As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

March 1806

3 articles

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

This item debates competing newspaper commentary (from Chetham's and Coleman's papers) responding to a Richmond Enquirer article about New York politics. It discusses speculation about Aaron Burr's future—whether he might be appointed minister abroad by Jefferson or run for Governor of New York—alongside sharp exchanges over accusations against Governor Lewis and DeWitt Clinton.

The Enquirer · 7 March 1806 · page 3

We ronfsfc we have perufed the above with no lit tle ftirprife. It affords hope that Burr has not yet made an atonement by murder for his political fins a gainft Mr. Jcfferfon. We will not thin till the af furance of tiie fact leaves us no room to doubt, believe fo ill of any man as to fuppofe the Preftdent lias ap pointed or will appoint Mr. Burr his minifter to any foreign country. As fo the Richmond attack on Governor Lewis, we think that decorum fhould have prevented any gentleman from going fuch lengths.

See moreSee less

To accufe pub licly the Chief Magiftrare of a refpeCfahle ftate with conniving a' “ intrigue and corruption” required furely fomething more than fufpicion. Tiie attack upon Ds Witt Clinton however juft in itfelf and properly exprelTed, originates in the defire to let it be feen that k'irgin/a frowns on the project of (electing the next Prefiient from NewYtrk or any Eaftern ftate. We can anf>ver the daft queftion of Mr. Ritchie, whether it is too ridiculous to fuppofe Mr. Burr is 'o

See the clipping

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · Portland, Me.

The passage attacks Jefferson for appointing the profligate Livingston and alleges Livingston embezzled public funds before fleeing. It also claims Jefferson nominated Aaron Burr, called a 'murderer,' as ambassador to a European court, questioning the propriety of rewarding him.

Portland Gazette, and Maine Advertiser · 10 March 1806 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Aaron Burr, as ambassador to one of the principal courts in Europe? I have read something to this effect in the Chronicle; but that paper, like most of those in the pay of administration is not noted for truth; and this may be false; but if it be true, will a murderer ever hereafter speak ill of Mr. Jefferson? Will not rogues, rascals, and scoundrels of minor grades in crime, take encouragement, when they see a murderer dignified with the first appointments in the power of the President to make, and look

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

The Evening Post responds to Richmond Enquirer articles criticizing New York politics, defending Governor Lewis and De Witt Clinton while dismissing suggestions that Burr could become governor as ridiculous. The piece also references rumors about Burr potentially being appointed as a foreign minister, which the editor doubts.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 12 March 1806 · page 2

... c , (-American Citizen.) W e confess we have perused the above with no lit h affortls hope th:it Mr* Burr has not > ct m„de an . attonement by murder for his political sms against Mr. Jefferson. VVe will not then till the assurance of the fact leaves us no room to doubt, bc hevc so ill of any man as to suppose the President has appointed or will appoint Mr. Burr his minister to any foreign country. As to the Richmond attack on governour Lewis we think that decorum should have prevented anv gentlenian trom going such lengths.

See moreSee less

To accuse pub. lickly the chict magistrate of a respectable state with conniving “at intrigue and corruption” required surely something more than suspicion. ' 'I he attack upon De Witt Clinton however just „» itself and properly expressed, originates in the de vice to let ube seen that f irginia frowns on the pro ject of selecting the next President from Aew-fcr* or any Lastern state. \Ve can answer the last question of Mr. Ritchie whether it is too ridiculous to suppose Mr. Burr is t.> he set up tor the next governour by anv party here ? lies, it is toe ridiculous”-—But “ ridiculous” ,s no't the term to be employed on so infamous a design, if it cou d for a moment be supposed to exist. \Ve do not believe it is in human impudence to make so scandalous a proposition to this community.

See the clipping