As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · The full archive

February 1895

1 article

In the story →

The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

This article recounts Herman W. Mudgett's life under the alias H. H. Holmes, tracing his schooling, marriage, insurance-fraud schemes with a college friend, and early frauds in Chicago before his jailing in Philadelphia.

The Clarksburg Telegram · 1 February 1895 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

KING OF CRIMINALS.

The Startling Career of H. W. Mudgett, Alias H. H. Holmes.

See moreSee less

In Some Respects the Most Interesting Lawbreaker of Our Times—An Account of a Few of His More Sensational Crimes.

[Special Chicago Letter.]

Of course you have heard of H. H. Holmes, all-around swindler and expert crook? You have also read about other frauds. Perchance you have even spent an hour or two with Sherlock Holmes, the wonderful creature brought forth by Dr. A. Conan Doyle's genius—Sherlock Holmes, the man who disentangled more mysterious knots than all the Scotland Yards force put together. But Sherlock, creature of imagination, is not as profoundly interesting as is H. H., his opposite, at present an inmate of the jail at Philadelphia. H. H. Holmes, swindler, ghoul, incendiary, perchance murderer, is unquestionably the most daring and most eccentric criminal of our time—in some respects the most unique violator of law known in American police history.

H. W. MUDGETT, ALIAS HOLMES.

The Beginning of His Career.

Herman W. Mudgett, subsequently known as H. H. Howard and H. H. Holmes, was born a short distance from London, N. H. When but sixteen years of age he taught a country school at Gilmartin, and began to save money to study medicine at Burlington, Vt. Just about this time he met a handsome young woman, named Clara Lovering, fell into love and was married. Soon afterward the couple left Burlington, where Mudgett had started his career as a medical student, and removed to Ann Arbor, Mich., where he intended to take a degree. After living for a time at his wife's expense, Mudgett formed an intimate acquaintance with a fellow-student who seemed to take considerable interest in insurance frauds. When the collegiate term was over, the two men went to Chicago, where Mudgett's friend was insured for $12,500. Some time later the couple procured a corpse and sent it to Connecticut where it was "planted" in a secluded spot near the seashore, and in due time identified by Mudgett as that of his friend. The insurance company paid the face value of the policy to the conspirat[ors an]d the two young [m]e[n] went back to the university with $6,000 apiece. The successful issue of this swindle made Mudgett known from that time on as Holmes, a confirmed criminal. His accomplice later on turned over a new leaf, and is now practicing medicine in New York city.

First Appearance in Chicago.

After graduating from the university Holmes had charge of a department in the Norristown (Pa.) insane asylum for six months. Later he was clerk in a Philadelphia drug store. But he could not forget the success of his first venture in crime. One day he resigned his position and went back to Chicago. His first wife and her boy had long since returned to New Hampshire. He assumed the name of H. H. Howard, hunted up his medical friend, who was then located in Chicago, and before a year had passed the two conspirators had swindled another insurance company out of $10,000. With the money secured by this operation he purchased a drug store and entered into various swindling schemes, out of which he

HOUSE AT NO. 1316 CALLOWHILL STREET, PHILADELPHIA.

claims to have made $30,000. When creditors began to crowd him he left for California, leaving behind him nothing but debts and his second wife. The trip to the Pacific coast proved quite profitable, and when he returned to Chicago, after things had quieted down, he organized a concern known as the Yates-Campbell Company. In the preliminaries necessary for the formation of this concern, Holmes made the acquaintance of a pretty girl stenographer named Minnie R. Williams. He learned that she and her sister had inherited $50,000 from an uncle in Fort Worth, Tex. In the course of a few weeks he won the young woman's heart and the two went to housekeeping at 701 Sixty-third street without the usual formalities. The Yates-Campbell company did not prosper, and so Holmes burned the flat in which he was living and which was insured for $60,000. But the insurance companies refused to pay, and Holmes had to think of some other way to raise money.

Mystery of the Williams Girls.

About this time Minnie Williams' sister Anna came to Chicago in response to an invitation evidently dictated by Holmes. The girl suddenly disappeared about a month after her arrival and nothing has been heard or seen of her since. Holmes is probably the only man who can tell what became of her; and his explanation is characteristic of the man. "Minnie got jealous of her," he said, a few days after his capture; "and picked up a stool and hit Annie on the head with it. The blow killed her. I got a trunk, put the body in it, and sunk it in the lake." Shortly afterward Minnie Williams and Holmes rented apartments at the Plaza hotel, at Chicago, under assumed names, and from that time on the existence of Minnie Williams has been shrouded in mystery. Holmes says the woman is in Europe, but no one in the wide world is ready to corroborate his statement.

The Williams Estate in Texas.

A few weeks after Annie Williams disappeared Holmes visited the city jail at Terre Haute, Ind., where he formed the acquaintance of B. F. Pitzel, who had been arrested on a charge of forgery. Holmes gave straw bail for Pitzel to the amount of $1,800, and the two worthies proceeded to Chicago, where they developed a scheme to secure possession of the Williams property. In February, 1893, one Benton F. Lyman (Pitzel) appeared in Fort Worth and recorded a deed from a man named Bond (Holmes) for a valuable piece of property. Holmes had doubtless secured the deed from Minnie Williams. Lyman began to build a three-story house on the property. Just as operations were beginning one O. C. Pratt (Holmes) appeared on the scene and was introduced by Lyman as superintendent of the work. A few weeks later Pratt left town with dozens of creditors searching for him. Next Lyman sold a number of lots and disappeared with the proceeds, leaving nothing but the unfinished building and unpaid laborers' and contractors' bills. Holmes and Pitzel also bought a great many horses and gave mortgages on the Fort Worth property in payment. The animals they shipped to St. Louis, where they remained for a time with Pitzel's family. From St. Louis Holmes went to Franklin, Ind., where he met and married Miss Yoke last January.

The Beginning of the End.

In Novem[ber, 18]94, Holmes, with whom the swindling of insurance companies was an incurable fad, had B. F. Pitzel take out a policy for $10,000 in a Philadelphia company. On August 18 of this year, an ordinary-looking man, who gave his name as B. F. Perry, appeared in Philadelphia and rented the old and ramshackle house known as No. 1316 Callowhill street. Perry was no other than Pitzel. He advertised himself as a dealer in agents' specialties. A man called at Perry's establishment on the 3d of September and made an engagement to call again on the following Monday. He could get no reply to his repeated raps. On the next day he came again. He noticed that everything was just as he left it the preceding day. He tried the door and found it open, and lying on the floor was the body of "B. F. Perry." The corpse was found in the position of a man who had been lying down and smoking. A pipe partly filled with half-smoked tobacco was found on the floor just where it might have fallen from the smoker's lips. Everything seemed so natural that the insurance company had no suspicions and was ready to pay over $10,000 to the beneficiaries. The body of Perry was identified as that of Pitzel by his wife, one of his daughters, and by Holmes. Three other children of the Pitzel family have mysteriously disappeared since their father's death, and Mrs. Pitzel and two of her children are in jail charged with being accomplices in the insurance swindle.

A Surprise and Holmes' Arrest.

On October 18, Chief of Police Harrigan, of St. Louis, received a note from Marion C. Hedgspeth, the Glendale train robber, in which was given an outline of the plan hatched by Holmes and Pitzel to rob the Philadelphia company. During one of his eccentric visits to jails and prisons Holmes had met Hedgspeth and explained to him his manner of swindling insurance companies. The train robber gave Holmes the name of an attorney who, he thought, might be willing to manage a crooked piece of work, and in return was promised a reward of $500. This reward Holmes never paid, and to secure revenge the train robber "squealed." Holmes was arrested on a charge of conspiracy, but may be tried for murder, for there is some reason to suppose that Pitzel was killed by his accomplice, although Holmes claims that the body found in the Callowhill street house was a corpse shipped to Philadelphia from New York. Much that is horrible will, no doubt, be brought out at his trial. The crimes confessed by himself are swindling schemes to the amount of $150,000 or $200,000. The crimes of which he is suspected are the murders of Annie Williams, B. F. Pitzel, and Alice, Nellie and Howard Pitzel. Holmes is a nervy man, but he will need all his nerve to clear himself of these terrible suspicions.

See the clipping