As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

April 1898

3 articles

Rocky Ford Enterprise · Rocky Ford, Colo.

The report recounts how Colonel Albert Fountain and his son vanished in February 1896, prompting Governor Thornton to appoint Pat Garrett—famous as the slayer of Billy the Kid—as sheriff to investigate. Garrett and his deputies have now arrested several men, including Billy McNew, Billy Carr, Oliver Lee, and W. F. Gilliland, on charges of the murders.

Rocky Ford Enterprise · 7 April 1898 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

In February, 1896, Colonel Albert G. Fountain and son, who were en route to a distant county from Las Cruces, disappeared, and as the abandoned wagon and horses were found it was reported that the colonel and his little boy were murdered by cow rustlers, whom he had prosecuted some before and was instrumental in seeing two or three of the gang in the penitentiary. W. T. Thornton was then governor and he persuaded Pat Garrett, the slayer of "Billy, the Kid," to accept the appointment of sheriff of Dona Ana county, in the hope that he might ferret out and arrest the murderers.

See moreSee less

Sheriff Garrett removed to Las Cruces from Lincoln county and has steadily worked on clues. On the 3rd very early in the morning Sheriff Garrett and Deputy Meadows arrested Billy McNew and Billy Carr, charged with the murders, and the day following in the Sacramento mountains Deputy Meadows and posse captured Oliver Lee and W. F. Gilliland, charged with the same crime.

See the clipping

Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

The report recounts the 1896 killing of Colonel A. J. Fountain and his young son near Las Cruces, noting the case initially had no clues beyond suspicion of an outlaw gang Fountain had prosecuted. It describes Pat Garrett's prolonged investigation, which has now produced four indictments and the arrest of two suspects, with officers pursuing the remaining two.

Santa Fe New Mexican · 8 April 1898 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

But It May Be Successful.

(Denver News.)

See moreSee less

On February 1, 1896, Colonel A. J. Fountain, a prominent citizen and lawyer of southern New Mexico, and his 12-year-old son were murdered on the road between Lincoln and Las Cruces and their bodies hidden. The crime was a dastardly one and created great excitement in the entire territory. There was absolutely no clew to the perpetrators of the deed, beyond the suspicion that it had been the bloody work of a certain gang of outlaws, whose members Colonel Fountain had been prosecuting in the courts. In a few days it was announced that the authorities and friends of the deceased had employed Pat Garrett, New Mexico's noted criminal catcher, the man who had hunted down and shot "Billy the Kid," to trail the murderers. Commenting on the fact, the News asserted that when Pat Garrett took the trail he would never leave it until he had caught the murderers.

More than two years have elapsed and the assassination had almost faded from the public mind, but Pat Garrett had not given up the chase. With the grim determination, sagacity and persistence for which he is noted, he has run down every clew, until now it is announced that four indictments have been found, two of the parties placed under arrest, and officers put on the track of the other two alleged assassins. As a piece of detective work this, considering all the difficulties and dangers involved, must be accorded a high rank.

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.

The passage recounts the disappearance of Col. Albert J. Fountain and his son, believed murdered by cattle rustlers he had helped prosecute. Sheriff Pat Garrett, appointed to investigate, has now arrested Billy McNew, Billy Carr, Oliver Lee, and W.F. Gilliland on murder charges, though the bodies were never found.

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 13 April 1898 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

was then governor, and he persuaded Pat Garrett, the slayer of "Billy, the Kid," to accept the appointment of sheriff of Dona Ana county, in the hope that he might ferret out and arrest the murderers. Sheriff Garrett removed to Las Cruces from Lincoln county and has steadily worked on clues. Yesterday, very early in the morning, Sheriff Garrett and Deputy Meadows arrested Billy McNew and Billy Carr, charged with the murders, and today in the Sacramento mountains, Deputy Meadows and posse captured Oliver Lee and W. F. Gilliland, charged with the same crime. Hon. Neil B. Field and Judge H. L. Warren left here this morning to defend McNew and Carr

Hagan, B Havens, P J Harvey, J Heard, Mrs L B Johnson, H King, H W Smith, Al

See moreSee less

SPANI[SH]

Madueno, E Rivera, J F Robles, M V

Please call for

Window shades to 50c.

HEINZ'S SA[illegible]

See the clipping