As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

November 1883

15 articles

The Bossier Banner · Bellevue, La.

An advertisement for J.W. Buel's book 'Heroes of the Plains' touts newly added material from his visit to Sitting Bull at Standing Rock Agency, claiming to present the Indian side of the 1876 Custer battle for the first time. It also promotes added content on 'White Beaver' and endorsements from military figures.

The Bossier Banner · 1 November 1883 · page 3

Shreveport, La. Heroes op the Plains.— Mr. J. W. Bnel, the well known anthor and traveler, spent a large part of the past summer among the Indians of the West, and daring the time visit ed the renowned Chief, Sitting Bull,

See the clipping

The Bossier Banner · Bellevue, La.

An advertisement solicits agents to sell J.W. Buel's book 'Heroes of the Plains,' which claims to contain the 'only authorized and truthful history' of Custer's Last Fight, allegedly related by Sitting Bull and his chiefs to the author in person. The ad touts illustrations, portraits, and sales figures to attract traveling salesmen.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Bossier Banner · 1 November 1883 · page 3

A book of wild life and thrilling adventure« on the Plain»; fights with Indians aud desperate whit« men; grand Buffalo hunt»; narrow escapes, wonderful shooting and rul ing. The only authorized and truthful history of the daring exploits of the greatest Indian fighters. monts, hunters and guides of the lar Wild Bill, Buffalo Bill, Gen. Custer, Califor nia Joe, CaptJack, the Poet Scout, Texas Jack, Kit Carson,Capt. Payne, the Cimarron Scout, White Beaver, the great Medicine Man of the Sioux, and many other celebrated Plains men, Pint and only History of Custer's "Last Fight," as related by Sitting Bull and bis Chief» to the abthor in person, with accurate Topographic Illustrations of the Battle, and snperib portraits of Sitting Bnll and his Gen erals.

See moreSee less

A great and valuable book-, reads like a romance, and outsells all others. Two hun dred thousand copies already sold. EP Agents, don't throw your time away on slow books, or worthless imitations of this grand work, bat send at once for the great original. It sells on sight. 600 large pages, 120 illustrations 16 Fine Colored Plates Price only $2.00. Canvassing Outfits 60. Outfits free to Agents who are canvassing for any other book. Don't miss this grand cnance, but write at once for Pictorial Circulars and extra terms address, HISTORICAL PUBLISHING CO.,

See the clipping

Catoctin Clarion · Mechanicstown, Md.

A classified ad solicits sales agents for a book by J.W. Buel claiming to be the "only authorized and truthful history" of Custer's Last Fight, supposedly based on accounts from Sitting Bull and his chiefs. It promises illustrations, portraits, and dramatic tales of frontier figures alongside the Custer narrative.

Catoctin Clarion · 1 November 1883 · page 2

Wild Bill, Uit Halo Bill, Gen. 1 C um! or, I alifornin Joe, C'apl. ’ Jack, the Pool Seoul, Tex as* Jack, Kit Carson, Clapt. Payne, the Cim arron Mount. White Beaver, the Oreat fled loine .Han of the Sioux, ;And many other celebrated Plainsmen.— First and only History of Custer’s “Last. Fight,” as related by Sitting Bull and bis Chiefs to the author in person, with accu rate Topographic Illustrations of the Bat tle, and superb portraits of Sitting Bull land bis Generals.—A great and valuable ■book; rends like a romance, and outsells all others.

See moreSee less

Two hundred thousand copies already sold. C-tT Agents, don’t throw your time away on slotebooks, or worthless imitations of this grand work, but send at once for the great original. It sells on sight. 0(10 large pages, 130 Illustrations, tfi Fine Col ored Plates. Price only $3.00. Canvass ing Outfits 50c. Outfits FREE to Agents who are canvassing for any other hook.— Don’t miss this good chance, but write at ■once for Pictorial Circulars and extra terms, address,

See the clipping

The Bossier Banner · Bellevue, La.

An advertisement seeks sales agents for a book called 'Heroes of the Plains' by J.W. Buel, claiming to be the 'only authorized and truthful history' of Western adventures. It highlights a chapter on Custer's 'Last Fight' supposedly as told by Sitting Bull and his chiefs directly to the author.

The Bossier Banner · 8 November 1883 · page 3

Wanted The Great New Book of 'Western Ad ventures. book of wild life and thrilling adventures __on the Plains; fights with Indians aud desperate white men; grand Buffalo hunts; narrow escapes, wonderful shooting and rid ing. The only authorized and truthful history of the daringexploits of the greatest Indian fighters.scouts, hunters and guides of the tar fighters, scouts, West. Wild Bill, Buffalo Bill. Gen. Custer, Califor nia Joe, Capt. Jack, the Poet Scout,, Texas Jack, Kit Carson,Capt. Payne, the Cimarron Scout, White Beaver, the great Medicine Man ofthc Sioux, and many other celebrated Plains men, First and only History of Custer's "Last Fight," as related by Sitting Bull and his Chiefs to thoanthorin person, with accurate Topographic Illustrations of the Battle, aud superb portraits of Sitting Bull and his Gen erals.

See moreSee less

A great and valunble book; reads like a romance, and outsells all others. Two hun dred thousand copies already sold. CP Agents, don't throw your time away on slow books, or worthless imitations of this graud work, but send at once for the great original. It sells on sight. 600 large pages, 120 illustrations, 1G Fine Colored Plates. Price only $2.00. Canvassing Outfits 60. Outfits free to Agents who are canvassing for any other book. Don't, miss this grand chance,but write at once for Pictorial Circularsand extra terms address. HISTORICAL PUBLISHING CO.,

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Bossier Banner · Bellevue, La. · 15 November 1883

Catoctin Clarion · Mechanicstown, Md.

This is a mail-order advertisement for 'The Great New Book of Western Adventures,' claiming to be the only authorized history of Custer's 'Last Fight' as told by Sitting Bull and his chiefs. It promises topographic illustrations, portraits, and sensational tales of Western plainsmen for agents to sell.

Catoctin Clarion · 8 November 1883 · page 2

Wild Bill, ItuUalo Kill, Gen. CiiH'er, < nlilornia Joe, < apt. Jaek, the Poet Scout, Tex an* Jack, Hit Carr* ii, I t upl. Payne, the C'lin arron Scout, While Beaver, the Great Med icine Man of the Sioux, And many other celebrated Plainsmen.— First and only History of Custer’s “Last Fight," as related by Sitting Bull and his !Chiefs to the author in person, with accu rate Topographic Illustrations of the Bat tle, and superb portraits of Silting Bull and his Generals.—A great unci valuable hook; reads like a romance, and ovtatlht all other*.

See moreSee less

Two hundred thousand copies already sold. HP Agents, don’t throw your time away on tlow book*, or worthless imitations lof this grand work, lint send at once for the great original. It mil on sight (100 large pages, 120 Illustrations, Hi Fine Col ored Plates. Price only $2.00. Canvass ing Outfits 60c. Outfits FREE to Agents who are canvassing for any other book. — Don’t miss this good chance, but write at jonee for Pictorial Circulars and extra llerms, address,

See the clipping

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.

A Minnesota newspaper criticizes the Cleveland Leader for publishing a sensational account of the Custer massacre supposedly from the only white eyewitness. The editor points out this is impossible since no white man who witnessed the battle survived, making all non-Indian versions mere conjecture.

The Worthington Advance · 8 November 1883 · page 2

The Cleveland (O.) Leader publishes a long account of the Custer massacre from the "lips of the only white man who witnessed it." It is unnecessary to say

See the clipping

The Desmet Leader · Desmet, S.D.

The item criticizes a Cleveland Leader account claiming to be from 'the only white man who witnessed' the Custer massacre. It states flatly that no white man survived to witness the event, so any such account is mere conjecture.

The Desmet Leader · 10 November 1883 · page 2

The Cleveland (O.) Leader publishes a long account of the Custer massacre from the "lips of the only white man who witnessed It.” It is unnecessary to say

See the clipping

The Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A 74-year-old frontiersman recounts his adventures trading and living among Sioux and Ute tribes, under the headline 'The Custer Massacre.' The interview veers into his personal tale of killing four Sioux men near Big Stone Lake in 1878, with little direct connection to the actual battle.

The Rock Island Argus · 13 November 1883 · page 1

The Custer Massacre. There is an old gentleman, 74 years of age, whose home is on the west side, but who, nevertheless, spends nearly all of

See the clipping

The Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · and 1 other paper

A self-described former trapper recounts a wild frontier story before claiming to be the only white man who witnessed the Battle of Little Bighorn. He describes Custer's men being ambushed in a gorge and slaughtered, ending with Custer fighting alone with revolver and sabre until felled.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Rock Island Argus · 13 November 1883 · page 1

Island was one of those naruroscarum sort o'chaps and said be didn't give a darn for the whole tribe. I did everything in my power to bring about a settlement between him and the Indians for the dog, but he wouldn't give a cent. The redskins set tled the matter, however, by tearing the diughter, scieiming and crying, from the mother's arms. That bight I camped with than, and before morning they had mur dered the girl in a manner that makes me shudder to this day. I did all I could to save the girl, but I darent say to much White Ex.

See moreSee less

C or thev would have turried on me. Yes, I was the. only white man that witnessed the Custer massacre. I had been trap ping along the Little Big Horn river that day, when a Sioux warrior, all covered with paint, rode up to me and said that there "was going to be a big fight, and if I wanted to see it to go and join the squaws on the other side of the neighboring gorge Kentucky Cider, W bbl., New York Cider, gal. I had no idea at the time that the tight Salt "... was against Uncle Sam's soldiers until I saw the blue coated columns moving slow ly up the gorge with Custer at the lit ad.' He was following the trail of a party of Indians who were leading him into am bush. From my position on the side of the bluff, behind a lot ot briar bush, I had a good view of the terrible slaughter. Thousands of Sioux bucks were stationed on either side of. the gorge, and when Imperial Custer was abreast of them they began to Gun Powder Young Hyson . pour in a cross fire, which moved his men English Breakfast. down like so much grass. He could not Oolong Japan advance, as the gorge ended at this point; neither could he retreat. In fact he was Quincy Patent completely hemmed in, and the best they wuincy Kagle could do was to get behind the dead White Rose horses and men for protection . The In Gold Medal Minnesota dians began to swarm out of their hiding Chapman's Best .Jack Frost places and charmed him. lie drove them Mt. Olive back lime after time with fearful slaugh White Satin ter, but it was do use, for fresh men took Uie place of fallen braves, who charged again. At last all the blue coats had bit No. S mackerel hf. bbls No. 1 mackerel kits ten the dust except Custer himself . There No. 2 mackerel - kits ne stood alone, liehind his barricade ot human bodies, with white . face and set teelh, firing his revolver with his left No. 1 white tish kits hand and swinging his sabre with bis right The last thing I saw him do was to smash out the brains of a big Sioux with the butt of his revolver. The Indians inten ded to take him prisoner, but he fought so like a tiger that they had to kill him. I left the scene in about half an hour af ter the fight, as the Indians had found some whiskey in the canteens of the dead soldiers and were preparing to have a big drunk.'and I concluded, therefore, that it would be healthier for me to light out." Cleveland Leader.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Benton Weekly Record · Benton, Mont. · 24 November 1883

Centre Democrat · Bellefonte, Pa.

A comrade recounts Buffalo Bill's famous duel with the Sioux chief Yellow Hand shortly after Custer's defeat, describing an elaborate mounted rifle duel where both combatants circled each other before their horses fell and Bill shot the wounded chief. The story is told secondhand as a dramatic legend of the noted scout's prowess.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Centre Democrat · 15 November 1883 · page 7

BUFFALO HILL'S DUEL. Th oul'a |lt|ool> F.nrintr will* nn I itllaii I hlef. One of Jllll's comrades tells this Tory of the noted scout's duel with an Indian chief: "it was just after the massacre of Custer," he saiil "Bill

See the clipping

The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D.

The Cleveland Leader published an account claiming to be from the only white man who witnessed the Custer massacre. This report dismisses that claim, noting no white man survived to witness it and that only Indian participant accounts exist.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Kimball Graphic · 16 November 1883 · page 2

There Is scarcely a locality in tbe northwest where fuel is so cheap that a frailly can afford to dispense with dou ble windows and many other expedients for keeping out the cold blasts of winter. Storm windows are very cheap, or at least the sasb, and anybody who has a bit of gumption can set tbe glass. Com fort is better than riches. The Cleveland (O.) Leader publishes a ong account of the Custer massacre from

See the clipping

Catoctin Clarion · Mechanicstown, Md.

This is an advertisement for a book titled 'Western Adventures' claiming to be the only authorized and truthful history of Custer's 'Last Fight,' as told by Sitting Bull and his chiefs to the author. It is marketed to agents for sale, boasting illustrations, colored plates, and 200,000 copies already sold.

Catoctin Clarion · 22 November 1883 · page 2

UiM Hill, I?nHalo Kill, Clcn. ('lister, i nlitounia Joe, (apt. Jack, (lie Poet Seoul, Tex as) Jack, lilt Cans-m, Csipt. I'ayne, (he Cim arron Seoul, White Heaver, the 4reat Med icine Man or the Sioux, j And many other celebrated Plainsmen.— ! First and only History of Custer's “Last Fight,” as related by Sitting Bull and bis [ Chiefs to the author in person, with aeeu ' rate Topographic Illustrations of the Battle, 1 and superb portraits of Sitting Bull and bis I Generals.—A great and valuable book; reads [ like a romance, and outsells all othen.

See moreSee less

Two hundred thousand copies already sold. 1 SPfr Agents, don't throw your lime away on xlm books, or worthless imitations of this I grand work, hut send at once for the great original. It sells on 120 Illustrations, 10 Fine Colored Plates.— Price only $2.00. Canvassing Outfits 50c.

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Artist Geo. D. Lunt has returned from the Custer battle field and made an accurate pen and ink drawing of it. The drawing shows the terrain features, Sitting Bull's camp, Custer's field, and the spots where Custer and his officers fell.

Bismarck Tribune · 23 November 1883 · page 8

Hilh and ravine* ia very carefully preserved, the sage brush and graaea are plainly vis­ ible. It gives the locations of the various por­ tions of the battle, including Sitting Bull's camp, Custer's field, and the spots where the

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

A German-language U.S. newspaper in 1883 reports a man's account of being captured by Sioux near the Black Hills with his family, enduring years of captivity, marrying a native woman, and claiming to have witnessed Custer's death at Little Bighorn before being 'captured' alongside Sitting Bull. He eventually escaped via British Columbia, destitute, with no knowledge of his wife and children's fate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 30 November 1883 · page 3

kvislvhcn. Ich war bei der Ermordung des Generals Custer am Little Big Horn-River zugegen und ebenso wie „Sitting Bull" ge fangen genommen wurde. Tie meiste Zeit brachte ich mit Fischeu und Jagen, mit Fal lenstellen u. s. w. hin. Ich spreche geläufig

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A correspondent corrects an earlier report, stating only 400 Indians went buffalo hunting rather than a higher number claimed, and details the extensive rations and supplies (beef, flour, tools, plows, housing materials) provided by the government to argue against sympathy for alleged Indian starvation. The writer references the Custer massacre and earlier Minnesota violence to justify skepticism toward claims of mistreatment.

Bismarck Tribune · 30 November 1883 · page 1

Custer massacre, fresh in the minds of all. The contractors have furnished for this year: 3,075,000 pounds of beef, besides several thous­ ands pounds of pork, 500,000 pounds of flour

See the clipping