As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

September 1888

18 articles

The Red Man · Carlisle, Pa.

This 1888 article by Lieut. Schwatka explains the origins of various Sioux chief names, including Spotted Tail, Crazy Horse, and Man-Afraid-of-his-Horses, noting mistranslations from Sioux to English. It mentions Crazy Horse's role as a leader in the Custer massacre as part of discussing his name's meaning.

The Red Man · 1 September 1888 · page 3

satisfaction with the simple name of his baby-days, though it arose from such trifling incident, and in his refusal to choose a name like “Pawnee Killer,” G l White Thunder, )7 or some other high sounding title. “Crazy Horse, ) > the great Sioux chief who was prominent in the Custer mas sacre, and who gained several other vic tories over us in war, is not given his right name, strictly speaking, changing it into our language it was mis interpreted. He was a superb rider, noted even among a nation of line horsemen,and he could ride anything, however vicious, wild, or intractable.

See moreSee less

Untamable Horse” 14 would have been a better rendering of his name. Man-Afraid-of-his-Horses, Ogallalla Sioux chief, is also not rightly named in English. He was very careful about his horses when on the war-path, in times of peril keeping guard over them all night—a very unusual precaution Indians. “Man-Careful-of-his among 4I )) a for, in the great

See the clipping

The Progress · White Earth, Minn.

This opinion piece argues that Native Americans have been repeatedly deceived and dispossessed of their land through fraudulent treaties and exploitative legislation. It cites Custer's death at Little Bighorn as a tragic culmination of these injustices, then pivots to criticize the contemporary Sioux Commission for coercing land cessions at a fraction of fair value.

The Progress · 1 September 1888 · page 4

Horn when the heroic Custer and his brave legion fell victims to the wiles of misguided ambition in censed by the lamentable blunders and distorted issues of abortive legislation. With the voluntary submission of Sitting Bull and his valiant

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Major Marcus Reno, a veteran of the Little Bighorn campaign, was arrested in Harrisburg on a non-support charge brought by his wife. The report recalls lingering accusations that Reno failed to adequately support Custer during the battle and was criticized for later disparaging Custer's courage in a published interview.

Evening Star · 3 September 1888 · page 3

ACCUSED BY HIS WIFE OF NOT PROVIDING FOR HER SUPPORT

Majar Reno Arrests*. ACCUSED BT BIS Win OK NOT PROVIDING BOS BKB scrroRT. ? telegram to tM New York Am tram Harrls bury, September 2, says: Major Marcua a. Reno, who until the last few years was a noted Indian fighter of the United states Army, was arrested here yesterday evening on tbe charge ot non maintenance preferred by his wile, Isabella R. Reno, who lives in this city. Major lie no, whose compact figure and darkened and somber race are familiar in this city, was a prominent figure in tbe later Indian wars, and was on the plains with General Custer when that heroic soldier and us command waa massacred.

See moreSee less

It has been charged that Major Reno did not aid Custer as he ought to htve done, and was out ot harm's way when tM murderous redskins surrounded and overwMlmed Custer and hir command. Major Reno left tM Army not long afterward. A few montha ago Reno had an interview published la a New York paper, in which M assailed the conduct of Custeraaa belittled that officer's courage. As a result tM newspapers all over tM country denounced Reno severely. He la bow under ball for his r?? atoon

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Major Marcus Reno, a former Indian-fighting officer who had been at Little Bighorn, was arrested in Harrisburg on his wife's charge of failing to support her. The report recounts lingering accusations that Reno failed to aid Custer and was "out of harm's way" during the massacre.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 3 September 1888 · page 1

MAJOR RENO ARRESTED.

hanged him to u straw carrier. The hoy was fi reeled wlthaahnwerof art. fioai a croud of bond aro packed lu other lhau Jul bagging a. .hlnpera re inu who bad gathered on tb out.klrti of tbe orowd, cut to pieces. ject all bale othervrlie palled uninercbanlabi. B.ifta TroEvmsaRmt to-d.ya vona.rralaoaotint Ba4 in Tin Brutaa Bra to-day a wendarrdl account Bead In Tas Brgaiaa Boa to-dar a wonderful aoaonnt of tb craal rntnrUy Event, th, fas wkleh taptrMdaa, ftbgrat rnturity Event tb race wbioh eup.raedea, of tb. great Kntnritr Brent, the raee whleh eaperaadea, Ji.no.fonh, ailcth.r ercnu et Ut lurf Utatam were anctforth, allethar aventaet thatoxt Uiktsvtr vite MSttr w'liaalitai 'ml U VuUut - .?

See moreSee less

t prominent figure In tbe later Indian wars, and 'Bel was on tho plains with Gen. Custer whon that jBel heroin soldier and his command were mas- ,!" sacred. It has been charged that Major Reno SH did not aid Custer as be ought to bavo done, flH nnd was out of barm's way when tbe murder- -H ous redskins surrounded and overwhelmed ' " Custer and his command. Major Bono left tha army not long afterward. jH A low months ngo Reno bad an Interview uWBei published in a New York papor. In wbioh he OBefl assailed the conduct of Custer and belittled 'H that ofltcer's courage. As a result the newsj)Baa papers all over tbe country denounced Reno - DBal severely. Despite all these things Bono Is ge- "" nlal socially, and can make friends enlly. tie H bad come up from Baltimore when arrested uwaaia yesterday, and is now under ball for his anageefl poaranco at court !H

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Harrisburg report says Maj. Marcus Reno, the Little Bighorn veteran, was arrested on his wife's complaint of non-support and released on bail. It recaps his controversial role in the battle, claiming he left the army soon after the massacre and had since criticized Custer.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 4 September 1888 · page 1

Major Reno verhaftet

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Thomas County Cat · Colby, Kan.

The article recounts the legend of Miles Keogh's horse, found alone on the Little Bighorn battlefield after the battle, as the sole living thing left among the dead. It claims the horse was honored by special order and sent to live out its days at West Point.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Thomas County Cat · 6 September 1888 · page 2

m m AN ARMY HORSE'S FATE. The Common Fate or Chargers Who Have Grown Old In the Service. The fate of the army horse is gen erally a sad one. Having taken to a military career he gives up all hopes of enjoying any of the benefits which some of his kindred enjoy who wear away their prime in dragging a truck or dray. These latter often are cared for by considerate masters in return for years of good, reliable service. Not so with the army equine. He can look forward to a few years of luxuri ous living and fare.

See moreSee less

But lot him be come 6ick or disabled and he is cast adrift in a cruel world, and he ends his days in misery. The gallant, prancing steed that bears the Colonel's manly form around the parade ground may in a month be crawling along some by-way in Tar Flat, drag ging at his heels a decrepit old soap fat wagon. As soon as it is discovered that a horse is unfit for duty, a request is sent to the quartermaster to have the ani mal condemned. A horse does not have to be disabled to be condemned and branded I. C. (inspected and con demned). If he will not stay in the ranks, if he is nervous at the sound of music or the whistling of a shot, he is condemned. Horses get soured in dis position, too, as if they repented of en tering the service and wanted to get out of it. , There are instances, preserved as legends in the army, where horses have been rewarded for long and faith ful services by being cared for in their old age. A notable case is that of the equine survivor of Custer's fatal battle with the Sioux on the Little Big Horn. The clouds of smoke had passed up the ravine, the last savage whoop had long ceased to re-echo among the hills, and Miles Keogh's horse at evening Was the only l.ving thing that moved along the battle-field where the corpses of poor Custer's boys in blue were strewn. Here was the ani mal discov ered lingering over the body of his dead m sister. Miles Keogh's horse, by a special department order, was sent to West Point, where he was to pass the rest of his days in comfort, and with no harder work to perform than to discover in what part of the lawn the greenest and dewiest grass grew. But such an elysian existence is not the common fate of the horse that expends his energies in Uncle Sam's service. .V. Y. Letter. She Will Make It Thinner. Guest at charming country summer resort I don't like to complain, Mrs. Millsap, but when it comes to vege table soup every day for three weeks'I think you are putting it on ratter thick. Mrs. Millsap (sweetly) I sometimes think so myself, Mr. Chunkerson. I'll have it made thinner hereafter. Chi cago Tribune. m m Mrs. Rebecca Taylor, Bayard Tay lor's mother, is still alive and hearty, though well into the nineties. Lately she went to West Chester, Pa., to see the handsome memorial window put into ths public library in honor of her poet soa.

See the clipping

People and Patriot · Concord, N.H.

Major Marcus Reno, who served in the 1876 expedition that ended fatally for General Custer, was arrested in Harrisburg after arriving from Baltimore on an alimony/maintenance complaint filed by his wife. Reno waived a hearing on the matter.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Sun, 3 September 1888, Der Deutsche Correspondent, 4 September 1888.

People and Patriot · 6 September 1888 · page 5

Criminal. William A. Swart, L. H. Johuston, and Elijah Beckler, president, teller and solicitor of the savings bank at Roseland, a suburb of Chicago have disappeared, and about $30,000, comprising the entire funds of the bank are also missing. On his arrival at Harrisburg from Bal timore. Saturday, Major Reno, who was in the expedition which resulted fatally to Gen. Custer, was arrested for main

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A Bismarck correspondent rebuts a published letter attacking Custer, accusing the letter's author of hypocrisy for having once defended the same corrupt post traders and Indian goods frauds he now denounces. The piece frames Custer as honest and honorable, suggesting his downfall stemmed from refusing to go along with such corruption.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 8 September 1888 · page 6

Special to the Globe. Bismarck, Sept. 7. -A recent com munication in the Minneapolis Tribune, signed C. A. L.— Lounsberry, 1 pre sume—l read with considerable sur prise, because of statements therein contained and general unfriendliness to Gen. Custer, post traders and steam boat interests that have helped so much to build up Bismarck, the flourishing city that C. A.L. used to think so much of before he lost the postoffice. <". A. L. confines himself to the truth when he speaks of the abuse of the Indians, the total disregard of treaty obli gations and deceptions practiced on the poor wards of the cation, but be forgot to say that the Republican party was re sponsible lor all litis Vlf.K ABUSE OF POWER,

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A newspaper correspondent defends General Custer against charges of being a money-maker, calling him an honest, brave soldier and Democrat who was undone by enemies rather than greed. The piece attacks a rival writer's hypocrisy while using Custer's reputation as a political weapon in a partisan dispute over Indian trading scandals.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 8 September 1888 · page 6

fund should have HELD HIS PEACE SO I.OXfi'.' He had many opportunities while publishing a paper here to expose these glaring frauds, but he dared not do il.as be held an office under the Republican party whom he now, as a Republican so-called, seeks to eepooe. There is one thing morally certain— the Demo cratic party had no hand in robbing the Indians. The hardest lick, the most glaring evi dence of C. A. L.'s meanness, is his slurring reference to Custer and the motives that prompted him to make his last grand fatal charge.

See moreSee less

Gen. Custer was a brave and glorious soldier and a Democrat. He was not a money-maker, as charged, for had he been, there would have been no neces sity for the disgrace of Gen. Belknap. True, Gen. Custer did some writing for the press and magazines, but it was pimply to record some of his own history on the frontier. Probably C. A. L. -re members the day that Gen. Custer brought his regiment to Bismarck and rounded up half of the leading men of the city for being implicated IX Tin: STEAMXG

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A writer defends Custer against charges of being a 'restless money maker,' arguing his rigid discipline and honesty earned him enemies within his own regiment, including Reno. The piece also defends Custer's Black Hills expedition as driven by genuine mineral discovery and Northwest commercial necessity, not personal gain.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 8 September 1888 · page 6

WHY HE HAD ENEMIES.

oils news of tiie mineral _^^^sa^fiM WEALTH OF THE HILLS? C. A. L.'s memory is not good, or else he prefers to tell an untruth and malign the memory of a true soldier. McKay, the mining expert that Custer took with him to the hills, found plenty of wealth, or rather the evidence of it, and it was for this purpose that Custer took him. Fied Gerard, now of Man dan, and many other old-time river men knew of the existence of gold In the Black Hills from the Indians them selves long before the city of Bismarck was dreamed of, and C. A. L. knows this to be true, and yet HE BLAMES CUSTER

See the clipping

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.

Twelve years after the battle, a newspaper recounts secondhand testimony from Mrs. Spotted-Horn-Bull, who claims she rallied her husband's band after he faltered and personally scalped multiple soldiers. The piece also claims Custer and his brother fought bravely and that their bodies alone were left unmutilated by the Lakota.

The Manitowoc Pilot · 13 September 1888 · page 4

A RED TERROR IN PETTICOATS.

Mrs. Bpotted-Horn-Bnll*s Part In W*■ Ter rible Custer Massacre. Mr. E. P. McFadden, one of Pitts burg's representatives among that peo ple, furnishes some queer specimens of the unwritten history of Indian out breaks in the Northwest that is pecu liar! v interesting and authentic, com ing'as it does from participants in those horrible massacres. On the Standing Rock Agency. _ living next door to him, is Mrs. “Spotted-HornBull, v the wife of a Dakota chieftain who bears that unique title: Mr. McFadden has frequently con versed with Mrs. Spotted-Horn-Bull about the Custer massacre.

See moreSee less

Tne cop per-colored Amazon was a prominent actor ou the Held of blood. Her trii>- ute to the merits of her better half is not at all flattering. She brands him as having been a most arrant coward. While the light, which reflected great credit on Gen. Custer's daring and bravery but little on his Generalship, was going on Spotted-Horn-Bull was in command of his tribe. He weaken ed before the bullets of the whites, and Mrs. Spotted-Horn rushed to the res cue. She incited the band by her speech and deeds to feats of Indian daring equaled by no other tribe in the tight. She was foremost in the com bat, and with tier own hands scalped and mutilated the bodies of dozeus of

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A correspondent, C. A. Lounsberry, defends his earlier account of Custer's conflict with Secretary of War Belknap, explaining that Custer's information on frontier abuses came secondhand and made him an incompetent witness in the congressional probe. He notes this controversy, including Custer's Herald connections, led to the dispute that cost Custer his command until Sheridan intervened, allowing him to join Terry's expedition that ended in the battle.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 15 September 1888 · page 11

. COMPETENT WITNESS. This was one of the points brought out for which I am abused by your correspondent. It was Custer's telegram from Fargo ■ when on his way to Bismarck, tendering testimony against Belknap; his utter failure to present any testimony from his own knowledge; and his supposed connection with Ralph Meeker's letters in the New York Herald, that led to the quarrel which deprived Custer of his command and finally resulted in the massacre. Custer was in command of one of the so-called wings of Terry's column, and was not in command, directly, of his regiment until ordered on the reconnoissance which ended in the fatal battle.

See moreSee less

It was indeed true that it was only through the intercession of Sheridan that Custer was saved from arrest and permitted to go with the expedition. My only purpose in this is to say that your correspondent unjustly assumes that Custer was attacked by me. He was not. C. A. Lounsberry.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A hotel acquaintance recalls Custer's boyhood in Lumley, Ohio, describing how young 'Armstrong' Custer led other boys in tearing down an old cooper shop despite fears of punishment. The story is framed as illustrating the same reckless, glory-seeking spirit later blamed for his fatal decisions at the Little Bighorn.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 September 1888 · page 2

CUSTER'S BOYHOOD DAYS. A Characteristic Story of the Famous Cavalry Commander RAZED AN OLD STRUCTURE, Impetuosity and a Desire for Glory Responsible for the Massacre At the Big Horn.

RAZED AN OLD STRUCTURE, Inpetuosity and a Desire for Glory Re sponsible for the Massacre _ At the Big Horn. Yesterday was a rainy Sunday, and as dull and cheerless a Sabbath as one would care to experience. The streets were well nigh deserted, the disagreea ble rain and cutting north wind driving the people under cover. The hotels, as usual on such days, afforded shelter for a large number, and among those who found comfort in a good cigar and a big easy chair at the Clifton hotel was J.

See moreSee less

*W. Cunningham. A Globe reporter, who was blown in out of the rain, pulled up a chair to where he was sitting and engaged him in conversation. The subject of the Custer massacre was introduced, and Mr. Cunningham stated that he was not only thoroughly posted as to that event, but had been an intimate ac quaintance of the dead general. "Gen. Custer," said he, "was born and raised next door to me, in the little town of Lumley, O. Even as a boy he was a leader among his playmates and manifested a good deal of the dare-devil spirit that was so characteristic of his his afterlife. I recall an incident that I remember vividly to this uay. On the street upon which we lived, and oppo site the Custer house, was an old dilap idated log shanty which was used as a cooper shop. It presented such a rick ety, tumble-down appearance that it was really a disgrace to the street. We boys thought so. at least, and were strongly inclined to pull THE OLD KOOKEBY DOWN.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A childhood acquaintance recalls young Custer leading boys in tearing down an old cooper shop, then describes Custer's eagerness to join the 1876 expedition despite troubles with Grant, and his march from Fort Lincoln under Terry's overall command. The writer attributes Custer's death to his ambition to strike the Sioux alone before Terry arrived.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 September 1888 · page 2

shop WAS COMPLETELY HAZED. The news of the depredation that had been committed under the leadership of Custer spread quickly about the town, and when that youth returned home his father, "a man severe if aught, and stern to view," gave him a terrible thrashing. When Custer went to West Point I corresponded with him for a number of years and have many of his letters yet, which 1 prize highly. Gen. Custer was in I St. Paul for several days preceding the fatal expedition that left Fort Lin coln. He wanted to go on the expe dition the worst way, but told me that he had some TP.OUIILE WITH GEN". GIIANT.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A writer recalls personally telling Custer the news that he was ordered to Fort Lincoln to join Terry's expedition against the Sioux, and reflects on how Custer's ambition led him to strike alone before Terry arrived. The account lists Custer's relatives who died with him, including his brothers Tom and Boston, brother-in-law Calhoun, and nephew Autie Reed.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 September 1888 · page 2

he had some TP.OUIILE WITH GEN". GIIANT. and feared he would not be selected. One day 1 met a reporter named Otis, who told me that lie had just been up to the department headquarters and learned while there that orders had been received from Washington for Gen. Custer to proceed to Fort Lincoln ami report to Gen. Terry. Shortly afterwards I met Gen. Custer on the street and told him what I had heard. He was over joyed at the reception of the news, and sprang across the street in about three bounds.

See moreSee less

Poor fellow! He little knew that lie was receiving his death war rant. He went to Fort Lincoln and re ported to Gen. Terry, who placed him in command of one division of the forces selects to go out in search of the wily Sioux. Gen. Terry assumed command of the other division. The plan of the expedition had been made out. The two forces were to march by circuitous routes and meet at a cer tain point. Custer's sad ending was due, in my opinion, to his vaulting am bition. He wanted to make a hold stroke, and he wanted to do it alone. He therefore hurried his men forward so as to strike the Indians before Terry's arrival. Toe redskins were lying in wait, and the brave little band were ambushed. Not a soul escaped to tell the tale of the terrible slaughter. Be sides Gen. Custer his two brothers, Tom and Boston, were killed; also Lieut. Calhoun, his brother-in-law, and Otic Bead, his nephew, about sixteen years old, whom Custer had taken with him on the expedition. _

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A newspaper gossip column profiles Sergt. Richard P. Hartley, who traveled from Montana to St. Paul to re-enlist for the seventh time in the army. He had served in C troop of the Seventh Cavalry during the Custer fight and received a congressional medal for gallantry during that campaign.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 23 September 1888 · page 2

C troop of the Seventh cavalry dur ing the Custer fight and was awarded a medal Irom congress for gallantry on the field during that campaign. On his

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

A Canadian-Frenchman named Legare has sued the United States government for $13,412, claiming he induced Sitting Bull and his followers to surrender and cross into Montana from Canada following the Custer massacre. The report notes the government continues to face costly legal and administrative troubles stemming from Sitting Bull's case.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 27 September 1888 · page 4

THE government is never through with trouble on account of Sitting Bull Esq. A Canadian-Frenchman, named Legare, Las just sued the United States for $13, 412, for the claim that he induced old Ball and followers to surrender and to cross into Montana from Canada after the Custer massacre./f Taking it with th£ present com Bion's unhappy success, the practical sore of education with the young Io^hr^ *ad the dubious future in civiliatioa jf the Siouxjparticularly, our good aowwah mentis wracked and worried •*****$ without law suits on aafcrjont ct ri#

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Cheyenne Agency Sioux are awaiting a government commission and some chiefs may visit Washington to meet the President, accompanied by Commissioner Pratt. The delegation would include former warriors from Sitting Bull's band, including Hump and Red Skirt, who reportedly took prominent parts in the Custer massacre.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 29 September 1888 · page 9

LIKE THE WHITE MEN.

The Old Pirate, Sitting Bull, Is One of the Great Obstacles. AHe Tells Them by Holding Out They Will Get Letter Figures. Special to the Glebe. Pout Benx'ett, Cheyenne Agency,

See the clipping