As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

October 1805

2 articles

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A correspondent writes emotionally in defense of Aaron Burr, describing him as inwardly tormented and penitent over the duel despite public condemnation. The writer attributes Burr's fall from popular esteem to human frailty rather than corruption, urging compassion over judgment.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 16 October 1805 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

that dazzles and fascinates the sight. In company. Burr is rather taciturn. When he speaks, it is with such animation, with such apparent frankness and negligence, as would induce a person to believe he was a man of a guileness and ingenuous heart; but in my opinion there is no human more reserved, mysterious and inscrutable. I have heard a great deal of Chesterfield and the graces. Surely Burr is the epitome—the essence of them all, for never were their charms displayed with such potency and irresistable attraction. He seems passionately fond of female society, and there is no being better calculated to succeed and shine in that sphere: to the ladies he is all attention—all devotion—in conversation he gazes on them with complacency and rapture, and when he addresses them, it is with that smiling affability, those captivating gestures, that je ne scai quoi, those dissolving looks, that soft, sweet and insinuating eloquence, which takes the soul captive, before it can prepare for defence.

See moreSee less

In short he is the most perfect model of an accomplished gentleman that could be formed, even by the wanton imagination of poetry or fiction. But alas! my friend, what avails these splendid talents—that transcendant address—nay, all the blessings that heaven can bestow, without that solace, that inestimable boon, content and tranquillity? Burr is and exemplary, an illustrious instance of the capriciousness of popular amiration, and the mutability of human glory and felicity. But why should we wonder at popular instability and clamour—a discordant voice that vilifies and arraigns even omnipotence itself? The circumstances that has thus contributed to blast the popularity and poison the peace and happiness of this unfortunate man, is lamentable indeed; but he who will presume to ascribe it to a corruption or depravity of heart, rather than to the fallity of man, and the frailty of human passions, must be blinded by his own venom, and utterly estranged to every sentiment of compassion, and that lenient and divine maxim which instructs us, that where opposing presumptions are of equal weight, the scale should always preponderate on the side of mercy. Confident I am that there is no person more sensibly, more deeply touched with grief, or more sincerely penitent for this misfortune, than him who was the instrument. Yes, my friend, even Burr, the inimitable, the incomparable Burr, is disturbed, is unhappy!—often did I mark the perturbation of his mind, the agonizing sensations which wrung his too susceptible heart, and which in spite of his philosophy and sprightlinesss wrote themselves in the darkest shades of his countenance; and when I beheld the melancholy, the saturine clouds which often inveloped his bleeding, his magnanimous soul, my feelings were melted with a thrilling, a sublime sympathy—the tears started in my eyes, and could I have given them the efficacy of the angels, I would have expiated his crime—I would have blotted out the imputation from the memory of man, and the records of Heaven!

See the clipping

Virginia Argus · Richmond, Va.

The piece poses a series of rhetorical questions about whether Burr is organizing a revolutionary movement in the western states, seizing public lands, recruiting settlers, and planning to invade Mexico with British aid. It notes the original publisher never explained these queries, framing them as unanswered speculation reprinted from another paper.

Virginia Argus · 19 October 1805 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

QUERIES.

Revolution?

Is it part of the plan for the new states to grant these lands in bounties to entice inhabitants from the Atlantic states?

See moreSee less

How soon will the forts and magazines, and all the military posts at N. Orleans, and the Mississippi, be in the hands of Col. Burr's revolution party?

How soon will Col. Burr engage in the reduction of Mexico, by granting liberty to its inhabitants, and seizing on its treasures, aided by British ships and forces?

What difficulty can there be in completing a revolution in one summer, among the western states, with the four temptations, 1st. Of all the Congress lands—2d. Throwing off the public debt—3d. Seizing on their own commercial revenues—4th. Spanish plunder in conjunction with the British?

[The Gazette has never given an explanation of thes questions.]—Aurora.

See the clipping