As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

January 1903

5 articles

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The piece recounts a humorous anecdote about Pat Garrett, described as the 'slayer of Billy the Kid,' during a visit to New York where a policeman warns him about pickpockets, not realizing who he is. It's part of a miscellany column of light human-interest stories.

Rock Island Argus · 3 January 1903 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

NEW SHORT STORIES

El Paso, Tex., friend of President Roosevelt, slayer of "Billy the Kid" and terror of all the bad men in the southwest, was in New York recently to attend a meeting of the government board of customs appraisers, reports the New York Times. Garret is 6 feet 4 inches in his stockings, long and lean, and his dress is that of the typical westerner.

It was his first visit to the metropolis, and when he got off the ferry at Cortlandt street he went up to a policeman and asked the way to his hotel. The guardian of the city's peace looked at the lanky Texan a moment. "Three blocks ahead and up on a Broadway car," he said. "But, my friend, let me advise you to hold on tight to that grip there. There's lots of fellows in this city looking for marks like you."

See moreSee less

And the policeman couldn't understand why Garrett laughed.

See the clipping

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

The article discusses General Lew Wallace's new book devoting chapters to Billy the Kid, promising to tell the true story of the outlaw's vendetta against him. It recounts a dramatic scene where Wallace, as Governor of New Mexico, waited in a remote cabin near Santa Fe for a midnight meeting with the notorious outlaw.

Shepherdstown Register · 8 January 1903 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

In answer, "Lord of all."

The songs are done, the camp is still, Naught but the stream is heard; But, ah! the depth of every soul By those old hymns was stirred.

See moreSee less

And up from many a bearded lip Rises, in murmurs low, The prayer the mother taught her boy At home long years ogo. —E. V. Wilson.

General Wallace and Billy the Kid.

The murderous bandit must have a singular attraction for the writer of romance. Gen. Lew Wallace, author of "Ben Hur," devotes much attention in his latest book to "Billy the Kid." This celebrated outlaw of the "wild and woolly" who has never before had a biographer of distinction occupies several chapters.

The General will also for the first time relate the true story of the Kid's terrible vendetta against him and his officers. The General's encounter with the desperado occurred in 1879, while Wallace was Governor of New Mexico. A more intimate acquaintance, however, was brought about when it became necessary for Governor Wallace to interview the Kid personally. The interview was to be held at night, and, in readiness for the occasion, two men a few minutes before midnight sat silent, eager, expectant, huddled together in a little hut on the outskirts of Santa Fe, N. M.

Their gaze, says the Indianapolis correspondent of the Detroit News-Tribune, was fastened on the door.

One man was the owner of the rude hut that stood desolate on the shifting sands of the great mesa. The other was Gen. Lew Wallace, governor of New Mexico.

The hands of the clock pointed to the hour of twelve. The hush deep-

See the clipping

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

The article dramatically recounts a secret 1879 nighttime meeting between Billy the Kid and New Mexico Governor Lew Wallace, arranged under promise of protection. It describes the outlaw's youthful appearance and piercing eyes, contrasted with his fearsome reputation as the most wanted man in the Southwest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 77 days later.

Wrong

Shepherdstown Register · 8 January 1903 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

was the quarry of every sheriff from the Rio Grande to the bordering foothills that shut in Death Valley. In facial features "Billy the Kid," the notorious bandit and fugitive from justice, was a mere stripling. His narrow shoulders were rounded, his posture slightly stooped, his voice was low and effeminate. But his eyes were cold and piercing, steady, alert, gray, like steel.

General Wallace rose to his feet and held out his hand, inviting the visitor to be seated for a conference.

See moreSee less

"Your note gave the promise of absolute protection," said the outlaw, warily.

"I have been true to my promise," said the governor. "This man," pointing to the owner of the cabin, "and myself are the only persons present."

The rifle was slowly lowered, the revolver was returned to its leather holster, Billy advanced and the two seated themselves at opposite sides of the narrow table.

Explaining the midnight interview with "Billy the Kid," General Wallace says: "The man whose deeds of

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · and 3 other papers

The passage recounts Pat Garrett's own narrative of his 1881 shooting of Billy the Kid at Maxwell's house, describing the confrontation in detail. It then shifts to comparing Billy the Kid to outlaw Harry Tracy, noting Billy's age and origin.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 55 days later.

Wrong

The American Citizen · 30 January 1903 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

"Who are you?"

"He drew back and fired as if he knew well enough who I was, as undoubtedly he did, but my bullet was the quickest and "Billy the Kid" rolled over dead."

See moreSee less

"Billy the Kid" was from New York state and was but twenty-two when he allowed Sheriff Garrett to get the drop on him, with fatal results. Like most of his class Billy had many friends and was regarded by a few as the best kind of a good fellow.

"A man with nerve behind a gun is worth twenty-five who are after him," added Sheriff Garrett in reply to some questions about Harry Tracy.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 3 August 1902
  • Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · 3 August 1902
  • The Professional World · Columbia, Mo. · 15 August 1902

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · and 1 other paper

The article revisits the 1877 Sam Bass train robbery at Big Springs, Nebraska, and his death after being shot by Ranger Ware, claiming Bass insisted he never killed a man. It then pivots to note that Sheriff Pat Garrett has recently retold the story of how he killed Billy the Kid, implying many prior versions were inaccurate.

The American Citizen · 30 January 1903 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SAM BASS AND "BILLY THE KID."

story told recently by Sherm Patrick J. Garrett of New Mexico, recounting the shooting of "Billy the Kid."

Twenty years ago "Billy's" name was as much of a terror as is Tracy's today. There have been dozens of stories written of the way in which he finally met his end, but Sheriff Garrett, says that the true story is only now told.

See moreSee less

"I had, on occasions sat opposite Bil-

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Professional World · Columbia, Mo. · 15 August 1902