As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

April 1904

4 articles

The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt.

A humorous tale describes a practical joker named Ben Hicks who stages a hoax, having a confederate tell an eastern visitor that a sullen-looking local man is Billy the Kid, still alive. The story explicitly notes Billy had long since been killed, with the prank playing on his legendary reputation to scare the tenderfoot.

The Barre Daily Times · 1 April 1904 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

A TENDERFOOT'S SCARE

[Original.] Down in the southwest there was a noted desperado named Billy the Kid. He was a real character and had a record more remarkable than anything that could very well be conjured up in fiction, though he came to the same end as all desperadoes. Long after Billy had been put out of the way it occurred one evening to Ben Hicks, who was a good deal of a practical joker, to play the part of the famous bandit. Ben got a number of hangers on in the town where he lived, the scene of some of the Kid's most famous operations, men who would do almost anything for the drinks, to play the subordinate characters to his "leading man."

See moreSee less

The coach had just come in; a gentleman from the east alighted and after supper lit a cigar and strolled about the town. One of the confederates approached him and entered into conver

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J. · and 1 other paper

A fictional anecdote recounts how, after Billy the Kid's death, a prankster named Ben Hicks staged an elaborate hoax convincing an eastern visitor that the outlaw was still alive. The story describes confederates frightening the tenderfoot into believing he must pay tribute to avoid being harmed by the supposedly living desperado.

The Jersey City News · 12 April 1904 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

A TENDERFOOT'S SCARE

He was a real character and had a record more remarkable than anything that could very well be conjured up in fiction, though he came to the same end as all desperadoes. Long after Billy had been put out of the way it occurred one evening to Ben Hicks, who was a good deal of a practical joker, to play the part of the famous bandit. Ben got a number of hangers on in the town where he lived, the scene of some of the Kid's most famous operations, men who would do almost anything for the drinks, to play the subordinate characters to his "leading man."

See moreSee less

The coach had just come in; a gentleman from the east alighted and after supper lit a cigar and strolled about the town. One of the confederates approached him and entered into conversation.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Bossier Banner · Bellevue, La. · 19 May 1904

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

A folksy anecdote describes Billy the Kid challenging a mysterious 'tenderfoot' stranger to a bowie knife duel after mockery over facial scars. The stranger, revealed to be a skilled fencer trained at Heidelberg, easily bests Billy, who gracefully concedes and treats everyone to drinks.

The Jersey City News · 12 April 1904 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the tenderfoot replied:

"You drink with me and the crowd too. I've been more frightened than I've ever been in my life. Nothing scares me so much as to fight a greenhorn. A skilled man has all he can do to keep from killing a man who can't fence. I'll pay the drinks and glad to get off so easy."

See moreSee less

When they were all lined up the Kid asked the tenderfoot where he had learned to handle the bowie knife.

"I learned to handle the small sword

See the clipping

The Daily Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

A short story recounts how a practical joker named Hen Hicks staged an elaborate prank on a visiting easterner, convincing him that the long-dead outlaw Billy the Kid was still alive and dangerous. The tale plays on Billy the Kid's legendary reputation for humor, with townsfolk playing along to scare the gullible stranger.

The Daily Telegram · 23 April 1904 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A TENDERFOOT'S SCARE

ain't he? Well, that's Billy the Kid."

"Is that Billy the Kid?" exclaimed the stranger. "I thought he was dead."

See moreSee less

"Don't you believe it," replied the informant. "They reported him shot to keep strangers from stayin' away from

See the clipping