As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

January 1890

9 articles

The Dickinson Press · Dickinson, N.D.

President Harrison is delaying his proclamation opening 8,000,000 acres of former Sioux land to settlers, pending congressional ratification of promises made to the Indians, including payment for ponies taken after Crook disarmed them following the Custer massacre. Cold weather is cited as a second reason for delay, to spare settlers frontier hardships.

The Dickinson Press · 4 January 1890 · page 2

NOT SPECIFICALLY STATED in the bill creating the commission, and the president has signified that lie will not issue his proclamation until he knows that congress will ratify these promises. He will, therefore, defer ac tion until the committees on Indian af fairs from both houses of congress have examined the report and signified that they favor legislation which will be the fulfillment of the promises made the Indians before they signed last summer. Chief among these promises was the payment for ponies taken from friendly Indians at the time Gen. Crook disarmed them after the Custer massacre, and that the money for schools shall not be deducted from the purchase money paid under this new act, but shall be from general appropriations as called for un der existing treaties.

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

Returning Sioux commissioners Crook, Warner, and Foster claim Sitting Bull was merely a medicine man who fled the Custer fight and watched from a hill, later looting scalps. They credit Red Cloud and Gall as the true Indian leaders at the battle.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Narragansett Herald · 4 January 1890 · page 8

CHIEF SITTING BULL. ACCORDING TO GENERAL CROOK HE WAS AN ARRANT COWARD.

throw of Nagoleot.. The toundations were Pi a22oun’s is s 0 ¢ mphicated that a man laid in 1815, but tke interior was not com- "“ggv“ A N g great chief of the RED CLOUD. Bioux. They had the entree to enough magazines and boys’ periodicals to spread their adulation of his character. He went East and his journey was a triumph. The truth is that Sitting Bull, wh) was only a medicine man, ran away from the fight and viewed it from a hill. When the massacre was complete he descended to the battlefiecld and filled his belt with scalps torn from the dead. The real leaders at the Custer massacre were Fed Cloud, who

See the clipping

Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D.

The article reports that President Harrison is expected to delay opening the Sioux reservation until spring, partly to honor promises made to Indians including payment for ponies taken when Gen. Crook disarmed them after the Custer massacre. It also cites concerns about harsh winter conditions for settlers.

Union County Courier · 8 January 1890 · page 1

(ien Crook disarmed them after tbe Custer massacre, aud that Ihe money for schools shall not be dedacted from the purchase money paid under this new act but shall bu from general appropriations as called for under existing treaties. Another rea son which leads the president to delay as ti is the cold weather. He believes that the reservaiion would open under inau spicious circumstances if done right away. A rush of immigration would be almost in evitable, and in that cold climate tbe set tlers would suffer privations incident to ftontier life wbich would injure not only tbe Particular settler, but the name and prospects of tbe great reservation, which is fertile aud in many ways choice.

See the clipping

The Central Nevadan · Battle Mountain, Nev.

This is an advertisement seeking agents to sell Buffalo Bill's book 'Story of the Wild West,' which claims to include an authentic account of the Custer Massacre and General Crook's campaign. It promises easy profits for agents and offers a canvassing outfit for $1.

The Central Nevadan · 9 January 1890 · page 1

"STORY OF THE WILD WEST” Au,t Camp-Fire CUats. The great standard History of Pio neer Life. A c 'inplele record of ex citing events on iho Western borders and for the first time an authentic ao, count of the Custer Massacre, Oen

See the clipping

Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D.

This editorial claims nearly all Sioux, even formerly friendly bands, have gone on the warpath, raiding into Nebraska and killing settlers, and defends the cavalry's killing of 'red devils' as deserved revenge for Custer's death fourteen years earlier. It calls for General Miles to be given free rein to suppress the uprising without restraint.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pierre Weekly Free Press · 9 January 1890 · page 4

THE INDIAN UPRISING

Tuesday, were of the Seventh cavalry, and some of them belonged to the regi meiit during the Custer campaign, over fourteen years ago, and had waited all that time for vengeance, which was not long in coming when the chance was given. Nobody but the eastern crank will blame them for having shot down the red devils 011 every hand, and pur suing them for that, purpose. It will be a profitable lesson to those that are left. The FUEE Pit ESS bel ves in seeing equal justice done on allisides, and can see no reason why an Indian murderer should bo protected any more than white. For this reason Gen. Miles should be allowed to proceed without let or hindrance.

See the clipping

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D. · and 1 other paper

The article reports that the U.S. president is likely to delay opening the Sioux reservation until spring, pending congressional ratification of promises made to the Indians. Among those promises was compensation for ponies confiscated from friendly Sioux by Gen. Crook after the Custer massacre.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Black Hills Union · 10 January 1890 · page 2

XO BE DELAYED. Impression That the Sioux Reservation Will Not be Opened Till Spring. The feeling is growing among Dakotans and their friends that the president will not issue his proclamation opening the Sioux reservation until spring. There are two principal reasons for this three months' delay in declaring the 8,000,000 aores of land open to be taken up by settlors. The president believes that the letter of the commissioners' promises to the Indians should be carried out. They promised several things which are not specifically stated in the bill creating the commission, and the president has signified that he will not issue his proclamation until he knows that congress will ratify these promises.

See moreSee less

He will, therefore, defer action until the committee on Indian affairs from both houses of congress have examined the report and signified that they favor legisla tion which will be the fulfillment of the promises made the Indians before they signed last summer. Chief among these promises .were the payment for ponies taken from friendly Indians at the time Gen Crook disarmed them after the Custer massacre, and that the money for schools shall not be deducted from the purchase money paid under this new act, but Bhall be from general appropriations as called for under existing treaties. Another rea son which leads the president to delay ac tion is the cold weather. He believes that the reservaiion would open under inau spicious circumstances if done right away. A rush of immigration would be almost in evitable, and in that cold climate the set tiers would suffer privations incident to frontier life which would injure not only the particular settler, but the name and prospects of the great reservation, which 1B fertile and in many ways choice.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Wessington Springs Herald · Wessington Springs, S.D. · 10 January 1890

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The report describes Comanche, said to be the sole survivor of the Custer massacre, still being cared for by the government at a Dakota post. It notes he is retired from work, kept in a special stall, and bears numerous scars from his twenty-two years of service.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 11 January 1890 · page 8

Survivor of the Custer Massacre. Troy Telegram, The old war horse, Commanche, the only survivor of the famous Custer mas sacre, is still handsomely cared for at the government's expense. By special order of the military authorities Com manche is provided with a comfortable stall, fitted up especially for him out in Dakota. No one Is permitted to ride • him and he is not allowed to do any work whatever. Riddled with bullets and scared by saber wounds, his body speaks eloquently of the. perilous duty' he has performed in his' twenty-two years of service under the government.

See moreSee less

He will go down to history holding about as proud a place as that accorded the" gallant black charger which once brought Gen. •'Phil" Sheridan to the field iv time to save the - battle, "from Winchester twenty miles away."

See the clipping

The Central Nevadan · Battle Mountain, Nev.

An advertisement promotes Buffalo Bill's autobiography, claiming it contains the first authentic account of the Custer Massacre alongside other frontier history. The ad seeks agents to sell the book door-to-door for commission.

The Central Nevadan · 30 January 1890 · page 1

“STORY OF THE WILD WES t’" Aud Camp-Fire ('liati. The groat standard History of Pio neer Life. A Complete record of ex citing events on the Western borders and for the lirst time an authentic ac, count of the Custer Massacre, (Jeu

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

A man named Mosher recounts stories from Sioux agency visits claiming Sitting Bull was not actually a combatant in the Custer fight but watched from a distance, with Gall as the true warrior leader. He asserts Sitting Bull was a medicine man reputed to be a coward who later claimed false credit and scalps for the battle.

Mineral Point Tribune · 30 January 1890 · page 5

Sitting Bull. • ... u M .sher, Y|wilanti, Mich., is in " ' ’ s . lVg the Minneapolis Journal. o l ' V-n'iifrlv in charge of a store at ?' Kocfe Agency. Dak., ami . inent visitors were Sit •*L 1 (j-ill. Red Cloud, and others L ‘ personages of the Sioux <• ' Mr. Mosher was this morning u ... - sitting Bull’s claim to honors Custer tight. 1 \ Hull has become famous as ~"7>f the Custer battle on the j but the fact is that he was 111 , „ti.rht at all.

See moreSee less

I can understand r "_' well and .-peak it fairly. One J ■ - ling Bull and Gall me tin my vid for over an hour discussed 'vs of the battle, and once or in: st reached a fighting point Ii-making an attack on Sitting oi, i , iit. mptiug to steal his bravery. *’ ; - ict is that sitting Bull was the Indian to reach a telegraph station ... I, U ews of the massacre: and he i',. ;iie most of his opportunity. He ‘V • himself in the thickest of the T. . ' | had scalps w ith him to prove •t Wit tiiev were all secured after the i ,-tl. and not in itSitting Bull was not in the tight, but watched it from a wnjlf nne distanee off. At its close he , adi wnand three or four J - nul rode away and painted him -1,1,,-ro. At least this is what the

See the clipping