As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

November 1887

24 articles

The Morning Star · Carlisle, Pa.

A Carlisle Indian school student writes to Captain Pratt about unrest among the Crow over an attempted arrest by their agent, fearing war may break out. He recalls Sitting Bull mocking the Crow as the white man's slaves in a speech given at the monument to General Custer, boasting of having killed him.

The Morning Star · 1 November 1887 · page 8

The Crow Difficulty. CAPT. PRATT—DEAR Sin:—I learned through Montana Stock Gazette there has been serious trouble among the Crows, probably it will lead to war, so I will write to you instead of home. The cause of this trouble appears to be an attempt of Agent Williamson to arrest a party of young Crows who had been stealing some horses from the Piegans on the Canadian side. The agent didn’t succeed in arrest ing these men as I learned, they refused to be arrested and shot into his house and disappeared.

See moreSee less

Some troops from Ft.Custer the agent and property. are protectin This act has aroused the settlers of Mon tana very much, I fear it will lead to some great trouble. The Piegans and the Sioux are intruders of my people and have spent all their lives in trying to get the Crow into trou ble, but they never accepted their pipe of war against the whites. I am afraid they have accepted at last. I know for the past thirteen years of my life among the Crows they were friends and helps to the white In case of war between the whites man. and Sioux, the Crow is sure to be on the white man’s side. NO aount tney nave tatugnt sitting nun many a lesson; in this cause he is always ’jealous of the Crows because they will not fight against the whites. In a recent speech by Sitting Bull before the Crows at the monument of General Custer, he said that the ll Crows are the white man’s slave, and that the Govern ment gives them only half a pound of ra tions while he gets one and half pound be cause the white people are afraid of him, because he killed their great chief and don’t have to work but ride around )) wherever he pleases. That shows the He saw that Crows Igziness of his race. were getting lands and he is trying to stop them, he don’t intend to work himself but thirsts after war. I hope the outbreak of war will come in due* time and give him a lesson that he will never forget.

See the clipping

Daily Yellowstone Journal · Miles City, Mont.

This dispatch describes tensions with Crow leader Wraps-Up-His-Tail near the Crow agency, with troops mobilizing to prevent an uprising. It explicitly references avoiding 'another Custer massacre,' showing how the Little Bighorn disaster had become a cautionary byword eleven years later.

Daily Yellowstone Journal · 2 November 1887 · page 1

ceive all old custonters and many new ones. W. 8. .T =O Z. been isnued that all Indians who re-' main without the agency are to be dealt with as ho-tihs and this time General Iluger means busine..s. Inspector (amnptll was ot,lized murbh against his wish to, attend this essilon of court here and cannot ex pect to get away in less than a week, before which time the Indian warl will, we believe, he a thing of the past. No opportunities should be affiorded for another Custer massacre.

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

This 1887 article about the Sword Bearer uprising among the Crow recounts an older legend from the Little Bighorn campaign, in which three Crow warriors believed sacred root medicine made them bulletproof and rode into Sioux lines, only to be killed. The piece uses this tale to explain the superstitions behind Sword Bearer's own claims of invulnerability.

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 2 November 1887 · page 3

considerable trouble The fact that Indians very often get the idea into their heads that they are bullet-proof, has been verified time and time again. The misguided brave takes from his blanket a piece of root which he placed there for that purpose, and chewing it, spits upon his fingers and crosses Ills breast and the breast* of his chosen followers with the saliva. In tho Little Big Horn campaign there were three Crows, who, having pre|tared themselves in this way, rode lioldly i-to the ranks of the Sioux, and of eoiiree weio riddled with bullets.

See moreSee less

The rest of the party who had similarly pre pared themselves, l<wt confidence in their medicine at this, and the experi ment ban not aince l>een tried, until Sword Hearer, mislead l»y ihe shrewd old Sioux ami the false traditions of his tribe, undertook to wake himself famous bv the same measures. AS HOUSE stealers.

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

This article describes a 1887 Crow Indian uprising led by Sword Bearer, with federal troops mobilizing near the Little Bighorn battlefield, site of Custer's 1876 defeat. The piece focuses on troop movements, Indian unrest, and negotiations during the unrelated Crow conflict, mentioning the historic battlefield only as a geographic landmark.

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 2 November 1887 · page 3

were unable to overtake thoin until the Indians had leached tn-j battle field of the Little Big Horn, near Ft. Custer, wliero the gallant Gen. Custer and follow ers lost their lives in tho memorable battle of 18/0. Ou Wednesday Sword Bearer passed in full view of the garrison at Custer on his way form the Cheyenne agency, with

See the clipping

Los Angeles Daily Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A dispatch from Bismarck claims 200 Crow Indians have fled soldiers and gone on the warpath, with Sitting Bull allegedly allied with them at Standing Rock. Troops in Montana are said to be preparing defenses as settlers demand reinforcements at Fort Lincoln.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 12 days later.

Wrong

Los Angeles Daily Herald · 4 November 1887 · page 1

ON THE WARPATH. Two Hundred Crows Raiding in tne North. • MrN.xiiAi'Oi.is, November.'!.—A spec ial from Bismarck, Dak., says: It is reported that 200 Crow Indians, wbo escaped from soldiers near Custer are on the warpath, and that soldiers in Montana are preparing as best they con for defense. Sitting Bull is at Standing Rock with over UOOO Sioux, and is said to be in league with the Crows. The iieople west of tho Mis sissippi are anxious that Fort Lincoln, five miles south of here, should be given more troops. NO r.UtIHIN TO DB (HVKN.

See the clipping

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A dispatch reports rumors that 200 Crow Indians who escaped soldiers near Custer are on the warpath, with Sitting Bull allegedly massing thousands of Sioux at Standing Rock in support. A later update from St. Paul contradicts the alarm, saying Indians are peacefully coming in to the Crow Agency as troops gather.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 4 November 1887 · page 1

Startling Rumors Concerning the Mon tana Indian Situation. Minneapolis, November 3d.— A special from Bismarck, Dak., says: It is reported that the 200 Crow Indians who escaped from the soldiers near Custer are on the warpath, and that the settlers in Montana are preparing, as best they can, for defense Sitting Bull is at Standing Rock with over G.OOO Sioux, and is said to be in league with the Crows. The people west of the Mississippi are anxious that Fort Lincoln, five milea south of here, be given more troops.

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A satirical sketch imagines Sitting Bull taunting young Crow warriors at the Custer battlefield, boasting that the Sioux get more meat rations for killing 260 whites than the Crows get for aiding the army. The piece mocks government Indian policy by suggesting the Crows might massacre settlers to earn bigger rations.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 4 November 1887 · page 5

THEY MUST MAKE A RECORD. STANDING in the shadow of the Custer monument Sitting Bull, the Sioux chief, said to a band of young Crow warriors: "You fools you children!" Then pointing his blood-washed index finger at the battle field he continued: "We Sioux killed 260 white men here, and we get three pounds of meat each day. You kill no whites, you do nothing—you get two pounds meat." And true It is 'that the Sioux who massa­ cred the whites are feasting on much larger rations than are given the Crows who fought in defense of the whites.

See moreSee less

It is also true ttiat Sitting Bull has not lost his cunning and that his brief speech to the young Crows made them realize what mammoth copper-colored chumps they have been ana inspired them with high ambitions. They will now attune their tom-toms, proceed to make a record, and after they have shown their metal by an artistic massacre or two our model repub­ lic will give them the additional pound of meat ana exhibit theui in the east where blue points on the half shell and rleh clam bakes await them. It is understood that the Grows, who have always been Jealous

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Sioux chiefs at Standing Rock debate the proposed land severalty law, with most professing friendship to whites. Gall, who led Indians at the Custer battle, recalls his past hostility but pledges support to the government against the Crows, while Sitting Bull remains silent and resentful.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 4 November 1887 · page 5

The commanding and intelligent Gaul, who led the Indians in the Custer mas­ sacre and who has been their military leader for many years, arose with a scowl of contempt for the orators who had pre­ ceded him and said: "1 have not always felt friendly to the whites. I fought them and tried to kill them. The whites and Crows fought me at the Custer battle and tried to kill me after that they chased me

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This 1887 editorial argues that U.S. government policy perversely rewards hostile tribes like the Sioux with larger rations while peaceful tribes like the Crows receive less. It cites Sitting Bull's speech at the Custer battlefield monument, where he mocked the Crows for their loyalty being poorly compensated compared to the Sioux's rewarded hostility.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 5 November 1887 · page 9

"NEVER FOUGHT THE WHITE MAN"

"SEVER FOUGHT THE WHITE MAX get only a moiety of the government bounty that is dealt out to the turbulent tribes. This offering a premium upon hostility has an educational effect upon the Indian, and increases the difficulties of all who have to deal with these wards of the nation. This policy it was that enabled Sitting Bull, in bis recent speech to the Crows on the site of the Custer massacre, to point to the monu ment erected to the 285 victims of Sioux hostility and tell the white men's friends that they who caused the death of the soldiers buried there had been ever since in receipt of larger rations than befoie, SAINT PAUL, MINN., SATURDAY MORNING, NOVEMBER 5, 1887.

See moreSee less

-- counsel. i they now, knowing that the said lands while the Crows, who did not take part are public lands, and accepting in good in that massacre, were half-starved as a faith the assurance of the government, reward for their friendship and (as. Sit shall desire to hold these lands by pre ting Bull put it) cowardice. If you want | emption or homestead entry, they may to fare as well as we do, you must be Ido so, and they will have such prefer brave Indians and go upon the warpath, ence as the government may be able to said he. It is that old mistake in family extend to them in the matter of the ac government, carried into Indian affairs, ceptance of their declaratory state by which the willful and bad boy. gets ments. There is a strong possibility of tiie best grub and the good little broth much litigation by duplicate filings on ers go on short commons. Kickers get the same sections and quarter sections. favors from the --Great Father" if they Men will especially endeavor to punish are lazy and bloodthirsty kickers. When their enemies as well as benefit them a party of the Christianized Yanktons. selves by settling upon and claiming the in their store clothes, short hair and of them? very, lands which families have re clean faces, visited the Cheyennes, who garded as their permanent homes. The appeared in long hair.paint and the cos general land office will endeavor to pro tume which the poet discribes thus: tect such persons as far as possible. "Lo. the poor Indian, whose untutored mind But it will not do for those who now Clothes him In front and leaves all bare be hold fhe lands to allow time to pass hind." without filing their declarations. It The former asked in aboriginal won will not do for them to fail to give no der, "How is it that we - tice of their holdings and their inten GET ONLY HALF AS MICH RATIONS |

See the clipping

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

A dispatch reports that 200 Crow Indians who escaped soldiers near Fort Custer are supposedly on the warpath, with Sitting Bull and thousands of Sioux at Standing Rock allegedly in league with them. Western settlers are demanding more troops at Fort Lincoln amid fears of a renewed Indian outbreak.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Superior Times · 12 November 1887 · page 1

Wife and Two Children stain by a Wash ./ I Tf non f.l I I T I . ington Man. The Fong Drawn Trial at Karine at Fast Washington, D. Nov. 2.—John Over. Model, a silk weaver living at Hebron, KsCive, Wis.. Nov. s.—The Tambor -heit h.s wn> lust night and then set tire case went to the jury at 2 10 this after to the houe. iwo < i ildren w> re burned noon The forenoon was taken up with to death, Model fled but is now under the concluding arguments, in ins *i rest.

See moreSee less

ami that the soldiers in Montana are. preparing lor a defense. Sitting Bull in at standing Rock with over O.fKM Sioux, and he is said to be in league with the Cr ;\vs. People vre“t of the Missourian*

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A dramatic feature story claims Paul McCormick's hair turned white in an instant during a terrifying encounter with Sioux warriors, an episode allegedly connected to a hidden cause of the 1876 war that historians overlooked. The piece frames itself as revealing a forgotten story behind the conflict that led to Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 13 November 1887 · page 21

20 AGED AN INSTANT

FEW persons only are really aware of one of the leading causes w ich prolonged the Sioux war of 1876, and led to the massacre of Custer and his brave little

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

The report describes Crow followers' belief in Sword Bearer's supernatural powers, including claims he could destroy enemies and control weather. It also details the tense negotiations as Gen. Ruger demanded the surrender of Sword Bearer and his followers from assembled Crow chiefs.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 16 November 1887 · page 1

SWORD BEARER, THE MEDICINE MAN.

a storm, which came about as follows: In conversation with his young men, he said: "To-day I will make it rain, and the soldiers will go away." And sure enough, during the afternoon a heavy rain set in, and some of the soldiers, not being provided with suitable protec tion, returned to Ft. Custer. There is no diubt but the

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

The report describes a skirmish between U.S. troops and Crow warriors led by Sword Bearer near the Little Horn River in 1887, noting the battlefield's proximity to the Custer Monument. It recounts the death of Sword Bearer and several followers after a running fight, while invoking the memory of Custer's 1876 defeat at the same site.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from 12 days earlier.

Wrong

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 16 November 1887 · page 1

meet the flank movement of the troons. Sword Bearer could be seen in the dis tance. beariu aloft the deadzy instru ment that was to be as fatal to the troopers as a touch of the death-angel's wing. As the lines approached each other, what must have been the thoughts of those misguided young Indians. The historic surroundings were indeed suffi cient to inspire Indians with superhuman efforts to overthrow and cast off tho yoke of their white rulers, while the historic surroundings were sufficient to in n corresponding degree dampen tiie ardor of the troops.

See moreSee less

To the northwest, distant about two miles, in plain sight of the battlefield, stands Custer monu ment, a silent witness of the martial scenes below. Here Sitting Bull met the advancing Custer and administered fi defeat so dreadful in its consequences as to shock the civilized world. Here it was that the red man achieved one of the ereatest victories that is recorded in Indian warfare. Here it was that the gallant Custer perished with the flower of his regiment. Here it was that Sit

See the clipping

The Daily Times · Richmond, Va.

This 1887 article uses a recent Crow uprising as a springboard to recap decades of Indian conflicts, including the Bear River massacre, Sioux uprising, Camp Grant massacre, Modoc War, and the killing of Gen. Canby. It briefly mentions the Custer massacre of June 25, 1876 as one entry in this historical survey.

The Daily Times · 17 November 1887 · page 4

INDIAN WARS BITS OF HISTORY SUGGESTED BY THE RECENT CROW OUTBREAK

Meanwhile the Sand Cresk Indians of eastern Colorado had given a little trouble; a force under Col. Chivington fell upon them while in their home eamp and unsus pecting, and massacred men, women and children. The tribe was annihilated. Early in 183 Gen. P. E. Connor cll on the Bannocks and Shoshones in their winter camp on Bear river, Idaho, slauzhitered some hundreds and brought the rest to'terms. In 1862 the Sioux of Minnesota rose and massa cred all the border settlers for 200 miles, save those who escaped to the larger towns and military posts. The Indians were subdued and partially punished. The slaughter of Black Kettie's band in their winter camp by Gen. Custer, and of the Piegans by a force

See the clipping

The Daily Times · Richmond, Va.

A later historical overview describes Custer, facing insubordination charges, recklessly attacking a stronger, well-armed Sioux force at Little Bighorn while his own men were exhausted, leading to the annihilation of his command. It frames the disaster as an inevitable result once the full circumstances became known, and notes the subsequent fates of Sitting Bull and other participants.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Daily Times · 17 November 1887 · page 4

Y | | ' | Yrefnsed to go on a ew rescrvation, and war began; they fought all winter, and in the spring of 1873 took position in the noted! “lava beds"—a region of wild gorges and kidden valleys, the remains of a voleanic field—and there withstood the troops till mid swnmer, At a conference with the Indians Gen, Cauby and Dr. Thomas were treacher ously killed, and Mr. Meacham, a member of the peace commission, wounded, For this the noted Capt. Jack and other chiefs were hanged. On the 25th of June, 1516, occurred the noted Custer massacre, which provoked long and angry controversy.

See moreSee less

We now know the important facts, Gen. Custer, being then under charges of insubordination, de ter mined to win another Indian fight and thus secure his standing in the army. With his regiment, the Seventh United States cavalry, he reached a big camp of Sioux at noon, and with great rashness attacked them on their own chosen ground while the In dizns and their horses were fresh and his ov i force worn out by a long march, Noth ing but disaster could follow, Maj. Reno, with part of the command, having attacked one end of the Indian camp, was able to get out upon high ground and sustain him sell till reenforcements came. Gen, Custer led an attack on the other end of the Indian camp; his command was surrounded and not a man escaped. The total loss was 21 killed, besides fifty-two wounded in Reno's command, Thero was a lond cry of indignation at somebody, but when all the facts were known there could be but one verdict: he had attacked a vastly superior force, as well armed as his own men, beiter mounted, betier posted and with all the advantages in favor of the Indians. But one result was possible. Sitting Boll and Rain-in-the-Face, the Rioux lead rs, became men of national fame. The war suited In their retreat into British America, whence they have since returned; nod now that par ticular band i: among the most peace ful, and several warriors who took part i that mas sacre are now quiet farmers on the Sioux reservation at Devil's Lake, PD. T. Fort Cus ter now dominates the once hostile section of Montana, and from it lately went the troops which had the battle with the Crows, The next vear the Nez Perces war inter ested the country; but it was settled by hard marching more than fighting. Gen. 0. O. Howard's troops made forced marches in pursuit of the Indians, over mountainsand across deserts, for 1,600 miles, In Angust, 1831, the Apaches of Arizona broke out again, committing the most horrible atroci tics. Four hundred warriors fell upon Col, Carr's command in the White mountains and massacred every one—seventy men and seven officers, Thus began the last Arizona Indian war which, after dragging tediously on for five years, was happily ended by Gen, Crook, tho Chief Geronimo surrendering and most of the hostiles being taken to Florida for safe keeping. Nearly two years of peace have succeeded, and now we have perhaps a big wi on hand with the Crows, The United States contains in round num bers nearly 800,000 Indians, Of these one fifth are highly civilized and two-fifths semi civilized. The former are in the older states and Indian territory; they have good homes and schools, printing presses and man ufactories, and are in a general way progres sive and enlightened. The semi-civilized in clude the Pueblos of New Mexico and Ari zona, the mission Indians of California and elsewhere, and a few others. Of the uncivil ized two-fifths more than half are peaceable. [ndewd, there has not been a time for forty years when one-fifth of all the Indians were hostile at one time. A new theory of duty toward them has Been adopted, The Hamp on and Carlisle schools are but types of the ww system. Awkwardly and slowly, it is rua, but in a sincere way, the Christian peo le of the United States are earnestly trying o redeem the Indians from heathenism and warharisin Copvists at the Lonvre, What astudy there is to be made of the odd coileetion of male and female copyists who people the galleries of the Louvre! Old women with gray curls bending over the rosy nudities of copies from Doucher—as it were Alecto illuminating the manuscript of An acreon; yellow skinned women with gray bibs and spectacles perched on the top of stepladders hung with green serge to spare the modesty of their lean limbs; porcelain painters grimacing through a magnifying glass as they copy the entombment of Titian: little withered old men in black blouses, their hair parted in the middle, and looking lik augelic dwarfs preserved in spirits of wine, What is the history of all these personilea tions of irony who have been east at the feet of masterpieces by hunger, misery, want, oi the desperation of a mistaken voeation Poor ridiculous folk picking up the crumb and alms of art at the feet of its gods, Anc yet these copyists must have their homes their pleasures and their passions. The)

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

This 1887 article revisits the fate of Lt. Henry Harrington, who died with Custer's Seventh Cavalry in 1876, but focuses on the mysterious disappearance of his widow Grace nearly three years earlier. It recounts their West Point romance and marriage before pivoting to her unexplained vanishing, which relatives had long kept quiet.

The Evening World · 19 November 1887 · page 4

NO WORD OF HER FOR YEARS. WHERE IS MRS. HARRINGTON, WHOSE HUSBAND FELL WITH CUSTER?

may bo found tho nsmo of Henry M. Harrington, Becond Lieutenant of Company C, of which 1. W. Custer was Captain. Along with bleuts. Porter and Murgea, and Assistant Hurgoon Lord, Llent. Harrington was reported ns mUslny, tho bodies not baring been Identified, bat there nercr has been

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report recounts the life of Lieutenant Harrington, a West Point graduate married into a prominent military family, who rejoined Custer's Seventh Cavalry despite being on leave and was presumed killed, his body unidentifiable among the dead. It describes his wife's grief and her public appearance in mourning beside Mrs. Custer at the dedication of Custer's monument.

The Evening World · 19 November 1887 · page 4

HUSBAND FELL WITH CUSTER?

prise. Young Harrington was assigned sb Becond Lieutenant to the Bevonth Iteglment of cavalry, under Gen. Custer, and started out with the pros poet of a successful military career. Shortly utter the marrlago LteuU Harrington, aocompanlod by bis wife, joined nls regiment on tho Western fron

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

In a later interview, Major Reno describes burying Custer's dead and dismisses rumors that Lieutenant Harrington was taken captive by Indians. He also criticizes Custer's judgment and courage, claiming the attack was unwarranted and recounting that Tom Custer's heart was cut out by Rain-in-the-Face.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 22 November 1887 · page 3

"WAS HARRINGTON BURNED. Major Reno Thinks lie Died at the Stake Custer's Courage Questioned, - H.arrisburg. Pa., Special. ' " " The story published concerning the mysteri ous disappearance of Mrs. Eve Harrington, widow of one of Custer's officers massacred at Xiittle Rosebud, was read with considerable in terest by Major 31. A. Reno, who is here on a visit. Major Reno was identified with the bat tle in which General Custer and his foroes were slaughtered. He was accused of cowardice in this fight, but a court-martial vindicated bim. "I knew Lieut Harington," said Major Reno, "and an elegant fellow he was.

See moreSee less

I am strongly of tbe opinion that be is not only dead but that he was burned at the stake. After the great battle I and several other officers, looking through field glasses, saw the Indians miles away eneaged in the war dance about three captives who were tied to the stake, and my impression was that Harrington was one of tbe unfortunate onea I rode over the field of the battle the morning after the fight," continued the Major; "and superintended the bnrial of Custer and his dead comrades. Custer was shot through the bead and through the heart but bis scalp was un touched. He was stripped of all bis clothing. Harrington was a magnificent specimen of hu manity, and I saw no resemblance to him among the dead whom we bnried. The supposition that be might bave been held a captive is absurd. Indians make captives of women, but never of men." The subject of the massacre warmed Major Reno np, and although he respects the memory of General Custer, it is very evident that he re garded the famous fighter as exceedingly inju dicious and not as gallant as he has a reputation for having been. He said General Cueter bore down on the Indians with his handful of men for the purpose of obtaining all the credit him self. "Tbe attack which occasioned tbe massaere was unwarranted," said Major Reno, "because the Indians were the rightful possessors of the land, and were entirely peaceable. Manr a brave man fell in that fight, and all because of Custer's ambition. When we found tbe dead men tbey lay in such a position as to show that they had fled after tbe first attack, and the Indians pursued them and shot them down, for in almost every instance they were shot in tbe back. When 1 came ta the body of Tom Custer, a brother of the Gen eral, and saw that his heart was cut out, I knew that Rain-in-the-Face had done it, for Custer had him imprisoned some days before for the larceny of the piece of cloth, and Rain-in-the Face swore vengeance." Major Reno then recited several instances of General Custer's lack of courage. "I knew him." said he. "to flourish his sword about his head and shout, "Follow me, men, follow me," and, then, when the fight began he would be found in the rear. 'During the rebellion, on one occasion I discovered him biding behind a tree when a battle was raging, and I am not the only person who knows that Custer was not a gallant fighter." The Movement for Nlblack for Governor. Indianapolis Letter in Cincinnati Enquirer. The recent meeting of the Indiana Democratic State central committee at Indianapolis, and the developments made at the time, have set the Indiana Democrats in Washington to talking about who will probably be the Democratic nominee for Governor next fall. There are those here who believe that the candidate will be a roan who has a good record as a soldier, but the advocates of this policy are somewhat annoyed over the plan developed at tbe meeting of the State committee to nominate Judge Niblaek. Several of tbe Indianians here say that this scheme of the Gray faction in favor of Niblaek will make more trouble in the party than there has been heretofore. It is claimed that Nib lack will encounter vigorous opposition frrm the friends of Green Smith all over tne State. It will be remembered that Niblaak, as a member of tbe Supreme Court of tbe State, was one of the judges who dodged the question of Green Smith's right to act as president of the State Senate during the Senatorial contest in the Legislature last winter. It is alleged that Judge Niblaek made a great mistake in assuming tbe position be did on tbe Smith-Roberts contro versy when the case was brought before the Supreme Conrt, and that any atleirjpt to nomi nate him for Governor will provoka a contest before and in the State conventiri that will, should the friends of the Gray iind Niblaek faction succeed, endanger the rnccess of the ticket at tbe polls. It is said tha a the nomina tion of Judge Niblaes would be '.ore distasteful to the friends of Green Smith than that of al most any other man who may be suggested. Notwithstanding all this.the N'.black programme oeveloped a great deal of strength at tbe recent meeting of the the State committee, and tbe friends of Governor Gray indicated a strong dis position to encourage it. Bishop Bedell's Condition. Cleveland, Nov. 21 A dispatch from Gam bier, O., reports Bishop Jiedell's condition as somewhat improved. Hia physicians say he is slowly out surely recovering. THIS INDIAN APOMS JOUaAtu TUESDAY, KOVEIBElx 22, 18S7. JOE' JEFFERSON, COMEDIAN. character actor, and plays the part of Job Arm -rord with force and expression. In his com Some Interesting Facts About Ilim and His pany are Miss Jessie Lee Randolph, a pleasing and attractive actress. Miss Jennie Satcerlee Forthconflns: Book of Remmiaoenoes. and others. There were large audiences and New York Correspondence Philadelphia Ciorth much applause yesterday. "Lost in London" all week, matinee and evening. American. Mr. Jefferson Is one of the gentlest and most

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report notes that Major Reno gave an interview to the New York World attacking Custer's competence and courage, and the newspaper dismisses this as unreliable given Reno's own record. It recounts that Reno was accused of cowardice during the Custer massacre but was cleared by a court of inquiry, and was later court-martialed twice for separate offenses, resulting in his dismissal from the army.

The Indianapolis Journal · 22 November 1887 · page 4

Some of the Democratic papers are talking of Governor Gray's military record. Some of them are praising him as a gallant soldier. For the purpose of shielding the Governor from the mortification and chagrin which these overzealous friends will bring upon him if they persist in this course, we give be low his record as appears in the Adjutantgeneral's reports of the State of Indiana: On Sept. 5, 1862, being a year and five months after the war had commenced, he en listed as a "colonel" in the Fourth Cavalry, Seventy-seventh Regiment, Indiana Volun teers.

See moreSee less

On that day he was commissioned as colonel of that regiment, and served five months and six days, when the record in forms us he resigned, but for what cause is not shown. (Vol. 3, page 12, Report of Ter rell, Adjutant-general.) . . Contemporaneous history informs us that his regiment was then tcross the Ohio river from Madison, this State, in Kentucky; and when the regiment started - South he started North. His next bit of military history is even more inconsequential than the first. He again enlisted as a "colonel" on July 12, 1863, this criminal evil. and was mustered out on July 17, 1863, the exact length of his service being five days, during which time he commanded the One-hundred-and-sixth Regiment, Indiana Volun teers. (Vol. 3, page 164, ibid.) - His next service, as appears in the history before referred to, is in connection with the bloodless Indiana Legion.' Unlike most sol busily engaged in the cjosmg up of the new book upon which he has been working for a long time. It will interest the friends of General Wallace to kaow that on Friday last be received a letter from Baron Tauch nitz, of Leipsic, asking authority to publish "Ben-Hur" in the celebrated Tauchnitz edi tions. This courtesy and compliment from it. j;t.: in , . . . xne uisuoguisueu puonsner, when he had a legal right to pirate the volume, is an acknowledgment of the standing of the General as an author, and the value it will be in Europe to issue an authorized edition of one of the most remarkable books of the century. - The New York World prints an interview with Major Reno, formerly of the regular army, in which he attacks the memory of Gen eral Custer, charging him with incapacity & an Indian fighter and with cowardice as a sol dier. General Custer's reputation is too well

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The article responds to Major Reno's claim that Custer was not truly brave and had avoided danger during battle. It argues Custer's heroic reputation is firmly established by testimony of those who fought with him, and that Reno should not try to overturn it so long after the fact.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 22 November 1887 · page 2

ub, riaoa to remark that 0nater wan anything bat a bravo man, that ho does not ' deserve his rcputaiion of hard fightor, that be hp.B known Cnater to ehout to his men to follow him and then when tho fight wau on to fie found in a place of bocurity. Major Reno dosa himaelf a groat wrong to start hia tonguo to wagging in thia way and at bo lato a day. Custer may not have bean at all timsa tho moat discreot Of m?Xl. frVin nHlnn in whioK l?n foil would better havo been avoided under all the circumstancea. But rashness has been seen before in bravo men.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Major Reno claims he saw Indians burning three captives at stakes after the battle, speculating one might have been Lieutenant Harrington, and accuses Custer's men of cowardice. General Terry's contemporary report and Harrington's brother-in-law dispute this, noting mutilated bodies were often unidentifiable and that Reno's account contradicts official records.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Indianapolis Journal · 23 November 1887 · page 3

About Caster. New Tort World. The dispatch from Harrisburg giving tbe views of Major iieno in regard to the fate of Lieuten ant Harrington and tbe conduet of General Cus ter and his men when attacked by the Indians under Sitting Buil evoked considerable com ment among military meu and civilians. Lieu tenant Harrington was one of four officers whose bodies were not identified after the battle. The other three officers were Lieutenants Porter and Sturges, and Assistant Surgeon Lord. All these were reported missing, on account of non-identification, although no doubt whatever was enter-, tained tost they had perished in the battle.

See moreSee less

Major Reno now says that after the battle he saw through his field-glass the Indians several miles away dancing around three captives who were fastened to stakes. One of these captives he believed to he Harrington, and thinks he was bnrned at the stake. He adds that Custer did not act in a gallant manner, and that many of his men were shot ia the back while flying from the Indians. Reno's charge of cowardice against General Custer and his men was mueh talked of yester

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

A newspaper looks back eleven years later at the Custer massacre, blaming Custer's rashness and desire to redeem his reputation after insubordination charges for attacking a superior, well-prepared Sioux force. It frames the disaster as unavoidable given the odds, and notes the war's aftermath including Sitting Bull's exile and later reconciliation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 25 November 1887 · page 7

Aleaaivhllo tho Sand Creek Indiana of tastcrn Colorado had given a littlo troublo; a forco und t Col. Chlvington fell upon them whilo in their homo camp and unsu3-p-cting, and massacred men, women nnd children. Tho tribo was nunlhilat' d. Karlv in isnl Gen. P. 13. Connor fe'l o;i tho Ilannoeks and Shoshones in thar vvln'"i crimp on lie .r river, Idaho, slnti'.U'lerc Isuuo h'.r drcd Hind brought tho rest to terms. In 1M'. tho Sioux of Minnesota roso and massa cred all the border settlers for :.'K) miles, save those who escaped to tho larger towns and military posts, Tho Indians were subdued and partially punished.

See moreSee less

Tho slaughter of Dl.ick Kettle's band in their winter camp by Gen. Custer, und ot tho Picga'js by a forco sent by Gen. Sheridan, next excited nttcu tiot., and tho latter wus feverely denounced, llolh these, however, were soon forgotten in the interest excited by tho famous, or infa mous, "Camp Grant massacre'' in Arizona. Pursuant to treaties lately mado a largo baud of Apaches, including the women nud children, had formed under tho protection of the United States fort. A motley band of Americans, .Mexicans and Indians of tho semi-civilized Papagos, Ytiinas, Pimas and Coco-Maricop,is mado a forced night march from tlieir rendezvous, fell upon these, In dians at daybreak nud slaughtered men, wo men nud children. A hundred nnd one per sons wero arrested by tho United States au thorities nnd brought to trial fortius action; but in th" stnto of public opinion iu that t( r ritory none of them could be convicted. After this tho monotony was somewhat broken, nnd it wns tho Indians' turn to have some rev ence. Art f'A In 1'sTSth" riodoesof southeastern Oregon "refused t" goon a new reservation," and war began: fiey fought all winter, and in tho spring ot INeJ took position in tho noted "lava beds" a legion of wild gorges and hidden val'"s, tho remains of a volcanic field mid tin re withstood tho troops till mid summer. At a conference with the Indians Gen. Cuiiby and Dr. Thomas were treacher ously killed, and Mr. Mea'dmai, a member of tho peace commission, wounded. For this tho noted Capt. Jack and other chiefs were hanged. On the lilth of June, l')Tl, occurred tho noted Custer massacre, which provoked long and angry controversy. We not." know the important facts. (Jen. Custer, being then under charges of insubordination, de termined to win another Indian fight nnd thus secure his standing iu tho army. With his regiment, tho Seventh United States caTalry, h" i cached a big camp of Sioux at noon, and with great rashness attackc 1 them on thciit own chosen ground whilo tho In di..ns and their horres wero fresh and his own force worn out by a long march. Noth ing but disaster could follow. Maj. Itcno, with part of tho conunand, having attacked ono cud of tho Indian camp, was able to get out upon high ground and sustain him self till re-enlorcements chmi. Gcu. Custer led an attack on tho other end of tho Indian camp: his command was surrounded and not n man escaped. Tho total loss was (il killed, beside fifty-two wounded iu Itc'io's command. Thero was a loud cry of indignation at somebody, but when all the iacts were known there could be but ono verdict: ho had attacked a vastly superior toree, as well armed as his own mc ., better nr i. .nted, better posted nnd with i.'l the advantages in favor of tho Indian-i. Put o::i result, was possible. Sitting Pull r.nd llain-in-tlie-Fnce, tho Sioux leaders, beciuno men of national fame. The war resulted in their retreat into liritish Am; rnu, whence tin., have sinco returned; and no.'.-that par tiouhr band is among the most ; reeful, nnd s. verr.l vvirriorx v. ho too!: pn:t i i that mas sacre are now qinit funnel's o i tho S:o:ix rest nation at Devil'.; Lake, 1). T. Fort Cus ter now dominates the once hostile section of Montana, and from it lately went tho troops which had the Kittle with tho Crows, Tho next year the Nez Pcrcej war inter ested the country; but it was settled by hard marching more '. Ii::n fighting. Gen. O. O. Howard's troops mime lorced marches in pursuit of tho Indians, over mountains and ncros i deserts, for l,ti00 miles. In August, ls-si, tinApaches of Arizona broke out c'li-i, committing the most horrible atroci Uv.s. l'i . I'uwhcd warrior., fell uj on Co!. Can" , ci : mum! iu the White i.i. ti.itains and luasv.oic 1 1 very one eevci.tvi.i .1 and seven o'.Ilccni. Thus began the last Arizona Indian war which, after dragging tediously on for five years, was happily ended by Gen. Crook, tho Chief Geronimo surrendering and most of the ho-tiles being taken to Florida for safe keeping. Nearly two years of inaeo have ..uccitded, and now wo havo pirhaps a big war on hand with the Crows. Ti e United States contains in round l um bers i.i arly i),oyo Indians. (If these one fifth arc highly civilk'od nud tv.o-df.hs scmi eivihzod, Tho former me m the older suites and Indian territory; they havo good homes and schools, printing presses c.n.l man ufactories, and aro in a general way progres sive anil enlightened, Tho semi-civilized in clude the Pii 'blos of New Mexico and Ari-, zona, the mi'sion Indians of California and elsewhere, und a few others. Of tho uncivil ized two-lift lis moro than half are peaceable. Indeed, there has not ben n a timo for forty years when ouc-llith of all the Indians wero hostile ut one time. Anew theory of duty toward them lias been adopted. Tho Hamp ton anil Carl: ! schools aro but types of tho .:ovv system. Awkwardly nnd t lowly, it is Irir, but in a m :cero way, the Christian peo ple of tho U'.ited States aro earnestly trying to redeem 1 1.' Indians from heathenism ami barbarism. (ejijl-ts at the I. on tie. What a st udy there is to 1m made of tho odd collection of nrilo and female copyists who people tho galleries of the Louvre! Old women with gray curl.-, landing over tho rosy nudities of copies trom Iiouchcr as it wero Alecto illuminating tho manuscript of An ncrcon; yello.v skinmsl women with gray bib and sj cctacles perched on the top of stepladders hung with green sorgo to sparo the modesty of their lean limbs; jiorcclaln painters grimacing tluough a magnifying :,l.s.-. as they copy tho entombment of Titian; little withered old men in black blouses, their hair pi.rle l in tho middle, nud looking like angelic dwarfs preserved in spirits of wino. What is tho history of all these jiersonillca tlons of Irony who have boon cast ut tho feet of masterpieces by hunger, misery, want, or tho disiiu'ration ot a mistaken vocation! Poor ridiculous folk picking up tho crumbs and alms of al l at tho feet of its gods, And yet thou' copyists must have their homes, their pleasures and their passions. They woo, in s'umiose, and marry, for lmvo wo not recant ucluug and innocent declaration ot low two piM'ics placed by an unknown hand c a the lid of nu unguarded collar boxl -mi Amateur

See the clipping

Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.

A satirical anecdote has a young man interrogating an old frontiersman about increasingly outlandish claims to fame, including guiding Brigham Young and inventing various frontier feats. The old man finally boasts he was the only man to survive the Custer massacre, lying wounded on the battlefield for forty-eight hours.

Macon Beacon · 26 November 1887 · page 1

tho only man that como through me Custer massacre alive, after layiu' on the battlefield wounded for forty-eight hours, surrounded hv tho groans an' shrieks of the dead an dym ! Hints niv record, young fel er, an I got tlio papers for cv'ry word of it!" CVii'cn? Tixium. .

See the clipping

The Livingston Enterprise · Livingston, Mont.

A Fort Worth special reports that the widow of Lieut. Harrington, killed in the Custer massacre, has been missing since 1885 and is presumed dead. She had become deranged, believing her husband was only captured by Indians, and vanished while searching for him.

The Livingston Enterprise · 26 November 1887 · page 1

A Fort W r orth, Texas, special says the widow of Lieut. Harrington, who per ished iu the Custer massacre, has been missing since 1885 and is supposed by

See the clipping