As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

November 1913

3 articles

Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

A 1913 article describes a historical artifact owned by Colonel George W. Prichard: an 1882 poster from Las Vegas, New Mexico threatening outlaws, including Billy the Kid, with lynching if found in town after 10pm. The piece also references a 1902 pioneers' banquet menu with humorous dishes named after old outlaws and their colorful nicknames.

Santa Fe New Mexican · 5 November 1913 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Curious Poster

Wheeler, Saw Dust Charlie, William Hedges, Billy, the Kid; Billy Mullin. Little Jack, The Cuter; Pock-Marked Kid, and about twenty others. If found within the limits of this city after 10 o'clock p. m. this night, you will be invited to attend a grand necktie party, the expense of which will be borne by one hundred substantial citizens." Colonel Prichard also has a menu of the banquet of the 79ers given February 1, 1902, at Duvall's restaurant, where the turkey is served with "Billy the Kid" sauce and where the ham and tongue are prepared a la "Cold Deck" George.

See moreSee less

The chicken salad is termed "Silent Henry" and the crackers "Piccolo Johnny." On the back is a list of names of "our departed pioneer friends" who were residents in Las Vegas. Among the dear departed are Squint-Eyed Bob, Stuttering Tom, Broken Nosed Clark, Long Vest George, Web-Fingered Billey, Big Foot Mike and about eighty others.

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

The report recounts how Harry Tuthill, after inheriting $50,000, was inspired by a friend's romanticized tales of Billy the Kid to seek adventure in Dakota Territory. It claims the outlaw's real name was William McArthur and describes his exploits as heroic, Robin Hood-like deeds.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

El Paso Herald · 22 November 1913 · page 22 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

REYNOLDS FORSBREY AND MARGARET T[...]

been smuggled in to Forsbrey by his sweetheart. The saws she had concealed in the thick coils of her hair, while the little bottle containing the [...] hidden in her shirt waist.

See moreSee less

The Tombs officials decid[ed]

of Harry Tuthill, Wh[...]

storekeepers of Dakota, as North and South Dakota were then known.

The name of Billy the Kid was often mentioned by this friend. The deeds of

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

This 1913 serialized story recounts an invented adventure of a wealthy Eastern tenderfoot, Harry Tuthill, who travels to Deadwood in 1883 and falls in with a bandit gang supposedly led by Billy the Kid. The tale includes elaborate fictional escapades like pony-stealing raids on Indian reservations, bearing no relation to the real Billy the Kid, who died in 1881 in New Mexico.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

El Paso Herald · 22 November 1913 · page 22 · transcribed from the page image

Tim O'Fallon, Red Wilson, all fellow members of the band in which William McArthur, or Billy the Kid, and George Exelbee shared the command.

Tuthill found Billy the Kid a slight,

See the clipping