A newspaper reports that the only known white survivor of the Custer massacre, Wake Evans, is being committed to an insane asylum in Indianapolis. The account claims he escaped the battle, was later found insane in Washington, briefly recovered, then relapsed into madness, with his history otherwise a mystery.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Indianapolis Journal · 2 September 1890 · page 1
Corydon, Ind., Sept. 1. The only known white survivor of tho Custer massacre will bo taken from this county te the Insane Asylum at Indianapolis this week. His name is Wake Evans, and his age is about forty five years. His relatives knew that be was with Custer and supposed that he had been killed, but two or throe years later he was, by accident, found in an in sane hospital at Washington city. His reason had been partially restored, and he related many incidents of the great Custer battle, but could not tell where he had been since the fight or how he came to be in the asylum.
See moreSee less
He was brought to his home in this coun ty, where he remained a short time, when he mysteriously disappeared and nothing was heard from him for several years, un til he came home about a year ago, appar ently sane and in excellent health. He re fused to eay whero he had been or what he had baen doing, and tho matter is yet a great mystery. His reason again began to totter and is now completely dethroned. Very little can be learned of his history, but it is known beyond doubt that he was with Custer; that he made his escape, and that his insanity was produced by fright in that great battle. Report of Attempted Train-Wrecking Denied. Albany, N. Y., Sept, 1. It looks as if the story of an attempt to wreck the east bound Chicago express near Karner's on Saturday morning was not founded on facts. John Bosch, a reputable citizen of this city, made a statement to-night which tends to show that no obstruction was
The report describes Wade Evans, said to be the only known survivor of Custer's command at the Little Bighorn, now being sent to an insane asylum in Indianapolis. It recounts his mysterious history of disappearances, temporary sanity, and recurring insanity supposedly caused by the trauma of the battle.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Pittsburg Dispatch · 3 September 1890 · page 6
Indianapolis, September 2. The only known snrvlvor of the band that followed Custer into Sitting Bull's village will be brought from Harrison county, Ind., to the insane asylum in this city to-day. His name is "Wade Evans, and he Is aged about 45 years. His relatives knew that he was with Custer and snpposed tbat he bad been killed, but three years later he was bv accident found in an insane hospital at "Washington. D. C. His reason had been Dartially restored, and he related many incidents of the great massacre, bnt could sot tell where he had been since the fight or how he came to oe in the asylum.
See moreSee less
He was brought to his home in Harrison county, where be remained a short time, when be suddenly disappeared, and nothing was heard of him again until about a year ago, wben he came home apparently sane and in excellent health. He refused to say where he had been or what he had been doing, and the matter Is still a great mystery. A few months ago bis reason again began to totter and is now completely dethroned. Very little can be learned of his history, but it is known beyond doubt that he was with Custer, that he made his escape, and tbat his insanity was produced by fright in the terrible massacre.
A Northern Pacific architect recounts how a Hudson Bay Company factor bought a silver watch from a Sioux in 1880, taken from a soldier killed with Custer. Tracing the watch's serial number to its Liverpool maker revealed it had been sold to General Sturgis, leading to inquiries at the War Department to locate him.
Spokane Falls Review · 4 September 1890 · page 11
CUSTER'S LAST FIGHT.
The presence here of Mrs. General Custer has called from Mr. B. C. Konway, formerly of Winnipeg, but now one of the supervising archi teeth of the Northern Pacific Rall roud, who also happens to he in town. an interesting story connected with tho massacre of (loneral Custer and his hrnvo comrade» at the battle of the Little Big Horn,June 2'), mm. in 1880 Mr. Konwny was at the town of Portage In Prairie, about sixty miles West of \Vlnnlpeg, and happening one day to be in the store of the Hudson May Company nt that plneo, he saw three Sioux Indians come in to make some pur chases.
See moreSee less
One of them oil‘orecl to sell Mr. It}. I“. (llgot, the factor of tho Hudson llay Company at Portage la Prairie, a silver watch. Mr. Uigot’s ourionlty being amused he asked the Indian where he had ob tained the watch. Ho laid ho had taken it "cm the body of a man killed in the tight with Custer four years before. i Mr. Uigot discredited the story, but
A jeweler named Gigot traces a watch bought from an Indian back through its Liverpool maker to General Sturgis, whose son Lieutenant "Jack" Sturgis died at Custer's battle with his body never recovered. The piece also quotes Captain Charles King's recent magazine article on Custer's Last Battle describing Sturgis and Lieutenant Harrington as the only two slain soldiers never identified among the dead.
Spokane Falls Review · 4 September 1890 · page 11
CUSTER'S LAST FIGHT
ion of the Seventh regiment oiflL-era. (.‘a tain Cimrieu King has aumlnilr abijy written article in the August number of HILI'IK‘I'II magazine on “Custer’a Last l attle" in which he areal“ of young margin. Here in t io extract: ”Koo h, Calhoun, Crittenden
A report from Indianapolis describes Wake Evans, said to be the only survivor of the soldiers who rode with Custer into Sitting Bull's village, being committed to an insane asylum. His family believed him dead until he was found years later in a Washington hospital, and his history since the battle remains a mystery.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 4 September 1890 · page 1
Crazed While With Custer. Indianapolis, Sept. 3.—The only known survivor of the band that followed Custer into Sitting Bull’s village will be brought from Harrison county, Indiana, to the insane asylum in this city tomorrow. His name is Wake Evans, and he is aged about 45 years. His relatives knew that he was with Custer and supposed that he had been killed, but »hree years later he was by accident found in an insane hos pital at Washington* His reason had been partially restored and he related many incidents of the great massacre, but could not tell where he had been since the fight, or how he came to be in the asylum.
See moreSee less
He was brought to his home in Harrison County, where ho remained a short time, when he suddenly disappeared and noth ing was beard of him again until about a year ago, when he came back apparently sane and in excellent health. He refused to say where he had been or what he had been doing, and the matter is still a mystery. A few months ago his reason again left him. Very little can be learned <>f his history, but is known beyond doubt that he was with Custer, that he m*de bis escape, and that his insanity was produced by (right io the terrible mas sacre. August Weather. As the old lady said, “most any kind of weather i< better than none at all.” In last mouth there were 12 cloudless, 12 partly cloudy and only 7 dark days, so there was plenty of good weather. Ruin fell 14 days during August, and Observer Slaughter records the total pre cipitation, as 3.18 inches, greater than for any corresponding month in the history of the signal office. It was quite breezy, the wind move ment. aside from campaign work, being 6,643 miles. The extreme velocity was 37 miles an hour on the 2d inst. The average temperature was 64.2 de grees, a trifle less than usual for August. The highest was 84 degrees on tho 6th, I and lowest 39 on the 26th. A Brilliant Young Lawyer. [Sundance Gazette.] Henry 8. Elliott, tho brilliant young attorney of Buffalo, was here a day or two this week, getting acquainted with some ot our people. Mr. Elliott is spok en of by bis admirers as “the best lawyer in Northern Wyoming.” He certainly has marked ability else he could not have so successfully filled the jiosition of county attorney of Johnson county, which he is now serving for the third term. And he also must be exceedingly popular iu bis own homo, for at the last election his name was put upon both the Republican and Democratic tickets. He is the only one of the six candidates for supreme judge who comes from the North, and he should receive a hearty support in this section of country, as we are sure he will in Sheridan and Johnson counties, where he has lived for eight years. Cheaper School Books. The undersigned takes pleasure in an nouncing that he has just completed ar rangements that will enable him to sell the school books mostly used in Chey enne, Wyo., at the following rates: New National First Readerso.2s ” Second “ 40 Third 55 ” Fourth “ 75 ” ” Fifth ” l.(X) Barnes’ History of the United States 1.25 Davis’ Practical Arithmetic7s Barnes’ Primary Geography6s “ Complete “ 1.50 Harper’s Copy 800k 10
This is a compilation of press reviews praising John Finerty's book about the 1876 Sioux campaign, including his firsthand accounts of the Rosebud battle and Sibley scout. The reviews note that Custer's final battle could not be fully described since no white witness survived to report it.
The Citizen · 6 September 1890 · page 5
A VERY READABLE AND COMMENDABLE BOOK
marked by equal bravery and humanity —virtues which had often to be exercised under very trying circumstances. The author, sharing in these good qualities, and having with them the effervescent spirit of his Irish temperament, and the ready pen of the practiced newspaper correspondent, was wall qualified to be the historian of such a con filet. His style, if occasionally careless and some times luxuriant in expression, Is always ani mated and graphic. In such a war there can be no non combatants, and the author was often In dang! r, and once, when en trapped with a scouting party, in extreme peril.
See moreSee less
Tho general movements of the troops, the marches, encampments and battles are well narrated. We learn all that Is likely to be known ot poor Custer’s last combat, which no white witness sur vlved to report. * * « Fortunately for himself and bis readers, Mr. Flnerty has escaped these varied dangers to give the public his very readable and com mendable book.
The report says Col. Allison, credited with persuading Sitting Bull to return from Canada after the Custer massacre, has been converted at a camp meeting and is now preaching among the Sioux. It notes hundreds of Indians are converting and many are traveling to a camp meeting at Sisseton agency.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Evening Star · 11 September 1890 · page 1
SCOUT ALLISON'S GOOD WORK.
PiEanr., S.D., Sept. 11.?Two weeks ago Col. Allison, the government scout, who induccd old Hitting Bull to return from Canada and surrender after the Custer massacre years ago. became converted At a camp meeting in Pierre, since which time he has been preaching among the Sioux, and the result is that hundreds of the Indians are becoming converted. Some two hundred families of these new converts from interior parts of the reservation have started for Sisseton agency, in the eastern part of the state, -00 miles distant, to attend an In dian camp meeting. Col. Allison rcinaius with the reservation Indians and if bis health permits will continue to preach and teach the more savage and backward tribes.
A newspaper personal-notes column reports that Wade Evans, described as the only known survivor of the Custer massacre, has gone insane. The item appears amid unrelated society and celebrity gossip items.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning News · 11 September 1890 · page 4
PERSONAL. Senator Rioolebeeger's widow is now editor of a Virginia paper. W ade Evaes, the oaly known survivor of the Custer massacre, is insane. It is noted by the cottagers at Crasson that Mrs Ha-rison dresses plain, even to severity. Keely, tbe motor man. has just completed his Std year. The motor is not yet completed. Miss Mary Lee, Gen. R. E. Lee's youngest j daughter, is said to never to forget a name or a face.
Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 2 other papers
Captain Charles King's narrative, reprinted from Harper's Magazine, describes Custer's cavalry being overwhelmed by Sioux warriors after being cut off at the river ford. It depicts the retreat to high ground, the skirmish line, and the final rally where Custer and his remaining officers died within minutes.
Iron County Register · 11 September 1890 · page 7
GENERAL CUSTER'S END.
Boys and squaws were shooting from the willows ("Oh, we had plenty guns!" said our story-tellers); and worse than that, hundreds of young warriors had mounted their ponies and swarmed across the stream below him, hundreds more were following and cir cling all about him. And then it was that Custer, the hero of a hundred dar ing charges, seems to have realized that ho must cut his way out. "Mount!" rang the trumpets, and leaving many a poor fellow on the ground, the troop ers ran for their horses. Instantly from lodge and willow Ogalallas and Brules sprang to horse and rushed to the ford in mad pursuit "Make for the heights!"
See moreSee less
must have been the order, for the first rush was eastward; then more to the left, as they found their progress barred. Then, as they reached higher ' ground, all they could see, far as they could see, circling, swooping, yelling like demons, and all the time keeping up their furious fire, were thousands of the mounted Sioux. Hemmed in, cut off, dropping fast from their saddles, Custer's men saw that retreat was im possible. They sprang to the ground, "turned their horses loose," said the Indians, and by that time half their number had fallen. A skirmish line was thrown out down the slope, and there they dropped at five yards' inter val; there their comrades found them two days after. Every instant the foe rode closer and gained in num bers; every instant some poor fellow bit the dust At last, on a mound that stands at the northern end of a little ridge, Custer, with Cook, Yates and gallant "Brother Tom," and some dozen soldiers, all that were left by this time, gathered in the last rally. They sold their lives dearly, brave fellows that they were; but they were as a dozen to the leaves of the forest at the end of twenty minutes, and in less than twenty-five all was over. Captain
Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · 24 September 1890
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 25 September 1890
Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo.
This 1890 account narrates Custer's final battle at Little Bighorn, describing how he misjudged the size of the Indian village and found himself surrounded by thousands of warriors. It depicts his men dismounting to fight, being overwhelmed by gunfire from the village, and ultimately attempting a desperate escape on horseback.
Iron County Register · 11 September 1890 · page 7
GENERAL CUSTER'S END. A Gallant Straggle Against the Stoat Un even Odds. Never realizing, as I believe, the fearful olds against him, believing that he would find tho village "on the run," and that between himself and Reno .he could "double them up" in short order, Custer had jauntily trotted
This 1890 account by Captain Charles King describes Sitting Bull's sun-dance trance eleven days before Little Bighorn, in which he predicted a Sioux victory over attacking soldiers. It then narrates the battle's opening, including Reno's surprise attack and Sitting Bull allegedly fleeing west on his pony with his family as the fighting began.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Sioux County Journal · 11 September 1890 · page 3
SHUtf 1 on s not the Inspiration ftJM graft txtory woo by the Sioux. I'ti tm IKia llm. K .... i -I-: I r --- w hi uw ir cwiun Mi ww chief. Eleven days before tb flght Uwr was a "sun-dance." II is own people have since told ui these particu bus, and Um best story-taller among thorn was that bright-faced aqua w of T-tonkahc-gie-ska -Spotted Horn HuU 'who aeeompni5i the party on their titern trip. She ia own cousin to Sitting Bull, and knows whereof she tpeaka. The chief had a trance and vision, writes Captain Charlea King in Harper's Magazine.
See moreSee less
Solemnly he as snred his people that within a few days they would be attacked by a vast force of white soldiers, but that the Sioux should triumph over litem; and when tlie Crows and Crook's command ap peared on the l"th it was a partial re demption of bis prom is. Wary scouts saw Heiio'scolumn turn ing back down the Bosehud after discov ering tlie trail, and nothing, they judged, would eome from that quarter. All around Crook's camp on (loose Creek the indications were that the "Gray Fox" was limply waiting for more soldiers be fore he would again venture forth. Sit ting Bull had no thought of a hew at tack for days to come, when, early on the morning of the 25th, two Cheyenne Indians who bad started east ard at dawn came dashing back to the bluffs, and waving their blankets, signalled. ''White soldiers heaps coming quick." Instantly all was uproar and confusion. Of course women and children had to be hurried away, the great herds of ponies gathered in, and the warriors as sett bled to meet tlie coming foe. Even as the chiefs were hastening to the council lodge there came a crash , of rapid volleys from the south. It was Iteno's attack an attack from a new and utterly unexpected quarter and this, with the news thut Long Hair was thundering down the ravine across the stream, was too much for Sitting BulL Hurriedly gathering bis household about him, he lashed his pony to the top of his speed, and tied westward for safety. Miles he galloped before he dare stop for breath. Behind him he could hear the roar of battle, and on he would have sped but for the sud den discovery that one of his twin chil dren was missing. Turning, he was sur prised to find the Sring dying away soon ceasing altogether. In half an hour more he managed to get back to camp, where the missing child was found, but the battle had been won without him. Without him the Black feet and Un. capapas had repelled Beno and penned him on the bluffs. Without him the Ogalallas, Brule, and Cheyennes had turned back Custer's daring assault, then rushed forth and completed the death gipping circle in which he was held. Again had Crazy Horse been foremost in the fray, riding in and braining the bewildered soldiers with his heavy war club. Fully had his vision been rea lized but Sitting Bull was not there. For a long time it was claimed for him by certain sycopbantic followers that from the council lodge he directed Um battle; but it would not da When the old sinner was finally starred out of her majesty's territory, and came in to accept the terms accorded him, even his own people could not keep straight faces when questioned as to the cause of the odd names given those twins 'The-One That-W as-Taken" and "The-One-That-as-Left." Finally it all leaked out, and now "none so poor as to do him reverence." Of course it was his rule to assume all the airs of a conqueror, to be insol ent and defiant to the "High Jointcom missiori," sent the following winter to beg him to come home and be good; , but the claims of Tatonka-e-Yotanka
Among a list of obituary notices, the item states that Wade Evans, described as the only known survivor of the Custer massacre, is insane. No further detail or corroboration is given.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.
Wrong
Asheville Daily Citizen · 11 September 1890 · page 4
OBITUARY.
OHITUAKY. Richard Bcnbury Saunders, of Durham, is dead, in the "7th year of his age. Cap tain Sniindcr was well known through out the State. Died, in Winston, in the (tilth year of hit age, Maj. Hamilton Smirs. Mat. Scales wits born in the county of Rock ingham, in January 1821, where he re sided up to the commencement of the war. Wadb Evans, the only known survivor of the Custer massacre, is insane.
A government scout named Colonel Allison, who had previously persuaded Sitting Bull to leave Canada and surrender after the Custer massacre, was converted at a camp-meeting and has since been preaching among the Sioux. Hundreds of Indians are reportedly converting, with some traveling to attend a camp-meeting at the Sisseton agency.
The Indianapolis Journal · 12 September 1890 · page 5
Indians Converted by a Preacher Scout. Pierre, S. D., Sept. 11. Two weeks ago Colonel Allison, the government scout who induced old Sitting Bull to return from Canada and surrender after the Custer massacre, years ago, became converted at a camp-meeting in Pierre, since which time he has been preachingamongthe Sioux. and tho result is that hundreds of tho Indians aro becoming converted. Some two hun dred families of these new converts from interior parts of the reservation have started for the Sizeton agency, in the east ern part of the State, 200 miles distant, to attend an Indian camp-meeting. Colonel Allison remains with the reservation In dians, and, if his health permits, will con tinue to preach and teach with tho more savage and backward tribes.
This 1890 account narrates Custer's approach to the Sioux village, describing his overconfidence and belief he could easily overwhelm the camp alongside Reno. It details how his force was ambushed by overwhelming numbers of warriors from the village, forcing him to dismount and fight a losing battle.
Iowa County Democrat · 12 September 1890 · page 4
Thp Heath of (ieneral Custer, Never realizing, as I believe, the fear ful odds against him. believing that he wouldjfind the village "on the run." and that between himself and Reno he could "double them up" in short order, Custer had jauntily trotted down to his death, it
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · and 1 other paper
A literary reprint from Harper's Magazine recounts Custer's final moments at the Little Bighorn, describing his troops being overwhelmed by Sioux warriors, forced to dismount, and making a last stand on a ridge with Cook, Yates, and his brother Tom. The dramatic narrative ends with all of Custer's remaining men killed within about twenty-five minutes.
Iowa County Democrat · 12 September 1890 · page 4
Eursnit. ‘‘Make for the heights!” mast ave been the order, for the first rush was eastward: then more to the left, as they found their progress barred. Then, as they could see. circling, swooping, like demons, and all the time keeping up their furious fire, were tl ousands of the mounted Sioux. Hemmed in. cut off. dropping fast from their saddles. Custer's men saw that retreat was impossible. They sprang to the ground. •'turned their horses loose,” said the Indians and by that time half their number had fallen. A skirmish line was thrown oat down the slope, and there they dropped at five yards' interval; there their comrades found them two days after.
See moreSee less
Every instant the foe rode closer and gained in numbers: every instant some poor fellow bit the dustAt last on a mound that stands at the northern end of a little ridge, Custer, with Cook. Yates, and gallant ‘'Brother Tom.” and some dozen soldiers, all that were left by this time, gathered in the last rally. They sold their lives dearly, brave fellows that they were; bat they were as a dozen to the leaves of the forest at the end of twenty minutes, and in less than twenty five—all was over.—From "Custer's last Battle,” by Capt. Charles King, in Harper’s Magazine.
St. Johnsbury Caledonian · St. Johnsbury, Vt. · 7 August 1890
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
Colonel Allison, the government scout who persuaded Sitting Bull to return from Canada and surrender after the Custer massacre, has been converted at a camp meeting in Pierre, South Dakota. He is now preaching among the Sioux, resulting in hundreds of Indian conversions.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 12 September 1890 · page 1
A bauquet was g;vfjn and last night a camp fire and firo works. flyjotu'l Alllaou In a Now Hole, ?ro P/CKUW, 8. J}., ?3pU 11.?Tffo weekt ago Colonel Allison, tho Government ll?* scout who induced C'l Sitting Bull tc 119 return from Canada and surreuder after retho Custer maseacru years ago, becamc ;B8 converted at a camp moating in Pierre i since which time he has been prejjcbjuj " , among among tho Sioux, and tho result
General Nelson Miles arrives to investigate current Cheyenne troubles, noting he once led explorations against Indians after the Custer massacre. He attributes the unrest to insufficient food rations leading Cheyennes to kill cattle, and suggests the government compensate ranchers.
The Helena Independent · 17 September 1890 · page 1
GOR. MILES. The Indian Fighter Lookingla Into the Chey enne Troubles. rmIS CrrY, Sept. 16.--[Special.]-Gen. Wilson A. Miles, after whom this city is named, and who conducted the early ex plorations against the Indians in this sec tion of the country immediately after the the Custer massacre, arrived from San Frencisco by special car to-day. His car
The column reports that Comanche, the horse ridden by Col. Keogh at the Little Bighorn and one of the few survivors of the Custer massacre, is living out his days at Fort Riley, Kansas. The item notes he is well cared for and enjoying a comfortable retirement.
PERSONAL*. 4 *Gail Hamilton.” Abigail Dodge, conducts “a Bible talk ' every Sunday afternoon at Sec retary Blaine**. Jives K. Merrieield. republican candidate for riilroad commissioner in Missouri, is a pas senger conductor on the Missouri Pacific rad road. Rexol. the grandfather of Benjamin Con stant, the great piint*r, died at M>nnonie, France, on Aug. \ He was a noted French man. Prince Albert Victor is the only son of a prince of Wales who has liken his seat in the House of Lords before his father's accession to the throne.
See moreSee less
M. deGarat. the French champion of woman's rights, recently tried successfully to have his daughter, 43 years ol 1, declared incompetent to manage her own affai r The Church in Boston in which Edward Everett Hale entred apon his fir*t pastorate, and in which Bishop Huntingdon began his career as a preacher in that city, is about to be demolished. An association ha? been formed at Troy. N. Y.. to raise a sum of $15,000 for a monument to Emma Willard < 1787-I**o . in honor of her ser vices to the cause of the higher education among women. By the will of the lnte Mr? Frances Brow nell Holland of Hartfor J. Conn., the sum of $10),000 is devised to the pr posed Episcopal cathedral of New York city. Mrs. Holland was a daugnter of Bishop Brow nail. Comanche, the old wir hors? ridden by Col. Keogh in the battle of the Little Big Horn, and who was one of the two survivors of the Custer massicre.isan honored pensioner at Fort Riley. Kansas, ami is spending nis old age in ease aiid comfort. Mlle. Louise Gautier, a young lady who was born deaf aid dumb, but taightbythe Grosselin system, was able to go through suc cessfully ail tbe examination*—bote written and oral—of the N itu*nal Scho > of Fine Arts, at Paris, has been appointed teacher of design In that in institution. Dr. Charles A. Strong, who has recently bee.i appointed docent in psychology at Clark University, ig a graduate of Rochester Unuer sity, class of 'B4. and of Harvard, class or 'BS. He spent two yea r s at the Rochester Theological Seminary and one at the Berlin University, and was instructor in philosophy at Cornell. Tiie Rsv. Dr. Joseph E. King, who has been the principal of Fort Edward Collegiate Insti tute at Fort Edward, N. Y., for over a third of a century, a teach *r for a Ion? time, has had over sixteen thou and young men and womeu under his instruction. H * was graduated from Wesleyan University in the sanu class with Bishop Andrews, and, although 86 years old, is in vigorous health. The statue of Horace Greeley, which has just been fi dshed by J. Q. A. Ward for the New York Tribune building, will be unveiled on thcSOtb. It is to stand iu front of the long window on tne groun ! floor to the left a* one faces the building. Tne is of polished granite. The position is very bad for any statue against so much reflecting glass, and it fs a wonder to the art world why Mr Re *d places it there. If it bad been placed in the great doorway leading up to the offices it would have given dignity to a great work.
The article speculates wildly that Sitting Bull is actually a white fugitive named McLain, possibly educated by Jesuits in Canada, explaining his knowledge of English and French and his military tactics against Custer and Crook. It claims this would resolve the 'mystery' of Sitting Bull's identity and his uncanny ability to anticipate U.S. troop movements.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Telegram-Herald · 19 September 1890 · page 5
.t- , -tt ... t i,-:.-s u-i i 1 - 1,-11 i j a ;au;Ji;: j t-iiici. ti.'i w.a n cater at an, true niw erroneous mis is must appear from consideration of hia prcat campaigns in tho last fifteen yean. Vro Custer tilive ho v.-culd not sav Sittin Bull was a me licino chief. Custer fot!nd to his cost that Sitting Bull knew the art of vnr. Crook learned the samo thin. Th.ra h?j always been a mystery abotit Sitting Bull, and 1 believo if it could bo clearivl up he would bo found t0 i no:io other than mr oU friend Me-
This dramatic account recounts Custer's approach to the Sioux village, describing his hope of a quick charge turning into a desperate defensive stand as warriors poured fire from the riverbank. It details his dismounting under attack, being surrounded by hundreds of mounted warriors, and the final order to remount as his men fell around him.
The Port Gibson Reveille · 19 September 1890 · page 4
H* government. Any other course would Ik* at once unjust and cow ardly.— SI. Ltui* Hepnblic. Th« Death of 0«n. Cuater. f N r V . cr ns I believe, the fearful odds against him; believi mg that he would find the villag«: "on Ihe run," and that between himself am! Reno he could "double them 25 4 order Custer had jannt tr °ttcd down to bis death It was n long livc-milc ride from where he sighted the northern end of the village to where he struck its centre nroum that Indd point of Muff, and from the start to the moment his guidons whirled into view, and his rimpcrs came galloping "front into line down near the ford, he never burly saw the great village - never dreamed of j U depth and extent.
An 1890 reprint from Capt. Charles King's account in Harper's Magazine describes Custer's cavalry surrounded by thousands of Sioux warriors, forced to dismount and fight on foot as casualties mounted. The narrative culminates in Custer's last stand on a small ridge with a handful of men, overwhelmed within twenty-five minutes.
The Port Gibson Reveille · 19 September 1890 · page 4
and liiere they dropped at VC yards' interval ; there their com rnik-s found tlien* two days after. Kverv instant th« foe rode closer and gained in numbers: every in stant some poor fellow bit the dust. At last, on a mound that stand* at the northern end ot a little ridge, Custer with Cook, Yates, and gal lant "brother Toni," and some dosen soldiers, all that were left sold their lives dearly, brave fel lows that they were; hut they were as a dozen to the leaves of the forent at the end of twenty minutes, and in less than twenty-five—all was over. —From "C ustcr'n hmf Hnlltr" hy hy Copt. Vhnrtns h'i»ff, in Harper* Muyuz'nr for A nanti
A serialized fiction piece describes a girl delivering birthday party invitations, including to the Hillman children. Backstory reveals their father was a soldier who died in the Custer massacre, leaving the family to find work.
Emmons County Record · 19 September 1890 · page 4
MY BIRTHDAY PARTY
And now, before I proceed further with my story, Kt toe tell what little I know of tbe Hillman family. Mrs. Hi)lman had come to Bonville only four months before the opening of my story. Her husband liad been a soldier and had lost his life ifi the Custer massacre. Mrs. Hillman was
The Fremont Clipper · Lander, Wyo. · and 1 other paper
A brief 1890 item reports that Colonel Allison, the government scout credited with persuading Sitting Bull to return from Canada and surrender after the 1876 Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn, has since become a Christian convert and is now preaching among the Sioux. It notes hundreds of Indians are reportedly being converted under his exhortations.
The Fremont Clipper · 19 September 1890 · page 1
Natural Gas in lowa. Des Moines, Sept. B.—Great excite ment has been caused In this city by the discovery of natural gas. Monday last John 11. West, a colored man,was engaged in boring a well on the farm of J. L. Door located in section 23, Crocker township The well was down about 35 feet, the last live being through rock. At this point a How of gas was struck,which poured forth with great violence. It was ignited and ighted up the whole country around that neighborhood. Tho well Is but four miles from the Des Moines corporation line, and if gas holds out arrangements will be made for confining and utilizing it.
See moreSee less
Colonel Allison, the government scout, who induced old Sitting Bull to re turn from Canada and surrender after the Custer massacre on the Big Horn River in b 76, became eon verted two weeks ago al camp meeting in Pierre, and has been preaching among the Sioux, and bun <rods of Indians are being converted under bis exhortings. If his health permits Colonel Allison will remain with the reservation Indians and continue to preach. A new fine has been raised on the cottage at Mount McGregor, where Gen eral Grant died
The Rawlins Republican · Rawlins, Wyo. · 19 September 1890
The Citizen · Chicago, Ill.
This passage collects newspaper and magazine reviews of John F. Finerty's book recounting his experiences as a war correspondent during the 1876 Sioux war, including the Custer and Crook campaigns. Reviewers from Scotland and the US praise its vivid, firsthand narrative style, with General Crook cast as hero and Custer as martyr.
The Citizen · 20 September 1890 · page 5
rated. REVIEWED BY THE SCOTCH. [Edinboro (Scotland) Scotsman.] "Mr. Finerty’s narrative reads like a romance of Fenlmore Cooper or of Mayne Raid; but it has also the im press of true history. General Crook is the chief hero of these battles and marches, night watches and surprises, among the wild scenery of the ‘Bad Lands,’ or on the wide stage of the prai. rte; and General Custer is the chief mar tyr. The ‘red man’ also deserves hiB meed ot praise as a fighter; and in our century there have been few such formtd able Indian figures as that of Bitting Bull.
See moreSee less
He may be said to have been the last of the great war chiefs able to oppose for a season by craft and courage the march of the white man; for although there have been and wtii be, desultory ngntiog tow ards the Mexican frontier, these Apache raids do nat attain the dignity of Indian warfare The episode of the last Bioux war had touches of romantic and dramatic interest to its close.”
The piece profiles marksman Adam Bogardus, noting his European shooting tour and famous buffalo-killing feats. It mentions he will impersonate Custer in a staged reenactment of the Little Big Horn battle during the Forepaugh "Wild West" show's upcoming Cumberland appearance.
Frostburg Mining Journal · 20 September 1890 · page 3
paugh-“Wild West” show, which appears in Cumberland Saturday, Sent. 27. ) Jn addition to •riyinj' exhibitions of j their amazing skill with firearms, both afoot and on horseback, Bojrardus impersonates the gallant Custer (and to the life, it is said) in the mimic representation of the Little Big Horn battle. Brevities. The two Macs, but not MeCaig and | MeKotnas.
This is a promotional advertisement for Adam Forepaugh's Wild West circus show coming to Cumberland on September 27, featuring a staged reenactment called 'Custer's Last Rally' along with other attractions like trick riding and a Mountain Meadow Massacre reenactment. The ad promotes general circus spectacle rather than reporting historical facts about the actual battle.
Frostburg Mining Journal · 20 September 1890 · page 3
ADAM FOREPAUGH'S GREAT ALL-FEATURE SHOW WILD WEST COMBINED
Wild West Exhibition! The Great Custer Battle! The Mountain Meadow Massacre, AND SHERIDAN’S FAMOUS RIDE ADAM FOREPATJGH, jr., The Illustrious Chief of all Arenic Stars, will
The Philadelphia Record retells a story from a Boston naturalist who rode with the Seventh Cavalry, describing how General Custer steered his horse around a meadow lark's nest during a march, with the entire column following his detour. The anecdote is presented among miscellaneous trivia items in a newspaper feature column.
The Indianapolis Journal · 21 September 1890 · page 11
Xo house Is now considered stylish with out a yellow room., the wall-naper, and draperies and upholster' all to harmonize, Philadelphia Record though in different shades, and the fur niture usually in white enamel. who accompanied the Seventh Cavalry on one of its marches. HeBaid that Goneral Custer riding at the head of the column seeing tho nest of a meadow lark with its young in the grass guided his horse around it and resumed the straight course again without a word. The whole command of many hundred cavalrymen made the same detour, each detachment coming up to the place where the preceding horsemen had turned out. and looking down into tbe nest to And tbe reason for the unusual de parture from the straight line of march.
The Texas State Fair announces new attractions including a lifelike cyclorama depicting the last moments of General Custer at Little Big Horn, alongside a painting of the Battle of Gettysburg. Other fair preparations include livestock entries, cannon salutes for dignitaries, and plans for a grand opening day with a major horse race.
Fort Worth Daily Gazette · 22 September 1890 · page 2
THE STATE FAIR Out at the fair grounds everything is progressing smoothly and rapidly and each day witnesses the signing of new contracts for the securance of fresh at tractions Among the latest and most important that have been arranged for is the lifelike tihantographa of the last moments of Gen Custer at the Little Big Horn and the battle of Gettysburg on canvas which latter a tine piece of re alistic art requires a bulldlug 200 feet In diameter for its proper presentation The parties who last year showed tho Fall of Paris at Oak Cliff to such ad miring crowds have entered into agree ment to exhibit in the fair grounds the Beige aud Storming of the Alamo which it said to be on a grander scale than tho Kail of Paris and will
This dramatic account describes Custer riding confidently toward what he believed was a fleeing village, only to discover its massive size and be overwhelmed by warriors. It narrates his attempt to dismount and fight, then remount and cut his way out as his forces were surrounded.
Mower County Transcript · 24 September 1890 · page 6
GENERAL CUSTER'8 END* A Gallant Struggle Agnlnut the Mo»t Un even Odds. -St,"' 'gi Never realizing, as I believe, the fearful odds against him. believing that he would find the village "on the run," and that botween himself and Reno bo oould "double them up" in short ordor, Custer had jauntily trotted
An advertisement for Adam Forepaugh's circus and Wild West show promotes a reenactment called 'Custer's Last Rally' alongside other spectacles like the Mountain Meadow Massacre and Sheridan's Ride. The show features cowboys, 'Sioux Indians,' trick riders, and sharpshooters, scheduled to appear in Gallipolis and Charleston.
The Weekly Register · 24 September 1890 · page 3
FOREPAUGH SHOW, With its Quarter of a Century of Glorions History, Limitless Capital, Vast and Varied Arenic. Zoological and Hippodn>niatic Resources, and now Tre mendously Reinforced with the Renowned, Romantic and RealUtic Wild West Exhibition?The Great Custer Bat tle?The Mountain Meadow Massacre-?and Sheridan's Famous Ride! ADAM FOREPAUGH, JR., Th? Illustrious Chief of all Arenic Stars, will appear in his Paring and Un paralleled Act of Riding and Driving 40 Fiery Thoroughbreds ait Breakneck Speed, bte will also present for the first time here, the Reason Gifted Equine Gymnast, 'Eclipse" together with all of his Famous and Self-Created Animal Sensations! COLLOSSAL 3 RING CIRCUS ! The Peerletw Paris Hippodrome, And tho Most Tremendous Menagerie Ever Exhibited Under Tonts! ??P?wa Crtl?sal Triple ClreiiH, 4>Pa?a Mlarlllng Nlnxc KenNallonx, 4-Pmwm ClIorloiiM Hippodrome Itnri'K,
A brief filler item reports that Wade Evans, described as the only known survivor of the Custer massacre, has gone insane. No further detail or context is given.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
The Marietta Journal · 25 September 1890 · page 3
fi'atitude bound to tell you how the icrobe Killer has benefited me. For several years past I have been a great sufferer from indigestion and chronic diarrheea and general ner vous prostration. After having taken two jugs of Wm. Radam’s Mi crobe Killer I find myself restored to health in my nerves and diges tion, and can eat vegetables without suftering any trouble. I most earn estly recommend it to all sufferers in that line as the best remedy 1 have ever found, and will testify the same to any one who wishes to hear more from me, as I have lived here in this town ten years and have a very extensive acquaintance.
See moreSee less
Hop ing all' may be benefited by this truly wonderful remedy, I lemain yours truly, Wu. M. CoGHILL. For sale by H M [Hammett. e — Wape Evaxns, the .only known survivor of the Custer massacre, is insane. B@F™ BLACK-DRAUGHT tea cures Constipation Miss Mary Lee, Gen. R. E. Lee’s youngest daughter, is said to never forget a name or face. Sparta Ishmaelite: Tom Nor wood has concluded to renew his citizenship of Georgia until after the Senatorial election. “filE_th?jp[ing_-Vtinu~" comes m as a tr)ni::;‘FE.;~s<;¢,.n.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan. · and 1 other paper
Gen. Wilcox speculates that Sitting Bull was actually 'Bison' McLain, a white man expelled from West Point who fled to Arizona, became an Apache chief, and later migrated to lead the Sioux. He cites physical resemblance and others' claims that Sitting Bull was white and educated by Jesuits, though he admits no photographs confirm this.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 25 September 1890 · page 8
!-- nicy zansc xane xnerr cnances.' ' 'Capt. Paige asked McLain if he had re strained his people because he knew that he (Paige) was in the party, and McLain answered that he had. Several days be fore this he had recognized Paige as an old classmate by the aid of his field glass, one of the few instruments of civ ilization which he had clung to, and one which had helped him amazingly in ac quiring renown and influence among the Apaches. McLain refused to tell Paige the name by which he was known among the Indians, and parried further inquiry concerning himself with ques tions about what had been going on in the world of civilization.
See moreSee less
As suddenly and mysteriously as he had appeared, Mc Lain then gave the signal to his follow ers, and the visitors rose and filed out of tho camp into the darkness. "Capt. Paige was unable to learn much more about our old classmate at West Point," continued Gen. Wilcox. "He made inquiries in various directions, but could only ascertain that there was a whito chief among the Mojaves, a great war chief on whom the native chieftains relied for leadership in their struggles with the troop3. One of the scouts attached to tho exploring expedi tion reported that he had engaged one of McLain's followers in such conversation as his small knowledge of Apache would permit tho night of the strange visit, and had learned that McLain was known among the Mojaves as 'Chief White Bull.' At least the scout thought it was 'White Bull.' He knew that it was 'Bull,' but he was not bo certain of the prefix. "That was in 1863. In 1867 there was a pitched battle between the Mojaves and a detachment of troops in the Gila river country. The troops were defeat ed, and defeated because of the masterly tactics displayed by the Indians. The officers were surprised and astounded at the familiarity with tho art of war dis played by their foe, and were at a loss to account for it till they heard rumors that tho Mojavo war chief, or captain, was an ex-cadet at West Point military academy. This engagement was de scribed in a recent number of The Cent ury Magazine, and in that article tho writer, one of the officers who was in the battle, pays high tribute to the mili tary skill displayed by his unknown an tagonist. "This is all I know positively of the career of 'Bison' McLain," Gen. Wilcox went on. "But I have reasons for be lieving that ho left the southwestern country and moved into the northwest. The Mojavo Apaches have been pretty well broken up, and if McLain had con tinued to reside with them ho would have been uncovered. Had ho met with death in the tribe some traditions of the taking off of such a unique and noted character would be likely to exist among his fellows or in the annals of the fron tier. What more natural than that Mc Lain, perceiving the gradual encroach ment cf the whites on tho Arizona coun try, and discovering the miserable char acter of the Indians among whom ho had cast his lot, and perhaps tiring of the family ties which he had formed, should seek to better his condition and enlarge his influence by seeking alliance with the nobler Indians of the Yellowstone, the Black Hills and the Big Horn the war liko Sioux? "That is just what McLain did, in my opinion. I firmly believe that 'Bison' McLain, expelled from West Point, a fugitive from Galveston, was chief of the Mojavo Apaches, migrated to the Sioux country and became the famous Sitting Bull. We have no photographs of Sitting Bull, as he has always refused to sit before a camera, claiming that to bo 'bad medicine,' unlucky; but such sketches as wo have of him show a strik ing resemblance between his head and faco and the head and face which at West Point led us to nickname their owner 'Bison' McLain. It is said Sitting Bull is a medicine chief and not a war chief at all, but how erroneous this is must appear from consideration of his great campaigns in the last fifteen years. Were Custer alive he would not say Sit ting Bull was a medicine chief. Custer found to his cost that Sitting Bull knew the art of war. Crook learned the same thing. There has always been a mystery about Sitting Bull, and I believe if it could be cleared up he would be found to be nono other than my old friend Mc Lain. Maj. McLaughlin, of tho army, tells me in his opinion Sitting Bull is a white man, and familiar with both French and English. My friend Col. Taylor, of this city, has written a little book to show that Sitting Bull was a whito man, educated by the Jesuits in Canada. That wonld account for his knowledge of English and French, but it would not account for his familiarity with tho art of war as taught at West Point a familiarity which has enabled him to anticipate precisely what his foe, the United States troops, would do at any particular crisis." Gen. Wilcox is one of the most promi nent citizens of Washington. He was strongly urged upon President Harrison a few days ago for appointment to the vacant oommissionership of the District of Columbia. Ho is nearly related to ex-Attorney General Garland. A little romance in Gen. Wilcox's life is worth mentioning. He and the late Gen. George B. McClellan were as young men fast friends. Both loved the same young lady. Magnanimously Gen. Wil cox stepped aside, and left the way clear to a union between his friend and the woman he loved. McClellan did marry the girl, and McClellan and Wilcox were warm friends as long as the former lived. Walter Weixm-vx. Carefnl of Hi Trnnsrn. Miss C&shley Ton have dropped your handkerchief on the floor, Mr. Van Dude kin. Van Dudekin (preparing to get on his knees I did it with a purpose, dear Miss Cashley er Edith, I love you; will you be my wife' Puck. The Quibbles Were Leffal. Lawyer Black Yo' honah, I rise to ob jeck to de legal quibbles dat der prosercu tion am bnngin' up. Judge Cole Mistah Black, yo' sit right down. Ef dem quibbles am legal they shall Ktand. and de cou't allows 'em. Harper's Bazar. The Tailor's Tula Hope. Tcu ..-.Taa': pst s ctzz.gi pocket in this coat. Saip." "I know it, sir. I thought very likely if yon had no pocket you might $end yeur change to me, and that would reduce yoer account'' Harper's Baxar. CnelfUh. "Why are you fighting o'" asked a man who had S6p.irted two strugslia boy. "Why don't you keap the peace" "The peaee don't belong so us' replied the bigger of tie two; "we ain't no taosep
The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me. · 29 September 1890
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis.
A narrative account describes Custer riding confidently toward what he believed was a fleeing village, only to be confronted by overwhelming numbers of warriors. The piece dramatizes his dismounting his men, the intense gunfire from hidden warriors, and his final order to mount up as his command was surrounded.
River Falls Journal · 25 September 1890 · page 2
GENERAL CUSTER’S END. A Stru«le Against the Uneven Never realizing, as 1 believe, the fearful odds against him. believing that he would find the village “on »-»e run.” ami that between himself and Reno be could “double them up’’ in short order, Custer had j* iiitily trotted down to his death. It was a long fire
This is a newspaper advertisement for the Adam Forepaugh Wild West show combined with a circus, touring Kentucky in late 1890. Among its advertised attractions is a dramatized reenactment titled 'The Great Custer Battle,' alongside other spectacles like the Mountain Meadow Massacre and Sheridan's Famous Ride.
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 26 September 1890 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
This is a promotional advertisement compiling newspaper praise for John F. Finerty's book 'Warpath and Bivouac,' which narrates the military campaigns against the Sioux including the Rosebud fight and the pursuit after Custer's defeat. The ad quotes several Chicago newspapers praising the book's accuracy and narrative style, and provides subscription and pricing details.
The Citizen · 27 September 1890 · page 5
INTERESTING PROM START TO FINISH. [Chicago Mf/mino Neure. J “Mr. Flnerty’s book contains all the material facts of a history of the opera tions against the Sioux, but it is written in a narrative style and is interesting from start to finish. His descriptions of the Rosebud fight, the “Sibley Scout,” the engagement at Slim Buttes, and his story ot the long march In pursuit of the Indians after the Custer massacre, have never been equaled.”
The report recounts how Comanche, Captain Keogh's horse, was the only survivor found on the Little Bighorn battlefield after Custer's command was wiped out, badly wounded by bullets and arrows. It describes how soldiers nursed the horse and transported it to a steamboat, and notes that Comanche, now aging, still serves as the regiment's honored mascot with a standing order forbidding anyone from riding him.
Fort Riley is now the headquarters of the Seventh cavalry, made famous by Gen. Custer m his Indian campaigns. The only survivor of that part of tbecoinmand led bv Gen. Custer at the battle of the Little Big Horn Is Comanche the dun-colored horse ridden by Col. Keogh
This is an advertisement for the Adam Forepaugh circus and Wild West show, promoting attractions including a staged reenactment called 'Custer's Last Rally' alongside Mountain Meadow Massacre and Deadwood stagecoach scenes. The ad lists show dates, locations, admission prices, and various circus acts including trick riding, animal shows, and sharpshooting demonstrations.
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 30 September 1890 · page 3
Races, 4 Paws Mammoih Double Menagerie, 4. Paws Trained Animal F.sposinon. Startling and realistic VILI WF.ST hcene oo Scouts, Cowboys ami Sioux Indians Custer's Last Rally -the Atrocious Mountain Meadow Massacre Indians' Attack uu Duadttood Stage Coach A Virginia Keel on Pony Cxprcss Riding All the Cr."uk Rule, Shotgun and Pistol Kxperlt The Champions of the Universe, Capt A II IIOCfARUUS and his Three Kamous Sons shoot at every perforinatue Wrt'AII the Wild West Attractions, all tho Circus Stars, all the HippoUome I eatures, all tnc r.le phants and Wild IJeasU.al!
See moreSee less
I he (treat Golden Chariots will be displayed in the Rare, Radiant and Romantic Street Parade nl oa. in. on the day of exhibition Two Complete Kxhibltions Daily at the Usual Hours. Admission 50 cents; children under q, 33c Cheap Round Trip Kxcursions on all railroads. See local agent for particulars.