As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

July 1920

3 articles

Indiana Daily Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

A journalist writing about personality and individuality in American life cites Billy the Kid as an example of a vivid Western character, claiming he was born on New York's east side and became a famous outlaw. The piece asserts he killed twenty-one men by age twenty-one, a figure long enshrined in popular legend.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Indiana Daily Times · 2 July 1920 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image

ever crude, and his own habits, however vicious, and dares to wear his own kind of hat.

William Bonney was born on the east side of New York, and if he had stayed there he would have been a common thug and pickpocket, with no fame outside of police records.

See moreSee less

But he went to the far west and became "Billy the Kid," one of the most famous killers in the history of American banditry, slaying twenty-one men by the time he was 21 years old.

Books and plays have been written about him. He is famous.

He was nothing but an east side gunman turned loose in a wilderness where he had room to expand and to develop his marvelous talent for homicide.

In New York personalities run about one to the 100,000 of population, and those few are mostly importations.

As you go upward in what is commonly called the higher social scale you think you are finding real people, but you soon find that you are mistaken.

PERSONALITIES

See the clipping

The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill. · and 1 other paper

A newspaper opinion piece argues that the open spaces of the West allow personalities to expand, citing Billy the Kid as an East Side thug who became a famous outlaw once given room to grow. It repeats the legend that he killed 21 men by age 21.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 39 days later.

Wrong

The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 6 July 1920 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

William Bonney was born on the east side of New York, and if he had stayed there he would have been a common thug and pickpocket, with no fame outside of police records. But he went to the far west and became "Billy the Kid," one of the most famous killers in the history of American banditry, slaying 21 men by the time he was 21 years old. Books and plays have been written about him. He is famous. He was nothing but an east side gunman turned loose in a wilderness where he had room to expand and to develop his marvelous talent for homicide.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Atlanta Tri-Weekly Journal · Atlanta, Ga. · 3 July 1920

Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.

A filler item in a miscellany column notes that Billy the Kid is advertised as having killed 21 men, not including Indians, comparing this favorably to famous Indian fighters like Custer and Buffalo Bill. The item appears amid unrelated jokes and trivia in a newspaper column.

Albuquerque Morning Journal · 9 July 1920 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

discontinue using same?"

"Also," Izzy asks, "was the article referring to the decline of Germany's zoo and the high cost of maintaining it intended as a joke?"

See moreSee less

The o. f. electric piano that used to imitate popular rag-time music in the corner of the barroom is now tinkling away in the cold-drink and sundae parlor.

Billy the Kid is advertised as having killed 21 men, "not including Indians." Which makes Custer, Buffalo Bill and other redskin fighters look like pikers.

See the clipping