As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

March 1884

24 articles

The Southern Herald · Liberty, Miss.

This advertisement promotes a book, "Heroes of the Plains," claiming to be the first and only true history of Custer's Last Stand, supposedly related directly by Sitting Bull and his chiefs to the author. It touts illustrations, portraits, and advertises for sales agents, boasting 200,000 copies already sold.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

The Southern Herald · 1 March 1884 · page 4

HEROES OF THE PLAINS. BY J. W. BUEL.

mood, lb stopped at th boa of a prominent General Luring ia hi room. Upon mtkicg lawyer of tb plaea, who. wbea told her rj.!f knowa to him aad lilting my grir tory, buteded to Inform ber tbat her hoe asr, h mtoifeated great tympatby and oSr band was so longer la Port Gibioo, bat io J to Mod any letter I might write to Geo. Jackson, and rspidly regaining his strength. I a by on of hi courier. At the i4i . La tu'.'tit!& m not to feel diet Ia proof of tbi new, which to the weary t U i'.e tLe letter failed of tbeir wife itemed almeit to good Io b true, bt J i, V U l( feared would be th binded ber a lata copy of the JckiooMii.

See moreSee less

liaaippUa, printed oa a half sheet of piper, io which ah found what h bsd just told ... s . ia bi room thro Federal ioli ber folly eooGrmed. '.t in at pritooer. who had ! t ia the Ticini'y of Etymood, Cold wthr A dod ram. venture. A BOOK of wild life and thrilling adrentnre en the Plains i fights with Indiana and des perate white men ; grand buffalo hunts I naarow escapes, wonderful shooting and riding. The only authorised and truthful history of the daring ex ploita of the greatest Indian fighter, ecouts, hunter and guidea of th far West. Wild Bill. Baffslo Bill. Gen. Cu.ter, GaHfort Bia Jo, Capt. Jack, lb Poet Bcoat, Teiaa Jack, Kit Csrioi. Captain Pay oe.the Cimarron Scout.Whit Bearr, tb great Medicia Mao of tb 8I001, and many other celebrated plainsmen. Firat and only History of Custer' " Last Fight," as related by Sitting Bull and his Chiefs to the author in person, with accurate Topographic Illustration of the Battle, and superb portraits of Sitting Bull and hit Generals A great and valuable book) read like a romance, and outsells all other Two bun. dred thousand copies already Bold. CF" Agents, don't throw your time away on alow books, or worthless imitations of thia grand work," but send at once for the great original. It sella on tight. 600 large pagea, and 120 Illustrations, 1ft Fioe Colored Platea Price only . Canvassing Outfits 50o, Outfits FREE to Agents who an canvassing for any other book. Don't miss thia grand chance, but write at once for Pictorial Cir culara and extra terma Address

See the clipping

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont.

The report describes Buffalo Bill Cody's request to use Comanche, the horse famed as the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, in his theatrical performances, which the Army is expected to deny. It recounts Comanche's history as Capt. Keogh's mount, his wounds and survival at the battle, and his subsequent ceremonial retirement at Fort Meade.

The River Press · 5 March 1884 · page 6

Keogh, and was ridden by him into the fight on the Little Big Horn in 1876. He was the sole survivor of the Custer massacre. To be sure, Curley, the Crow

See the clipping

The Dawson Journal · Dawson, Georgia

An advertisement solicits book agents to sell a 500-page illustrated volume recounting Custer's Indian War battles, ending with his 'last fight on the Little Big Horn, as told by Sitting Bull.' It promises thrilling tales of scouts like Wild Bill and Buffalo Bill alongside the massacre account.

The Dawson Journal · 6 March 1884 · page 1

BY GEN. G. A. CUSTER, U. 8. A. Containing a thrilling and truthful as count of desperate Indian battles; personst encounters with; and narrow escapes fro» wily savages. Heroic struggles and woun derful encdurance of General Custer and h'e men; who fougbt Indiaits from the close of the civil war, in 1#65, till the masac’e in 1876. Custer;s last fight on the Liitle B¢ Hora, as told by Sitting Bull. Sketches of Custer’s Famons Scouts Will Comstoex, Wiild Bill, Buffalo Bi!'; Doctor Carver and Bloody Knife; Ges Crook’s Cauipaign against the Apachss, Massacre of Judge McUomas and wife, ar capture of his son.

See moreSee less

A grand book f agents to make money with. A Over 500 octavo pages and 75 full pagrg engravings. Kxpensively bound. Cire . lars and terms free, Act quick and se: d 75 cents for outtit, stamps taken. Addres-

See the clipping

The Southern Herald · Liberty, Miss.

A newspaper advertisement promotes 'Heroes of the Plains' by J.W. Buel, billed as the only authentic history of Custer's Last Fight as supposedly told directly to the author by Sitting Bull and his chiefs. The ad touts illustrations, portraits, and seeks agents to sell the book, claiming 200,000 copies already sold.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Southern Herald · 8 March 1884 · page 4

venture, A BOOK of wild life and thrilling adventurea on tho Plains', fights with Indiana aad detnerate white met: errand buffalo huats; narrow escapes, wonderful shooting and riding. The only authorised and truthlul history of the daring ex ploits of the greatest Indian fighters, scouts, huntera and guides of the far West. Wild Bill. BelTalo Bill. Gen. Cutter. Calif or i nia Joe, Capt. Jack, tbe Poet 8conl, Texas Jack, Kit Carson. Captain , , Payne. the Cimarron Scout, White Bear . ar, the great Medicine Man of tba 8ioox, and many other celebrated plainsmen.

See moreSee less

First tnd only History of Custer's " Last Fight," aa related by Sitting Bull and his Chiefs to the inthor in person, with accurate Topographs Illustrations of tho Battle, aud superb portraits of Sitting Bull aud his Generals A great and valuable book) reada like a romance, and outsells all others Two hun dred thonssnd copies already sold. I r Agents, don't throw your time away on slow books, or worthless imitations of this grand work. dui senu at once lor tne great original, it sens on sight. COO large pages, and I 'JO Illustrations, 18 Fine Colored Plates Price only $2. . Canvasaina; Outfits 50c, Outfits FREE to Agents who ara canvassing for any other book. Don's miss tbia grand chance, but write at once for Pictorial Cir culars and extra terms. Address

See the clipping

The Daily Enterprise · Livingston, Mont.

The report notes Buffalo Bill's attempt to acquire Comanche, the sole surviving horse from the Custer massacre, for a touring exhibition, though it predicts the scheme will fail. It describes the horse's current care at Fort Meade and notes it is paraded saddled but riderless, in memory of its last rider, Capt. Keogh.

The Daily Enterprise · 11 March 1884 · page 1

Inter-Mountain: Mr. Wilber N. A vies worth is in receipt of a telegram from one of the projectors of the Montana history enterprise indignant ly denying the reported collapse of that work. This will be cheerful news to those gentleman who have put up money to have themselves ill ustrated in that valuable publication. Buffalo Bill is now trying to get the famous horse Comanche, the sole sur vivor of the Custer massacre for ex

See the clipping

The Dawson Journal · Dawson, Georgia

This is a newspaper advertisement recruiting book agents to sell 'Wild Life on the Plains,' a volume attributed to Custer recounting his Indian wars and 'last fight on the Little Big Horn, as told by Sitting Bull.' It promises hundreds of pages and engravings, offering commissions to sales agents years after the battle.

The Dawson Journal · 13 March 1884 · page 1

BY GEN. G. A. CUSTER, U. 8. 4. Containing a thrilling and truthful e~ count of desperate Indian battles, personat encounters with, and narrow escapes frows wily savages. Heroie strugzles and wome derful endurance of General Custer and kis men, who fought Indians from the clese of the civil war, in 1865, till the masacre in 1876, Custers last fight on the Little Big Horn, as told by Sitting Bull. Sketches of Custer's Famous Scouts Will Comstock, Wiid Bill, Buffalo Bill, Doctor Carver and Bloody Knife; Ges.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Sitting Bull, described as forever linked to the Custer massacre, passed through Fargo en route to St. Paul accompanied by his nephew One Bull and Indian agent Major McLaughlin. He spoke through an interpreter, seemed pleased with his rail journey, and was being introduced to white customs and society.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Southern Herald, 1 March 1884, The Southern Herald, 8 March 1884.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 14 March 1884 · page 6

SITTING BULL. Re Will Arrive in St. Paul this Morn ing and Make a Stndy of Civil ized Ways. [Special Telegram to the Globe. | Fargo, March 13. —Sitting Bull the Sioux chief whose name will be forever memorable in connection with the Custer massacre, passed through^ Fargo this evening on his way to St. Paul. He is accompanied by his nephew, One Bull and in charge of Major McLaughlin, Indian agent at Standing Rock. He was dressed in buckskin, gaudily dec orated with beads and other ornaments. He looks mild and inoffensive, and talked freely thro' an interpreter to the curious crowd,and submitted to an interview by an Argus re porter like a white man.

See moreSee less

He has never been to a larger town than Bismarck before, and as he still has great influence with his large tribe, it was thought that it would have a good effect to introduce him further to the white meth ods and people. He said it was the first time he had traveled much by railroad, and he was much pleased with his trip so far. He was gratified with the treatment received from the great father and liked civilized ways. It is not certain that he will be taken further east than St. Paul.

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Sitting Bull, described as forever linked to the Custer massacre, passed through Fargo on his way to Minneapolis accompanied by his nephew and Indian agent Major McLaughlin. He gave an interview through an interpreter, saying he was pleased with his first long train journey and the treatment he received.

Bismarck Tribune · 14 March 1884 · page 1

Sitting Hall on his Journey. FABGO, March 13—Sitting Bull, the Sioux chief, who will ba forevar memorable in con­ nection with the Custer massacre,parsed through Fargo this evening on bis way to Minneapolis. He is accompanied by his nephew "One Bull," and is in charge of Maj. McLaughlin, Indian agent.at Standing Rock. Sitting Bull talked freely through an interpreter to the curious crowd, and submitted to an intervi3W by an Argus reporter. He has never been to a larger city than Bismarck before, and ash still has great influence with bis large tribe, it was BISMARCK, D.

See moreSee less

T., FRIDAY, MARCH 14, 1884. NO. 41. thought that it would have a good effeot to in­ GOXnENMED TELGGBAHM. unable to make tbe opinion of Lasker adopted by the American house of representatives my troduce him fnrther to tha. white methods and own. My desire is (hat the good relations people. He said it was the first time he had which have existed between the two oountries legislature opened today. traveled much by railroad, and be was much for a century may still continue. My action was forced upon me by the abuse to which I pleased with bis trip so far. He .was gratified Was subjected here at home, as a consequence of mence on the 17th in Beadle county. with the treatment received from tbe great the vote of the house of representatives of father, and liked the civilized ways. It is not Prussia, which has withstood all the tempta­ tions from other powers to interfere in the certain that he will be taken farther east than tion as is given men. affairs of America and to recognize the south­ Minneapolis. ern states. Indeed Prussia might dim the

See the clipping

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

A dispatch on starving Indians at the Fort Peck Agency warns of possible uprising and claims that the carbines and rifles lost by Custer's command at the Little Big Horn in 1876 are hidden in the camp or cached in nearby hills. It notes General Miles never discovered where the weapons went after Sitting Bull's surrender, since only old flintlocks were turned in.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Perrysburg Journal · 14 March 1884 · page 1

Custer campaign, or rather massacre, on tho Littlo Dig Horn are In this very camp and would bu brought Into use should such a calamity happen. Whero theso arms dis appeared to after that memorable day of 1870 General Miles never could Hull out. When Sitting Hull and his chiefs surrendered to Undo Sam's nillltnrjk they brought In a lot of old Hint lock and muzzlu-londing guns, hut no tSprluglleld anus. A scout informed 1110 a day or two ngo thnt tho Custer carbines wero In tho Poplar Hirer camp or cached among tho hills of tlio Redwatcr, and that thoy would bo lesorted to whenever tlio

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A newspaper reports on Father Stephan's lecture tour in which he recounted Sitting Bull's own account of the Little Bighorn battle. In this version, Custer had given the Lakota permission to hunt, and the soldiers initiated the fighting, with the Indians acting only in self-defense after years of mistreatment.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 March 1884 · page 6

Dakota among the friends of the colonel at the information that he has accepted the position of managing editor of the Beening Critic, a daily paper at Washingtan, as it will take him away from the territory, but they have assurance of a powerful representative of their interests at Washington. The Brule Index gives this statement of the profit of growing cattle in Dakota: O. Tur geon, who lately shipped thirty-five head of cattle from Kimball to the Chicago market, returned from the east Wednesday night and expresses himself as well satisfied with the re sults of his sale.

See moreSee less

He received #6 per 100 pounds for the lot, which brought him the snug sum of $2,656.25, making an average of $76.75 per head. Tiie cattle Mr. Turgeon siiipped were raised and fattened simply upon Dakota grass and hay, never having been "stall-fed," which speaks volumes in praise of the nutritive and fattening qualities of our grasses, and also furnishes a good ar gument in favor-of Dakota's merits jjs a stock-raising country. It is one of the peculiarities of the local and political situation in Fargo that the two Republican papers have so far bridged the chasm between them as to both support Col. Morton, the leading Democrat of the city,for mayor, while the Democratic paper and the guerrilla sheets are bitterly opposing. The Itroadaxe aims to take charge or the politics of the city and slashes around astutely with no apparent aim other than to individualize itseli and make things lively. It would not be easy to select a man who would wield the municipal baton with more vigor and at the same time sit down harder upon visiona ry schemes than Colonel Morton. He com bines prudence and economy with public spirit and will no di ubt do more for tiie good of the city than almost any one that couid be selected. The Hope Pioneer says: The Mayville brunch of the Manitoba railroad is practically useless during the greater part of the winter, there being almost one continual Hue of snow-banka along its entire length. As Portland and Mayville are but two miles apart, the railroad company manages to rim a train to the former pjace, ami wait on May ville by stage? coach, and the two towns com bined being able to furnish a little more bus [ess n for the road, the rolling stock naturally rolls in that direction for the present. It is not Ju>i tin-' wa.v tora railroad to do business. Our merchants have supplies on the road which are needed, aud, taken all together, the Manitoba company 6hould man age in some way to give us a train. The plea that snow in tho cuts below Page causes a blockade, is too gauzy. All that is necessary is a little investigation on the part of Mr. Manvel. Father Stephan, who has lived among the Indians many years, and is specially known as the spiritual guide of Col. Donan, is de livering a series of lectures upon the Ameri can red man, to large audiences at James town. In the first lecture he referred to Sit ting Bull and the Custer massacre, with that old chief's version of the unfortunate affair. Ills statement, according to the Alert, was this: Sitting Bull went to Gen. Custer and asked permission to go on a hunt with his braves. The general readily consented. The Indians were encamped in a gulch when scouts brought in the information that Cus ter's command was advancing for the pur pose of battle. Sitting Bull was loth to light and stationed his braves iu the gulch, with instructions not to fight until they were fired upon by the whites. The whites commenced the battle which ended in such a sad result, and which the Indians fought in self de fence. They were goaded to relentless en mity to the whites by years of abuse which no race of men could submit to without sac rificing all independence and manhood. Hardly any questions stir up so much local feeling as the location of county seats, which statement is by no means confined to Dakota, but there are many couuty seats to be located fn the territory, and rarely is one fixed without a contest. Traill county has been in a squabble over this question for several years. Caledonia has been the coun ty seat, but at the last legislature a special act was passed relocating it, and providing that the town that received two-thirds of the vote should be the county seat. There was a real hard fightbetween the east and west end and some magnificent voting done. The west end pulled 2,300 votes out of about that population and a clear two-thirds vote, as alleged. It is stated that a high board fence was erected about the polling booth at Portland and Mayville to prevent the east end men from seeing how the voting was done. The canvassing board refused to al low the returns and the case is to come be fore the court at Fargo on the 18th. It is said that nearly 500 witnesses will appear and a good deal of time be taken up with it. The Fargo Contempt Case. To the Editor of the Globe: Fargo, D. T., March 10, 1884.—I have noticed several items, either in the Globe or copied from it, going the rounds of the press, relating to the case of Wm. H. H. Matteson, editor of the Fargo Daily Sun, be ing ordered before Judge Hudson for con tempt of court, etc. All of said items are un doubtedly intended to give an unfavorable coloring to the actual facts. The articles published in the Sun containing the alleged contempt, did not refer to Judge Hudson or any proceeding of his court in anyway what ever, but did charge the district attorney and sheriff of belonging to a ring and exercising their official favor to further the aims of that ring. The contempt case has not "become serious on account of the course pursued by the defendant's attorneys," as stated by the Globe. All there is to it is, Matteson pro poses to test the question whether a newspa per has a right to criticise the official acts of county officers, outside of the court room, without being liable for contempt or not. He regards it as a matter in which every newspaper in the land is interested and one which involves very Important issues with the press at large, otherwise the whole mat ter would have been settled within an hour after his appearance before the court. Very respectfully, X. Vital Questions! Ask the most eminent physician Of any school, what is the best thing in the world for quieting and allaying all irritation of the nerves and curing all forms of nervous complaints, giving natural, childlike refresh ing sleep always? And they will tell you unhesitatingly "Some form of Hops!" CHAPTER I.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This 1884 article looks back on the Little Bighorn disaster, blaming Custer's rash attack without Terry's support for the total loss of his command. It then narrates Sitting Bull's subsequent years of resistance, flight to Canada, failed peace negotiations, and eventual surrender alongside other chiefs.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 18 March 1884 · page 3

SITTING BULL Major General Ta-ton-ka-i-y-a-ton-ka; or Sitting Bull. Interesting Extracts from a forth-com ing new Book. By Major T. M. Newson. We have been permitted to publish the following article about Sitting Bull, from the forthcoming new work of Maj. T. M. New son, entitled, "He-le-o-pa," Indian Legends, Characters and Peculiarities. The article is especially interesting at this time, as the sub ject of his comments is now in the city. It will be seen that while Maj. Newson accords to Sitting Bull many crimes and barbarities, yet he places him among the ab lest of Indian warriors of modern times.

See moreSee less

He says: Major General Ta-ton-ha-i-y-ton-ha ; or, Sitting Bull. This Indian deserves the rank of Major General in the army of the savages, for of all the chiefs, he was the most implacable, the most unrelenting, the most hostile, the most sagacious, the most cruel, and the most desperate foe of the whites, of any chief of modern times. He never assented to the control of the U. S. Government over his peo ple, but persistently fought our troops when ever they came in his way. He claimed that the country belonged to the Indians; that they had a right to hunt or fish where ever they pleased; that the white man had wronged them, and thus appealing to the feel ings of the younger portion of his race, in duced a large number to follow him, and for twenty years, carried on his war of mur der and rapine, until he finally, surrended to the United States forces, on the 19th of July, 1881. From the earliest history of the man, down to the time he yielded his power, he had been a vindictive and determined enemy of the whites. His numerous raids and savage cruel ties ; his unfaltering purpose to harass, rob an d kill the settlers; his undaunted courage and wily reasoning; his successful massacres and wise counsels, soon elevated him to the highest pitch of a leading and powerful chief, and he gathered about him men of the same peculi ar cast of mind, and continued to march forth to success and to victory, until his name became well known in every part of this country and in Europe. These successes on the part ofSitting Bull, inspired the Indian heart, so that many who were living on the bounty of the government at the various agencies, left and joined his forces, and hence, he was a constant source of disturbance, even outside of his own im mediate command. Indians who were peace fully Inclined flocked to his ranks, and for a time he put at defiance that portion of the army of the United States then operating on our frontier. His influence had become so great and was working such deleterious ef fects among the agency Indians, that finally the Department at Washington was obliged to take prompt measures to prevent a gener al outbreak among the friendly Indian tribes; and to this end, Sitting Bull and his follow ers were ordered to come inontothe Reserva tion, or they would fall under the control of the military power. Sitting Bull laughed at these commands of the Indian Department, and still continued his raids; and then fol lowed the campaign of 1876, Inaugurated by Gen. Sheridan, wherein three powerful columns of troops were to move simlltane. ously upon the enemy and force them either into civilization, or extermination. In the attempt to carry out this movement, which was a wise one, it will be remem bered General Crooks was repulsed, and Gen. Custer, in his eagerness to make an attack, without proper support, which could have been obtained, brought on a fight, in which he and his men were aU killed, leaving Sitting Bull and his warriors com plete masters of the field. No such Indian battle was ever known before in this country, and so complete an Indian massacre, has no parallel in history; and I am forced to the conclusion, that it could have been avoided had General Custer not been misled as to the number of Indians In the village, or had he promptly informed Gen. Terry, when he first discovered the Indian camp, and awaited for his support. After this battle the savages crossed into Canada, and notwithstanding there were several Indian fights on this side of the boundary line, subsequently, Sitting BuU took no part in them for a year. Then the old chieftain began again to commit dep redations among the Americans, and finally, a commission was appointed by the United State Goverment to cross the line and try to effect by diplomacy, what had failed by force of arms. In the meantime Sitting Bull's forces had greatly decreased by the return of the out laws back into the agencies from whence they originally came, and here they were fed and petted again by a great government, which had failed to subdue them, and which, when they were in its power, had failed to punish them. Through the intercession of British officers, the Peace Commissioners were ushered into the presence of the august Chieftain, who disdainfully refused to shake hands with them, and arrogantly demanded that they should come out from behind the table and speak the truth to his chiefs. No such audacity was ever shown before in the history of the Indian race; and then, after all the promises made by the govern ment, Major General Sitting Bull sneeringly rejected every overture for peace, and the Commission, having marched up the hill, marched down again, and the grim old ren egade quietly smoked his pipe inside of the walls of his greasy tcDee! Matters now continued quiet with Sitting Bull for nearly one year and a half, when, in 1879, he broke out again and commenced depredations upon the settlers. He was met by Geu. Miles and a battle ensued, Bull be ing in command in person, but fearing that the whites would be reinforced, he wisely withdrew his warriors and retreated to the British possessions, where he remained peace fully until he gave up his arms to the Amer ican power. Then followed the surrender of Rain-in-the Face, Crow Wing, Chief Gaul, and many thousand Indians, leaving Sitting Bull with only a few disheartened warriors, and finally, sullenly, and in a defiant man ner, he'succumbed to the inevitable march of the white race, aud came within our military lines, and everybody felt better and breathed freer. On surrendering, Maj. General Bull, among other things, said: "I surrender my rifle to you through my young son, whom I now desire to teach in this manner, that he has become a friend of the Americans. I wish him to learn the habits of the whites and to be educated as their sons are educated. "I wish it to be refhembered that I was the last man of my tribe to surrender my rifle. This boy has given it to you, and he now wants to know how he is going to make a living. Whatever you have to give, and whatever you have to say, I would like to re ceive or hear now, for I don't wish to be kept in darkness longer." He then continued bis speech quite at length, telling what he desired, while his rifle was taken from the hands of his little son, and Sitting Bull's power for evil among his own people, had gone forever. Speaking of the last great Indian battle in which Custer was killed, Maj. Newson says: "White Reno was contesting every foot of ground, Custer had passed down the north bank of the river aud made two unsuccess ful attempts to cross it, but was repulsed by the Indians, who outnumbered him some fifteen to one, and after stubbornly contest ing this point, he fell back to a smaU emi nence, and there the battle .raged terrifically. Soldiers and horses fell from the unerring bullets of the Indians, like wheat under the stroke of the scythe. The brave men, led by their brave but deceived leader, continued to close up the gaps made by the enemy, until not a living soul was left upon the field I All was still! Three hundred men! hundreds of horses! the most gallant cavalry officer that America ever produced had passed out of life, out of activity, out of reality, down Into the shadow of death! Sitting Bull and his chiefs satiated with the blood of the pale faces, and fearful of the ad vancing troops, called off their men, and took up their march to the British line. Now, after all this, if Major General Bull de sires civilization for his people—desires edu cation for his children—desires sincerely to adopt the habits of the whites, let us give him the helping hand. He was consistent in fighting the whites; great in his last battle, SITTING BULL his own race. Major General Ta-ton-ka-i-y-a-ton-ka; or Sitting Bull. he had made." Interesting Extracts from a forth-com ing new Book. By Major T. M. Newson. We have been permitted to publish the following article about Sitting Bull, from the forthcoming new work of Maj. T. M. New son, entitled, "He-le-o-pa," Indian Legends, Characters and Peculiarities. The article is especially interesting at this time, as the sub ject of his comments is now in the city. It will be seen that while Maj. Newson accords to Sitting Bull many crimes and barbarities, yet he places him among the ab lest of Indian warriors of modern times. He says: Major General Ta-ton-ha-i-y-ton-ha ; or, Sitting Bull. This Indian deserves the rank of Major General in the army of the savages, for of all the chiefs, he was the most implacable, the most unrelenting, the most hostile, the most sagacious, the most cruel, and the most desperate foe of the whites, of any chief of modern times. He never assented to the control of the U. S. Government over his peo ple, but persistently fought our troops when ever they came in his way. He claimed that the country belonged to the Indians; that they had a right to hunt or fish where tense interest. ever they pleased; that the white man had wronged them, and thus appealing to the feel ings of the younger portion of his race, in duced a large number to follow him, and for twenty years, carried on his war of mur der and rapine, until he finally, surrended to the United States forces, on the 19th of July, 1881. From the earliest history of the man, down to on trial. the time he yielded his power, he had been a vindictive and determined enemy of the whites. His numerous raids and savage cruel ties ; his unfaltering purpose to harass, rob an d kill the settlers; his undaunted courage and wily reasoning; his successful massacres and gued and submitted. wise counsels, soon elevated him to the highest pitch of a leading and powerful chief, and he gathered about him men of the same peculi ar cast of mind, and continued to march forth to success and to victory, until his name became well known in every part of this country and in Europe. These successes on the part ofSitting Bull, inspired the Indian heart, so that many who were living on the bounty of the government at the various agencies, left and joined his forces, and hence, he was a constant source guardian. of disturbance, even outside of his own im mediate command. Indians who were peace fully Inclined flocked to his ranks, and for a hearing April 10 at 10 a. m. time he put at defiance that portion of the army of the United States then operating on our frontier. His influence had become so tor. great and was working such deleterious ef fects among the agency Indians, that finally istrator appointed. the Department at Washington was obliged to take prompt measures to prevent a gener al outbreak among the friendly Indian tribes; March IB at 10 a. m. and to this end, Sitting Bull and his follow ers were ordered to come inontothe Reserva tion, or they would fall under the control of the military power. Sitting Bull laughed at these commands of the Indian Department, and still continued his raids; and then fol peace. lowed the campaign of 1876, Inaugurated by Gen. Sheridan, wherein three powerful columns of troops were to move simlltane. paid. ously upon the enemy and force them either into civilization, or extermination. derly; fines of §10 paid. In the attempt to carry out this movement, which was a wise one, it will be remem bered General Crooks was repulsed, and Gen. Custer, in his eagerness to make an ued until to-day. attack, without proper support, which could have been obtained, brought on a fight, in which he and his men were aU killed, days. leaving Sitting Bull and his warriors com plete masters of the field. No such Indian fine of $10paid. battle was ever known before in this country, and so complete an Indian massacre, has no days. parallel in history; and I am forced to the conclusion, that it could have been avoided orderly; fines of $15 paid. had General Custer not been misled as to the number of Indians In the village, or had he promptly informed Gen. Terry, when he first discovered the Indian camp, and awaited for his support. After this battle the savages crossed into Canada, and notwithstanding there were several Indian fights on this side of the boundary line, subsequently, Sitting BuU took no part in them for a year. Then the old chieftain began again to commit dep redations among the Americans, and finally, a commission was appointed by the United State Goverment to cross the line and try to effect by diplomacy, what had failed by force of arms. In the meantime Sitting Bull's forces had greatly decreased by the return of the out laws back into the agencies from whence they originally came, and here they were fed and petted again by a great government, which had failed to subdue them, and which, when they were in its power, had failed to punish them. Through the intercession of British officers, the Peace Commissioners were ushered into the presence of the august Chieftain, who disdainfully refused to shake hands with them, and arrogantly demanded that they should come out from behind the table and speak the truth to his chiefs. No such audacity was ever shown before in the history of the Indian race; and then, after all the promises made by the govern ment, Major General Sitting Bull sneeringly rejected every overture for peace, and the Commission, having marched up the hill, marched down again, and the grim old ren dence on Fuller street. egade quietly smoked his pipe inside of the walls of his greasy tcDee! Matters now continued quiet with Sitting Bull for nearly one year and a half, when, in 1879, he broke out again and commenced depredations upon the settlers. He was met by Geu. Miles and a battle ensued, Bull be

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A roundup of Iowa local items includes a note that a correspondent sent the queue (hair braid) allegedly worn by Sitting Bull at the Custer Massacre to an academy's historical cabinet. The rest of the passage covers unrelated Iowa news such as a skating rink, suffrage statistics, and an oil discovery.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 20 March 1884 · page 9

but now a newspaper correspondent at LaGrace, Dakota has sent to the Mt. St. Joseph academy, to be added to the historical cabi net, the identical queue worn by Sitting Bull at the Custer Ma66acre.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A reader's letter responds to an earlier piece calling Sitting Bull a murderer and renegade, arguing that white settlers' seizure of the Black Hills without treaty provoked conflict. The writer notes Sitting Bull claims he acted only in self-defense regarding the Custer fight.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 20 March 1884 · page 10

Immigration Notes. Secretary Young, of the board of immigra tion, says that the demands for information from France in respect to Minnesota is great er than ever beior.*, to his knowledge, and that there is a disposition in both the north ern and southern provinces of that republic to come to this state in considerable numbers. Active inquiry is also increasing from Hol land. Mr. Younsi is recently In receipt of a letter from the publishers of a paper in Hol land, offering weekly, free of charge, a space for contributions descriptive of the state, of which he will take advantage.

See moreSee less

The publish ers will translate these communications into the language, and, being immigrant agents, probably expect to be rewarded through ad vertisements of parties owning Minnesota tracts of land. A Word For Sitting Bull. To the Editor of the Globe: In your issue of yesterday an article ap peared signed "Citizen," in which it was stated that if Sitting Bull could raise a force sufficiently strong he would doubtless like to visit our schools and scalp our children; and he is spoken of as a murderer and a rene gade, and the writer declares that no tor ture that could be invented would be too cruel for him. ffow I would suggest that such expres sions as t}ie above are not calculated to im press the savage mind with a very exalted idea of the magnanimity and high civilization of the white people, who recommend the game barbarous treatment for the fallen warrior which he is accused of having en couraged towards the advancing white race. And as to Sitting Bull's murders and cruel ties, I would like "Citizen" to show that any honorable white man would not have pur sued substantially the same course under similar circumstances. It has been said of Sitting Bull that he has never harmed any one except in self-defense, and it must be borne in mind that the Black Hill country was taken possession of by a number of gold hunters, who undertook to establish themselves there, although there had been no treaty with the Indians as to the possession of those lands. As to the Custer massacre so-called. The writer shared the thrill of horror which passed over the nation when the news reached us of the tragic death of Custer and his brave followers; but when Sitting Bull is asked about the fight, his sole answer is, " God gave me strength to defend myself." Every body knows quite well that Custer and his men were engaged in an ex pedition against the Indians, who would un doubtedly have met the fate which they in flicted upon their assailants, if Sitting Bull had not outnumbered his opponents. The term renegade, by Citizen's own showing, is not applicable, as the old warrior never made a treaty with the whites, and therefore never broke one. The writer of this has lived all his life in the west and has spent a good deal of time on the frontier, and although he has seen dirty, drunken, thieving Indians, he has also seen sober Indians, kindly taking care of a drunken white man, from whose bottle they refused to drink when it was offered them; and he has seen Indians with quiet dignity and the kindest courtesy toward whites who were behaving like unmitigated blackguards toward them Whether Citizen's charges against Sitting Bull are true or false, there seems to be something ungenerous in throwing them in highest indebtedness being limited to $5,000. The first board of directors are Andrew J. Burkee, O. N. Ostrom, Ole Amundson, Ole T. Ringer, Q. O. Grundukker, Aug. Lily quist, F. H. Glossop, C. J. Johnson, E. L. chief in his declining years. Bergland, O. W. Larson, Ole Kron, Math.

See the clipping

Helena Weekly Herald · Helena, Mont.

A travel correspondent describes passing by train near the site where Custer and the Seventh Cavalry fought the Sioux, as well as Col. Baker's 1872 battle site. The account focuses mainly on business and social notes about Miles City and its growing cattle trade.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Helena Weekly Herald · 20 March 1884 · page 2

Washington, March 18 —There seems to rests. Prominent a mong the causes which be no doubt that Col. David Stanley, of have inspired confidence in the future of the 22nd infantry, will succeed Gen. Mc Livingston is the railroad plant to which Kenzie as Brigadier General. friends at this place, Mr. S. E. Irwin, who has resided in Montana since the early days of '65. ''Sid" has stood the wear and tear of frontier life remarkably well, and seems to be good for ninety-nine years more of active business life. He is at present proprietor of a large wholesale liqnor establishment having a complete and choice stock of pure wines and liqnors.

See moreSee less

Here I also met Mr. Coverly, formerly of Twin Bridges. Since my last visit in '82 he has improved his time to good ad vantage. Then he was bookkeeper for Mr. P. W. McAdow; now he is a member . of the firm which for many years has con trolled an extensive and profitable whole sale and retail trade. In addition to this he has had the good fortune to secure a , wife and is now a staid and sober citizen. His many friends |will he glad to hear of his success and heartily unite in the wish that fortune may continue to smile upon him. After a few hours' ride on the train which rapidly takes us past the scene of Col. Baker's battle with the Sioux in 72, in sight of the spot where General Custer and the famous Seventh cavalry fought the warriors of the same nation a year later, and where alterward the heroic members of the Bozeman expedition erected their fort, and waged a successful though bloody contest with the same dusky savages, led on by Chief Sitting Bull, the loud whistle of the locomotive announces our approach to Miles City. This town shows many ev idences of the changes which the times have wrought. In place of the trade in buffalo hides, which at one time was its chief source of revenue, comes that derived from their successors on the free pastures of Uncle Sam, the cattle. The town is indeed rapidly becoming a stock centre of importance, and at the rate Eastern and Texas stock are arriving, will soon represent an immense amount of capital employed in that industry. A num ber of herds from Wyoming, Idaho and Oregon have been within the past year driven in upon contiguous ranges and many more will arrive during the coming summer, while mnny of the stock men of the country adjacent are increasing their herds by importations from the Eastern States. At hotels the chief topics of con versation seem to be the respective mer its of Herelords, Durhams, Polled Angus and other breeds, while the expressions "a thousand head,'' five thousand head," etc., are continually heard on every side. In the evening the amusement ot the billiard and pool tables has to dispute for supremacy with that derived from design ing cattle brands and discussing their de fects or advantages. The town still shows the scars inflicted by two serious fires that occurred last sea son, hut with the opening of spriug the gaps at present existing will be tilled by handsome brick structures. The present summer will witness a remarkable chunge in the appearance of the place, as building i operations will he extensive. F, M. W.

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The article mockingly describes Sitting Bull's tour of St. Paul and Minneapolis, arranged by officials hoping to civilize him and curb any spring urge for 'the war path.' He reportedly joked that he hadn't had so much fun since the Custer massacre.

Bismarck Tribune · 21 March 1884 · page 4

MITTIXV ITlili'S TBI P. The visit of Sitting Bull to St. Paul and Minneapolis was brought about through a desire of the officials to have

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Father Stephan, former Indian agent at Standing Rock, recounts a lecture in which he related Sitting Bull's account of the Custer battle. In this version, Custer gave Sitting Bull permission to hunt, the Indians camped in a gulch and fought only in self-defense after the whites attacked first.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Bismarck Tribune · 21 March 1884 · page 4

A Talk with Father Stephan

"OlIE OTHER JUAMB. Since Bismarck, the German chancel­ lor, made his bad break regarding the Lasker resolutions, the papers all over the land have called for a change of the name of our city. Of course this will never be effected and we have paid little attention to the appeals. The following from the New York Times, however, draws such a graphic picture of the cor­ ner stone ceremonies that we give it space: When the Villard excursion in its western progress reached Dakota in September last, its arrival and the presence of the many notable men of both hemispheres who participated in it were taken advantage of for the laying of the corner stone of the capitol building of the new territory.

See moreSee less

The occasion wan impressive and deeply interesting. The site selected for the building is on the top of the first ridge of a great swell of land that rolls up as far as the eye can reach without a break or an angle to height of about 150 feet above the river, and thence extends to tbe horizon in further grace­ ful undulations of uninhabited, treeless prairie. About the foundation,' which evidently contem­ plated a building of large and commanding pro­ portions, was an assemblage the like of which was probably never gathered for any similar ceremonial. There were Sitting Ball and Gen. Grant real Indians, radiant with paint and feathers and with the taint of the Custer massa­ cre still about them, and officers and men of the federal army, officials and the orator of tbe day in silk hats and black coats, and cowboys and teamsters with broad brimmed sombreruB and gaysbirtsand handkerchiefs members of con­ gress, of the British parliament and the German reichstag high diplomatists, Catholic missiona­ ries, elegantly drtssed women, the ever present representatives of the press and the photogra­ phers men on foot, on horseback, in backs, buggips, stago coaches, omnibuses, covered prairie schooners and buokboaids squaws and darkies, railroad employes, boatmen, shopkeep­ ers—in all from a thousand to fifteen hundred people all respectful, all interested and atten­ tive. Below the hill, about half a mile distant was the town and some thousands of inhabitants, mainly composed of two streets with not a few good, substantial brick blocks and prerty houses —Queen Anne style—a good market, several ho­ tels and adundant shops, that window decora­ tions and merchantable stocks would not suffer by comparison with the best that the Bowery or the side avenues of New York could offer. A half mile further on was the Missouri, with a small fleet of stern wheel steamboats tied to its banks, navigable for some 2,001) miles further westward, stretching its shining stream loDg, far away to the right and left distance, and spanned by the newly builtand magnificent iron bridge of tbe Northern Pacifio, which con­ struction in itself has no superior in any coun­ try. The whole scene was eminently typical of American progress and civilization and one could but feel as he participated in it that he was witnessing the birth of an empire, and the very "homing'' of a new and great, popu­ lous and mighty-state, and that, too, on territory where five years before the control of the savage was so complete' that the man who ventured there did so at tbe risk of his life. At the same time, one thought came uppermost to many and found frequent verbal expression. Why should this oapital of this new state, with its euphonious Indian name, ''Dakota," whose history is characteristic of the progress and growth of tbe people of the United States, and of all that they regard as politically precious, be called after one living man—"Bismarck"— who represents all that is antagonistic to Ameri­ cans who is the bitter opponent of all free government and the upholder of military des­ potism, and who, latterly, has so little appreci­ ated the compliment that has been paid him in naming this new city that he has gone out of his way to make the occasion of a pleasant act of national courtesy to one of tbe most distin­ guished of his countrymen an occasion for a de­ liberate insult to our whole nation. We trust that there is enough of American pride and self respect in congress to see that no bill admitting Dakota (as a state) into the federal union ever becomes a law until some other and more ap­ propriate name is given to its oapital than the one it now bears. THE Fargo Argus observes: "Colonel Lounsberry is receiving letters from all sections of the territory requesting him io permit the use of his name for gov­ ernor. The Michigan delegation are said to be urging the colonel, who is now in Washington, to do the same. The plea is that Colonel Lounsberry would har­ monize all the elements. His frank, open, manly course is admired by all, both north and south." IT is believed by some that no appoint­ ment for governor of Dakota will be made until after the presidential cam­ paign, and that Gov. Ordway will con­ tinue to officiate in the meantime. A Talk with Father Stephan. Father Stephan, who has lived among the In­ dians for several years, and who wan Indian agent at Standing Bock at the time of the sur­ render of Sitting Bull, was in the city Tuesday and was greeted by bis host of friends. Among other things he stated that he had arranged with the superintendent of Castle Garden, New York, a personal friend, to forward to Burleigh county about a hundred families of the most desirable emigrants. He desires that the city or county appoint sbme one to look after th3m upon their arrival and see that they are well located on good claims. Father Stephan has been recently de­ livering a series of lectures upon the American red man, to large audiences at Jamestown. In the first lecture he referred to Sitting Bull Bnd the Custer masmcre ,with that old chief's version of the unfortunate affair. His statement was this: Sitting Bull went to Gen. Custer and asked permission to go on a bunt with his braves. The general readily consented. The Indians were encamped in a gulch when scouts brought in the information that Custer's command was advancing for the purpose of battle. Sitting Bull waa loth to fight and stationed his braves in the gulch, with instructions not to fight until they were fired upon by the whites. The whites commenced the battle which ended in such a sad result, and which the Indians fought in self defense. They were goaded to relentless enmity to the whites by years of abuse which no race of men could submit to without sacrificing all in­ dependence and manhood. A number of agents are in the city to be present at tbe opening of bids for the steam heating apparatus for the capitol building.

See the clipping

Cooperstown Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D.

A correspondent writes from Fort Custer, Montana in March 1884 describing the remote posting's geography, hunting opportunities, and surrounding mountains. He notes the location near where victims of the Custer massacre are buried, visible from the fort in clear weather.

Cooperstown Courier · 21 March 1884 · page 5

GARRISON LIFE.

Unpleasant. out ustek. Mont., Mar. 12, '84. Mk. Editok:—Certain inquiries dur ing any brief stay in Cooperstown last fall led me to beileve that a few items through the columns of your valuable paper would reach the circle of my t'tieiids and acquaintances and be found interesting to many of your readers. I Fort Custer is situated in an out-of the-way place, on a plateau at the con lluence of the liig Horn and Little Big I Horn rivers. The nearest towns of any importance are Miles City, Billings and ern Pacific U. R.. none of them within a "IV line of less than 50 miles. I victims of the Custer massacre bears about S. E.: distant 15 miles near which

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

Father Stephan relays Sitting Bull's version of the battle, claiming Custer gave permission for a hunt and that Indians only fought after being fired upon by advancing soldiers. The speaker uses this account to argue the Indians' actions were justified given government mistreatment and broken treaties.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 21 March 1884 · page 8

V^,"V' r'?' •:J :. JH The American Indian. '•Mr.-. The first lecture of the series which has been announced to oecur under the auspices of the city schools was given last eyening by Rev. Father Stephan at Klaus hall. The room was packed full, and it is estimated that four hundred peeple were present. The subject of the lecture was "The American Indian." The lecturer is well known to the North­ west as one who has derived much in­ formation and a thorough understanding of the theme from many years of personal contact with the dusky tribes who fast approaching that oblivion which four centuries of rapid decay have brought about.

See moreSee less

He has been identified with the tribes in Western Dakota in a greater degree, and they are known to have been representative of their race and prominent in many warlike as well as peaceable relations with the govern ment during the past few years. From this portion of hie experience Father Stephan formed a highly entertaining and instructive discourse, which no one in his audience would have missed. The venerable speaker after his intro­ duction to the audience by Mayor Flint, brought to the minds or his hearers a lively appreciation of the grandeur of man as a creation of the Infinite and brought vividly forth the principles of equality which Christianity makes a primary teaching. The distinctions be­ tween the races of men were unjust and irreligious. The Indian in his dark skin and the primitive surrounding of his life has a soul as tendery watched by the Creator and occupying as exalted a placn in the world to come, as the white man with all of the surrounding parapherna­ lia of civilizaliou. But distinctions were made against him. He was and Is treated with as much indignity and injustice as the negro, whose freedom was purchased with the blood of a million martyrs, lie is not understood. His landa are takeu from him by the government and he does not get a legitimate roturn. He is forced to make treaties and cede away to an en­ croaching power his most valuable possessions. When the treaties are made, the United States is in every case the party to break them. Dissolute soldiers ruin their homes. A hundred forces are at work to break their hope for the fut­ ure and render their present existence miserable. It is no wonder that the proud spirit of the race leads them to an occasional outbreak and such bloody deeds as Custer's massacre In relation to this massacre, Father Stephan gave Sitting Bull's account of it and it strong evidence that the action of the Indians on that occasion was in a meas­ ure justifiable. Sitting Bull went to Gen. Custer and asked permission to go on a hunt with his braves. The genoral readily consented. The Indians were encamped in agulch when scouts brought, in the information that Custer's com­ mand was advancing for the purpose of battle. Sitting Bull was loth to fight and and stationed his braves in the gulch, with instructions not to fight until they were fired upon by the whites. The whites commenced the battle which end­ ed in such sad result, and the Indian? fought in self defence. They were goaden to relentless enmity to the white* by years of abuse which no race of men could submit to without sacrificing all in­ dependence and manhood. The speaker urged with illustrations taken from his experience that the civil­ izing process in ceurse by the govern­ ment toward the Indians was not helped oy the dissolute soldiery which is placed to guard them, and said that as long as their rights were so flagrantly abuaed by them there was no hope for the estab­ lishment of civilised custom among them They were willing to work, and could with a proper administration of their affairs by the government be raised from their present condition to a semb­ lance of the life we would like to see them live but with the examples con­ stantly before them of the drunkenness and disorder of their guardians, all re­ ligious effort looking toward ther civil­ isation was in vain as far as the nation is concerned. He said that the pronenes* of the whites to criticise the Indians for laziness waa unjust. He had noticed a disposition widely prevalent among the whitee to do as little work as posslbleualess it was for the accumulation of money or property, and thought that if tho Indians were given some sqch incentive to |abor( their hopeless attitude toward agricult­ ure and 0her industrial pursuits would give way to an ambition quite as com­ mendable as that of the whites. They have no tools or implements, aad are in otherespects under such disadvantage' that they have no hope, and consequent­ ly are listless, apathetic and unambiti )U*. or EIJOT1CK FINAL PftOOF.

See the clipping

The Southern Herald · Liberty, Miss.

This classified ad promotes 'Heroes of the Plains' by J.W. Buel, a book claiming to be the first authorized history of Custer's Last Fight as told by Sitting Bull and his chiefs directly to the author. It boasts 200,000 copies sold and includes illustrations and portraits of Sitting Bull and his generals.

The Southern Herald · 22 March 1884 · page 4

Wild Bill, Buffalo Bill, Geo. Caster, Oalifori. uia Joe, Oept. Jack, (be Peat Scoot. Tezaa Jack, Kit Careen, Captain Payoe.the Cimarron Bcont.WhiteBeartt, (be great Mediclae Mao of tbe Sioui, and many other celebrated plainsmen. First ami only History of Custer's " Last Fight," aa related by Sitting Bull and hia Chiefs to the author in person, with accurate Topographic Illustrations of the Battle, and superb portraits of Sitting Bull audi his Generals A great and valuable book; reads like a romance, and outsells all others Two bun dr.'d thousand copies already sold.

See moreSee less

HP Agents, don't throw your time away on alow books, or worthless imitations of this grand work, but send at once for the great original. It sells on sight. COO large pages, and 120 Illustrations, 18 tine Colored Plates Price only $i. Canvassing Outfits 50c, Outfits FREE to Agent who are canvassing for any other book. Don't miss thte grand chance, but write at once for Pictorial Cir culars snd extra terms. Address

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A correspondent recounts Sitting Bull's history of resisting white encroachment rather than initiating war, framing him as having kept treaty promises while whites broke theirs. The piece credits Sitting Bull, with Four Horns and Black Moon, with defeating Crook and annihilating Custer's command.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Wrong

St. Paul Daily Globe · 24 March 1884 · page 5

FATHER DE SMET

Sitting Bull a Chief of Warriors, and Not a Border Balder. To the Editor of the Globe: In 1803 the government sent a commission of distinguished officers to negotiate with the Sioux Indians for roadways through their country and for peace. The demands of the Indians, especially of the Unkapapas, [among whom Sitting Bull was regarded as first of warrior chiefs, though Four Horns and Black Moon then outranked him in council,] would not have been agreed to by the com mission had they thought the government then able te send an army of 25,000 men in to the country.

See moreSee less

No less an army, they be lieved, could subdue these Indians. The treaty was accordingly substantially as pro posed by Black Moon and Sitting Bull. The forts wliich had been establishedin the Unka papa country were abondoned and the emi grant roads and surveys for railroads were limited to regions liitle occupied by the In dians. Up to this time Sitting Bull's part in war against the white's had consisted only of resistance to what he and his people regarded as invasions of their country —by gold prospectors and buffalo hunters. He was not a treaty Indian—he had never signed a treaty and he avoided all contact with the whites. He did not attack settlements or in any way provoke war, ex cept by defending what he regarded as his own country. He never took part in council or treaty with the whites save in the year I.GS when the Unkapapas were visited, on behalf of the peace commission, by Father De Smet. and on which occasion Sitting Bull was pursuaded to agree to be represented at a peace council at Fort Rice. At that coun cil a treaty was concluded which was well enough observed on the part of Sitting Buil but which the whites did not intend to keep. It was broken by Custer's first Black Hill's expedition and then by the advance of Gen. Crook, from the south, followed by the Terry expedition, when Cus ter and his immediate command were all killed. Custer endeavored to charge an In dian village, to repeat scenes of massacre which have often occurred in our dealings with the Indians, but was met by an over whelming force and he and his men perished, every one. The subsequent history of Sitting Bull is familiar to readers of the GLOBE. He was a fugitive for years, more than ever distrustful of the promises of the whites, and when at last forced by regard for his people to sur render, he did not abandon his honest belief that he and his people owned the Black Hills country; but he yielded to necessity, and, giving his word, has done what no white chief had ever done with him, kept his word. The man is ignorant according to our esti mate of men, but is regarded as wise by his own people. With Four Horns and Black Moou he outgeneraled and defeated Crook and annihilated Custer's little force. He wus never guilty of the atrocities attributed to him by a late correspondent of your paper, but if he had been it might be said for him that he only followed examples set by white warriors in hundreds oi raids upon Indian villages. And I might truly add that Indians learned most of tlie devilish cruelty to the helpless and to prisoners which is commonly regarded as their particular savage trait, from those white warriors whose fame as Indian lighters is recorded in the histories of the colonies and the United States.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn. · 23 March 1884

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A correspondent defends Sitting Bull's character and honesty, noting he outgeneraled Crook and defeated Custer's force, and disputes claims of Indian atrocities as no worse than those committed by white fighters. The piece then reproduces Father De Smet's 1868 report to the peace commission describing his approach to the Hunkpapa camp on Powder River, where Sitting Bull first agreed to a treaty.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 24 March 1884 · page 5

FATHER DE SMET.

hundreds oi raids upon Indian villages. And I might truly add that Indians learned most of tlie devilish cruelty to the helpless and to prisoners which is commonly regarded as their particular savage trait, from those white warriors whose fame as Indian lighters is recorded in the histories of the colonies and the United States. But I intended only to call your attention to Father De Smet's report of the council he had with the Unkapapas in 1808, on Powder river, where Sitting Bull, for the first time, consented to a treaty with the whites. His second aud last treaty was his surrender about two years ago. Father De Smet's re port to the peace commission, was as follows: PRESENTED TO THB HON. COMMISSIONERS BT

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn. · 23 March 1884

The Spirit of Democracy · Woodsfield, Ohio

Mrs. Custer describes her life since the Battle of the Little Big Horn, including philanthropic work in New York and her plan to join and travel with Mrs. Calhoun, Custer's sister. She reflects on how much Mrs. Calhoun's voice and mannerisms resemble the general's.

The Spirit of Democracy · 25 March 1884 · page 4

Caster's Wlte and Sister. Mrs. Custer in an Interview. "I expect to be with Mrs. Calhoun all winter. After tha battle of the Little Big Horn I went to New York and engsged in philanthropic work, in which I intend ed to devote mv entire time. I have felt the necessi'y for rest frequently, and was considering this win'er whether I should take an ocean voyage or come west. finally concluded to join Mrs. Calhoun, and accompany her in her readings. have no relatives of my own father, mother, brothers or sisters and she is i he dearest one on earth to me.

See moreSee less

She is very mneh like (he general. Her ways, her laugh, are the tame, and ber quick tones are very much like his. Sometimes my heart almost stops beating when I hear her speak in another room her voice is so much like that of the one who is gone." ... ees.. i .1, ,..

See the clipping

Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

The article recounts the story of Comanche, the cavalry horse said to be the sole survivor of Custer's command at the Little Big Horn in 1876, describing his wounds, rescue, and subsequent ceremonial status with the Seventh Cavalry. It also notes a request by Buffalo Bill to use the horse in theatrical performances, which was refused.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Bridgeton Pioneer · 27 March 1884 · page 2

The History of a Warliorse. An officer of the Fourth cavalry says that Buffalo Bill has applied for per mission to take the horse Comanche and use him in connection with his theatrical performances throughout the country. Of course his request w ill not be granted. Comanche was the favorite horse of Capt. Iveogh, and was ridden by him into the fight on the Little Big Horn in 187C. He was the sole survivor of the Custer massacre.

See the clipping

The Southern Herald · Liberty, Miss.

This is a mail-order advertisement for a book by J.W. Buel claiming to contain the 'only authorized and truthful history' of Custer's Last Fight, allegedly as told by Sitting Bull and his chiefs to the author in person. It promotes the book to agents for sale, listing its illustrations, price, and sales figures.

The Southern Herald · 29 March 1884 · page 4

Psyoe.the Cimarron Seout.Wbit Betfi . tr. tbt grttt Msdieitt Han of tht Sioax and many other celebrated plainsmen. Firat and only History of Custer's " Last Fight,'' as related by Sitting Bull and bis Chiefs to the author in person, with accurate Topographic Illustrations of the Battle, and auperb portraits of Sitting Bull and his Generals A great and valuable book; reads like a romance, and outsells all others Two hun dred thousand copies already aold. tjr Agents, oon t throw your tiine away on slow books, or worthless Imitations of this grand work, but send at once for the great original.

See moreSee less

It sells on sight. 600 large pages, and 120 Illustrations. 16, Fine Colored Pistes Price only )l. Canvassing Outfits 50o, Outfits FREE to Agents who si,, canvsssing for any other book. Don't miaa tb grand chance, but write at once for Piotorjal Cir culars and extra terms. Address

See the clipping