As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

April 1896

13 articles

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Theodore W. Golden, clerk of the circuit court in Janesville, Wis., received a bronze Congressional Medal of Honor for gallantry at the Little Bighorn as a private in Custer's Seventh Cavalry. The medal recognized his volunteering with three others to fetch water for wounded soldiers besieged by Indians under General Reno's command.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.

Wrong

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 1 April 1896 · page 7

Big Horn River, Montana, July 26, 1876." General J. B. Doe, assistant secretary of war, presented the medal yesterday In the name of the president. Golden was a private in General Custer's fight ing Seventh. When General Reno's command was besieged by 300 Indians, the wounded sodliers suffered under the blazing sun from a terrible thirst. Pri vate Golden, then a raw recruit, vol unteered with three others to go down the biuft With a big camp kettle for water. All four came back, but the camp kettle, which they dragged .be tween them, was pierced by bullets.

See moreSee less

General Doe made a. touching and patriotic speceh In presenting the token from the government. The monthly meeting of the board of managers of the Home for the Friend less will be held in Trinity parish house to-day at 3 p. m.

See the clipping

The Journal · New York, N.Y.

A Wisconsin newspaper reports that Theodore W. Goldin, a former Seventh Cavalry private, has received a Congressional medal for gallantry during Reno's siege at the Little Big Horn in 1876. It recounts how Goldin and three others risked enemy fire to fetch water for wounded soldiers under a blazing sun.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 6 days earlier.

Wrong

The Journal · 1 April 1896 · page 6

Medal for a Cavalryman

W. Goldin, of Troop G, Seventh Unite< :: States Cavalry, for most distinguished gal lantry at the Little Big Horn River, Mon tana, July 26, 1876." Goldin was a privat in General Custer's Fighting Seventh When General Reno's command was be sieged by 300 Indians, the wounded soldier suffered under the blazing sun from a tei rible thirst. Private Goldin, then a ne\ recruit, volunteered, with three others, t go down the bluff with a big camp kettl for water. All four came< back, but th< camp kettle, which they dragged betweei them, was pierced by bullets.

See the clipping

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

The item reports that Rain-in-the-Face, described as leader of the Custer massacre, is now employed as a policeman at the Standing Rock agency. It notes he wears his government uniform with pride, now preserving peace rather than breaking it.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

Edgefield Advertiser · 1 April 1896 · page 5

INTERESTING PERSONALITIES.

The widow of Alexander Campbell, the founder of tho Christian or Camp bellite church, is living, at tho age of ninety-four, in Bethany, W. Va. Mrs. W. R. Thompson, who was for so many years postmistress of Louisville, Ky., is her daughter. Riin-in-theFace.who was the leader in the Custer massacre, is now a po liceman at the Standing Rock agenoy. He wears his government uniform with as much pride as he used to wear the war bonnet, and is as active now in preserving the peace as he was for merly in breaking it.

See moreSee less

It is commonly supposed that Mr. Chamberlain is the greatest amateur orchid grower in the world, but this is far from being the case. His collection is worth from $75,000 to $100,000. Tho collection of the dowager empress of Germany, however, is worth nearly, double that of Mr. Chamberlain. Miss Alice Rothschild is a most enthusiastic horticulturist, her collection of roses alone being valued at 850,000. The Archdnko Joseph of Austria owns $200,000 worth of flowers. W. W. Astor recently paid S6.000 to an Eng lish grower for the stock of a single variety of rose trees.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

Congress has granted a bronze medal to T. W. Goldin, who served in Troop G of the Seventh Cavalry under Custer. The brief notice is listed among a roundup of national news items.

San Antonio Daily Light · 3 April 1896 · page 4

Congress gives a bronze lAedal to one of Custer’s fighting boys, T. W. Goldin, Troop G, Seventh cavalry. Reed is out of it in New Hamp

See the clipping

The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D.

A Rock County clerk, Col. Theodore Golding, was given a bronze medal by order of the president for allegedly climbing a cliff under fire from 20,000 warriors to fetch water for wounded comrades at the Little Bighorn. The report calls him the only survivor of Custer's command, claiming he carried Custer's order to Reno and thus escaped the massacre.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Wrong

The Dickinson Press · 4 April 1896 · page 1

Ilrnvery Recognized. Jancsville, Wis., April 2.—Col. Theo dore W. Goldiug, clerk of the Rock county circuit court, and the only sur vivor of tlie command of Gen. Custer, was to-day decorated with a bronze medal in recognition of his services on the Big Horn river, by order of the president. The presentation was made by Assistant Secretary of War Doe, who stopped here on his way to Lake ICoshkonoiig to shoot dneks. The ser vice for which Col. Goldiug was re warded was rendered in 1870. when he climbed down a cliff in the face of the (ire of 20,000 savages to get water for his wounded comrades.

See moreSee less

He suc ceeded iu returning with several can teens filled with water, but the kettle he also carried was riddled with bul lets. Col. Golding was au aide to Gen. Custer, and at the time of the massa cre he was selected to carry Custer's famous order to MaJ. Reno and thus escaped the cruel fate that awaited every other man in Hint historic en gagement. Contract Let for Seeds. Washington, April 2. Secretary Morton has lot the contract for the 10.125.000 packets of vegetable seeds to be -listributeil to the public under the recent se of congress to 1. Lnnd rolli iVSons of Philadelphia. The price fixed is $70,000. th" seeds to be delivered subject tn the germinative test, under a very carefully drawn contract, free of cost, at findepart ment in Washington, ready for mail ing. The contract for a million pack ages of llowcr seeds was let to I,. I.. May Co. of St. Paul, .Minn., at 1-2 rent per package. More tiiNliru'rntN iilllnl. Havana. April Near .laguey Cl-ico. I he insurgents have hanged a prominent inhabitant named Euscbio Aiiueyda. Col. Pa via has been en gaged with an insurgent, band under Larret and Callaxo at the Catnubria plantation, Matanzas. The insurgents lost fifteen killed and derailed anil de stroyed an exploring engine after its escori had retired. Col. Paleneia lias been twice engaged with the insurg ents at Manicaragua. province of Santa Clara. The enemy lost six killed and the iroups captured a quan tity of ammunition and medicine. It-l#el Hun S| -rji ,1) um Cape Town. April 2.-The news from the seat of the outbreak iu Maiahcle increases iu gravity, aud details are coming to hand of the failure of the force-', dispatched against the natives to gain any substantial advantage over them. The rebellion is spieading and the in.ideijna of the present force and equipment to quell it is ad mitted. Il is learned th.u live white men. Including Mes rs Cass, llandl-y and liiiii'oid. have been unlcivd at Inyati. forty miles northeast of ISidu w.iyo. Scalded to Dentb, Anoka. Minn.. April 1. Irving Millim.'in. the lliree-ytar-old son of James Miiliman of Stanford, Isanti county, fell into a pail of hot water Saturday and died yesterday in ter rible agony. Another child in the neighborhood died from burns a week ago. Deaths In Wisconsin. Rorlin. Wis., April 1. Ex-Senator George Fitch died this morning of ap pendicitis. Manitowoc, Wis., March 31. Nick Ley. an old resident, committed sui cide by drowning In the river to day.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This report describes a lieutenant who fired shots at his commanding officer, Colonel Crofton, after finishing West Point the same month Custer and his five troops were wiped out at Little Bighorn in June 1876. The Little Bighorn reference is incidental, used only to date the lieutenant's graduation within a larger story about military discipline problems.

The Indianapolis Journal · 5 April 1896 · page 15

SHOT AT THE COMMANDANT. Chapter 4 was similar to Chapter 2 an other assault on the Colonel a p!stcl, In stead of fists, being used. First Lieut. Sam uel S. Pagne, who finished his four years at West Point i the month that Custer and his

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The article mocks an old man called 'Mountain Charley' who falsely claims to be a survivor of Custer's last stand, insisting no government soldier survived that part of the battle. It clarifies that any actual survivors would have been with Reno's command, not with Custer himself.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 14 days earlier.

The Indianapolis Journal · 15 April 1896 · page 4

ANOTHER CUSTER "SURVIVOR. Unfortunately for Ilia Claim, There "Were No Survivors. Chicago Post. The last survivor of Waterloo is dead. The number of colored ladles who had the honor of nursing the infant George Wash ington is rapidly diminishing. But Mr. Mon taton "Mountain Charley" lingers with us, minus a good part of his vertebral column, with a silver-plated head, rich in years and with a pleasant delusion that he is the last survivor but one of the Custer massacre. As the old gentleman softly descends the slope of life he lives over the incidents of the fight in which he did not participate.

See moreSee less

He believes that "at the time of General Custer's death he was within' a few feet of him. Surrounded by Indians, he made a desperate attempt to go to the General's aid. but was surrounded and scalped, and, after falling on his face, a squad of Indians rode their horses over his body." Why break up the old gentleman's harm less hallucination. Let him have all the com fort he can get out of It. But the fact is that there was no survivor of the Custer massacre. The one man who might have escaped a noncommissioned officer, who managed, with a fleet horse, to get two miles away from the scene of slaughter killed himself, probably because he thought his

See the clipping

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

The item recounts Carlo di Rudio's early life as an Italian revolutionary implicated in the 1858 Orsini bomb plot against Napoleon III, his pardon, and emigration to America. It traces his military career through the Civil War to his 1876 service with Major Reno's column at the Little Bighorn.

The National Tribune · 16 April 1896 · page 4

Y whero he served a few weeks aud was coru missicnod a Second Lieutenant in the colored troops, in which he served until Jan. 5, 38GG, when ho was mustered out aud commissioned a Second Lieutouant in tho Regular Army. In I860 ho was assigned to tho 7th U. S. Cav., and was with Maj. Keuo's column at the Custer massacre.

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark. · and 1 other paper

Theodore W. Goldin, a Janesville court clerk, was awarded a bronze Congressional Medal for gallantry at the Little Big Horn in 1876. As a raw recruit in Reno's besieged command, he volunteered with three others to fetch water for wounded soldiers under heavy fire, returning with a bullet-riddled kettle but saving water via canteens.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Daily Morning Journal and Courier, 1 April 1896, The Dickinson Press, 4 April 1896.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 17 April 1896 · page 3

BRAVE MAN, BRAVE DEED.

Montana, July 26, 1876.” General J. B. Doe, assistant secretary of war, pre sented the medal in the name of the president of the United States. Colonel Goldin was a private in Gen eral Custer’s fighting Seventh. When General Reno’s command was besieged by 800 Indians, the wounded soldiers suffered under the blazing sun from a terrible thirst. Private Goldin, then a raw recruit, volunteered with three oth ers to go down the bluff with a big camp kettle for water. All four came back, but the camp kettle, which they dragged between them, was pierced with bullets.

See moreSee less

Had it not been for canteens slung about their shoulders they would have brought back no water. Long ago the other three men were decorated by congress. Colonel Goldin’s modesty prevented the details of his achievement from being known, but his comrades were not content to let him re main in the background.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · 16 April 1896

The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D.

Theodore W. Golden, a Seventh Cavalry private who survived the 1876 battle, received a Congressional medal for volunteering to fetch water under fire while Reno's command was besieged. The medal was presented by Assistant Secretary of War J. B. Doe in Washington.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Kimball Graphic · 18 April 1896 · page 2

A Memory of the Little Big Horn

Prospect of a Fine Fruit Crop. Malvern, la., April 13.—W. K. Follett, the pioneer horticulturist of Mills coun ty. says that an examination of the various kinds of fruit buds on his prem ises discloses the fact that they are In a very thrifty and promising condition. The winter has been favorable, he says, and unless something yet occurs to pre vent there will doubtless be a good yield, of fruit of alt kinds. A Memory of the Little Big Horn Nfw York Sun. Theodore W. Golden, clerk of the cir cuit court of Janesville, Mo., is the re cipient of a bronze medal inscribed: "The Congress to Private Theodore W.

See moreSee less

Golden of Troop G, Seventh United States cavalry, for most distinguished gallantry at the Little Big Horn river, Montana, July 26, 1876." General J. B. Doe, assistant secretary of war, presented the medal Monday in the name of the president. Golden was a private in General Custer's fighting Seventh. When General Reno's com mand was besieged by 300 Indians, the wounded soldiers suffered under the blazing sun from a terrible thirst. Pri vate Golden, then a raw recruit, volun teered with three others to go down the bluff with a big camp kettle for water. All four came back, but the camp kettle, which they dragged between them, was pierccd by bullets. General Doe made a touching and pa triotic speech in presenting the token from the government. The Iowa In Its Hletnent. Philadelphia Record. One launch Is apt to be much like an other but the enthusiastic thousands who were inspired by the spectacle pre sented Saturday when the battleship Iowa went plunging into the Delaware with a magnificent splash are all agreed that this launch was a beauty and that no finer has ever been witnessed at this port. Indeed, the scene, in every way so majestic and auspicious, was one of the proudest events in the history of the state thus honored in her namesake an event to make the Hawkeye spark'e and the eye of the ^mer'can .agle to fairly blaze with the untamed •spirit of prowess. "With a Difference." I'm weary waiting here, The chill east wind Is sighing, The autumn tints are sere, The summer flowers are dying. The river's sullen way Winds on through vacant meadows. The dying light of day Strives vainly with the shadows. A footstep stirs the leaves! lhe faded fields seem brighter. The sunset gilds the sheaves, The low'rlng clouds look lighter. The river sparkles by, Not all the flowers are failing, There's asure in the sky, Atvd thou, my love, art calling ^-JuHana Horatio Ktalng.

See the clipping

The Louisiana Democrat · Alexandria, La.

The report details the retirement of Capt. Charles C. De Rudio from the U.S. Army, recounting his eventful life including service in Europe, involvement in the Orsini plot, and his near-eyewitness role at the Custer massacre at Little Big Horn under Major Reno. It notes he later testified at Reno's court-martial.

The Louisiana Democrat · 22 April 1896 · page 2

1OW 0 verity is im possible to o ithont be ing defiled." -Capt. Charles U. D)e Rudio, of the United States Army, who is just about to be retired has had a remarkable history. The career of the retiing vflicer was conlnect ed with the 1Franco-Austrian war, and the emancipation of Italy firomi Austrian rule, aniid incidentally with the overthrow of the Palmer aton Ministry in England in 1858. In later years, as a member of Ma jor lteno's command, lie was al most an eye witness of the Custer mnasacre at Little Big Horn, and he was an important witness at the court-martial over MBI,jor Reino which followed.

See moreSee less

For alleged colm plicity in the Orsini plot against - Ljouis iapoleon, in which fourteen people were killed, a fragment of the bomb passing through the Emperor's hat, De Rudio was tried llland conldenled to ldeath, butil was subsequently pardolled throngh the intercetssiou of his wif'e. [Tilnes I)emocr;t.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The article describes a private collection of Native American artifacts, including a war club, knife, and medicine bag, housed in a den in Indianapolis. It explains their use and ritual significance, noting one knife was taken from a Sioux man who threatened the owner's life shortly after the Custer massacre.

The Indianapolis Journal · 26 April 1896 · page 17

PENNSYLVANIA STREET DEN

little, but it seemed too bad to take such mean advantage of his innocence, and, with a really commendable effort he restricted himself to telling John some large fish stories, of the hauls he had made, and the Indianapolis. enormous size of the fish. As no pickerel ap peared after long and patient waiting, John could not resist the temptation of asking more questions of Rob, who had inspired him with genuine respect for his wide and varied, knowledge in the out-door sports, of which the studious John knew ro little.

See moreSee less

Rob Campbell was sixteen years old. and as merry, and mischievous, and dauntless a lad as could be found In the town of Mon roe. Gkllled in every manly rport and hard ened by cut-door exposure In Ms long skat lng and fishing expeditions, vne could not understand John Graham's gentle and retlr Ins manners, and there was nJin-d In his cccd-hucrcd trftitr:tnt cf hlra Jurt a chr!o cf c:-U't JcJi rrzs elztten, tcs, tut fcs has the den. who may be called captain. for short, took the knife from an Indian who had threatened his life Just after the Custer massacre. Had not the captain been dextrous tho knife which now hangs peacefully on the wall ot his den might have prevented his ever havlnr euch a place In which to enjoy life in the calm atmos phere of the Hcosier capital.

See the clipping

The Somerset Reporter · Skowhegan, Me.

At a Maine National Guard officers' school in 1896, Capt. W.S. Edgerly—a survivor who had served with a detachment under Custer's command—gave an evening talk recounting the 1876 campaign and battle. The account describes Custer's final force as overwhelmed by ten times their number of Indian warriors.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 12 days later.

Wrong

The Somerset Reporter · 30 April 1896 · page 1

COMI’ANY OFFICERS: A—Ervin A. Robertson, Captain; George Emery, 1st Lieut.; Frank C. Turner, 2d Lieut. I!—William A. Paul, 1st Lieut. C—William K. Kimball, Captain; Frank S. Wakefield, 1st Lieut.; George A. Iluker, 2d Lieut. D—Stephen P. Bumpus, 1st Lieut., Burton L .Alden, 2d Lieut. E—Milford Wither, Captain; Wallace 15. McPheters, 1st Lieut.; T red t . Dun lap, 2d Lieut. F—William T. Pollard, Captain. G—Ernest K. Spencer, Captain; Frank B. Cummings, 2d Lieut. II—Albert • T. ShurtlifT, Captain; Hiram O. Bay, 2 i Lieut. 1—Williams. Hume, Captain; Harry li. Corthcll, 1st Lieut.: Edward S.

See moreSee less

Wade, 2d Lieut. K—Ernest T. Lei", Captain; Thomas McCullough, 1st Lieut. L—Frank M. Hume. Captain ; Olin M. Smith, 1st Lieut. There were also present Geu. W. S. Choate, iuspeetor general on the stall' of Governor Cleaves, Capt. W. S. Kdgerly of the U. S. army, military instructor at the State College at Orono, and Col. L. 11. Kimball of die First regiment. ’The school convened for the llrst ses sion ’Tuesday afternoon and was devoted to examination of the officers of the company and close questioning by Col. l’hilbrook, Lieut. Col. Hoyt, Capt. Kdgerly and Geu. ( home. The evening session was devoted to reports of com pany commanders, a paper by Surgeon Fuller on the care of men at State En campment going to and returning there from, and a very interesting account of the campaign against the Indians which so sadly resulted in the slaughter of Gen. Custer and his men on tlie Little Big Horn river. Capt. Kdgerley participated in this battle with a detachment of Custer's forces that engaged with the Indians all day but was not drawn into the vortex where Gen. Custer and his brave troops perished, overwhelmed by ten times their number of Indians. Au interesting exercise of the evening was a sijuad drill by S men of Co. "E" under command of Corporal Branu. The work was performed with a promptness and precision that met the hearty ap proval of officers and visitors. Through the courtesy of Col. Phil brook, (ten. Isaac Dyer, Col. A. G. Blunt, Capt. II. M. Weston, Messrs. Lewis Anderson, W. IT. Wildes, E. N. Merrill, L. C. Emery, J. O. Smith, Geo. B. Saflbrd, C, A. Marston, JF. S. Cairns and W. P. Ordway were present in the Armory. Tuesday evening, and most of them availed themselves of an invitation to a dinner given at Hotel lieselton at li o'clock l’. >t. This dinner was an occasion of groat pleasure to those who participated there in. the menu being :

See the clipping