As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

September 1885

13 articles

The Morning Star · Carlisle, Pa.

This 1885 report about the Rock Springs massacre of Chinese miners in Wyoming invokes the Custer massacre by Sitting Bull's Sioux as a point of comparison for brutality, arguing the perpetrators of the Rock Springs killings were even more cowardly since they attacked as civilized men rather than 'savages.' The item is primarily about a different massacre but references Little Bighorn as a known historical benchmark for frontier violence.

The Morning Star · 1 September 1885 · page 4

by Indian savages, such as the "Modocs, )) or the Sioux as Sitting Bull’s band, who butcher The wretches ed General Custer and his men. who committed this second massaereof Wyom ing rank themselves among civilized men', but

See the clipping

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D.

An army officer who investigated since the Custer massacre claims Sitting Bull was not actually present at the battle despite his own claims otherwise, citing a story about his twin sons—one left behind and found after the fight. The officer ranks Sitting Bull as the least deserving of fame among Indian leaders, placing Spotted Tail, Red Cloud, and Chief Joseph above him.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Weekly Copiahan, 22 August 1885, The Salt Lake Herald, 30 August 1885.

Wrong

Turner County Herald · 3 September 1885 · page 2

Sitting Bull's Twin Boys

who brought at oncn summons and a A release. Mr. Wallace raised himself from his 'peaceful pillow—there was not even time for him, like Colonel Nowcome, tp say Adsum"—his head dropped, and his eighty-first year, his lonely life, and the year of our Lord 1870 came to un end together. One oan almost fancy that even in the sol emn moment when his soul left the weary body there may have come to him a flash of satisfnetfon that he had baffled all the curiono, intrusive dis turbers of his peace.

See moreSee less

In the express ive language of Shakespeare, "he died and made no sign.*' nolumg a letter in his lmnd, and re mark, "This is from my lady friend in Edinburgh." When ho had passed away, Mrs. Huntington, with rare good taste and pathetic kindness, wrote a lotter de scribing his last moment). Sho addressed it to "Mr. Wallace's Ladv Friend, Ed inburgh," and sent it "through tho chain of banks through which the old man's money had come. In duo timo a reply arrived—cold, formal, unsympa thetic. It was signod "Mr. ll'aUace's Lady Friend." u. "Who was Mr. Wallace?" I see the question in your eyes. I wont to East hampton in tho autumn of 1878, and did my best to find out. I talked with Miss Cornelia Huntington (author of a charming little monograph anent East hampton and its ways in days gone by, celled "Sea Spray") and I should count a pilgrimage fruitful which gave mo the ploasure of their acquaintance. I found them at tho time of my last visit enjoying a green old ago, loved and re spectod by a}l. They told me much of great interest about Mr. Wallace, and among other things they spoke of find ing copies of his accounts (of charities in his nativo land) with tho headings torn off. One had been carolossly torn, and on it I found a name. 1 sent this name with a mass of notes to my late accomplished friend Robort Mackenzie, Esq., of Dundee, Scotland, author of A liixlorij of the Kineteenlh Century, and other interesting works. In a few weeks ho wrote me that he was "on the trail." In a few weeks more ho sent me what he properly called "a very tautalizing letter." Said he, "I know tho mystery to tho very bottom, but— 1 maij not tell you.'"' Not a little disappointed, I commu nicated this information to a circle of equally disnppointed friends. One of thorn, a distinguished divine, told mo that "it made his flesh creep like one of Wilkio Collins' storien." Then I went to Scotland? No—to Colorado, of all places in tho world, and at the foot of I'iko's Peak, in the summer of 1879, I found out all about the poor exile. As living persons are concerned in tho manner of my discovery, I may not rightly publish tho details thereof but they are among the strongest hnnpen ings of any life. Sutlico it to say that on my return 1 held all the clews, proof, and facts in my hands, and that only now am I permitted to tell tho truth about John Wallace. in. Perhaps some of you know how distin guished and important a judicial officer is tho High Sheriff of a greai Scotch county. Such distinguished and im portant oHicor was, in 1840, Sheriff W resident of Edinburgh, lie was a bachelor of 50 years of age. He was fauii'd for his benevolence and his good work?. Ho was the friend to the poor, the widow, and the orphan. His services to the State had earned him a public testimonial. Ho had "honor, love, obedience, troops of friends." Ho was a founder and ardent supporler of Sunday-schcols. People flocked from cultured Edinburgh homes to hoar his weekly addresses to tho children. One day, at tho height of his fame, there was made against him the subtle charge of a gr.ive and mysterious crime. At (i o'clock in tho eveniug the Lord High Advocate wont to a mutual friend. "Go to Sheriff W at once," said he, in sad and measured tones, "and tell him that when I go to my ofhco at 10 clock to-morrow morning a war rant will issue for his arrest." That night Sheriff W died out of Scotland. He had just time to sny to a friend that he was not guilty of more than an indiscretion, but that he could not face oven the shame of that. His disappearance is mourned in Ed inburgh after all these long years, and tears como to the eve3 of old fr.ends when it is mentioned. The man who so patiently bore the long crucifixion of a self-imposed exile, tho man who en dured tho penance of thirty-one years among strangers in a strange land, tho man who read tho beautiful service in the little Easthampton Church, was no John Wallace. Under the white marble tablet in the old Easthampton cemetery sleeps the scholar, the great jurist, tho courtly gentloman, the humble Chris tian—Sheriff W .—A. A. Hayes, in Harper's Magazine. Two Problems in (Jnstronomics. In a weaving mill near Manchester, where the ventilation was bad, tho pro prietor causod a fan to bo mounted. The operators, instead of thanking tlieir employer, made a formal com plaint that the ventilator had increased their appetites, and, therefore, entitled them to corresponding increase in wages. By stopping the fau a part of the day tho voutilation and voracity of the establishment were brought to a medium standard, and tho complaints ceased. The operatives' wages would but iust support them any additional demand by tire stomach could only bo answered by drafts .upon their backs, which were by no means in a condition to answer them. In Edinburgh a club was provided with a dinner in a well-ventilated apartment, the air being perfumed as it entered, imitating in snccession the fragrance of the lavender nnd the orange flower. During the dinner the members enjoyed themselves as usual, but were not a little surprised at tho 'announcement of the provider, that they had drank three times as much wine as he had usually provided. The perfume of tho air was the cause of the increased appetito for wine. Silting Bull's Twin UoyF. Ah army officer, who has been inves tigating the subjoct ever since tho mas sacre of Custer and his men, expresses the opinion that Sitting Bull was not present at the Custer massacre, not withstanding liii statements to the con trary. He soys he lias ascertained that Sitting Bull has two twin boys. One of them was christened "Tho Boy that was Taken," and tho other "Tho boy that was Left." He says that Sitting Bull and Mrs. Bull wero in such a hurry to run away that't.bev left one ot' lie twins. 'J he infant was in the thickest of tho fight, and escaped injury of any kind by crawling under the roots of a tree. This was "ilie Boy that was Left." After the massacre Mrs. Sit ting Bull went to the scone an 1 found tho child. This officer favs Silting Bull is a mean kind of an Indian, ami is not entitle.' titthefamo.th.it he has received. Spol'r 1 Tail -.van the best Indian and the bravest 'ighter. Bo.l Cloud ame next, and Cixief Joseph unxt., Sittitg Bull he places last last on the list..—Ex. Ix forty years the mean duration of human life in England has gained two years among males and nearly three and one-linlf years among females A WIDOW in \N ilton, Connecticut, savs she nevor intends to. inarrv again. Sho is 104. 0

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A light society/gossip column profiles local St. Paul figures, including police officer Charley Scheffer, noted as a frontier scout at the time of the Custer massacre. The piece is anecdotal and humorous, covering many unrelated local personalities.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 5 September 1885 · page 5

TRIFLES

D Charley Scheffer, one of the most dapper officers on the force, was a scout on the frontier at the time of the Custer massacre

See the clipping

The Sun · Morris, Minn. · and 1 other paper

A brief notes that Sheridan's new staff appointments won't be announced until October, with speculation that Col. Frederick Benteen may be named an aide-de-camp. The item recalls that Benteen was a captain in the Seventh Cavalry at the time of the Custer massacre and saved the rest of the regiment.

The Sun · 10 September 1885 · page 2

prominent army officers herq that Lieut. Gen. Sheridan has concluded to tender one of the vacant positions as aide-de-camp on his staff to Col. Fred W. B. Ben teen, major of the Ninth cavalry. Col. Benteen com manded a regiment in the volunteers, and iis captain of the Seventh cavalry at the time of the Custer massacre, saved the rest pf £he regiment.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 10 September 1885

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

A St. Louis Globe-Democrat correspondent revisits the Little Bighorn massacre nine years later, describing the total annihilation of Custer's five troops and crediting Crow scout Curley as the only survivor, who escaped by disguising himself in a Sioux blanket. The writer notes Curley's disjointed recollections and describes attempts to interview Sitting Bull, Rain-in-the-Face, and other participants who avoid discussing the battle.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Wood County Reporter · 10 September 1885 · page 6

Massacre. A correspondent of the St. Louis Globe Democrat writes a very inter esting article on the incidents sur rounding the death of Gutter. The article is too long ‘obe republished in its entirety, but the following extracts from it will be ot interest: ‘ Niue years ago last June occurred on the Little Big Horn R ver. in Montana, near the present sue of Fort Custer, the complete annihilation of Lieut Col. George A. Custer, 7 b U. S. Cavalry, and dve troops of his reg iment. Very little is known of the happenings of that dreadful June day, since every soldier, citzen and team ster who marched into the Valley of the Little Big Horn with the intrepid cavalry leader perished on the field with him.

See moreSee less

There is however, a single survivor, a Crow scout named Curley who saved himself by donning a Sioux blanket hastily snatched from a dead warrior and amid the con fusion to the Wolf Mountains. Cur ley has often been questioned by the writer as the exact manner in which so many soldiers were killed withou one being left alive, but the poor fel low’s mind seems to become unbal anced when the subj.-ct of the fight is broached, and he wanders off inlivin coherencies foreign to the subject. About his own escape he talks inielli" gibly enough. He says he darted up a ravine apparently in pursuit of a party of fleeing soldiers, and when at a safe distance paused on a ridge and saw the Sioux massacre ever\* blue coat. When the soldiers were all allied, Curley c mtinued his flight, and afterward j lined Gen. Terry’s command at the junction of the Lillie and Big Horn rivers Tke writer has talked with Silting Bull, Rain in theFace (the most desperated and blood thirsty Indian in the whole north west), Iron Horn and a number of other famous bucks,besides the squaws and other Indian women who undeni ably did the mutilating and scalping, but one and all of them seem to shun the subject and will tell nothing about it. [sources OF INFORMATION. s The only reliable information is to be had from an actual inspection of the field, close conversation with tne officers present, with Reno on the hill, what can be gathered from Curley’s narrative, and the notes ©f the New 1 York Herald correspondent, Kellogg, who was killed with Custer, but who kept an accurate account of the marches and occurrences up to the night of Jane 24, the eve of the fight. If Sitting Bull had only been aware of hi& power, be could, without the slightest difficulty, after finishing Custer, have turned his attention to Reno and kept at him until the latter was overpowered by numbers, then attacked and annihilated Bmteen’s three companies, then used up McDougall's one company which was guarding the pack train, and finally wiped out Gen. Terry’s whole outfit, which numbered less than Custer’s, and which was camped a few miles below at the forms of the Little and Big Horn Rivers. Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse were both at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, and Sitting Bull has been credited with an im portance in that affair which really does net belong to him. His own di rect following was comparatively small, numbering not more than forty lodges all told. Rain-in-the-face was undoubtedly the leader of the hostiies, and he was ably backed up by Crow King, Gall, Crow Eagle, Low Dogand numerous other doughty chieftains and head men. Of this latter class was the Ball family, father and son, Jumping Bull and Sitting Bull, who had never accepted the reservation system, would not recognize the auth ority of the government, and insisted upon remaining wild and perfectly free from control. They were head men or medicine men, and not chiefs. ♦ * * * The valley of the creek was follow ed toward the Little Big Horn, Custer on the right of the creek, Rene on the left of it, Benteen off still further to the left and not in sight. About 11 o’clock Custer motioned to Rmo to cross over and come to him, when their last conversation was held prior to charging the village. At 12:30 the report was brought back by the scouts that the village was only two miles ahead and running away. Reno was now directed to recross his com mand, to move forward as rapidly as prudent, and to charge, with the un derstanding Custer would follow him up and support him.”

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

A newspaper correspondent recounts Crow scout Curley's story of fleeing up a ravine and witnessing the massacre of Custer's men, then speculates on how the Sioux could have destroyed Reno, Benteen, and Terry's forces too. The piece also assesses Native leadership, claiming Rain-in-the-Face was the true leader of the hostiles while downplaying Sitting Bull's role.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Wood County Reporter · 10 September 1885 · page 6

Massacre. A correspondent of the St. Louis Globe Democrat writes a very inter esting article on the incidents sur rounding the death of Gutter. The article is too long ‘obe republished in its entirety, but the following extracts from it will be ot interest: ‘ Niue years ago last June occurred on the Little Big Horn R ver. in Montana, near the present sue of Fort Custer, the complete annihilation of Lieut Col. George A. Custer, 7 b U. S. Cavalry, and dve troops of his reg iment. Very little is known of the happenings of that dreadful June day, since every soldier, citzen and team ster who marched into the Valley of the Little Big Horn with the intrepid cavalry leader perished on the field with him.

See moreSee less

There is however, a single survivor, a Crow scout named Curley who saved himself by donning a Sioux blanket hastily snatched from a dead warrior and amid the con fusion to the Wolf Mountains. Cur ley has often been questioned by the writer as the exact manner in which so many soldiers were killed withou one being left alive, but the poor fel low’s mind seems to become unbal anced when the subj.-ct of the fight is broached, and he wanders off inlivin coherencies foreign to the subject. About his own escape he talks inielli" gibly enough. He says he darted up a ravine apparently in pursuit of a party of fleeing soldiers, and when at a safe distance paused on a ridge and saw the Sioux massacre ever\* blue coat. When the soldiers were all allied, Curley c mtinued his flight, and afterward j lined Gen. Terry’s command at the junction of the Lillie and Big Horn rivers Tke writer has talked with Silting Bull, Rain in theFace (the most desperated and blood thirsty Indian in the whole north west), Iron Horn and a number of other famous bucks,besides the squaws and other Indian women who undeni ably did the mutilating and scalping, but one and all of them seem to shun the subject and will tell nothing about it. [sources OF INFORMATION. s The only reliable information is to be had from an actual inspection of the field, close conversation with tne officers present, with Reno on the hill, what can be gathered from Curley’s narrative, and the notes ©f the New 1 York Herald correspondent, Kellogg, who was killed with Custer, but who kept an accurate account of the marches and occurrences up to the night of Jane 24, the eve of the fight. If Sitting Bull had only been aware of hi& power, be could, without the slightest difficulty, after finishing Custer, have turned his attention to Reno and kept at him until the latter was overpowered by numbers, then attacked and annihilated Bmteen’s three companies, then used up McDougall's one company which was guarding the pack train, and finally wiped out Gen. Terry’s whole outfit, which numbered less than Custer’s, and which was camped a few miles below at the forms of the Little and Big Horn Rivers. Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse were both at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, and Sitting Bull has been credited with an im portance in that affair which really does net belong to him. His own di rect following was comparatively small, numbering not more than forty lodges all told. Rain-in-the-face was undoubtedly the leader of the hostiies, and he was ably backed up by Crow King, Gall, Crow Eagle, Low Dogand numerous other doughty chieftains and head men. Of this latter class was the Ball family, father and son, Jumping Bull and Sitting Bull, who had never accepted the reservation system, would not recognize the auth ority of the government, and insisted upon remaining wild and perfectly free from control. They were head men or medicine men, and not chiefs. ♦ * * * The valley of the creek was follow ed toward the Little Big Horn, Custer on the right of the creek, Rene on the left of it, Benteen off still further to the left and not in sight. About 11 o’clock Custer motioned to Rmo to cross over and come to him, when their last conversation was held prior to charging the village. At 12:30 the report was brought back by the scouts that the village was only two miles ahead and running away. Reno was now directed to recross his com mand, to move forward as rapidly as prudent, and to charge, with the un derstanding Custer would follow him up and support him.”

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

This report, published nine years after the battle, describes Custer and Reno's approach to the Little Bighorn village and names Rain-in-the-Face as the real leader of the hostiles rather than Sitting Bull. It claims the village held an enormous number of warriors, explaining the scale of the 'massacre'.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.

Wrong

Wood County Reporter · 10 September 1885 · page 6

Massacre. A correspondent of the St. Louis Globe Democrat writes a very inter esting article on the incidents sur rounding the death of Gutter. The article is too long ‘obe republished in its entirety, but the following extracts from it will be ot interest: ‘ Niue years ago last June occurred on the Little Big Horn R ver. in Montana, near the present sue of Fort Custer, the complete annihilation of Lieut Col. George A. Custer, 7 b U. S. Cavalry, and dve troops of his reg iment. Very little is known of the happenings of that dreadful June day, since every soldier, citzen and team ster who marched into the Valley of the Little Big Horn with the intrepid cavalry leader perished on the field with him.

See moreSee less

There is however, a single survivor, a Crow scout named Curley who saved himself by donning a Sioux blanket hastily snatched from a dead warrior and amid the con fusion to the Wolf Mountains. Cur ley has often been questioned by the writer as the exact manner in which so many soldiers were killed withou one being left alive, but the poor fel low’s mind seems to become unbal anced when the subj.-ct of the fight is broached, and he wanders off inlivin coherencies foreign to the subject. About his own escape he talks inielli" gibly enough. He says he darted up a ravine apparently in pursuit of a party of fleeing soldiers, and when at a safe distance paused on a ridge and saw the Sioux massacre ever\* blue coat. When the soldiers were all allied, Curley c mtinued his flight, and afterward j lined Gen. Terry’s command at the junction of the Lillie and Big Horn rivers Tke writer has talked with Silting Bull, Rain in theFace (the most desperated and blood thirsty Indian in the whole north west), Iron Horn and a number of other famous bucks,besides the squaws and other Indian women who undeni ably did the mutilating and scalping, but one and all of them seem to shun the subject and will tell nothing about it. [sources OF INFORMATION. s The only reliable information is to be had from an actual inspection of the field, close conversation with tne officers present, with Reno on the hill, what can be gathered from Curley’s narrative, and the notes ©f the New 1 York Herald correspondent, Kellogg, who was killed with Custer, but who kept an accurate account of the marches and occurrences up to the night of Jane 24, the eve of the fight. If Sitting Bull had only been aware of hi& power, be could, without the slightest difficulty, after finishing Custer, have turned his attention to Reno and kept at him until the latter was overpowered by numbers, then attacked and annihilated Bmteen’s three companies, then used up McDougall's one company which was guarding the pack train, and finally wiped out Gen. Terry’s whole outfit, which numbered less than Custer’s, and which was camped a few miles below at the forms of the Little and Big Horn Rivers. Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse were both at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, and Sitting Bull has been credited with an im portance in that affair which really does net belong to him. His own di rect following was comparatively small, numbering not more than forty lodges all told. Rain-in-the-face was undoubtedly the leader of the hostiies, and he was ably backed up by Crow King, Gall, Crow Eagle, Low Dogand numerous other doughty chieftains and head men. Of this latter class was the Ball family, father and son, Jumping Bull and Sitting Bull, who had never accepted the reservation system, would not recognize the auth ority of the government, and insisted upon remaining wild and perfectly free from control. They were head men or medicine men, and not chiefs. ♦ * * * The valley of the creek was follow ed toward the Little Big Horn, Custer on the right of the creek, Rene on the left of it, Benteen off still further to the left and not in sight. About 11 o’clock Custer motioned to Rmo to cross over and come to him, when their last conversation was held prior to charging the village. At 12:30 the report was brought back by the scouts that the village was only two miles ahead and running away. Reno was now directed to recross his com mand, to move forward as rapidly as prudent, and to charge, with the un derstanding Custer would follow him up and support him.”

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

Nine years after Little Bighorn, a St. Louis Globe-Democrat correspondent recounts the annihilation of Custer and five troops, noting that Crow scout Curley was the sole survivor by disguising himself in a Sioux blanket. The article claims Curley watched from a ridge as the Sioux killed every soldier before fleeing to join General Terry's command.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Mineral Point Tribune · 10 September 1885 · page 6

Custer's Massacre

The Dead sea is an old and decrepit salt lake iu a very advanced stage of an angel.” evaporation. It lies several feet below the level of the Mediterranean, just us the Caspian lies several feet below the level of the Black sea; and at m be lli cases the surface must once have been continuous, it is cl*ar that the water of either sheet must have tlneo up to a considerable extent. But an acrordion.” while the Caspian has shrunk only to eightx-five feet below the Black sea, the Dead sea has shrunk to the enor mous depth of 1,292 feet below the r Custer's Massacre.

See moreSee less

A correspondent of the St. Louis Globe Dmocrat writes a very inter esting article on the incidents ~„r _ rounding the death of Custer. The article is too lone to be republished , tl its entirety, but the following extract* from it will be ot interest: ‘ Niue years ago last June occurred on the Little Big Horn River, m Montana, near the present site of Fort Caster, the complete annihilation of Lieut. Col. George A. Custer, 7ih U S. Cavalry, and live troops of his reo’ im nt. Very little is known of tlie bappeningsof that dreadful June day since every soldier, cit zen and team ster who marched into the Valley of the Little Big Ilorn with the intrepid cavalry leader perished oh the field with him. There is however, a single survivor, a Crow scout named Curley who saved himself by donning a Sioux blanket hastily snatched from a dead warrior and ei-capmg amid the con fusion to the Wolf Mountains. Cur ley has often been questioned by the writer as the exact manner in which so many soldiers were killed without one being left alive, but the poor f*u low’s mind seems to become unbal anced when tho subject of the fight is broached, and he wanders off into in coherencies foreign to the subjeel. About his own escape he talks intelli gibly enough. He says he darted up a ravine apparently; in pursuit of a, party of fleving soldiers, and when at a safe distance paused on a ridge and saw the Sioux massacre every blue coat. When the soldiers were all allied, Curley continued his flight, and afterward joined Gen. Terry’s command at the junction of the Luile and Big Horn rivers The writer has talked with Sitting Bull, Rain in theFace (the most desperated and blood thirsty Indian in the whole north west), Iron Horn and a number of other famous backs,besides the squaws and other Indian women who undeni ably did the mutilating and scalping, but one and all of them seem to shun the subject and will tel) nothing about it. [sources of information. The only reliable information is to be had from an actual inspection of the field, close conversation with the officers present, with Reno on the hill, what can be gathered from Curley’s narrative, and the notes of the New York Herald correspondent, Kellogg, who was killed with Custer, but who kept an accurate account of the marches and occurrences up to the night of Jane 24, the eve of the fight. If Silting Bull had only been aware of his power, he could, without the slightest difficulty, after finishing Custer, have turned his attention to Reno and kept at him until the latter was overpowered by numbers, then attacked and annihilated Benteen’s three companies, then used up MeDougall’s one company which was guarding the pack train, and finally wiped out Gen. Terry’s whole, outfit, which numbered less than Custer’s, and which was camped a few miles below at the forks of the Little and Big Horn Rivers. Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse were both at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, and Sitting Bull has been credited with an im portance in (hat affair which really does not belong to him. His own di rect following was comparatively small, numbering not more than forty lodges all told Rain-in-lhe-face was undoubtedly the leader of thehostiles, and he was ably hacked up by Crow King, Gall, Crow Eagle, Low Dog and numerous other doughty chieliains and head men. Of this latter class was the Bull family, father and son, Jumping Bull and Sitting Bull, who had never accepted the reservation system, would not recogmzs tho auth ority of the government, and insisted upon remaining wild and perfectly free from control. They were head men or medicine men, and not chiefs. * * ♦ * The valley of the creek was follow ed toward the Little Big Horn, Custer on the right of the creek, Reno on the left, of it, Benteen off still further to the left and not in sight. A bout 11 o’clock Custer motioned to Reno to cross over and come to him, when their last conversation was held prioi to charging the village. At 12:30 the report was brought back by the scouts that the village was ouly two miles ahead and running away. Reno was now directed to recross his com mand, to move forward as rapidly as prudent, and to charge, with the un derstanding Custer would follow him up and support him.” THE LAST SEEN OF CUSTER

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

Nine years after the battle, this report revisits the Little Bighorn, describing Crow scout Curley as the lone survivor of Custer's command who escaped disguised in a Sioux blanket. It also notes interviews with Sitting Bull, Rain-in-the-Face, and others, downplaying Sitting Bull's direct role and crediting Rain-in-the-Face as the true leader of the hostiles.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Mineral Point Tribune · 10 September 1885 · page 6

The Dead sea is an old and decrepit salt lake iu a very advanced stage of an angel.” evaporation. It lies several feet below the level of the Mediterranean, just us the Caspian lies several feet below the level of the Black sea; and at m be lli cases the surface must once have been continuous, it is cl*ar that the water of either sheet must have tlneo up to a considerable extent. But an acrordion.” while the Caspian has shrunk only to eightx-five feet below the Black sea, the Dead sea has shrunk to the enor mous depth of 1,292 feet below the r Custer's Massacre.

See moreSee less

A correspondent of the St. Louis Globe Dmocrat writes a very inter esting article on the incidents ~„r _ rounding the death of Custer. The article is too lone to be republished , tl its entirety, but the following extract* from it will be ot interest: ‘ Niue years ago last June occurred on the Little Big Horn River, m Montana, near the present site of Fort Caster, the complete annihilation of Lieut. Col. George A. Custer, 7ih U S. Cavalry, and live troops of his reo’ im nt. Very little is known of tlie bappeningsof that dreadful June day since every soldier, cit zen and team ster who marched into the Valley of the Little Big Ilorn with the intrepid cavalry leader perished oh the field with him. There is however, a single survivor, a Crow scout named Curley who saved himself by donning a Sioux blanket hastily snatched from a dead warrior and ei-capmg amid the con fusion to the Wolf Mountains. Cur ley has often been questioned by the writer as the exact manner in which so many soldiers were killed without one being left alive, but the poor f*u low’s mind seems to become unbal anced when tho subject of the fight is broached, and he wanders off into in coherencies foreign to the subjeel. About his own escape he talks intelli gibly enough. He says he darted up a ravine apparently; in pursuit of a, party of fleving soldiers, and when at a safe distance paused on a ridge and saw the Sioux massacre every blue coat. When the soldiers were all allied, Curley continued his flight, and afterward joined Gen. Terry’s command at the junction of the Luile and Big Horn rivers The writer has talked with Sitting Bull, Rain in theFace (the most desperated and blood thirsty Indian in the whole north west), Iron Horn and a number of other famous backs,besides the squaws and other Indian women who undeni ably did the mutilating and scalping, but one and all of them seem to shun the subject and will tel) nothing about it. [sources of information. The only reliable information is to be had from an actual inspection of the field, close conversation with the officers present, with Reno on the hill, what can be gathered from Curley’s narrative, and the notes of the New York Herald correspondent, Kellogg, who was killed with Custer, but who kept an accurate account of the marches and occurrences up to the night of Jane 24, the eve of the fight. If Silting Bull had only been aware of his power, he could, without the slightest difficulty, after finishing Custer, have turned his attention to Reno and kept at him until the latter was overpowered by numbers, then attacked and annihilated Benteen’s three companies, then used up MeDougall’s one company which was guarding the pack train, and finally wiped out Gen. Terry’s whole, outfit, which numbered less than Custer’s, and which was camped a few miles below at the forks of the Little and Big Horn Rivers. Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse were both at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, and Sitting Bull has been credited with an im portance in (hat affair which really does not belong to him. His own di rect following was comparatively small, numbering not more than forty lodges all told Rain-in-lhe-face was undoubtedly the leader of thehostiles, and he was ably hacked up by Crow King, Gall, Crow Eagle, Low Dog and numerous other doughty chieliains and head men. Of this latter class was the Bull family, father and son, Jumping Bull and Sitting Bull, who had never accepted the reservation system, would not recogmzs tho auth ority of the government, and insisted upon remaining wild and perfectly free from control. They were head men or medicine men, and not chiefs. * * ♦ * The valley of the creek was follow ed toward the Little Big Horn, Custer on the right of the creek, Reno on the left, of it, Benteen off still further to the left and not in sight. A bout 11 o’clock Custer motioned to Reno to cross over and come to him, when their last conversation was held prioi to charging the village. At 12:30 the report was brought back by the scouts that the village was ouly two miles ahead and running away. Reno was now directed to recross his com mand, to move forward as rapidly as prudent, and to charge, with the un derstanding Custer would follow him up and support him.” THE LAST SEEN OF CUSTER

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

This 1885 piece reexamines the Battle of the Little Bighorn nine years later, downplaying Sitting Bull's role and crediting Rain-in-the-Face as the true leader of the hostile forces. It also details the troop movements of Custer, Reno, and Benteen on the day of the battle, including Reno's charge toward the massive Indian village.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.

Wrong

Mineral Point Tribune · 10 September 1885 · page 6

The Dead sea is an old and decrepit salt lake iu a very advanced stage of an angel.” evaporation. It lies several feet below the level of the Mediterranean, just us the Caspian lies several feet below the level of the Black sea; and at m be lli cases the surface must once have been continuous, it is cl*ar that the water of either sheet must have tlneo up to a considerable extent. But an acrordion.” while the Caspian has shrunk only to eightx-five feet below the Black sea, the Dead sea has shrunk to the enor mous depth of 1,292 feet below the r Custer's Massacre.

See moreSee less

A correspondent of the St. Louis Globe Dmocrat writes a very inter esting article on the incidents ~„r _ rounding the death of Custer. The article is too lone to be republished , tl its entirety, but the following extract* from it will be ot interest: ‘ Niue years ago last June occurred on the Little Big Horn River, m Montana, near the present site of Fort Caster, the complete annihilation of Lieut. Col. George A. Custer, 7ih U S. Cavalry, and live troops of his reo’ im nt. Very little is known of tlie bappeningsof that dreadful June day since every soldier, cit zen and team ster who marched into the Valley of the Little Big Ilorn with the intrepid cavalry leader perished oh the field with him. There is however, a single survivor, a Crow scout named Curley who saved himself by donning a Sioux blanket hastily snatched from a dead warrior and ei-capmg amid the con fusion to the Wolf Mountains. Cur ley has often been questioned by the writer as the exact manner in which so many soldiers were killed without one being left alive, but the poor f*u low’s mind seems to become unbal anced when tho subject of the fight is broached, and he wanders off into in coherencies foreign to the subjeel. About his own escape he talks intelli gibly enough. He says he darted up a ravine apparently; in pursuit of a, party of fleving soldiers, and when at a safe distance paused on a ridge and saw the Sioux massacre every blue coat. When the soldiers were all allied, Curley continued his flight, and afterward joined Gen. Terry’s command at the junction of the Luile and Big Horn rivers The writer has talked with Sitting Bull, Rain in theFace (the most desperated and blood thirsty Indian in the whole north west), Iron Horn and a number of other famous backs,besides the squaws and other Indian women who undeni ably did the mutilating and scalping, but one and all of them seem to shun the subject and will tel) nothing about it. [sources of information. The only reliable information is to be had from an actual inspection of the field, close conversation with the officers present, with Reno on the hill, what can be gathered from Curley’s narrative, and the notes of the New York Herald correspondent, Kellogg, who was killed with Custer, but who kept an accurate account of the marches and occurrences up to the night of Jane 24, the eve of the fight. If Silting Bull had only been aware of his power, he could, without the slightest difficulty, after finishing Custer, have turned his attention to Reno and kept at him until the latter was overpowered by numbers, then attacked and annihilated Benteen’s three companies, then used up MeDougall’s one company which was guarding the pack train, and finally wiped out Gen. Terry’s whole, outfit, which numbered less than Custer’s, and which was camped a few miles below at the forks of the Little and Big Horn Rivers. Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse were both at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, and Sitting Bull has been credited with an im portance in (hat affair which really does not belong to him. His own di rect following was comparatively small, numbering not more than forty lodges all told Rain-in-lhe-face was undoubtedly the leader of thehostiles, and he was ably hacked up by Crow King, Gall, Crow Eagle, Low Dog and numerous other doughty chieliains and head men. Of this latter class was the Bull family, father and son, Jumping Bull and Sitting Bull, who had never accepted the reservation system, would not recogmzs tho auth ority of the government, and insisted upon remaining wild and perfectly free from control. They were head men or medicine men, and not chiefs. * * ♦ * The valley of the creek was follow ed toward the Little Big Horn, Custer on the right of the creek, Reno on the left, of it, Benteen off still further to the left and not in sight. A bout 11 o’clock Custer motioned to Reno to cross over and come to him, when their last conversation was held prioi to charging the village. At 12:30 the report was brought back by the scouts that the village was ouly two miles ahead and running away. Reno was now directed to recross his com mand, to move forward as rapidly as prudent, and to charge, with the un derstanding Custer would follow him up and support him.” THE LAST SEEN OF CUSTER

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

Nine years after the battle, a reporter claims to have obtained new testimony from Sitting Bull about how Custer actually died, disproving Rain-in-the-Face's claim to have killed him. The passage recaps the background of the 1876 campaign against the Sioux leading up to the battle before presenting this supposed new evidence.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Turner County Herald, 3 September 1885, Wood County Reporter, 10 September 1885, Mineral Point Tribune, 10 September 1885.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 23 September 1885 · page 4

HOW GEN. CUSTER DIED. A TALK BETWEEN AN OLD SOLDIER AND SITTING BULL

into Montana and the British Northwest, had become aggressive, and that frequent charges had been made against them of murder and theft. They finally lmrat inonv frnm flio control of the agents. The aid or tho war department was invoked. The Seventh Uuited States cavalry, of wich General Custer was the commander, in response to orders, quickly took the field and started in pursuit of the ''renegade" Sioux. After a hard ma'-cb, following the trail made by the Indians, scouts brought in word on June 21th. that the enemy was only a short d stance in advance, and it was further learned that the camp of the redskins, which was a very large one, extended along the Little Big Horn creek or river, [an affluent of the Big Horn, for some four or five miles.

See moreSee less

Custer's plan of attack was to divide his force, the sccond portion being under command of Major Reno, and to strike the Indians at both ends of their camp simultaneously. On the morning of June 25th, all arrangements having been made, Custer with his men filed oft' to the right, or down the stream, while Reno went to the left. The latter was the first to arrive at the objective point, and immediately charged across, the stream and began the attack. A stout resistance was met with from the Sioux,

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

Nine years after the battle, this piece recounts the 1876 campaign against the Sioux, describing Reno's charge and retreat to the bluffs and Custer's separate attack that ended in his command being wiped out. The report frames this history as background for a visit to Buffalo Bill's Wild West show, accompanied by veteran policeman John Ryan.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 13 days earlier.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 23 September 1885 · page 4

I 1 THE SCARECROW. t c In yonder field lie stands erect, t No matter what the weather, ( And keeps a watch so circumspect t On foes of every feather, < So faithful is he to tho trust 1 Committed to his keeping < That all the birds suspojt he must 1 Dispense with any sleeping. < Sometimes his hat tips down so low It seems a cause for censure, For tben some old, courageous crow Believes it safe to venture; But catching sight of cither arm Outstretched in solemn warning.

See moreSee less

The crow decides to lea\ e this farm Until another morning. Although his dress is incomplete, It really does not matter; Perchance the truest heart may beat Beneath a patch or tatter. And it is wrong to base our love On wealth and name and station. For he who may will rise above His daily occupation. >? e should not look with eyes of sr orn, And find in him no leauty "Who stands and guards our fields of corn, And does the whole world duty, But honor him for native worth, For rustic independence. And send a hearty greeting forth For him and bis descendants.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

A newspaper reporter describes a Custer's Seventh Cavalry veteran, Sergeant John Ryan, meeting Sitting Bull at Buffalo Bill's Wild West show years after the battle. Ryan shows the chief a blood-stained cavalry guidon, prompting Sitting Bull to recall details of the fight where Custer's men were killed.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 23 September 1885 · page 4

cooled, nnd he enlisted in the Seventh Regular Cavalry, General Custer's regiment. He served two terms of five years each with that commander, and was in all the expeditions, and in all the Indian lights iu which Custer and his regiment were engaged Ryan was an active and gallant participant. In the final battle with Sitting Bull he bore the rank of orderly sergeant in Captain Frenche's company, and was in the detachmcnt of the regiment under the command of Reno. Or course, iu all these campaigns

See the clipping