As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

May 1892

16 articles

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A newspaper query column answers a reader's question about Custer's Last Stand, noting that little is known of the actual movements of Custer's command since all were killed. It cites casualty figures and references a recent Century Magazine account as the best available, while noting the only survivor was a horse.

The Morning Call · 1 May 1892 · page 9

Custer's Last Rattle— J. C. P., City. Of the actual movements of General Custer and the five companies under his immediate command at the battle of the Little Bis Horn scarcely anything is known. He was killed and his entire command was obliter ated. The only living thing that came out of it was a horse. The entire loss was 12 officers, 247 enlisted men. 5 civil ians ana 3 Indian scouts killed, aud 2 officers . and 51 men wounded. The Seventh Cavalry, which was Custer's regi ment, had about GOO men and horses and started out under General Terry with about 400 Infantry.

See moreSee less

The best, account yet pub lished of the affair Is that which appeared recently in the Century Magazine. As no one witnessed the actual conflict resulting in the massacre of Custer's detachment the account must necessarily be conjecture. Stats Legislation— F. X., City. No State can legally legislate on a Abject which Is a matter for Federal legislation. In a limited way it can pass laws with re gard to the voting, qualifications of its citi zens at Presidential elections, but they must be in harmony with the United States law. That is the only answer to your gropiug-iu the-dark question. Nothing Inconsistent —G.• F. McK., Davis Creek, Cal. The crime for which Goldenson was hanged was committed on November 10, 1888, and Y he suffered the penalty of death on September 14, 1888. There is nothing inconsistent, therefore, in -^Eacfllteni a Decided BaMainfe mmmm 160 dozen LADIES' BLACK HOSE, mock CLOAKINGS, In all the newest spring MOUSQUE lAIRE KID GLOVES, In ;,;:L'^.'V' ; '. i : CC .-;■;.■ , ; --" ' ■ --^ : \L-.-.-:LL-'-/-L'L: : -.'':^-'L;LL: :

See the clipping

The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho

The article reports the death of Comanche, the horse found wounded after the Little Bighorn massacre in 1876, noting he was the sole survivor among men and horses. It recounts how soldiers saved him from being put down and how he lived out his days pampered at Fort Riley.

The Kootenai Herald · 6 May 1892 · page 6

FOUR LEGGED VETERANS. THREE HORSES THAT KNEW AND LOVED THE BATTLEFIELD.

: made breastworks of them. Captain I v _, ,, . , . , 1 I ? e ° s L 1 '. ^ 0Ulan<dl ® 8 nder > was among i the slaln - Au or '> wr was issued that the badly wounded horse should be shot to put him out of his misery, but the sol ; diers grieved so deeply that the farriers ! exhausted their skill and Comanche was 1 saved. Thereafter no man ever backed ; him . He lived at Fort Ril Kall iu i „ ...

See moreSee less

, - ' I * lorsw heaven, it such there ibe, fed j with the choicest food, groomed with loving care, patted and petted and solaced with lumps of sugar and the j sweetest of apples. He was part of the . j i original mount of the Seventh Cavalry» i I * n I860, bail carried Captain Keogli and others through many an Indian fight i v«. n * • 1 , , , ö , • an . c was literally striped and splotched VVU1 wounds, ■ j

See the clipping

Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D.

Ernest Russell of Muncie, Indiana, long believed dead, returned home and claims to have served in the Civil War and later on the Indian frontier. He asserts he is a survivor of the Custer massacre.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Union County Courier · 6 May 1892 · page 3

Ernest Russell of Muncie, Ind., who has loug been mourned as dead, returned frontier und ciaims to be a survivor of the Custer massacre. A Devilfish Seises a B«al»

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

This obituary for Captain Gustavus Doane recounts his military career, including leading the first detachment to reach the Custer battlefield after the massacre. It also notes his roles in Arctic exploration and surveying the Snake River.

The Helena Independent · 9 May 1892 · page 4

THE PIONEER DEATH ROLL

tions and he expired. Capt. Donne will be remembered by many old-timers as having been prominent in many ways and in many events of histor ical note. He was in charge of the first dr taohment that visited the Custer bsttlr. field after the massacre. He was the' lrt

See the clipping

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory

A newspaper item describes Comanche, the cavalry horse said to be the sole survivor of the battle in which Custer died, now pensioned at Fort Riley with the Seventh Cavalry. It claims he belonged to Capt. Keogh, a relative of Custer, and was found badly wounded far from the battlefield.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 10 May 1892 · page 3

she marry mu. — Lpodi. pre : -Don't give dat red headed feller de is j prize ' eaU se be didn't win fair. Look ! at jj; s bands." : The referee looked, and saw that the : b<jy waa wearing a pair of flesh colored i ru bb e r gloves webbed between the fifi gers and thumbs, an ingenious device, giving the swimmer much added power to his stroke. The referee gave the prizes to the boys who finished in sec ond and third places.—New York Her ald.

See moreSee less

_ An Equine Pensioner. "Do you know," said Corp. Moore, of the Newport barracks, "that there to is a horse in the United States army oil the retired list drawing a pension/ Well, it s a fact The horse belonged to Capt Keogh, a near relative to Gen. Custer, and is the only horse that es caped the massacre in which that gen eral was killed. His name is Comanche, and he is stationed at Fort Riley, Kan., with the Seventh cavalry—Custer's old regiment. His pension is sufficient to cover his transportation wherever be goes and to pay for his foragp. He is eared for by a man detailed j j or j u iy, and who does nothin

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The miscellany item describes Leon Joseph, said to be a son of Chief Joseph and now a government employee in Kansas City, as having been present with Sitting Bull when Custer's command was annihilated at the Little Big Horn. It notes he lives quietly with a white wife and children and expresses regret over his role in Custer's death.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Weekly Union · 18 May 1892 · page 5

GENERAL AXD PARTICULAR. North Dakota is said to be receiving more from the sale of schoollandsthan was ever received by any other state. Rev. Epaminondas J. Pierce of Phlladel phia has left his estate, value at $200,000, for the education of colored youths for the ministry. It is stated that over 40,000 persons land at Joppa every year in order to make a pil grimage to Jerusalem and other spots cel ebrated in sacred history. The discovery is made that the Alaska soil and climate are peculiarly adapted to hop raising.

See moreSee less

AnOregon syndicate has pur chased a large tract near Fort Wrangel and will plant it with hops. The grand medical council of England has issued an order compelling medical students to take five years’ study, hospital attendance and lectures, before being qualified to appear [for the final examina tion. Dynamite has been superseded in Sweden for blasting purposes. Electric ;wires are introduced in the rock and then heated. The sudden heating of the rock rends itin pieces, quietly and effectively. without per il to human life. ; - Seven hundred and fifty persons are now undergoing prosecution in the German courts for disrespect to the emperor. Of this number nearly all are editors or pro prietors of newspapers, who have criticised the emperor’s speeches. In an old trunk in a forgotten corner of a garret of a house in Martinsville, Ind., the other day, were found SIO,OOO in gold coin. Itis supposed to have been deposited there by the father of the present cwner of the place many years ago. The Rev. Dr. Wild, who was once spoken of as Beecher’s probable successor in Ply mouth pulpit, was asked not long ago by a parishioner why he accepted a call to Tor onto. “I might say it wasa callfrom God,” he replied, “but the real fact is that I am paid S2OOO a year more than I was getting.” _The gavel wielded by the Oregon depart ment commander of the Grand Army of the Republic recalls the murder of General Canby and Rev. Dr. Thomas, the Modoec peace commissioners. Itis of white pine and is made of a part of the gallows on which the Modoe murderers—Captain Jack. Beston Charley, Black Jim and Schonchin —were executed. / Cne of the hottest regions in the United States is along the line of the Southern Pa cific railroad in Arizona. At Bagdad, in that territory, the thermometer has been known to stand as high as 140 in the shade for days in succession. The ticket agent at Bagdad says that he has seen the murcury standing at 128 on the cool side of the depot building at midnight. David H. Ames of Jerseyville, 111., who celebrated his 100th anniversary on Sunday weighs over 200 pounds,has never, it is said, expended $25 for doctors, never used intox icants, but has been a user of tobacco for - 85 years. He was a soldier of the war of 1812, and fhas never missed voting for a president from Monroe to Harrison. His father lived to be 162 years old and wasa soldier in the revolution. Thomas A. Edison has taken out more pa tents than has been given to any other in ventor in the United States, and probably in the world. He is credited at the patent bureau in Washington with more than 600 inventions, mostly in electrical appliances, and during one week eight sets ot letters patent were issued in his name. Itis said that so great is the proportion of patents taken out in Connecticut that one citizen out of every 700 is an inventor. Leon Joseph, a son of the late Chief Jo seph of the Cherokees, a powerfully-built half-breed who was with Sitting Bull when Custer’scommand was massacred on the Little Big Horn, is now employed in the government building ‘at Kansas City. Joseph is married to a white woman and they have several children. In a little frame house on the outskirts of the city, the ex-warrior lives a prosaic life when notonduty as a servant of the govern ment. He often expresses regret thathe took part in the annihilation of Custer and his men. In a quaint sermon on Mr. Spurgeon, pub lished by James Murray. of Aberdeen, Mr. Burnett of Kemay tells the following story: “I was talking to him one !day at our tea table ahout the German language. ‘Do you know,’ said he, ‘how the German lan guage originated?’ ‘No,” I replied, ‘ldo not.’ ‘Well,> he said, quite gravely, ‘it was in this way: There were two work men at the Tower of Babel, one standing above the other. The uppermost one acci dentally threw some mortar from his trow el into the mouth of the lower one, and he began to splutter with the mortar in his mouth.’ 2? In India, a novel method of making a foundation in damp ground was recently tried with great success. A hole was bored in the earth from 10to 12 feet deep and 125 inches in diameter. Dynamite cartridges were then exploded in the hole, thus not only increasing the diameter to threefeet, but actually driving the water out of the surrounding earth to such a distance that

See the clipping

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

A travel correspondent describes Miles City, Montana, its businesses, Fort Keogh garrison, and the nearby Cheyenne agency holding over 1,200 Indians under military watch. She notes some had participated in the ghost dance and others in the Custer massacre.

Ellsworth American · 19 May 1892 · page 1

Mr. and Mrs. Harvey Ash have moved to Sullivan. Mrs. J. M. Fogg, who has been visiting her sister in Lowell, has returned home. Mrs. Frank Fogg is in Dedham visitiug relatives and friends. We anticipate quite a lively snmmer at Flood’s Pond as visitors are already thronging its waters in search of the “speckled beauties,** which are quite nu merous. The visitors of one day this week were as follows: Mr. Edwaid Stetson, president of the First National Bank; Henry Peavey, of firm of Peavey & Son; Mr. Parker, firm of Parker & Peaks; L.

See moreSee less

G. Bragdon, firm of Lord & Bragdon; Edward Egeryf firm of Egery & Son, iron works; Walter Morse, firm of Morse & Son; L. D. Kicker, clerk of the firm of Oakes & Clark; R. H. Hurd, C. F. Durby, G. F. Leavy, B. Stanley and C. Royal, all of Bangor. Mr. Henry Peavy caught a trout which weighed five and one-half pounds. M»y 10. KaT. rtians. Over twelve hundred are quartered there and kept in subjection by the pres ence of the soldiers. Many of them were in the ghost dance two years age. and some In the Custer massacre.

See the clipping

The Citizen · Chicago, Ill.

The passage promotes John F. Finerty's book 'Warpath and Bivouac,' a firsthand account of the Indian wars including the Custer massacre, Chief Joseph's fight, and Sitting Bull's surrender. Multiple newspapers are quoted praising the book's vivid, eyewitness style and comprehensive scope.

The Citizen · 21 May 1892 · page 2

NO NEW CHAPTER CAN BE ADDED.

NO NSW CHAPTXB OAK BE ADDED. [Bismarck Tribune.] Sven those familiar with the history of the Custer massacre will read with fresh Interest the graphic details leading up to that terrible slaughter, as related by the Timet correspondent Hr. Fin erty, and now oSered to the public in the volume with the above title. The campaign of 1878, on the British line, which embraces Gen. Hlies’ battls with Chief Joseph; Sitting Bull’s last light and the rounding up of that expedi lion, which might be considered as a ter min all on of Indian warfare, forma an In tcrewing part of the volume and it may solely be asserted that no new materia] will ever be furnished that can add an other chapter of like interest to the his tory of progress on this continent in sup1 planting barbarism with civilisation.

See the clipping

The Citizen · Chicago, Ill.

This passage compiles praise from several Chicago and Pennsylvania newspapers for John Finerty's memoir 'Warpath and Bivouac,' covering the Sioux campaigns including the Rosebud fight, Sibley Scout, Slim Buttes, and the pursuit of Indians after the Custer massacre. The reviews emphasize the book's vivid, accurate, and thrilling narrative style.

The Citizen · 21 May 1892 · page 2

IHTKBB8TTHG THOU START TO HHISS. [Chicago Mornine Xfsm.1 "Hr. Finerty’s book contains all ths material facts of a history of the opera* tlons against the Sioux, but It is written In a narrative style and is Interesting from start to finish. His descriptions of the Rosebud fight, the "Sibley Scout,” the engagement at Slim Buttes, and his story of the long march in pursuit at the Indiana after the Custer massacre, have never been equaled.” □mnnanse as mnsou ooofbr. ^ (Chicago Evening Journal.] ; "Probably the most exciting chap ters of the work are those In which are described the adventures of the Sibley scouting expedition, which the author o» tained leave to accompany, and which came near resulting in the capture and death of all who took part in Ik The story of the way in which this little band of t men were aurnriaed bv the Indians, of \ their sias* by ever-increasing numbers at , savage foes, of their stout resistance, and < of their skilfully managed retreat when j all escape seemed hopeless, Is none the Isas Interesting because It is strictly tram and Is quite as thrilling ss a chapter of Penlmore Cooper’s novels.”

See the clipping

Grand Rapids Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

The article recounts Elizabeth Custer's life after her husband's death at Little Bighorn in June 1876, describing her grief alongside other officers' widows and her eventual settling near West Point. It details her work as secretary of a decorative art society and her efforts supporting fellow widows of the massacre.

Grand Rapids Herald · 23 May 1892 · page 2

SHE IS A HEROINE.

The first winter alter the leartui traeedy of June, 1876, which swept five gallant men out of the Custer family, the two young wtaows, Margaret mus ter Calhoun and ttiuanetn acon mus ter, accompanied by two other stricken souls. Mrs. Captain Yates and Mrs. Lieutenant Smith, sat down in the quiet little village of Monroe, Mich., and in dumb agony wept away the days with noor old Father and Mother custer. In the spring of 1877, when General Sheridan and his band of picked men accomplished the terrible task of pen etrating the "baa lands," rescued tne remains ot those woo leu in mat in dian massacre, and brought them east for burial, Elizabeth Custer followed the muffled drum to her husband's last camping ground, then pitched her own tent in the neighboring city, where she could work with brain and with band for her own heart's sake and for the sake of "her widows," as she always calls them those who went down into that dark valley with ber and who came out even more crushed and help less than she.

See moreSee less

Through the mother of Capt. Louis Hamilton ot tne sevenin cavalry, (slain by Indians two years before) Mrs. Custer was appointed secretary of

See the clipping

Grand Rapids Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

The report details Mrs. Elizabeth Custer's post-widowhood life, including her secretarial work for the Decorative Art Society, her writing of 'Boots and Saddles' to defend General Custer's reputation, and her hospital volunteer work in New York City. It portrays her as a resilient figure who turned personal grief into public service and literary achievement.

Grand Rapids Herald · 23 May 1892 · page 2

SHE IS A HEROINE.

camo life. "Boots and Saddles." She was instigated, moreover, by a desire to correct a false idea of the character of General Custer dissemin ated by sensational dramas and "yel low covered literature." So, though the ink was literally obliterated by tears, he persevered In the mournful task of reviewing tnose precious asys that were gone. The gratifying success of her first nook made the writing of those which followed much easier; and now, the assurance thst she is raising a monument to the hero more valuable and more durable thsn eraniWior bronze, makes the writ ing and the speaking on the subject which is a part of her hie botn easy ana nlant.

See moreSee less

The opportunity to do hospital work was another thing wnicn msae reidence in New York city so congenisl at the very first to Mrs. Custer. .Nothing

See the clipping

Grand Rapids Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

Elizabeth Custer, widow of General Custer who died at Little Bighorn, gave a lecture titled 'Garrison Life' to a packed Ladies' Literary Club audience. She described the daily rhythms of army camp life, from reveille to sunset, framed by the boom of guns.

Grand Rapids Herald · 24 May 1892 · page 4

Ufa In ihs Far West. Nearly every seat in the Ladies' lit erary club bouse was taken before 4 o'clock yesterday afteruooo, the hour assigned for the opcuing of the lecture by Mrs. Klisabeth 11. Custer, widow of the famous and gallant soldier whose life was sacrlnocd at the Little Big Horn. The stage was beautifully draped with the national flag, aud was further adorned with red and white tulips. Mrs. Custer was introduced by Mrs. Smith W. Osterhout, the lecture being given under the auspices of Mrs. Oster nout's Ten" of the 1'ark Congrega tional church. Mis. Custer Is a modest, unassuming

See the clipping

Wyoming Weekly Republican · Sundance, Wyo.

An artist named Riordan has completed a statue of a Sioux maiden called Minnehaha for a South Dakota exhibit. The passage recounts a romantic legend claiming she was the daughter of a Sioux warrior named Sitting Bear who fought at the Little Big Horn, and her ill-fated love for a cavalry lieutenant.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Wyoming Weekly Republican · 25 May 1892 · page 3

| and every fold, wrinkle and ornaI ment is clearly cut and produces I a strong effect. Riordan took for his subject a Sioux maiden of 18 Summers, named Minnehaha, in connection with whose life and death there is a romantic legend. Minnehaha was the daughter of Sitting Bear, one of the forcmos of the Sioux Warriors who was in the engagement with General Custer’s troops on the Little Big

See the clipping

The Citizen · Chicago, Ill.

This item compiles newspaper blurbs praising John Finerty's book 'Warpath and Bivouac,' covering his firsthand accounts of the Rosebud fight, the Sibley Scout, Slim Buttes, and the pursuit of Indians after the Custer massacre. Reviewers call it accurate, thrilling, and comparable to Fenimore Cooper's fiction.

The Citizen · 28 May 1892 · page 2

INTERESTING FROM START TO FINISH. [Chicago Morning New.] “Mr. Finerty’s book contains all th< material facts of a history of the opera tions against the Bioux, but it is written in a narrative style and is interesting from start to finish. His description! of the Kosebud fight, the “Sibley Bcout,’ the engagement at Blim Buttes, and hii story of the long march in pursuit of the Indians after the Custer massacre have never been equaled.”

See the clipping

Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J.

A planned South Dakota exhibit at the World's Fair will feature a life-size statue of a Sioux maiden named Minnehaha, said to be the daughter of a chief called Sitting Bear who fought at Little Bighorn. The item recounts her romantic legend of falling for a U.S. Army lieutenant and dying of a broken heart.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Passaic City Record · 28 May 1892 · page 3

WORLD'S FAIR NOTES

Bear, who was prominent in the engagement with General Custer’s troops on the Little Big Horn Minnehaha fell in lore a Lieu tenant in the United States Army at Fort

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

A notice describes a planned World's Fair exhibit featuring a statue of a young Sioux woman called Minnehaha, said to be the daughter of 'Sitting Bear,' tied to the Custer fight at Little Big Horn. The piece adds a romantic tale of her falling in love with an army lieutenant and dying of heartbreak.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Madison Daily Leader · 31 May 1892 · page 2

A Dakota Beauty

Attention. Xante l»«ver*. trainard'a Musical World for May is of beautiful new music and interest ing reading matter. It contains four choice piano pieces: "Remember Me" by Brinkmann the celebrated "Bar carolle." op. 37, by Tschaikowsky "Doubt," a beautiful tone poem, by Emery and "May Bells," by Spindler. Also a charming new song by Fannie Snow Knowlton, entitled "I'm Yours, Sweetheart, Forever." The music in this number is alone worth $2.00. Mailed post-paid for 15 cents in stamps, or three back numbers mailed for 25 cents. Pu b lished monthly at $1.50 per year.

See moreSee less

The Musicians Guide (Spring edition 189*2) contains, besides 212 pages of musical information, biographies of 150 Musicians, with 25 portraits, a "Teachers' Guide" and other valuable feature, three new songs. "My Kathleen coming Back,' "Last Night" and "That is Love," and two piano pieces, "sounds from the Ball room" and "Stolen Kisses"—Gavotte. Mailed free for eight two-cent stamps, or the World and Guide, containing the above ten songs and pieces, mailed for twelve two-cent stamps. Address, The S. Braiunrd's Sons Co., Chicago, 111. A Dakota Beraty. Tire World's Fair Notes: In the wo men's exhibit from South Dakota will be a life size statue of a Sioux Indian maiden. The subject was Minnehaha, the eighteen year old dalighter of Sit ting Bear, who was prominent in tbe engagement with Gen. Custer's troops on the Little Big Horn. Minnehaha fell in love with a lieutenant in the U. S. army at Fori Sully &aU diad^of heart. -One of tbe most notable magazine ar ticles of the month is Mr. B. O. Flower's paper in the June Arena on "Democracy of Darkness of Ishmaelites of Civiliza tion." In it the author gives vivid pen pictures of the sub-cellar of our social world, where want and woe mingle with vice and sin. Much information in the way of statistics aud important data are given. Miss Francis Willard writes: "I have read 'Ishmaelites' with thought ful interest, sorrow and hope. It is much that such studies are made in our day and brought before the great magazine reading world. Every word in this pa per has my warm and unqualified ap proval. The church of Christ has no adequate explanation in the3e new days save as it seta itself to solve the problem Iit the social cellar." This paper should be read by all who •re interested in the problem of poverty and crime. Other notable papers in this Issue are by Prof. A. E. Dolbear of Tufts University, R£v. M, J. Savage, W. McCrackan, A. m., Rabbi Solomon Bchindler, Louise Chandler Moulton, and D. N. Hoi way.

See the clipping