As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

March 1913

7 articles

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Mrs. Frederick A. Huxtable, known locally as 'Baby Alice' Mortlock, is visiting her mother in Wilmington with her husband after finishing a western tour performing in 'Billy the Kid.' The couple, recently married in January, will soon head to New York for a new engagement.

Evening Journal · 3 March 1913 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

STAGE FOLK ON VISIT

Mrs. Frederick A. Huxtable, known to residents of Wilmington as "Baby Alice" Mortlock, with her husband, are visiting Mrs. Huxtable's mother, Mrs. William Mortlock, of No. 223 Broome street. The couple have just finished a tour of the west in "Billy the Kid." They were married in January. After a few days in this city they will go to New York where they have been engaged for one of the new Blasco productions.

See the clipping

Tensas Gazette · St. Joseph, La.

This report recounts Billy the Kid's reputation as a killer in Lincoln County, New Mexico, describing the lawless conditions, cattle feuds, and how he evaded capture by appearing unpredictably across a vast, remote territory. It concludes with the cattlemen's recruitment of Pat Garrett, a seasoned Texas lawman, to restore order by capturing or killing the Kid.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 20 days earlier.

Tensas Gazette · 7 March 1913 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Kid after him. They exchanged shots, and the officer escaped with a few wounds.

From that time on it was dangerous for the Kid to enter a community. He raided north through Lincoln county, which was larger than many eastern states. There was not a line of railway or telegraph in it, and no telephones. It was easy to get away.

See moreSee less

At that time there was rivalry between the different outfits. The country was filled with bad men, and they were about evenly divided among the cowmen. Cattle stealing was a common thing. The Kid became involved in a number of rows, and he took sides. His reputation as a "killer" grew.

Undoubtedly a number of these men were killed as a result of trouble among themselves, and the killing laid to the door of the Kid. It was easy. He could not deny it. No one would have believed him if he had. Besides, the more murders credited to him, the greater the fear in which he would be held.

Thus it was that it finally became impossible to get any one to accept the position of sheriff of Lincoln county, for it was only a question of time when he would run across the youthful demon.

The Kid knew that he had terrorized the country. He knew that the instant he let down his guard he would be killed. His safety lay in continuing.

The Turn of the Tide.

Then, one day, even those hard characters who professed to be his friends were amazed by the report that for some trivial incident he had killed a member of his own band. The outlaws were now as anxious to end his career as were the law-abiding people of the village. His friends commenced to murmur. The Kid was now reported in a dozen places at the same time, and these stories he turned to his advantage by appearing at irregular, though frequent, intervals in widely separated cow camps for more than a hundred and fifty miles north and south of the Pecos river.

Pat Garrett, a lanky Alabaman, who had helped organize the Texas Rangers and had assisted in driving the bad men out of Texas to the first water west of the Staked Plains, was invited by the cattlemen to locate in New Mexico. They wanted him to restore order. The only way that could be done was either to arrest or to kill the Kid.

Garrett's record in Texas as a man-hunter and bad man tamer was known all over the southwest. In addition to being quick with a gun, he was absolutely without fear.

He was elected without opposition and took hold with an iron hand. He was an organizer, and men flocked to his standard. They felt, instinctively, that at last a man had arrived who could cope with the situation.

The Capture of the Kid.

In November, 1880, Garrett came upon the Kid suddenly and captured him, with several others, after killing one man.

Word had reached Garrett that the Kid and his gang of three were located in an old house a short distance from Sumner.

"We had better make plans to get him," said one of the deputies.

"The plan is to get there before he gets away. I'll tell you what to do on the way."

The way led down a sage-covered "draw," with several bends made by sand dunes around which the road curved for a distance of about five miles. Before he reached the last bend he pulled up his horse, and waiting for his deputies to come up to him, and then, in the even voice for which he was noted, said:

"I am going to ride ahead. All attention will be centered on me. That will give you a chance to surround the house. I am going to take my time and walk my horse. They may get me, but if they do I want you to make certain that you get him."

The deputies withdrew to right and left, advancing under cover of the sand hills in an ever-widening circle until they had surrounded the house. Then Garrett rode forward. From his position he could see his deputies, who had dismounted, advancing cautiously through the sagebrush. He permitted his horse to walk slowly, as though utterly unconscious of the presence of the gang. At the door he called loudly.

Some one appeared at the window and, firing a shot at the sheriff, dodged back. It was done in an instant, but in that fraction of a second the man who had fired dropped dead in his tracks! Garrett had dismounted, and with his deputies poured a fusillade of bullets through the sides of the thinly boarded shack. A white handkerchief at the window indicated the surrender of Billy the Kid and his gang.

"You Give Me a 'Six-Gun,' Pat!"

When Garrett reached the railroad with his prisoner he was menaced by a crowd that sought to lynch the Kid.

"It looks as though they are going to get me, Pat," the Kid remarked.

It was an ugly crowd, bent on dealing to the boy the fate he was certain to meet sooner or later.

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

This is a newspaper advertisement/review for a stage melodrama titled 'Billy the Kid,' describing plot scenes including the hero rescuing a heroine at a saloon and defeating his pursuers despite overwhelming odds. It promotes an upcoming theatrical performance at the Hyperion theater, mixed with details of an unrelated play about a character named Stafford.

The New Haven Union · 16 March 1913 · page 29 · transcribed from the page image

one of the inmates of the saloon, he turns the odds, and when the smoke of battle has cleared it is the hero who is the victor when it looked as if his death was but a mater of moments.

"Billy the Kid" tells an extremely well connected as well as reasonable story, and offers the star most excellent opportunities. The production is stated to be an elaborate one and the company exceedingly well balanced. "Billy the Kid" will be presented at the Hyperion on Friday and Saturday, with daily matinees.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

John Reilly, a mining man in New Mexico during the days of Billy the Kid, is recalled playing a high-stakes poker game. He wins a large pot with an ace-high flush over an opponent's straight, prompting a wry remark about watching him deal.

Arizona Republican · 18 March 1913 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

ONE AMENITY OF THE GAME

John Reilly was a mining man in New Mexico in the days of Billy the Kid, and John was always on the job for work or play.

See moreSee less

One night he was in a poker game, with the sky as the limit, and it came his turn to deal. The

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

An advertisement announces that the play 'Billy the Kid,' set in New Mexico and featuring Berkeley Haswell in the lead role, will be presented at the Hyperion theater Friday and Saturday with daily matinees. It also previews the following week's production, 'Bought and Paid For.'

The New Haven Union · 19 March 1913 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

HYPERION.

Few of the infant prodigies of the stage ever appear to amount to over much as they grow up. It is said that all rules are made to be broken so this one has been by Berkeley Haswell. This season he is being featured with that ever popular play, "Billy the Kid" which has for its locale New Mexico and which tells a story of great interest, full of strong dramatic situations yet telling it extremely well. Novelties abound in each of the four acts and the central figure, that partrayed by Mr. Haswell, is certainly a heroic lover. "Billy the Kid" is to be presented at the Hyperion Friday and Saturday with daily matinees.

See moreSee less

All next week William A. Brady's

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A play titled 'Billy, the Kid' is reviewed as an entertaining production with comedy and strong situations, starring an actor named Haswell in the title role. The piece is set to run at the Hyperion theater on Friday and Saturday.

The New Haven Union · 20 March 1913 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

HYPERION. "Billy, the Kid" tells a very interesting story, and tells it well. There are numbers of good strong situations and plenty of comedy, and it is said to fit the requirments of Berkeley Haswell, who is this season being featured with the company, playing the part of "Billy" to a nicety. "Billy, the Kid" will be presented at the Hyperion on Friday and Saturday.

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

The passage advertises a touring western melodrama titled 'Billy the Kid,' describing its plot about a young man avenging his father's murder and becoming an outlaw, with comedy and romance woven in. It notes the play has been popular in New York and will run at the Hyperion theater with daily matinees.

The New Haven Union · 21 March 1913 · page 18 · transcribed from the page image

"BOUGHT AND PAID FOR." The ever popular western melodrama "Billy the Kid' which will be the attraction at the Hyperion today and tomorrow with matinees daily has been seen several times during the past sea

See the clipping