As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

May 1879

18 articles

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

A retrospective first-person narrative by Capt. W. Clifford describing the days just before and after the Little Bighorn battle, including scouts reporting Indian movements and anxious waiting for word of Custer. It also describes finding an abandoned Indian camp littered with equipment, suggesting a hurried retreat.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 1 May 1879 · page 5

THE INDIAN CAMPAIGN OF 1876. BY CAPT. W. CLIFFORD, U. S. A. About four hours ago Bostwick and Tay lor, (white scouts), started to find General Custer. They have just returned and re port a large body of Indianls moving across the Little Big IIorn valley from the diree

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

An officer recounts arriving at the Little Bighorn village site, finding dead cavalry horses, bloodstained uniforms, and dead warriors in lodges, then learning that Major Reno's shattered command of 250 men had survived a desperate fight. The narrator describes mounting dread as reports arrive of nearly two hundred dead cavalrymen found by Lieutenant Bradley, with no one yet able to confirm Custer's fate.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 1 May 1879 · page 5

BY CAPT. W. CLIFFORD, U.S.A.

7th cavalry" marked on the lining, a bullet hole through the right breast and deeply stained with blood. Now we begin to find cavalry saddles, and to realize that there must be truth in the report of the Crow scouts that Custer's: force had been defeated. Soon, like a clap ,f thunder, causing the bravest among uts to blench, came a report from the opposite side of the river that

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

A correspondent travelling with the relief column describes finding Major Reno and 250 survivors of four companies besieged in timber near the Little Bighorn, where Indians had set fire to the grass to drive them out. The writer notes some of Custer's command are missing and hopes they may yet be found, while scouts estimate 4,000-5,000 warriors were present in the vast village.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 1 May 1879 · page 5

came on a run with the intelligence that the men in the hills to the right were MaNor Reno and his command of 250 men, all that were left of four companies. Hie knew nothing of Custer, but stated that he himself, with three companies, had charged through the village and had met with such'a hot reception that he was oblig ed to take to the hills, from whence, but.for our timely arrival, not one of them would have escaped, as they were surrounded on all sides by splendidly armed and mounted Indians, and could only obtain water at the imminent risk of their lives.

See moreSee less

The red scouts who are still with us think that there were not less than twelve hun dred lodges here besides a great number of wicky-ups. They, (the seouts), as well as old frontieimen, think that there could not have been less than from four to five thou sand warriors, and even that they consider a low estimate. The Sioux have disappeared like a scene in a magic lantern-triumphant. Some of Custer's command are missing. Have they fallen alive into the hands of their pitiless enemies? Woe to them if they have. Better to have fallen, far better, in their tracks beside their dauntless chief. A Crow scout, Curly, is also missing, and hopes are entertained that he may have es caped. We go into camp on Reno's battle field, just at the point where the Indians had him surrounded in the timber. For years the Sioux have been in the habit of making here a winter camp, and when the ground was so covered with snow as to ren(er it difficult for their animals to graze, they made a practice of cutting down the cottonwood trees, the bark of which furnishes the horses a very nutritious food. The dry wood the next year supplied the savages with an abundance of dry fuel. The grass grows to an unusual height among this dead timber. Dry brush is abundant. In such a place as this was Reno acd his men surrounded by the Indians. They, (the Indians), set fire to the grass, and though the flames did not reach Reno, it bade fair to do so. The smoke was very dense, and at best they could not long have remained in such a trap. Their only safety

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

A cavalry officer recalls discovering the decomposed bodies of Reno's men and later surveying Custer's battlefield, describing how the skirmishers and Custer's circle of forty fell among dead horses. He also recounts the Crow scout Curly's story of escaping the final stand and carrying news of the massacre to the Crow camp.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 8 May 1879 · page 5

BY CAPT. W. CLIFFORD, U. S. A.

All of June 28th was consumed in bring ing Reno's wounded from the hill tops to the river bottom, burying the dead herie and on Custer s field, four and thrcc-fourths niles below, and in the* construction of lit ters for the transportation of the wounded to the steamer'reported to be lying at the mouth of the Little Big I~orn, distant twen ty miles. There are only twenty-one so severely wounded as to require moviing on litters; the others, twelve in number, being able to ride. Au examination of the ground where 7t.ster's five companies perished shows that th*sklirrmishers feo.on the.

See moreSee less

line, the most of them shot dead. Inside the skirmish line they fell in groups of fours, and finally Cus ter and a number of officers inside a circle of forty men, surrounded by slain horses, placed head to tatil. Curly, the Crow scout, who escaped by wrapping himself in a blanket, Indian fashion, and who afterwards joined us, says that here the fight was the bitterest; that the continuous discharge of the rifles he can liken to nothing so much as the sound of the tearing of strong cloth, and only when their ammunition was gone did the Sioux swarm upon them like a host of howling wolves. Then he jumped on a horse and made his escape, swiming the Big Horn, and going direct to the Crow camp, which was turned into a community of mourners by the terrible intelligence of which he was the bearer. The Crows, fearing that tLe victorious Sioux would follow up their success by an attack on tlem, at once hastened £o leave their camp ground on Prior's Fork and seek the protection of their agency. They be lieved that all of the 7th cavalry had been killed, and were fully convinced that our little force would share the same fate. Their demoralization was -complete when the dce serting scouts arrived in a body and corrob rated Cur ly's story. How these scouts managed to obtain such accurate informa tion as they imparted to us on the 26th, is a puzzle. All the bodies save those of Custer and

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

A cavalry officer recounts the scout Curly's escape and the Crow camp's panic upon learning of Custer's defeat. He describes the mutilated bodies on the battlefield, Custer's and Keogh's bodies spared, and a wounded Indian pony he encountered among the dead.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 21 days earlier.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 8 May 1879 · page 5

BY CAPT. W. CLIFFORD, U.S.A.

All the bodies save those of Custer and lKeogh are more or less mutilated. Hands, head,, feet and legs are cut off and scattered here and there. The squaws finished the wounded by knocking them in the head with axes furnished by the United States government. Custer was shot through the temple, evidently while lying on the ground. HIis face is as placid as it he were sleeping. Keogh was probably saved from mutilation by the discovery, when the squaws stripped him, of an agnus dei suspended from his neck. All the bodies except Custer's were stripped.

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

A survivor's reminiscence describes mercy-killing a dying horse, then details the height of the riverbank Reno's men leapt from during their retreat from the valley fight. The account also recalls the battlefield burial service and the grueling effort to move wounded men by litter after the battle.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 8 May 1879 · page 5

Thie tormenting flies were about him in swarms. Knowing. that he must die there a lingering death, I rode back and again he came up, this time laying his head, on my horse's rump, looking straight at me, as if pleading for help. Drawing my revolver, I held:it within a few inches of his forehead and pulled the trigger. Lightning could not have finished him sooner. Better thus than the day. of lingering agony that must follow if left to himself. On my return, 1 marked more carefully th'e embankment from which Reno's horse men jumpedlinto the river as they retreated The vertical bank was not less than ten feet high.

See moreSee less

From there they jumped into water about four or five feet deep, then crossing the stream, climbed the hills which were too steep for a direct asebnt. 'iTh marvel is that with such a multitude of lidians around them so minY escaped. Thipfetreat was a mad race to-a place of safety,. While wind ing up the steep hill-side the fugitives were exposed to a murderous fire.. Had the'pur suors been white men, hardly one of the 1eeing party could have reached the sum mit unlhurt. The Custer battle'ffeld has been described too often to need further mention here. The sorrowful burial was over at last 'The muffled drum's sad roll has beat The soldier's last tattoo. No more on life's parade shall meet That brave and fallen few. O -famhes eteunal camping grouad.4 them shot dead. Inside the skirmish line they fell in groups of fours, and finally Cus ter and a number of officers inside a circle of forty men, surrounded by slain horses, placed head to tatil. Curly, the Crow scout, who escaped by wrapping himself in a blanket, Indian fashion, and who afterwards joined us, says that here the fight was the bitterest; that the continuous discharge of the rifles he can liken to nothing so much as the sound of the tearing of strong cloth, and only when their ammunition was gone did the Sioux swarm upon them like a host of howling wolves. Then he jumped on a horse and made his escape, swiming the Big Horn, and going direct to the Crow camp, which was turned into a community of mourners by the terrible intelligence of which he was the bearer. The Crows, fearing that tLe victorious Sioux would follow up their success by an attack on tlem, at once hastened £o leave their camp ground on Prior's Fork and seek the protection of their agency. They be lieved that all of the 7th cavalry had been killed, and were fully convinced that our little force would share the same fate. Their demoralization was -complete when the dce serting scouts arrived in a body and corrob rated Cur ly's story. How these scouts managed to obtain such accurate informa tion as they imparted to us on the 26th, is a puzzle. All the bodies save those of Custer and

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

Capt. Clifford recalls the exhausted command's march from the Little Bighorn battlefield back toward the Yellowstone in early July 1876, describing the physical hardships and lingering shock among the troops. He reflects on Custer's fate and Terry's failed rendezvous, while detailing the mundane logistics of the retreat.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 15 May 1879 · page 5

THE INDIAN CAMPAIGN OF 1876.

On the evening of July 1st we reached the site of our old camp of June 25th. Only to think that while we were wearily toiling over the' heat-oppressed'hills on that day, the men fainting from thirst, Gen. Terry, eager to fulfill his part of the u,'derstand ing with the impetuous Custer to meet him and jointly attack the contident Sioux, that. fearless rider was already in the toils. The motives that swayed him may nevcr be known. Whatever his faults, his bright

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

A soldier's journal recounts the Fourth of July in camp after Little Bighorn, including the risky mission of a scout called 'Sandy' sent to carry dispatches to Gen. Crook. Sandy's riderless horse is later found, and he is feared killed or drowned, while Crow scouts report hearing distant gunfire.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 15 May 1879 · page 5

BY CAPT. W. CLIFFORD, U. S. A.

On the 5th, Gen. Gibbon sent for and di rected me to cross the river with as many picked men as I chose to take, and drive over from there, a number of horses and mules that had been abandoned on the re turn from the Little Big Horn, and which were now reported in the bottom on the other side. Crossing with ten good men, they were deployed on the river bank. Pass ing through the timber, we reached the plain under the bluffs. A covey of young sage hens were flushed and a number of shots fired at them.

See moreSee less

Starting for Tullock's Fork, distant four miles, we saw a man emerge from the brush on our right. It proved to be Sandy who, aroused by the noise of firing, came out of his biding place. He stated that he had started the night be " 1LO 1 CU UL1Ui 111611U IJUt

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

Couriers bring word that five companies of Custer's 7th Cavalry have been destroyed, while Crook, despite claiming victory, was actually defeated and forced back to his supply train, with Col. Guy Henry shot through the head. The report credits Gen. Gibbon's caution for sparing their own small force of 393 men from a similar fate.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 14 days earlier.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 15 May 1879 · page 5

So the matter stands just this way: Cus ter, with five companies of the 7th cavalry, blotted out of existence; Crook has met with a defeat, been forced back to his train, and is, calling for help, and we can thank our good fortune that we had, in the person of Gen. Gibbon, a leader too wise to be caught in the trap set for us in May by our wily enemies. Our little army of 393 men would have been destroyed or penned up as were Custer and Reno, and, if failing to finish us at once, they had surrounded us on the 19th of May, there could have been no rescue for us, and the grief that now darkens Fort Lincoln would have hung like a cerement over Forts Shaw, Ellis and

See the clipping

The New Northwest · Portland, Or.

Elizabeth L. Chapman was tried for stealing books worth twenty dollars, but claimed to be the widow of an army officer killed in the Custer massacre and said she had legitimately sold books from her late husband's library. The court found her not guilty and discharged her.

The New Northwest · 15 May 1879 · page 4

The testimony showed that tbe oomplainant's property had been stolen on the 21st of March last, and was found with a book-seller named Dugan, who swore be purchased tbem from the pris oner. Mr. Hummel led the accused to ttie witness stand, where, in reply to his question, she stated that she was a widow of au army officer who was killed by the Indians in tbe Custer massacre. She was under no necessity to steal books, but had purchased tbem and sold tbem to Mr. Dugan, who had previously purchased from her other books from ber late husband's library.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Chap man's manner was so genteel and sin cere that Counsellor Hummel said he would leave tbe case to the Court with out comment, except to move her dis cbarge, which motion tbe Courtgrantcd after finding ber not guilty. The Duke of Argyie will shortly renoh this country on his way to visit his son, the Marquis of Lorne, Governor-General of Canada. As the Duke has lately suf fered severe family afflictions In the death of the Duchess of Arygle, and lias also been an Invalid for some weeks, he has expressed in a letter to a friend the desire to maintain strict privacy while

See the clipping

Public Ledger · Memphis, Tenn.

A miscellaneous Chicago society and news column notes that Major Reno is well known in the city as the central figure in the recent Custer massacre court of inquiry held there. The rest of the item covers unrelated local topics like parks, a new music hall, and a confidence scam.

Public Ledger · 15 May 1879 · page 2

Lverybodv has heard! of the latter be cause of his being the central figure in the late General Custer massacre court of inquiry held in Chicago.

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

Lieutenant M. Carrow of the Seventh Cavalry committed suicide in St. Louis, apparently over unrequited love for Ella Sturges, daughter of Gen. Sturges and sister of Capt. Jack Sturges, who died with Custer at Little Bighorn. A letter found among his belongings revealed the romantic backstory behind his despair.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 21 May 1879 · page 7

LIEUT. CARROW.

im,* , i nu . latB * but atUl H came. 61., L. 8. A Western Itjr. freiutit uc Ifrt flyF.i* er ° r .® the at Louis.roads, count ....... , . 187 Wltd to the Alton, will be cum> Wls. Cent. U. It. freight account. 2,633 Foreign ticket account 24.004 ® utu same action as the trunk Car service account &007 Daughter of (ion. Sturges Did Nut Wish to Marry Him. ftUteUu Ultpateh to The Tribune. St. Louis, Mo., MuyUO.—The suicide of Lieut. M. Carrow, of the Seventh Cavalry, at tliu Haulers’ House yesterday afternoon, was tele graphed yesterday in its main details, hut the mystery surrounding the alfulr cleared upsome what to-day by the finding, among his personal ailceta, of a letter written by Ella Stunres, daughter of MoJ.-Gon.

See moreSee less

Sturgcs, of the United Slates Cavalry, mid sister to CapL Jack Si urges, who lost his life with Geo. Custer at the time o( the famous massacre. .Miss Stunted hud met

See the clipping

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

This 1879 report recounts Dull Knife's history of conflicts with whites, including claims that his Cheyenne band did the bulk of the fighting at the Custer battle and against Crook. It also details his band's later 1878 clash with General Mackenzie in the Big Horn country.

The New North-West · 23 May 1879 · page 4

DULL KNIFE'S CAREER.

Bull. The first party, consisting of about 40 lodges, were m the Custer fight and did the largest part of the deadly work. They were also in the fight first with General Crook, though it was wrongly reported to have been Crazy Horse's party. The Chey. erme's did the sanguinary business there too.

See the clipping

Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Lieutenant M. Carrow of the Seventh Cavalry shot himself at a St. Louis hotel, and a letter found among his effects revealed the tragedy stemmed from unrequited love for Ella Sturgis. She was the sister of Captain Jack Sturgis, who died with Custer at the Little Bighorn massacre.

Daily Republican · 24 May 1879 · page 1

ALL VOK LOVE. Why Lleoteuam ( arroa, of the Seventh Cavalry, Shot Jllin.elf Through the Heart, [St. Louis Dispatch to Cincinnati Enquirer.] The suicide of Lieutenant M. Carrow, of the Seventh Cavalry, at the Planter's House, yesterday afternoon, was tele graphed yesterday in its main "details, but the mystery surrounding the af fair was cleared up somewhat to-day hy the finding among his personal effects of a letter written hy Ella Hturgis, the daughter of Lieutenant Colonel Hturgis, of the United States Cavalry, and sister to Captain Jack Hturgis, who lost his life with General Custer, at the time of the famous massacre. Miss Hturgis had

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A Seventh Cavalry lieutenant, Carrow, shot himself at a St. Louis hotel after a failed romance with Ella Sturgis, sister of Capt. Jack Sturgis who died with Custer at Little Bighorn. The report details his courtship, her father's intervention, and his despair leading to suicide.

Evening Star · 24 May 1879 · page 5

LIEUTENANT CARROW, OF THE SEVENTH CAVALRY SHOT HIMSELF THROUGH THE HEART.

CAVALRY SHOT HtMSRLF THROCOH THE HRART. A St. Ij^uis dispatch to the Cincinnati En<juirer says:?The suicide of Lieut. M. Carrow, of the Seventh Cavalry, at the Planters' House, yesterday afternoon, was telegraphed yesterday

See the clipping

Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

Lieutenant Carrow of the Seventh Cavalry killed himself at a St. Louis hotel after a failed romance with Ella Sturgis, daughter of Lieutenant Colonel Sturgis and sister of Captain Jack Sturgis, who died with Custer at Little Bighorn. A letter found among his effects revealed she had rejected his final proposal.

Memphis Daily Appeal · 24 May 1879 · page 2

ROMANCE OF GARRISON LIFE ON THE PLAINS

Oallant Wtnrgls. St. Louis special, twentieth, to the Ciccin nati Enquirer: The suicide of Lieutenant M. Carrow, of the Seventh cavalry, at the Planters house, yesterday afternoon, was telegraphed yesterday in its main details, but the mystery surrounding the attair was cleared up somewhat to-day by the finding among his personal effects of a letter written bv KUa Sturcris, daughter ot .Lieutenant Colonel Stureis, of the United States cavalry, and sister to Captain Jack Sturgis, who lost his life with General Custer at the time of

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

An Army officer's 1879 dispatch describes desertions among Sioux warriors and a scare over horse-stealing raiders, then shifts into interpreter La Forge's personal account of the chaotic aftermath of the 1876 Custer battle. La Forge recounts hiding among Crow allies who believed him dead, and the mourning rituals his Crow wife and relatives performed before discovering he had survived.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 29 May 1879 · page 5

BY CAPT. W. CLIFFORD, U. S. A.

Sioux that fought Crobk and Custer is be ing gradually depleted by desertions, and for the sole reason that they cannot hang together through lack or food. Our Crow interpreter, La:Forge, who is married to a Crow woman, told me to-night that when the panic-streken scouts who de serted us went back to their carmp they re ported all of Custer's men killed ; that they lett us going down into the same place from whence there ceold not possibly be any escape for us. La Forge's Indian wile und relatives, supposing him to be killed, weit into mourning.

See moreSee less

His wife, who had very long hair. at once cut it oft--cut off one of her fingers, slashed her legs with a knife, destroyed her lodge, and gave his horses, fired and Missed him; fired again and missed; and just then he came into full view in the open opening-a splendid shot, but I had only an empty gun. The little stinging, biting devils being just is bad here as on the plain, I jumped onto my horse and gallopped toward camp, almost running over another deer; jumped to the ground and knocked him over at 75 yards. My horse won't stand fire. On my return to camp, I found that I had not by any means escaped the musquitoes. They are tormenting every one; they are biting my feet while I write 'em. A mail came in on the 24th from Powder river. The steamer is on her way up. A dispatch from Capt. Wheelan says she is thirty miles below here. The paymaster is on board and the troops are to be paid. Have just learned that there are thirty nine widows at Fort Abe Liucoln, made so wedded.-Paris Paper. by the Custer massacre. Since lying so long in camp a number of Crows squaws have joined their husbands. Near the camp is a shallow channel in which the soldiers bathe, and the squaws; who are camped on an Island, strip and mingle with the men while in swimming, creating a great deal of fun. Thirty-nine widows ! Who says the army is eager for war ? r To be Continued.1

See the clipping

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · Diamond City, Mont.

A Crow scout named La Forge recounts swimming a river with a broken arm after being separated during the fighting near Reno's command, and his emotional reunion with fellow scouts presumed dead. The excerpt continues with a soldier's diary entries from the weeks after the battle, describing camp moves, scouting parties, and daily life near the Yellowstone.

Rocky Mountain Husbandman · 29 May 1879 · page 5

Boyer. We biought in a number of horses captured from the Sioux which we gave to our friends. All my horses and other prop erty that my wife threw away has been re turned to me. And now they say they will go to help the white man w'henever they are sent for. They call Custer's battlefield

See the clipping