As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

July 1884

11 articles

Sun River Sun · Sun River, Mont.

This 1884 article reviews the military campaign against the Sioux from 1876, describing the converging columns of Crook, Terry, Gibbon, and Custer. It states that Custer, acting prematurely, attacked the Sioux alone and that every officer and soldier engaged in the fight was slaughtered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.

Wrong

Sun River Sun · 3 July 1884 · page 1

TEN YEARS OF WARFARE

anI·d l~ld,.I r l~~ I tI1' wtnt tion, however, gontinu.d Fo be disa ftetb, and rumors were dispatched to notfly them to give themselves up at the agencies by the 81st of the fol lowing January, or war would be do olarec. rn stmrroae asuL wAR. The savages chose the lhtter alter native, andit was determined to sub due them with a strong force. On March lst, 1870, Gen. Co, with 888 1 men, set out from Fort Fetterman on the North Platto-rtb , and after scouting along the Tongue and Rose bud, struck across, through deep snow and bitter cold, to the Powder river, where, on March, 17th, he attacked and defeated Crazy Horse, returning to Fort Reno on the 21st.

See moreSee less

This ex pedition was not satisfactory in its rosults, and a larger one was at once ordered into the field. On May 2'th, Gen. Cook again left Fort Fetterman with about 1,000 men, and reaching the Rosebud, had an indecisive tight with the Sioux on the 17th of June. Meanwhile, on May 17th, Gen. Terry, with 400 Infantry and 000 of the 7th Cavalry under Lieut. Col Custer, left I Fort Abraham Lincoln opposite Bis markt and reached the mouth of Pow der river Juno 9th, and theomoath of the June 21st. Simultaneous with these movements Col. John Gibbon, 7th Infantry, with his regiment and 450 men of the 7th Cavalry, marched from Fort Ellisdown the Yellowstone to a point opposite the ltcscbud. After the combination was offwted at the -latter point. Terry, Gibbon and Custor concerted a plan for de!oating tl e Indians on the Little liighorn. and Rosebud. Gibbon went by boat up the Little Bighorn, and Custer, who marched with the 7th Caimlrylup the Rosebud,;unhappily anticipated~ in his zeal, the arrival of Gibbon, and attacked the Sioux, who overwhelmed and nimrcolessly slaughtered every of fbier and soldier engaged in the tight. Reinforcements wore promptly sent into the Territory until Cook's force numbed 1,774, and Terry's 1,878. The Indians retreated, however, toward Tongue river, and could not be entic ed again into a light, and the military forces were eventually withdrawn in the fall from Montana, excepting the 5th Infantry, under l. Miloes, who had come up from Kansas to take part in suppressing the savages, and who was left behinmd to construct a cantonment on the Yellowstone at the mouth of Tongue river. By the brav ory and energy of this eommand the valley was almost immediately open ed for settlement. The summer's demonstration had proven worse than fruitless, the hostiles remaining mas ters of the situation, with the added prestige of a wholesale victory, such as they had never before achieved. The turning point, however, had been reached. Leaving about 150 to build the cantonment, the remains which are still visible near Fort Keogh, Col. Miles with 420 of the 5th Infantry, pursued and overtook Sitting Bull at Cedar Crook, on Out. 21st, and chas ed him over the Yellowstone, after separating the Indians into two bod ies, one of which, under Crazy Horse, escaped up the Powder river; the other under Sitting Bull, moving northward. T'ho ltter wore vigorous ly followed early in November, and the country between the Muselosholl river and the Dry Fork of the Mis souri was thoroughly scoured by the troops, marching on foot through the rough, bad-lands in deep snow and bitter cold. The brilliant pursuit was repeated by the same command at the end of 1lo)omber, and again in May, 1877,tho hostiles being thorough ly whipped successively on the Rod water, among the Wolf Mountains, and in the losobud valley, until a lharg portion surrendered at the agen cies and the remainder sought refuge across the British border. The sol diers had marched over 4,000 miles, and, by their persistency, upopened 400 miles of river land to settlement. In September, 1877, Col. Miles, by a rap id flank movement, overtook, at the Bear Paw mountains, a large party of Noz Purees under Chief Joseph, on their way from Idaho to join Sitting Bull in Canada, and compelled their surrondor, with some losses on both sides. The year 1878 was occupied in completing lort Keogh, and in oponing roads and builing toloegraph lines, until September 4th when Col. Miles doefated a forco of Bann.cks who were soeking to force their way

See the clipping

Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.

The report describes an officer's account of Comanche, the cavalry horse ridden by Capt. Keogh at the Little Bighorn in 1876, denying Buffalo Bill's request to use him in a theatrical show. It recounts how Comanche, wounded seven times, was found standing in the river after the battle and was later honored by being led riderless at every regimental parade.

Ellsworth American · 17 July 1884 · page 1

—An officer of the Fourth cavalry says that Huffalo Hill has applied for permission to take the horse Comanche and use him in connection with his theatrical performance throughout the country. Of course his re quest will not he granted. Comanche was the favorite horse of (’apt. Keogh, and was ridden by him into the tight on the Little Hig Horn in 1876. He was the sole surviv or of the Custer massacre. The horse was found soon after the battle standing in the | waters of the river. He had seven wounds, j three of them dangerous ones, and had made j his way to the river to slake his thirst and : allay the fever resulting from his injuries,

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

The piece reflects on Sitting Bull's fearsome reputation after the Custer massacre, noting his flight to Canada and later return to live under U.S. law. It muses, with heavy sarcasm, that he is now reportedly taking up farming and could even become a politician.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 18 July 1884 · page 1

SITTING BULL was once a name of ter­ ror in the Northwest, and the old blood­ thirsty chief no doubt earned by merciless carnage upon tbe whites all the unenvia­ ble celebrity he obtained in that direc­ tion. Many a scalp has dangled from his belt and many a scout has bit the dust in trying to obtain the top knot of the old chief. But all things earthly must end and the conflict between the whites and Sitting Bull is perhaps at an end forever. There has not probably been a very radi­ cal change of heart on the part of the old chief nor much brotherly love engendered for him in the feelings of the eld timers on tho frontier.

See moreSee less

After the Custer massa­ cre a few years ago Sitting Bull went up

See the clipping

Daily Yellowstone Journal · Miles City, Mont.

The Army reports that Buffalo Bill has requested permission to use Comanche, the horse ridden by Capt. Keogh and sole survivor of the Custer massacre, in his theatrical performances; the request is expected to be denied. The horse's history, wounds, and current care at Fort Meade are recounted.

Daily Yellowstone Journal · 23 July 1884 · page 2

Little Big Horn 6b 187. ie was the sole survivor of the Custer mssacre. The horse was found soon after the battle standing in the waters of the

See the clipping

The Daily Enterprise · Livingston, Mont.

The item reports that Lt. Kisslingbury, who had fought under Reno at the Little Bighorn and was later stationed at Custer, died of starvation during the Greeley Arctic expedition. It notes his wife had died at Custer, leaving four children, one of whom was adopted by a relative in Deadwood.

The Daily Enterprise · 26 July 1884 · page 3

PERSONAL POINTS.

Co. C.; ( orporal Nicholas Nalor, Co. H.; Private Julius 'Fredericks, Co. I. and Private Win. A. Ellis, Co. C. 2d Cavalry. Of these only Serg't. Brai nerd and Private Fredericks were res cued, the others having died of starva tion. Kisslingbury fought under Reno at the Little Big Horn fight and was afterwards stationed at Custer. His wife died there, leaving four children. He was a brother-in-law of Seth Unl ock, of Dead wood, who has adopted one of the children.

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

The report lists six Montana soldiers who joined the Greeley Arctic expedition, noting only two survived while the rest starved to death. It mentions Lieut. Kislingbury fought under Reno at Little Bighorn and later lost his wife at Fort Custer, with his children taken in by relatives including Seth Bullock.

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 30 July 1884 · page 3

Nicholas Nalor, Co. H.; Private Julius Fredericks, Co I, and Private Wm. A. Ellis, Co. C., 2nd Cavalry. Of these only Serg't. Brainerd and Private Fredericks were rescued, tiie others having died of starvation. Kiaslingbury fought under Reno at the Little Big Horn fight and was afterwards stationed at Custer. His wife died there, leaving four children. He was a brother-in-law of Seth Bullock, of Deadwood, who has adopted one of the children. He was an old man, and as he entered the office, he remarked shvly to the edi tor : "Do you want something to print in your paper ?"

See moreSee less

"Yes," replied the edi tor, "if it is suitable. What is it?" "Get your pencil out—I never saw a railroad train, and I am going on eighty years of age. I never saw a telephone, nor a pretty girl. I haven't had a bath for twenty years. I was in my teens when I drank my last glass of water. I never hear«! Pinafore, por Grandfather's Clock.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A Minneapolis personals column reports that 'Curley,' described as the famous Indian scout and only survivor of the Custer massacre, is on exhibition alongside the painting 'Custer's Last Rally.' The item appears amid routine social notes about visitors and local residents.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 31 July 1884 · page 6

MINNEAPOLIS PERSONALS

Gen. W. 11. Gibson, of Ohio, is the guest -of I>'. H. Henderson. Capt. C. S. Hartley, of Chicago, is visiting friends in the city. Mrs. Fred T. I'eet died yesterday afternoon, after a lingering illness of some weeks. Boa. K. L. Koon, of Hllhidale, Mich., is the guest of Judge Koon, of the district court. Chas. J. Wright, of Fergus Falls, clerk of Otter Tail county, was at the West hotel jester day. >?; ■ C. M. Palmer, of the Xorthwtttern Miller, has been called to Pipeetone City by the sickness of hitfather.

See moreSee less

"Curley," the famous Indian scout and only survivor of the Custer massacre, is on exhibition with the picture of "Ouster's Last Rally." 11. O. Shepard, of the Chicago Publishing firm Of Shepard & Johnson is in the city, the guest of •W. K. Gilee.city passenger agent of the Chicago Milwaukee A St. Paul K. K.

See the clipping

Sun River Sun · Sun River, Mont.

Published on the eighth anniversary of the Little Bighorn battle, this piece reflects on how the memory of that June day endures, promising 'heretofore untold reminiscences.' It then shifts into background description of Fort Custer, built in 1877 near the battle site, and the surrounding Crow reservation lands.

Sun River Sun · 31 July 1884 · page 1

The military post which is situated at the junction of the Big Horn and Little Big Horn rivers in Montana was established July 4, 1877. It was first known as Fort No. 2, Big Horn river, but on its occupancy by the troops in November, 1877, the namne was changed to Fort Custer. The

See the clipping

Sun River Sun · Sun River, Mont.

An officer who was present at Little Bighorn recounts the coordinated movements of Reno, Benteen, Weir, and Godfrey during the battle, describing how the combined command retreated to the bluff where Reno made his final stand. The piece reflects on how details of the fight are fading from memory even among veterans, eight years after the massacre.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 28 days earlier.

Sun River Sun · 31 July 1884 · page 1

ON THE BIG HORN.

Thomas G. Troxel, Seventeenth in. fantry. Custer Station (formally known as Terry's Landing), on the Northern Pacific, the nearest railroad point is 29 miles distant, and from that place all supplies are carri'ed by wagon to the fort.

See the clipping

Sun River Sun · Sun River, Mont.

A survivor recounts the desperate defense on the hill after Reno and Benteen united, describing repulsed Sioux charges and a call for volunteers to fetch water from the river. He highlights Private Madden, a soldier facing discharge for drinking, who bravely volunteered and was shot through the ankle during the water run, later having his leg amputated.

Sun River Sun · 31 July 1884 · page 1

RECOLLECTIONS OF A TRAGEDY

Ot'- tO;2 05 EXrI.,. inu , iidnt i , Lhed, h t too, l ,I Ain I 4yot hitting it too. If one showed any part of his body abovo the pit or broastwork, crack went the rifltes of the Indialis, and the fellow was lucky to escape with his life. We had re pulsed several charges of the red devils during which one of them came close enough to count a coup on one of Benteen's men. Quito a tnm her of menl had been killed and the wounded were lying about pretty thick.

See moreSee less

We had been nearly twenty hours on the hill without a drop of water tand were almost dying with thirst. 8o, during a lull in the light, Betnteen called for volunteers to go down the ravine to the river for water. Madden was one of the hardest drink or in the regiment, and before the ex pedition started his cgptain had de termined to give him a bobtail dis charge; but on this day hlie showed clear grit, for, as I have said, he was the first to step out from the ranks. As it turned out, the service was not so danlgerous as it looked, still it was a brave act, for tile hills and coulies swarmed with Iudiauls, and it seemed alnost sure death. 11 ell, iafter a little

See the clipping

The Daily Enterprise · Livingston, Mont.

The report notes that Crow, a step-brother of chief Gall who fought at the Little Bighorn, is dying. It adds that since his tribe's defeat he has lived peaceably, working to help his people become self-supporting.

The Daily Enterprise · 31 July 1884 · page 3

Crow, a step-brother of Gall, one of the chiefs in the Custer massacre, is at the point of death. Since Ills tribe was conquered lie has been a good Indian, has worked hard and induced his brethren to try and become self supporting.

See the clipping