As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

September 1881

20 articles

Arizona Weekly Citizen · Tucson, Ariz

This 1881 feature offers a biographical sketch of Sitting Bull, describing his lineage, youth as a hunter, rise to chieftainship, and family, framed within racist rhetoric about 'survival of the fittest' and the inevitability of white conquest. It also notes his role in the 'massacre' of Custer and his subsequent flight to and recent return from Canada.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Arizona Weekly Citizen · 4 September 1881 · page 2

SirriNtt BULL Tto Kroleoa of The Red Skini. In presenting, to-day, to our renders, the portrait of this wily and merciless savage, we are, of course, sensible of the fact that no pleasing interest attaches to tho subject; but then, as a warrior and strategist beyond the boundaries of civilization, this'cruel and calculating Special to tbs (Htiun. Sioux is entitled to a place in history, notwithstanding that his career has been so marked liitherto with deeds of treach¬ ery and blood, that it were better for¬ gotten. "Tlie survival of tho fittest" appears to be a natural and inexorable law; and such being tho case, it will be perceived readily that the progress of civilization, and the dominion of superior races, cannot fail to be npheld at any cost; consequently, while we would shrink unfeignedly from any net savoring of inj;tsticu or oppression, we must expect th.it the savage obstacles, which, from time to time, so mar the happiness of 0111 .ituens in remote quarters, and so obstruct the peaceful settlement and cultivation of the public domain, shall be Bwept out of cxistenco as summarily as may be, wherever those who are the cause of such difliculties refuse to fall into line with tho requirements of hu¬ manity and tho age.

See moreSee less

Sitting Bull, tho son of the chief, Jumping Bull, and the nephew of Four Horns and Hunting His Lodge, two chiefs also, was liorn in the year 1K57, near old Fort George, 011 Willow Creek, below the month of the Cheyenne river. According to his own statement, his fa¬ ther was "a very rich man, and the own¬ er of a great many ponies iu four colors.'' When he himself was bnt ten years old he was famous us a hunter, his ipecinlty being 'buffalo calves." These lie gave to tne poor who had no horses, and was, consequently, considered '"a good man." Ou the death of his father, thirty-one years ago, he "lined buffalo, and fed his hours. people," and vi,en he had readied his fouiteenth jcar, on slaying an enemy, lie began to make himself "great in battle, and became a chief:" for, if we aro to credit his own v.ords, although an Indian may be. a chief by inheritance, he has to make lumself one "by his deeds." From the age of ten to four¬ teen, his people called hint Sacred Stand; but after he liad slain this foe, thev changed his name to Tatank-yan-tanka, This sullen thief has two wives, and has had another who has "gone to tlie urcai apiru. ne ims nine children; and what, .'01 tunatoly for the country, is most rure arming his r..'.-e, two pairs of twins. He has t.i-uys U en a faithless and troublesome .ii.jtomfr;aad after his participation in themassacre of the un. brave Custer and those who fell vith hiui, he escaped with his warno.-s to Canada, whore until recently, he remain ed beyond tho reach of the United btates tjovernmont In an interview with him, nnd with 0110 or two other ciiicrs, reported iu the Chicago Times, wo find, for the first time, the true de¬ tails of the wlaiiesalu slaughter of Gen¬ eral Custer tind his men; and althou these dcdails have been presented in a light the most f.-.vorable to the savages, it can readily be seea tliat the onslaught shell. was most inhuman and the deliberate act of overwhelming numbers. Now, however, that this formidable and rebel¬ lious red skin has been stnn ed out of Canada into the clutches of onr Govern ment wo havo no doubt thst ho trill be rendered powerless for mischief during the remainder of his natural life, how 1 . 1 .... snort or long soever that term may be. Sitting Bull avers now that he want no more blood spilt, and that through the agency vi a lronch Canadian, Mr. .Lewis Ijegare, and tho promptings of nis own desire lie recrossed the borders with his braves and surrendered him¬ self and them to Major Brotherton at Fort Bufonl, in the hope of making his pence with the authorities he had so long set at defiance. He appears, howeer, be a somewhat sullen and illt:r.'isfi.-.l Prodigal Son, inasmuch as he hiplains bitterly of the treatment he I;mi icceived at tho hands or the in power, nnd absolutely ventu es to dic¬ tate the terms on which ho s all Ikj re ceivet; by our government liis recross. ing tie borders, however, i.ppears to nave neon more a matter of necessity than t f choice, for prior to tint move he sec ms to haie been deserted not only bv many or ins followers, but for the time being by his favorite daughter. It is notto lie supposed therefore, that be youd the mere necessities of justice mere win no much regard jiaid to his demands or lximbast, for he has caused the How or too much innocent blood to entitle him to any very special consider¬ ation in this relation.' But now that we have so far spoken only from a standpoint of American civ¬ ilization, wo must on a principle of common justice, make some allowance for that from which the Indian views the whole question. Ho is an unculti¬ vated savage, brought up in the murkv light of untenable traditions and taught rchtl to the Cmw. to oenevetiie vtlnte man a natural enemv. He has never entertained the idea that there are no rights superior to thoe of civilization, and tliat barbarism is only an intruder wherever the light of prog¬ ress diffuses its glorious lieams. Igno¬ rance, superstition and cruelty can lmve no inalienable rights beyond tln-se per¬ taining to life and liliertv. Hencp. the liarbarous nomads that persistently keep beyond the pale of rivinlaliou in this country have 110 true right in the soil, it having to the last acre fallen a conquest to the invincible armies of nroirreiai Yet have no donbt that our government inav, in its'generosiry, take the low moral and intellectual status of the red man into consideration, and look upon even the crimes and treacheries of Sitting Bull with some degree of loniencv. It will be perceived from our engrav¬ ing, or rather from the grotcsone sketch inconsirated with it. thst althongh this refractory Sioux may lie a great warrior he is but a very poor artist. This sketch is a fac simile of 0110 made by his own hand, and i., as may bo divined, a repre¬ sentation or memorial of some act of his prowess. Evidently he here repre¬ sents himself in the light of a con¬ queror, who contemplates with fierce pride and sat age complacency the silent windrows of his fallen enemies. But all such representations must lie taken cum grano. for like his eastern progenitor, the Indian is full of hvpocrisv and exag¬ geration. TmitTY thousands tons of coiinnr are used in the United States ner annum. !.! . , , 7 oiie-uMii 01 wuicii is produced bv two mines in the Lake Superior region Urn Calumet and Hecln. It costs about $250 Ier ton of pure metal laid down at the Atlantic seaboard. Other ores from tho same district aro of lotter grade and cost more to reduce, and are so much poorer in qunlity that the opening of such im¬ mense copper deposits as thero are in Arizona and New Mexico will, upon the first principles of supply and demand, reduce the value of this metal to such a figurp that the Iow-grado copper ores cannot lie worked at a profit and the mines will be abandoned. There is an apparently inexhaustiblo amount of cop¬ per ore in .ew Jtexico which will nvere one-third of the rmre metal, while the Superior ores average abont onetwentieth. The difference in cost bfl mining and transportation is consider¬ able in this comparison and tho metal enn lu ilfrlireriixl n ".-t V.irtf Tmm ' six to seven cents a pound or $140 per Ia,t frtm" oSSetid wwrw i A A -V- , rm a i ou ai, uuosi. .ew .Mexico ami Anzonn moms, bepiemtx-r will supply the world with copper. No L. Hkell. A. D. C. mineralogist doubts that at all. ITie vnlne of the metal will not be decreased very much; although sufficiently, per¬ haps, to close tiD some of the poor mines wiueti are now paying meagre dividends j to the stockholders. Mining World. SirriNtt BULL Tto Kroleoa of The Red Skini. In presenting, to-day, to our renders, the portrait of this wily and merciless savage, we are, of course, sensible of the fact that no pleasing interest attaches to tho subject; but then, as a warrior and strategist beyond the boundaries of civilization, this'cruel and calculating Special to tbs (Htiun. Sioux is entitled to a place in history, notwithstanding that his career has been so marked liitherto with deeds of treach¬ ery and blood, that it were better for¬ gotten. "Tlie survival of tho fittest" appears to be a natural and inexorable law; and such being tho case, it will be perceived readily that the progress of civilization, and the dominion of superior races, cannot fail to be npheld at any cost; consequently, while we would shrink unfeignedly from any net savoring of inj;tsticu or oppression, we must expect th.it the savage obstacles, which, from time to time, so mar the happiness of 0111 .ituens in remote quarters, and so obstruct the peaceful settlement and cultivation of the public domain, shall be Bwept out of cxistenco as summarily as may be, wherever those who are the cause of such difliculties refuse to fall into line with tho requirements of hu¬ manity and tho age. Sitting Bull, tho son of the chief, Jumping Bull, and the nephew of Four Horns and Hunting His Lodge, two chiefs also, was liorn in the year 1K57, near old Fort George, 011 Willow Creek, below the month of the Cheyenne river. According to his own statement, his fa¬ ther was "a very rich man, and the own¬ er of a great many ponies iu four colors.'' When he himself was bnt ten years old he was famous us a hunter, his ipecinlty being 'buffalo calves." These lie gave to tne poor who had no horses, and was, consequently, considered '"a good man." Ou the death of his father, thirty-one years ago, he "lined buffalo, and fed his hours. people," and vi,en he had readied his fouiteenth jcar, on slaying an enemy, lie began to make himself "great in battle, and became a chief:" for, if we aro to credit his own v.ords, although an Indian may be. a chief by inheritance, he has to make lumself one "by his deeds." From the age of ten to four¬ teen, his people called hint Sacred Stand; but after he liad slain this foe, thev changed his name to Tatank-yan-tanka, This sullen thief has two wives, and has had another who has "gone to tlie urcai apiru. ne ims nine children; and what, .'01 tunatoly for the country, is most rure arming his r..'.-e, two pairs of twins. He has t.i-uys U en a faithless and troublesome .ii.jtomfr;aad after his participation in themassacre of the un. brave Custer and those who fell vith hiui, he escaped with his warno.-s to Canada, whore until recently, he remain ed beyond tho reach of the United btates tjovernmont In an interview with him, nnd with 0110 or two other ciiicrs, reported iu the Chicago Times, wo find, for the first time, the true de¬ tails of the wlaiiesalu slaughter of Gen¬ eral Custer tind his men; and althou these dcdails have been presented in a light the most f.-.vorable to the savages, it can readily be seea tliat the onslaught shell. was most inhuman and the deliberate act of overwhelming numbers. Now, however, that this formidable and rebel¬ lious red skin has been stnn ed out of Canada into the clutches of onr Govern ment wo havo no doubt thst ho trill be rendered powerless for mischief during the remainder of his natural life, how 1 . 1 .... snort or long soever that term may be. Sitting Bull avers now that he want no more blood spilt, and that through the agency vi a lronch Canadian, Mr. .Lewis Ijegare, and tho promptings of nis own desire lie recrossed the borders with his braves and surrendered him¬ self and them to Major Brotherton at Fort Bufonl, in the hope of making his pence with the authorities he had so long set at defiance. He appears, howeer, be a somewhat sullen and illt:r.'isfi.-.l Prodigal Son, inasmuch as he hiplains bitterly of the treatment he I;mi icceived at tho hands or the in power, nnd absolutely ventu es to dic¬ tate the terms on which ho s all Ikj re ceivet; by our government liis recross. ing tie borders, however, i.ppears to nave neon more a matter of necessity than t f choice, for prior to tint move he sec ms to haie been deserted not only bv many or ins followers, but for the time being by his favorite daughter. It is notto lie supposed therefore, that be youd the mere necessities of justice mere win no much regard jiaid to his demands or lximbast, for he has caused the How or too much innocent blood to entitle him to any very special consider¬ ation in this relation.' But now that we have so far spoken only from a standpoint of American civ¬ ilization, wo must on a principle of common justice, make some allowance for that from which the Indian views the whole question. Ho is an unculti¬ vated savage, brought up in the murkv light of untenable traditions and taught rchtl to the Cmw. to oenevetiie vtlnte man a natural enemv. He has never entertained the idea that there are no rights superior to thoe of civilization, and tliat barbarism is only an intruder wherever the light of prog¬ ress diffuses its glorious lieams. Igno¬ rance, superstition and cruelty can lmve no inalienable rights beyond tln-se per¬ taining to life and liliertv. Hencp. the liarbarous nomads that persistently keep beyond the pale of rivinlaliou in this country have 110 true right in the soil, it having to the last acre fallen a conquest to the invincible armies of nroirreiai Yet have no donbt that our government inav, in its'generosiry, take the low moral and intellectual status of the red man into consideration, and look upon even the crimes and treacheries of Sitting Bull with some degree of loniencv. It will be perceived from our engrav¬ ing, or rather from the grotcsone sketch inconsirated with it. thst althongh this refractory Sioux may lie a great warrior he is but a very poor artist. This sketch is a fac simile of 0110 made by his own hand, and i., as may bo divined, a repre¬ sentation or memorial of some act of his prowess. Evidently he here repre¬ sents himself in the light of a con¬ queror, who contemplates with fierce pride and sat age complacency the silent windrows of his fallen enemies. But all

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Citizen · Tucson, Ariz

The report profiles Sitting Bull, his rise to chieftainship, family, and role in the 'massacre' of Custer, before detailing his flight to Canada and recent surrender to Major Brotherton at Fort Buford. It references a Chicago Times interview said to reveal new details of the Little Bighorn fight from the Lakota perspective, while editorializing that he deserves little sympathy.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Arizona Weekly Citizen · 4 September 1881 · page 2

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening Critic · Washington, D.C.

The report describes a fresh Indian uprising in Arizona, with rumors that Gen. Eugene Carr's command has been wiped out, and warns that the U.S. Army is too thin on the frontier. It invokes the earlier massacre of Custer's command by Sitting Bull as proof that scattered troops invite disaster.

The Evening Critic · 5 September 1881 · page 1

our cities aro filled with people that tho Congress of tho United States with a nig gardly parsimony limits our army to a mcro handfuh Tho Indian of tho plains with his natural sharpness very quickly discovers this They know that our llttlo army is spread out all over tho frontier from post to post nnd in such lufitiitessl mally small quantities that it has been likened to tho spreading of an ottuco of butter over a loaf of broad Tho Modocs know how our troops wcro scattered when they assassinated Gen Canby Sitting Bull and his gaug of murderers know it when thoy massacred Gen Custer and his com mand Aud now conicj tbo report that

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This editorial about the Apache outbreak criticizes US Indian policy and Congressional underfunding of the army, citing the Custer massacre as a consequence of military inadequacy. It warns of continuing bloodshed from Apache and other tribal resistance unless government reform occurs.

New-York Tribune · 5 September 1881 · page 4

THE APACHE OUTBREAK.

It will be said, with much truth, that Congress is responsible for the inadequacy of the army to keep the Indians in subjection over our vast Western territory. A blind prejudice against United States troops, a contemptible fear of the influence of the army, a stupid stinginess at the very point where, more than anywhere else, stinginess causes enormous waste, and the disgraceful demagogism of persons who have tried to gain place for themselves by erying out against “a standing army” have cost the country many valuable lives and much shame. These things caused the massacre of General Custer and his men, and

See the clipping

Lancaster Daily Intelligencer · Lancaster, Pa.

This passage is a career biography of a U.S. Army officer, detailing his Civil War brevets and later frontier service, including campaigns against the Cheyennes and Sioux following the 'Custer massacre.' It briefly references Little Bighorn only as an established past event in the context of his career timeline.

Lancaster Daily Intelligencer · 5 September 1881 · page 1

Black River Ridge, Miss.. May 17, 180e. In March, 1803, he was made a brevet major trcncral of volunteers, having com manded the left wing of the Sixteenth army corps during 1SG:J-1, and having taken part in the principal actions in Ar kansas and against Mobile. On March 13, of the same year, he was brevettcd a brig adier general in the regular army for his services at Iho capture of Little Reck and a major general in the regular army for gallant and meritorious services in the field during the war.

See moreSee less

In 1SG7 and 'G8 he was en .special duty in Washington, after which he was he was oiice mere transferred te the frontier as major in the Fifth Cav alry, lie took part in the campaigns against the Cheyeniics and Sioux, and was in the Big Hern and Yellowstone expedi tions after the Custer massacre. He acted as lieutenant colonel 6f the Fifth Cavalry in the railway riots at Omaha during 1877 and was commissioned colonel and trans form! te the command of the Sixth Caval ry, April 20, 1879.

See the clipping

Alpena Weekly Argus · Alpena, Mich.

A reporter interviews a young white-haired man named John Lacfarr who claims to have been one of seven packers riding with Custer's column at Little Bighorn in 1876. He describes escaping Sioux warriors on a stolen horse while wounded, watching his companions killed, and fleeing on foot to safety, his hair turning white from the trauma.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Alpena Weekly Argus · 7 September 1881 · page 1

A Narrow Escape. Among the excited crowd that visit ed the otlice of the Helena (Mont.) Independent for news concerning the Ute outbreak, there stood a tall, hand some youth of twenty-three years, the strange uhitenes of whose hair be came at once a matter of comment This young man was John Lacfarr, who had not long ago hired himself as a ranchman with Charles I). Hart, three miles out of Helena. Laefarr was importuned by an Independent re porter to tell "the story of his topknot." He at the age of nineteen year, wa one of the seven packers who left Fort Lincoln in 17", to ride with Ccneral Custer along the Little Big Horn.

See the clipping

Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

This report gives military career summaries for several officers, including General Carr, Captain Benteen, and Lieutenants Carter, Stanton, and Gordon. It notes their service records, including participation in the Big Horn and Yellowstone expeditions that followed the Custer massacre.

Memphis Daily Appeal · 7 September 1881 · page 2

GENERAL CARR

piieu lor ana ouiaineu m sick leave anu was on duty lor six weeks, having previously. however, been breveted Colonel for his con duct it the Black River Bridge, Mississippi. Durinir the last months of 1863 and the early months of 1864 he commanded tbe left wing of the Sixteenth Army Corps, and participated in the principal action in Arkansas, and in the operations against Mobile. Fiom April 6. 1S66, to March 31, 1867, he waa in command of Raleigh, Kurth Carolina. He was mustered out of the volunteer service January 15, 1866, hav ing been breveted Major-General, March 13, 1805.

See moreSee less

He was charged with the protection of public buildings in the Department of Washington during 1867 and lSbS, and was th n assigned to active command in the West as Maior in the t iitn Cavalry, taking part in engagements sgainst the Cheyenne and Sioux, and against tbe hostile in Colorado, fie narticiuated in the Bin Horn and Yellowstone, expeditions after the Custer massacre. Dur ing the railway riots in 1877, as Lieutenant

See the clipping

The Columbia Banner · Magnolia, Ark.

A newspaper editorial decries Apache attacks led by Nana in New Mexico and Arizona, comparing them to past Indian military successes. It references Custer's death at the Little Big Horn in 1876 as having been inflicted by Sitting Bull, alongside Captain Jack's Modoc War victory, as examples of U.S. troops being poorly handled against Indian fighters.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Columbia Banner · 8 September 1881 · page 1

POOR LO! ureenvile Advocate.] If there is nothing bad about such an expression, we would like to say the Indians are playing old Harry in the most approved style in New Mexico and Arizona. Daily the tel egraph brings us new chapters to the old story, sickening, horrible, heathenish in their make-up) of men, women and children being mur dered by the score in those territo ries. Nana, the leader of the Apaches, is the new chief who is trying to fill Sitting Bull's niche in the stupendous structure of Indian crime.

See moreSee less

Fiendishly brutal is a mild way of expressing the Apache char acter at best, and Nana seems de termined to koep up their reputa tion. United States troops have always appeared to be badly handled in In dian warfare, and the deadly man ner in which they were used up by Sitting Bull on the Little Big Horn, when the brave Custer gave up his life in 1876, and by Capt. Jack, of the Modocs, in the lava beds, at an earlier date, are but striking in stances in a long series of misfor tunes, from which there has been little variation. Information comes from Denver and other far western points of the organization of volun teer bands to go and try their met tle with Nana and his allies, the beastly Navajos. This looks like business, for when those resolute pi oneers start out on a hunt, they are very apt to find and bring in game. These class of men are those who won the great States of the West and plantea the banner of trade on the confines of civilization. To these daring pioneers America owes some of the brightest stars in her Of course this whole coun crown. try belonged to the “noble red man’’ by right of occupation, and this land now occupied by teeming mil lions was "stolen,’’ if the ’ philan thropists please, but it was not made to be inhabited by savages, and now this whole land, from the Atlantic to the Pacific, is ours by right of occupation, by virtue of civilization. There is a sickly sentiment in this country that drops many a puerile tear over poor Lo, and it doesn’t speak much for those affected by it. They have stood and wept while brave men carved out a great na tion from a wilderness, and they are still standing back in the shadows while the work is being completed It was a proper transaction when William Penn bought of the Indians a kingdom, the purchasing power boing a few gewgaws, but if history serves us right the people that set* tied on Penn’s purchased land to [ the best of their ability made the Indians feel their presence. Now, the U. S. government spends yearly millions to feed and clothe the In dians; keeps them up through the winter and turns them out fat and sleek in the spring time to go on their annual expeditions of murder and robbery. The nation’s pets, they may well be termed, and we show little tact in managing our pets. Truth is; we don’t manage them at all, but they manage to do a vast deal of devilment in the way of diminishing our population and

See the clipping

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.

The piece reports a new Indian clash in Arizona initially likened to the Custer disaster, noting corrected casualty figures from the earlier exaggerated report. It pivots to a reflection on Sitting Bull, arguing he is unfairly vilified for acts that would be celebrated as heroic in 'civilized' warfare.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Manitowoc Pilot · 8 September 1881 · page 2

Another Indian massacre is reported from tho Arizona Territory. The first reports made it parallel to the Custer affair but more trustworthy information proves that the matter was greatly ex

See the clipping

The County Paper · Oregon, Mo.

The report describes a supposed massacre of Captain Hentig and his entire company of 100 men and seven officers by White Mountain Apache near Fort Apache, Arizona, drawing a comparison to the earlier Custer massacre. It warns that if the fort and its women and children were also destroyed, fierce retaliation would follow.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The County Paper · 9 September 1881 · page 8

Another Massacre. Since tlio massaero of tlio gallant Custer and his command, there lias been no occurence In tlio Indian coun try that lias had such a tendency to r-tlr

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The report discusses 2,800 Indians who had been with Sitting Bull at the time of the Custer massacre but surrendered before him, warning that government actions may cause them to flee the agency. It criticizes the government's handling of the situation, suggesting reinforcing forts instead would have been wiser.

Bismarck Tribune · 9 September 1881 · page 4

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Ottawa Free Trader · Ottawa, Ill.

After sensational dispatches claimed a massacre of Gen. Carr's command rivaling Custer's defeat, later reports clarify the actual events at Cibicue Creek. Carr's force arrested a resistant medicine man, Lt. Hentig was killed when scouts turned hostile, and the ensuing battle cost seven soldiers and the officer, with wounded evacuated that night.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Ottawa Free Trader · 10 September 1881 · page 4

INDIAN TB0UBLE8 IN ABIZ0NA. The dispatches in lost Saturday's dailies In reference to Indian disturbances in Arizona wero decidedly sensational. They depicted a bloody massacre of Gen. Carr and his com mand almost equal in its sangiunary results to tko famous Custer massacre several years

See the clipping

The Opelousas Courier · Opelousas, La.

An opinion piece reflects on repeated army failures against Indigenous fighters, listing Braddock's 1755 defeat, Custer's destruction by Sitting Bull's Sioux, and the recent killing of Gen. Carr by Apaches as examples. It argues army officers never learned to avoid ambush.

The Opelousas Courier · 10 September 1881 · page 1

From the time of the massacre of braddock's army by Indians in 1755. down to the destruction of Custer and his troops by Sitting Bull's Sioux in re cent times and the slaughter of Gen. Carr and his men the other day by the Apaches, it seems that the regular army officers could never learn enough to keep out of an Indian ambuscade. It is the same story repeated of surprise, want of preparation and extermina tion.-N. O Times.

See the clipping

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

A newspaper miscellany column reports a massacre of Army officers and soldiers by Apache Indians in Arizona, comparing it to the earlier Custer massacre at Little Bighorn. The editorial criticizes government Indian policy, suggesting either surrender or stronger military protection to prevent repeated tragedies.

Martinsburg Independent · 10 September 1881 · page 4

Custer massacre. The Government ought to surrender to the Indians, or else keep enough soldiers on the frontier to protect each other in such cases of emergency. We don’t think the mistake ought to he re peated more than a half-dozen times, as eacli time a number of brave and valuable lives are lost by it. Mahone is wielding the political axe with fatal effect in Virginia. The heads of several prominent Re publican office-holders in that State, who were active in the Lynchburg straightout convention, have already fallen into the basket.

See moreSee less

The most prominent among the number decap itated is Arnold, the colored orator from Norfolk, who was so eloquently bitter on Mahone at Lynchburg. lie has received his ticket-of-leave, and the end is not yet. Mahone shows plenty of venom aud pluck, but we doubt the wisdom of it.

See the clipping

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

The report describes the killing of General Carr and two companies of soldiers by Apaches in Arizona, drawing a direct comparison to the earlier Custer massacre at Little Bighorn. It notes the accounts are confused and uncertain, much like the Custer affair, since no white witnesses survived either incident.

Martinsburg Independent · 10 September 1881 · page 4

NOTES AND COMMENT

Apaches, in Arizona, is a terrible event, hardly less tragic than the slaughter of Custer’s command. The accounts thus far received are somewhat confused, even the ollleial report of General McDowell being based “on rumors more or less au thentic.” It appears, however, to have been a surprise to the troops, and it is not improbable that the friendly Indians employed as scouts and guides participated in the mas sacre. The affair will, in all proba bility remain forever wrapped in the same uncertainty which attends the massacre of Custer’s command, and for the same ghastly reason—because all of the white witnesses were kill ed.

See moreSee less

It is reported that 7 officers and 110 men were killed. If the first ac counts received are correct, Lieu tenant Cruise was ordered to “ar rest” a medicine man in the midst of his believers, and finding that be | resisted, shot him dead. This seems quite as audacious a thing as Cus ter’s charge into the Indian village. The term massacre may, however, be misapplied. It is more than probable that the soldiers, who fired first, died lighting bravely to the last.

See the clipping

The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa. · and 1 other paper

The passage describes Sitting Bull's arrival by steamboat with his band, including an emotional greeting from Running Antelope and a reception with curious onlookers aboard the boat. It notes his reduced status, from once leading thousands of warriors to now having only 200 followers, and describes the Indians being marched ashore and counted.

The Forest Republican · 14 September 1881 · page 4

Sitting Bull stood immovable and unde monstrative in the row of chiefs, second from tho end furthest from the landing side. lie was the least adornod of his companions, and tho last who would be selected as tho notorious chief by those unacquainted with him. After the boat had touched the shore it was some time before the gang-planks were run out, and tho interpreter having gained per mission for him, the chief, liunnincr Antelope, stepped aboard. Ho passed hurriedly to the upper deck, and in ascending the stairs near the side of the boat found Sitting Bull standing, still immovably, in the row of chiefs and di rectly m front of the hatchway.

See moreSee less

Run ning Antelope stepped up to Sitting Bull's back, threw his arm around his neck and placed his cheek against his face and exclaimed, in the Sioux lan guage, " My love I" Sitting Bull made no movement of recognition until Antelope had passed through the line, stepping in front of the chiefs, shaking hands with them and saying " How " to each. As he reached Sitting Bull, next to the last in the line, ho found the great chief crying and wiping away the tears with a costly silk handkerchief that had been presented to him. No other Indian was allowed on the boat, and after this hasty salutation tho chiefs broke ranks and passed down on the main deck. Sitting Bull, his father, Four Horns, and Running Antelope were then in vited into the cabin, and the officers, ladies and citizens were invited aboard the boat and were introduced to the famous warrior. Such exclamations as " Why, he does not look at all as I Ex pected," " He doesn't look as savago ns 1 thought, ana " (Jan that be the insti gator of the Custer massacre?" etc., were heard on every side. The great chief was very gracious to the ladies, ns, indeed, he was on the entire trip, and showed them much attention, and furnished them with his autograph free of charge, while ho either refused en tirely or demanded from 1 to $5 from the gentlemen. After the reception in the cabin, which lasted for half an hour, all the Indians, including the chiefs and Sitting Bull, were marched aehore in single file and counted. They were ISO in number, including five children, and they were assigned a camping-ground near the river. After marching ashore they seated themselves in a circle on the ground, with the squaws on the outside and the chiefs in the center, while waiting for their uter.sils to be re moved from the boat. There sat in humiliation the great chief, smoking his pipe. Only a few years aao Sitting Bull had a following of 10,000 people, including nearly 5,000 good fighting warriors. Ho rambled at his leisure and adorned his belt with many a scalp. He planned the Custer massacre and defied the government. At this moment he is looked upon with jealousy by nearly all the other chiefs. His spirit is broken, and he Bits on a sandy river bank surrounded by civilization with his last 200 followers, calmly awaiting his fate.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Sentinel · Trenton, N.J. · 27 August 1881

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

Years after the battle, Cincinnati lawyer George Sage obtained an interview with Ogallala chief Low Dog describing the Sioux camp's surprise and the start of the fight at Little Bighorn. Low Dog recounts being asleep when warned of approaching soldiers and initially disbelieving the alarm.

Narragansett Herald · 15 September 1881 · page 4

THE CUSTER MASSACRE, A Vivid Account Given by a Participating Chief."” Mr. George R. Sage of the Cincinnati bar, while spending his summer vaca tion at a point on the Missouri river, two thousand miles above its mouth, made the acquaintance of the Indians who were enmin-tho Custer fight, and having ilities for talking with them obtained for the Cincinnati Com mercial the Sioux story of the defeat and death of the “Long Haired Chief.” From his letter we take the following: ““There has been a great desire to hear the Indian account of the Caster

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

An unnamed Indian leader recounts the surprise attack at Little Bighorn, describing how a scout's warning was initially disbelieved, the chaotic defense of women and children, and the eventual counterattack. He praises the bravery of Custer's soldiers while describing the Indians' tactics of regrouping and charging together.

Narragansett Herald · 15 September 1881 · page 4

THE CUSTER MASSACRE

' where Sitting Bull and the Uncapapas were. The Indians held their ground i to give the women and children time to 'get out of the way. By this time the

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

This report recounts Sitting Bull's history before Little Bighorn, describing how General Morrow's peace overture and gift-giving placated him, and how his refusal to live on a reservation drew increasing numbers of warriors to his camp. It details the 1875-76 siege of Fort Pease on the Yellowstone, where his forces besieged a small group of Montana settlers for months until messengers escaped to summon military relief from Fort Ellis.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 21 September 1881 · page 4

SITTING BULL.

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Millheim Journal · Millheim, Pa.

This is an advertisement for a book claiming to be the clearest and latest history of Custer's campaigns in the Northwest, his final battle, and the surrender of Sitting Bull. It promises coverage of the Custer-Belknap controversy and reasons for Custer's defeat, and seeks agents to sell the book.

Millheim Journal · 29 September 1881 · page 4

mailed tree to all Bufferers on application to P. Neustaodu r it Co.. Box 3946. New York. Campaigns of General Custer til the Northwoet. and the Final Mar render of Kitting Hull. Now realty. Clearest and latest history of Custer's last battle; final surrender of "Sitting Bull;" savage life faithfully portrayed, and special comment upon the military and interior departments, the Custer Belknap trouble thoroughly ventilated, and the reasons shown why Custer was defeated. Every man, woman and child should read thia work. Bva paper, price 75 cents. Energetic Agents and Canvassers wan ten In every town.

See the clipping