As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

January 1921

2 articles

East St. Louis Daily Journal · East St. Louis, Ill.

This report profiles Evangelist La Mance, who uses his own troubled youth—working in a Kentucky saloon, gambling, prize-fighting, and pool-playing under the nickname 'Billy the Kid'—to argue persuasively against sinful living. It describes the violent feud culture of Somerset, Kentucky, including the killing of his employer Barney Higgins, before his conversion at a revival meeting.

East St. Louis Daily Journal · 7 January 1921 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

FRIDAY EVENING, JANUARY 7, 1921.

[L]a Mance Known to S[...] "Billy, the Kid" is [C]rowds to Methodist R[...]

See moreSee less

Kid," scrapp- prize Middle eputa- padded . Ev- large

ing in envi- tracts y larg- of the nine- y, but ows it Right s and relistic hodist

dark. two str[...] ly he t[...] elusive evangel[...] cided a[...] strings would [...] And it [...] Soon College [...] years. Taylor years h[...] logical as bach[...]

Evang[...] er has blooded You lik[...] joy his

"Billy" La Mance.

saw killed after he was charged with insulting a girl. Barney was slain by the girl's brother.

But in Somerset, the heart of the feud country and Barney's bar the favorite rendezvous of feudists, killings were so frequent that one really meant nothing. If a week passed without a couple being passed off it was food for gossip. So the only change in "Billy the Kid's" life as a result of Higgins' death was a change in employment.

He took to pool playing and later became champion of Kentucky; he engaged in prize fights at every opportunity and in between 50 and 100 scraps in which he was signed he was never outpointed or took the count.

Tiring of this sport he was taken up by the gambling fraternity and having gambled thousands for his employer in his early youth, he decided to invest his own money. He did.

A few years later "Billy the Kid" could have been found switching cars for a railroad operating out of Somerset. In his spare moments he continued his pool playing—and poker playing. To him life was just one good time after another.

It was about this time that he wandered one evening into an evangelistic meeting in Somerset. He listened attentively to the services, it being one of the few times the religious and more serious side of life had been disclosed so graphically before him.

The meeting ended, Billy returned to the freight yards to resume the switching of box cars. It was

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

A 1921 newspaper piece contrasts modern criminals with old-timers, quoting a subway companion who recalls his father's stories of the James boys, the Youngers, and Billy the Kid. Detective William J. Burns is cited arguing that modern criminals are far more audacious and successful than those old-time outlaws ever were.

The New York Herald · 9 January 1921 · page 72 · transcribed from the page image

dozen citizens in New York and Chicago are shot down beneath brilliant street lamps and robbed while the police are rubbing their eyes. And then an enterprising burglar robs a few safes in places next door to Police Headquarters. You get used to it in time, but finally you begin wondering what sort of crooks these are.

Looks Like Old Times to Man Who Remembers the James Boys

See moreSee less

"Well, well," cries the old timer sitting beside you in the subway, "the crooks are pretty busy these days. Reminds me of old times. I remember my father telling me of the bad men in the West before the civil war; about the Jameses and the Youngers and Billy the Kid and all those boys, and I remember for myself a pretty tough bird named Tracy and such yeggs, counterfeiters, forgers and burglars as Jimmy Hope, Jimmy Logue, Ned Lyons, Billy Burk, Alonzo Whiteman, who went by the name of Jim the Penman; Dick Johnson, Billy Boston and the rest of them. Lord, man, this looks like old times, according to the newspapers."

Now, if you informed this old timer that, compared with their successors of to-day, these worthies he mentions were frowsy bums, futile bunglers and clumsy dolts, there would be a long and pointless argu-

See the clipping