As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

October 1879

17 articles

The Daily Gazette · Wilmington, Del.

A scout who rode 90 miles in 24 hours brings word that Thornburgh's body lies beyond Indian lines, with eleven soldiers reported killed and over thirty wounded, including several officers. Officers debate whether Merritt's relief column can reach the trapped command in time, while fears grow of a wider alliance among Utes, Arapahoes, and Snakes.

The Daily Gazette · 2 October 1879 · page 4

Lieutenant Wolf, slightly wounded. CONDITION OK TIIK COM 11 A TA NTS. The Indians are well armed with Win chester rifles, and are plentifully supplied with aininiinlion. The expedition has provisions sufficient to last them six days and may be able to hold out that length of time if they retain their position. The Indians had prepared an ambush ill the canyou through which they sup posed the command would pass, but Ran kin, the scout, led the troops around the canyon, and the command was thus saved from another Custer massacre. It is f ared that the Utes have formed an alliance with the Arrapahoes and Snakes and a geueial Indian w ar w ill re sult. FKARH FOU TIIK COMMAND.

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

This 1879 editorial argues that repeated massacres of soldiers by Native Americans, including Custer's command and the recent Milk River/Thornburgh disaster, result from the government's refusal to maintain adequate troop strength in Indian country. It cites Custer, General Howard's Bannock campaign, and the Thornburgh massacre as examples of this false economy costing American lives.

The New York Herald · 3 October 1879 · page 6

Hardly a briof two mouths have passod since, with impressive and mournful ceremonies, a monument to tho brave Custi-r was consecrated at West Point. Why did tho bravo Custer and nil the men of his gallant command fall victims to an Indian massacre, none escaping to toll the horrible talo? It was because tho government had not troops enough in tho Indian country. Why did General Howard, two or three years ago, make so lame and impotent a campaign * against tho Bannock Indians under Chief Josenh in Orecron? It was because tliu government had not troops enough in tlio Indian country. Year in and year out wo liavo unceasing repetitions of the sanio sickening tale of

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A roundup of Washington news notes that military officials feared the ambush of Major Thornburgh's command by Ute forces could have been a total massacre, comparing it to Custer's defeat. The item is part of a broader digest covering Treasury receipts, yellow fever cases, and other unrelated news.

Alexandria Gazette · 3 October 1879 · page 3

A dispatch reoetved at tho Pobt Office Do partment to day states that Assistant FcstmasterTjner, whom a few unsophisticated ptople wero fcimplo enough to suppose was ia some danger from tho Uto lodiaos, now in revolt, was with a largo burning party one hundred and fifty ruiles i'rcui the sceoo of hostilities, with a high raDgo of ictervoniog mountain?. Assistant Adjutant General Dunn soys that nothing further had been received at the Wur Office with regard to tho fato ol tho people at tho agency or cf tho troops who havo lately been defeated.

See moreSee less

The wonder at the War Office, in consideration of tho nature (i the canyon in whioh Major Thornburgh's command was am busoaded, is that llio wholo of it was not cot ell, and a second Custer massacre made ol the alliir. Major Thoroburgh was lormerly io th^

See the clipping

Bristol News · Bristol, Va. & Tenn.

This 1879 article reports the death of Major Thornburgh in a Colorado Indian engagement, drawing a parallel to the earlier killing of Custer at Little Bighorn as another military blunder against Native Americans. It uses the Custer Massacre as an established historical reference point to frame the new disaster and criticize government Indian policy.

Bristol News · 7 October 1879 · page 2

Hoge Tyler. Hon. It. M. T. Hunter, Treasurer of Va., is out in a letter approving the Me Culloch bill settlement of the Public debt, and urging Its acceptance. Senator C. T. Smith, of Nelson ha been by aeelatuat Ion, nominated for re election. Ho and Daniel audCoghill ne-iii to have their Districts in a sling, Major Tiiohnbvho whose death we publish to-ctey was a brother of Hon. J. M. Thornburg of Knoxville, and is a native of New Market, Tenn The dieasrer seems to have been little less of a blunder of some sort than the Custer Massacre, Capt. Payne

See the clipping

Juniata Sentinel and Republican · Mifflintown, Pa.

A mail contractor describes his Indian employees, including six drivers who claim to have witnessed the Custer massacre while herding ponies nearby. He notes they refuse to say who killed the soldiers, fearing retaliation from Custer's friends.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 19 days earlier.

Juniata Sentinel and Republican · 8 October 1879 · page 1

UK. Sit to climb to the top of the highest moun tain in the country. They would have been destroyed also had they not pray ed to the Great Spirit so rervcutly that their supplications were answered. They lived to a great age and replenish ed the earth. When they died they be came a brilliant star in the heaven. These Indians know the principal stars by the names of departed chiefs. This heller is prevalent among nearly all the savage Indians In the southern part of the Indian Teriitory." "Are any of your Indians desperate characters?"

See moreSee less

"Some of them. Six of my drivers saw the Custer massacre. They proba bly took part in it, but they claim that they were near by herding ponies. They describe the whole bloody affair, but will not tell who killed the whites. Custer had many friends, and they are afraid of them. "Have any of your Indians ever seen the cars?" "YVs, seven chiefs went up to Vinta one day, and I got them to look at a lo comotive. It suddenly whistled and blew off steam, and you ought to have seen those seven Indians wilt. They fell down on their knees in consterna tion and began to pray to the IJreat Spirit. I truess they thought the en gine was the Great Spirit, but I don't know as to that." "Mack Trurkers" la A antral!.. The settlers of Victoria arc so much vexed by bush rangers, who invariably disappear when they are "wanted." that they have sent to Queensland for black trackers. That it should be nec essary to go to Queensland to find blacks in fossessoin tf these acuities says not very much, perhaps, for our success in keeping the aboriginal alive. I:i England people may be inclined 10 rank the belief lu the savage power of tracking w ilh the belief in the hazel waml of the tre-isure seeker, or the ex plorer for wells. The cleverness of the wild hunter is supposed to exist only in Cooper's novels. In Australia it is very will known by experience that the blacks will recognize the tracks of .1 man they have not seen for years and w ill hunt it over tracks of bush where the white uau is lost. The great story of the sleuth-hound qualities of the , I Morn is unfortunately mixed tip with a gho.t. la the eyes of science and perhaps common sense, it is therefore a record of hallucination. The tale, however, has often been repeated and perhaps never contradicted, that a

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper interviews a young ranchman, John Laefarr, who claims he was one of seven packers riding with Custer at the Little Big Horn and the only one to escape the Sioux attack, his hair turning white from the ordeal. He says he was wounded, hid for three days, and was rescued by Crow Indians who took him to Fort Lincoln.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 10 October 1879 · page 3

WHY LARFARR's HAIR TURNED WHirE. Among the excited crowd that besieged the oMee of the Helena, Montana, INdependent for news concerning the Ute outbreak there stood a tall, handsome youth of 23 years, the strange whiteness of whose hair became at once a mat ter of comment This young man was John Laefarr, who not long ago hired himself as a ranChman with Charles D. Hard, three m!le3 out of Helena. Laefarr was importuned by an Independent reporter to tell "the story of his gray topknot." le, at the age of nineeen years, was one of seven packers who left Fort Lincoln In 1S75 to ride with General Custer along the Little Big Horn. When the fight of that bright but disastrous summer mora

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A young man named John Laefarr claims his hair turned white from terror after surviving an attack near Custer's command, escaping six companions who were killed and hiding for three days before being rescued. The anecdote is presented as a curiosity rather than verified fact.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 October 1879 · page 2

A handsome youth of 2d years, named John I.aefarr, whose perfectly white hair recently attracted attention at Helena. Montana, stat ed that he owed it to Custer's fight with the Indians. He was attached to Custer's force, on the morning of the massacre happened with several companions to he three miles from the commnnd, when a band of Sioux sprang from the grass within a few feet of them. Springing upon a horse I.aefarr started in rapid flight. As he hugged his horse lie saw his six companions go down, one after the other.

See moreSee less

One bullet out of the hundred that followed him tore through his neck, another cut a deep furrow across his cheek, a third im bedded itself in his thigh and a fourth killed his horse. The desperate boy shot an ap proaching Indian anil ran for a belt of timber a half mile distant, where he hid for three days, when he was found by some friendly Crow Indians and taken to Foit Lincoln.

See the clipping

The Spirit of Democracy · Woodsfield, Ohio

General Alfred Pleasonton discusses the army's flawed tactics against Plains Indians, citing the Custer massacre and the recent Thornburgh disaster as repeated failures. He argues speed and lean supply, not larger troop numbers, are needed to defeat Indian forces.

The Spirit of Democracy · 14 October 1879 · page 2

SOLDIERS SENT TO DEATH.

Gen. Alfred -Pleasonton's Experl (ji enee In Fighting: the Red Men. Washington, 'Oct. 6. Tbe Ute In dians have been cheated. That was un doubtedly the Origin of the uprising The army, after nearly half a century of experience in fighting Indians Is unable to cope with them. The Indian olDce can start a tribe on the warpath with givat facility, Tbe regular army cannot subdue the mountain tribts without the expenditure of vat noms of money and grsat los9 of life, and then only by force of overwhelming number.0. The uia?s8cre of Custer by the In dians was only a repetition of the.

See moreSee less

Dade massacre bv the "Seminole Indians in Florida in 1836, and the destruction ol Tbornburgh and his command is only a second edition of the Custer horror.

See the clipping

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.

A newspaper interviews a young Montana ranchman who claims to have been one of seven packers riding with Custer at the Little Bighorn, six of whom were killed while he alone escaped, wounded, with his hair turned white from the ordeal. He says he hid in timber for three days before being rescued by Crow scouts and brought to Fort Lincoln.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

The Manitowoc Pilot · 16 October 1879 · page 2

A TERRIBLE EXPERIENCE. Among the excited crowd that besieged the office of The Helena, Montana, Inde pendent for news concerning the Ute out break there stood a tall, handsome youth of 23 years, the strange whiteness of whose liair became at once a matter of comment. This young man was John Lae fair, who not long ago hired himself as a ranchman with Chas. D. Hard, three miles out of Helena. Laefarr was im portuned by an Independent reporter to tell “the story of his gray topknot.” He at the age of nineteen years was one of seven packers who left Fort Lincoln in 1873 to ride with Gen.

See moreSee less

Custer along the Little Big Horn. When the fight of that bright, bat disastrous summer morning opened Laefarr, with his companions, happened to be throe miles away from the command. In a few moments after the sound of the combat reached him a band of Sioux sprang from the grass within a few feet of them. Laefarr noosed a rope, placed it in the mouth of the nearest horse and, leaping upon the animal’s back, plunged Lis spurs into the llank. As he bagged his horse he saw his six companions go down, one after the other. One bullet cut of the hund red that followed him tore through his neck, another cut a deep furrow across his cheek, a third imbedded itself in his thigh and a fourth killed his horse. The desperate l>oy shot an approaching In dian and ran for a belt ol timber a half mile distant. Barefooted, weak and faint from loss of blood, he outran his pursuers and reached the woods, where he bid for three days. He was at last found by three friendly Crow Indians and taken by them to Fort Lincoln, where he told of the massacre. It was not until he had reached the fr;: that he knew of the change in his hair, which, l*efore his terrible suffering, was as black as a raven’s wing. Laefarr has since been liviug at various points on the plains. He does not like to go over the storv of his wonderful adventure. Judge H. llaydenj of the Wood conn1 ty court, a politician well known through out the stute us a candidate for the attor ney generalship on tiie greenback ticket two years ago. was shot and killed at Centralis, Wis., last Thursday, by W. J. Cochrane, cashier of First National Bank. The affair grew out of an alleged intimacy on the part of Hayden with Cochrane’s wife, the scandal being one of longstanding. Cochrane had separat ej from his wife some time ago, although a divorce had not been obtained. The weapon used was a shot gun, loaded with due buckshot, the entire charge peuetrat ing the right side of the victim, killing him instantly. No words passed between the parties, so it is thought the killing was premeditated. Excitement at the time ran high and threats of lynching were treely indulged in; but finally bet ter counsel prevailed. Cochrane deliver ed himself up and was committed to jail, but the following day he was out attend ing to business as usual. Judge Hayden will be buried Sunday, and Cochrane will have his examination on Tuesday, A1 though the murder occurred Thursday nothing was known of the affair outside of Centralia until Saturday,

See the clipping

Le Louisianais · Convent, La.

This French-language opinion piece argues that war against the Ute tribe is justified, citing the killing of U.S. soldiers and officers as grounds for retaliation without mercy. It invokes the memory of Custer's death at Little Bighorn as a rhetorical touchstone, asking rhetorically whether Custer has been avenged, to bolster the case for subjugating 'uncivilizable' tribes.

Le Louisianais · 18 October 1879 · page 1

parfaitement légitime et naturelle. Ces sauvages ont tué. Et ce ne sont pas des mineurs, des pionniers et des aventuriers qu'ils ont tués, — ce qui serait déjà uti grand crime — mais bien des offi ciers et «tes soldats de l'armée fédé rale. Le drapeau «le la république a été insult«'«, et d'odieux sauvages ont commis un crime qui veut justice. Il ne s'agit plus de philanthropie. La circonstance réclame autre cho se. Au reste, il serait bien temps d'en finir avec une race qui gêne, qui trouble et «pli massacre. Est-ce que le général Custer a été vengé ! Est-ce. que l'entretien «l'une armée

See the clipping

Le Louisianais · Convent, La.

This French-language article discusses the Ute uprising and speculates that General Grant might lead a military campaign against them. It references the 1876 Little Bighorn massacre of Custer by Sitting Bull's Sioux as unfinished business from Grant's presidency that demands vengeance.

Le Louisianais · 18 October 1879 · page 1

canons et capturer sans peine des Indiens comme Ouray, Sitting Bull, Queue Mouchetée et cent autres, lit il n'épargnerait assurément point les Peaux-Rouges. Il a lin vieux compte A régler avec eux. C'est sous son administration présiden tielle, il y a trois ans, que Sitting Bull et ses Sioux ont si criminelle ment massacré Custer et ses compa L. S. U. Library Baton Rouge La.

See the clipping

Daily Press and Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.

The piece attacks Rev. Mr. Harsha for excusing Ute and Sioux violence, including Sitting Bull's role in the 'Custer annihilation,' as justified reactions to white mistreatment. It argues Indian policy and civilizing efforts have failed for two centuries, citing the Custer and Meeker killings as proof.

Daily Press and Dakotaian · 24 October 1879 · page 2

reverend gentleman does nothing by halves. He even defended by implication the massa cre of Custer's troops by Sitting BulL "What a sarcasm upon our Indian policy was the going of Sitting Bull to Canada for

See the clipping

The Bolivar Bulletin · Bolivar, Tenn.

A Helena newspaper recounts the story of John Laefarr, who claimed to have been one of seven packers riding with Custer who escaped the Little Bighorn battle, witnessing his companions killed and his hair turning white from the ordeal. The story describes his wounds, his flight through enemy fire, and his eventual rescue by friendly Crow scouts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Evening Star, 10 October 1879, Daily Kennebec Journal, 14 October 1879, The Manitowoc Pilot, 16 October 1879.

Wrong

The Bolivar Bulletin · 30 October 1879 · page 1

Why Laefarr's Hair Turned White. Among the excited crowd that be sieged the office of the Helena (.Mon tana) Iwh pendent for news concerning the Ute outbreak there stood a tall, hand some youth of 2.0 years, the strange whiteness of whose hair became at once a matter of comment. This young man was John Laefarr, . who .not long ago hired himself as a ranchman with Charles. I). Hard, three miles out of Helena.. Laefarr was importuned by an Independent reporter to tell 44 the story of his gray topknot." He, at the age, of VJ ye;Trs, was one of seven packers who left Fort Lincoln in 1875 to ride with Ceneral Custer, along . the Little Big

See the clipping

The Weekly Arizona Miner · Prescott, Ariz

This opinion piece references Custer's death at the hands of Sitting Bull's warriors as justification for transferring Indian management from the Interior Department to the Army. It argues that military officers understand Indians better than church-appointed agents, and criticizes the Indian Bureau's policies as causing continued frontier violence.

The Weekly Arizona Miner · 31 October 1879 · page 1

THE INDIAN SITUATION. When poor Custer was ambushed and slain by Sitting Bull's warriors, the pross ol the country advocated the transfer of the Indians from the IntcMcr Di'partment to the Department of the Army, where they pruperly belong. Thtre are hundreds of officers in tho service who could manage the Indian question much more intelligent ly thun tliuc nppointcd by the church de nominations with tho christian theories. A wild Indian has but little knowledge of re ligion and does not care to learn. They have a desiro for the hunt and cnasc anil a pcrfiinr lnVf of limi t ivinl'inn tlm ituniriiiiiiinl

See the clipping

Lewiston Teller · Lewiston, North Idaho

An 1879 opinion piece argues that ambitious young army officers provoke conflicts with Native Americans to build reputations, citing the Custer and Thornburg massacres as proof that mistreated Indians retaliate fiercely. It urges that Indians be treated decently to avoid further bloodshed.

Lewiston Teller · 31 October 1879 · page 1

West Point who are sent out west. He is tired of it, He is very tired of it. It is just possible that he may make the young men from West. Point very tired of it liefere he gets through with them. ''The Custer and the Thorn burg massacre ought to teach the young military men in the west that the Indians, when driven to desnara lion, are very apt to do a great deal of harm. It pays to treat them decent ly. Ex.

See the clipping

The Hickman Courier · Hickman, Ky.

In a wide-ranging newspaper interview, showman Buffalo Bill Cody discusses Indian policy, the Ute outbreak, and his own frontier career. He mentions that he took the first scalp to avenge the Custer massacre, killing a man he calls Red Knife on the same day.

The Hickman Courier · 31 October 1879 · page 1

Custer massacre On the same day he also killed Red Knife "What do you think of Grant as a third-term candidate, Mr Cody?' 'Next to myself, I think Grant is

See the clipping

Ashtabula Telegraph · Ashtabula, Ohio

In this 1879 interview, Buffalo Bill Cody reminisces about his theatrical career since 1872, including managing Wild Bill Hickok who proved difficult to handle on stage. He also recounts serving as Chief of Scouts in 1876 and killing Cheyenne chief Yellow Hand, taking 'the first scalp for Custer.'

Ashtabula Telegraph · 31 October 1879 · page 1

NOT EASY TO HANDLE

General Terry. On the 17th of July 1 killed Yelaow Hand, a noted Cheyenne chief, and took the hrst scalp for Custer. I returned to the stage in October, 1876, and during the season of 1876 and 1879, I cleared $38,000. I have generally been successful financially on the stage. I am now in the cat tle business in Nebraska, to which place I will return as soon as the sea son is over, providing nothing se rious occurs to call me nome earlier."

See the clipping