As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

August 1898

2 articles

Western Liberal · Lordsburg, N.M.

The Western Liberal reports on Oliver Lee's letter defending himself against charges in the killing of Deputy Sheriff Kearney during his arrest by Sheriff Pat Garrett's posse. The article compares the circumstances to Garrett's famous arrest of Billy the Kid, noting both involved disputed claims about whether shooting began before or after a call to surrender.

Western Liberal · 5 August 1898 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

telling all about his little trouble with Sheriff Pat Garrett, which difficulty resulted in the murder of Deputy Sheriff Kearney. Lee claims that the sheriff's posse commenced shooting and then told him to throw up his hands. Lee had just awoke from a sleep when this occurred, and it may be that he was told to throw up his hands before the shooting commenced.

Whether it was true or not that the shooting commenced before the call to surrender was made is not of much importance. It was in this way that Sheriff Garrett arrested Billy the Kid, and he has always been commended for the way he arrested him, and circumstances seem to indicate that Oliver Lee is fully as hard a citizen as Billy the Kid, although he has not

See the clipping

Lewiston Teller · Lewiston, North Idaho · and 2 other papers

The article argues that blue-eyed men have superior long-range vision and marksmanship compared to dark-eyed men, citing historic frontier gunmen like Billy the Kid, Wild Bill, Bat Masterson, and Jesse James as examples of blue-eyed killers. It extends this theory to military contexts, including the Battle of New Orleans and predictions about the Spanish-American War in Cuba.

Lewiston Teller · 19 August 1898 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

from Natty Bumpo to Captain Bogardus —have blue or hazel eyes. Look over the long list of western "killers" who flourished in the frontier days, now passed away, and you will recall that the invincible ones, those who were quickest on the trigger and who never missed their man, were blue-eyed. Billy the Kid, Wild Bill, Bat Masterson and Jesse

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • · · 17 August 1898
  • The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · 20 August 1898