As the Papers Told It

Jesse James · The full archive

September 1874

12 articles

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

The James boys and Youngers allegedly robbed a stagecoach near North Lexington, Missouri, taking money and valuables from passengers. A romantic twist emerged when one robber recognized a young woman, Miss Hamlet, and forced his accomplice to return her jewelry, with the piece speculating she had ties to Jesse James himself.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 4 September 1874 · page 4

HaZcn thinks the robber wounded at Northfield was Frank James, and that the one who took him on his horse was Jesse James. Colo Younger, Jesse James, and Clcll Miller, all of the Missouri gang, ho says, answer the descriptions of those who entered the bank, Jesse James being the one who killed Haywood. Ills known that all

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The report describes Frank and Jesse James and the Younger gang robbing a train, lining up passengers, and a local woman recognizing the outlaws despite their disguises. It includes dialogue between Miss Hamlett and Frank James over the return of a stolen watch and chain.

Paper unidentified · 4 September 1874 · page 6

(he robbers from the woods this noon, and was Drought Into Jamesvillc at 7 this evening.- He lays his name Is Sprague; that ho (s a detective icqualnted with the Younger and James broth ers, having met them at horse races In Missouri, indwos out on this hunt for the, Northfield tobbers with citizens. Ills captors have uo loubt he is ope of the gang. To the Western Attodaled Press, St. PiDL, Minn., Sopt. IU.-Tlic Most In formation from tho pursuit of the Northfield robbers Is that they have been run out of the woods at Lake Elyslan and across a bridge to ward Watcrvlllc.

See moreSee less

Squads of men have been sent In various directions to head them off. A special train leaves hero.this evening on the Bt. Paul & BUmxOHy Road, canrlng tho Chlef-of-Pollcs and -sor 80 picked men. A hundred men are lurroundlng tho country In which tho robbers are, and It don’t seem possible for them to escape, llazcn, a detective in the employ of the AmcrItan Express Company, scut here from Cincin nati, Identifies two of tho dead by photographs os Charley ITUs and Bill Chadwell. Hu says xr .i 1 !? 11 . 1 * , tko Nght-hnlrcd man wounded at Northfield Is,undoubtedly Frank Jajncs. There Is no mistake about this being tho famous gang operating in Missouri, and, If any of them arc lucky enough to eicope, they will hereafter give Minnesota a wide berth. b St. Paul Planter.Preu, Sept. a.

Clipping to come

The Tipton Advertiser · Tipton, Iowa

The item reports that a Jesse James visited Tipton and is thriving as State Agent for the Aetna Life Insurance Company. This is clearly a different, law-abiding man of the same name, not the outlaw.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Tipton Advertiser · 10 September 1874 · page 3

azjzosbis the guilty. An Imitation of Jesse James visited the office of the Leavenworth Times recently ond demanded an Instant loan of 23 cents; not being gratified in this matter, ho borrowed n lead-pencil and walked

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Three armed horsemen stopped the Waverly hack south of Carrollton, robbing eight passengers of over $1,100 and a gold watch while sparing the mail. The robbers boasted of having robbed the Lexington express the previous night for four thousand dollars.

Paper unidentified · 11 September 1874 · page 7

BOLD ROBBERY, Highwaymen on the Warpath, A Beautiful State of Affairs

azjzosbis the guilty. An Imitation of Jesse James visited the office of the Leavenworth Times recently ond demanded an Instant loan of 23 cents; not being gratified in this matter, ho borrowed n lead-pencil and walked

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The item mocks state officials' weak response to a daylight robbery of the Waverly mail stage, sarcastically proposing toothless resolutions demanding the James boys return stolen goods. It also reports a separate robbery that same evening at Frederick Straus's house near Norborne, where armed men stole cash, a revolver, and other items.

Paper unidentified · 11 September 1874 · page 7

BOLD ROBBERY

Brigandism Rampant. On last Thursday forenoon, a gang of eight mounted men made their appearance in Northfield, and while four of them went into the

Clipping to come

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

The Lexington Caucasian reports that the James and Younger gang robbed an omnibus/ferry stage near North Lexington, Missouri on the evening of August 30, holding up eight male passengers and gathering in additional bystanders including a Miss Hamlett. The report identifies Frank James as one of the masked robbers who directed the robbery while his brother held the horses.

Perrysburg Journal · 11 September 1874 · page 1

ROAD AGENTS.

Brigandism Rampant. On last Thursday forenoon, a gang of eight mounted men made their appearance in Northfield, and while four of them went into the

Clipping to come

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

A gang of masked robbers, identified as the Youngers and James brothers, held up passengers from a bus crossing near a river, lining them up and robbing them of watches, money, and clothing. A young woman named Miss Hamlett recognized Will Younger and Frank James and persuaded Frank to return stolen items to one victim, though the robbery of others continued.

Perrysburg Journal · 11 September 1874 · page 1

ROAD AGENTS.

again it is not improbable that they have confederates in that vicinity, who are either aiding them in keep ing concealed, or have helped them to get away in disguises. .Those who profess to know, de clare them to be the James and Younger gang of Kansas, and say that Jesse and Frank James and two of the Younges are with this com pany. Some of this same gang were in this city not long ago and purchased horses and equipments here. They, also, visited the banks. One of them answers to the descrip tion of Jesse James, but they were not suspected at that time. The people of Northfield deserve great

Clipping to come

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

A newspaper account describes Frank James and companions robbing stagecoach passengers of about $1,000 while declining to search a lady, Miss Mattie Hamlett, among their belongings. The outlaws boasted of their fast horses and escaped in plain view of onlookers gathered on the river bluffs.

Perrysburg Journal · 11 September 1874 · page 1

The two noted bandit, Jesse James and Cole Younger, visited the Pleasant XI til, Kansas, lair grounds recently, and while there practiced at a shooting gal lery, making tine shots. They conversed with Irieuds and said they believed Clel Miller and C'hadwell were killed in Min nesota. The knowledge of their pres ence created considerable excitement among the people.

Clipping to come

Little Rock Daily Republican · Little Rock, Ark.

A cousin of Frank and Jesse James gives an interview denying the brothers' involvement in the Lexington omnibus robbery and the Gads Hill train robbery, offering alibis placing Frank James at his home during the Lexington crime. The report also claims Jesse James married and left the country, and disputes the existence of accomplice William Younger and witness Miss Hammett's identification.

Little Rock Daily Republican · 12 September 1874 · page 1

WHO DID IT? Denial of the Participation of the James Boys in either the Lexington or Gads Hill Robbery.

The two noted bandit, Jesse James and Cole Younger, visited the Pleasant XI til, Kansas, lair grounds recently, and while there practiced at a shooting gal lery, making tine shots. They conversed with Irieuds and said they believed Clel Miller and C'hadwell were killed in Min nesota. The knowledge of their pres ence created considerable excitement among the people.

Clipping to come

In the story →

The Weekly Caucasian · Lexington, Mo.

A detective named Styles returns from Lafayette and other Western Missouri counties with new information about the James gang's whereabouts, including an interview with a young woman named Mattie Hamlet linked to the outlaws. The report also disputes a rival detective's claim that locals doubt the bandits were the James boys.

The Weekly Caucasian · 19 September 1874 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE JAMES BOYS.

Detective Styles Back From Lexington—Tells What He Has Heard Concerning the Stage Robbery—The Best of Evidence as to the Whereabouts of Jesse and Frank.

See moreSee less

Under this heading, the St. Louis Dispatch, of September 12, contains the appended sketch of matters in our part of the moral or immoral vineyard. We must say that detective Styles is entirely mistaken when he asserts that nobody hereabouts believes the bandits to be the James boys. Many excellent citizens are confident of their identity, and more than one could be found, if necessary, prepared to assert it. Here is the Dispatch's report:

Detective Styles is just back from some official work in Lafayette and other counties of Western Missouri, with some new ideas. He has had dealings with the sheriffs and officials of three or four counties, and says he never was among a more clever set of men in his life.

"While I was in Lexington," said Styles, chatting pleasantly with a Dispatch reporter, "I had a talk with Mattie Hamlet, who is the heroine of that part of the county just now. She is a very prepossessing young lady of twenty-five, well educated and intelligent. They tell me that during the war she was almost constantly in the saddle, doing scout duty and carrying amunition and mail to the Confederates. She handles a horse and a pistol with the greatest of ease."

Reporter—Well, what does she say of the James boys and the Lexington stage robbery?

Styles—She weakens on that story. She says she hasn't seen the James boys in four years. At first she thought it might be them, and on the impulse spoke out, and as the masked men seemed to acknowledge the recognition she felt confident, but now she thinks she may have been mistaken.

Reporter—What do Lafayette people generally say about it?

Stiles—Oh, they don't any of them believe they were the James boys. Responsible parties say that Jesse James is married and has been in Texas all the time. Then there is other proof that Frank James was a hundred miles away from Lexington the day of the robbery. In regard to the other exploits attributed to them, three ministers swear positively that on the day of the Iowa robbery the Younger boys were at home at Monegaw Spring. After the shooting of the Chicago detective Lull, and one of the Younger boys last spring, the other Youngers went to Mexico. Two of them were seen in Sonoras last summer. So you see the people up there don't believe in these stories that are told about these men

From the James boys the conversation turned on the wonderful stories told of Missouri sharp-shooting. "One man," said Styles, "with only a single arm, got out his horse to show me how the thing was done. He went into the saddle with a bound, took the bridle rein in his teeth, galloped down the road fifty yards and back, sending the contents of his six-shooter into the ace of spades every crack. I told him that when I wanted him I would send for him."

Styles says they are holding conventions all over the Central Missouri, and that every man he saw wanted him to shake hands with him.

See the clipping

The Weekly Caucasian · Lexington, Mo.

A reporter interviews a source named Stiles about Miss Hallie Hamlet, a local woman who initially thought she recognized the James boys during a robbery but now doubts her identification. Multiple alibis are cited placing Jesse James, Frank James, and the Younger brothers elsewhere during various crimes attributed to them.

The Weekly Caucasian · 19 September 1874 · page 2

THE JAMES BOYS.

the safe and be d----d quick about it,too," Sbut the brave man refused with a knife as his throat and the cold muzzle of a revolver in his face. He was shot and instantly killed. The robbers were foiled in obtaining plunder. While this tragie sne was be ing enacted inside the bank, the ftightened citizens of the town in part recovered their senses, and rallied to an attack upon the desperate outlaws. Several brave towns men secured carbines and shot-guns, and from street corners and house windows poured in bullets, bnokshot and slugs at those of the gang in the street and on the sidewalk.

See moreSee less

A Dr. Wheeler-more courage ous than all-posted in an open window at a building opposite the bank, shot two of the robber crew dead and severely wound ed a third. Another citizen shot and killed one of the robbers'. horses. Alarmed at this fierce and deadly onslaught, the rob bers hastened from the bank, remounted, and with all speed and brandishing and firing their pistols fled through and out of the town leaving their dead bel.dd, but carrying off their woundedptll, whom they were obliged to support i. thle saddle. The whole country, of course, was soon aroused. St. Paul, Minneapolis, St..Peter, Faribault and other points were telegraph ed, and officers and volunteer parties were quickly oh their way to Northfield and en tering upon the pursuit of the highway men. Up to September 12tbh, three days after the murder and attempted robbery, the desperadoes had not been ovethauled. They took to the fields and -woods, and though several times surrounded and sup posed to be as good as prisonems, they man. aged to elude their pursuers and get far ther away toward the Iowa line. It is believed a portion or all of the gang will yet be taken as a multitude of officers and citizens thoroughly armed, remain on the hunt. The two robbers killed are named Chas. Pitts and Bill Chadwell. Thebank cashier (Haywood) was killed by Frank James. The identity' of the gang as that of the James and Younger brothers, of Missouroi was fully established by the testimoay -of Mr. Charles Robinson, of uankato, whro a few days before the affair at NorthfBeld, met and aeecoted Jesse James, whom he intimately knew in former times. . Jesse refused to talk with Robinson, and told him to "go about his business." The dead brigands have their ugly faces depicted in' wood eut engraving printed in the St. Paul Pioneer-Press of the 12th. In their flight, the highwaymen stopped farmers and others on the county roads, changing their jaded boasts for fresh ones, , and atvarious places stole the best horses they could find to help them along in their flight. It is hoped and believed these desperate outlaws will be taken, and justice untem pered with mer'y meted out to them.

Clipping to come

The Elk County Advocate · Ridgway, Pa.

The report describes the robbery of ferry passengers, including an exchange between outlaw Frank James and an acquaintance, Miss Mattie Hamlett, who chided him for petty theft. It identifies the robbers as William Younger and Frank and Jesse James, and notes the editor of the Caucasian praising their exploits as folk heroes of Missouri.

The Elk County Advocate · 24 September 1874 · page 4

the safe and be d----d quick about it,too," Sbut the brave man refused with a knife as his throat and the cold muzzle of a revolver in his face. He was shot and instantly killed. The robbers were foiled in obtaining plunder. While this tragie sne was be ing enacted inside the bank, the ftightened citizens of the town in part recovered their senses, and rallied to an attack upon the desperate outlaws. Several brave towns men secured carbines and shot-guns, and from street corners and house windows poured in bullets, bnokshot and slugs at those of the gang in the street and on the sidewalk.

See moreSee less

A Dr. Wheeler-more courage ous than all-posted in an open window at a building opposite the bank, shot two of the robber crew dead and severely wound ed a third. Another citizen shot and killed one of the robbers'. horses. Alarmed at this fierce and deadly onslaught, the rob bers hastened from the bank, remounted, and with all speed and brandishing and firing their pistols fled through and out of the town leaving their dead bel.dd, but carrying off their woundedptll, whom they were obliged to support i. thle saddle. The whole country, of course, was soon aroused. St. Paul, Minneapolis, St..Peter, Faribault and other points were telegraph ed, and officers and volunteer parties were quickly oh their way to Northfield and en tering upon the pursuit of the highway men. Up to September 12tbh, three days after the murder and attempted robbery, the desperadoes had not been ovethauled. They took to the fields and -woods, and though several times surrounded and sup posed to be as good as prisonems, they man. aged to elude their pursuers and get far ther away toward the Iowa line. It is believed a portion or all of the gang will yet be taken as a multitude of officers and citizens thoroughly armed, remain on the hunt. The two robbers killed are named Chas. Pitts and Bill Chadwell. Thebank cashier (Haywood) was killed by Frank James. The identity' of the gang as that of the James and Younger brothers, of Missouroi was fully established by the testimoay -of Mr. Charles Robinson, of uankato, whro a few days before the affair at NorthfBeld, met and aeecoted Jesse James, whom he intimately knew in former times. . Jesse refused to talk with Robinson, and told him to "go about his business." The dead brigands have their ugly faces depicted in' wood eut engraving printed in the St. Paul Pioneer-Press of the 12th. In their flight, the highwaymen stopped farmers and others on the county roads, changing their jaded boasts for fresh ones, , and atvarious places stole the best horses they could find to help them along in their flight. It is hoped and believed these desperate outlaws will be taken, and justice untem pered with mer'y meted out to them.

Clipping to come