As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

May 1899

8 articles

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A narrative account, framed as a tale told by a passing stranger, recounts how Billy the Kid escaped the Lincoln County jail in 1881, killing guards Bell and Olinger before fleeing on a horse. The story is presented as anecdote within a larger frontier narrative rather than straight news.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 52 days earlier.

Evening Journal · 2 May 1899 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

drew near we perceived that he was a beardless boy, riding a fine black gelding, Capt. Jack turned to the right to pass him, and I took to the left as a measure of safety. With a slight motion of the hand the rider signaled that I, too, must go to the right, and he appeared to 'a heap sabe' what our movements meant. I obeyed his command. When we met all three stopped and Capt. Jack asked him how far it was to Fort Stanton. The answer came readily enough, and the boy asked us how far it was to water. We informed him, and told him that he had best turn back, as the Indians were out. He replied: 'I am going to Grant county, and will keep on if the whole Apache tribe is in the way.' He then asked us for tobacco, and Capt. Jack gave him a supply. After rolling a big cigarette and lighting it, he demanded: 'Say, ain't you Capt. Jack Crawford, the scout?' 'I am,' was the reply. 'I thought so,' said the youth. Capt. Jack then said: 'Are you not Billy, the Kid?' 'Yes,' he frankly answered. 'I thought you were in the Lincoln county jail,' said Capt. Jack, 'under a death sentence.' 'I was,' said the Kid, 'but I bade them adieu this morning.' 'Well,' said Capt. Jack. 'I think you have not had a fair deal from what I have heard. I am glad to have met you, and I sympathize with you.' 'I know I have been tough,' replied the Kid, 'but they made out things against me that I am not guilty of.'

"About six o'clock we emerged from the salt beds, when we met a negro on horseback whom I recognized as one of Billy the Kid's band, having seen him two years before at Rincon, where he was cook for John Kinney, the famous cattle rustler. 'Say, boss,' he said, as he approached, 'have you seen anything of a young feller with a black hoss?' 'No,' replied Capt. Jack. 'Mighty strange,' said the negro, 'here's his tracks in the trail.' In the meantime I was nodding my head in the affirmative to the negro, but without Capt. Jack's knowledge. 'Sure you ain't seen him?' asked the negro. 'We have not,' was the reply of Capt. Jack. I again nodded my head in the affirmative, and a broad grin passed over the negro's face. Just then Capt. Jack turned around and caught me nodding and giving the lie to his assertions. He was angry in a moment, and started to express himself when I said: 'This man's name is Wash. He is a friend of Billy's, who would be very glad to have him with him.' This gave the negro the desired information, and then he told us of the escape of the Kid, and how it was effected.

See moreSee less

"The Kid was in the Lincoln county jail under a sentence of death for murder. He was in charge of a sheriff by the name of Pat Garrett. Two guards, Ollinger and Bell by name, were placed in immediate charge of the Kid during the daytime. Other men were on duty at night. They were enemies of the Kid and took great delight in taunting him with his approaching fate. All their victim would say was: 'I may outlive you, ducks yet,' and sure enough he did. That morning Ollinger went across the street to get the Kid his breakfast, Bell being left to guard the jail. The Kid asked Bell to get a rag and wrap it around one of his shackles, as it was chafing his leg. Bell procured the desired article, and, stooping down, was in the act of placing it around the shackle when the Kid reached over, took Bell's gun out of his hip pocket and in an instant shot him fatally, although he lived some hours and was able to relate how the affair occurred. The Kid then took the shackle key out of Bell's pocket, and in an instant was free. Ollinger heard the shot and came running across the street. The Kid, however, met him at the door with a Winchester in his hands. With an oath he said: 'Ollinger, you must go to meet your pard,' and at that shot him dead. Across the street there was a fine horse tied to a post, all saddled and ready. It belonged to one of the county officers, who said he was going out into the country to see his girl, but many believed he was a friend of the Kid and had placed the horse there for his use. Be that as it may, the Kid ran quickly across the street, untied the animal and mounted him, only to be thrown. However, he caught the end of the lariat and was in the saddle again in an instant. By this time a crowd began to gather, but the Kid stood them off with his Winchester and dashed out of town. He had the fleetest horse in the country and no pursuit was made.

"The Kid made his way in safety to the Chisholm ranch, in Grant county, where he found friends. Garrett, learning of his whereabouts, went to

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 2 other papers

A humorous recollection describes journalist Eugene Field's practical jokes on Colorado's Senator Tabor, including a prank about lost night robes and mock speeches. Billy the Kid is mentioned only in passing as part of a joke list of Western outlaws.

The Indianapolis Journal · 19 May 1899 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

TABOR'S LACE NIGHT ROBES

many of 'em out where I live. There's Wild Bill and Pecos Bill and Billy the Kid —all no good. If you let Tariff Bill have everything to do with the custom house he is liable to steal the Atlantic ocean.' Many of the honest frontier folk took these flights of fancy seriously and drove Tabor nearly distracted by long letters of remonstrance, urging him to read up and get posted, so as not to disgrace the State. At the expiration of the senator's brief term he circulated an autograph album among his fellow-members and the incident tickled Field immensely.

See moreSee less

He gave what purported to be a copy of the 'sentiments' inscribed in the volume by the different statesmen—such things as 'when this you see remember me, Roscoe Conkling.' and 'sure as the moss grows 'round a stump you are my

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn. · 16 June 1899
  • The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del. · 29 June 1899

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This 1899 article recounts Billy the Kid's reputation for reckless bravery, gunfighting skill, and near-supernatural luck in escaping death and capture. It then transitions into a firsthand anecdote told by W. H. Summons about an 1881 dispatch-carrying mission during an Apache raid scare, tangentially connected to the Kid's era.

Evening Journal · 20 May 1899 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

usually left a trail of blood behind him.

The incident in the career of Billy the Kid, which I am about to relate, was given to me by Mr. W. H. Sammons, of Lake City, Col. Mr. Sammons' part in

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A 1899 reminiscence describes scout Captain Jack Crawford encountering a young rider who turns out to be the fugitive Billy the Kid, freshly escaped from the Lincoln County jail. The anecdote includes invented dialogue and a later meeting with one of the Kid's associates who recounts details of the jailbreak.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 75 days later.

Wrong

Evening Journal · 20 May 1899 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

drew near we perceived that he was a beardless boy, riding a fine black gelding, Capt. Jack turned to the right to pass him, and I took to the left as a measure of safety. With a slight motion of the hand the rider signaled that I, too, must go to the right, and he appeared to 'a heap sabe' what our movements meant. I obeyed his command. When we met all three stopped, and Capt. Jack asked him how far it was to Fort Stanton. The answer came readily enough, and the boy asked us how far it was to water. We informed him, and told him that he had best turn back, as the Indians were out. He replied: 'I am going to Grant county, and will keep on if the whole Apache tribe is in the way.' He then asked us for tobacco, and Capt. Jack gave him a supply. After rolling a big cigarette and lighting it, he demanded: 'Say, ain't you Capt. Jack Crawford, the scout?' 'I am,' was the reply. 'I thought so,' said the youth. Capt. Jack then said: 'Are you not Billy, the Kid?' 'Yes,' he frankly answered. 'I thought you were in the Lincoln county jail,' said Capt. Jack, 'under a death sentence.' 'I was,' said the Kid, 'but I bade them adieu this morning.' 'Well,' said Capt. Jack, 'I think you have not had a fair deal from what I have heard. I am glad to have met you, and I sympathize with you.' 'I know I have been tough,' replied the Kid, 'but they made out things against me that I am not guilty of.'

"About six o'clock we emerged from the salt beds, when we met a negro on horseback whom I recognized as one of Billy the Kid's band, having seen him two years before at Rincon, where he was cook for John Kinney, the famous cattle rustler. 'Say, boss,' he said, as he approached, 'have you seen anything of a young feller with a black hoss?' 'No,' replied Capt. Jack. 'Mighty strange,' said the negro, 'here's his tracks in the trail.' In the meantime I was nodding my head in the affirmative to the negro, but without Capt. Jack's knowledge. 'Sure you ain't seen him?' asked the negro. 'We have not,' was the reply of Capt. Jack. I again nodded my head in the affirmative, and a broad grin passed over the negro's face. Just then Capt. Jack turned around and caught me nodding and giving the lie to his assertions. He was angry in a moment, and started to express himself when I said: 'This man's name is Wash. He is a friend of Billy's, who would be very glad to have him with him.' This gave the negro the desired information, and then he told us of the escape of the Kid, and how it was effected.

See moreSee less

"The Kid was in the Lincoln county jail under a sentence of death for murder. He was in charge of a sheriff by the name of Pat Garrett. Two guards, Ollinger and Bell by name, were placed in immediate charge of the Kid during the daytime. Other men were on duty at night. They were enemies of the Kid and took great delight in taunting him with his approaching fate. All their victim would say was: 'I may outlive you ducks yet,' and sure enough he did. That morning Ollinger went across the street to get the Kid his breakfast, Bell being left to guard the jail. The Kid asked Bell to get a rag and wrap it around one of his shackles, as it was chafing his leg. Bell procured the desired article, and, stooping down, was in the act of placing it around the shackle when the Kid reached over, took Bell's gun out of his hip pocket and in an instant shot him fatally, although he lived some hours and was able to relate how the affair occurred. The Kid then took the shackle key out of Bell's pocket, and in an instant was free. Ollinger heard the shot and came running across the street. The Kid, however, met him at the door with a Winchester in his hands. With an oath he said: 'Ollinger, you must go to meet your pard,' and at that shot him dead. Across the street there was a fine horse tied to a post, all saddled and ready. It belonged to one of the county officers, who said he was going out into the country to see his girl, but many believed he was a friend of the Kid and had placed the horse there for his use. Be that as it may, the Kid ran quickly across the street, untied the animal and mounted him, only to be thrown. However, he caught the end of the lariat and was in the saddle again in an instant. By this time a crowd began to gather, but the Kid stood them off with his Winchester and dashed out of town. He had the fleetest horse in the country and no pursuit was made.

"The Kid made his way in safety to the Chisholm ranch, in Grant county, where he found friends. Garrett, learning of his whereabouts, went to the ranch in the night and called on Chisholm, who denied knowing where the Kid was. There was no light in the room, and while they were talking some one came in and asked Chisholm if he was there. Chisholm answered in the affirmative. The Kid, for it was he, said he had come after fresh meat, but instinctively suspecting something wrong he demanded: 'Who's here?' Garrett had recognized his voice, and before Chisholm could reply he fired in the direction from whence it came, well knowing that the time had come for him to kill the Kid or to be killed by him. Fortunately his aim was well taken. The desperado fell dead in his tracks with a bullet through his heart and without a groan. Thus perished Billy the Kid, whose blood-stained career is still talked of in the southwest.

"The negro who informed us of the manner of the Kid's escape kept on in his pursuit, while we went to Fort Stanton. The next day a detachment of soldiers was sent out in pursuit of the Apaches. We accompanied them. On reaching the Dripping Springs we learned that the Indians we had seen the day before were a lot of Mescalaro Apaches in the employ of the government, and who were out after the renegade Apaches. They had fired off their guns and yelled only to have some fun with us."

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The passage reports on the unsolved disappearance and apparent murder of Colonel Albert Fountain and his son, with suspects Lee and Gilliland awaiting trial after a change of venue. It notes that Pat Garrett, the sheriff who famously captured Billy the Kid, is building the case against the accused.

Arizona Republican · 23 May 1899 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

the territory. Pat Garrett, the gigantic sheriff of Donna Ana county, who stands over seven feet in his stockings, who captured "Billy the Kid," who has been the terror of evil-doers in New Mexico

See the clipping

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

The murder trial of Oliver Lee and Jim Gilliland for killing young Henry Fountain begins in Hillsboro, New Mexico, with the prosecution seeking a continuance to secure a key witness. Pat Garrett, famed as the slayer of Billy the Kid, is seen among the crowd amid reports of deep enmity and near-violence between rival factions in town.

El Paso Daily Herald · 27 May 1899 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

the town, like a calm before a storm. Groups of interested persons are to be seen earnestly discussing the details of the situation in low tones. The tall form of Pat Garrett appeared late this evening as the slayer of "Billy the Kid" wended his way along the sidewalks. Near him stood Judge

See the clipping

Kansas City Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

This is a humorous reminiscence about journalist Eugene Field's pranks on Senator Tabor, including a mock speech naming Billy the Kid alongside Wild Bill as western outlaws. The piece is nostalgic storytelling with little direct connection to the Kid's actual history.

Kansas City Journal · 28 May 1899 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Why," he responded, absent "I—er—I'll have the same." He declared that Tabor opposed the tariff bill on the ground that it encouraged lawlessness in the West. 'I don't know this tariff bill,' he reported the senator as saying in a speech, 'but we have entirely too many of 'em out where I live. There's Wild Bill and Pecos Bill and Billy the Kid—all no good. If you let Tariff Bill have everything to do with the custom house he is liable to steal the Atlantic ocean.' Many of the honest frontier folks took these flights of fancy seriously, and drove Tabor nearly distracted by long letters of remonstrance, urging him to read up and get posted, so as not to disgrace the state.

See moreSee less

At the expiration of the senator's brief term he circulated an autograph album among his fellow members, and the inci[dent]

See the clipping

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

Judge Parker improvised a method to select additional jurors after the regular panel was exhausted, prompting a legal challenge from defense attorneys representing Oliver Lee and James Gilliland. Pat Garrett rushed to arrest a key prosecution witness, Jack Maxwell, who was reportedly too ill to testify.

El Paso Daily Herald · 29 May 1899 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

THE FOUNTAIN TRIAL

an exception, contending that the court should either have fallen back on the common law or followed the old jury law, the latter method having been recently sustained by a supreme court decision.

Court adjourned until this morning to allow the sheriff to summons the other venire.

See moreSee less

The failure oi the territory's witness. Jack Maxwell, to attend court created great consternation among the attorneys for the prosecution. Pat Garrett, the tall slayer of "Billy the Kid," immediately left in haste for Three Rivers to arrest the witness and bring him in. Maxwell is said to be ill at Tularosa and unable to travel. He is considered the most important witness for the territory and without his evidence the prisoner will readily prove an alibi.

El Paso HERALD Bureau. Hillsboro, May 27, via Lake Valley, N. M., May 28.—Court opened this morning promptly at ten o'clock and the first act of the defense was to file a challenge to the entire special venire summonsed according to Judge Parker's ruling of yesterday.

The objections when reduced to writing are as follows:

Now comes Oliver Lee and James R.

See the clipping