Delegate W. W. Corlett plans to introduce a resolution for a Congressional military committee inquiry into the 1876 Little Big Horn disaster, based on allegations from Custer biographer Captain Whittaker against certain officers. Witnesses including Reno's column officers, scouts, and interpreters would be called to determine responsibility for the defeat.
Daily Globe · 1 June 1878 · page 2
THE CUSTER MASSACRE. Endeavor to Have An Inquiry by Congress. The facts and reason of the massacre of Genral Custer, and his command at the battle of the Little Big Horn on June 25, 1876, will be the subject of special Congressional investigation if Mr. W. W. Corlett, dele gate from Wyoming Territory, succeeds in securing the passage of a resolution to be introduced by him authorizing tbe military committee of the House to send for poreoui and papers and thoroughly inquire into the affair. Mr Corlett has in his possession from Captain Whittaker.
See moreSee less
who is the author of Cus ter's biography, a set of allegations against certain officers of the United States army which, if proven, will show conclusively that, if General Custer's orders had been obeyed the result of the battle would have been very different, and if it had not resulted in a vic tory for our troops there would at least have been a saving of life. The witnesses who are willing to appear before the committee are the officers and some of the soldiers who were in Colonel Reno's column, together with interpieters, certain scouts and others. The resolution has the backing of the chairman of the mili tary committee, with whom Mr. Corlett has conferred. Delegate Corlett will offer his resolution on the very first opportunity. The com mittee is instructed by the resolution to re port to the House who. if any one, i? re sponsible for the disaster of tbe battle in which Custer and the five companies of the seventh cavalry perished. The resolution is intended, Mr. Corlett bajs. to vindicate the truth of history and to rid the military service of improper officers Tcntwssee Democratic onr, iitton.
The report describes calls for a congressional inquiry into the Custer massacre, proposed by Delegate W. W. Corlett, to be conducted by the House Military Committee. It notes rumors that Custer's subordinates failed to support him as expected, suggesting the disaster might have been avoided and urges accountability alongside vindication of the dead.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 2 June 1878 · page 1
Investigating the Cutter Massacre. The inquiry into the cause of the massacre of Custer and his men, pro posed by our Delegate, W. W. Corlett, and which will probably be made by the Military Committee of the House of Representatives, is clue to the memory of the victims as well as to the military reputation of a great and patriotic sol dier. When the dreadful news was re ceived that Custer and nearly all his command were slaughtered by the Sioux a general cry was raised that the head long courage and desire for distinction attributed to the gallant General proved superior to his military judgment, and that he allowed himself and his men to tie trapped and killed by the savages.
See moreSee less
In time, however, sinister rumors came floating about that had Custer lieen seconded in his attack as well as his confidence in his subordinates led him to expect, the massacre would not have occurred, and that a decM* victory, instead of defeat, would have rewarded the courage of Custer and his men. Even the SiCWx themselves bear some testimony that throws light on that dark event, and, when taken in con nection with the statements of men at tached to the force under Reno, shows that a searching inquiry is necessary. We hope that the result of an inquiry will be to show that every man did his duty on that fatal day. But we also desire to see those, if any there are, who have been guilty of disobedience or unsoldierly conduct punished as they deserve, and the fair fame of the dead heroes vindicated before the world.
The item claims two white men are living with Sitting Bull's band: a disgraced former Army major who joined the Sioux years earlier, and a man named John Lee allegedly captured at the Custer massacre and adopted into the tribe. Lee is said to be kept under watch to prevent his escape.
White Indian*.4!.?Two white men are re ported in Sitting Bull's band. One is a Major 1 eace, dismissed in disgrace from the 4th in fantry In 1861, while stationed in Kansas, since which time he has been living with the In dians, with whom he has completely identified himself. The other man is named John lel\' and was taken prisoner at the time pft lie Custer massacre. He has been adopted Into the tribe and has a squaw wife, but is
Delegate W. W. Corlett of Wyoming plans to introduce a House resolution calling for an investigation into the conduct of U.S. troops at the Little Bighorn, prompted by a letter from Custer biographer Frederick Whittaker accusing Major Reno of cowardice. The resolution would direct the Committee on Military Affairs to examine the actions of Custer's command and any supporting forces before and during the battle.
The New York Herald · 5 June 1878 · page 3
IitniON TO BE INTBODVCED IN THE HOUSE PY DELEGATE COBLCT f, OF WVOMINO. Mr. W. W. Corlett, Delegate from Wyoming Terri tory, bag not been able, as yet, to got a bearing for bis resolution for an Invorligation of tbo Custer tnassacy, owing to tbo psasauro ol other business upob tbe at tention of tbe House. He will-ofTer*it at tbe first opportunity. Mr. Corlett was prompted to prepare tbo resolution by the statement of facta pre sented in a latter written to blm by Mr. Frederick Wbittnkor, tbo biographer of General Castor, lu which be elates that n* baa good reason lor believing that tbo oonduot ol Major Reno was ol sach a character as to lead to tbo belief that cowardice can bo trnlhlully charged against him; tbat tbo only offlolal report of Abe battle in which General Custer and his command lost their lives Is tbo 600 wrttton by Major Reno, wbtcb Mr.
See moreSee less
Whlttaker stigmatises as false and libel lous to tbo memory of Caster. Sir. Wbtttsker cites as bis witso*sos to support tbese charges all of lbs surviving officers ot tbe Seven Mi cavalry and etners. Tbc following Is tbo text ot'the resolution as It will bo oflbred:? ? Kcsolvud, Tbat tbo Committee on Jfllttiwy Affairs ol tbie House bo and is Hereby instructed to isqoiro into tbo oonduot of the United States troops on gaged In tbo battle of the Little Big Horn, iought on tbo 26th day of Jane, A. D., 1870. ana otherwise known as tbe "uuetor Massacre,"m wblcb Lieutenant Colonel Caster, of tho Soveoth regiment <>l United States cavalry, perished wttb five companies af saM reg - meat ai loo bands of tb* Indians; Vtnd alsa to inquire Into tho ooudnot ol any other United States military commands or iorces o.'-operating witb or supporting too command of said Lieutenant Colonel Caster at and lumadiately praoedtag tbo time ol said angage tueot, end to ascertain and report to ibis Houto what person or persons were la aay respect respon sible for tho disaster of spM engagement; and said comraiitvo U authorized to scad Mt persons and pa pees sad BMf rep?r 1 oy otU ev otherwise. BEOBGAN1ZATION OF THE / EMI.
The Bossier Banner · Bellevue, La. · and 2 other papers
The article recounts Charles De Rudio's dramatic life story, from his escape from a penal colony to his U.S. Army career, culminating in his harrowing survival during the 1876 Custer expedition. It details how he was cut off from Reno's command and survived for hours hiding behind a stump, fighting off Indian attackers.
The Bossier Banner · 6 June 1878 · page 1
uma put. After a dangerous and frequent ly hopeless voyage of six days, the improvised sail and rowboat reached English Guinea, landing at New Am sterdam. On freedom's soil De Rudio at last saw daylight. He engaged as a launchman on an English merchant man. In England he was reunited with his family February 29, I860. January, 18G3,he landed in New York. August, 18G3, he joined the Union army as a private. In 1864, he wa3 appointed a Second Lieutenant in a regiment of col ored troops. He served in that capacity until 186G.
See moreSee less
He was then eight months in the Quartermaster's Department at force of hydros Washington. In 18G7, he was assigned to the Seconed Infantry, and on the 14th of July, 1869, was appointed to a com mand in the Seventh Cavalry. From that day to this He has participated in every movement of his regiment. In the South he was closely identified with the suppression of the Ku-klux operat ing in Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana, lie was a prominent witness before the Congressional Com mittee in New Orleans in 1875. In August, 1875, he brought the 54 miuers out of the Black Hills. In May, 1876, he came to Fort A. Lincoln as First Lieutenant, and commanding officer of :!v Company E, the troop of gray horses. The next and last great episode in De Rudio's career thus far was his part in the fatal Custer expe dition of 1876. He was with the Reno
The article laments that Decoration Day was observed only halfheartedly in Leavenworth, with businesses staying open and little public demonstration. It notes that tributes were placed at the cemetery for those who fell with Custer at the Little Bighorn, with a modest turnout of troops and civilians marching to the grove and cemetery.
The Leavenworth Weekly Times · 6 June 1878 · page 4
Fell With Custer in the ' Little Big Horn. A DAY OK KE3IKM11RAXCE. "The day upon which It Is sumiosed we most generally decorate, but which yesterday we most generally didn't, that Is, in theaccepteil
A Decoration Day observance at a Fort Leavenworth cemetery honored Custer and other officers killed at Little Bighorn nearly two years earlier, with flags, flowers, and monuments placed at their graves. Speeches, music, and a child's recitation were part of the ceremony, which was smaller than in previous years.
The Leavenworth Weekly Times · 6 June 1878 · page 4
the Hour nauieu lor me COMMENCEMENT Ol' THE EXERCISES, one oVclock, quite an assemblage had gath ered around the stand erected In the grove adjoining the tenietiry proper. In tlie mean lime small Hags nau lieen piameu ai eacu aim every graie, wnlch, together with the floral offerings w hlch were most profusely scattered about presented quite a pseturesque appeai ance. Ukii the graves 01 Cants. Custer and Vales, aud l.ltuu. Smith, Mcintosh and Cal
This 1878 report describes a Decoration Day commemoration at the Little Bighorn battlefield, with a military procession marching to the headboards marking where Custer's men fell. It reflects on the fading of wartime patriotic fervor a dozen years after the Civil War and two years after the battle.
The Leavenworth Weekly Times · 6 June 1878 · page 4
I.LOW-IVO TIIKsS MMK CITIZENS on foot an'i lu carriages. Hie proiesiion licing qiute a iiugiuy one. i 110 line oiuarcn wi.s inrough Hie cnlrul 'aveiine to the .. one running east ain. west: easl tijam that to the one run til 11.; north aud Miutli; ami north ujiou ihit until the head ot the column rested near the huge c. n uou which servesasa motiumeiit,aiid which i situated Just win-re Custer's ollictrs He bulled. Here the procession halted, and idler A H'XEEAL PIECE
The report states it is probable that a Congressional Committee will investigate the facts surrounding the Custer massacre. No further details are given about the scope or timing of such an investigation.
Stevens County Tribune · 6 June 1878 · page 1
Hon. James T. Maxfield, inaypr of St. Paul, died last Wednesday. Wheat, at this point, is the lowest It has been for nearly three years. It is probable that a Congressional Committee will investigate the foots in regard to the Custer massacre. The Grand Lodge of Good Tem plars, of Minnesota, will meet in Le
The report notes that just two years after the Custer massacre, the wilderness where it occurred has been settled by farmers. It describes a town of nearly a thousand inhabitants rising where Gen. Miles camped on the Tongue River in 1876, with former Sioux lands now occupied by pioneers.
The Home Journal · 6 June 1878 · page 1
It is Lot two years since tho Custer massacre took place, yet the wilderness In which it occurred is now populated by farmers who are rapidly turning the desert into a cultivated country. A town of nearly onethousand inhabitants has risen where Gen. Miles encamped on Tongue river in 1876 ; in fact the whole country which Sitting Bull occupied is
The report claims two white men live with Sitting Bull's band: a disgraced former U.S. Army officer named Major Pease, and John O'Brien, allegedly captured at the Custer massacre and adopted into the tribe. O'Brien is said to have a Native wife but is kept under watch to prevent his escape.
bankrupt himself in the attempt. The Behringa 8trait route is full of promise, and it is wen mat air. Bennett has selected it. Courier-J. Those who are draging this coun try into the abyss of Communism talk as if there was an impassable gull between the rich and poor something in our institutions which prevents the poor from becoming rich, or the rich from becoming poor. This is the argument of men whose idleness and poverty can generally be traced to their own misconduct or misfortune. Families, formerly rich and living in luxury, are now beggars In .
See moreSee less
our midst there are men who, ten years ago, were as poor as the Communists of the present day, but by honest in dustry have became rich. The mil lionaires of Boston, New York and other cities of the North, are fast dwindling down to men of very small fortunes. Memphis Appeal Two white men are reported in Sitting Bull's band. One is Major Pease, dismissed in disgrace from the Fourth Infantry in 1861, while stationed in Kansas, since which time has been living with the In dians. He has the full confidence of the Indians, and is, to all intents and purposes, an Indian a rene gade from and an enemy of his race. The other man is named John O'Brien, and was taken prisoner at the time of the Custer massacre, He has been adopted into the tribe, and has a squaw wife, but is under surveillance to prevent escape. American. The export of canned goods fig urea largely in the commerce of the country, New York alone sending abroad no less than 50,000 packages each week, or at the rate of 2,500, 000 cans per year. The number sent from other Atlantic ports fully as large, while Chicago, St. Lionis, and Cincinnati export as much. The steamships that sailed from New York last week took out not only a Jarger quantity of fresh beef than usual, but also some 60, 000 packages of canned goods, rep resenting everything in that line. from peaches to soups. Gallatin Tennesseean : The wool shipments from Gallatin this season has been very good. Up to date 22S sacks 30,000 pounds have gone North, and we learn of quite a number of pounds to be shipped yet. Cure your horses of Sweeny, Rlnebones.Sprains, spavin and kindred dis eases by the use of the Fiiamond Oil Trice, 75 cents par bottle for sale at Sumpter $ Stanley's, Corner Drug store. - . . - uecti-tr
The article jokes that Sitting Bull, since the Custer massacre, has found refuge in Canada and offered his Sioux warriors' services to the British government. It humorously suggests the U.S. could profit by allowing foreign enlistment of such warriors as a solution to the 'Indian problem' and the 'tramp nuisance.'
The Cincinnati Daily Star · 7 June 1878 · page 2
l,TlI.I.li NMSAXt KS. ' . Brave men are always grateful. No one questions the bravery of Sitting Bull eince the Custer massacre, and he has given expression to his gratitude for hay ing been" "allowed au asylum in Canada liy nowjoflering his services and those of .hie Sioux Warriors to the British Gov ernment if their services should be de- ' aired. The Sioux of to. Bull's command are as meciless as the Sepoys or the Bashi Bazouks," and .wouIdr on their mus tang ponies, armed with Henry rifles, be" more than a matchfor the.
See moreSee less
Cpssack of he Don. There seems to, be, if not V kinship, at leant some kind of affinity be tween Hitting Bull and John Bull that would enable them to act in harmony, . This foreign enlistment of the Ameri-
The item describes the rapid settlement of the Yellowstone valley, noting that a town of nearly 1,000 people now stands where General Miles once camped. It states that the battlefields where Custer and his men died are now occupied by farmers, and the land from which Sitting Bull was driven is peacefully held by settlers.
The Greenville Times · 8 June 1878 · page 4
lf cf a t-cigKbcrig university, Uet. 1 can ace it now whenever I il as the larrrnptibls returning boi'i ttit!!5l cot tL re'iilt of the l-5r.ii si tegsift moiuent by nio Ki: U diw k pon the horrified ja-Wus tlit t'itii picaiiinuy hud wi t jrlxcfie coropleltd '.".. V. t6rttit-d this elartting u(mU.n. Tie darkey ftiuoccut M .-.',i;.i to U the handsomest bs.Vr-f .t tbt Uct-St of the church Vy i.iadt4B B &jotity. The .iT i'te wa t'tLUy drawn, and J ist,. ievac rooted in every jTfrdnct. V,h tLe ladiw of W'au-k-piia gt-ttp 60iher baby show for tie gwd cf tie churth " folks will know it," The w:ulri'ni:U i, ih Lee mouv'n-tit frcm the several Stales los-e my eyes."
See moreSee less
fttMvr'aTIatUciield. Oiic of the marvel of this age of emigration and eutorprheisthe rapid settlement of tho Yellow stone valley. At tho point on tho ionguo river where Oouoral Miles encamped iu 1870 there is now a town with a population oi noarlv 100'. Tho battlefields of Custer ana Lis men nro occupied by farmcrs, and tho country from which Sitliug Bull was driven is in neacnful possession of the pioneers of emulation ngaiust which such tre mendous tragedies as the Custer massacre count as nothing. Uc Moimaient &t Kctr 0rkait3.
Father Genin, a Catholic missionary who spent months with Sitting Bull's band at Wood Mountain, brings news of a large council of Sioux warriors demanding supplies or threatening violence. The report describes the chief's friendly reception of the priest and mentions the horse Sitting Bull rode during the Custer fight, now given to Genin.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 9 June 1878 · page 3
SITTING-BULL.
Special Correspondence of The Tribune. Bismarck, D. T., June 7.— Father Genin, the Sioux missionary, is back after an abscucefrom Bismarck of fourteen months among the Indians. lie is the chief Catholic evangelist of the Northwest, and tbe only man I know of who is acquainted with the Indians, and has any special knowledge that is of importance to the public. He arrived here direct from Woodv Mountain, after a drive of fifteen days Dehind the war-horse that Sitting-Bull rode in the Custer massacre. Sitting-Bull made his old friend -and spiritual adviser a present of this pony,—a very; respecta ble looking gray.
See moreSee less
He bus a scar on his neck, as a reminder of the terrible affray in which he and Ids rider took such an active interest. Father Genin reached Sitting-Bull’s camp and tepee on the 10th of last August. He went that way as a missionary, and not as a civil, military, or newspaper ambassador. It came about iu the order of his visits to the far off tribes of the Sioux Nation. Since 1807 he has been a missionary among them, and since ’OS a PERSONAL FRIEND OF SITTING-BULL.
The report describes the Sioux's ample ammunition supply and clever cartridge-reloading methods, sourced from Father Genin's visit to Sitting Bull's camp. It then begins relaying Sitting Bull's personal narrative of the Custer battle, presented as his unembellished account to a trusted friend.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 9 June 1878 · page 3
AMMUNITION PLENTY—INDIAN INGENUITY.
ing a compromise. - S.-H.’s REPORT OF THE CUSTER MASSACRE. This brief account of the Custer massacre was given to Father Gcnin hv Sitting-Bull as one friend would narrate any interesting event to another. There was no motive to tell any thing but the plain truth. Sitting-Bull said: •* The ncople in the States blame me for killing Custer and his army. He came to attack me in sufficient numbers to show that he wanted to destroy me and my children. For three days 1 looked at them coining toward us.
See moreSee less
I then as* semblcd the young men, and told them to put up the old tepees, light fires Inside and out, put blankets and other things upon the stick?, and plant them in the ground around the tires, so that they would look like people at a distance. At the same time I sent the children aud women across the hills to a place of safety. With my warriors I turned around two or three bluffs to give Custer time to come no ami charge our empty fences. When he came I fell upon him by tile ye*V, and in less than two hours destroyed them all. When I saw them coming I culled on God to help me, and liberate me and my children. They call me a very bad man. Father, all I have done ia my life has been to get a living for my children and my old parents, and save them from the dangers ol death.” Gcnin says they say Keno acted wisely, and that they only withdrew from the fight because of their scouts reporting Terry’s approach. Geniu was told that the warriors who fell on Custer used their round-stone tomahawks, and killed tnanv soldiers with them. That explains the broken skulls, and the so-called mutilation attributed to the squaws. He was presented with two of those relics of the Custer horror. One has eleven and the other has twenty-seven horseshoe murks on it. The horseshoe mark means a dead cavalryman. The warrior who presented the Father with the one of twenty seven marks claims that he killed twenty-seven men in the Custer fight (probably struck that many). He sighed when he gave it up, but he thought he was obliged to make some great sacrifice in respect: to “ the Black Gown with long beard.” COLT*.
Father Genin relays Sitting Bull's personal account of the battle, describing a decoy of empty tepees to lure Custer in and a quick two-hour destruction of his command. Sitting Bull also explains that stone tomahawks, not squaws' mutilation, caused the soldiers' broken skulls, and presents relics marked with kill-tallies.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 9 June 1878 · page 3
ing a compromise. - S.-H.’s REPORT OF THE CUSTER MASSACRE. This brief account of the Custer massacre was given to Father Gcnin hv Sitting-Bull as one friend would narrate any interesting event to another. There was no motive to tell any thing but the plain truth. Sitting-Bull said: •* The ncople in the States blame me for killing Custer and his army. He came to attack me in sufficient numbers to show that he wanted to destroy me and my children. For three days 1 looked at them coining toward us.
See moreSee less
I then as* semblcd the young men, and told them to put up the old tepees, light fires Inside and out, put blankets and other things upon the stick?, and plant them in the ground around the tires, so that they would look like people at a distance. At the same time I sent the children aud women across the hills to a place of safety. With my warriors I turned around two or three bluffs to give Custer time to come no ami charge our empty fences. When he came I fell upon him by tile ye*V, and in less than two hours destroyed them all. When I saw them coming I culled on God to help me, and liberate me and my children. They call me a very bad man. Father, all I have done ia my life has been to get a living for my children and my old parents, and save them from the dangers ol death.” Gcnin says they say Keno acted wisely, and that they only withdrew from the fight because of their scouts reporting Terry’s approach. Geniu was told that the warriors who fell on Custer used their round-stone tomahawks, and killed tnanv soldiers with them. That explains the broken skulls, and the so-called mutilation attributed to the squaws. He was presented with two of those relics of the Custer horror. One has eleven and the other has twenty-seven horseshoe murks on it. The horseshoe mark means a dead cavalryman. The warrior who presented the Father with the one of twenty seven marks claims that he killed twenty-seven men in the Custer fight (probably struck that many). He sighed when he gave it up, but he thought he was obliged to make some great sacrifice in respect: to “ the Black Gown with long beard.” COLT*.
Father Genin, a Catholic missionary who spent fourteen months among the Sioux, returns to Bismarck with reports from Sitting Bull's camp, including a gift horse that carried Sitting Bull during the Custer fight. The report describes a large gathering of Sioux warriors and tensions over whether they will seek peace or cross back into the United States.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 10 June 1878 · page 3
SITTING-BULL.
Sprda! Cormpondentt of Tht Tribune. Btsmarck, I). T., Juno 7.—Father Gcnln, tho Sioux missionary, la back after an absence from Bismarck of fourteen months among tho Indian*. Ho la tho chief Catholic evangelist of the Northwest, and the only msu I know of who la Acquainted with tho Indians, and haa any special knowledge that Is of Importance to the public. Ho arrived here direct from Woody Mountain, niter a drive of fifteen days Behind the war-horse that Sitting-Bull rode (□ ths Custer massacre. Sitting-Bull made bis old friend and spiritual adviser a
Sitting Bull reportedly told a missionary priest his own version of the Little Bighorn battle, describing how he set up decoy tepees to lure Custer while women and children fled, then ambushed the soldiers from the rear. He also attributed the broken skulls often blamed on squaw mutilation to warriors' round-stone tomahawks.
other argument that they are savage*. AMMUNITION ri.BNTT—INDIAN INOBNIJTTT. Father Gentn reports theammnnltlon plenty, and tho trader* always, like Barkis, “willin’.'’ No trouble to trade tor cartridges, powder, and ball. Ho llluatratea the ammunition question In this way: Many of tbe warriors bare double belts around the waist, full of cartridge*; also, suspenders crossing In front and hack, with cartridges; even bracelet* full of cartridges. There are seventeen men at work on bright day* lb Sittltig Bull’* camp, refitllng cartridges, and challenging professional* In thetr expertnes*. They cut the com mon percussion-cap In two, and use It, wben necessary, in tho central Are cartridge.
See moreSee less
Tallow I* used around It In fitting It ti> tight. They do better than that: they refill the Henry rim fire cartridge, which, tn expert gunsmith told me, wasn’t practicable. They take tho phosphorus from matches, make paste of It, put a little In the bottom of a cartridge, dry In the *un, and then fill with powder ana ball. It never misses fire. They caught tho idea from striking matches and producing a tight. They Inferred that a gun-hammer could do the same and Ignite the powder. The am munition doesn’t come from this side of the lino. Tho traders are Canadians. l>lko Kn elaud, Sitting-Bull, while preparing fur peace, has been loading up for war. Ho understands a well-equipped enemy has an advantage io mak ing a compromise. a.-n.’s report on tits coster massacre. This brief account of the Custer massacre was given to Father (Jenin by Sltllng-Bult as one Friend would narrate any interesting event to another. There was no motive to toll any thing but the plain truth. Sitting-Bull said: “The people in the Btatcs blame mo for killing Custer and his army. ITo came to attack mo In sufficient numbers to show that he wanted to destroy me and my children. For three days 1 looked at them coming toward as. I then as sembled tho young men, and told them to put up the old tepees, light fire* Inside and out, put blankets and other things upon tho sticks, and plant them In thu ground around the fires, so that tbev would look like people at a distance. At tho same time 1 sent the children and women across the hills to a place of safety. With my warriors 1 turned around two or three blulfs to give Custer time to enmo up and charge our empty tepees. When ho came I fell upon him by the rear, and In less than two hours destroyed them all. (When 1 saw them coming 1 called on God to help me. iml liberate mo and my children. They call me a very bad man. Father, all I have done In my life has been to gut a living (or my children and my old parents, and save them from the dangers of death.” Gcnln says they soy Keno acted wisely, and that they only withdrew from tho fight because of their scouts reporting Terry’s approach. Gcnln was told that the warrior* who fell on Custer used thetr rouml-slone tomahawks, and killed many soldiers with them. That explains
Father Genin relates Sitting Bull's first-person narrative of luring and destroying Custer's command, and displays two stone tomahawks marked with horseshoe notches said to tally slain cavalrymen. The account claims these tomahawk blows, not squaws' knives, explain the skull fractures and alleged mutilation of soldiers' bodies.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 10 June 1878 · page 3
killed many soldiers with them. That explains I the broken skulls, and the so-called mutilation attributed to the squaw*. Ho wo* presented with two of those relics of the Custer horror. One has eleven and the other has twenty-seven horseshoe marks on ft. The horseshoe murk means a dead cavalryman. Tho warrior who presented the Father with the ons of twenty bcvcd marks claims that ho killed twenty-seven men in the Custer fight (probably struck that many). Ho sighed when no gavo it up, but ho thought bo was obliged to maUo lomo great sacrifice (a respect to " tho UUck Gown with long beard." GOLD.
Father Genin, a missionary who lived among Sitting Bull's band, reports on a planned congress of all Sioux and allied tribes to decide whether to move south, driven by buffalo scarcity. He also describes gifts from Sitting Bull, including the horse he rode and tomahawks credited with killing soldiers in the Custer fight.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The New York Herald · 10 June 1878 · page 3
THE SIOUX?SrUENOIU OF TBK COMBINED INDIAN FORCES?WHAT IS BFQUlItED AS A GUARANTEE OP PifACE. Bismarck, D. Tm June S, 1878. The noted missionary ol tho Blbtix notion. Father. J. B. M. Geotn, has arrived at Bismarck from his pro longed visit to tho bostilos across the Hue. Father Genin arrived at Sitting Boll's camp alone last August, and up" to the 15th ol May prosecuted his mission ary labors. lie has boon with tho Sioux since 1807 and bus personally kcown Sit ting Bull tea yoare. Sitting Bull calls bun bis brother, so strung Is tboir trlehdsbtp.
See moreSee less
Wliou Father Genin left blin the old warrior, who is really only thirty-eight years of age, presented the bearer of the cross with the war mare that bo rode In the Custer massacre; also two stono tomahawks of war riors who claimed they bad killed respectively oleven and twenty-sejen soldiers with them in tho Custer disaster. Tbey valood them ae great treasures, but their love lor their priest forced the sacrifice of part lug with them. Father Ueolu's confidential and re Haioue rotations with Sitting Bull and bis baud, some ol whom he instructed iu the Catholic taut) and bup t zed, meke bun the most Important witness who bae ever beta in or near Hitting Bull's tent. OONUkkSS or TBS SIOUX. First, Father Genin reports that a oongross ot all brunches of the Sioux nation across tbe Hue, includ ing lbs Blackleet, Bloods, 1'iegaus, Aasiuubolncg, Cress, Big Bear aud CuippewaB, Iiad been appoloicd lor the latter dsyaef May and tho Urst ol June, .lu ting Bull bad bcon working up this cougross lor a year, and all the Indians invited to participate lu tho meeting had accepted. It was to doterinlue whether tuey should make a union and move touth In a body whou toe inevitable necessities ol the situation lorced them. It Is a question ol bulUio meal, and Father Genin says tbey must meet It, as tbe bulfalo raoge on tbe Canadian eido cannot support one-sixth ot the lndiaus mora, lbo number oi lodges ot sll tbe boett os. Father Uontn says, is 1,5711 by his own count, or nearly seven ihoueaud warriors, lis gives the grand loyal of all tbe Indian lodges accepting Mlltng Hull's invitaiiou H/tho congress at 8,4r>w. or 2k,oou warriors. He estimates over lour warriors lo tne lodge. Tbey have plasty ot urnis and ammunition. ?I'rrMM or axucsition. Sitting Bull's warriors have a double bolt of car tridges about tbe waisi, suspenders ol cartridges over tbe ehouldors crossing lo front sod back, and evnn uraceiels around lbs wrists filled witu car tridges. Seventeen young bucks on lair days work at refilling cartridges, iney even refill tbe Henry fire cartridge by reducing tbo pnosphorus Iroui tbe ends ol maiobea le a paalo and patting It in tbeboi turn of tne cartridge, thou drying in tno sun una alterward tilling wiin powder ana ball. The traders uu tno Canadian tide sell aintnuuilioo Ireoly 10 the host ilea Father Genin SRya. hitting Hull told n l in that In tbe Caster massacre bis warriors used their stona tomahawks Ireoly, and the mutilation attributed to tho squaws waa tbe result ol a haud io InuU light, wbereiu the tomahawks wero bundled as tbe soldier would imve used nis sauro il be bad it. HITTIXO HULL'S RXOWI.SDUK AMD PCRPOSKS.
Father Genin reports that Sitting Bull organized a congress of Sioux and allied tribes in Canada to decide on a unified move south due to buffalo scarcity, claiming nearly 28,000 warriors well-armed with cartridges and even homemade ammunition. The account also relays Sitting Bull's claim that mutilation of bodies at the Little Bighorn resulted from hand-to-hand tomahawk combat rather than deliberate mutilation by women.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The New York Herald · 10 June 1878 · page 3
THE SIOUX?SrUENOIU OF TBK COMBINED INDIAN FORCES?WHAT IS BFQUlItED AS A GUARANTEE OP PifACE. Bismarck, D. Tm June S, 1878. The noted missionary ol tho Blbtix notion. Father. J. B. M. Geotn, has arrived at Bismarck from his pro longed visit to tho bostilos across the Hue. Father Genin arrived at Sitting Boll's camp alone last August, and up" to the 15th ol May prosecuted his mission ary labors. lie has boon with tho Sioux since 1807 and bus personally kcown Sit ting Bull tea yoare. Sitting Bull calls bun bis brother, so strung Is tboir trlehdsbtp.
See moreSee less
Wliou Father Genin left blin the old warrior, who is really only thirty-eight years of age, presented the bearer of the cross with the war mare that bo rode In the Custer massacre; also two stono tomahawks of war riors who claimed they bad killed respectively oleven and twenty-sejen soldiers with them in tho Custer disaster. Tbey valood them ae great treasures, but their love lor their priest forced the sacrifice of part lug with them. Father Ueolu's confidential and re Haioue rotations with Sitting Bull and bis baud, some ol whom he instructed iu the Catholic taut) and bup t zed, meke bun the most Important witness who bae ever beta in or near Hitting Bull's tent. OONUkkSS or TBS SIOUX. First, Father Genin reports that a oongross ot all brunches of the Sioux nation across tbe Hue, includ ing lbs Blackleet, Bloods, 1'iegaus, Aasiuubolncg, Cress, Big Bear aud CuippewaB, Iiad been appoloicd lor the latter dsyaef May and tho Urst ol June, .lu ting Bull bad bcon working up this cougross lor a year, and all the Indians invited to participate lu tho meeting had accepted. It was to doterinlue whether tuey should make a union and move touth In a body whou toe inevitable necessities ol the situation lorced them. It Is a question ol bulUio meal, and Father Genin says tbey must meet It, as tbe bulfalo raoge on tbe Canadian eido cannot support one-sixth ot the lndiaus mora, lbo number oi lodges ot sll tbe boett os. Father Uontn says, is 1,5711 by his own count, or nearly seven ihoueaud warriors, lis gives the grand loyal of all tbe Indian lodges accepting Mlltng Hull's invitaiiou H/tho congress at 8,4r>w. or 2k,oou warriors. He estimates over lour warriors lo tne lodge. Tbey have plasty ot urnis and ammunition. ?I'rrMM or axucsition. Sitting Bull's warriors have a double bolt of car tridges about tbe waisi, suspenders ol cartridges over tbe ehouldors crossing lo front sod back, and evnn uraceiels around lbs wrists filled witu car tridges. Seventeen young bucks on lair days work at refilling cartridges, iney even refill tbe Henry fire cartridge by reducing tbo pnosphorus Iroui tbe ends ol maiobea le a paalo and patting It in tbeboi turn of tne cartridge, thou drying in tno sun una alterward tilling wiin powder ana ball. The traders uu tno Canadian tide sell aintnuuilioo Ireoly 10 the host ilea Father Genin SRya. hitting Hull told n l in that In tbe Caster massacre bis warriors used their stona tomahawks Ireoly, and the mutilation attributed to tho squaws waa tbe result ol a haud io InuU light, wbereiu the tomahawks wero bundled as tbe soldier would imve used nis sauro il be bad it. HITTIXO HULL'S RXOWI.SDUK AMD PCRPOSKS.
Delegate Corlett introduced a House resolution calling for a military investigation into the Little Bighorn battle, prompted by a letter from Custer's biographer Frederick Whittaker accusing Major Reno of cowardice. The resolution's full text is printed, calling for inquiry into the conduct of all troops involved in the disaster.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 11 June 1878 · page 4
A few days ago Tiib Leader men tioned the fact of our Delegate in Con gress having offered a resolution in the House calling for an investigation into the cause or causes of the late General Cnster’s defeat at the battle of the Utile Big Horn. Mr. Corlett was prompted to this course by the state ment presented in a letter written to him by Mr. Frederick Whittaker, the biographer of General Custer, in which Whittaker states that he has good rea son to believing that the conduct of Major Reno Was of such a character as to lead to the belief that cowardice can be truthfully charged against him; that the only official report of the battle in which General Custer and his command lost their lives, is the one written by Major lieno, which Mr.
See moreSee less
Whittaker stigmatizes as false and libellous to the memory of Custer. Mr. Whittaker cites, as his witnesses to support these charges, all of the surviving officers of the Seventh cavalry and others. The following is the resolution: Resolved. That the Committee on Military Affairs of this House be and is hereby instructed to inquire into the conduct of the United States troops engaged in the battle of the Little Big Horn, fought on the 25th day of June, A. D. 1876, and otherwise known as the “Custer Massacre,” in which Lieu tenant Colonel Custer of the Seventh regiment of United States cavalry, per ished with five companies of said regi ment, at the hands of the lndiaus; and also to inquire into the conduct of any other of the United States military commands or forces co-operating with or supporting the command of said Lieutenant Colonel Custer at aud immediately preceding the time of said engagement, and to ascertain and re port to this House what person or per sons were in any respect responsible for this disaster of said engagement ; and said committee is authorized to send for persons and papers and inay report by bill or otherwise. • Taken to Ohio.
A report citing a 'Major Jlges' describes Sitting Bull supposedly torturing Dakota tribesmen, parading warriors in uniforms stripped from dead soldiers at Custer's battlefield, and giving a fiery speech about fleeing north. The paper itself casts doubt on these sensational tales, noting that impartial observers will likely not believe them given past exaggerations.
Der Nordstern · 13 June 1878 · page 6
Sitting Bull. Erschreckliche Dinge berichtet ein ge wisser Major Jlges über Sitting Bull. An einem Tage versammelten sich Tau sende fcinUich gesinnter Dakotas in dessen Lager. Dort wurden von dem berühmten Kriegshäuptling Stunden lang gefoltert. Etwa 30 junge Krieger, in Jacken und Hosen gekleidet, die sie den tobten Soldaten auf Custer's chlachtfeld ausgezogen, ließ man pa radiren, um dadurch kriegerischen En thusiasmus zu erregen. Sitting Bull sagte den versammelten Ariegern, daß er aus dem Pellow-Stone-Lande ent flohen sei, nicht weil er sich Vörden Weißen fürchtete, sondern weil er den Gestank nicht mehr ertragen konnte, den die Leichen der von ihm erschlagenen Soldaten verbreiteten.
See moreSee less
Dieser Krieg und Verderben drohende Mensch sehnt sich nach frischer Luft und ist über die Grenze gegangen, um die wahren Söhne der „Mutter Häuptlingin" zu finden. Er droht, daß. wenn das Gras aufgewachsen ist, er sich nach dem 3}e( low-Stone zurückziehen wird. Wäh rend seiner Rede wurde Sitting Bull so aufgeregt, daß er die Kleider, die er anhatte, in Fetzen zerriß, was die Tau sende von Kriegern mit lautem Jubel Inländische BölkerwandeSeit Iaht und Tag finde! fast »«be achtet in dem wüsten Larm des alltÄz?
A traveler describes Fort Benton, Montana, including a hotel museum of Indian relics collected by John J. Healy, among them a mallet supposedly wielded by one of Sitting Bull's warriors at the Custer massacre. The rest of the passage recounts a muddy, flood-plagued stagecoach journey from Benton.
Helena Weekly Herald · 13 June 1878 · page 5
Western country. Mr. IT. fa having a fine cabinet made, m which to preserve these relics. I had the pleasure of seeing a mallet which one of Sitting Bull's warriors wielded '-ii the Custer massacre, and I was also shown a black thorn cane which was lately brought over from Cork and presented to Mr. Healy. The coaches are all a day and a half behind time and it will be several days before they t an make up the lost time. I left Benton in tiie coach Saturday morning, the prospect of a fuir day being good, but my best hopes were not destined to live long.
See moreSee less
The coach was crowded full and we had many a mile to walk in order to allow the coach to keep moving. The lakes were very bad, and all along were to be seen hundreds of trains 'nek fust in the mud and mire. We did not arrive at at the Leavings till nine in the even ing, and the driver very wisely declined to go on further till the next morning. We were all glad for we needed the rest, as we had worked oar passage the greater part of the way, and required rest such as only re freshing sleep could give us. An early break fast and we pulled ont again Sunday morning only to get mired before we had gone a mile, and it took eight yoke of oxen to pull the coach out of the mire. The rise of Sun River was so great as to submerge a large portion of Mr. Vaughan's land, and threat ened to drown out Mr. Reinicke at the Leav ings ; they packed up preparatory to taking to the hills. The lanes all the way are in a fearful condition. At the Crossing the dam age sustained was considerable, the new road being washed away and Mr. Steell's bridge floated off. A boat w 7 as rowed from Bull's place to the post-offee, and many lively little incidents occurred in that neighborhood. Mr. Thos. Dunn and Henry Rowles had an opportunity to try their skill at swimming, and they had a severe time of it though they were fully equal to the emergency. Some of the kitchens were well flooded. The road from the Crossing to Ford's place looks fear ful, but it is fast being put in order again un der the immediate supervision of Mr. Lar gent, and if good weather continues trains can pass without serious trouble. The road from Benton to Shaw is lined with heavy wagon trains and there are quite a number of families with private wagons camped along the road at different points. Let Helena establish the intelligence office which you proposed in a recent issue and its beneficial results will soon be seen, for there are many .who come here with but litle means, and who, if they could have half a chance held out to them, would settle and become permanent residents ; and with such an office they could easily learn what opportunity there was open for them. L. T. M.
The House Committee on Military Affairs agrees to report favorably on a resolution to investigate the Custer battle, based on a letter from Frederick Whittaker alleging cowardice by Major Reno and inaction by Captain Benteen. Whittaker claims Reno disobeyed Custer's orders and fled, while Benteen remained idle despite hearing the fighting, causing the defeat.
The Sun · 13 June 1878 · page 1
follows: Mount Vrtivov. N. T.. May 1R, 1973. fin. W. W. Oaroff, M 6. Dkaii BtBl Having boon called on to prepare the Plogrnidiy of the late brevet Major-Uon. Qeorgo A. Cuitar, U.B. A., a great amount of "ii hli ", oral and written, cam" Into my bands tending P, prov that the sacrifice of his life and the lives of his immediate command nl the bat tie of the Little Big Horn, was useless, and owing to tip-cownrdico of his subordinates. I desire, therefore, to nsk your ntt. ntloii, nnd that of Congress through you.totlm necessity of ordering an official investigation by a com mltteo of your honorable body into tho OpndttCt of th" l"nit"d Status troops engaged In th" I ,t tle ,,f th" Little Big Horn, ight June 25.
See moreSee less
1H7H. otherwlll known ns the I usPt massacr". In whl"h Lleut-Ool. (.'lister. Heventh united states I'avalrr. perished, with flvi OOBipanflg Oi the s.'Venth ( avalry. at the hnmls ot tho In, Hans, The reason on which I found my request aro as follows; First Information coming to mo from partlc. Ipants in tho battle, wrrftP n and oral. Is to the elT".t t li nt gross cowardice was displayed there in by Mai .r Hircoi A. Reno, Seventh United Htnb-s Cavalry, leoond In command that day; nnd that, owing to such ooWBTdloa, the ordors of I. lout. -Co. Cusler, i omnium ling officer to eaid Reno, to axeouti a certain attaok were uot obey id. That the failure of this mnyempnt. owing to his oowardldi and dtaooadlinoa, caused the do feat Of the United States forces on tlio day In question: and Hint, had Custer's Drain boon obeyed, the troops w-mld probably have defeat
A letter, apparently from interpreter F.F. Girard, accuses Major Reno of cowardice and inaction during the Battle of the Little Bighorn, claiming his failure to support Custer caused the massacre. It calls for a congressional or official investigation to establish blame and clear Custer's reputation, offering surviving officers as witnesses.
The Sun · 13 June 1878 · page 1
boiloui to tno memory of th, late I.lout.-Col, Custer. In taut It repriaantl tiedeh.it ..f the United St at. s forces "ii that -icension ns .-wingi i the division by Custer of his foroea into these tlctacbmoiits. t" overmanning his for es. ami tolgnornn f ti nomyi for-.. all aorloui charge! against the capacity of said Cust.-r as aii pffloertwhereaatbo defeat was really owing t wanuoe and dlaobedleneo of laldRenn and to the wilful neglect of said IP-no nnd 1 apt. 1 1 u i .-en I,, join batui with th" Indian!
See moreSee less
in suii p at ,-f their oommandlng ifllcer when ihey might have done it. and il was their plain duty so i , do, Foiirlh The welfare of tho United States nrmy demands that In ens, of a massacre of a large party of tr-'ops, under cir umftanco covered w.th luiplcion, ii should be ,fli, iiilly estab'lshed wh-rthe bhimo belongs, to the end Hint the serve-,, miiy uot deteriorate by tho re tent, on mf cowards. FifthJuiOOO to in officer of the previously UnaUtinetl rooord of I.lout.-Col. Custer, Ionian, Is Dial the a-'eiisatioii under which his memory
The horse Comanche, sole survivor of the Battle of Little Bighorn where Custer and his men were killed, was found wounded on the battlefield and belonged to Captain Keogh of the Seventh Cavalry. Efforts were made to save him, he has since recovered, and a general order was issued declaring he shall never be ridden again.
The Weekly Arizona Miner · 14 June 1878 · page 2
OLD COMANCHE.
"Oi,d CoiLo:cnE."-.Tiie horse "Coman chc," whicli is the only survivor or the bat tle of Little Big-Horn, in which Custer nift lim (Il'Mtll IlilU luun .1... ' . r general order. Ho was found on the battlolaovornoroi uciu cnvous v uv.nml..ii. ri..a .,.... two
A scout named Chris Gilson reports that Sitting Bull claims to want peace and was forced into the fighting that led to the Custer massacre. Gilson also relays Sitting Bull's dramatic account of the last soldier to fall, who allegedly killed five Indians before dying.
wagons, which the Indiana procured. Mr. „ „ .... , Coflia took I... departure, on Sunday night j for the scene of the depredation.- World ' June 4th, From flitting Bull's Camp. Chria Gilson, a scout, recently returned from Sitting Bull's camp, where he stopped for sereral weeks, reports the "old Medi cine Man" an absolute beleiver in the poli cy of peace. The warrior force Gilson es
The report notes that the Crow tribe, long a loyal U.S. ally in Indian wars, has become uneasy due to settlers flooding the Yellowstone country. It attributes this partly to the new forts Keogh and Custer, which have brought in settlers threatening game and tribal trust.
Walla Walla Statesman · 15 June 1878 · page 1
The Cause of Indian Wars
settlers along the Ycfluwstune annuity. uhich. tln-y say, will sum drive away all the game. The establishment of new WYS of Fort Kenna!) and Fort Custer on the Yelluwstnmc and Little Big Horn has hruagint the sezzltrn, thev say, and tinny dzcrcture distrust the saliva! they have szudily iougbt with for the past five ycus. (‘.xuronxu Cams. The San Franciscn ('.mmiclg says the [m :'rct at this time is that the prcwnt year will L», by millinns uf cwuds, the most productive uf wheat and Other ct nulls ever yet *lfxl’iesctxi by my farmers of “.15. furnia. The max of when: is Ambzmiy thiny-fivr to forty per out. gnu-£4: {Khan :'.;3
The report reflects on the rapid growth of towns, farms, and commerce in the Yellowstone valley region since the 'massacre' of Custer's command two years earlier. It marvels at how quickly American settlers transformed former battlegrounds into thriving colonies with schools, stores, and churches.
The Superior Times · 15 June 1878 · page 1
1 was enacted—The massacre of the chivalric Custer and his command— and }et a marvelous change has been effected throughout the valley of the Yellowstone and its tribu taries. The tide of emigration has j poured in from all sections. Schools and stores and newspaper offices and churches, and improved farms and herds of cattle, now dot the tortile valleys and the green hill sides, where two years ago only armed bodies of disciplined troops : could go, and then not always safely. At Tongue River, where General Miles was encamped in i 176—7, a town has sprung up with a population of over one thousand.
See moreSee less
Many other localities in the then | center of savogedom have grown into thriving colonies of enterpris ing American citizens within the two years past. It is a marvel to
The newspaper reports receiving a stone battle-axe trophy from Father Genin, who obtained it while visiting Sitting Bull's camp. The editor describes the weapon in detail and relays the claim that such axes played an important role in the defeat of Custer's forces.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Superior Times · 15 June 1878 · page 4
| Genin tells us that such battle-axes are largely used by the Indians, and that they played an important part in the annihilation of the gal lant Custer and his heroic soldiers. We prize the trophy very highly, and thank the doner most kindly lor his remeraberauce of us. Our correspondent, “T. C ,” in an other column, in speaking of the ability of the county to take care of SIO,OOO of floating debt with $25,- 000 of assets in the shape of tax certificates, takes a rather more hopeful view, we think, than the situation warrants.
See moreSee less
If the most the county has been able to secure late ly for its most valuable tax certif icates— those on pine lands—is 25 cents on the dollar, it is pretty safe to assume that the SJO,OOO of tax liens on wild cat town lots and cop per range lands cannot, in the pres ent condition of affairs, and with the best of management, be made —The death of VV. R. Perry, its long time and faithful agent here, has caused the Aetna Insurance Company of Hartford, Conn., to withdraw from Superior, and all policy holders in that company l ave been requested to surrender their policies for cancellation. There is now no insurance company locally represented here. —Honor your engagements. It you promise to meet a man, or do a certain thine: at a certain moment, be ready at the appointed time. If you go out on business, attend strictly to the matter in hand, and then as promptly go about jour own business. Do not stop to tell stories in business hours. It you have a place of business be found there when wanted. —The High trestle bridge on the St. Paul tfc Duluth railroad over the first ravine west of Fondulac is be ing rebuilt, the Duluth Tribune says by the St. P. & D. and N. P. roads jointly. The timber is btdng sawed out by Peyton & Co.,and framed on the outside dock at Duluth. This is probably a beginning of the restor ation of all the high bridges be tween Fondulac and Thomson. —The auditor and treasurer of St. Louis County Minn., inform us that of the tax of $29,000 for 1877 they collected in the last three months $20,300; and collected of delinquent taxes in the same time $20,500, in all $16,800, a pretty good showing for our neighbors over the bay, especially in a time like the present.- —For some reason the Duluth Minnesotian-llerald, now simply the Herald, under its new managers ; failed to reach us until this week. llt is a real live, well editett, high j toned journal, with a dash and spice | that never fails to captivate the reader. The paper reflects credit upon even as old a quill-captain as Judge Parker. We wish it abund ant success. Cole’s mammoth circus which exhibited in Duluth on Wednesday was the great event of the year. The show was a very good one, coming fully up to the advertise ments, and gave general satisfac tion. The big man and woman were there, also the wild animals, the street pageant, and everything as promised. Duluth was crowd ed with people, all out as if for a holiday. It is estimated that fully 4,000 people attended the show in the afternoon and evening. —The Polk County Press proud ly stepped into its nineteenth year a few days ago, enlarged to a 7 column quarto, 50 columns of mat ter, the largest paper in Wisconsin. While wc are willing to accord to Brother Mears, the editor, the 1 greatest of credit for nis enterprise, we can’t help saying his paper is now’ too large, has too much matter in it; I life is too short, and good people | can’t afford to be three fourths of I their time reading the Polk County Press. —Father Genin wdiile in Sitting Bull’s camp did not forget the ed itor of the Superior Times. He brought us from the stronghold of that celebrated chief a very interest ing trophy, in the shape of a stone battle-axe. The implement may be described as an oval shaped granite boulder, about 2 inches in di ameter and about 3 inches long, worn or ground to a point at each end. It is bound to a wooden han dle some 3 feet long by a strip of rawhide which also covers the en tire handle, and to the end of the handle is attached a buffalo hair tassel about two feet long. The weapon in savage hands must be a very formidable one, and capable of doing great execution. Father | Genin tells us that such battle-axes are largely used by the Indians, and that they played an important part in the annihilation of the gal lant Custer and his heroic soldiers. We prize the trophy very highly, and thank the doner most kindly lor his remeraberauce of us. Our correspondent, “T. C ,” in an other column, in speaking of the ability of the county to take care of SIO,OOO of floating debt with $25,- 000 of assets in the shape of tax certificates, takes a rather more hopeful view, we think, than the situation warrants. If the most the county has been able to secure late ly for its most valuable tax certif icates— those on pine lands—is 25 cents on the dollar, it is pretty safe to assume that the SJO,OOO of tax liens on wild cat town lots and cop per range lands cannot, in the pres ent condition of affairs, and with the best of management, be made
A priest, Father Genin, describes Sitting Bull's command over thousands of warriors in Canada, his contempt for the Mounted Police, and his claim he was driven to war by white incursions into the Black Hills. Genin also dismisses as fiction rumors of white men in Sitting Bull's camp and a supposed Custer survivor married to the chief's daughter.
Dakota if they could only be as sured of being let alone. Ho says that Sitting Bull declares that the whites invaded his country, the Black Hills, killed his people and drove him to the war path, and if now the whites will let him alone he will return and be a “good In dian” the remainder cf his days. Father Genin says that the Indians take to themselves great glcry from the Custer massacre, and that their camps are full of trophies of that gallant general'-* ill-fated band of soldiers.
See moreSee less
He says the stories that there are white men in Sitting Bull's camp are mere inventions; that he never heard cf these stories till he earno east amongst the white people, lie laughs heartily at the fiction of “Corporal Martin Ryan, the only survivor of the Custer
The House Committee on Military Affairs agreed to recommend an investigation into the Custer massacre, prompted by a letter from Custer biographer Frederick Whittaker alleging cowardice by Maj. Marcus Reno. Whittaker's letter argues that Custer's death and that of his command was needless and due to subordinates' failures.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 16 June 1878 · page 3
THE COSTER MASSACRE. MaJ. Reno Accused of Cowardlco*-An Inves fixation Probable. Washington, D. C., June 12.—The House Committee on Military Affairs decided to-day to report favorably to the House a resolution di recting an Investigation into the Custer massacre. Mr. Bragg will present a resolution for a sub committee to sit in recess and send for persons and papers. The basis of this action is em braced in a letter addressed by Frederick Whit taker, of Mount Vernon, N. Y., to Mr, Corlett, representing Wyoming Territory, and by him turned over to the Committee on Military Allairs, on whom it seems to have made a very decided impression.
See moreSee less
Whittaker’s letter is as follows: Mount Vernon, Y., May 18, IS7B. —The Hon . H’. ir. Corlett, M. C.~Deab Sir: Having been called on to prepare the biography of the laic Brevet Maj.-Gen. George A. Custer, U. S. A., a great amount of evidence, oral and written, came into mv hands tending to prove that the sacrifice of his life and the lives of hi 5 * immediate com mand at the batlle of the Little I*l2 Horn was use less, and owing to the cowardice of his subordin ates. 1 desire, therefore, 10 ask your attention, and that of Congress through you, to the necessity of ordering an official investigation by a committee of your nonorablc body into the conduct of the United States troops engaged in the battle of the Little Bis Horn, fought June 25. IS7C, otherwise known as the Caster massacre, in which Lieut.-Col. Cus ter, Seventh United States Cavalry, perished, with five companies of the Seventh Cavalry, at the hands of the Indians. The reasons on which 1 found mv request arc ae follows: First— lnformation coming to me from paitici pants in the battle, written and oral, is to the ef fect that gross cowardice was displayed therein by Moj. Marcus A. Kcno, Seventh United States Cav alry, second iu command that day; and that, owing to such cowardice, the orders of Lieut, -Col. Cus ter. commanding officer to iwud Itcno, to execute a certain attack were not obeyed. Thai the failure of this movement, owing to his cowardice and disobedience, caused the de feat of the United States forces ou the day iu question; and that, had Custer’s orders oeen obeyed, the troops would probably have defeated the Indians. That after Mai. Bono’s cowardly flight, he was joined by Capt. F. W. Bouteen, Seventh United Stales Cavalry, with reluforcemcnia which were placed under his order, and that he remained idle with his force while his superior officer was Agut in" against the whole force of the Indians, the battle being within h!s knowledge, the sound of firing audible from his position, aiid his forces oat of immediate danger from the enemy. Tnat the consequence of this second exhibition of cowardice and incompetency was the massacre of Lieut.-Coj. Custer and five companies of the Seventh United States Cavalry.
A writer petitions Congress to open an official investigation into the conduct of U.S. troops at the Little Big Horn, accusing Maj. Reno of cowardice and disobedience of Custer's orders, and Capt. Benteen of idling nearby while Custer's command was destroyed. The author claims Reno's official report falsely blames Custer's tactics for the defeat, when in truth, he argues, Reno's own failures caused the massacre.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 16 June 1878 · page 3
follows: Mount Vernon, Y., May 18, IS7B. —The Hon . H’. ir. Corlett, M. C.~Deab Sir: Having been called on to prepare the biography of the laic Brevet Maj.-Gen. George A. Custer, U. S. A., a great amount of evidence, oral and written, came into mv hands tending to prove that the sacrifice of his life and the lives of hi 5 * immediate com mand at the batlle of the Little I*l2 Horn was use less, and owing to the cowardice of his subordin ates. 1 desire, therefore, 10 ask your attention, and that of Congress through you, to the necessity of ordering an official investigation by a committee of your nonorablc body into the conduct of the United States troops engaged in the battle of the Little Bis Horn, fought June 25.
See moreSee less
IS7C, otherwise known as the Caster massacre, in which Lieut.-Col. Cus ter, Seventh United States Cavalry, perished, with five companies of the Seventh Cavalry, at the hands of the Indians. The reasons on which 1 found mv request arc ae follows: First— lnformation coming to me from paitici pants in the battle, written and oral, is to the ef fect that gross cowardice was displayed therein by Moj. Marcus A. Kcno, Seventh United States Cav alry, second iu command that day; and that, owing to such cowardice, the orders of Lieut, -Col. Cus ter. commanding officer to iwud Itcno, to execute a certain attack were not obeyed. Thai the failure of this movement, owing to his cowardice and disobedience, caused the de feat of the United States forces ou the day iu question; and that, had Custer’s orders oeen obeyed, the troops would probably have defeated the Indians. That after Mai. Bono’s cowardly flight, he was joined by Capt. F. W. Bouteen, Seventh United Stales Cavalry, with reluforcemcnia which were placed under his order, and that he remained idle with his force while his superior officer was Agut in" against the whole force of the Indians, the battle being within h!s knowledge, the sound of firing audible from his position, aiid his forces oat of immediate danger from the enemy. Tnat the consequence of this second exhibition of cowardice and incompetency was the massacre of Lieut.-Coj. Custer and five companies of the Seventh United States Cavalry. Second—' The proof of these facts lies in the evi dence of persons in the service of the United States Government, chiefly in the army, and no power short of Congress can compel their attend ance and protect them from annoyance and perse cntlon If they openly testify to the cowardice ex hibited on the above occasion. Third—' The only official record of the battle now extant is the report written by Maj. Keno, above named, and is, in the main, false and libelous to the memory'of the late Lieut.-ColCaster, in that it represents the defeat of the United States forces on that occason as owing to the division by Coster of his forces in these detachment?, to overman ning his forces, and to ignorance of the enemy’s force,—all serious charges against the capacity of said Custer as an officer; whereas the de feat was really owing to the coward ice and disobedience of said Beno and to the wilful neglect of said Beno and Capt. Bouteen to join battle with the Indians In sup port of their commanding officer when they might have done it, and it was their plain duty so to do. Fourth—' The welfare of the United States army demands that in case of a massacre of a largo party of troops, under circumstances covered with sus picion. It should be officially established where the blame belomrs, to the end that the service may not deteriorate by the retention of cowards. Fifth— -Justice to an officer of the previously unstained record of iLieut. -Col. Custer demands that the accusation under which his memory now tost-*, in the onlyofliclal account of the battle of the Little Big Horn now extant, should be proved or disproved. I have thus given you, as briefly as T can, ray reasons for asking Ibis investigation, end the fact lam confident of being able to prove. .My wit nesses will be all the living officers of the Seventh United States Cavalry who were present at the battle of Jnne *25, including Tflaj. Kcno and Capt. Bouteen,—myself to prove statements of an officer since deceased, made to me a few days before his death,— F, T. Girard, Indian in terpreter to the United States forces; X>r. Porter, of Bismarck, D. T., contract surgeon at the battle in question; Lieut. Gotland, Sixth Infantry; Sorgt. Godman, now of the Signal Service, and others whose names I can find in time for the Com ralltee’H session, should the same be ordered. Trusting, dear sir, that this letter may result in an investigation which shall decide the whole truth about the battle of the 25th of June, 187t>, and the purgation of the service, I aia your obedient serv ant, Frederick Whittaker.
The report notes that Congress may finally investigate Custer's battle and death at Little Big Horn, following accusations by Custer's biographer F. Whittaker against Major Reno. Whittaker claims Reno's disobedience and cowardice caused Custer's disaster and that Reno's official report was false.
Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 17 June 1878 · page 7
Jetzt soll gar endlich noch Custer's Schlacht und Untergang am Little Big Horn vom Congreß untersucht werden. Custer's Biograph und Bewunderer F. Whittaker klagt den (wegen gemeinen Be—
A Catholic missionary, Father Genin, returns from nearly a year spent among Sitting Bull's Sioux and reports on relics from the Custer battle, including a war mare and tomahawks said to have killed numerous soldiers. He also describes plans for a congress uniting multiple Sioux-allied tribes to decide on a mass southward movement driven by the scarcity of buffalo.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 17 June 1878 · page 1
IN SITTING BULL'S CAMP. VISIT OF FATHER GENIN TO THE QUARTERS OF THE GREAT CHIEF. A Congress of All the Sioux--Strength of the Combined Indian Forces.
,y Sitting Bull's camp alone last August andl iacross the line. Father Genin arrived at to up to the fifteenth of May prosecuted his It missionary labors. He has been with the 'r Sioux since 1867 and has personally known i. Sitting Bull ten years. Sitting Bull alls o him his brother, so strong is their friendship. - When Fathtier (enin left him, the old war d rior, who is really only thirty-night years of age, presentedl the bearer of the cross with the war mare that he rode in the Custer mas sacre; also two stone tomahawks of warriors who claimed they had killed, respectively, eleven and twenty-seven soldiers with them . in the Custer disaster. They valued them as great treasures, but their love for their riest
The report describes a planned grand council of Sioux and allied tribes organized by Sitting Bull to decide on uniting and moving south due to dwindling buffalo herds. It details the warriors' ammunition stores and reloading methods, and relays Sitting Bull's own account that the mutilation of Custer's dead resulted from hand-to-hand tomahawk combat rather than squaws.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 17 June 1878 · page 1
and ammunition. RIUI'TPr[Fq oF AMMI7NTTION. Sitting Bull's warriors have a double belt of cartridges about the waist, suspenders of cartridges over the shoulders, crossing in front and hack and even bracelbts aroundi the wrists filled with cartridges. They refill the, Henry centre fire cartridge by reducing the phosphorus from the ends of matches to a paste and putting it in the bottom of the cart ridge, then drying in the sun and afterward filling with powder and ball. The traders on on the Canadian side sell ammunition freely to the hostiles.
See moreSee less
Fatiher Genin says Sitting Bull told him that in the Custer massacre his warriors used their stone tomahawks freoely, and the mutilation attributed to the squaws was the result of a hand-to-hand fight, whereI in the tomahawks were handled as the soldier would have used his sabre if he had it.
Father Genin relays Sitting Bull's message that he wants to return to his own land on the Yellowstone and will not fight unless compelled, warning that pursuit by Gen. Miles could cause 'another Custer massacre.' The priest argues the U.S. should cede the territory north of the Missouri to avoid the worst war in the nation's history.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 17 June 1878 · page 1
STRENGTH OF THE SIOUX. Sitting Bull is strong, and the Father says Americans wrong themselves when they un derestimate his lighting strength. He can't take the United States, but if provoked he can give them many bullets and a very unprofita ble warfare. He has not made up his mind to accept the terms of any reservation propoCi sition. ie wants a land of his own. He will c first test the United States on that point, and D accept a reservation as the last extremity, I) which he does not conslidler near at hand. K
A brief dispatch from Washington notes that Major Reno desires an official investigation into the Custer massacre, implicitly into his own conduct during the battle. The item appears among other short capital news items with no further detail given.
New-York Tribune · 18 June 1878 · page 1
28F informed about the investigation. Glover's assistants tried to buy of an innecent man for $1,000. Major Reno desires an investigation of the Custer massacre, Two District Commissioners have been appointed. : —
Major Reno wrote to Rep. Banning, chairman of the House Military Affairs Committee, asking that an investigation into his conduct during the Custer massacre be ordered as soon as possible. He stated he wished to vindicate his character against malicious reports he believed originated from Frederick Whittaker.
A DEMAND BY MAJOR RENO. HE ASKS BANNING THAT HIS CONDUCT IN THE CUSTER FIGHT BE INVESTIGATED.
18th instant that your committee had “ decided to reort favorably to tne House a resolution directing an nvestigation into the Custer massacre, and that a resolution for a sub-committee to sit in recess and send for
Among a roundup of domestic news items, the dispatch notes that Major Reno has demanded an official investigation into the Custer Massacre. No further detail is given on the nature of the demand.
New-York Tribune · 18 June 1878 · page 4
THE NEWS THIS MORNING.
Department. ==== Mr, Josiah Dent and 8. L. Phelps ‘ave - mommnated $0 be District Commissioners, =——= The Poiter Committee eross-examined Mr. Clarke, Governor Kellogg's private secretary, yesterday, === Major Reno has demanded an investigation of the Custer
Major Marcus Reno writes to the House Military Affairs Committee requesting an immediate investigation into charges against him stemming from the Custer massacre, prompted by a resolution from Wyoming delegate Corlett based on a letter by Frederick Whittaker. Reno says he has long suffered malicious rumors and wants the chance to vindicate his record.
The New York Herald · 18 June 1878 · page 7
THE CUSTER MASSACRE. MAJOR RENO ASKS AN EARLY INVESTIGATION OF THE CHARGES AGAINST HIM.
Kijhitt House, Washington, June 17, 1873. Hon. 1L If. Banning, M. C., Cbuiruiau Committee on Military AQairs:? Sm?HavtOK read in tbo New York San of tbo 13th lost, that your committee bad decided to report luvor ably to tbo House a resolution directing an investiga tion into tbe Custer marsucre, and tbat a resolu tion lor a nib commute to ait In roccsj and tend lor pvraotis uud papers would be presented, whlon action was bated upon a letter addreseou to Hon. W. W. Corbetl, delegate irotu Wyoming, by oue Frederick Wblttakor.
See moreSee less
1 beg leave to lulorm you tbat 1 buve couie to Woablugtou to czpreas jairsonally to your cuniiuillee my earnest desire ibat tbe contemplated investigation be ordered as roon as praclicuUle. Duriug tbo last two years 1 have beeu compelled to sudor the circula tion of various malignant reports concerning tula aflair aud myself oinanutinx, it is |ircsumeu, Irom tbo same irresponsible source. This bomg tbe ilrst time I but their author, perhaps emboldened by my slleuce, bus ventured to give tbew duQaito shape, 1 rospcct luily demand that 1 tnuy have tuts opportunity to vindicate my cbaractor and record, which have beeu thus wickodly assailed. 1 am, Sto., M. A. UK NO, Major seventh Cavalry.
The House Committee on Military Affairs has delayed reporting a resolution calling for investigation into the Custer massacre, partly because members are reluctant to take on the task. Major Reno, whose conduct at the battle was criticized by biographer Frederick Whittaker, has written demanding an investigation to clear his name, under the mistaken impression that only Whittaker supports such an inquiry.
The Sun · 18 June 1878 · page 2
THE CUSTER MASSACRE. DISCUSSION AS TO INVESTIGATION OF THE CHARGES AGAINST HIM
TUB i tTBB w iss.H HK la.,r Ken,. Desaaaillan aa lavastlsa4loa af tini harass Bgalaal Hint, Wahiuni.Tiin, June 1". There has boon some delay in reporting from the Committee on Military Affairs the resolution directing an In vostlgatlon of the cinumatanees oi the Custer massacre, duo partly to tho pressure of other public business and partly to tim faet that it has been somewhat difficult to iimi thno mem bers of the commlttoe who an willing to under take tim lab ir of conducting tim Inquiry during the incoming summer, a totter demanding an Investigation has beon addressed by Major li'-ii".
See moreSee less
whoso conduct at tim battle was seriously Impugned by Frederick Wltlttakor, Due ler's biographer, to p n. Panning, Major Reno ovldoutly Inbow under the mfaatipnhenslon iu this hater that tim only perai u imklng or appr ivlngtite Inveatlgntlou is Mr. W lilttaker, Mr. vYhlttsksr's lettr to Cor h ti. iclegnie froin v yum lug, as iranamlti dhy the latter to tho House Comuiltlea on Mllllnrv tffalrs. wss acompunhul b a letter from for loit . saying that a was th" general Impression of ins "oii-iii .n-nts that tin' nlr umatuuees w .1 ., i .'f.-ren -e to Custer a death hail nevei been properly atab'd, ami that sticli oflbial llivesll
The House Committee on Military Affairs agreed to recommend a congressional investigation into the Custer massacre, prompted by a letter from Custer biographer Frederick Whittaker alleging cowardice and disobedience by Major Marcus Reno. The letter, addressed to Representative Corlett of Wyoming, was forwarded to the committee and reportedly made a strong impression.
Daily Globe · 19 June 1878 · page 1
THE CUSTER MASSACRE.
WHITTAKER'S LETTER is as follows: MOUNT VERNON, N. Y., May 18,1878.HON. W. W. CORLETT, M. CDEAR Sra Having been called on to prepare the biography of the late Brevet Maj. Gen. George A. CuRter, S.A., a great amount of evidence,^oral and written, came into my hands, tending to prove that the sacrifice of his life, and the lives of his im mediate command, at the battle of the Little Big Horn, was useless, and owing to the cow ardice of his subordinates. 1 desire, there fore, to ask your attention, and that of Con gress, through you, to the necessity of ordering an official investigation, by a committee of your honorable body, into the conduct ot the United States troops engaged in the battle of the Little Big Horn, fought on June 25, 1876, otherwise known as the Custer massacre, in which Lieut.
See moreSee less
Col. Custer, 7th United States cavalry, perished with five companies of the 7th cavalry at the hands of the Indians. The reasons on whioh I found my request are as follows: 1. Information coming to me from partici pants in the battle, written and oral, is to the effect that gross cowardice was displayed there in by Maj. Marcus A. Reno, 7th United Sttaes cavalry, second in command on that day, and that owing to such cowardice the orders of Lieut. Col. Custer, commanding officer, to said Reno to execute a certain attack who never obeyed that the failure of this movement, ow ing to this cowardice and disobedience, caused the defeat of the United States forces on the day in question, and that had Custer's orders been obeyed the troops would probably have defeated the Indians that after Mai. Reno's cowardly fight he was joined bv Capt. F. W. Benteen 7th United States cavalry, with rein forcements which were placed under his orders and that he remained idle with this force while his superior officer was fighting against the whole force of the Indians, the battle being within his knowledge, the sound of the firing audible trom his position, and his forces out of immediate danger from the enemy. In conse quence of this second exhibition of cowardice and incompetency was the massacre of Lieut. Col. Custer and five companies of the 7th Unit ed States cavalry. 2. The proof of these facts lies in the evi dence of persons in the service of the United States government, chiefly in the army, and no power short of Congress can compel their attendance and protect them from annoyance and persecution if they openly testify to the cowardice exhibited on the above occasion. 3. The only official record of the battle now extant is the report written by Major Reno, above named, and is in the main false and libellous to the memory of the late Lieutenant Col. Custer, the commanding officer of said Reno at the above mentioned battle, in that it represents the defeat of the United States forces on that occasion, owing to the division by Custer of his forces into these detai n ments, to overmanning his foices, and to ig norance of the enemy's force, all serious char ges against the capacity of said Custer as an officer, whereas the defeat was really owing to the cowardice nud disobedience of said Reno, and to the willful neglect of said Reno and Captain Bsnteen to join in the battle with the Indians in support of their commanding offi cer when they might have done it, and it was their plain duty so to do. 4. The welfare of the United States army demands that in the case of a massacre of a large party of troops under circumstances covered with suspicion, it should be officially established where the blame belongs, to the end that the service may not deteriorate by the retention of cow ards. 5. Justice to an officer of the previously unstained record of Lieutenant Colonel Custer demands that the accusation under which his memory now rests in the only official account of the battle of the Little Big Horn now extant should be proved or disproved. I have thus given you as briefly as I can my reasons for asking this investigation, and the facts that I am confident of being able to prove. My witnesses will be all the living officers of the 7th United States cavalry who where present at the battle of June 25, includ ing Major Reno and Captain Benteen, myself to prove the statements of an officer, since de ceased, made to me a few days before his death, F. T. Girard, Indian interpreter to the United States forceb Dr. Porter, of Bismarck, Dakota Territory, contract surgeon at the battle in question Lieutenant Garland, Gth infantry Sergeant Godman, now of the signal service, and others whose names I can find in time for the committee's session, should the same be ordered. Trusting, dear sir, that this letter may result in an investigation which shall de clare the whole truth about the battle of the 25th of June, 1876, and the purgation of the seivice, I am your obedient servant, FREDERICK WHITTAKER. W. W. CORLETT accompanies this communication by a letter to Gen. Banning, chairman of the commit tee on military affairs, in which he says: I desire to say to you that the immediate occa sion on my part for calling for the investiga tion contemplated by said resolution, is a litter addressed to me by Frederick Whitta ker, of Mount Vernon, N. Y., which the reasons for such an inquiry are stated. I transmit the letter to you with the statement that I am informed that Mr. Whittaker is the gentleman who is engaged in the prepa ration of a biography of the late Gen. Cus ter, and is in possession of much informa tion relating to the subject matter of the proposed, inquiry, and is a gentleman of honor and integrity. I also desire to say that in the West THERE IS A STBONO SUSPICION
A correspondent writes to a government official demanding a Congressional investigation into Major Reno's alleged cowardice and failure to support Custer at the Little Bighorn. He argues Reno's official report unfairly blames Custer's tactics for the defeat, when in fact Reno's and Benteen's refusal to engage caused the massacre, and lists witnesses willing to testify.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Globe · 19 June 1878 · page 1
WHITTAKER'S LETTER is as follows: MOUNT VERNON, N. Y., May 18,1878.HON. W. W. CORLETT, M. CDEAR Sra Having been called on to prepare the biography of the late Brevet Maj. Gen. George A. CuRter, S.A., a great amount of evidence,^oral and written, came into my hands, tending to prove that the sacrifice of his life, and the lives of his im mediate command, at the battle of the Little Big Horn, was useless, and owing to the cow ardice of his subordinates. 1 desire, there fore, to ask your attention, and that of Con gress, through you, to the necessity of ordering an official investigation, by a committee of your honorable body, into the conduct ot the United States troops engaged in the battle of the Little Big Horn, fought on June 25, 1876, otherwise known as the Custer massacre, in which Lieut.
See moreSee less
Col. Custer, 7th United States cavalry, perished with five companies of the 7th cavalry at the hands of the Indians. The reasons on whioh I found my request are as follows: 1. Information coming to me from partici pants in the battle, written and oral, is to the effect that gross cowardice was displayed there in by Maj. Marcus A. Reno, 7th United Sttaes cavalry, second in command on that day, and that owing to such cowardice the orders of Lieut. Col. Custer, commanding officer, to said Reno to execute a certain attack who never obeyed that the failure of this movement, ow ing to this cowardice and disobedience, caused the defeat of the United States forces on the day in question, and that had Custer's orders been obeyed the troops would probably have defeated the Indians that after Mai. Reno's cowardly fight he was joined bv Capt. F. W. Benteen 7th United States cavalry, with rein forcements which were placed under his orders and that he remained idle with this force while his superior officer was fighting against the whole force of the Indians, the battle being within his knowledge, the sound of the firing audible trom his position, and his forces out of immediate danger from the enemy. In conse quence of this second exhibition of cowardice and incompetency was the massacre of Lieut. Col. Custer and five companies of the 7th Unit ed States cavalry. 2. The proof of these facts lies in the evi dence of persons in the service of the United States government, chiefly in the army, and no power short of Congress can compel their attendance and protect them from annoyance and persecution if they openly testify to the cowardice exhibited on the above occasion. 3. The only official record of the battle now extant is the report written by Major Reno, above named, and is in the main false and libellous to the memory of the late Lieutenant Col. Custer, the commanding officer of said Reno at the above mentioned battle, in that it represents the defeat of the United States forces on that occasion, owing to the division by Custer of his forces into these detai n ments, to overmanning his foices, and to ig norance of the enemy's force, all serious char ges against the capacity of said Custer as an officer, whereas the defeat was really owing to the cowardice nud disobedience of said Reno, and to the willful neglect of said Reno and Captain Bsnteen to join in the battle with the Indians in support of their commanding offi cer when they might have done it, and it was their plain duty so to do. 4. The welfare of the United States army demands that in the case of a massacre of a large party of troops under circumstances covered with suspicion, it should be officially established where the blame belongs, to the end that the service may not deteriorate by the retention of cow ards. 5. Justice to an officer of the previously unstained record of Lieutenant Colonel Custer demands that the accusation under which his memory now rests in the only official account of the battle of the Little Big Horn now extant should be proved or disproved. I have thus given you as briefly as I can my reasons for asking this investigation, and the facts that I am confident of being able to prove. My witnesses will be all the living officers of the 7th United States cavalry who where present at the battle of June 25, includ ing Major Reno and Captain Benteen, myself to prove the statements of an officer, since de ceased, made to me a few days before his death, F. T. Girard, Indian interpreter to the United States forceb Dr. Porter, of Bismarck, Dakota Territory, contract surgeon at the battle in question Lieutenant Garland, Gth infantry Sergeant Godman, now of the signal service, and others whose names I can find in time for the committee's session, should the same be ordered. Trusting, dear sir, that this letter may result in an investigation which shall de clare the whole truth about the battle of the 25th of June, 1876, and the purgation of the seivice, I am your obedient servant, FREDERICK WHITTAKER. W. W. CORLETT accompanies this communication by a letter to Gen. Banning, chairman of the commit tee on military affairs, in which he says: I desire to say to you that the immediate occa sion on my part for calling for the investiga tion contemplated by said resolution, is a litter addressed to me by Frederick Whitta ker, of Mount Vernon, N. Y., which the reasons for such an inquiry are stated. I transmit the letter to you with the statement that I am informed that Mr. Whittaker is the gentleman who is engaged in the prepa ration of a biography of the late Gen. Cus ter, and is in possession of much informa tion relating to the subject matter of the proposed, inquiry, and is a gentleman of honor and integrity. I also desire to say that in the West THERE IS A STBONO SUSPICION
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · Mifflintown, Pa.
This item recounts the biography of Lieutenant De Rudio, a Seventh Cavalry officer who survived two days evading hostile Sioux after Little Bighorn. It also details his earlier life as an exiled Austrian army officer and Italian revolutionary conspirator involved in a plot against Napoleon III.
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · 19 June 1878 · page 1
NO. 25. A Remarkable Career. ' The following remarkable sketch of the career of Lieutenant De Rudio of Custer's old Seventh Cavalry, now sta tioned at Bismarck, W. T., is told by a
A miscellany item notes the rapid settlement of the Yellowstone valley, citing a town of 1,000 at General Miles's 1876 camp on Tongue River. It states that the Custer battlefields are now occupied by farmers and that Sitting Bull's former territory is peacefully settled by pioneers.
Watertown Republican · 19 June 1878 · page 6
One of the marvels of this age of emigration and enterprise is the rapid settlement of the Yellowstone valley. At the point on Tongue river where General Miles encamped in 1876, there is now a town with a population of 1,000. The battlefields of Custer and his men are occupied by farmers, and the country from which Sitting Bull was driven is in the peaceful possession of the pioneers of civilization.
A letter dated June 17, 1878 reports that an officer (implicitly Reno) has come to Washington urging Congress to proceed with its planned investigation into the Custer massacre. He states he has endured malicious rumors for two years, originating from a letter by Frederick Whittaker to a Wyoming delegate, and demands the chance to clear his name.
The Rock Island Argus · 20 June 1878 · page 2
Ebbitt Hotob, Washington, 'Jane 17, 1878. Sir: Having read in the The New York Sun of the 13th inst, that yoar committee had deoided to reDort favorably to the House a resolution directing an investiga tion into the Custer massacre, and that a resolution for a sub-committee to sit in recess and send for persons and papers would be presented, which action was based upon a letter addressed to the Hon, VV. V. Corlett. delegate from Wyoming, by one Frederick Wbittaker, I beg leave to inform you that I have come to Wash ington to express personally to your com mittee my earnest desire that the contemplated investigation be ordered as soon as practicable.
See moreSee less
During the last two years I have been compelled to suffer the circu lation of various malignant reports con cerning this affair and myself, emanating, it is presumed from the same irrespansible source. This being the first time that their author, perhaps emboldened by my silence, has ventured to give them definite shape, I respectfully demand that I may have this opportunity to vindicate my chacacter ard record which have been thus wickedly assailed.
The passage discusses public shock over Custer's defeat and the atrocities committed, with speculation about how an experienced officer could be led into such a trap. It reports that a congressional investigation was demanded after Major Reno was accused of failing to support Custer, a charge made by Custer's biographer Frederick Whittaker and relayed by Wyoming delegate Mr. Corlett, with Reno responding to defend his honor.
The Rock Island Argus · 20 June 1878 · page 2
with having failed .to do his duty. This charge has been specifically made by Iredenck Whittaker the biographer of Custer. Mr. Corlett, the delegate io the
General Reno has written to Congressman Banning, chairman of the House Military Affairs Committee, requesting a formal investigation into the Custer massacre. Reno seeks to clear his name from what he calls false and unjust accusations regarding his actions during the battle.
2,700. CIRCULATION EMPKnoE William, of Germany, is lowly recovering from hie Injuries. I U! " Tns Berlin Congress is nt work to try and nettle the Turkey question. It is complication of diflicult arrangement for the European Towers. BLAiNistook occasion the other luy to ay that Packard's title to the Governor ship of Louisiana was just as Rood as Hayes's title to be Tre ideut. No love between Hayes and Blaine. John Sherman must have thought when he learned that the workingiuen of Washington were on the steps of the Capitol asking relief.
See moreSee less
He miint have thought of the Generals and the army, and thanked God. Of seventy-five meetings of operatives held in Lancashire, England, on Mon day, fifty concluded to go to work, and it is eaid the mills will all soon resume at the reduced rates of wages. The market for cotton goods seems terribly stagnant. Gin. Reno, of Custer massacre fame, has written a letter to General Banning, Chairman of the Committee on Military Affairs of the House, asking an inveHti pttion of that massacre, in order that he may vindicate himself from what he terms the false and unjuBt aspersions that have been made upon bis character in connection with the last Custer fight, Tn Republicans in Congress succeed ed in the attempt to defraud Louisiana and Florida out of their electoral votes, honestly chosen for Tilden. The Re publican Senator and Republican Con gressman from Oregon aided in the con tamination of the Louisiana and Florida infamy, and the people of that State have chosen a Democratic Congressman and a Democratic Legislature that will elect a Democratic U. S. Senator. Mr. Burchard's declaration that neither House has jurisdiction to revise the actionofthe Congress that put Hayes in cannot mean that the House of Reps resentatives has not authority to impeach Mr. Hayes, because the sole power of impeachment is vested by the plain let ter of the Coustitution in the House of Representatives. The House cannot divest itself of that power. Every mem ber has taken an oath to support the Constitution, and would perjure himself by disclaiming the power vested in him by that instrument. Congressman Hewitt, of New York, who voted against Burchard's resolution as to the President's title, but, voted for the report of the Judiciary Committee, explains his course. The explanation is only important because he is presum ed to voice Governor Tilden's senti ments. He says, in a speech printed in the Congressional Record : So far as the question of title is con cerned, I should have hesitation in vot ing for the resolution offered by the gen tleman from Illinois, Mr. Burchard, hut when he declared that possible action of this House, orany future House of Uep resentatives may be revolutionary, I can not bring myself to acknowledge by my tote that such a contingency is porsililn. The House expresses the direct voice of the people; and, in a country where the people aro sovereign, it is a contradic tion to assert that revolution is possible through the Representatives of the peo ple. It seems to me little short of trea son to ray own conscience, treason to the memory of the host of martyrs who, from the time of James I. to William HI. fought the battles of human freedom for the British people, for us and for man kind, to tolerate the idea that the people through their representatives can organ ise revolution iu any contingency what ever. I shall, therefore, vote against the resolution of the gentleman from Il linois, but shall vote for the resoiution which I understand will be presently of fered by the Judiciary Committee, de claring the title of the President can not be successfully assailed, and that Con gress can not confer power upon any Court to try his title to the high office which confers no honor to the present occupant. ASSASSINATION IN JAPAN. Minister OViibo, of Japan, was mur dered on the 14ih of May, about 8 o'clock in the morning. lie was on his way to attend the council, and j ist before reach ing the palace gate, an open space near one of the city moats, hi" carriage was topped by a band of armed assassins, six in number. They first killed one of the horses and the coachman, and then fell upon the Minister, who was unarm 4 ed and helpless, and hacked him almost to pieces. The murderers, after wash ing their hands, walked deliberately to the palace gate, and surrendered them selves to the Sergeant in charge. This crime was committed iu the heart of a city (Tokio) containing near one million population, and a police force of over 12 000 men. Thr Michigan Republican Convention was an exceedingly harmonious affair, and everybody oui that way seems to be pleased with its action. The cause may be found in the fact that there were no pesky Hayes men in the Convention to throw firebrands and otherwise break Bp the good feeling that prevailed. Now if the Hayes men had only stayed away from the Cincinnati Convention every thing would have been lovely in this 8tate, too. We always thought Michi gan was a very sensible sort of a 8tate. Cohmbui JHtpatch. Gsif. Fbihokt, who has recently been appointed Governor of Arizona, has not been a resident of the Pacific slope since Xbt time that he made the historical peech in which occurred the statement : "I came to this conntry without a cent, 0ad I now leave it owing $2,000,000." He tetorns to the scene of his early adven tures, however, as poor as when he first wentthere, with a large amount of ex perience in addition. The veteran editor, John Hopley, has at last been turned out of the Bucyrus poetoflice. John has been holding on to that position like grim death for a lorgtime, in spite of the efforts ol local politicians to have him removed, but his enemies have proven too much for him, ' and lte has received the grand bounce. Gone to meet Peter Cuneo I Columbia Dirpalch.
Delegate Corlett explains his resolution calling for a military committee investigation into the conduct of U.S. troops at Little Big Horn, prompted by a letter from Frederick Whittaker who was writing a Custer biography and alleged facts had been concealed. Major Reno welcomes the investigation as a chance to rebut charges made against him regarding the battle.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 20 June 1878 · page 2
Custer massacre is to be a subject of investi gation, as it will enable him to meet and rc el the charges that have been made against liim in connection with this afiair.
The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · and 1 other paper
Biographer Frederick Whittaker claims to have found proof that Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn resulted from Major Reno's cowardice and disobedience, and that Reno's official report was falsified to cover this up. The House Committee on Military Affairs has responded by deciding to investigate the matter.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The True Northerner · 21 June 1878 · page 3
Mr. Frederick Wiiittaker, a gentle man who is engaged in writing a biogra phy of Gen. Custer, has written a letter in which he states that he has made dis coveries proving beyond a doubt that the massacre of Custer and his troops at the Little Big Horn battle was entirely due to cowardice and disobedienco of orders on the part of Gen. Marcus A. Reno, and that after the fight Reno wrote a false and libelous report of it, which now constitutes the only official record of the affair. The statement of Whittaker having been brought to the notice of the House Committee on Mili tary Affairs, the committee has very properly decided to report a resolution for the investigation of the massacre.
See moreSee less
The act charged against Reno is the most heinous of which an officer could be guilty, and if the charge is proved it will reveal a degree of cowardice and treaohery almost unparalleled in the his tory of arms.
The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis. · 20 June 1878
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Frederick Whittaker, writing a biography of Custer, charges that Custer was sacrificed due to the cowardice of Major Reno. The House military affairs committee plans to recommend a formal investigation during the recess.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 21 June 1878 · page 1
Frederick Whittaker of Mount Vernon, N. Y., who Is writing the life of the late Gen Custer, has made specific charges, to the effect that this gallant officer was sacrificed to the SPRINGFIELD, MASS., FRIDAY, JUNE 21, 1878. Ohio railroad, Recorder Hackett of New York, Max Strakosch, Maurice Grau, Clara lonise Kellogg, Mrs Lester Wallack, Mme Modjeska, Rev Dr John Hall, and Bishops Clarkson, Howe, Littlejohn and Scarborough, who go to the. Lam beth Episcopal conference. About 150,000 bushels of grain was shipped. Sixteen clergymen, including Bishop O’Reilly, Vicar General Doane and Drs Storrs and Tiffany, sailed for Europe Wednesday.
A news brief reports that General Marcus Reno has formally requested an investigation into his conduct during the Battle of the Little Bighorn. This item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news items.
The Aegis & Intelligencer · 21 June 1878 · page 3
BEL AIR, FRIDAY, JUNE 21,1878. THE NEWS. —'The Emperor William is getting well of the wounds inflicted by Nobbing. —General Reno asks for an investigation of bis conduct in the late Custer fight. —Mrs. Myra Clark Gaines has been nil j udged owner of the town of Kennerville, La. —A bill lias passed both Houses of Con gress for the re-organization of the Life-Sav ing Service. —The schooner Kotben, with the Frank lin-Arctic search party, sailed from New York on Wednesday.
The report describes how towns, schools, churches, and farms have rapidly developed in the Yellowstone valley region in the two years since Custer's command was wiped out there. It also notes army officials fear current forces are inadequate against hostile Indians and will rely on frontiersmen, who were previously disparaged after aiding against the Nez Perce.
The Benton Record · 21 June 1878 · page 2
C But a trifling periodot time has , elapsed since the saddest, bloodiest of our Indian tragedies was enacta ed-the massacre of the chivalric Custer and his command-and yet 1 a marvelous change has been alI ready effected throughout the valI
A satirical editorial notes that Sitting Bull, now sheltering in Canada after the Custer massacre, has reportedly offered his Sioux warriors' services to the British Government out of gratitude. The piece jokes that the U.S. could profit by allowing foreign nations to recruit American "savages" as mercenaries.
The Benton Record · 21 June 1878 · page 2
is. per exceeding the supply of paper 3making material. Brave men are always grateful. ul. le No one questions the bravery of Sitting Bull since the Custer mas 18* d sacre, and he has given expression on
Father J. B. M. Genin, a missionary who lived among the Sioux since 1867, reports returning from Sitting Bull's camp after a prolonged stay. He relays Sitting Bull's wish to return peacefully to the Yellowstone country and warns that General Miles's pursuit could provoke another Custer-style disaster.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 21 June 1878 · page 4
SITTING BULL.
Cheyenne, June 19, 1878. je2o-tf constituting the Troubadour combina A new lot of Suita, very latest style, tion. are at tbe Inter Ocean. A full line of white vests at Polack’s, _ P*e cent, leas than they could be Frank Beaucaire, Esq., the gentle 16th street, Masonic Temple. m2otf tonCht for at the beginning of the seamanly clerk at Hurlbut Broa, leaves Refrigerators, Ice chests, water cool this morning for Hurlbut Bros.’ ranch Percale Suits from S2.SO ers, etc., at Fr E. Warren’s, on Pole creek, where he will make It my29-tf 376 A 378 Sixteenth street.
See moreSee less
his home for two or three weeks. and Printed Piques, a large Paints, oils and heavy dregs we are Light weight case suits at a bargain Bob Shades from 20 cents up. selling at leas than cost and freight. at Masonic Temple. m2stf ' IHnmmai nuts lower than the lowest mjl9-tf Addons ft Glover. ad>y carriages, perambulators, etc., JOttJN, 6,000 burlap and gunny sacks for sale at * T. E. Warren’a, ***** 960 Sixteenth street cheap at Mann’s, 16th street m2B-03t | my29-tf 376 ft 378 Sixteenth street. vj BITTING BULL. *s latsresflsg ttsry by a Maslaaary. The noted mtationary of the Sioux nation, Father J. B. M. Genin, has ar rived at Bismarck from hia prolonged visit to the hostile* across the line. Father Genin arrived at Sitting BoD’s camp alone last August, and up to the 15th of May prosecuted his missionary labors. He has been with the Sioux since 1867 and has personally known Sitting Bull ten years. Sitting Bull calls him his brother, so strong is their friendship. When Father Genin left him the old warrior, who is reaUy only 38 years of age, presented the bearer of the cross with the war mare that he rode in the Custer massacre; also two stone tomahawks of warriors who clam ed they had killed respectively eleven and twenty-seven soldiers with them in the Custer disaster. They valued them as great treasures, but their love for their priest forced the sacrifice’ of part ing with them. Father Genin’s confi dential and religious relations with Sit ting Bull and his hand, some of whom he instructed in the Catholic faith and baptized, make him the most important witness who has ever been in or near Bitting Bull’s tent.
Father Genin, a Catholic missionary who had lived among Sitting Bull's band since the prior year, reports from Bismarck that the Sioux leader is not seeking war but wants peace and access to buffalo for food. He describes a planned conference of allied tribes to negotiate for provisions from the Canadian government, with force as a last resort if refused.
Feliciana Sentinel · 22 June 1878 · page 1
SITTING BULL NOT ON THE WAR-PATH -- IS READY TO TAKE FOOD WHEREVER HE CAN GET IT -- WANTS PEACE AND BUFFALO
CAN GrET IT--WAxNrs PiEACE AND BUFFALO. BlISIAIiK, D. T., June G.-'Father GenN in, the French Catholic miissiona.iy, who has been planting missions among the Si oux tribes since 1867, and spreading the Gospel by. personal ministration among D the tribes who have never accepteu a res ervation, has just come in by wagon from ri a visit to the Sioux hostiles across the i( line. lie has been with Sitting Bull and his baud since last August, instructing tl hem in the Catholic faith and haptizingc: a few. He has known Sitting Bull as an ti Indianu friend for ten years, and is in 1P
A missionary named Genin describes meeting Sitting Bull on the Canadian side and relays the chief's account of the Little Bighorn battle, including claims that warriors lured Custer's men toward empty-saddled ponies before attacking their flank and rear with tomahawks. The piece also reports on tribal leadership structure, Sitting Bull's demeanor, and warns that Major Walsh should be wary of the Indians' feelings toward him.
Feliciana Sentinel · 22 June 1878 · page 1
not light unless he was compelled to. I' Genin says they will have to come b south of the line for buffalo. The priest " was with the three hundred warriors who y caused the scare last winter. They hunt11 edl bullffalo nearly down to Fort Peck, but v had no other mrotive in coming. There n was an invasion, as Geun. Miles at the time claimed, and reported to military headquarters, but not a hostile one. They t will come again, and may havo to come in large bodies, and occupy what is 1 known as the M1ilk river country.
See moreSee less
If our t soldiers keep south of the Missouri there will be no collision. Sitting Bull wants ' peace and buflalo. Genia says there will 1 be no war if we act . i:;cly and let themo have tLe Milk river country. If we try to keelp thent out of the United States t entirely there will be bloodshed, as the Indians must live. They are abundant1 ly supplied with arms and amunuition. While preparing for peace they have been filling their cartridge belts. Geniu reports Sitting Bull the head of the Wsarriors, and no dispito as to his 1 rank. Black Moon is chief of the nation, but has nothing to do with Sitting Bull's comuads ltasas general of the aarnty. Ieo says he is 38 years of age, in the prime of life, iintelligent, close-Inouthed, and shrewed. lie can talk French andl a lit tle English. Genin knows this because lhe has talked with hint in those laugiia ges. Genii talked with him in Sioux, as Sitting Bull hates English and doesn't fancy French. 11i gave Genin his war po ny, the one lhe rode is tihe Custer light. The ponyi has one scar on his neck frout a wound received in that battle. In, his conversation with Sitting Bull as to that fight, the warrior told him they enticed Custer's men to charge down on a large inuller of empty lrepeers, and theu fell on -their rear and flank. They killed many soldiers with their stone tomalhtwks, knocking them ftom tlheir horses alnd then finishing them by a tap on tile head. Tihe I supposed mutilation was tihe result of the hand-to-hand light wshen the Indians dis
The St. Louis Times notes the rapid settlement of the Yellowstone Valley, including a town of nearly 1,000 near Gen. Miles's 1876 encampment. It observes that Custer's former battlefields are now farmed and the land from which Sitting Bull was driven is peacefully settled by pioneers.
The Daily Intelligencer · 22 June 1878 · page 4
St. Louis Tune*: One of the marvels of this age of emigration and enterprise is the rapid settlement of the Yellow stone Valley. At the point on Tongue Kiver where Gen. Miles encamped in 1870, there is a town with a population of nearly 1,000. Tho battle fields of Custer and his men are occupied by farmers, and the couatry from which Sitting Hull was driven is in the peace ful possession of the pioneers of a civi lization against which such tremendous tragedies os the Custer Massacre count »-> nothing.
A partisan letter-writer, signing as 'Old-Fashioned Democrat,' argues against reducing the standing army by citing ongoing Indian hostilities on the frontier, invoking the 'Custer Massacre' as evidence of a dangerous, powerful enemy. The piece is primarily a political argument about Reconstruction-era Democratic policy, using the 1876 battle as a rhetorical touchstone two years later.
West Virginia Argus · 22 June 1878 · page 2
FROM AN OLD DEMOCRAT
Seneion. By 38 to 7 tbe Beoate in 8t Mathews Ca*ho! c Church eetded that be deserved a pension. The cstsfa que was draped w th the - Aegwer* Peruvian flag, covered with fl >wer» l •a * whipped; and our own noble State among the number. Our excel lent Governor acknowledged that he, as comm-toder in chief of the State force*, was not able to put d^owu the rebellion aud asked the Federal troops to aid him iu the The present threatened mi lore a k and violence .# heller or_ gatmsd aud much more formidable than the one through which we have just passed.
See moreSee less
But, to say nothing ol our internal strife, have we not a savage enemy on our Western plains more powerlul than the oneltnat per petrared the "Custer Massacre? ’—
Charles Welch, who served under Reno at the battle, accuses the officer of disobeying orders and deliberately abandoning Custer to be destroyed. Welch claims there was existing ill-will between Reno and Custer.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 25 June 1878 · page 1
Ciias. Welch, who was with Gen. iieno at the battle of Little Big Horn, accuses that officer of disobedience of orders, and purposely leaving Gen. Cus ter to be destroyed. Welch avers that that there was ill-will existing between Reno and Custer.
The item claims two white men are present in Sitting Bull's band: a disgraced former U.S. Army major named Pease who has lived with the Indians since 1861, and John O'Brien, said to have been captured at the time of the Custer fight and adopted into the tribe with a squaw wife, though kept under watch to prevent escape. It presents this as established fact about survivors from the Little Bighorn engagement.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Batesville Guard · 27 June 1878 · page 4
discharged -in disgrace from the Fourth Infantry in 1861 while stationed in Kan sas, since which time he has been living with the Indians, with whom he has completely identified himself The oth er man is named John O'Brien and was taken prisoner at the time of the Custer massacre. He had been adopted into
Custer biographer Frederick Whittaker claims new evidence shows Custer and his men were sacrificed due to Major Reno's cowardice and inaction during the battle. He calls for a Congressional investigation into the conduct of the battle.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Yorkville Enquirer · 27 June 1878 · page 2
? The centennial anniversary celebration j of the evacution of Valley Forge by the Continental army, was celebrated on Wednesday i of last week, by a grand military display, j The troops were reviewed by Gov. Hartranft , and Gen. Hancock. Thirty thousand people j were present. ? Barnum says that lorn Thurao is "a great, big fellow now," weighing eighty : pounds, and forty-one years old. He and his wife, with General Grant, Jr., and his wife, live in Middleborough, Mass. Mrs. Grant is the dwarf known as Minnie Warren, j and Barnum is authority for the statement; that she will soon be a mother.
See moreSee less
? Frederick Whittaker, the biographer of j Gen. Custer, asserts that evidence, oral and written, has corne into his hands proving that Custer and his men were sacrificed by the 1
This roundup of domestic news notes that Maj. Reno has written to the House Committee on Military Affairs demanding a formal investigation into charges that his failure to relieve Gen. Custer contributed to the massacre. The item appears amid unrelated items on missionaries, an Arctic search expedition, and a Chicago hanging.
Canton Register · 28 June 1878 · page 2
DOMESTIC.
Maj. Reno, of the cavalry force, whose failure to relieve Gen. Custer at the time of the massacre provoked .charges of cowardice, has written to the Chairman of the House Committee on Military Affairs, demand
The report claims two white men live in Sitting Bull's camp: a disgraced former U.S. Army officer and John O'Brien, allegedly the sole survivor of the Custer massacre, captured and adopted into the tribe. It also recounts a scout's story of delivering orders to Custer two days before the battle, which Custer disregarded.
ltd tibnrth infautfy of United. Spates troops in 18G1, wbilo stationed some whbro in Kaunas, since which time hehas been living and acting with the Indians. Ho has the full confi denco of tho Indians, stands high in tho estimation of the . great Sioux warrior, and is to all intents and pur poses an Indian a renegade from and an enemy of his race. . Tho other man it named John O'Brien, and was ta ken prisoner at the lime of tho Custer massacre, and is held in captivity. Ho has been adopted into tho tribe, and has a squaw wife, but is under tho.
See moreSee less
strictest surveillance to provent escape, air. Louis has been and talk ed with both of theso gentlemen, and knows they arc' with, tho Indians un der theso circumstances.'' O'Brien is supposed to be tho only survivor of tho Cust&r massacre. Ho was wound cd twice, and while lying in tho bush es wns saved by a squaw, whom he know snniotiino provious at Fort Aborcromblc. It has been reported that neither Sitting Bull nor any of his warriors were on this side of the lino. Louis denies this by saying that Gen. Miles sent out scouts to find, the where abouts of Sitting Bull, and that they returned, saying there wcro no In dians this side of Forth Walsh. Louis says that although Sitting Bull's camp is beyond tho'linc, there aro now, and have been all tho time.moro or less Indians on this side, some of them noted warriors. Louis says that two days before the Custor matsacrc ho was sent by Gen. Terry to Sitting Bull's camp, and when with in five miles of there ho came .across Custer's command, camped for tho night. He had ordors from Gen Ter ry to Custer to fall back about fiflv miles, but when Louis told him that he was within five miles of Sottin Bull's' village, he saddled up and camo within sight of the Indian camp about three o'clock in tho morning. wiion lie made the ill-fated attack. When lie (Louis) left Gen. Custer, ho bid him good-by, and said: "General I never expect to see yon again." Tho statement given by Mr. Louis in rogard to tho movemonts of Sitting Bull arc corroborated by a lctlcrfrom a prominent Montatiian to Congress man McGinuoss. Women's Rights. It seems to mc that those who clam or loudest for women's rights aro those who most abuse the rights they have. Surely women have rights enough 11 they turn each one to account and im prove them rXS they should. It is her; right to reign qhecn ofthe hearthstone. in the heart ot her husband and chil dren, and no one daro usurp her right to wield a strong influence in church and society and none can say her pow er has not been felt. There are certainly enough branch es of trade and professions open to us to satisfy all manner of tastes. The broad plains of literature open wide their gates and invite all to enter who aro willing to plant good seed tor those who will glean the fields. Art's path ways aro tree to all who ohoso to walk therein and wealth and fame often at tend those who worship at the shrine of Minerva. Thoro Is a great need of noble and good women to undertake tho training of our children, both in school and families; while to those whb admiro the different , branches q'f domestic industry, many and varied avenues are open to them. Then why should wo.wlsh to burden ourselves with the nffalrs of state? Surely the Government that has made the progress ours has during the days of bur mothers and grand-fathers (and they were all protected) Is still equal to the task of proffressinsr, without woman so lar stepping out her sphere as to meddle with its politics. Are our husbands bo far inferior to our fathers, that nivcs must tear tho scep tre from their hands that our country may be governed aright ? Woman should bo pot ted in nil tho affairs of our country and bo able to udgc right from wrong, tor it is her right to aid In her countrle's progress, but certainly not by tho unfeminino process of voting at,, the polls. The shallow, noisy, dashing stream. as it rolls and tumbles over its uneav en bed, accomplishes but little good. 'Tis the deep silent river, flowing on in its noiseless courso that carries the greatest burdens upon its bosora and assists most in the progress of the world. Our newspapers and periodic als enter our homes silently, or but with a slight rustlo. and yet they wield tho power of church and State In all countries of tho world. It was the impulse given to Valeria in answer to prayer, and Volumnia's pleading with her son, Coriolanns, that saved Kjmc. A mothers plead ing In the presence of hi-i beloved wile and children accomplished that which IIlc.Koinan embassadors, and tho "sa-
Major Reno, who commanded US troops near Custer during the massacre and whose actions afterward were heavily criticized, has written to the House Committee on Military Affairs demanding a formal investigation. This request came amid ongoing scrutiny of his decisions during the battle.
Essex County Herald · 28 June 1878 · page 4
R. W. Penton, of New York, William S. Groesbeck, of Ohio, and Francis Walker, have been nominated to be United States commis sioners at the international monetary con ference. The agricultural department estimates that the wheat crop of the couutry will be 400,000 000 bushels. For the last three years, the yield has been one-third larger than for the pre ceding years, Major Reno, who was in command of United States vroops, stationed near General Custer when the latter and his men were massacred, and whose conduct on that occasion has been severely criticised, has written a letter to the House committee on military affairs, demand ing an investigation. Tbe Senate has confirmed the nomination of Sumner S. Kimball, of Maine, to be genera superintendent of the life saving service,
General Reno writes to the House Military Committee chairman asking for an investigation into public charges blaming him for the Custer massacre. He states that if Congress refuses, he will request a military court of inquiry, noting the charges originate from Fred Whittaker, author of a Custer biography.
PERSONAL ANI POLITICAL,. Thomas Ewino Sherman, eldest son of General Sherman, says the Catholic Review, has sailed for England, where he proposes to enter the Novitiate of the So ciety of Jesus. lie is 23, and was educated at Georgetown College and in the Law De partment of Yale. His father has reluctantly but fully consented to the step which the young man has taken. Liect. Totten, U. S. A., was killed by the cars near Cold Springs, X. Y., on the 13th. Cadet Derby, who leads his class at West Point this year, is a son of "John rhesnix."
See moreSee less
A. B. Stockwell, of New York, formerly President of the Pacific Mail Steamship Company, has been adjudicated a bankrupt, with liabilities of over a million dollars. Ant person knowing of the wherea bouts of the children of Gen. Earl Van Dorn, will do an act of kindness by com municating with Gen. Wheeler, Courtland, Lawrence County, Alabama. It may be tbe means of greatly benefiting the children. Minister Notes has returned from France In order to testify before the Potter Investigating Committee. Col. Hendrick B. Wright, Demo cratic Representative In Congress from the Twelfth Pennsylvania (Luzerne) District, has been renominated by the Greenback and Labor Reform party. Representative T. J. Qcinn, of the Sixteenth (Albany) Congressional District, New York, died on the 18th. Gen. Reno has addressed a letter to Hon. EL B. Banning, Chairman of the House Military Committee, asking an investigation of certain charges made against him in the publie press in connection with the Custer massacre. General Reno states that if this request be refused he will ask a military court of inquiry. The responsible author of the charges is Fred. Whittaker, author of a Life of Custer, and he claims that it was through Reno's culpability that Custer's band were annihilated. The wedding of Col. Russell Hast ings and Miss Emily Pratt, niece of Presi dent Hayes, was solemnized at the White House on the evening of the 10th, Bishop Jaggar, of Ohio, officiating. The wedding was a very quiet one, only the immediate friends of the President and bis family, and of the bride and groom being present. The President and Mrs. Hayes at tended tbe commencement exercises at Princeton College on the 20th. The Vermont Democratic State Con vention, held on the 20th, nominated W. It. H. Bingbsm for Governor. The resolutions advocate the gradual substitution of green backs for national bank bills. Congressman Swan, of Maryland, was married at Princeton, K. J., on tbe 20th, to Mrs. John It. Thompson, sister-inlaw of Speaker Randall. The groom bas reached the mature age of Tli, and the bride 50. She is tbe widow of a former Senator from New Jersey. Swan bas been Governor of Maryland, and United States Senator from that State. It is said to be a love match. Both the bride and groom are very wealthy, Swan being a millionaire. Hon. Joseph Pulitzer, of St.Louis, was married on the 19th to Miss Kate Davis, one of the reigning belles of Washington, and a relative of Jeffersan Davis. Although the wedding was intended to be private, a large number of distinguished people were pres ent. Including Senators Lamar, Gordon, Cockrell and Armstrong. Charlie Ross's father, who has spent all his property in the vain search for his lost boy, has been appointed by Gov. Har tranft Master Warden of tbe port of Phil adelphia, with a salary of $2,500. Hon. Daniel Sheffer, of York Springs, Adams County, Pa., recently cel ebrated bis 95th birthday. He is probably tbe oldest ex-Congrcssuian living, having been elected in 181. Ex-Congressman Vance, of Ohio, has been adjudged insane and sent to an asylum. Moses A. Wheelock, for 20 years President of tbe New York Stock Exchange, killed himself on the 23d. Financial troubles, loss of position in tbe Exchange and intem perance are said to have been tbe causes. The estate of the 1 ate William C. Bry ant is valued at $350,000, and, with the ex ception of a few trifling bequests, is divided by his will equally between his two daugh ters, one unmarried and the other the wife of Mr. Parke Godwin.
General Bradley's expedition sets up camp on a former Sioux homestead once used by Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse, finding abandoned tepee poles, bones, and moccasins as relics of former encampments. The report describes the arduous march through mountain passes and swollen rivers, noting that Custer's massacre and the pressure of gold miners had changed the region, allowing peaceful occupation without battle.
The New York Herald · 30 June 1878 · page 9
PLENTY OF HARD WORK AND TOILSOME
out a fight provea iba irutb ol the old udugo that Time changes all things, a change brought about by previous bard marches, hard lights, Custer's massacre and lha Indomitable pluck ol minors Iu sourcb ol gold. WILD Kl'MOK.1.
Major Reno has written to Representative Banning asking for a Congressional investigation into the Custer massacre, citing two years of damaging rumors about his role. He states that if Congress refuses, he will instead seek a military court of inquiry.
Eureka Daily Sentinel · 30 June 1878 · page 2
-.$• Major Reno hag written to Mr. Ban ning. Chairman of the House Committee on Military Affairs, requesting an investi gation into the Custer massacre. He Bays that during the past two years he has suf fered much from the circulation of various malignant reports concerning his connec tion with that terrible affair, and he now demands an opportunity to vindicate his character and reputation. If his request for a Congressional investigation is denied, Major Reno will demand a military court of inquiry. Dubino a fall of rain at Lowell, Mass., recently, a yellowish substance was depos ited npon the ground and in the water iu different parts of the city, which had the taste and odor of sulphur and all the char acteristics of that mineral.
See moreSee less
When it fell into the water there was a yellow scum on the surface, and a basin which had keen left out of doors was partly filled with the substance, which, when dried and burned, gaveoff strong snlphurons fumes. A simi lar phenomenon was observed at Mans
This is a miscellaneous roundup of steamboat and river news from various papers, covering drought conditions, wharf disputes, and local color. One item notes a boat passenger said to have been a scout in Sitting Bull's camp at the Custer battle.
papers. One of the occupants is said to have been a scout in the army of Sitting-Bull at the Custer battic. The owner of the Trout is a Mexican trader."