tion, "Sheriff, how many notches are there on your gun?" he blushed like a school-girl, and said:
"Oh, they are only scratches. They were all accidents, mine were."
See moreSee less
How He "Got" the Outlaw.
It was twenty-one years ago that Billy Bonney, with a record of killing eleven men, was brought to book by this quiet, determined man. Garrett was a deputy sheriff in Las Cruces. He had kept a small store in the new country, and on occasions had sat opposite "Billy the Kid" at the poker table. The outlaw, whose exploits were the talk of the country then, as Tracy's are today had associated with him a gang of six men who broke every law and defied all authority.
"We had got the gang," said Garrett yesterday, when pressed to tell the true story of how he killed the outlaw. "Three were dead and three were alive. Billy had murdered a man on the Indian reservation while stealing horses, and he was sentenced to be hanged on May 28, 1881. He broke out of the Lincoln county jail a few nights before that and escaped after killing a deputy sheriff and a United States marshal. I was sent after him.
"On the night of July 12 I got to Peter Maxwell's ranch. I left my two men outside and went in to see Maxwell, whom I knew well. Peter was lying in bed in a corner. I put my Winchester against the wall and sat down on the bed to talk with him. I told him I had heard that Billy had been seen around there. He said he hadn't seen him. I knew by his manner that he wasn't telling the truth, and while we were sitting there talking Billy came in.
"He had gone across the road, I learned afterward, and ordered a Mexican there to get up and make him some coffee. When he came back to the ranch house he saw my two men and accosted them in Spanish. They made no answer, and he darted into the house and upstairs in his stocking feet. My face was in a shadow when he appeared in the doorway and he darted over to me with his knife in one hand and his gun in the other. He had his gun within a foot of me when he laid his hand on my knee and demanded, "Who are you?"
Garrett Fired First.
"He sprang back instantly and fired. But I had fired first and the ball went through his heart. I fired a second time but the bullet went over him. He had fallen.
"A hundred different stories have been told about how I killed Billy, but this is the true one. I've got a tintype of Billy at home, the only one in existence, I believe and as I was on the way to the train I left it at a photographer's to be enlarged, for General Lew Wallace, who wants to write an article about him.
"There were many good traits about Billy. He came from New York state somewhere. He was only 22 years old when he died, but he had been up to all kinds of deviltry for six or seven years. He wasn't what you'd call a killer. He never made a gun play he didn't mean, and he never shot up a town or committed any such foolishness. I've met worse men than Billy."
Garrett discussed Tracy, the Northwestern bandit, and inquired with much interest if it was true that he had been wounded. He said:
"A man with nerve with a gun is worth twenty-five who are after him."
Garrett said he had heard that "Bat" Masterson, whom he knew in Dodge City years ago, was fined for carrying a pistol in New York, and the former sheriff expressed no sympathy for him.
"I never carry a gun," he said. "My forty-four is upstairs in my gripsack, and will stay there. Before President Roosevelt appointed me Collector at El Paso I never carried a gun off duty, and I never allowed one of my deputies to carry one unless he was on duty."
The collector said that when there was trouble in Washington last December over his appointment he had a little talk with President Roosevelt which went something like this:
"Garrett, they say you're a drunkard"?
"It isn't true, Mr. President. But I've been drinking all my life.'
"You're charged with being a gambler?"
"I know the difference between a straight and a flush, Mr. President, and in my section of the country a man who doesn't know this doesn't know enough to keep the flies off in fly season."
"I'm told you're an atheist and an infidel?"
"I have pronounced views on some subjects, Mr. President, but I know enough to keep them to myself when they don't agree with the men around me."
Garrett was appointed, and now he