As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

March 1917

2 articles

Carrizozo Outlook · Carrizozo, N.M.

This serialized historical account describes how a sheriff's posse, while serving an attachment writ on cattle in Lincoln County, encountered John Tunstall, Richard Brewer, and William Bonney (Billy the Kid). According to Brewer and Bonney's account, Tunstall was shot by the posse after raising his hands as ordered.

Carrizozo Outlook · 16 March 1917 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Mrs. Scholan commenced legal action to recover the insurance money. In this suit an attachment was levied on the mercantile firm of Tungstel & McSwain and upon all the cattle on the ranch owned by Tungstel on the Felix river in Lincoln county. "When the deputy sheriff and his posse arrived at the ranch to serve the writ they found there John H. Tungstel, Richard Brewer his foreman and William H. Bonney, later famous as Billy the Kid. Mr. Coe states that the parties were friendly while at the ranch and that after levying the attachment on the cattle the deputy sheriff permitted Tungstel, Brewer and Bonney to set off for town with all the ranch horses.

See moreSee less

When about twenty miles from the ranch the latter party discovered a bunch of turkeys in what is now known as Tungstel canyon and stopped to hunt them. While hunting the sheriff's force came upon them. According to the statement of Brewer and Bonney, Tungstel rode toward the possee. Arriving within 15 to 20 feet they ordered him to throw up his hands which he did, dropping his gun and everything, and they shot him while his hands were over his head.--Continued next week.

See the clipping

Carrizozo Outlook · Carrizozo, N.M.

The article recounts how Billy the Kid killed guards Bell and Olinger during his famous escape from the Lincoln County courthouse, then fled toward Fort Sumner where Sheriff Pat Garrett later killed him. It frames this history as justification for preserving the old courthouse as a museum.

Carrizozo Outlook · 23 March 1917 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

As soon as he was free he rode out of town, shooting at everyone he saw, toward Ft. Sumner, his old stamping grounds. Sheriff Pat Garrett, who was in White Oaks at the time, at once set out to capture him, which he did in two weeks, when he killed the notorious outlaw at the home

See the clipping