs describes his account of Indian campaigns, including a feeling and discriminating account of the Custer massacre and his visit to the battle site. The review also covers other topics in the book, including the Civil War, travels to California, and irrigation in arid regions.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 8 February 1897 · page 6

TO THE READING WORLD

Prominent as Is the subject of Indian control. General Miles' story is not lim ited to this scheme. He writes graphically of the closing scenes of the civil war. and there is a feeling as well as a discriminat ing account of the Custer massacre, and

See the clipping

Audubon County Journal · Exira, Iowa

General Nelson Miles' personal recollections, excerpted in 1897, champion Custer's conduct in the Sioux campaign, arguing his battle dispositions followed sound military strategy. Miles states Custer failed only because he lacked adequate support, while also detailing the command disputes among Grant, Terry, and Sherman before the campaign began.

Audubon County Journal · 11 February 1897 · page 2

TELLS A GRAPHIC STORY

CnstcrS Operations Against the Sioux In* doned by Major General Bitten. In Major General Miles' personal recollections of army life a chapter is devoted to General Custer and tlie Sioux war, tho massacre and tl:e campaign that followed. The points of interest in this history of the lust great campaign against the Indians are naturally the operations leading to the death of Custer and the oper ations in Arizona that led to the retiring of General Crook from active command and the transfer of General Miles to that distriot. General Miles writes with great feeling and unhesitatingly cham pions the cause of General Custer in the campaign against Sitting Bull.

See moreSee less

He states clearly the conditions that prevailed when General Custer moved with the Seventh cavalry into the Indian country, when Gen eral Terry, in command of the de partment, General Sheridan in com mand of the military district and General Sherman in command of the army, knew not enough of the conditions and circumstances to give definite instructions. General Miles admits that at the time there was feeling in military circles that Gen eral Custer's training in the civil war and his general temper in battle were against him as the commander of an expedition against the hostile Indians, and General Grant insisted that Terry, and not Custer, be placed in command of the expedition. It was admitted, on the other hand, that General Custer had more expe rience in fighting Indians than Gen eral Terry, and that he would be lu command of the active column. General Miles takes the position that General Custer's dispositions for the battle were in direct accord ance with the best military strategy, and that he failed to defeat the In dians simply because he was not ad equately supported by the seven companies of cavalry that were to act in concert with him. He insists that General Custer did not disobey orders, because the last instructions of General Terry were to make his own dispositions and to use his own judgment. General Miles conduct ed the winter campaign immediate ly following the Custer massacre. He was familiar with the Indians who participated in that campaign. He visited the battlefield, traced the line of battle and the development of the fighting, or the progress of the battle, by the position of the dead bodies, and he scouts the idea that General Custer moved up the ravine, a theory that was advanced by some of his critics, but shows that the bodies found in the ravine were those of the 30 or 40 men who had attempted to escape when all their comrades had been slaughter ed. He criticises the actions of Ma jor Reno, and incidoniclly those of Captain Benteen. He tells, in a graphic story of what must have been one of the most dramatic bat tles of history and his discussion is from first to last a defense of the dead Custer and severe condemna tion of Major Reno.

See the clipping

The Hocking Sentinel · Logan, Ohio

This passage reviews a book by Gen. Nelson Miles recounting his military career, including Indian campaigns from Yellowstone to Texas and the Civil War. It specifically mentions a discriminating account of the Custer massacre and a visit to the battlefield site.

The Hocking Sentinel · 11 February 1897 · page 4

covered by millitary operations ex tended from the region of the Yellow stone to Texas, and the scenes enact ed on tho huge battle field are de scribed with a grim fidelity to fact. The hazardous exploits perJormed, the intense suffenngs from cold and hunger, and the heroic. conduct of the troops throughout a waifare in which the Indian's implacable hatered and insariauie thirst tor vengeance were constantly displayed, are narrated at length and inspire the reader with alternate admiration and horror. Gen. Miles' story is by no means limited to this theme.

See moreSee less

He writes graphically of the closing scenes of the Civil War, and that la-t, awful campaign. There is a feeling, as well as a dis eliminating account of the Custer massacre, and a pathetic visit to the scone of that deplorable calamity. In another poition of the work the

See the clipping

The Hocking Sentinel · Logan, Ohio

A newspaper book review discusses General Nelson Miles' published recollections, noting a chapter giving a feeling and discriminating account of the Custer massacre, with a visit to the battle scene. The review praises the book's style and scope, covering the Civil War, Indian wars, and other topics.

The Hocking Sentinel · 18 February 1897 · page 4

campaign. There is a feeling, as well as a dis criminating account of the Custer massacre, and a pathetic visit to the scene of that deploiablo calamity. In another i)oi tiou of the woik the

See the clipping

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · Mt. Sterling, Ky.

This 1897 report discusses General Nelson Miles's personal recollections, which include a chapter defending General Custer's conduct in the campaign against Sitting Bull. Miles argues Custer's battle dispositions followed sound military strategy and that defeat resulted from inadequate support by other companies, not Custer's error.

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · 23 February 1897 · page 3

TELLS A GRAPHIC STORY CtiAtera Operations Against the Sioax In dorsed by Major General JUlen In Major Goneral Miles personal recollections of army life a chapter 1b devoted to General Custer and tho Sioux war the massacre and the campaign that followed Tho points of interest in this history of the last great campaign against the Indians aro naturally tho operations leading to tho death of Custer and the oper ations in Arizona that led to the retiring of General Crook from active command and tho transfer of General Miles to that distriot General Miles writes with great feeling and unhesitatingly cham pions tho cause of General Custer in tho campaign against Sitting Bull He states clearly tho conditions that prevailed when General Custer

See the clipping

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · Mt. Sterling, Ky.

Years after the battle, General Nelson Miles is reported defending Custer's military decisions, arguing he was let down by inadequate support from Reno and Benteen rather than having disobeyed orders. The account also describes Miles's visit to the battlefield and his dismissal of theories about Custer's movements during the fight.

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · 23 February 1897 · page 3

TELLS A GRAPHIC STORY

Genoral Miles takes tho position thdt Genoral Custers dispositions for tho battle wero in direct accord ance with tho best military strategy and that ho failed to defeat tho In dians simply because ho was not ad equately supported by the seven companies of oavqlry that weroto act in concerfrwith him He insists that Gonejral Custer did not disobey orders because the last instructions or uenerai Terry wero to inane ins own dispositions and to use his own judgment General Miles conduct ed the winter campaign immediate ly following the Custer massacre Ho was familiar with tho Indians who participated in that campaign Ho visited tho battlefield traced the line of battle and the development of tho fighting or he progressof the battle by the pdBitidn ofi tlie dead bodies and he scouts tho idea that General Cu8termovod up the ravine a theory that was1 advanced by somo of his critics Bui shows that the bodies found in tho ravine were those pf the 30 or 40 monwho had attempted to escnpe Ylion all their comrades had been slaughter ed Heeriticisos the actions oft Ma jor Rend and inolOeAftiHy tlioeo of Captain1 Benteori Ho tolls in snort agraphicstory of wfiakmitst havebeen one of thff mpst dramatrcrbatp

See the clipping

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · Mt. Sterling, Ky.

The article recalls how scouts-turned-correspondents Frank Grouard and Captain Jack Crawford each raced toward Deadwood after the Little Bighorn fight to be first to telegraph news of the disaster, Grouard for the War Department and Crawford for the Omaha Bee. It describes their perilous ride together through hostile territory, each secretly trying to beat the other to the telegraph.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 19 days earlier.

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · 23 February 1897 · page 6

A WESTERN SCOOP

General Custer commanding Captain Crawford acted at this time also as a correspondent for The Beo then a small daily struggling for existence During Custers last stand Crawford was with Colonel Bon teen who commanded a part of Custers command at Slim Buttes and Grouard was with Colonel Re no who commanded another detach ment of Custers forces After tho Custer massacre Reno dispatched

See the clipping

The Hocking Sentinel · Logan, Ohio

This is a review of General Nelson Miles' memoir, praising his accounts of Civil War service, Indian campaigns, and western travels. It specifically mentions his discriminating account of the Custer massacre and a visit to the battlefield, recommending the book to readers.

The Hocking Sentinel · 25 February 1897 · page 4

There is a feeling, as well as a dis criminating account of the Custer massacre, and a pathetic visit to the scene of that deplorable calamity. In another portion of the work the

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A survivor recounts the desperate fighting after Custer's battalion was wiped out, describing how Reno and Benteen's combined force held out against overwhelming Indian numbers for two days. The account credits Benteen's leadership, including a reveille bugle call meant to bluff the surrounding warriors.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 27 February 1897 · page 10

STORY OF CUSTER MASSACRE. Col Benteen's Important Aid and How it Was Secured A Charge That Turned the Tide. Th number of Indians engaged in the Little Big Horn battle has been estimated at from 8500 to C000, and we went into the fight less than 600 men In all, and as Custer had nearly half of this number in his battalion, all of whom had been killed, consequently we, about 330 men strong were battling with the entire force of Indians. Against such odds resistance seemed almost hopeless. It must have been In the neighborhood of noon when we took up this position, and until after nightfall the fight raged furiously, with a constant crash of carbines and mus ketry on both sides.

See moreSee less

Reno had lost considerably while in the bottom, but our casualties increased greatly during the afternoon and evening. The next morning before dawn, at Col Benteen's suggestion we had a reveille sounded. This was done to put on a bold front and impress our enemy with the fact that we were ready to resume the con test. We knew there was no alterna tive but to resume it, so we tried to "make a virtue of necessity." The lost notes of the reveille had not died away before volleys from the In dian muskets, from all directions, crashed through the morning air, as if in answer to our chalenge. The fight all that day was incessant, vicious and at very close quarters. We were losing men rapidly, in killed and wounded. The Indians saw this, and grew bolder from time to time, until they got with in 25 feet of the right of my line. I had held this hill in obedience to Col Benteen's orders until my troop was so reduced in numbers as to make my evacuation of It almost necessary. My men who were still able to fight fully realized their peril and remained there only baeause they, too, knew if that posttion was surrendered it would be a sorry day for us. I was in sore need of both men and ammunition, but to send a man to the command was almost sure death. We were not in communi cation -with the rest of the command, and had no idea how it was faring. Finally our situation became desper ate; something had to be done at once If we hoped to live many minutes long er. Just as I had decided to send a messenger 'to Col Benteen, , Private McDermott spoke to me, and asked if I would like him to carry a message to the cqlonel. I hastily pointed the da'nger of his going, but he agul.i expressed his willingness to go. So he carried my message to Col Benteen that I must have men and ammunition at once. McDermott miraculously got there and back without a scratch. He said the colonel would be there im mediately with reinforcements. He did not arrive at once, and McDermott asked me if he should go back. I re plied, "No;" that if Col Benteen said he would come, he certainly would. Sure enough, he soon arrived ' with about ten to twelve men. Considering the smallne'ss' of the command and the losses it had sustained, twelve was quite a large number. Benteen took in the situation at once, and said we must charge them. This we did, and it resulted not only disas trously to them, but surprised them, so that they gave us a wide berth after it. Subsequently Con Benteen convinced Maj. Reno that ours was the position to defend, we got more troops up there, and some spades and picks, and soon threw up very respectable earth works. This strengthened our position immensely, and, after fighting us until dark, the Indians with all their be longings withdrew and left us in pos sesssion of the field. This they did for two reasons; they had had pretty hard fighting had lost heavily, and their runners had dis covered Gen Terry's command ap proaching in the distance. About 8 o'clock on the morning of the 27th, Terry's command was in sight, and from it we heard of the fate of Custar and his men. They, it turned out, had perished in. less than half an hour after they became engaged, and the 'dead bodies of our comrades were lyingabout two miles from us. Thus the battle of the Little Big Horn ended. It carried many of our comrades whom we loved with almost a brother's affection, to the, "happy hunting ground," and may their souls be at rest. Col Reno Is now dead, but I do not think I do any violence to his memory by stating most emphatically that had if not been for Benteen's perfect coolness and surpass ing judgment, we all would have ended our careers there. New York Evening Post.

See the clipping