As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

May 1888

16 articles

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A dispatch from Washington reports that the expected ruling in the Hatfield-McCoy case did not come down as anticipated, with Justice Miller reportedly still drafting the opinion. It notes a similar prior case from Illinois was decided against the petitioner, suggesting a possible outcome.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 1 May 1888 · page 1

THE HATFIELD-M'COY CASE

10 laws. West Virginia's Governor followed auit by ottering rewards for the McCoys And their friem!?. Tbis raid laatod a week. It resulted in aoveral killings on both sides, bnt as it was the result of open warfare it did not attract any particular attention. Hat the sequel was terrible in the extreme. Tnis proroked one of the most horrible feitures of this mountain feud. Iheliatlields naid this raid of the Ken tuckians raado them Tight' mad. Then they determined to even uv the score. It was understood that they would visit the McCoys abont a month later.

See moreSee less

It was New Vear's, lb0, when Jim Vance notified the gang that they would return Olo KandTs latest compliment. They assembled that nijht at the homestead of Had Arise, This was tire xnilesfrom where the old-fashioned, log house of the McCoy chief nestled at the foot of a big mountain peak. Fifteen of the Hathelds arrived at the house of Ola L'and'l about 10 o'clock. In the houee at the time was the old man. Calvin, his grown son. Grandma McCoy. Miss Allapbare McCoy, a beautiful young woman, the only daughter, and a nine-year-old boy. the old man's neohew. After surrounding the house it was tired. The family was aroused from slumber by the smell of smoke. Kand'l opened the door to ascertain the trouble and was greeted with a dozen shots lrom the ll&thelds' Winchesters. He sprang back and grabbed his gun. Calvin did likewise. Both men climbed to the garret, where they could shoot "with more accuracy. Miss Alia Dhare observed the flames slowly making their way up the side of the wall. "Without saying a word she seized a churn of milk and walked outside amid the ilying bullets to quench the tire. Jim Vance ordered ner back into the house. Jonce and Cap Hatfield asked their leader's per

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Washington dispatch notes that the Hatfield-McCoy legal decision, along with other matters, has been deferred until the following Monday. No further details on the case are given.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 8 May 1888 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Daily Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed a lower court's refusal to grant a writ of habeas corpus for Plyant Mahon, who was indicted in Kentucky for murders tied to the Hatfield-McCoy feud. Mahon had been forcibly abducted from West Virginia by an agent named Phillips after West Virginia's governor refused extradition, but the Court ruled Kentucky could still hold him regardless of how he arrived, with Justice Bradley dissenting.

Los Angeles Daily Herald · 15 May 1888 · page 1

MAHON HABEAS CORPUS CASE

The clearing was one hundred yards wide, and they were shot at seventy-nine times in crossing. Old Kand'l escaped without a scratch. As Calvin entered the woods he received a ball in the brain. Mrs. McCoy and the little boy did not die. but were thought to be dead by the Hatlields. Jonce and Ellison Hatfield were shot, but not dangerously. This raid in turn made the McCoys 'right" mad. They got all their family and friends together, and for the next month thirty of the Kentnckians hunted the West Virginia mountains for the Hat fields.

See moreSee less

The week after the party started thirteen Hatlields were suddenly found by as many McCoys in a mountain ravine. For an nonr the fight was spir ited, and ended in the rout of the Hatlields.

Clipping to come

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The U.S. Supreme Court denied applications for writs of habeas corpus for McCoy and other West Virginians who had been abducted into Kentucky by Kentucky deputy sheriffs in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta case. The court also addressed the limits of state sovereignty regarding cross-border abductions and extraditions.

The Morning News · 15 May 1888 · page 1

HABEAS CORPUS WRITS DENIED.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

In the story →

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The U.S. Supreme Court, in a divided decision, declined to grant a writ of habeas corpus for Mahon and other West Virginia citizens held in a Kentucky jail after being seized by Kentucky agents in connection with the Hatfield-McCoy feud murders. Justice Field's opinion emphasized that the abduction of Mahon was made without authority from the Governor of West Virginia, rendering the seizure unlawful despite Kentucky's appointment of an agent.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 15 May 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

KENTUCKY A WINNER.

The Hatfield-McCoy Case Decided in Favor of That State.

See moreSee less

JUSTICE FIELD'S OPINION

In the Case--An Elaborate Review of the Constitutional Phases of the Question--The Law in the Matter--Other News.

Special Dispatch to the Intelligencer.

WASHINGTON, D. C., May 14.--The Supreme Court of the United States today decided by a divided court not to grant the writ of habeas in the case of Philant Mahon and a number of other citizens of West Virginia, who was arrested in that State by Kentucky officials for participations in the murders growing out of the Hatfield-McCoy feuds, and confined in a Kentucky jail. Governor Wilson, of West Virginia, made application to the United States Circuit Court of Kentucky for a writ of habeas corpus on the grounds of unlawful seizure of Mahon and his companions. The writ was issued, but when presented the Kentucky District Court refused to honor it.

Justice Field in his decision said: It was the duty to secure the territory of the State from lawless invasion from other States, and to afford the means of compelling them to return. The abduction of Mahon by Phillips and his aids was made, as appears, from the return of the respondent to the suit and from the findings of the court below, without any warrant or authority from the Governor of West Virginia. It is true, Phillips was appointed by the Governor of Kentucky as agent of the State to receive Mahon upon his surrender on the requisition, but no surrender having been made, the arrest of Mahon and his abduction from the State were lawless and indefensible acts, for which Phillips and his aids may justly be punished under the laws of West Virginia. The authority from the Governor of Kentucky furnished no ground for charging any complicity on the part of that State in the wrong done to the State of West Virginia. The accused had the right of insisting he should not be surrendered to the Governor of Kentucky by the Governor of West Virginia, except by act of Congress, and was entitled to release from any arrest in that State, but having been subsequently arrested in Kentucky the question is not as to the validity of the proceeding in West Virginia, but as to the legality of the detention in Kentucky.

There is no comity between the States by which a person accused of a criminal offense in one can be turned over to the authorities of the other in the absence of positive law on the subject. If there were any such comity the enforcing of it would be purely that of courtesy. The question presented is, whether one indicted for a felony in one State, forcibly abducted from another State and brought to the State where he was indicted without authority is entitled, under the Constitution, to release from detention under the indictment, by reason of such forcible and unlawful abduction. The detention of the appellant is in violation of the provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution, that no State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United State, nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty or property, without due process of law."

The decision upon the last point is applicable to the case at bar, and is conclusive in this, that whatever effect may be given by the trial court to the illegal mode in which the defendant is brought before it from another State, no right is violated by disregarding it secured under the Constitution or laws of the United States. It follows, therefore, that the judgment of the court below must be affirmed."

See the clipping

The Comet · Johnson City, Tenn.

The Supreme Court issued a decision in the 'Hatfield-McCoy case,' involving Mahon, a West Virginia resident whom Kentucky authorities wanted for crimes after West Virginia refused extradition. Mahon was forcibly abducted from West Virginia and convicted in Kentucky, and the case was appealed on jurisdictional grounds, though the passage is garbled where the actual ruling would appear.

The Comet · 17 May 1888 · page 2

Hatfield-McCoy Case.

Transcript to come.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The U.S. Supreme Court upheld a lower court's refusal to grant a writ of habeas corpus to Pliant Mahon, who was held by jailor Abner Justice in Pike County, Kentucky in connection with the Hatfield-McCoy feud. The court also denied a separate habeas corpus request in an unrelated Indiana election fraud case before adjourning for the term.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 18 May 1888 · page 7

END OF THE GREAT FUED. HATFIELDS AND M'COYS MADE FRIENDS BY A MARRIAGE. The True Story of tho Quarrel is Herewith Given in Detail. The Execution of Ellison Mounts in Kentucky. Tho fued, which for years has drenched thomountninsof Kentucky and WcHt Virginia with hlood, has jieon permanently Bottled. Sovornl times during tho existence of tho terrihlo strife reports of a similar nuture have been circulated, only to be followed by outbreaks more hitter than before, until each faction has looked upon advances of friendly character as merely a part of a concerted plan to secure an udvantagoin the mountain war.

See moreSee less

lVacn was tho result of tho marriage of Frank Hatfield and lint-tip McCoy, representatives of the younger element of both factions. They met in a log schoolhouso In the wilds of tho Kentucky mountains several weeks ago. TJio place was selected owing to its isolated location and beeauso It was an equal distance removed from the homes of tho two factions. About n dozon representatives of both families were For two years tho young couplo had been corresponding without tho knowledge of their families and through their ndvane.es and tho efforts of mutual friends' tho mountain filed Is ended forever.

Clipping to come

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

The U.S. Supreme Court upheld a lower court ruling in the Hatfield-McCoy case, refusing West Virginia Governor Wilson's petition for a writ of habeas corpus on behalf of Plyant Mahon. Mahon had been forcibly taken from West Virginia to Kentucky without extradition papers to face murder charges, and will now stand trial there.

Shepherdstown Register · 18 May 1888 · page 2

friends' tho mountain filed Is ended forever. mrTTHK FRIENDLY arrangements eauio aftor years of flerco warfare, In which many lives have been pacrlliced by both factions in order that their peculiar ideas of family honor might he maintained with becoming dignity. Tho ilrstquarrol between tho families was nbout two hogs. This was amicably settled after only one man had been killed. The second trouble was caused by a wayward glrh Pretty ltose Ann McCoy, daughter "of old ltand'1, loved stalwart

Clipping to come

Martinsburg Herald · Martinsburg, W. Va.

The U.S. Supreme Court, by a divided vote, refused to grant a writ of habeas corpus for Thilant Mahon and other West Virginia men arrested by Kentucky officials in connection with the Hatfield-McCoy feud killings. The report notes Kentucky's refusal to honor an earlier writ issued by a federal circuit court after West Virginia's governor sought the prisoners' release.

Martinsburg Herald · 19 May 1888 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

A humorous miscellany item claims the shanty on Blackberry Fork, Kentucky, where the Hatfield-McCoy massacre occurred, is now haunted by ghosts who appear amid musket volleys and cold winds. The item treats the haunting as local color/folklore rather than hard news.

The Evening Bulletin · 21 May 1888 · page 4

POINTED PARAGRAPHS

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A short item in a West Virginia newspaper states that the Hatfield-McCoy legal case has been decided in favor of Kentucky. No further details are given about the nature of the ruling or its implications.

Paper unidentified · 22 May 1888 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich.

The U.S. Supreme Court decided the disputed jurisdiction case between West Virginia and Kentucky arising from the Hatfield-McCoy feud, affirming that it does not matter how a prisoner came to be within a state's borders. The ruling followed the precedent set in the case of Chicago defaulter Ker, where kidnapping had also been used to establish jurisdiction.

The True Northerner · 23 May 1888 · page 2

THE NATIONAL CAPITAL.

The remnant of the Hatfield family, in Kentucky, composed of three widows and a boy of 17, representatives of four gen erations, are now cn route for Missouri,where they claim they have relatives who will take care of them when they arrive at their destination. This is the sequel of the McCoy-Hat-ffeld

Clipping to come

Hand County Press · Miller, S.D. · and 1 other paper

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled on disputed jurisdiction between West Virginia and Kentucky stemming from the Hatfield-McCoy feud, affirming that it does not matter how a prisoner came to be within a state's jurisdiction. The ruling cited the precedent of the Ker case, noting that in both instances kidnapping had been used to establish jurisdiction.

Hand County Press · 24 May 1888 · page 2

AN OLD FEUD DREARS OUT. The Hatfield-McCoy Gangs Gunning for Each Other Again. PAKKERSRUUO, W. Va.. March 20. Several citizens of the neighborhood noto rious for the recent llatfw Id-McCoy feuds,

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Iowa Plain Dealer · New Oregon, Iowa · 24 May 1888

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

The U.S. Circuit Court for Kentucky refused a writ of habeas corpus in the case of Mahon versus the jailor of Pike County, a matter arising from the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta. The U.S. Supreme Court subsequently sustained the lower court's decision.

The Big Sandy News · 24 May 1888 · page 1

J' rank I'IuIIijh. Sever ll men from that section, who arried hero as wit nesses in the United bt ites court, gno tho followim: account of tho trauio af fair: L'ist Friday Frank Phillips, who was one ot th most notorious leaders of the McCoy fiction during too 1-ist fond, in which many livi s on both suleiwere lost, came down from Ins hea iquarters in the mount uns 0f Ken tucky and orcjM'd the boundary at St Peter'h creel;, where lie learned that Hob Hatfield, hou of .u-e II afield, wvis Miniewhere noiir.

See moreSee less

Phillips had al ways claimed that Hob Hatfield wis the man who sdiot and c ime near kill. iiiK him in tho last feud, and he doter mined to kill hitu. Ho 1 iv in nmbusu. and when Huttield camo along the road ho shot and killed him. Jlose (.'hn--tian, a friend of Hob Hatfield, heard the filing and ran to his asM,tance and was also bhut bj Plulli)- ind mort illy wounded. Pmihps hul teen men with linn at the tune, and after shoot ing the men they ("-enpd into Ken tucky Tho Hnttiolds are said to be collecting their forces to avenge tho murder of Hob H alield and Christian.

Clipping to come

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled on a disputed jurisdiction case between West Virginia and Kentucky arising from the Hatfield-McCoy feud. The decision affirmed that it does not matter how a prisoner came to be within a state's jurisdiction, even if kidnapping was used to bring them there, following the precedent set in the Ker case.

River Falls Journal · 24 May 1888 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled on the disputed jurisdiction between West Virginia and Kentucky arising from the Hatfield-McCoy feud, affirming that kidnapping to bring a prisoner into a state's jurisdiction is not grounds for dismissal. This follows the precedent set in the Ker case involving a Chicago defaulter.

The Hope Pioneer · 25 May 1888 · page 2

The Hatfield-McCoy feud has broken out agaiin n West Virginia. Last week one of the McCoy men murdered one of the Hatfield men, and now both factions are collecting

Clipping to come