As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

November 1881

18 articles

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

This 1881 report presents Low Dog's eyewitness account of the Battle of Little Bighorn, describing the Sioux charge against Custer's dismounted soldiers and their valiant but doomed stand. Low Dog states he did not witness Custer's death and does not know who killed him, noting the chaos of battle and the chiefs' order not to mutilate the fallen commander's body.

The Stark County Democrat · 3 November 1881 · page 3

77. Spencer in Popular Science Monthly. Custer's Valor. The most striking account get given by Indians of Custer's last battle is that by Low Dog, as follows ;

See the clipping

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

A Native American warrior recounts the Little Bighorn battle years later, describing Custer's men fighting bravely to the last man and being killed, while Reno's force retreated and was later spared by the chiefs' mercy. He claims not to have known Custer's identity during the fight and denies knowledge of who killed him.

The Stark County Democrat · 3 November 1881 · page 3

ing nntil the runner came in and told us. I do not say that Reno was a coward He fought well, but our men were fight ing to save their women and childfen, and drove them back. If Reno and his warriors had fought as Custer aud his warriors fought, the battle might have been against us. No white man or In dian ever fought as bravely as Custwr and his men. The next day we sought Reno and his forces again and killed many of them. Then the chiefs said these men had been punished enough and that we ought to be merciful, and we let them go.

See moreSee less

Then we heard that another force was coming up the river to fight us (General Terry's command), and we started to fight them, bnt tha chiefs and wise men counseled that we had fought enough, and that we should not fight unless attacked, and we went back and took our women and children and went away."

See the clipping

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory

The report notes that a granite obelisk monument has been erected on the battlefield where General Custer fell. It states the monument bears the names of all who died in Custer's fight.

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 8 November 1881 · page 3

The Custer monument has been erected on t lie battlefield on which the daring General fell. It is of gran ite, in the form of a low obelisk. It bears the uames of all who died in j Cusli r's fight. --------- Colonel Robert C-. Ingersoll is go ing with all his family to New Mexi co, where lie has bee .me interested in some silver mines. The miner's little effort: 'I seek for weal I h in vein."

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

General Sheridan reports on Sitting Bull's surrender and return from British Columbia, noting he was not a prominent warrior and played only a peripheral role in the Custer battle. Sheridan states that Northern Cheyenne and Oglala Sioux under Crazy Horse actually did the fighting, cautioning against false narratives attributed to Sitting Bull.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 32 days earlier.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 9 November 1881 · page 12

SHERIDAN'S SHOWING.

ward being civilized. Ho was In tho outskirts of (ho light with Custer, hut not conspicuous, ami shortly afterward struck out with his small band for llrltlsh Columbia, being subsequently followed, from necessity, by other bunds of Sioux. I have seen In newspapers long accounts mid narratives purporting to bo descriptions of ttio (hister battle, as related by Sitting-Bull, which had, In my opinion, hut Utile train In them, and historians arc cautioned against re* celvlug them us correct. The Northern Chev* ciincs and tho Ugallaia Sioux—tho former under two or threeof their principal chiefs, and tho latter mntor Crazy Horse, as their leaders—did the llglillng at tho battle of tho Little Horn, when Custer fell. With the exception of the Incursions of In*

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

General Sheridan's official report downplays Sitting Bull's status, claiming he was not a chief but merely led a small band of about sixty lodges and was not prominent in the fighting against Custer. Sheridan credits the Northern Cheyennes and Crazy Horse's Oglala Sioux with doing the actual fighting at Little Bighorn, and warns against trusting published narratives attributed to Sitting Bull.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

New-York Tribune · 10 November 1881 · page 8

TILE APACHLES. Cricaco, Nov. 9.—General Sheridan's official peport has been forwarded to the General of the Army. In Lis review of the departments he shows that peace generally prevailed. Referring to the Indians, the case of 8itting Bull receives some attention. (General Sheridan says : “ Sitting Bull was not a chief, but was the leader ofa greall band of about sixty lodges, who held with him the same feelings of bitter opposition toward being civil fzed. le was in the outskirts of the fignt with Custer, bul not eonspicuous, and shortly afterward struck out with his small band for British Columbia, being subsequently followed, from necessity, by other bands of Bioux.

See moreSee less

Ihave seen in the newspapers long accounts and narratives, purporting to be descriptions of Custer’s Dateic as related by Sitting Bull, which had in my opin- "on but little truth in them, and historians are cautioned agalust reeciving them as correct, The Northern Cheyennes and Ogallala 8ioux—the former under two or three of their principal chiefs, and the latter under Crazy Horse, as their leader—did the fighting at the Battle of Little Horn when Caster fell.” . In the Department of the Platte there were no even of miiitary importance. General Sheridan earnestly recommends Congressional action to keep out intruders from the Indian Territory. * The military field operations in Texas,” says General Sheridan, “during the year were confined to the pursuit of small raiding partics from Mexico. The extensive construction of raiiways in Texas has greatly contributed to the economical adminfatration of this department and to the effectiveness of military operations. The good feeling which exists between our Mexican neighbors and ourselves along the Grande frontier has almost entirely relieved the emments which for a long time existed in that directicu. The troops in this division are efficient, and their discipline good, considering the smaliness of the companies and the amount of bard work to be performed in fighting Indians, building posts, making roads, guarding settlements and raMroads, and escorting parties engaged in surveying projected railroads, boundary lines and public lands in the Territories. The rights and lands of Indians have also to be protected against encroachments, and I have to reiterate what I have said in former rethat the Army is much too small efficiently and to perf the duties required of it. I recommend greater activity in enlistments.” In the nt of the Missonri sinall raiding par-

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

General Sheridan's official report downplays Sitting Bull's role at Little Bighorn, calling him a minor leader of about sixty lodges who was not conspicuous in the fight. He credits the Northern Cheyennes and Oglala Sioux under Crazy Horse with the actual fighting against Custer, and warns historians against trusting sensationalized newspaper accounts attributed to Sitting Bull.

The Portland Daily Press · 11 November 1881 · page 2

REPORT OF GEN. SHERIDAN. Ilncrease of the Army Recommended. Chicago, Nov. 10.—Gen. Sheridan’s official report has been forwarded to the General of the Army. In his review of .the departments he shows that peace generally prevailed. Re ferring to the Indians, the case of Sitting Bull receives some attention. General Sheridan says: “Sitting Bull was not a chief, but was the leader of a small band of about sixty lodges, who held with him the same feelings of bitter opposition toward being civilized. He was in the outskirts of the fight with Custer, but not conspicuous, and shortly afterward struck out with his small band for British Columbia, being subsequently followed, from necessity, by other bands {of Sioux.

See moreSee less

I have seen in the newspapers long accounts and nar ratives, purporting to |be descriptions of Cus ter’s battle as related by Sitting Bull, which had in my opinion but little truth in them, and historians are cautioned against receiving them as correct. The Northern Cheyennes and Ogalla Sioux—the former under two or three of their principal chiefs, and the latter under Crazy Horse, as their leader— did the fighting at the battle of Little Horn when Custer fell.”

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

General Sheridan cautions historians against accepting recent newspaper accounts claiming Sitting Bull participated in the Custer massacre. He also praises Mexican authorities for cooperating with U.S. troops during the Indian troubles.

Connecticut Western News · 16 November 1881 · page 4

General Sheridan warns historians not to accept as true recent newspaper accounts off Sitting Bull's participation in the. Custer massacre. He highly praises also the Mexican authorities for their prompt co-operation with our troops an the Indian troubles. Nine persons were killed and many others were injured Wednesday morn ing by the falling of two houses at the corner of Grand street and South Fifth avenue, New York City, With two towns to hear from, the total vote of the State of Massachusetts

See the clipping

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · and 2 other papers

General Sheridan's annual report notes peace among most Dakota Indians and the removal of Sitting Bull as a rallying point after his surrender from Canada. He credits the Northern Cheyennes and Crazy Horse's Oglala Sioux with the fighting at Little Bighorn and dismisses published accounts attributed to Sitting Bull as largely untrue.

The Worthington Advance · 17 November 1881 · page 1

Army and Indians In Dakota. CHICAGO, Nov. 9.—Lieut Gen. Sheridan, in sub mitting bis annual report, says: Although the department of Dakota has bv far the larjrest number ot Indians from whom hostile acts micht be expected, these have been at peace during the past year and seem to have made some advancement in labor and in the cultivation of the soil at the different aeencies. The exceedingly an noying condition of havint? a small body of our hostile Indians with Sittine Bull just across the line in British Columbia has been removed by the sur render of this head man.

See moreSee less

So long as this body of Indians remained across the line, they formed a nucleus with whom all dissatisfied or disaffected ones at the agencies could take refuge. For this reason I supported Gen. Terry in his efforts 'o get Sitting Bull back, and I think the results will be satisfactory. Al though Sittini: Bull was not much of a warrior, and had no prestige among Indians on that account still he was stubborn in his resistance to the gov ernment reservation system and naturally had many adherents among the disaffected. I have seen in newspapers long accounts and narratives purport ing to be descriptive of the Custer battle as related by Sitting Bull, which had, in my opinion, but little truth in them, and historians are cautioned against receiving them as correct. The northern Cheyennes and Ogallala Sioux, the former under two or three of their prin cipal chiefs and the latter under Crazy Horse as their leaders, did the fighting at the battle of the Little Bie Horn when Custer fell. To Gen. Terry, for his cood management, and to the troons who so faithfully served in the field during the bitter weather of last winter in collecting and bringing in bands of hostile Sioux who had surrendered, I re turn my sincere thanks. In this connection the services of Maj. Guido Ilges, Fifth infantry, and his command are especially deserving of commen dation.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn. · 17 November 1881
  • The Northern Pacific Farmer · Wadena, Minn. · 17 November 1881

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

General Sheridan's annual report to the Army describes Sitting Bull's surrender from Canada and downplays his role in the Custer battle, noting he was not a chief and not conspicuous in the fighting. Sheridan cautions historians against trusting published narratives claiming to be Sitting Bull's own account of the battle.

The Iola Register · 18 November 1881 · page 7

Amallercvt. la Us raetat amaal report to the General of the Army liuteaaat-Garal Sheridaa speaks at length cMcaratoff military affairs in his eow i. -After recapitulating the compositloa ai UteeamsBd aad stating its dispoaiUoB, the Lieut awt-General saya: 44 Although the Departaeat of Dakota has by far the largest number of Indiana frea whoa hostile acts mizht be expected, these have bee at peace, dorwg the past year, d teem to have nude mm adraaceneat in labor aad in the cultivation ef the sell, at tbe different agencies. The exceedingly annoying condition of having a null body of our hostile Indians, with Sitting Bull,

See the clipping

The Cambria Freeman · Ebensburg, Pa.

The report states that Mrs. W. M. Evans of Pottstown possesses the tomahawk supposedly used by Sitting Bull in the Custer massacre. It claims the weapon was given to her by Lieutenant Ogle, to whom Sitting Bull had surrendered it.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Cambria Freeman · 18 November 1881 · page 2

niwiy. l ne citizens threaten lo ivncn mm. j Johiel Kent, a noted turfman, of Susi horses, while attempting to harness a frac tious horse on Saturday was kicked to death. Mrs. W. M. Evans, of Pottstown, claims to have the tomahawk used by Sitting Bull in the Custer massacre. It was given to her by Lieutenant Ogle, to whom it was surren dered. Snow fell last week in large quantities in Western Kansas, Colorado and New Mex ico and trains were greatly delavect. Inoth

See the clipping

The Sentinel · Trenton, N.J.

General Sheridan's annual report states Sitting Bull was not a chief but led a small band of about sixty lodges, and was not conspicuous in the fighting against Custer. Sheridan credits the Northern Cheyennes and Crazy Horse's Oglala Sioux with doing the actual fighting, and warns historians against trusting embellished newspaper accounts attributed to Sitting Bull.

The Sentinel · 19 November 1881 · page 4

Generai Sheridam'< Report. General Sheridan's oSciad report has been orwarded to the general of the army. He "r 2*^ that peace has generally prevailed in the '!:9Yren: departments daring the past year, tie: riing to Sitting Bull he says: "Sitting Bttit wag not a chief, but was the leader of a mall ban ! of abon: sixty lodges, who held "dth hitn the same feelings of bitter opposition toward being civilized. He was in the out :s of the fight with Caster, bat not con spicuous, ^nl shortly afterward Struck oat with his small band for British Columbia, being subsequently followed, from necessity, by other bands of Sioux.

See moreSee less

I have seen in the newspapers long accounts and narratives par porting to be descriptions of Caster's battle, as reiatecf by Sitting ball, which had, in my opin t jtn bat little truth In them: and historians are cautioned against receiving them as correct. The M.rthem Cheyennes and Ogii'ala Sioux— tne former nnder two or three of tneir princi pa. chiefs, and the latter under Crazy Horse as

See the clipping

Democratic Messenger · Snow Hill, Md.

General Sheridan cautions historians against trusting recent newspaper accounts describing Sitting Bull's direct participation in the Custer massacre. He also commends Mexican authorities for cooperating with U.S. troops during the Indian troubles.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Democratic Messenger · 19 November 1881 · page 4

i!o*t>fr, TROVPS*rA., ftlVmiaa *• Yark. majority. The Liberals claim Iris ma jority at over 10,000. —The Republicans have gained unex pected victories in several Democratic counties in Maryland, including live Senators and seven Assemblymen. -With two towns to hear from, the total vote of the State of Massachusetts is: Long, 06,582; Thompson, 58,558; Andrews, 4,775; Almy, 1,741. Long’s majority will be over 30,000. —ln New York the Republican State ticket, with the exception of Gen. Rus ted, is elected. The New York Times says the latter is undoubtedly defeated, though full returns of his vote have not ye t been received.

See moreSee less

—The Capitol building at Austin, Texas, was burned down Wednesday, j —General Sheridan warns historians not to accept as true recent newspaper accounts of Sitting Bull’s participation in the Custer massacre. Ho highly praises also the Mexican authorities for their prompt co-operation with our troops in the Indian troubles. —Nino persons were killed and many others were injured Wednesday morn ing by the falling of two houses at the corner of Graud street aud South Fifth avenue, New York City. —Ah Kim, a Chinese student at Mari j etta College, committed suicide because 1 he could not win a servant girl’s love. —Phillip E. Sullivan, one of the j young Arkansas train-robbers, died in ; prison Tuesday of nostalgia, or homeJ sickness. He had seventy years to serve.

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

General Sheridan's official report states Sitting Bull was a minor band leader, not a chief, who played no conspicuous role in the fight against Custer. He credits the actual fighting to Crazy Horse and Cheyenne chiefs, and dismisses popular newspaper accounts attributed to Sitting Bull as largely untrue.

Narragansett Herald · 19 November 1881 · page 4

General Sheridan’s official r?rt has beer forwarded to the general of the army. He shows that peace has generally prevailed in the different departments during the past year Referring to Sitting Bull he says: *‘Sitting Bull was not a chief, but was the leader of 2 small band of about sixty lodges, who hell with him the same feelings of bitter oppositior toward being civilized. He was in the out skirts of the fight with Custer, but not con spicnous, and shortly afterward struck oui with his small band for British Columbia, being subsequently followed, from necessity, by other bands of Sioux.

See moreSee less

I have seen in the newspapers long accounts and narratives pur porting to be descriptions of Custer’s battle, as related by Sitting Bull, which had, in my opin ion, but little truth in them; and historians are cautioned against receiving them as correct. The Northern Cheyennes and Ogallala Sioux— the former under two or three of their princi pal chiefs, and the latter under Crazy Horse as their lealers—did the fighting at the battle of Little Horn when Caster fell.” In the department of the Platte there were no events of military importance, and the milii tary fleld operations in Texas during the yea: were confined to the pursuit of small raiding parties from Mexico. The one which did the most damage was severely chastised by First

See the clipping

The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn.

General Sheridan's annual report describes Sitting Bull's surrender from British Columbia and his minor role in the Custer fight, noting he was not a chief but led a small band. Sheridan explicitly warns historians against trusting published narratives attributed to Sitting Bull about the Custer battle, calling them largely untrue.

The Milan Exchange · 19 November 1881 · page 6

Grand Jury. Bv the will of Chas. II. Northam, of Hartford, Conn., Trinity College receives $120,000; Hartford Hospital, $00,000; Christ Episcopal Church, $10,000. The sum of $30 000 is given to erect a chapel at Cedar Hill Cemetery. Tho remainder of the estate, about $000,000, is distributed among tho heirs. Geo. Park, of Charleston, W. Va., shot and killed bis half-brother. No arrest Gamuetta announced the definite formation of the Cabinet to President Grevy, at Paris, on tho 14th. Dii'H theria, scarlet fever and small pox are devastating the central and southern portion of Russia.

See moreSee less

Herbert Osiiorn, of San Rafael, Cal., murdered Mrs. Prinee by breaking her Jaw with an iron and then poisoned biiu self with laudanum. Lord Lorne arrived in Liverpool, Eng., on the 14th, and was met by the Prin cess Louise, and with her proceeded to the seat of the Duke of AVestminster, neart'hes ter. They were cheered by thousands of people who had assembled at Birkenhead Landing stage. There was -also a popular and municipal reception In their honor at Chester. Eight persons in New Orleans were poisoned by eating creamcakes purchased at the bakery of A. V. Flotte. Some of the cake was procured by Capt. Gill, who sent It to Chief Boylan's office, from whence it was taken to the Charity Hospital for ana lysis. The supposition Is that the poison was contained in the baking powder used in making the cakes. As Mr. Flotte Is well known as an honest, industrious man, who bail no animosity against any one of the par ties, the police tare of the opinion that the poisoning, was an accident. i.eneral Sheridan Annual Report. In his recent annual report to the General of the Army l.ieutenanl-General Sheridan speaks at length concerning military affair in IIIcommand. After reespini ating tho composi j,n of bis command and staling it di-posii ion, the Lieutenant-General s.iys: "Although the Department of Dakotaha by far tielargest number of Indian from w hom hntiie acts might be expected, these ha e b. en at peace, during the pa-t vear, mil seem to have made some advancement in labor and In the cultivation of the soil. at 1 he different agencies. The exceedingly auuoving condition of having a small body of our hostile Indians, with Sitting Bull, )ust across the boundary line. In British Columbia, has been removed by the sur render of this head man. Nearly all of tho Indians who clustered around him have come over, either with him or in advance of him, and have submitted to the authority of tbe Government. So long as this body of Indians remained across tho line, they formed a uuclcus with whom all dissatisfied or disaffected ones, at I lie agencies, could take refuge. For this reason I supported General Terry in his efforts to get .fitting Bull back, and I think tbe results will bo satisfactory. Although Sitting Bull was not much ot a warrior, and hd ni prestige among Indians on that account, still he was stubborn in bis resistance to the Govern ment reservation system, and naturally had many adherents among the disaffected. Hi original offense was his refusal to go to tho reservation of his tribe the ITncapapas at Standing Rock; be wanted to live wild. He was not a chief in that tri'oe, but was the leader of a small band of about sixty lodges,, who held with him the same feelings of bit ter opposition toward being civilized. Ho was in the outskirts of tho light with Cus ter, but not conspicuous, and shortly after ward struck out with his small band for British Columbia, being subsequently fol lowed, from necessity, by other hands of Sioux. I have seen in newspapers long ac counts and narratives purporting to be de scriptions of the Custer battle, as related by Sitting Bull, which have, in my opinion, but little truth in them, and historian are cautioned against receiving them as correct. The Northern Cheyennes and the Ogallala Sioux the former under two or three of their principal chiefs, and the latter, under Crazy Horse, as their leaders did the fight ing at the battle of the Litt'.e Horn, when Custer fell."

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

General Sheridan's official report to the army describes Sitting Bull as merely a minor band leader who was on the outskirts of the Custer fight, not a prominent participant, and cautions historians against trusting sensational newspaper accounts claiming to be Sitting Bull's own narrative of the battle. He credits Northern Cheyenne chiefs and Crazy Horse's Oglala Sioux as the actual combatants against Custer.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 23 November 1881 · page 4

cautioned against receiving them as correct. The Northern Chcyennes and Qgallala Sioux ? tho former under two or three of their principal chiefs, and the latter under-Crazy Horse as their leaders?did the fighting at the battle of Little Horn when Custer fell." In tho department of tho Platte there were

See the clipping

In the story →

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 3 other papers

This 1881 report disputes popular narratives attributing leadership of the Little Bighorn fight to Sitting Bull, stating he was a minor band leader of about sixty lodges who was not conspicuous in the battle. It credits the actual fighting to the Northern Cheyennes and Crazy Horse's Oglala Sioux, and warns against trusting newspaper accounts purporting to quote Sitting Bull's own description of the battle.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 months earlier.

Iron County Register · 24 November 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

General Sheridan's Annual Report.

In his recent annual report to the General of the Army Lieutenant-General Sheridan speaks at length concerning military affairs in his command. After recapitulating the composition of his command and stating its disposition, the Lieutenant-General says:

See moreSee less

"Although the Department of Dakota has by far the largest number of Indians from whom hostile acts might be expected, these have been at peace, during the past year, and seem to have made some advancement in labor and in the cultivation of the soil, at the different agencies. The exceedingly annoying condition of having a small body of our hostile Indians, with Sitting Bull, just across the boundary line, in British Columbia, has been removed by the surrender of this head man. Nearly all of the Indians who clustered around him have come over, either with him or in advance of him, and have submitted to the authority of the Government. So long as this body of Indians remained across the line, they formed a nucleus with whom all dissatisfied or disaffected ones, at the agencies, could take refuge. For this reason I supported General Terry in his efforts to get Sitting Bull back, and I think the results will be satisfactory. Although Sitting Bull was not much of a warrior, and had no prestige among Indians on that account, still he was stubborn in his resistance to the Government reservation system, and naturally had many adherents among the disaffected. His original offense was his refusal to go to the reservation of his tribe—the Uncapapas—at Standing Rock; he wanted to live wild. He was not a chief in that tribe, but was the leader of a small band of about sixty lodges, who held with him the same feelings of bitter opposition toward being civilized. He was in the outskirts of the fight with Custer, but not conspicuous, and shortly afterward struck out with his small band for British Columbia, being subsequently followed, from necessity, by other bands of Sioux. I have seen in newspapers long accounts and narratives purporting to be descriptions of the Custer battle, as related by Sitting Bull, which have, in my opinion, but little truth in them, and historians are cautioned against receiving them as correct. The Northern Cheyennes and the Ogallala Sioux—the former under two or three of their principal chiefs, and the latter, under Crazy Horse, as their leaders—did the fighting at the battle of the Little Horn, when Custer fell."

Referring to the Departments of the Platte and the Missouri, he says that "although they have had plenty of time, the Uncompahgre Utes, who were to move to this vicinity from the Department of the Missouri, have not yet arrived at the new agency appointed for them, on the east side of Green River, not far distant from the new post above mentioned; nor have the White River Utes yet reached the Uintah reservation—the place the Commissioners have selected for them as their future home. Hopes are, however, entertained that, before the first of the new year, both the Uncompahgre and the White River Utes will reach their respective destinations without serious trouble. Still, some fears are entertained that they may not go there, and this impression has so firmly settled itself in the mind of the Commission that, at the request of Commissioner Russel, the General of the army has directed that the White River Utes be driven to the Uintah agency. I am afraid, however, that little can be done toward carrying out this order before spring, and will hope that better results will have obtained before that time. No one can form any idea, excepting by personal examination, of the rough and broken country of the Gunnison and White rivers—the old home of the White River Utes—and I shall hope for a peaceful solution and settlement of this complication without necessity for military operations."

"In the Department of the Missouri, small raiding parties of Apache Indians—the remnant of Victoria's band, joined by a few young men from the Mescalero reservation, in all not to exceed sixty in number—caused widespread alarm and serious loss of human life in Southern New Mexico last winter. The band came in from Mexico, south of Fort Cummings, and, after making a raid of extraordinary boldness, recrossed into Mexico near their point of entrance. They killed a number of people, and, I am sorry to say, received but little punishment in return. This same band re-entered Southern New Mexico in July and raided the same region of country, killing Lieutenant G. W. Smith, 9th cavalry, and several people, and again escaping into Mexico without serious loss so far as I have been able to learn from any official data received at these headquarters. I would advise that, if possible, the consent of the Mexican Government be obtained for our troops to cross and catch this small band of free-booters, or at least to break down the confidence, with which the boundary line inspires them, in their ability to escape punishment."

In regard to the Indian Territory General Sheridan says: "I earnestly recommend Congressional action to keep out intruders from Indian Territory. Had it not been for the military, the territory of Oklahoma would have now been covered with settlements. The intruders have been kept out by companies of troops marching from east to west and back again, on the south side of the line between Indian Territory and the State of Kansas, while the intruders marched to and fro, in Kansas, on the north side of the same line. The question, as I understand it, is this: Congress bought certain lands from Indians belonging to Indian Nation, for the purpose of colonizing other bands of Indians upon these lands. After some hostile Indians had been settled on portions of these lands, some of the members of Congress and Senators of adjacent States, becoming alarmed at the assembling of these Indians in Indian Territory, secured the passage of an act prohibiting the removal of certain outside Indians to Indian Territory. Then the people, styled the "intruders," set up the claim that what was left of this purchase, which is now named Oklahoma, was subject to the same conditions of settlement as any other public domain, and they still persist in their purpose of obtaining possession of it. I therefore earnestly recommend some Congressional action which will settle this question and release the military from the complications involved by this Oklahoma trouble."

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas · 18 November 1881
  • Southern Standard · McMinnville, Tenn. · 19 November 1881
  • The Milan Exchange · Milan, Tenn. · 19 November 1881

West-Jersey Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

General Sheridan's official report states that Sitting Bull was not a chief but led a small band of about sixty lodges, and was only on the outskirts of the fight with Custer, not conspicuous in it. He identifies Crazy Horse and Cheyenne chiefs as the actual leaders of the fighting, and warns historians against trusting newspaper accounts attributed to Sitting Bull.

West-Jersey Pioneer · 24 November 1881 · page 2

GEN. SHERIDAN’S REPORT. Hen. Sheridan’s official report has been forwarded to the General of the Army. He shows that peace has generally pre vailed in the different departments dur ing the past year. Referring to Sitting Bull he says: “Sitting Bpll was not a chief, but was the leader of a small band of about sixty lodges, who held with him the same feelings of bitter opposition toward being civilized. He was in the outskirts of the fight with Custer, but not conspicuous, and shortly afterward struck out with his small band for British Columbia, being subsequently followed, from necessity, by other bands of Sioux.

See moreSee less

1 have seen in the newspapers long ac counts and narratives, purporting to be descriptions of Custer’s battle, as related by Sitting Bull, which had, in my opinion, but little truth in them; and historians are cautioned against receiving them as correct. The Northern Cheyennes and Ogailala Sioux—the former under two or three of their principal chiefs, and the latter under Crazy Horse as their lead ers—did the fighting at the battle of Bit tie Horn when Custer fell.”

See the clipping

The Carbon Advocate · Lehighton, Pa.

A brief notice states that Mrs. W. M. Evans of Pottstown claims to own the tomahawk used by Sitting Bull in the Custer massacre, given to her by a Lieutenant Ogle to whom it was reportedly surrendered. The item appears amid unrelated miscellaneous news items with no further verification offered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 37 days later.

Wrong

The Carbon Advocate · 26 November 1881 · page 4

.TIlSCELI.iJtUOlJS. Ad unknown old woman was fotmilileait In th streats ef Pittsburg on Thursday. Starvation was the eauso of her death. Mrs. W. M. Evans, ef Fottstown, claims to havo the tomahawk used by Silting Bull in the Custer massacre. It was given to her by Lieutenant Ogle, to whom it was sur rendered.

See the clipping