As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

January 1883

3 articles

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This piece reflects on years of competing claims about whether the Bender family was lynched by vigilantes avenging Dr. York or is still alive, noting dozens of false 'Bender' identifications across the West. It recounts the original crimes at their roadside inn near Cherryvale, where travelers were killed and robbed before burial on the property.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 824 days earlier.

Omaha Daily Bee · 8 January 1883 · page 2

8t. Louia illepubllcii. Time and again the fate of the Bender < der family has been a question warm ly dobatflfMu all parta of the West , Many people maintain that the famllj were duly killed by the avengers ol Dr. York , whoso death first broughl to notice the murderous family. Not' withutanding this , every little whih comes the report that the Benders are still living and have been captured , There have been dlacoverod no leei than a hundred different Bender faml lies , and a collection of the nowspapa ) sensations relative to the dlscovcriei of Bondera would prove a moat inter' ' eating literary curiosity.

See moreSee less

The latos Bender sensation waa a local ono when the detectives of this city clap ped a guileless citizen into a ralaboosi upon the statement of a man name * Green. Ho was discharged from ens tody a few daya afterwards. The Benders kept an inn on a lone some road near Ohorryvalo , Libetti county , Kinois. The road paasoi f through the middle of a prairie , si : miles from Gherryvalo , aud all the iui travellers often stopped to get lodg ings for the night , Travellers stop plug there , supposed to have money were seated at the table , aud wbil they were taking their meala , a cur t tain which waa auiponded behim them showed the position of the ! heads. A blow with the head of a uxo from behind the curtain woul atun or finish them. The bodies wer lowered into n collar underneat through a trap door , where the pocket wonld bo rifled of money and value blea and then the bodies were

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A decade after the crimes, this piece republishes Captain S. O. Reeves's account of the Bender family's inn-murders near Cherryvale, describing the trapdoor, cellar, and burial pit used to kill and rob travelers. It also recounts Dr. York's disappearance and his brother Colonel York's search, which led to the Benders' exposure and sudden flight.

Omaha Daily Bee · 8 January 1883 · page 2

BURIED IN A HOLE dug in the lot In the roar of this hoi pltable tavern. The disappearance c Dr. York led to the discovery of thos terrible crimes and the sudden departure turo of the Bender family.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The report describes how Colonel York searched for his missing brother Dr. York, traced him to the Bender place, and after raising a posse discovered multiple bodies buried in the garden. It then details the pursuit of the fleeing Bender family via wagon tracks, abandoned horses, and railroad tickets purchased toward the Cherokee line.

Omaha Daily Bee · 8 January 1883 · page 2

BURIED IN A HOLE

Thaycr , Kansas , which ii about twelve miles from the Bender houeo. There they found the Bonders' wagon and homes , which had been aban doned. They tbero learned that the Benders had taken the train on the L. , L & G. railroad for the north. The pursuing party telegraphed thu conductor of the train , aind ho tele graphed back that the Bendara had stopped at Ohinntte or Now Chicago. They next telegraphed the ticket agent at Chicago or Chlnutto. Ho an swered that ho had sold the Benders tickets to Ghetopka , Kansas , which la juat two .miles from the Ohorokoo line.

See moreSee less

Messrs. Wright and Potcraon , after obtaining this Valuable information , mounted their horses atid rode rapidly back to the Bender place , where they found Colonel York and Sheriff Stone.

See the clipping