A review of the January 1892 Century magazine notes its feature article by Capt. E. S. Godfrey, one of Custer's troop commanders, offering a new theory on Custer's movements at Little Bighorn based on his own knowledge and information from the attacking chiefs. The piece is followed by a critical review of the campaign by Gen. James B. Fry.
Iowa County Democrat · 1 January 1892 · page 8
Horn, “Custer’s Last Battle.” Capt. Godfrey advances anew and conclusive theory with regard to Gen. Custer’s movements, which is based upon his own knowledge at the time, and also upon information derived directly from the chiefs who led the attack. Capt. Godfrey’s article is followed by a critical review of the events of the
This 1892 report memorializes Comanche, the cavalry horse that survived the Little Bighorn battle wounded in seven places, and recounts his subsequent honored life at Fort Riley until his death at age 45. It notes he was ridden by Captain Keogh and later appeared riderless at military reviews as a symbol of the battle.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The World · 1 January 1892 · page 4
In Memoriam—Comanche
Choose what you will have and pay the price.—Ancient Greek Saying. The tin plate industry is depressed in Great Britain. Was it the Ohio election that did it? Portraits of various centenarians bob up every little while in the newspaper illustrations. But if all persons who are to arrive at the age of a hundred are bound to look like that, then the aver age citizen may well pray to be taken out of the world about the time he comes of age. That is a fearful row about nothing which Amelie Rives Chanler makes in her new novel, “According to St.
See moreSee less
John.” The heroine commits snicide because she thinks the hero wants to be rid of her, and she loves him so much that she wants to set him free. Why didn’t the foolish creature get a divorce? What can be thought of men calling themselves civilized and decent, and liv ing in an enlightened eastern state, who will tar and feather a girl of eight een and turn her out on a cold night in a public highway without clothing? There are reform schools, there are prison reformatories, there is law enough in any county of the Union to properly punish a girl of that age, no matter what her crimes may be. The day may come when these men will not be proud of their exploit. A remarkable machine for cutting lumber has been invented by Dr. Brad ley, of New York city, and Thomas Crane, of Newark, N. J. The taro have experimented live years, with the result of perfecting a machine that will cut forty boards a minute from a sawlog and drop them as smooth as if they had been planed in the most careful man ner. The machine thus saws and piaues the wood at one operation, with no loss of either sawdust or shavings. It will revolutionize lumber cutting. The cut ting is done by a powerful knife that works with a draw motion. The inven tion was tried in presence of a practical lumberman from New York, another from Canada and another from Penn sylvania. All pronounced it a success. If it comes into common use the human ear will be no more harrowed with the sound of the buzz saw. In Memnrlam— Comanche. He was the only surviving creature from the Custer massacre on Little Big Horn in 1870. He was wounded in seven places, robbed of all his valuables and left for dead. Yet he was not dead, but managed to crawl away from the field of blood, where he was found some days after the battle. He was tenderly cared for and recovered. He belonged to the United States army, but was never re quired to do any service from that event ful day till not long since, at Fort Riley, Kan., he died of old age, honored and regretted by all who knew him. Comanche was a horse. He belonged to the United States cavalry service and was 45 years old when he died. He was ridden into the fatal fight by his gallant master, Captain Keogh, a relative of General Custer. Comanche came out. but he was riderless, and no roan ever rode him again. At military reviews he appeared on parade with empty sad dle, a reminder of the bloodiest battle tragedy of this generation, the massacre of Little Big Horn. At cavalry drills the old fellow was occasionally bridled and saddled and led out with the rest, responding to the familiar bugle signal for fifteen years, till he heard and an swered the final trumpet call. Brave old Comanche! It is hard to believe yon have no soul. The Millennium, Perhaps. it would be agreeable to live in the time when the hopes of a writer in Far and Near are realized. Far and Near is the organ of the working girls’ clubs of America, and it was left for one of these working girls herself to establish an ideal of conduct between woman and woman which has escaped the notice of her richer and more favored sis ters. But if the sex would all hold before them the ideal of this poor work ing girl, something like the millennium would dawn. It has been said so long it has become a commonplace that women all dislike one another at heart and are jealous of one another. It will certainly not be true if all women, rich and poor, take to heart the words of the working girl who writes in Far and Near. She tells us that a new force will begin to move the world when women hang together and help one another and have only good will toward one another, each rejoicing in a sister’s success, no matter what one’s own failures and disappointments are. These are things to keep still about. If each does the best she knows how to do, there is success worth having for all in one line or another without grudging or picking flaws in the work of another. The working girl’s definition of love is interesting: Much has been written of the love betwe man and woman, not so much of the love women for one another. When this latter fully recognized, there will be a new force the world. 1 know only one satisfactory, i around definition of love in existence. It Is woman's feeling toward her follow woms She will suiter long for her; she Is kind to hi She neither envies her nor looks down up' her. She is not easily provoked with her; s thinks no evil of her. She bears and believ and hopes aDd endures all things for her sat and loves unfailingly. This Is not a mere se timental feeling; it Is a controlling life pri clple, the motive power which keeps theengi at work. In a working girl's club or elsewhe It will walk straight through difficulties ai accomplish anything. It Is the great whole what we call charity-the giving to those th need, and the thinking no evil Is but a part. Choose what you will have and pay the price.—Ancient Greek Saying. The tin plate industry is depressed in Great Britain. Was it the Ohio election that did it? Portraits of various centenarians bob up every little while in the newspaper illustrations. But if all persons who are to arrive at the age of a hundred are bound to look like that, then the aver age citizen may well pray to be taken out of the world about the time he comes of age. That is a fearful row about nothing which Amelie Rives Chanler makes in her new novel, “According to St. John.” The heroine commits snicide because she thinks the hero wants to be rid of her, and she loves him so much that she wants to set him free. Why didn’t the foolish creature get a divorce? What can be thought of men calling themselves civilized and decent, and liv ing in an enlightened eastern state, who will tar and feather a girl of eight een and turn her out on a cold night in a public highway without clothing? There are reform schools, there are prison reformatories, there is law enough in any county of the Union to properly punish a girl of that age, no matter what her crimes may be. The day may come when these men will not be proud of their exploit. A remarkable machine for cutting lumber has been invented by Dr. Brad ley, of New York city, and Thomas Crane, of Newark, N. J. The taro have experimented live years, with the result of perfecting a machine that will cut forty boards a minute from a sawlog and drop them as smooth as if they had been planed in the most careful man ner. The machine thus saws and piaues the wood at one operation, with no loss of either sawdust or shavings. It will revolutionize lumber cutting. The cut ting is done by a powerful knife that works with a draw motion. The inven tion was tried in presence of a practical lumberman from New York, another from Canada and another from Penn sylvania. All pronounced it a success. If it comes into common use the human ear will be no more harrowed with the sound of the buzz saw. In Memnrlam— Comanche. He was the only surviving creature from the Custer massacre on Little Big Horn in 1870. He was wounded in seven places, robbed of all his valuables and left for dead. Yet he was not dead, but managed to crawl away from the field of blood, where he was found some days after the battle. He was tenderly cared for and recovered. He belonged to the United States army, but was never re quired to do any service from that event ful day till not long since, at Fort Riley, Kan., he died of old age, honored and regretted by all who knew him. Comanche was a horse. He belonged to the United States cavalry service and was 45 years old when he died. He was ridden into the fatal fight by his gallant master, Captain Keogh, a relative of General Custer. Comanche came out. but he was riderless, and no roan ever rode him again. At military reviews he appeared on parade with empty sad dle, a reminder of the bloodiest battle tragedy of this generation, the massacre of Little Big Horn. At cavalry drills the old fellow was occasionally bridled and saddled and led out with the rest, responding to the familiar bugle signal for fifteen years, till he heard and an swered the final trumpet call. Brave old Comanche! It is hard to believe yon have no soul. The Millennium, Perhaps. it would be agreeable to live in the time when the hopes of a writer in Far and Near are realized. Far and Near is the organ of the working girls’ clubs of America, and it was left for one of these working girls herself to establish an ideal of conduct between woman and woman which has escaped the notice of her richer and more favored sis ters. But if the sex would all hold before them the ideal of this poor work ing girl, something like the millennium would dawn. It has been said so long it has become a commonplace that women all dislike one another at heart and are jealous of one another. It will certainly not be true if all women, rich and poor, take to heart the words of the working girl who writes in Far and Near. She tells us that a new force will begin to move the world when women hang together and help one another and have only good will toward one another, each rejoicing in a sister’s success, no matter what one’s own failures and disappointments are. These are things to keep still about. If each does the best she knows how to do, there is success worth having for all in one line or another without grudging or picking flaws in the work of another. The working girl’s definition of love is interesting: Much has been written of the love betwe man and woman, not so much of the love women for one another. When this latter fully recognized, there will be a new force the world. 1 know only one satisfactory, i around definition of love in existence. It Is woman's feeling toward her follow woms She will suiter long for her; she Is kind to hi She neither envies her nor looks down up' her. She is not easily provoked with her; s thinks no evil of her. She bears and believ and hopes aDd endures all things for her sat and loves unfailingly. This Is not a mere se timental feeling; it Is a controlling life pri clple, the motive power which keeps theengi at work. In a working girl's club or elsewhe It will walk straight through difficulties ai accomplish anything. It Is the great whole what we call charity-the giving to those th need, and the thinking no evil Is but a part.
The report announces the death of Comanche, the cavalry horse famed as the only survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, who died of old age at Fort Riley at about 45. It recounts his wounded, riderless discovery after the battle, his subsequent retirement from riding duty, and plans to have him mounted for display at the Chicago World's Fair.
Wyoming Weekly Republican · 2 January 1892 · page 2
there arc no such things ns republican institutions, as we understand the term, in tho states of South and Cen tral America. 'l'he form of govern ment may vary, according to the whim or the interest of the faction in control for the time being; but a republic, at the United States is a republic, cannot exist in South America until the ma terial for it has been prepared. Those states contain a population of which a heavy majority is entirely ignorant of and indifferent to political affairs. To the recently emancipated slaves of Brazil, to the Indian tribes of that and other countries, to the vast body ol mixed bloods in these governments, who are without interest in political questions, the existence of a republic or a monarchy is a matter of profound indifference.
See moreSee less
To them all rules are alike; and they submit to any that al lows them to live their lazy, easy lives, just as ready to shout for u dictator as for a president* and with no under standing that there is a distinction be tween the two. Years ago, when the foreigners were but few in our country towns, a teach er took great pains to correct the pro nunciation of one of tho offspring of the only foreign family in the district and he wanted to know if she expected to "make a Yankee of him.” That is just what we want to do, make Yankees or Americans of them all. They have come here because they thought this country was better than their native land, and if thej’ are to enjoy its bene fits they should bo ready to support its institutions, not only in war, where many of them have already shown their devotion, but in peace as well. them cherish the memory of their ancestors and of tho land that gave them birth if they will, but teach them that their first duty is to the land that shelters them, supports them and edu cates them, and encourage them to identify themselves with iL With a little stronger safeguard drawn around to prevent the entrance of an undesi rable class, and a little better organ ized effort to Americanize those who are allowed to come and their children, the United States can still remain, sis it has boa>ted of being for a century past a refuge for the oppressed of every nation. sacred. He was one of the original i mount of the Seventh cavalry. which regiment was organized in 1866. and had been in almost every battle in the ' Indian service. After the battle of Little Big Horn he was found covered with wounds, riderless and saddleless, some distance from the scene of the massacre. He was taken charge of by ('apt. Bowlan and sent to Fort Kiley, where for fours teen years he had not Iwen subject to bridle, and had been in charge of the Seventh cavalry. His death was dur to old age. His skin will be stuffed and mounted and kept in the museum of the Kansas State university until the world’s fair at Chicago, where it will Im* taken for exhibition. Enterprising showmen have from time to time endeavored to secure Comanche for exhibition purposes, but the authorities have invariably refused to disturb his well-earned rest. Co manche was the horse of (’apt. Keogh, a relative of Gen. Custer. Special provision was made for the care and support of Comanche. Once in a while, when the cavalry tnwips were on inspection. Comanche was led out. saddled and bridled, but no one ever sat in his saddle after the battle of the Little Big Horn.
Captain Godfrey, a troop commander under Custer, challenges the long-accepted theory that Custer's column tried to ford the river and was driven back before retreating to the ridge. Using Native American testimony and his own observation of horse tracks, he argues Custer's column never reached the river or village, moving directly to the final ridge position instead.
The Morning Call · 3 January 1892 · page 16
Has so Often Been Started. The January Century contains a profusely illustrated description of " Custer's Last Battle "by Captain Godfrey, the commander of a troop under Custer. From it we quote the following: The accepted theory for many years after the battle, and still per sisted iv by some writers, was that Custer's column had turned the high bluffs near the river, moved down the dry (Reno's) creek, and attempted to ford the river near the lowest point of these bluffs; that he was there met by an overpowering force and driven back; that lie then divided his bat tallion, moved down the river with the view of attacking the village, but met with such resistance from the enemy posted along the river bank and.
See moreSee less
ravines that he was com pelled to fail back, fighting, to the position on the ridge. The numerous bodies found scattered between the river and ridge were supposed to be the first victims of the fight. I am now satisfied that these were men who cither survived those on the ridge or at tempted to escape the massacre. Custer's route was as indicated on the map, and his column was never nearer the river or the village than his final position on the ridge. The wife of Spotted Horn Bull, when giving me her account of the battle, persisted in saying that Coster's column did not at tempt to cross at the ford, and appealed to her husband, who supported her statement. On the battle-field, In 1886, Chief Gall indi cated Custer's route te me, and it then flashed upon me that 1 myself had seen Custer's trail. On June 28th, while we were burying the dead, 1 asked Major Reno's permission to go on the high ridge east or back of the field to look for tracks of shod horses, to ascertain if some of the com mand m lit not have escaped. When I reached the ridge I saw this trail and wondered who could have made it, but dis missed the thought that' It had been made by Custer's column because it did not ac cord vith the theory with which we were then filled— that Custer had attempted to cross at. the ford— and this trail was too far back, and showed no indication of
A participant recalls finding Custer's shod-horse trail on a ridge in 1876 but dismissing it at the time because it didn't match the prevailing 'ford theory.' Years later, confirmed by Chief Gall and a fellow soldier, he concludes Custer never approached the river or village, revising the long-held account of the battle's final movements.
The Morning Call · 3 January 1892 · page 16
LEADING TOWAKD THE FOItD. Trumpeter Peowell was my orderly and accompanied me. it was a singular coinci dence that in 1886 Pen well was stationed at Fort Custer, and was my orderly when visit ing the battle-field. Penwell corroborated my recollection of the trail. The ford theory arose from the fact that we fotini there numerous tracks of shod horses, but they evidently had been made after the Indians had possessed themselves of the cavalry horse?, for. they rode them alter capturing them. No bodies of men or horses wore found anywhere near the ford, and these facts are conclusive to my mind that Custer did uot go to the ford with any body of men.
See moreSee less
. '- As soon as Gall had personally confirmed Iron Cedar's report he sent word to the war riors battling against Reno and to the people in the village. The greatest consternation prevailed among the families, and orders were given for them to leave at once. Be fore they could do so the great body of warriors Ind left Reno and hastened to at tack Custer. This explains why Reno was not pushed when so much confusion at the river crossing gave the Indians every oppor tunity of annihilating his command. Not loug after the Indians began to show a strong force in Custer's front. Custer turned his column to the left and advanced in the direction of tiie village to a place now marked as a spring, halted at the Junction of the ravines just below it and dismounted two troops, Keogb's and Calhoun's, to fight on foot. These two troops advanced at double - time to a knoll, now marked by Crittenden's monu ment. The other three troops, mounted, followed them a short distance in their rear. '1 lie led horses remained where the troops dismounted. When Keoch and Calhoun got to the knoll the other troops marched rapidly to the right; .Smith's troop de ployed as skirmishers, mounted, and took position on a ridge, which, on Smith's left, ended in Keogh's position (now marked by Crittenden's monument), and, on Smith's right, ended at the hill on which Custer took position with Yates and Tom Custer's troops NOW KNOWN AS ci Kit's BILL, And marked by the monument erected to the command. Smith's skirmishers, hold ing their gray horses, remained in groups of fours. The line occupied by Caster's battalion whs the first considerable ridge back of the river, the nearest point being about half a mile from it. His front waa extended about three-fourth! of a mile. The whole village was in full view. A few hundred yards from this line was another but lower ridge, the fuither slope of which was not com manded by his line. It was here that the Indians under Crazy Horse from the lower part of the village, among whom were the Cheyenne*, formed for the charge on Custer's Hill. All Indians had now left Reno. Call collected his warriors and
A news item describes an upcoming issue of the Century magazine featuring Captain E. S. Godfrey's article on the Little Big Horn massacre, offering a new theory on Custer's movements based on his own knowledge and information from Native chiefs who led the attack. The piece notes it will be followed by a critical review of the campaign by General James H. Fry.
The Roanoke Times · 3 January 1892 · page 7
article by Captain E. S. Godfrey, one of General Custer's troop commanders, on the massacre of tho Little Big Horn, "Custer's Last Rattle." Captain Godfroy advances a new and conclusive theory with regard to General Custer's move* moots, which is based upon his own knowledge at tho time, and also upon information derived directly from the chiefs who led the attack. Captan God? frey's article is followed by a critical re? view of the events of tho campaign by General James H. Fry.
This is a literary notices column listing contents of various magazines, including the January Century featuring an article by Capt. E.S. Godfrey, one of Custer's troop commanders, on the 'massacre of Little Big Horn' titled 'Custer's Last Battle.' The item is a book/magazine review, not a direct news report of the battle itself.
The Morning News · 4 January 1892 · page 7
don and Dr. William A. Hammond. No. 8 East Fourteenth street. New York. A portrait of Gounod, the celobrated French,composer, forms the frontispiece of the January Century. The first of tho series on “The Jews in New York,” by the Rev. Dr. Wheatley, is given with numer ous illustrations, and there also appears a brief article on "Thu Jowisn Question” in general, treated from a very lofty paint of view by an anonymous writer who uses the signature "Josephus.” Another timely subject is treated in an essay by J. It. Dodge'of the agricultural de partment.
See moreSee less
on "The Discontent of the Far mer.” The "feature” of this number is an article by Capt. E. 8. Godfrev, one of Gen. Custer’s troop commanders, on the massacre of Little Big Horn, "Custer’s Last Batile.” The Kipling-Balestier very original novel, “The Naulahka” is con tinued, and the second installment is given of Dr. Weir Mitchell's “Characteristic*." Dr. J. M. Buckley, editor of the Christian Advocate, prints a very full and interesting essay on the subject of “Witchcraft” in general, and the Salem witchcraft in par ticular. The Century Company, Union square, New York.
Captain Godfrey disputes the long-accepted theory that Custer attempted to ford the river near the village before being driven back to the ridge. Citing Native American testimony and his own discovery of a cavalry trail in 1876, he argues Custer's column never approached the river or village, staying instead on the high ground leading directly to his final position.
The Indianapolis Journal · 4 January 1892 · page 2
Undertakes to Settle the Ccntrovcrsj. Jannarr Contnrr. ' 'The accepted theory for many vears after the battle, and still persisted in by some writers, was that Custer's column had turned the high bluffs near the river, moved down tho dry (Reno's) creek, and attempted to ford the river near the lowest point of these blulls; that ho was there met by an overpowering force and driven back; that he then divided his battalion, moved down the river with the view of attacking tbe village, but met with such resistance from the enemy posted along the river bank andravines that be was compelled to fall back, fighting, to the position on the ridge.
See moreSee less
The numerous bodies found scat tered between the river and ridge were supposed to be tbe first victims of tbe light. I am now satisfied that these were men who either survived those on the ridge or attempted to escape tho massacre. "Custer's route was as indicated on the map, and his column was never nearer the river or village than his final position on the ridge. The wife of Spotted Horn Hull, when giving me her account of the battle, persisted in saying that Custer's column did not attempt to cross at tbe ford, and appealed to her husband, who supported her statement. On the b.ittle-ueld. in 18feC, Chief Gall indicated Custer's route to me, and it then flashed upon mo that I myself had seen Custer's trail. On June 2?, while wo were burying the dead, I asked Major Heno's permission to go on tho high ridge east or back of tho field to look for tracks of shod horses, to ascertain if some of the command might not have es caped. When I reached the hill I saw this trail, and wondered who conld have made it, but dismissed tho thought that it had been made by Custer's column, because it did not accord with the theory with which we were then filled, that Custer had attempted to cross at the ford, and this trail was too far back, aud showed no indi cation ot leading toward tbe ford. Trump eter Penwell was my orderly and accom panied me. It was a singular coincidence that, in 1SSG. Penwell was stationed at Fort Custer, and was my orderlv when visiting tbe battle-field. Fenwell corroborated my recollection of the trail. The ford theory aroso from the fact that we lound there numerous tracks ot shod horses, but they evidently had been made after tbe Indians had possessed themselves or the cavalry horses, for tbey rode them after capturing them. No bodies of meu or horses were found anywhere near the ford, and these facts are conclusive to my mind that Custer did not go to the ford with any body of men. As soon as (jail had personally confirmed Iron Cedar's report be sent word to. tbe warriors battling against Heno and to the people in the village. The greatest con etenation prevailed among the families, and orders were given for them to leave at once. Before they could do so the great body of warriors had left Keno and has tened to attack Cnster. This explains why Keno was not pushed when so much con fusion at tbe river crossing gave the In dians every opportunity of annihilat ing his command. Not long after tho Indians began to 6bow a strong force In Custer's front, Cnster turned his column to the left, and ad vanced m the direction of tbe village to near a place now marked as a spring, halt ed at the junction of the ravines just below it, and dismounted two troops. Keoglrsand Calhoun's, to fight on foot. These two troops advanced at double-time to a knoll, now marked by Crittenden's monnmont. Tbe other threo troops, mouuted. followed them a short distance in their rear. Tbe led horses remained where tbe troops dismounted. When Keouh and Calhoun got to tho knoll the other troops marched rapidly to tne right; Smith's trooo, deployed as skir misher's, mounted, and took position on a ridge, which, on bmith's lett. ended in Keogh's position (now marked by Crlstcn den's monument), and, on Smith's right, ended at the hill on which Custer took po sition with Yates and Tom Caster's troops, now known as Custer's bill, and marked by the monument erected to the cdmmand. Smith's skirmishers, holding their gray horses, remained in groops of fonrs. "The line occupied by Custer's battalion was the lirst considerable ridge back from the river, tbe nearest point being about half a mile from it. His front was extend ed about thrcefourths of a. mile. Tbe whole village was in full view. A few hun dred yards from his line was another, but lower, ridge, the further slope of whicU was not commanded by his line. It was here that the Indians under Crazy Horse from tbe lower part of the village, among whom were tho Cheyennes, formed for the charge on Custer's hill. All Indians had now left Keno. Gall col lected his warriors, and moved up a ravino south of Keogh and Calhoun. As they were turning this Hank tbey discovered tbe led horses without any other guard than tbe horse-holders. They opened lire upon the horse-holders, and nsed tbe usual devices to stampede the horses that is, yelling, waving blankets, etc.: in this they succeeded very soon, and the .horses were caught up by the squaws. In this disaster Keogh and Calhoun probably lost their reserve am munition, which was carried in the saddle bags. Gall's warriors naw moved to the foot of the knoll held by Calhoun. A largo force dismounted and advanced up the slope far enough to be able to see tho soldiers when standing erect, but were protected when squatting or lying down, liy jumping up and tiring quickly, they ex posed themselves only lor an instant, but drew the lire of tbe soldiers; causing a waste of ammunition. In the mean time Gall was massiDg his mounted warriors under tbe protection of the slope. When everything was in readiness, at a signal from Gall the dis mounted warriers rose, tired, and every In dian gave voice to tbe war-wboor: the mounted Indians put whip to their ponies, and tbe whole mass rushed upon and crushed Calhoun. The maddened mass of Indians Was carried forward by its own momentum over Calhoun and Crittenden down into the depression where Keogh was, with over thirty men, and all was over on that part of the Held. Iu the meantime the same tactics were being pursued and exeeuted around Cus ter7 hill. The warriors, under the leader ship of Crow King, Crazy Horse. Wbite Hull. Hump, and others," moved up tbe ravine west of Custer's Hill, and concen trated under tbo shelter of the ridges on bis right Hank aud back of his position. Gall's bloody work was finished before tbe anni hilation of Custer was accomplished, and bis victorious warriors hurried forward to tbe hot encounter then going on. and tho frightfnl massacre was completed. fcmitb's men had disappeared from tbe ridge, bnt not without leaving enough dead bodies to mark their line. About twentv-eicht bodies of men belonging to this troop and other organizations wero found in one ravine nearer the river. Many corpses wero found scattered over tbe field between Custer's line of defense, the river nnd in tho direction of Keno's MIL. These, doubtless were of men who had attempted to escape; some of them may bavo been aent as couriers by Custer. One of tbe lirst bodies 1 reconized, aud one of tbo nearest to tho ford, was that of Sergeant llutler. of Tom Custer's troop. Sergeant liutlerwasa boldierof many j'ears' exper ienco nnd of known conrage. Tbe indica tions were that he had old his life dearly, for near and under him were found many empty cartridge-shells. All the Iudii accounts that I know of ngreo that there was no organized cloae quartt r lisbting. except on the two flanks; that with tbe annihilation at Custer's hill the battle was virtual!) over. It do-a not ODe&r tbat the Indians made any advance to the attack from the direction of the liver; they did have a defensiveforcealong
An army officer in St. Louis speculates that Gen. Nelson Miles's summons to Washington signals a coming war with Chile, citing his record as a fighting general. The account recalls that after Custer was massacred and Crook failed to subdue Sitting Bull, Miles was sent north and succeeded in capturing Crazy Horse and later Sitting Bull.
The Helena Independent · 4 January 1892 · page 1
MILES AS A FIGHTER.
ually did by defeating them on Aug. 30, 1874, on the Red river. When Custer was massacred, and Crook and the rest of them failed in their efforts to bring Sitting Bull in. Gen. Miles was sent north and suceeededp in capturing Crazy Horse, ooraling Chief Joseph, of the Nez Perces after making a
The article reports a dispute between Gen. James Fry and Rev. Dr. Munger over Munger's funeral-sermon claim that Custer disobeyed Terry's written and verbal orders at Little Bighorn. Munger explains his source was Col. Hughes, who said Terry withheld the truth to protect Custer's reputation after his death.
The Sun · 5 January 1892 · page 1
DID CUSTER DISOBEY ORDERS? Dr. Munger Gives His Authority for the Statement, Which Gen. Fry Denies.
Dr. Muncer Give ill Authority for the Htutement, Which Gen. Fry Menles. New Haven. Jan. 4. An artlclo by Gen. Jamos It. Fry In tho January Century, ontltled " Comments on tlio Cubter Rattle." has caused much talk In this city. Tho artlclo was n de nial of tho declaration made by the Rov. Dr. T. T. MungeratGon. Alfred H. Terry's funoral on Doc. 'JO. 1800. that Gon. Custor's Tato was the result of his rashness and disobedience of orders. Dr. Mungor said: ' Custer's fatal movement wns In dlroct vio lation of both verbal antl written orders.
See moreSee less
When his rashness nnd disobedience ended In tho total destruction of his command, Gon. Terry withhold tho fact of tlio disobeyed or dorsnnd sulTored nn Imputation hurtful to his military reputation to rest upon himself rather than subject a bravo but Indiscreet subordi nate to a charge of disobedience." Dr. Mungor when asked to-day how ho was. led tobpeukot Custer in his luneral soimon, bald: "Prior to tho funeral Col. Hughes, In eon veisatlon nbout Gen. Terry anil his eonnee-' tlon with tlio Ill-fated Indian wars, said that Custer had disobeyed both written und verbal mders. Ho (Hughes) had listened to tho ver bal orders and know what they wero. Oil. Hughes, however, did lint Mute tu mo tho tint hi t) of tho orders. Ho simply said that Custer had dsoboed outers. Col, Hughes said that ho bad sevotal times urgod Gen. Teny to tell the wln.li. stoiy, as it was duo li I in thut tlio whole affair should bocleured up. Toiry rcplli'il that bo did not care to dis close the Inets, ns Ituioulil stand it better than lien. Cui-tnr, who was dead. Col. Hughes sug gested that in my remarks at the funeral I should leferto tho facts. Thatlsthi.reusr.it that 1 did so. Subsequent to tho funeral Mrs. Custer wrote me, asking for my uuthoilty lu snyingth it hor husband had disobeyed orders. 1 replied that my authority wns Col. Hughes, and that If bhe would communicate with him be would undoubtedly furnish her with ull the details. That (sail thoro Is to It so far as I am concerned. My excuse tn referring to tho matter was thu suggestion from Col Hughes. Gon. Terry was a careful soldier, and If Gun. Custer had heeded his oidors. tho terrible massacre would, without doubt have Deen prevented."
At General Terry's funeral, Rev. Theodore Munger claimed Custer disobeyed Terry's orders before the 1876 massacre, and that Terry concealed this to protect Custer's reputation. The report details a subsequent dispute over whether Munger's source, Col. Hughes, actually authorized this accusation.
The Indianapolis Journal · 6 January 1892 · page 1
DID CUSTER DISOBEY ORDERS?
Made at the Funeral of General Terrj. New Havbn; Conn., Jan. 5. In his mem orial sermon at the funeral of Maj.-Gen. Alfred II. Terry, Her. Theodore T. Munger, pastor of the Unity Churcb, this city, ro ferred to the massacre of General Custer's command in June, 1870. He said: "Custer's
A clergyman, Dr. Munger, reveals that Col. Hughes told him before a funeral that Custer had disobeyed Terry's written and verbal orders, though Hughes later denied authorizing the statement. General Terry himself reportedly declined to clarify the matter, saying he could bear the truth better than the dead Custer could.
The Indianapolis Journal · 6 January 1892 · page 1
Custer had disobeyed both written and verbal orders. He had listened to the ver bal orders and know what they were. Col. Hughes, however, did not state to me the nature of the orders. He simply stated that Custer had disobeyed orders. Colcnol Huahes stated that he had several times urged General Terry to tell the story of the all air, as it was due him that the whole af fair should be cleared up. Terry replied tuat he did not care to disclose facts which he. living, could stand better than Gen.
See moreSee less
Custer, who waa dead. Colonel Hughes suggested that in my remarks I should re fer to the statement as it was. That is the reason I did so. That is all there is to it so far us I am concerned. If there is more to tho story it is likely that it will come from the soldiers who know the facts."
The report recounts the death of Comanche, the cavalry horse ridden by Captain Keogh at Little Bighorn, describing him as the only survivor from Custer's side. It retells a dramatized version of the battle's final moments, including Keogh's death and the horse's escape.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The True Northerner · 6 January 1892 · page 7
DEATH OF COMANCHE. The Only Thins: of Custer Command that Came Oat Alive. There died at Fort Itlley, Kan., recently, the most famous horse in the
The report announces the death of Comanche, the cavalry horse that survived Custer's final battle in June 1876, noting he was ridden by Captain Myles Keogh. It recounts a version of the battle in which Custer and Benteen were driven to a ridge awaiting Reno's support before being overwhelmed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Lusk Herald · 7 January 1892 · page 7
DEATH OF COMANCHE. The Only Thins: or Custer's Command that Camo Out Alive. There died at Fort Riley, Kan., recently, the most famous horse in the West In many respects. It was Co manche, the war-horse that was the only thing on Custer’s side that came out of the massacre in June, 1876, alive. Comanche had never been under saddle since, and lived at ease until death by old age, the pet and care of the Seventh Cavalry. He was twenty-five years old, and was visited by sight-seers from far and near dur ing the last years of his life.
See moreSee less
Pro fessor Dyche, of the State University, secured the skin and skeleton for mounting, and will prepare them for exhibition at the world's fair. With Custer was Captain Miles Keogh, who rode Comanche. The horse had been in several battles and could stand fire like a post or run like a mustang. At first the soldiers seemed successful, but then the ter rific fire told on their ranks. Cap tain Benteen and Custer were driven slowly before the great force of the enemy and waited for Reno to attack the rear, but he did not come. Leaving Captain Keogh on a lower ridge, General Custer and his men ascended the crest of the knoll to which they were driven and there made his last stand. Keogh, seeing his men exposed to the fearful rain of bullets, gave the order to the men to kill the horses and take refuge behind their bodies. The order was obeyed. He still rode Comanche—and here there Is a variance as to the manner in which the escape of the animal oc curred. Some Indians say he broke
The article reports the death of Comanche, the horse that survived Custer's last stand in 1876, and recounts legendary versions of the battle including how the horse escaped. It describes Captain Keogh allegedly freeing Comanche by striking him and driving him away rather than the horse being found wounded among the dead.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Mitchell Capital · 8 January 1892 · page 3
/J DEATH OF COMANCHE. The Only Thing: of Cuater^ Command tliat Came Out Alive. There died at Fort Riley, Kan., recently, the most famous horse in the West in many respects. It was Co manche, the war-horse that was the only thing on Custer's side that came out of the massacre in June, 1876, alive. Comanche had never been under saddle since, and lived at ease until death by old age, the pet and care of the Seventh Cavalry. He was twenty-live years old. and was visited by sight-seers from far and near dur ing the last years of his life. Pro fessor Dyche, of the State University, secured the skin and skeleton for mounting, and will prepare them for exhibition at the world's fair. With Custer was Captain Miles
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands
The article reports the death of Comanche, the cavalry horse famed as the sole survivor of Custer's 1876 massacre, recounting how he was found wounded on the battlefield and spared from euthanasia out of soldiers' affection, then lived out his years pampered at Fort Riley. It also profiles two other legendary war horses, Sheridan's Rienzi and Lee's Traveler, as part of a nostalgic retrospective on famous military mounts.
The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 9 January 1892 · page 6
FOUR LEGGED VETERANS. THREE HORSES THAT KNEW THE BATTLEFIELD AND LOVED IT. Recent Death of Keogh's Comanche, Sole Survivor of the Custer Massacre. Sheridan's Famous Rienzi and General Lee's Traveler.
COMANCHE. caped the dreadful Custer massacre of June, 1876. Evidently the Indians had stripped and left him to die, for he was found by Reno's men standing in the water and gazing mournfully over the field of slain. Every man and every other horse was killed, and as the horses fell the men made breastworks of them. Captain Keob, Comanche's rider, was among the slain. An order was issued that the badly wounded horse should be shot to put him nut of his misery, but the sol diers irrieved so deeply that the farriers exhausted their skill and Comanche was saved.
See moreSee less
Thereafter no man ever backed him. He lived at Fort Riley. Kan., in "horse heaven," if such there be, fed with the choicest food, groomed with loving care, patted and petted and solaced with lumps of sugar and the sweetest f apples. lie was part of the original mount of the Seventh Cavalry in ISC)'), had carried Captain Keogh and others through many an Tndian fight and was literally striped and splotched with wounds.
The Century Magazine publishes an article by Capt. Godfrey of the 7th Cavalry, a Reno fight survivor, offering a new theory on Custer's actions at Little Bighorn. Godfrey argues Custer's column never approached the river or village but moved directly to the ridge position, contradicting the long-accepted theory that Custer attempted a river crossing before being driven back.
The Citizen · 9 January 1892 · page 5
NEW LIGHT ON CUSTER
* See Macbeth. SEW LIOHT ON ODtjTEB. Oapfc. Godfrey’s Btrlktug and Picturesque Article In the “OsBtury” Magazine, The Century Magazine tor January is one of the most attractive numbers of that great periodical ever published. An ar ticle that will attract more attention than any among the many able ones that ap pear in this month’s issue, is one by Capt. Godfrey, of the 7th cavalry, splendidly illustrated, who took part in Iieno’s fight at the Little B'g Hornjand who helped at the burial of the dead of Custer's com mand two days later.
See moreSee less
His theory of the Custer disaster is essentially different from those already advanced, and will serve to throw new light on the greatest tragedy recorded in the history of our Indian wars. Capt Godfrey, after dealicg with the preliminaries of Custer’s move ment, the march down the Rosebud, etc., says: "The accepted theory for many years after the battle, and still persisted in by some writers, was that Custer’s column had turned the high bluffs near the river, moved down the dry (Reno’s) creek, and attempted to ford the river near the lowest point of these bluffs; that he was there met by an overpowering force and driven back; that he then divided his battalion, moved down the river with the hope of attacking the village, but met with such resistance from the enemy posted along the river tank and ravines that he was compelled to fall back, fighting, to the position on the ridge. The numerous bodies found scattered between the river and ridge were supposed to be the first victims of the fight. I am now satisfied that these were men who either survived those on the ridge or attempted to escape the massacre. "Custer’s route was as Indicated on the map In the Century, and his column was never nearer the river or village than his final position on the ridge. The wife of Spotted Horn Bull, when giving me her account of the battle, persisted in saying that Custer’s column did not attempt to cross tt the ford and appealed to her hus band, who supported her statement. "On the battlefield, to 1886, Chief Gall Indicated Custer’s route to me and It then flaahed upon me that 1 myself had seen Custer’s trail. On June 38, while we were burying the dead, I asked Major Reno’s permission to go on the high ridge east or back of the field to look for tracks of shod horses to ascertain if some of the command might have escaped. When I reached the ridge I saw this trail, and wondered who could have made it, but dismissed the thought that it had been made by Custer’s
The report describes the tactics used by Gall, Crazy Horse, Crow King and other warriors to overwhelm Calhoun's and Keogh's positions before converging on Custer's Hill. It notes the discovery of soldiers' bodies, including Sergeant Butler, and states Indian accounts agree the battle was essentially decided once Custer's Hill fell, with no organized fighting elsewhere except on the flanks.
to the people la the Tillage. The greatest consternation prevailed among the famll tea, and orders were given for them to leave at once. Before the; coaid do so the great bod; of warriors had left Reno and hastened to attack Custer. This explains wh; Reno was not poshed when so mach confusion at the river crossing gave the Indians every opnertunit; ot annihilating hfs command Rot long after the Indiana began to show a strong force In Caster's front, Caster turned his column to the left, and advanced In the direction of the vil lage to near a place new marked as a spring, hailed at the junction of the ra vines just below It, and dismounted two troops.
See moreSee less
Keogh’s and Calhoun’s, to fight on foot. These two troops advanced at double, time to a knoll, now marked b; Crltten den’s monument. Tbeother three troops, mounted, followed them a short distance In the rear. The led horaes remains d where the troops dismounted. When Keogh and Calhoun vot to the knoll the other troops marched rapidly to the right; Smith'a troop deployed aa skirmishers, mounted, and took poaltlon on a ridge which, on Smlth’a left, ended In Keogh’s poaltlon (now marked by Crlttenden'a monument), aDd on Smlth’a right ended on the hill on watch Cuater took poaltlon with Yatea’ and Tom Cueter’a troepa, now known ae Cuater’a Hl.l, and marked by the mouu ment erected to the command. Smith’a aklrmiahera, holding their gray horaee, remained In groupa ot fours. “The line occupied by Cueter’a battalion waa the drat conelderable ridge back from the river, the neareat point being about half a mile from It. Hie front waa ex tended about three fourtha of a mile. The whole village waa In lull view. A few hundred yarda from hia line waa another but lower ridge, the further slope of which waa not commanded by hla line. It waa here that the Indiana under Crazy Horae, from the lower part of the village, among whom were the Cheyennea, formed for the charge on Cuater’a Hill. All Indiana had now left Reno. Oall collected hia warriota and n. ived up a ravine couth of Keogh and Calhoua. Aa they were turning thia fl'-nk they dlacovered the led horaea without any other guard tban the horse holdera. They opened Are upon the horae holdera and uaed the uanal devices to stampede the Dorses—mat is, yelling, waving Diauaeis, etc.; In this they succeeded very soon, and the horses were caught by the squaws. In this disaster Keogh and Calhoun probably lost their reserve ammunition, which was carried In the saddlebags. Gall’s warriors now moved to the foet of the knoll held by Calhoun. A large force dismounted and advanced up the slope far enough to be able to Bee the soldiers when standing erect, but were protected when squatting or lying doWD. By jumping up and firing quickly they exposed tbemBelves only for an Instant, but drew the fire of the soldiers, causing a waste of ammunition. In the meantime Gall was massing his mounted warriors under the protection of the slope. When everything was In readiness, at a slgual from Gall the dismounted warriors rose, fired, and every Indian gave voice to the war whoop; the mounted warriors put whip to their ponies and the whole man rushed upon and crushed Calhoun. The maddened mass of Indians was carried forward by lie own momentum over Cal houn and Crittenden down into the de pression where Keogh was, with over thirty men, and all was over on that part of the field. "In the meantime the same tactics were being pursued and executed around Custer’s Hill. The warriors, under the leadership of Crow King, Crazy Horae, White Bull, ‘Hump’ and others, moved up the ravine west of Custer’s Hill and con centrated under the shelter of the ridges on his right 11 ink and back of his position. Gall’s bloody work was finished before the annihilation of Custer was accomplished, and his victorious warriors hurried for ward to the hot encounter now going on, and the frightful massacre was com pleted. Smith’s men had disappeared from the ridge, but not without leaving enough dead bodies to mark their line. About twenty-eight bodies of men belonging to this troop and other organizations were found in one ravine nearer the river. Hanv corpses were found scattered over the field between Custer’s line of defense, the river, and in the direction of Reno’s Hill. These, doubtless, were of men who had attempted to escape; some of them may have been sent as couriers by Custer. One of the first bodies I recogn'zed, and one of the nearest to the ford, was that of Sergeant Butler, of Tom Custer’s troop. Sergeant Butler was a soldier of many years’ experience, and of known courage. The indications were that he had sold his life dearly, for near aud nnder him were found many empty cartridge shells. All tne Indian accounts mat l know ol agree that there wai no organized close quarters fighting, except on the two flanks; that with the annihilation at Custer's Hill the battle was virtually over. It does not ap pear that the Indiana made any advance to the attack from the direction of the river; they did have a defense force along the river and In the ravines, which destroyed those who left Custer’s line. “There was a great deal of firing going on over the field after the battle by the young men and beys riding about and shooting Into the dead bodies. ■lap hast Faratfaa of Anelaat Oaf a. It *u In the processions end pageants that elephanta made the finest appearance, fitted with magnificent trapping), and marching slowly along, aa II conacloua of their fine looks. One of the moat remark able ahowi waa that at the wedding of Viatar All, In 1796. Here twelve hnndred elephanta were In line, all richly coalumed. Of theee one hnndred had howdahe, or cutlea, covered with ailver, while in the centre aat the nabob upon a very large elephant whoae howdah waa covered with gold aet with lewela. The daily parade of the elephanta of the court of Jehanghlr waa a wonderful dis play. The elephanta were bedecked with precious atones, chains of gold and silver, gilt banners and fl age. The first elephant, called the lord elephant, had the plates of his head and breast aet with rubles and emeralds, and as he passed the king he turned, dropped upon his knees and trumpeted loudly—not in loyal frame of mind exactly, but because the driver pricked him with a sharp prod just at the right time. Silly per p>, however, believed that the elephant was showing respect for the king. Today the elephant is still used In India In pageants, as a laborer, especially in the lumber districts, where it is taught to carry long timbers, and, as has been said, forms a corps In the British army; but in active warfare it is now useful only In a few cases, and can never t e employed so frr quently as In ancient times — Charles Frederick Bolder, t'n January St NicKoUu.
An obituary for Mrs. Ann Timothy Daggett in Jacksonville recounts her family history, including a son, Albion Howe, a West Point graduate said to have been killed during 'Custer's charge' in the Modoc massacre at the lava beds. This conflates Custer with the 1872-73 Modoc War, an event he was not part of.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning News · 11 January 1892 · page 1
THE STAR SPRANGLED BANNER. Khe was also a cousin to Fran is Key, the author of the “Star Spangled Banner.” Mr. Turnbull *as an indigo planter who first brought the Minorcans to thie stato as slaves. Mrs. Daggettl’s familv moved to St. Augustine when she was’ a child and there she lived until she was 15 years of age, at which time sho was mar riep to Col. A. P. Howe of the United States army. To them were born two children, Albion and Lucieo. The former became a graduate of VVo.,t Point and was killed during Custer’s charge at the lava beds in the great Modoc massacre.
See moreSee less
Dr. Lueien Howe is a cilebrated specialist of Buffalo, N. Y., and widely known as a philanthropist. Her siooad marriage was in 18G6.
The January issue of Century magazine will feature an article by Capt. E. S. Godfrey, one of Custer's troop commanders, presenting a new theory about Custer's movements at the Little Bighorn based on his own experience and information from the attacking chiefs. The article will be followed by a critical review of the campaign by Gen. James B. Fry.
Hopkinsville Kentuckian · 12 January 1892 · page 2
A portrait of Gounod, the od French composer, forms tho frontispiece of the January Century, and along with the portrait is n charming paper of remiuiscenoe of the early life oEtkeimteioiau.Ilisuxperioucons a stu dent of musio in Home and his later acquaintance with Mondslssohu nro delightfully narrated. This paper by Gounod is one of a musical series whioh will make the Century especially Bttractiro to lovers of music during the coming year. "The "feature" of thU numbar ia an article by Capt. E. S. Godfrey, ono of General Custer's troop cammauders, on the massacre of the Little Big Horn, "CustwV Last BtUe."
See moreSee less
CaptJ Godfrey advauces n new and conclusive theory with regard to Gen. Customs movements, which is based upon his own at the tinio, aud also upon information derived directly from the chiefs who lod tho attack. Capt. Godfrey's article is followed by a critical review of tho ovents of tho
A minister's funeral sermon for Gen. Terry claimed Custer's destruction resulted from disobeying orders, which Terry supposedly covered up to protect Custer's reputation. The minister's authority for this claim, Col. Hughes, later denied authorizing the statement, sparking a published dispute.
The Hocking Sentinel · 14 January 1892 · page 1
In u'-s memorial sermon at tho funoral ot Maj.-Gen. Alfred H. Terry, Uev. Theo dore T. Munger, pastor of the United church, of New Haven, Ct, referred to tbo massacre of Gee Cuslor's command in Juno, IS70. Ho said: '"Custer's fatal movement was in direct violation of both verbal aud written orders. When his rashness and disobadicnce sudod in the --total destruction of his command. Gen. Terry withheld tka fact of the disobeyed ord-rs and uffarcd as iu.putatiou hurtful to h 5 onu military refutation ra-her than tubject a bravo but indiscreet subordinate to a charge of dlsouedience" Iu the
A review of the January Century magazine highlights Capt. E. S. Godfrey's article 'Custer's Last Battle,' which proposes a new theory of Custer's movements based on his own knowledge and accounts from the attacking chiefs. The piece is followed by a critical review of the campaign by Gen. James B. Fry.
Grant County Herald · 14 January 1892 · page 4
CENTURY.
General Custer’s troop commanders, on the massacre of the Little Big Horn, “Custer's Last Battle ” Capt. Godfrey advances a new and conclusive theory with regard to Gen. Custer's move ments. which is based upon his own knowledge at the time, and also upon information derived directly from the chiefs who led the attack. Capt. God frey’s article is followed by a critical re view of the events of the campaign by
A newspaper notice describes the upcoming Century Magazine issue, highlighting Capt. E. S. Godfrey's article on the Little Bighorn massacre, which offers a new theory on Custer's movements based on his own knowledge and accounts from the attacking chiefs. The notice also mentions other magazine contents including pieces on Gounod, Jewish life in New York, and farmer discontent.
The Willimantic Journal · 15 January 1892 · page 2
Custer’s troop commanders, on the mas sacre of Little Big Horn, “Custer’s Last Battle.” Capt. Godfrey advances a new and conclusive theory with regard to Gen. Custer’s movements, which is based upon his own knowledge at the time, and also upon information derived directly from the chiefs who led the attack. Capt. Godfrey’s artiole is followed by a critical review of the events of the campaign by Gen. James Daniel Ruggles of Fredericksburg, Va., gives public notice that he patented in July, 1880, a method of creating artificial rainfalls, by sending into the clouds tor pedoes and cartridges, whose explosion would liberate gases, and thus produce expansion, and consequent cold.
A newspaper recounts a controversy sparked by Rev. Munger's funeral sermon for Gen. Terry, in which Munger claimed Custer disobeyed written and verbal orders before his 1876 defeat. Col. Hughes and journalist James B. Fry dispute the accuracy and authorization of Munger's claim, with Munger clarifying what Hughes actually told him.
Brookings Register · 15 January 1892 · page 6
Did Custer Disobey.
In his memorial sermon at the fune ral of Maj. Gen. Alfred H. Terry, Rev. Theodore T. Munger, pastor of the United church, of New Haven, Conn , referred to the massacre of Gen Cus ter’s command in June, 1876. He said: ‘‘Custer’s fatal movement was in di
Rev. Dr. Munger explains that his inflammatory remarks at a soldier's funeral, alleging Custer disobeyed orders, were based on a conversation with Col. R.P. Hughes, Gen. Terry's brother-in-law and aide. Hughes confirms he was the source of the information but denies authorizing Munger's public statement, while Munger recounts that Terry himself had declined to clear up the controversy while alive.
Brookings Register · 15 January 1892 · page 6
Rev. Dr. Munger speaking of Gen. Fry’s criticism, said: “Prior to the funeral Col. Hughes, in conversation about Gen. Terry and of his connection with the ill-fated In dian wars, said that Custer had dis obeyed both written and verbal or ders. He (Hughes) had listened to the verbal orders and knew what they were. Col. Hughes, however, did not state to me the nature of t he orders. He simply stated that Custer Had disobey ed orders. Col. Hughes stated that he had several times urged Gen. Terry to tell the whole story of the affair, as it was due him that the whole affair should be cleared up.
See moreSee less
Terry replied that Le did not care so disclose the facts, as he, living, could stand it bet t*r than Gen. Custer, who was dead. Col. Hughes suggested that in my re marks I should refer to the statement as it was. This is the reason I did so. That is all there is to it, so far as I am concerned. If there is more to the story it is likely that it will come from the soldiers who know the facts.”
A Century Magazine piece reprinted in 1892 reviews past Indian wars—including the Modoc War, Nez Perce War, Little Bighorn, and Ute campaign—as cautionary examples of American troops underestimating Native forces. It cites Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn as a case of overestimating one's own strength and underrating the enemy.
Howard Times · 16 January 1892 · page 3
The Little Big Horn fight in 1876, where Gen. Custer and most of his command were massacred, was surely the result of overestimating one’s strength and under rating that of the enemy. Other examples can be furnished, but are not these, with attendant losses and fail ures, sufficient to prove that with the In dian as a foe we must always be prepared and especially careful when he seems most friendly and still hold on to his rifle? On the other hand, many instances are known where troops bhave met and over come at the start more serious obstacles than those mentioned above, and without a shot being fired. A column on the march
The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis · and 1 other paper
A cavalry officer recounts revisiting the Little Bighorn battlefield years later with Native witnesses like Chief Gall and Spotted Horn Bull's wife, concluding that Custer never reached the river ford as long assumed. He argues the shod-horse tracks near the ford were made by Indians riding captured cavalry horses, not by Custer's column, and that Custer's actual route stayed higher on the ridge.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 20 January 1892 · page 10
10 TARIFF THE ISSUE. It Cannot Be Obscured or Belittled. VoorheesTakes Issue With Governor Hill. NO TIME FOR QUIBBLING. The Party's Path Clearly Indi cated And It Cannot Afford to Deviate
Capt. Godfrey, a troop commander under Custer, publishes a detailed account in Century magazine disputing the long-accepted theory that Custer tried to ford the river and was driven back before retreating to the ridge. He argues, based on Indian testimony including that of Spotted Horn Bull's wife and Chief Gall, that Custer's column never reached the river or village at all.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 20 January 1892 · page 10
CUSTER'S LAST BATTLE. THE TRUE THEORY OF THAT VERY GREAT FIGHT.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
A participant reconstructs Custer's final movements, arguing the absence of bodies near the ford disproves any crossing attempt, and attributes the lack of pressure on Reno to Gall's sudden recall of warriors. The piece details troop positions—Keogh, Calhoun, Smith, Yates, and Tom Custer—along the ridge later marked by monuments.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 20 January 1892 · page 10
GREAT FIGHT.
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D. · and 1 other paper
A preacher's published sermon uses the Custer massacre as an illustration of divine judgment on pride and lack of faith. He speculates that if Custer's subordinate officers had fought aggressively toward him instead of defensively, the general and his men might have been saved.
The Mitchell Capital · 22 January 1892 · page 3
WHAT THE LESSON TEACHES
For mine own sake and for my servant David's sake. There are two of us, let me not forget it I must always act for Qod when I act for m-fplt I cannot do for my self alone. Wo have, many of us, been re reading in the periodical press the details of tho fearful Custer massacre. What was the occasion of it? Underestimate of num bers, no doubt an impetuosity all toe courageous, perhaps. And yet if* taking the risk of battle, Custer's lieutenant and his men had kept themselves on the ag
Crawford Avalanche · Grayling, Mich. · 21 January 1892
The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.
This is a review of periodicals including the January Century magazine, which features Captain E. S. Godfrey's article 'Custer's Last Battle' on the Little Big Horn massacre. The review notes that Godfrey, one of Custer's troop commanders, advances a new theory regarding Custer's movements during the battle.
The Record-Union · 23 January 1892 · page 5
musician. The first of the series on "The Jews in New York," by the Rev. Dr. Wheatley. An essay by J. R. Dodgo, of the Agricultural Department, on "Tim | Discontent of the Farmer." The "l.> ,t --j ure" of this number is an article by Cap tain E. S. Godfrey, ouo of General Cus ter's troop commanders, on the massacre I of the Little Big Horn, "Cutter's Last I Battle." Captain Godfrey advances s new and conclusive theory with regard to General Custer's movements. Dr. J. M.
This is a publisher's advertisement for John Finerty's book 'Warpath and Bivouac,' compiling glowing newspaper reviews praising its accuracy and thrilling depictions of frontier campaigns against the Sioux. It includes pricing and ordering information alongside unrelated classified ads for health remedies.
The Citizen · 23 January 1892 · page 2
INTBBBSTING FROM START TO FINISH. [Chicago Morning Newt.] “Mr. Finerty’s book contains all the material facts of a history of the opera tions against the Sioux, but It is written in a narrative style and is interesting from start to finish. His descriptions of the Rosebud fight, the “Sibley Scout,” the engagement at Slim Buttes, and his story of the long march in pursuit of the Indians after the Custer massacre, have never been equaled.” INTKBKSTLNG AS FKNIMORB OOOFBR.
This article, published 16 years after the battle, reflects on how the Little Bighorn massacre made a lasting impression on the public mind despite the passage of time. It discusses how the remoteness of the event led to a mix of credible testimony and fiction, noting that truth is gradually emerging through slow efforts to extract facts from Indian witnesses.
New-York Tribune · 24 January 1892 · page 6
THE FATE AND FAME OF CUSTER. The massacre of General Custer and his hattalion on the Little Big Horn, June 25, 1X76, made an impression upon the popular mind which time has not succeeded in effacing, It was so swift and unexpected, «0 complete and so unrecompensed that no special gift of foresight was required for the prediction that it would have a permanent place in the record of National tragedies. If the event had not heen intringically significant and memorable by reason of its sombre and melancholy character professional discussion of the military questions which it sugaested would have kept its features familiar to this day. During the sixteen yeas that have elapsed since Custer’s last battle countless
The article reflects on how fact and fiction about the Little Bighorn massacre have gradually separated over time, with Indian testimony being slow and difficult to extract. It highlights Captain Godfrey's Century magazine article as an authoritative source examining Custer's discipline, growing apprehension, and the question of his obedience to orders before the battle.
New-York Tribune · 24 January 1892 · page 6
The military questions which it involves do not touch the valor and devotion of General Custer, Beyond all possibility of dispute or suspicion he possessed those qualities in an eminent degree, But his reputation for judgment and even for obedience has been brought into the controversy, though net, we think, malevolently. For the purpose of restoring what his fame has lost in that particular, and for preserving it intact hereafter, no other contribution to the history of the expedition and the massacre is more useful than the article by Captain E.
See moreSee less
8. Godfrey and the comments by General James B. Fry in the January * Century.” Captain Godfrey was one of General Custer's troop commanders in the battle, and for that and other reasons he writes with authority. A large, and not the least interesting, part of his narrative is deveted to the most revolting inhumanity. This surgeon re. fused repeatedly to take to the hospital a man who was plainly suffering frightful agony from severe injuries, because] the surgeon said, it was a case of “alcoholism.” The unfortunate wretch died afterward in Bellevue Hospital. An ambulance surgeon who could be guilty of the atrocious cruelty which is alleged in this case ought to be dismissed from the hospital service withous delay. > 2
This piece rebuts claims that Custer disobeyed General Terry's orders before Little Bighorn, arguing no superseding orders were ever produced. It also attributes Custer's defeat to a broader military miscalculation about Indian troop strength, not personal fault.
New-York Tribune · 24 January 1892 · page 6
NEW-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE, organization of the forces and the incidents of the march. He shows that the discipline was effective, that the troops were well Jooked after, and that their temper was excellent. But he indicates also that as the expedition proceeded a sense of care amounting, in the case at least of General Custer, to apprehension became per vasive and conspicuous. This seems 10 have heen the atmosphere of the camp on June 22, when General Custer was ordered to advance with the 7th Cavalry* up the Rosebud River in pursuit of the Indians, whose trail had been found by Major Reno a few days before.
See moreSee less
At this peint began General Custer's independent responsibility, so far as his orders left him independent. At this point, therefore, comes in the question of his chedience. It has heen chareed that he disregarded his instructions. No! a little popular effect has heen produced by the declaration of a clergyman at the funeral services of General Terry that his fatal mevement was in direct violation of both oral and written orders, and that General {I'erry had magnanimously concealed that fact. As General Fry points out, this is not only a grave charge against General Custer, but also an impntation against the soldierly character of General Terry. If he gave his subordinate orders which were dissheyed those orders should be on record. Where are they ? They have been called for, but they have never heen produced. Did General Terry neglect his duty by suppressing them? The only orders in evidence are the undisputed written orders given to General Custer on June 22, “to proceed up the Rosebud.” They set forth General Terry's “views,” to which he desired General Custer to conform, unless he saw ** sufficient reason for departing from them.” As (ienaral Fry remarks, he certainly obeyed the order to proceed up the Rosebud, * and everything alse was left to his discretion.” Where and fwhen were thesa recorded orders of June 22 superseded by the “orders” the “direct violation” of which was fatal to General Custer and his men?“ Nowhere and never” is the only answer which the evidence justifies, The charge of disobedience falls to the ground. The military judgment of General Custer has also been impugned. Indisputably the calenlations upon which he proceeded were erroneous, but that is not the heart of the question. The whole campaign was hased upon a misconeeptien for which no single individual was responsible. ‘I'he number of Indian warriors in the field was greatly underestimated. The strength of the avowed “ hostiles™ was taken as a measure of the difficulty of the problem. It was not known that they had been heavily reinforced by ardent fighters who had slipped away from the agencies, though General sheridan had received and forwarded too late some suggestive information on that point. It was supposed hy Gieneral Terry that Custer’'s 600 troopers would be con-
The article reports the death of Comanche, the cavalry horse found wounded after the Little Bighorn massacre, at Fort Riley at age forty-five. It recounts his history as Capt. Keogh's mount, his survival of the battle, and plans to stuff and display his hide at the Chicago World's Fair.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Daily Independent · 25 January 1892 · page 1
A FAMOUS WAR HORSE.
Ilo was forty-five years of age and the j only living thing belonging to the ; United States service which escaped the j massacre at (he battle of the Little Dig llom, where Gen. Custer and his com mand were massacred, lie was one of the original mount of the Seventh cavalry, which regiment was organized in lt>GM, ana linu oeen in aunost every battle in tac Indian service. After the battle of Little Big Horn he was found covered with wounds, rider less end saddlclcss, some distance from the scene of the massacre, lie was taken charge of by Capt.
See moreSee less
Itowlan and sent to Fort Riley, where for fourteen years lie had not been subject to bridle, and had been in charge of the Seventh cavalry. II is death was due to old age. His skin will be stulFod and mounted and kept in the museum of the Kansas state university until the world's fair at Chicago, where it will be taken for ex hibition. Enterprising showmen have from time to . time endeavored to sccuro Comanche lor exhibition purposes, but the authorities have invariably refused to disturb his well-earned rest. Com nnche was the horse of Cupt. Kcogh, a relative of Gen. Custer. Special provision was mode for the care and support of Comanche. Once in awhile, when the cavalry troops were on inspection, Coinanehc was led out, saddled and bridled, but no one ever sat in his saddle after the battle, of the Little Big Horn. it will be remembered that Custer's ill-fated command uacd the dead iKxlics of their horses killed by the shower of Indian bullets as a barricade as far ns possible. All the horses were saddled, as the troop had ridden into the valley and atUicked the Sioux camp, and, as Comanche was found stripped of hia accoutrements, it has always been sup posed that his saddlo and bridle were taken by the victorious Indians, who, believing that he would die of his wounds, turned liira loose. The body of every oilier horse that carried tlio brave cavalry into battle on that futc ful morning was found among tho heaps of tho slain soldiers. Aettllng Dny in Pennsylvania. Lancaster county, Pa., lias a custom that prevails perhaps nowhere else in the United btatcs. "Settling day" in that county falls upon April 1, and on that day thousands of country folks gather at Lancaster, tho county seat. Bargains arc mode, contracts ore cn terod into, debts nrc paid and new ones arc contracted. If a man contracts n debt at any timo during the year the undcrstartding Is, in the absence of spocifle agreement, that payment shall bo made on settling day. A similar custom prevails in parts of China, but tho Luncaster countians probably took their settling day from German an cestors. No C'liance for Railroads. It is almost impossible to find on the peninsula of Delaware and Maryland a point ten miles from navigable tide water. The whole region is eut up by navigable streams, and in the lower part of the peninsula small shipyards arc found in many villages, nnd, indeed, of ton clear outside of villago limits, 'rhcre are many good shipwrights throughout the rogion, and for nearly two hundred years much of the produce has been carried in vessels built within a few miles of where it was grown. Henry Villari) is quoted as having expressed a belief "that nil trniqsof the Northern Pacific will, before long, be operated entirely by electric power."
A Century magazine article by Capt. Godfrey, a troop commander under Custer, revises the long-accepted theory that Custer's column reached the river and village before being driven back. Based on his own observations and testimony from Native witnesses including Chief Gaul, Godfrey argues Custer never got closer to the river than his final ridge position.
The Somerset Herald · 27 January 1892 · page 1
Custer's Last Battle. The January Century contains t profase ly illustrated description of "Custer's Last Battle," by CapL Godfrey, the com mander of a troop under Custer. From it we quote the following : The accepted theory for many years after the battle, and still persisted in by some writers, was that Custer's coin tun had turned the high bluff near the river, moved down the dry ( Reno's creek, and attempted to ford the river near the low est point of these bloffs ; that he was met there by an overpowering force and driv en back ;that he then divided his bat'al lion, moved down the river with a view of attacking the vil'aae, but met with such resistance from the enemy posted along the river back and ravines that he was compelled to fall back, fighting, to the position on the ridge.
See moreSee less
The numerous bodies found scattered between the river and ridge were supposed to be the first victims of the fight. I am now satisied that these were men who either survived those on the ridge cr attempted to escape the massacre. "Custer's route was as indicated on the
A veteran revisits the Little Bighorn battlefield evidence years later, describing how he traced shod-horse tracks and consulted Indian witnesses like Gall and Spotted Horn Bull's wife to conclude Custer never reached the river ford. He argues the ford tracks were made later by Indians riding captured cavalry horses, and explains that Gall's warriors left Reno to join the attack on Custer once his force appeared threatening.
The Somerset Herald · 27 January 1892 · page 1
Bull, when giving me her account of the battle, persisted in saying that Cu-ter's col am n did not attempt to cross at the ford, and appealed to her husband, who supported her statement. Oa the battle field, in ISS'1, Chief Gaul indicated Cus ter's rotite to me, and it then SaVtiel upon me that I myseif had seen Custera' trail. On June 2ih, while we were bury ing the dead, I asked Major loco's per mission to go on the high ri le east or back of the field to look fjr tracks of shod horses to ascertain if sotne cf the command might not have escaped, and when I reached the ride I saw thia trail and wandered who could have mad-s it, but dismissed the thought that it had been made by Custer's column, became
This detailed account reconstructs troop movements during Custer's final battle, describing how Keogh and Calhoun's companies dismounted near a knoll while Smith's troops formed a skirmish line, with Custer's own position marked by monument. It details how Gall's warriors outflanked the soldiers' horse-holders, stampeding the mounts and cutting off reserve ammunition, while Crazy Horse's forces prepared to charge from a lower ridge.
The Somerset Herald · 27 January 1892 · page 1
Smith's troops deployed as skirmishers, mounted, and took pwitioa oa a ri ls which, on Smith's left, en led in Keogh's position 'now marked by Critter.. '.en's monument , and, on Smith's right, ended at the hill oa which Caster to)s: pjsltijn j with Yates and Tom Cesser's troopx, now I known as Custer'slliil. and '.marked by the monument erected to the command. Smith's skirmishers, holding their gray horses, remained in groups of fours. "The line occupied by Caster's littal ion was tte first c:nsi ierablc ridg back from the river: the nearest point being about half a niiie front it.
See moreSee less
His t'ont was extended abottt three fourths of a mile. The whole village was ia fill view. A few hundred yards from his line was an other, hut lower ri.lge, the farther slope of which w as not commanded by his line and it was here that thi In liacs, under Crazy Horse, from the lower p-irt of the village, among whom were the Cheyennes, firmed for the charge on Custer's
A January Century article by Capt. Godfrey, a troop commander under Custer, offers a new theory of the battle, disputing the long-accepted idea that Custer's column reached the river and ford before being driven back. Godfrey argues Custer never got closer than his final ridge position, citing Native accounts and his own observation of tracks.
The National Tribune · 28 January 1892 · page 12
ON LITTLE BIG HORN.
ing to doalh in southorn Idaho. Tho Winter lias not been equaled iu severity uiuco 1670, tho position ou tho ridgo. The numerous bod ies found scattored between tho river and ridge woro supposed to be the first victims of the fight. I am now satisfied that these wore men who cither survived those on tho ridgo or at tempted to escape tho massacre. "Custer's routo, as indicated on tho map, and his column was never nearer the river or villago thau his final position on tho ridge. The wife of Spotted Horn Bull, when giving mo hur account of the battle, persisted in saying that Cu-1tei' column did not attempt to tro-vS at the ford, and appealed to her husband, who supported her statement.
An officer recounts how Indian witnesses like Gall and Spotted Horn Bull's wife corrected the mistaken 'ford theory' of Custer's approach. He describes finding a shod-horse trail on a ridge during burial details that he later realized was Custer's actual path, far from the river ford.
The National Tribune · 28 January 1892 · page 12
ON LITTLE BIG HORN.
Iron Cedar's roport ho sent word to tho war riors battling against Reno, and to the people in tho village. Tho greatest consternation prevailed among the families, aud orders wcro given for them to leavo at once. Before they could do so the great body of warriors had left Itcno aud hastened to attack Custer. Thig ex plains why Reno was not pushed when so much coufusion at the river crossing gave the Indians overy opportunity of annihilatinghis command. Not long aftor the Indians began to show a strong force in Custer's front.
See moreSee less
Cu3tor turned his column to the loft, and advanced in tho direction of tho village to near a place now marked as a spring, halted at the junction of tho ravines just below it, and dismounted two troops, Keogh' and Calhoun's, to fight on foot. These two troops advanced at double-time to
The report reconstructs the movements of Custer's battalion at Little Bighorn, describing how Keogh and Calhoun's troops dismounted near a knoll while Smith's and Custer's troops took positions on ridges overlooking the village. It details how Gall's warriors stampeded the horse holders and used tactical movements to exploit weaknesses in the soldiers' defensive positions before the final assault by Crazy Horse's forces.
The National Tribune · 28 January 1892 · page 12
"The lino occupied by Custer's battalion was the first coii3idcrab!o ridgo back from the river, tbo nearest point being about half a mile from it. His front was exteuded about three fourths of a mile. Tho wholo village wa3 in full view. A few hundred yards from his lino was another but lower ridge, tho further slope of which was not commanded by his line. It was horo that tho Indians under Crazy Horse from tho lower part of tho village, among whom wero tho Clieyonnos, formed for the chargo on
This item compiles glowing newspaper reviews of John F. Finerty's book 'War path and Bivouac,' which recounts the 1876 Sioux campaign including the Custer massacre. Multiple publications praise the book's vivid, firsthand narrative style, comparing it favorably to works by Washington Irving.
The Citizen · 30 January 1892 · page 2
K0 NEW CHAPTER CAN BE ADDED, f Biemarck tribune. 1 Even those familiar with the history of the Custer massacre will read with fresh interest the graphic details leading up j to that terrible slaughter, as related { by the Timet correspondent, Mr. Fin ' «rty, and now offered to the public ' In the volume with the above title. ! The campaign of 1879, on the British | line, which embraces Gen. Miles' battle i with Chief Joseph; Sitting Bull’s last ( light, and the rounding up of that expedi I tion, which might be considered ss a ter 1 mination ot Indian warfare, forms an in | terewlng part of the volume and it may , safely be asserted that no new materia!
See moreSee less
I will ever be furnished that can add an other chapter of like interest to the hia | lory of progress on this continent in sup planting barbarism with oiviliiatlOB.
This is a publisher's advertisement compiling newspaper blurbs praising John Finerty's book 'Warpath and Bivouac,' which covers military operations against the Sioux including the Rosebud fight, Slim Buttes, and the pursuit after the Custer massacre. The ad lists glowing reviews from various papers alongside the book's price and ordering information.
The Citizen · 30 January 1892 · page 2
IMTSBKSTnfO FROM START TO FIHI8K. ICTleaflo Moraine If cum.] “Mr. Finerty’s book contains all the material facts of a history of the opera tions against the Biouz, but it ia written in a narrative style and is interesting from start to finish. His descriptions of the Rosebud fight, the “Sibley Bcout," the engagement at Blim Buttes, and hie story ol the long march in pursuit of the Indians after the Custer mass acre, have never been equaled.”