As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

May 1896

5 articles

Daily Public Ledger · Maysville, Ky.

A humorous syndicated sketch features blustering gunslinger characters in a saloon, with a 'tenderfoot' from Brooklyn claiming to have killed more men than them. Bystanders speculate the newcomer must be infamous outlaws like Jesse James or Billy the Kid, used purely as comic shorthand for notoriety.

Daily Public Ledger · 9 May 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A TERROR OF THE EAST

"I'm some on that, too. I've killed ten or twelve myself. I disremember exactly which."

A murmur, an awed murmur, arose from the crowd and the Broncho's swarthy face paled visibly.

See moreSee less

"It's Jesse James!" said Whisky Dick.

"No, it's Billy the Kid!" said One-Eared Rafferty.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This editorial decries the hidden savagery of ordinary city boys, comparing their hypocrisy and danger to slum gangs led by figures like 'Billy, the Kid' in Hell's Kitchen and Mulberry Bend. It then recounts a court case where a cash-boy's prank with a pin injured a woman in a department store, illustrating boys' casual cruelty.

The Indianapolis Journal · 10 May 1896 · page 16

Is wholly foreign to their thoughts. They are nothing but boys whose real nature will come out the moment an opportunity is ar forded them. Probably most of them have homes and during the hours of thair eranlovment thav are under constant super vision. Were it not so, their numbers would soon swell the gangs of boy rufllans who, under leaders like Billy, the Kid, rob and

See the clipping

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A humorous tale from the N.Y. World describes a tenderfoot from Brooklyn frightening a blustering gunslinger named Tarantula Bill in a saloon. The terrified crowd compares the mysterious stranger to famous outlaws, including Jesse James, Bob Younger, and Billy the Kid, showing how the Kid's name had become shorthand for deadly reputation.

Waterbury Democrat · 15 May 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A TERROR OF THE EAST.

"It's Jesse James!" said Whisky Dick. "No, it's Billy the Kid!" said One-

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 1 other paper

A narrator recounts being bullied by a gun-wielding cowboy who forced him at gunpoint, until Billy the Kid intervened from a doorway and shot the pistol from the cowboy's hand. Billy then forced the cowboy to dance, pray, and perform humiliating antics for the amused crowd.

The Morning News · 17 May 1896 · page 19 · transcribed from the page image

between the store and saloon. "'Put up that gun,' it said. A young fellow, scarcely more than a boy, stood in the doorway, with a revolver in his hand, and it was he who had spoken. It was Billy the Kid. The cowboy did not seem to know him, but the bystanders did.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I. · 30 May 1896

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 1 other paper

A cattleman named Amos Pendleton recounts his youthful encounter with Billy the Kid and his gang while working as a surveyor in Lincoln County. The Kid and companions approached his campfire, chatted and played guitar, while the rest of his band waited hidden nearby in preparation for an ambush on a paymaster that ultimately failed.

The Indianapolis Journal · 24 May 1896 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

TOLD OF BILLY THE KID: TWO MEETINGS WITH THE NOTED MAN KILLER OF NEW MEXICO

"Our camp was in the open prairie at the edge of the thickly wooded bank that sloped down to the creek. Three men came out of the bushes near by, walked up to the camp and sat down. They were strangers to me, but the one who plainly was the leader I knew by description to be Billy the Kid. They asked me some questions about the surveying outfit and whether I had seen any party going toward Fort Stanton that day. Billy picked up the guitar, played and sang a little, and then, after talking a short time longer, the three men said good-night and went down the bank out of sight.

See moreSee less

The next morning I could see where, just over the bank among the bushes, the rest of the Kid's band of fifteen or twenty men had been waiting in concealment while their leader talked with me. They were on their way to rob the United States paymaster as he came to Fort Stanton, and, as he had a military escort, they were prepared for fighting. But he took an unexpected route to the fort, and they missed him.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · 17 May 1896