As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

January 1894

5 articles

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This 1894 article reflects on Billy the Kid years after his death, comparing him to Jesse James as a psychologically unstable killer prone to paranoia. It recounts his cattle rustling in New Mexico and Texas, his reputation drawing challenges from drunken cowboys, an incident where he wept after killing a persistent antagonist at Caparita, and his involvement in the Lincoln County War under John Chisholm.

Evening Star · 13 January 1894 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image

aist the temptation of 'tapping his game.'

Wouldn't Let Him Alone.

See moreSee less

"The exuberant nature of the average cowboy, especially when assisted by the incautious drinks of his region, results in this: That there are no men whom he fears. To point him out some western hotspur like Billy, the Kid, was to simply issue an invitation to go after him. The cowboy is an optimist and he is also a fatalist. He believes that he will never go until his time comes: that his fate is already written on leaves of steel. This breeds recklessness, so more than once some youth of the range, panting for glory, anxious to signalize himself, crowded up for trouble with the renowned Kid. Time and again the Kid seemed to suffer all things to avoid war; and there are many men in the southwest today who will describe the Kid as a great coward, basing their opinions on instances where he fled from trouble. At Chaparita, a little 'doby aggregation southeast from Vegas some fifty miles, there was one persistent cowpuncher who simply would not let the Kid alone. He drove him into a fight. There was a brief fusillade, and the

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · and 2 other papers

General Lew Wallace recalls his time as New Mexico governor, describing Billy the Kid as a notorious outlaw who had killed nearly fifty men. He explains that after the Kid's capture and threats of revenge, Wallace began daily pistol practice in case of a confrontation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 20 days later.

Wrong

The Salt Lake Herald · 21 January 1894 · page 3

When I was governor of New Mex ico that territory was and had bee 1 for years terrorized by bands of dar 1S ing and murderous outlaws at the head of whom was the famous horde desperado Billy the Kid By virtu of my office I became this mans dead Hest J enemy No man ever excited more terror along the frontier or gave better ground for the dread in which he was held than this man He had perpe trated murder after murder and there were few crimes of which he had not been guilty He had opely boasted

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va. · 15 March 1894
  • Clarke Courier · Berryville, Va. · 28 March 1894

The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa.

This narrative recalls how Billy the Kid was captured after a mountain pursuit and jailed in Lincoln County under Sheriff Pat Garrett, guarded by Bob Olinger and John Bell. It recounts his vow to kill Garrett, a judge, and Governor Lew Wallace, and sets up the start of his famous jail escape.

The Star · 24 January 1894 · page 6

Governor Lew Wallace. ' "After I have nettled aooouuts with those three men," said the desperado, "I will be willing to surrender and be hanged. When I get ont I will ride into Banta Fe, hitch my horse in front of the Palace and walk in and put a bullet through Lew Wallace." This seemed idle boasting at tho time, because there appeared to be not the remotest possibility of the prison er' escape. He was in the custody ot Hberiff Garrett iu the County Jail at Linooln, and the HUeriff, besides being a cool, courageous and reliable man, had every incentive to be watchful of Li charge.

See moreSee less

It was thought a pretty sure thing that Garrett would never let the "Kid" go, and Governor Wal lace felt fairly seoure in his office a way oft in Santa Fe. Garrett appointed as guards over

See the clipping

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

The article recalls Billy the Kid's capture after a mountain pursuit, his vow to kill three men including Pat Garrett and Governor Lew Wallace, and describes how he grew friendly with his jail guards Bell and Ollinger before his famous escape. It includes biographical detail about Lew Wallace as author of Ben Hur.

Shenandoah Herald · 26 January 1894 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Enraged at having been trapped, the outlaw swore that if ever he regained his liberty he would kill three men. One was a judge who had once passed sentenced upon him, one was Pat Garrett of Lincoln County, who had been conspicuously active in effecting his capture, and the third was Governor Lew Wallace.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The article narrates Billy the Kid's upbringing in Silver City, claiming the violent frontier culture there instilled in him a need to kill to gain social status, and recounts his first killing of a soldier from Fort Cummings. It continues describing his years as a cattle rustler in eastern New Mexico and the Texas Panhandle, protected by locals who profited from his stolen cattle.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sun · 28 January 1894 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

a method of life. The restaurant must have failed by New Mexico standards. Perhaps the overripe appetites of a region given to chile concarne as a food and mescal as a beverage failed to appreciate the milder points of Bowery cookery as brought West by the Bonneys. At any rate, our honest couple with the Kid between them veered further to the southwest, and the next one hears of them they have pitched camp at Silver City.

"Silver City was at that time an easy 1,000 miles from a railroad; was a land flowing with the hustler and the desperado, and young Bonney grew up in an atmosphere of pistol smoke and poker. He grew up feeling the nervous necessity for killing somebody; he must fix his social status. His surroundings taught him that in no other way could he be regarded as a southwestern success. The sooner he got a notch on the handle of his pistol the sooner he would be regarded as in full southwestern fellowship. To kill a man was at that time regarded as much of a decoration in southwestern New Mexico as the regalia of a Knight of the Bath is in England. At any rate, this was the feverish view instilled into the rather ardent nature of Billy the Kid.

See moreSee less

"He arrived at his first success with a negro soldier from Fort Cummings. This buffalo soldier, as the Indians called them on account of their woolly heads, got very drunk and very voluble, and, in the full expression of his feelings, concluded to whip Billy the Kid. The Kid at that time was only about 16, and, as he never at his heaviest weighed more than 125 pounds, thrashing him didn't at first view present a host of difficulties. The troop of cavalry at Fort Cummings were shy one. The Kid, it would seem, was of a very nervous nature. While Silver City sentiment justified the killing, nobody for one moment thought of interfering with the Kid. Still the reflection must have preyed on Bonney. Not that he regretted it, but the thought made him nervous, and he seemed in more or less fear of the vengeance of his colored victim's friends.

"For one or two years nobody heard much of the Kid. The next his flutterings attract attention he is industriously stealing cattle in eastern New Mexico. He did most of his stealing in the Texas Panhandle, and drove his cattle west, killed them, or sold them up about Fort Stanton or Fort Union. He was hunted and rehunted by cattle people, and had a great many shooting scrapes, and was once or twice captured; but there was a strong interest in protecting him in New Mexico, as he was the cause of a great deal of cheap cattle to cattle buyers in that region. A great deal of the Kid's shooting was forced. As soon as he had name and fame as a blood letter, every drunken cowboy who happened to meet him alone couldn't resist the temptation of 'tapping his game.'

"The exuberant nature of the average cowboy, especially when assisted in his views by the incautious drinks of his region, is such that there are no men whom he fears. To point him out some Hotspur like Billy the Kid was to simply issue an invitation to go after him. The cowboy is an optimist, and he is also a fatalist. He believes that he will never go until his time comes; that his fate is already written on leaves of steel. So more than once some youth of the range, panting for glory, anxious to signalize himself, crowded up for trouble to the renowned Kid. Time and time and again the Kid seemed to suffer all things to avoid it, and there are many men in the Southwest to-day who will describe the Kid as a great coward, basing their opinions on instances where he fled from trouble. At Caparita, a little 'dobe aggregation southeast from Vegas some fifty miles, there was one persistent cow puncher who simply would not let the Kid alone. He drove him into a fight. There was a brief fusillade, and the cowboy went thence without delay. They covered his body with a blanket, and then the Kid sat down on a coffee sack in a store near by and wept copiously.

See the clipping