The Monte Vista Journal · Monte Vista, Colo.
Governor Otero commuted the death sentence of Jose Chaves y Chaves, a Las Vegas murderer, to life imprisonment without consulting the trial judge. The report notes Chaves was once a member of Billy the Kid's gang and had acted under the Silva gang in killing young Romero five years earlier.
The Monte Vista Journal · 27 November 1897 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
who decided against the accused, joined in the appeal for executive clemency. That Chaves is a notorious criminal is not denied. As a member of Billy the Kid's gang years ago he is charged with the most brutal crimes.