As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

March 1885

3 articles

Paper unidentified

This Chicago Times narrative, reprinted in 1885, describes how farmers found a murdered man named Jones in Drum Creek with his skull smashed and throat cut, prior to the killing of Dr. York. It recounts a tramp's account of secretly witnessing three people digging at night behind the Bender home, speaking German.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 235 days later.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 22 March 1885 · page 9

PAGES 9 TO 12 the body of Jones. He bad his skull smashed in with a hammer and bis throat cut from ear to ear. The body bad no clothing upon it save a shirt. Some ten or a dozen farmers met quietly on the banks of Drum Creek, and after viewing the body of Jones held a council. At this meeticg the Benders were spoken of suspiciously, and it was deter mined to keep the discovery of the body quiet until future developments. The next day a man who was evidently a tramp and bad footed It from Independence on hia way to Fort Scott, stopped at Datroit's house and asked for something to eat.

See moreSee less

In conversa tion with this man, Dutroit learned tbat the previous evening the tramp bad, while look ing around for a place to pa&a the night, come acre si a small haystack back of the Bender's home, into which be quietly nes

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A tramp who had slept in a haystack behind the Bender home recounted overhearing three people digging at night, prompting a posse to investigate. The vigilantes found the Bender farm abandoned and, searching the grounds, dug up what proved to be the body of Mr. York.

Paper unidentified · 22 March 1885 · page 9

Bender mansion a quiet investigation. A wagon track was discovered leading to the Bender place from where Jones' body had been thrown into the creek. The party struck out on the wagon trail, and at about sunbet it brought them within view of the tavern. It was thea determined to forego proceedings until the morrow, when in the morning the entire party would meet on Drum Creek well armed, and ride over to ths Bender place. On tbe morrow, at about 8 o'clock, the party assembled on the creek and immedi ately proceeded over the prairies to the aus pected house.

See moreSee less

But when they arrived there tbey found the Bender ranch deter ted. The Benders bad noticed the squad ot horeemen riding upon the wagon trail the previous evenirg, and during the night had bundled up their etfecta and departed. The Benders

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

This sensational account claims the fleeing Benders were overtaken on the prairie, with John Bender shot dead and old man Bender making a last stand before Kate's capture. It also describes discovery of the body of murdered victim York at the Bender ranch during the chase.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 235 days later.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 22 March 1885 · page 9

The track of tbe Bender wagon could be seen leading to the southwest. " The horse men f jllowed it at full speed. Just before sunset the pursuers came in sight ot the fugitives. They bad evidently nrged their teams on with all speed toislble. as they were a good forty rive miles from their tavern, and their animals appeared well used up. There was no cow with the outfit, nor had tbe Benders' cow been been or beard ot from that day to this. As the pursuit came in sight of their game they gave a yell, and charged down upon them.

See moreSee less

The moment the Bee drs caught eight of their pursuers, the gr a est consternation appeared to seizs npon them. John Bender, who was walking by the aide of the wagon, ran forward to the lead team, as though to unhitch them but waa recalled bv tbe old man, who handed him out an o d fashioned smooth bore Yea ger rifle. With thia weapon he fired a harm less shot at the advancing horsemen, and then drew a navy revolver and reached his hand Into the wagon for another. Before he had time to draw it forth, however, a ahot from one of the farmers laid him out lifeless on the prairie, the ball entering hia left breast and piercing the heart. Old man Bender stood up in the wagon,

See the clipping