New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.
A 1904 feature profiles former Texas Ranger Sumner, now a prospector, recounting his violent past including battles with train robbers and a shootout with the remnants of Billy the Kid's gang after the outlaw's death. The article notes Sumner lost fingers and an arm in these fights, with the Kid's gang encounter costing him his left arm.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 7 September 1904 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image
The powder marks are yet to be seen. One of the other fights in which he was engaged was a round-up of the toughs of the gang of "Billy the Kid." after the latter had been killed by Capt. "Pat" F. Garret, then the sheriff of Dona Ana county, New Mexico. The gang were all rounded up across the line in New Mexico and a fierce battle took place. During the firing a ball struck Sumner in the left arm and mangled it in such a fashion that it had to be amputated at the elbow.