As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

February 1907

4 articles

Albuquerque Evening Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

A report on a Western rodeo tournament describes a Navajo rider thrown by an outlaw horse, with Pat Garrett serving as judge of the outlaw horse contest. The article notes Garrett's fame as the sheriff who killed Billy the Kid, described as a desperado with twenty-five murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 50 days later.

Wrong

Albuquerque Evening Citizen · 9 February 1907 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

INDIANS NOT BEST OF COWBOYS

Armijo took no prize, the outlaw Hightower did, through the award of a judge of the outlaws, Pat Garrett, who in the line of his duty as sheriff had killed the famous outlaw, "Billy the Kid," a desperado with twenty five murders to his debit, and the

See the clipping

Tombstone Epitaph · Tombstone, Ariz.

A cap and ball pistol on exhibit at a Tombstone business is claimed to have a colorful provenance, supposedly made for Wild Bill, used by Jesse James, given to Billy the Kid, then passed to Wyatt Earp and later Burt Alvord. The item was displayed as a donation for an upcoming Elks Bazaar in Bisbee.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Tombstone Epitaph · 10 February 1907 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Donations on Exhibit in Kreuder's Window

Charles Kreuder has on exhibit in the windows of his Dining Rooms a number of donations that have been made by Elks residing in Tombstone to the Elks Bazaar that is to be held in Bisbee during the coming week at the new Elks' Home, that has just been completed in that city. Among the contributions is an o'd-time musket, and a cap and ball pistol. The latter has the following attached to it as its history:

See moreSee less

"This gun was made especially for "Wild Bill," and was the weapon used by him in killing ten men. It passed into the hands of Jesse James and was carried in many raids of that notorious gang. It was given by Jesse James to "Billy, the Kid" and the latter transferred it to Wyatt Earp, former chief of police of Tombstone, who was a particular friend Burt Alvord, the Arizona bandit, and was taken him the last time he was arrested by Ranger Porter McDonald."

See the clipping

The Evening Tribune · Providence, R.I.

A 1907 reminiscence piece recounts tales of a frontier figure named Clay, including courtroom antics and a fatal stagecoach duel, noting he was eventually killed in a quarrel with 'Billy the Kid' in Arizona. The account then shifts to unrelated Civil War anecdotes told by Maj. Ewen.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Tribune · 17 February 1907 · page 26 · transcribed from the page image

though nothing had happened. "While Clay was in the 'pan handle,' he was in a way a peacemaker. If any man did wrong, Clay would simply shoot him, saying that the man was a bad citizen and needed to be removed. Clay was a generous man and would always give freely to those in trouble. He went finally to Arizona and was killed in a quarrel with 'Billy the Kid.'" Not all of Maj. Ewen's interesting ex-

See the clipping

The Meeker Herald · Meeker, Colo.

A sheep broke loose and charged into a group of police officers and a magistrate, injuring several. A sergeant jokingly named the unruly animal 'Billy the Kid,' and it was kept at the station awaiting its owner.

The Meeker Herald · 23 February 1907 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

CHARGES ON POLICE

keep close watch, general observation has shown beyond doubt the majority of members have been faithful.

vein of the boar and it quickly bled to death.

See moreSee less

sergeant dropped the rope and the sheep charged into a squad consisting of one police lieutenant, six sergeants and Magistrate Leake, with the disastrous results recorded above. Sergeant Moreheiser promptly named the sheep "Billy the Kid," and he is at present browsing in the back yard of the station, where his owner can claim him.

See the clipping