As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

August 1896

15 articles

The Madisonian · Virginia City, Mont.

Private Theodore W. Goldin of the Seventh Cavalry received a Congressional Medal of Honor for volunteering to fetch water for wounded soldiers during the siege of Reno's command at Little Bighorn in 1876. The article notes three other soldiers involved in the same act had been decorated long before him.

The Madisonian · 8 August 1896 · page 4

BRAVE MAN, BRAVE DEED.

"The Congress to Private Theodore W. Goldiu of Troop G, Seventh United States Cavalry, For Most Distinguished Gallantry at the Little Big Horn River, Montana, July 26, 1876." General J.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A reader's column answering miscellaneous questions states that biographies of General Custer, killed at Little Bighorn, do not claim he was married at the time of his death. This is presented as a simple factual answer among many unrelated trivia responses.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The San Francisco Call · 12 August 1896 · page 6

ANSWERS TO CORRESPONDENTS. Metropolitan Temple— J. McN., City. The seating capacity of the Metropolitan Temple is 124,5. 9 Patience— E. L. C, City. The contralto part in the opera of "Patience" Is assigned to the character of Lady Jane. Dramatic School— M. E. Ji., San Jose, Cal. For information about the dramatic school of this City you should address Leo Cooper, this City. Evaporation —M. W., City. According to calculations that have been made an acre of wheat evaporates sixty tons of water in a month. Tramp Steamers— A. J. , City.

See moreSee less

The place to apply for "a position on one of the tramp steamers that is here loading wheat for .Eu rope" is on board tbe vessel. General Custer— S., Santa Barbara, Cal. The biographies of General Custer, killed at the battle ot Little Big Horn, do not assert that at the time of his death he was a married man. Discharged— A. L., City. A man who leaves an employment of his own free will is not dis charged. To discharge an employe means to dismiss him from the position in which he was employed. "Nigger Hole"— B. , City. "Nigger Hole,"de scribed in a recent Sunday issue of The Call, is on the ranch of J. H. McLaughliu on Mill Creek, Mendocino County, about fourteen miles east of Ukiab. The Duchem of Marlboroxjgh— A. O. S., City. Consuelo Vanderbilt, who, on the 6th of No vember, 1895, married the Duke of Marl borough, is the daughter of William K. Van derbltt of New York. From Bar to Bar— Subscriber, City. When a steamer running between San Francisco and Portland, Or., makes or breaks a record, the time is between the bar at the Golden Gate and the bar at the mouth of the Columbia River. Government Lands— Mrs. N. G. L., Los An geles, Cal. This department cannot recom mend any "Government land that does not have to be irrigated." You must make your application to any of the United States land offices in the State. Bdndat in August— C. R., City. The 2d of August, 1832, fell on a Thursday. It fell on Sunday in 1801 and has fallen on Pundny in the foUowing years since: 1807, 1812. 1818, 1829, 1835, 1846, 1857, 1863, 1868. 1874 1885, 1891 and 1896. At Saußalito— G. S., City. The wall with arcnes that is near the foot of the hill at Sau salito on the eastern slope and which is a strik ing object to all who view it from the ferry boat, as it approaches the slip, is part of the wall that surrounds the property of William R. Hearst.

See the clipping

The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa.

A 1896 feature reflects on the twentieth anniversary of Custer's defeat, claiming no serious Indian uprising has occurred since, crediting government policy with successfully pacifying tribes onto reservations. It recounts other past conflicts like the Modoc and Apache wars as further evidence of this transformation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Star · 12 August 1896 · page 3

A NATION'S WARDS. UNCLE SAM'S SUCCESSFUL GUARDIANSHIP OF THE INDIANS.

IT is a fact worthy of note that inee Jnne 25, 1870, the date npon which General George A. Custer and his entire command were massacred by the Cheyennes, no erioas outbreak upon the part of the ViImi.'. Ik. T.lt.... has occurred in the United States. Yet, despite the fact that the Custer massaore practically dutes an entirely new epoch in the history of the In dian races of this great country, its twentieth anniversary, which occurred recently, passed unnoticed and unhonored, save by a few individuals with whom the memory of the little band of heroes who perished on the plains is yet green.

See moreSee less

1'rior to that time Indian uprisings were of frequent ocenrrence, for of the 200 or more tribes now in the United States there are not ten bnt what have been in rovolt t.i come time or another. There are many residents of San Francisco, says the Chronicle of that city, to-day who car. recall the Modoo troubles of 1873 and the Bannock war, in whioh King Joseph asserted him self so persistently, while the Apache ontrages under the leadership of Geronimo ore still fresh in the memory of

See the clipping

The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa.

This report is a retrospective compilation of American Indian wars from the 1850s through 1891, listing costs, casualties, and major conflicts including the Fetterman massacre and the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn. It also includes population tables of Indians by state as of the mid-1890s.

The Star · 12 August 1896 · page 3

CHirPEWA INDIANS IS CAMP. War, 1877; the Bannock War, 1878; and that against the Northern Chey ennes in 1873-79. These inolude the Fetterman massacre of December 21, 1800, and the Custer massacre of Jnne 25, 1870. The Utes in Colorado and invading Indians from outside that State caused three wars prior to 1890, and the Apaches in Arizona and New Mexico were frequently murderous and de structive. The removal of Geronimo's band of 381 Apaches as prisoners of war from their former homes to Monnt Vernon barraoks, near Mobile, Alii., effectually stopped their depre dations, however. The number of notions between reg ular troops and Indians from 1800 to 1891 was 1005, keeping an average of 10,000 officers and men actively em

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

The report marks the 20th anniversary of the Custer massacre, noting it passed largely unnoticed despite marking a turning point in US-Indian relations. It credits the government with successfully civilizing and controlling tribes on reservations since that time.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 12 August 1896 · page 6

A NATION'S WARDS. UNCLE SAM'S SUCCESSFUL GUARDIANSHIP OF THE INDIANS.

DIANSHIP OF TIIK INDIANS. Il P The Once Hostile Tribes Have Aban- ^ doned the War Path and Taken e to the Arts of Peace? ^he Custer Massacre. IT is a fact 'worthy of note that since June 25, 1876, the date upon which General George A. Custer art] his entire command were massacred by the Cheyennes, no serious outbreak upon the part of the Kition's ward, the American Indians, haa occurred in the United States. Yet, despite the fact that the Custer massacre practically dates an entirely

See the clipping

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.

A newspaper article compares the Little Bighorn to other famous last-stand massacres including the Fetterman Massacre, Isandlwana, and Rorke's Drift, emphasizing soldiers' courage against hopeless odds. It details the positions of Custer's companies under Calhoun, Keogh, Yates, Smith, and Tom Custer as they were overwhelmed by Sioux warriors.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Princeton Union · 13 August 1896 · page 9

assaults coming in two directions against the angle, Colonel Madill found his reg iment alone, facing a withering fire of artillery and musketry. When a whole Confederate division emerged from a sheltering wood and dashed for the peach orchard one of the captains said to the colonel, "Hadn't we better get out of this?" "I have no orders to get out If I had my old regiment, I could whip all of them," was the response. Twenty min utes later, with 19 unwoundedmen and his flag intact, the colonel marched back before the wave of enemies.

See moreSee less

The loss in killed and wounded was 75 per cenk Another striking battle incident at Gettysburg was the defense of McPher son's woods by Meredith's Iron Brigade. Meredith's men were the "block hatted fellows" whose unexpected presence in line of battle warned the Confederates that they must cope with the veterans of the Army of the Potomac, not with raw militia. When ordered to hold the woods at all hazards that July morn ing, they responded confidently, "If we can't do it, where will you find the men who can?" But that task was not to be so easy as it looked just then. Archer's Tennesseeans, backed by pavis' Missis sippians, entered the woods from the west, across the theoretical border line of Willoughby run. Then came the tug of war. For hours the fight went on. Archer's men were captured Davis' also. The men of iron charged forward and gave back slowly. They held the vale of Willoughby run, they battled for McPherson's woods, they charged out of the forest north along the bare ridjfe and finally began the sullen retreat, with backward steps, facing the over whelming foe. The brigade first entered those woods with 1,800 fighting men only 600 re tired to fight next day. Three command ers were shot down. The Nineteenth Indiana marched out with 78 muskets as a remnant of the 288 carried in. Captain Edwards of the Twenty-fourth Michigan led back 99 ablebodied men, leaving *400 to be accounted for among the casualties. The Seventh Wisconsin lost 178 killed and wounded out of 300 engaged. In the Wisconsin Second the casualties amounted to 77 per cent, i The Twenty-fourth Michigan estab lished and defended for a time six dif ferent lines of battle. Nine of its color ijearers were shot down while striving to keep the tattered flag afloat. In regular warfare between civilized men the soldier has hope to sustain him in the most desperate straits. Jf nothing else, he may win the respect of his vic tor. But in combats against savages, where the alternative is victory or death, brute courage animates the hero who stands until death brings relief. Self destruction would seem natural and excusable under those conditions, but we know that in the most noted of modern massacres the victims have fate, courting death in fought againstbattle. The British Isandlhwana and Borke's Drift expected no mercy from the Zulus so welcomed the cruelty of their spears. 'Major, Fetterman's men at Fort Phil Kearny Nebraska, courted death, and found i4S to a man rather than yield to the^tortlures of the Sioux. Fetterman's men, like Custer's at Little Big Horn, were chiefly war veterans. The massa cre took place in 1866 just outside the fort, where the party, numbering 79, fell into ambush and died in self de fense, unseen, except by their savage foes. Finding themselves surrounded, the soldiers, who belonged to the garri son of regulars stationed in the fort, at tempted to cut out their way through the swarm of hostiles. The position of the bodies gave evidence that Fetterm an and a handful had made a last stand on the side of the field nearest the fort. There, were no Indian bodies on the bat tlefield when visited by the whites, but pools of dark blood all over the hillside and valley, where the fight took place, showed that the Sioux had paid heavily for their treachery and their triumph. Custer's last battlefield presented evi dence of the most remarkable death struggle in open field on record. When the Indians broke from cover and ran forward to attack, Captain Calhoun's company formed line to cover the retreat of the main party to a sheltering ridge. Calhoun and all his brave boys were killed in their tracks. Keogh's company halted on the ridge, facing Calhoun's battleground. This company was slaughtered also. Meanwhile the main party had retreated a mile to another ridge. There the remaining companies of Yates, Smith and Tom Custer formed a line with their backs to the river and to Keogh's position and fought until overpowered. In the general battle" at that point General Custer, his brother Tom, Captain Yates and the adjutant, also 32 soldiers, were killed. The rest retreated toward the river and were killed together near the stream. The last stand was made two miles from where the deadly struggle began. Not by savages indeed, but by enemies equally cruel their practices, the Texans were slaughtered at the Alamo. The battle began with a living chance for the 188 men shut up in the old mission, but aft er it had been surrounded by over 4,000 Mexicans, death was the certain doom victory out of the questiSu. The sturdy Texans hurled the Mexicans from the walls twice, and finding themselves closely pressed in the third assault club bed their rifles and gave ground inch by inch until only a handful remained. It was said by the Mexicans themselves that seven of the brave fellows threw up their hands when they no longer had serviceable weapons to carry on the fight and were stabbed to death by the order of Santa Anna and in his presence. But the martyrs of the Alamo had made the enemy pay for their victory. During the siege and assault their busy rifles had slain over 500 Mexicans and wounded 1,000 more. The news of the tragedy called all Texas to arms, and, the people arose for vengeance and for liberty GEORGE L. KILMER. it -yS* a? 1 The heart that has once been bathed in love's pure fountain retains the pulse of youth forever.Lander.

See the clipping

Southern Christian Advocate · Charleston, S.C.

A correspondent describes attending an Indian dance at Fort Yates, N.D., noting details like diamond-dye face paint, tom-toms, cigarette gifts from young officers, and the Indian police presence to prevent trouble. The writer mentions some older participants had been in the 'Custer massacre' and that their wartime spirit still seemed to surface during the dances.

Southern Christian Advocate · 13 August 1896 · page 1

Many of these old bucks could tell some thrilling tales, and some were in the Custer massacre. When in their enthusiasm the yells grew loader and wilder and thie old fierce spirtT seemo to ■Wre-liOltt-of'-tiieae bucks, it grew scary and one felt a little uneasy to be among so many inspired demons as they appeared to be. One or more of the Indian police is always sent to witness these dances and prevent any trouble arising.

See the clipping

Emmons County Record · Williamsport, N.D.

The Medical Fortnightly of Boston published a biographical sketch of Dr. H. R. Porter, who served with General Reno's command during what the article calls the Custer sacrifice. The sketch praises Porter, the only one of three army surgeons present to survive, for his composure under fire.

Emmons County Record · 14 August 1896 · page 1

Porter, who was with General Reno's command during the Custer sacrifice, and who was the only one of the three United States army surgeons with Custer's com mand that escaped alive. The sketch gives the doctor mueh credit for his cool ness under fire.

See the clipping

The Weekly Intelligencer · Lexington, Mo.

A general-interest article explores how indigenous and tribal peoples transmit news rapidly, comparing the Sudan campaign, Alaska, and other regions. It recounts that Sioux scouts spread word of the Custer massacre swiftly, with Terry's Crow scouts reporting it the next day though initially disbelieved, only confirmed when Terry reached the battlefield two days later.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Weekly Intelligencer · 15 August 1896 · page 4

HOW THEY COMMUNICATE.

green standard of the khalifa. Long before the tidings of the Custer massacre reached Fort Abraham Lin coln the Sioux had spread it among their brethen of the northwest. The

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

Marking the 20th anniversary of the Custer massacre, this 1896 article credits the U.S. government with successfully pacifying once-hostile tribes through reservation policy. It reviews past conflicts including the Modoc, Bannock, and Apache wars as evidence of how far relations have progressed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Narragansett Herald · 15 August 1896 · page 8

A NATION'S WARDS UNCLE SAM'S SUCCESSFUL GUARDIANSHIP OF THE INDIANS

The Custer Massacre. T is a fact worthy of note that since June 25, 1876, the date upon which General George A. Custer and his entire command were massacred by the Cheyernes, no Berious outbreak upon the part of the Nation’s ward, the American Indians, has occurred in the United States. Yet, despite the fact that the Custer

See the clipping

The Breckenridge News · Cloverport, Ky.

This is an advertisement for an Indian entertainment show featuring Sioux chiefs, horse drills, dances, and reenactments of famous frontier conflicts including the Battle of Wounded Knee and the Custer Massacre. The ad is sponsored by the Cincinnati Zoological Society and includes other unrelated classified content about cough remedies and women's bicycle freedoms.

The Breckenridge News · 19 August 1896 · page 4

Knee the Custer Massacre etc The burning ol a white prisoner at ths stake running the gauntlet the attack upon a settlers cabin tho waylaying of stage

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

A first-person narrative describes an Indian attack on a party of quarrymen and soldiers, with heavy fighting and the wounding of a man named Tom Ryan before they escape to Fort Wallace. Three days later Custer and six companies of the Seventh Cavalry arrive and the siege is lifted.

The Evening Bulletin · 29 August 1896 · page 2

Having anticipated this movomont, we wore prepared for It. As Ryan came limping toward us, troop er and quarryman poured in a most offect lvo fire on the advanoing Indian lino. Mustangi wont down by tho dozen. The char9 was turned into a flight, and a soora of our strong follows dashod out, picked up Ryan as ho fell blooding and exhausted and carriod him back to tho wagons. "Well, boys," was tho man's only coin mont, "I reckon you'll say that was a d n closo call for Tom Ryan."

See moreSee less

Wo rcaohod Wallace in safoty, and, though tho Indians remained in sight for 48 hours, they did not renew tho attack. Throe days after that Custer, with six companies of tho Soventh cavalry, appear ed to tho oastward, and tho slogo of Fort Wallaco was raised.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This is a serialized Western fiction story about a reticent clerk named Buzzrow at a trading post on the Rosebud, with the Little Bighorn battle mentioned only as a background timestamp for how long various characters have been in the territory. The narrative focuses on frontier customs of not questioning a man's past and Buzzrow's quiet efficiency running the trading post.

The Sun · 30 August 1896 · page 5

SQUAW MAN LIFE

For years before Jackson bought the upper tore at the Rosebud Buzzrow had been head clerk. He was there when Castle, who sold to Jsckiou. bought out Louis, the half breed. Mote Hoitarth. wbo had been In that country since before Custer went down on the Little Big Horn that terrible June day In 'TO, could sot remember that there had ever been any ether head clerk than Buzzrow. "You'll find him a valuable man," Castle laid to Jackson one day as they were taking Itock at the rale. "He's quiet and hard to get acquainted with, bat he's business.'

See moreSee less

Where'd he come from 7" asked the trader. Jii-'iion nw In the Indian country, and the quel ." d d not surprise the old trader. "1 dm't now." answered Cattle, " I never asked him. He came here one day soon after I jours started this store, and has never been ar from the agency since. He knows all the Indians on the reservation; married a Brule

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A reminiscence describes a desperate Indian attack near Fort Wallace, highlighting Tom Ryan's knife fight and narrow escape before Custer's cavalry arrived to lift the siege. The account also includes a separate description of Eskimo craftsmanship and customs.

Rock Island Argus · 31 August 1896 · page 3

WITH A LEAP LIKE A WILDCAT BE ErBAyo I T THE WHTTE MAS. of onr strong fellows dashed out, picked up Ryan as he fell bleeding and exhausted aud carried him back to the wasons. "WeiL boys." was the man's only com ment, "I rot-son you'll say that was a d n close call for Tom Ryan." We reach d Wallace In safety, and, though the lo-l'mns remained in sight for 43 hours, they did not renew the attack. Three day aftt-r that Custer, with six rompanies of the Seventh cavalry, apptar f d to the eastward, and the siege of Fort Wallace was raised.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A newspaper review of a local amateur theatrical production describes an actor's realistic portrayal of 'Major Bradley' wielding a historic pistol, prompting a digression into a Civil War anecdote about General Custer failing to take a bridge in the Shenandoah Valley. The piece refers to Custer in passing as 'the hero of the Sioux massacre,' a casual legendary characterization embedded in an unrelated local arts story.

San Antonio Daily Light · 31 August 1896 · page 8

ROOK PORT THEATRICALS.

Clellan left the army, this aide to whom this pistol belonged, then a brigadier general, was on his way down the Shauaudoah valley when the enemy was encountered in large numbers. Gen. Custer, the hero of the Sioux massacre, had the advance and was ordered to take six regiments, charge and take a bridge which was of vital importance. Custer sent back word this was impossible. An order was at once sent to “Little Mac,” former aide, to form his command, four regiments and charge the enemy. Placing himself at the head of his command with this same pistol in his hand he cap tured the bridge and routed the enemy.

See moreSee less

With this bit of history in his mind, this wild charge of union cavalry on overwhelming numbers in an intrenched posi tion, it is no wonder that Mr. Hanaford imagined himself back in those grim and awful times and fairly captured the house by the realistic way in which he

See the clipping